“They are everywhere but invisible, toiling as domestic servants in homes, laboring
behind the walls of workshops/factories, hidden from view in sugarcane plantations,
unsafe in the production of pyrotechnics, collecting garbage from households, risking
their lives in the streets selling newspapers and cigarettes, hopping from one jeepney to
another to wipe our shoes and beg for alms afterwards, experiencing malnutrition, can be
seen asleep in the coldness of the earth provided with carton papers as their beds, paying
their ancestors’ debts in some big haciendas, working for their families in the rice farm,
diving for pearls in the ocean/seas of the archipelago, involved in mining and quarrying
in some places, demoralized and prostituted at young age… “
The use of child labor was not regarded a social problem until the introduction of
the factory system.
Child Labor is most concentrated in Asia and Africa, which together account for
more than 90% of total children employment. Though there are more child workers in
Asia than anywhere else, a higher percentage of African children participate in the labor
force. Asia is led by India, which has 44 million child laborers, diving it the largest child
workers are between the ages of 10 – 14 yrs. old (1991). Nigeria has 12 million child
workers. Child labor is also common in South America. For example, there are 7 million
children working in Brazil (ILO 1992).
Though restrictions on child labor exist in most nations, many children do work.
This vulnerable state leaves them prone to exploitation. The International Labour Office
reports that children work the longest hours and are the worst paid of all the laborers
(Bequele and Boyden 1988). They endure work conditions, which include health hazards
and potential abuse. Employers capitalize on the docility of the children recognizing that
these laborers cannot legally form unions to change their conditions. Such manipulation
stifles the development of youth. Their working conditions do not provide the stimulation
for physical and mental development. Finally, these children are deprived of the simple
joys of childhood, relegated instead to a life of drudgery. However, there are problems
with the obvious solution of abolishing child labor. First, there is no international
agreement defining child labor. Countries not only have different minimum age work
restrictions, but also have varying regulations based on the type of labor. This makes the
limits of child labor very ambiguous. Most would agree that a six year old is too young to
work, but whether the same can be said about a twelve year old is debatable.
Until there is global agreement, which can isolate cases of child labor, it will be
very hard to abolish. There is also the view that work can help a child in terms of
socialization, in building self – esteem and for training (Collins 1983). The problem is,
then, not child labor itself but the conditions under which it operates (Boyden 1991).
Child work refers to the children’s participation in economic activity – that does
not negatively affect their health and development or interferes with education, can be
positive. Work that does not interfere with education (light work) is permitted from the
age of 12 years under the International Labour Organization (ILO) Convention 138.
Worst forms of child labor involves children being enslaved, forcibly recruited,
trafficked, forced into illegal activities and exposed to hazardous work.
The Philippines is literally a young nation with a high percentage of young people
in its overall population. And the child labor problem in the Philippines is a serious one.
According to the National Statistics Office survey, there are about 4 million
working children in the country today.
Of the 4 million, 2.4 million are engaged in hazardous work, which means that
they are exposed to chemical, physical and biological hazards. These are the children
involved in the worst forms of child labor such as prostitution, domestic work, mining
and quarrying, commercial agriculture, deep – sea fishing and pyrotechnics production.
In Metro Manila and neighboring towns, most child laborers are found in
factories, livestock industries like poultry farms and piggery. They often come from
the provinces. In many cases, they live like convicts, incarcerated and without the
freedom of movement. Young workers in the farm are made to sleep inside pigpen or
poultry house together with the animals.
BASELINE RESEARCH
One year ago Lingap Pangkabataan Inc. started its CDL Program. There are now 101
Child Domestic Laborers being served and catered by this program. The CDL
program is assisted by US Department of Labor through the Winrock
International’s Community-Based Innovations to Reduce Child Labor
through Education (CIRCLE) initiative.
Socio-Demographic Profile
SEX
Almost three-fourths of the Child domestic Laborers involved in
the program are females (75) while the rest (26) are males (see Table
1).
Table 1. Sex
Category f %
Male 26 25.7
Female 75 74.3
TOTAL 101 100.0
This could be due to the nature of the work that these children
provide for their employees, which are mostly household chores. Being
a domestic worker, they do all household chores, including cooking and
washing clothes for males. A male child recounted,
AGE
As of May 2006, the ages of the child domestic laborers in the
program range from 13 to 17 years old. There were 69 respondents
who are fifteen years old and above – seventeen years old (26
respondents), sixteen years old (22 respondents) and fifteen years old
(21 respondents). On the other hand, there were 32 respondents who
are thirteen and fourteen years old – 18 and 14 respondents –
respectively (see Table 2).
