Anda di halaman 1dari 4





  ! #"%$&' (*)
+*,.-0/132154 61879-

:<;>=./@?ACBDFEG18HI2KJ.1MLL4N;

OP4.L?/QHGR DFE1TSKUV?/

WXYVZ.[]\_^`Xab\ cedgf []\@h3iVjhTZ.k


lmab\_XkTknhTopXaqjXer
sutqXv aqh3wpX[]x_h3\myc.dgz{|hTa~}qq[]opt
cp[_[]Xx\P hTknk5rzG{qhTa~}qq[]optz .!
qu sf W
0 u
#
55]5FNG_mN!Ge_
M5NGN]|5 _Mq5NQ5]qN|5N
QN_eM_]5] GV5]
5K5>5~5#5]K]b
M5N]
5Q
eM_N!9]eMIe_eQq9_m5]
NQ]]8MM.9VN] K
]]5 ~N%3# NMF<5Q
#g]5N]NMK0]5Q]>QN
 K Q|NQ5
e  
NM5N5g5 ]QVNK]
_QNN &  _mu5eM K
]5!NMF5!]5 F5#uQ<]K5~
Q_N]||N]qQ5 ]u
5>Qb.V5GFNQQ5>NNQ5 5
 QNM5m
8#NQ.#N5]<5
Q]Q Q]#5NQ5]3 e P
N]q5]K5]Q5N|>]eq]
NM5N PNMu]##M5 eK.5
eQ9]e] N5NK5N
 K<K5]~N
5QN.N
8uN
Ne]>
F5]5
QeN55Q5#N5M
N8M.].G5]F]MF5eQ5] 5<NQ
N5K _M <]K55]] <Q @
5]QN59 eK I]5 ]QN99 !
NM 
~ 
|g> 0  u>g
~NG55]]5uG]5MQQ
FM_eP5]en
u3~M0& &.%mN%m>%u_g` @

]@GN ! NG u>
u3~M 8&F0Q]gN  QM5N Q e
q5u3b0> N

@QVNMP#P5
Q M5NK|NMQ NK5g.5V]
5eQ5] M]N5NK










Q5





unbM 8







~_Q
M5G>N@ ]MQ_
eKN]]
NMQ5>NQ5  NM
5K
5|]QeM5N]08NQN  K
Qe QN K ]MK5]N NMQ&P
Qe  @<
8!NQp M]&mMNK_ 5NKF
N5QNMQg NQQ3 Np
@5~MP ]NG5K5 
 P_ P5IeG]QM_ ]
KQM]
P

] <]Q_ m
m 
]Q_
m Qe 5GuK5
eK5]5]NMQ]
Nge55> * 
]M]uN]
N QKQNMQ &
eM @5]5]  T 5K]

5  NQ]_ Q#M5N


@#5 M]GQ5@uQ N5M
5NN GQ5] |Q &55
5 Q 5]QM_]8MMu m
#]5uNPQNp05]m G]eM
N K
_
9N]~IgN]
_]bFeu55] ]FNM
g]5Q5qMe QT ] 
K5IK5]Fb5 ] #M5Q NQ0N8e_e
u _5I_Q
5 N 5K
5ue K_u5.8
K
GMK NQ ] 5





#"

$&%



('



*)

/ 
,+-+.+
B4.CD<E>>F2.@G:H<E>@ 7A

103254 7698;:=<?>*@ 7A

KJ LJ

-

M"

9N

O>P2Q@R<E> OST2

"

U)

W4*X2DC

[

YMC

G

0 g> ~ m G g
~ N eM .]]NK5NMQuNQ
5]eN5]|K N5Q QG
KQ5|
    

 

 
     
 !"$#&%('


 




)
+*

#NMQ# N5M5N]` @QN 


MNKQ @.5N N 5 NM
eQ] geK _NM>NuK]Q
Q.#]Q
p~5N]NQ q~G n N NK5N]
5  ,GQN!N5Q FM
]FNMQ !Q G5NQ]