Table 2. Age
Category f %
Thirteen 18 17.8
Fourteen 14 13.9
Fifteen 21 20.8
Sixteen 22 21.8
Seventeen 26 25.7
TOTAL 101 100.0
PLACE of ORIGIN
Family Background
On the other hand, one of the strong reasons why CDLs accept
domestic jobs is because one of their parents died. This implied that
some of the cases of CDLs handled by Lingap were only due to the fact
that even at an early age, a child had to fill up some of the working
obligations of the deceased parent to his/her family. A female child
when asked how long had she been helping her mother in her laundry
work said,
“Am, simula po nung namatay ang tatay ko… …Nung
August 2005 po.” --- Julie, 13
Again, another reason was when parents separate. This was what
happened to one of the children under the program which she had to
work separately, since her mother remarried and already had another
family, after being separated with his father.
NUMBER of SIBLINGS
It is true that children who had many siblings go to this job more
often than not since, aside from their parents, they also had to help in
the family’s finances. A discussant said,
Domestic Labor
RELATIONSHIP to EMPLOYER
Some of the participants who are living with their relatives said
they are sent to Manila by their own parents and left them to close
friends/relatives like tito, tita or lola.
Others who worked for people they are not related with said they
were also sent to work for them, since these people would help them
get through their studies. A child also said,
“Pinakilala sa akin ng tatay ko. Tapos sabi po sa akin dadalhin
daw po ako sa Maynila. Tapos po pumunta po kami ng...Basta
po nag-iikot-ikot muna kami dito, nagpunta ng Blumentritt para
magtinda lang po kami ng orchids, pagdating po dun sa Cavite,
sa Bacoor po...Pinag-alaga niya po ako ng anak niya, yung
disable. Ako po nag-alaga nun. Bago po ako dinala ni Ate Marlyn
dun sa Tita ko.”
--- Gerson, 17
WORK HAZARDS
Deprivation of sleep was the most common hazard that the child
domestic laborers reported. Almost one out of four of the children in
the program experience excessive hours of work (24%). The children
have to wake up early to start their chores. A total of eight respondents
reported that they are prohibited to attend school by their employer.
Less than 1/3 of the children have reported “no” work hazards (see
Table 7).
Most of the time though, even at weekends, some of the CDLs still had
to work instead of rest. One FGD participant said,
Such schedule made them literally busy and deprived of rest and
sleep. Some of them had to wake up early everyday and go to bed late
at night only after they’ve finished their household duties. Only this
time can they finally rest and do their assignments in school.
FREE TIME
The Child Domestic Laborers usually had their rest and recreation
after having finished all their tasks for the day. However, some of them
only have their day-offs from work once or twice in one month. Some
of the participants in the FGD said that,
--- Art, 16
SALARY in a MONTH
Educational Background
SCHOOL
All the children involved in the program attend schools which are
located within Quezon City. Among the children, one out of four is
enrolled in Krus na Ligas High School. Other children attend school at
Camp Gerneral Emilio Aguinald High School (19), Flora Ylagan High
School (20), and Carlos P. Garcia High School (13). A small number of
children go to school at Juan Sumulong High School (2) and Ramon
Magsaysay High School (3) (see Table 10.)
Table 10. School
Category f %
Juan Sumulong 2 2.0
Camp General Emilio
19 18.8
Aguinaldo
Carlos P. Garcia 13 12.9
Ramon Magsaysay 3 3.0
Lagro High School 8 7.9
Krus na Ligas 26 25.7
Flora Ylagan 20 19.8
Others 8 7.9
No answer 2 2.0
TOTAL 101 100.0
YEAR LEVEL
Children under the program also get to learn lessons about God
which made them enjoy and thankful about Lingap.
All these endeavors and activities helped the CDLs to be able to socialize with
other people, meet some friends and learn other things outside their boxes. The
organization, together with the Child Domestic Laborers hope that such efforts to
improve their lives would continue for them to get out of domestic job and achieve their
future dreams and ambitions.
Poverty is the primary cause of child labor in the developing countries like the
Philippines. Children work to ensure the survival of their family and themselves. Though
children are not well paid, they still serve as major contributors to family income in the
developing countries.
Children are often prompted to work by their parents. According to one study,
parents represent 62% of the source of induction into employment. Children make their
own decisions to work only 8% of the time (Syed et. al. 1991). In fact, a possible reason
parents in developing countries have children is because they can be profitable of their
children. Children seem to be much less of an economic burden in developing versus
developed countries. Children in developing countries also contribute more time to
households than they deplete as compared to their counterparts in developed countries
(Lindert 1976). Therefore, parents in developing countries make use of children’s ability
to work. Evidence suggests that parents have children based on a cost – benefit
perspective. Children in developing countries tend to be of economic value and, as a
result, become a desirable asset for struggling parents. This desire also leads to the
increase of the population that is also one of the factors causing child labor.
Schooling problems also contribute to child labor. Many times children seek
employment because there is no access to schools possibly because of the distance or
worse yet there are no schools at all. When there is access, the low quality of the
education often makes attendance a waste of time for the students. Schools in many
developing areas suffer from problems such as overcrowding, lack of resources,
inadequate sanitation and pathetic teachers. As a result, parents may find no use of
sending their children to school when they could be home learning a skill, farming for
example and supplementing the family income. Because parents have so much control
over their children, their perception of the value of school is a main determinant of child
attendance. Parents who are educated understand for themselves the importance of
schooling from personal experience. School attendance by a child is also highly
correlated with family income. Therefore, when children drop out of school, it is not
necessarily because of irresponsible parenting; it may be due to the family’s financial
situation. When these children leave school, they become potential workers.
Traditional factors are also important. The established female role in certain
countries dictates that women will not fit into traditional roles if they become educated.
Such cultural practices restrict the education of females and promote child employment.
The acceptance of social class participation perpetuates child labor as well.
Often parents assign different roles into their children. This has been called child
specialization, and may increase the number of working children. This phenomenon
involves certain siblings going to school while the others work.
Rapid rural – to – urban migration is the cause for the increasing rate of child
labor in the urban areas of the developing countries. Families leave the severity of
agricultural working conditions for cities in order to search for economic opportunities
that often do not exist.
Another problem with the complete abolition of child labor is that education
and employment for children are not mutually exclusive. Many children work and go to
school. In fact, many children have to work to go to school; otherwise, they could not
afford the tuition and other fees associated with attendance.
Family structure research shows that 75% of the working children are products
of broken families. There are no parents to take care of them, feed them, provide them
with their first education and their needs so they won’t need to roam around the streets
and do pathetic works to earn money.
COMMUNICATION PROBLEMS
Lack of Awareness – the government has numerous projects on child labor, but the
communities aren’t aware of these or even the approach of the advocates is not pleasing
for the audience.
Lack of Knowledge – people may then have access to the campaign in their community,
but it is also possible that these people are illiterate or couldn’t understand the materials,
or it also depend on what kind of information and materials the advocates will feed the
audience.
Lack of Acceptance – the advocates inform the parents about the issue on child labor, if
they would not accept it because of their orientation that the younger their children work
the better because their children are being trained at an early age. This happens both in
urban and rural areas.
Lack of Determination – the audience accepts the fact that is not right for their children
to work. They also knew that their children could be abused by overworking. They
cannot prevent this because of their status in life. They thought that if all of them will
work it would change their dilemma.
Lack of Access –it pertains to a certain distance of a place. Even though we have
knowledgeable IECs but if the place is not accessible for the advocates its useless,
because we must consider the place of our target audience.
Lack of Participation – people may find it less interesting to attend seminars with
regards to the issue, the employers would probably be in denial when accused violating,
some of the parents who are supposedly the ones to protect their children turned out to be
the ones to push their kids into work, then, even the children involved in the issue are not
participating because of they fear of losing their jobs.
LAWS ABOUT SPECIAL PROTECTION OF CHILDREN AGAINST CHILD
ABUSE, EXPLOITATION AND DISCRIMINATION ACT
Children shall not be the object of attack and shall be entitled to special respect.
They shall be protected from any form of threat, assault, torture or other cruel, inhumane
or degrading treatment.
Shall recognize the vital role of the children in nation building and shall promote
and promote and protect their physical, moral, spiritual, intellectual and social well-
being.
The employer shall consider the following before having a child laborer in their welfare.
A work permit from the Department of Labor and Employment.
Ensure protection, health, safety, and morals of the child.
Institute measures to prevent exploitation or discrimination taking into account
the system and level of remuneration and the duration and arrangement of
working time.
Formulate and implement a continuous program for training and skill acquisition
of the child.
R.A. #7610
R.A. #9231
Determination:
Inculcate to the minds of almost 25% of the respective audience the conditions of those
involving in child labor and the circumstances they are in after 6 months.
PRIMARY AUDIENCE
Child laborers: we have to inform them that even if they need to work for their family’s
survival and their own, there’s still a conflict with it because under 15 years old are not
allowed to work provided that the parents allow them.
Employers: even if they have the good intentions for the welfare of child, still it is against
the law and there are penalties for it. Also it aims to tolerate the child to involve in such
act.
Parents: they should be the first to stop their child to work but with country like ours,
most likely, the parents become dependent to the child hoping that they will alleviate
them from poverty. And also the culture of the Philippines accepts this kind of situation
because parents think that their child is an investment and by this, the child carry the
burden of responsibilities.
TERTIARY AUDIENCE
The government shall recognize the vital role of the youth in nation building and
shall promote and protect their physical, moral, spiritual, intellectual and social well-
being by enhancing their over all development, taking into account sectoral needs and
conditions in the development of educational, cultural, recreational policies and programs
addressed to them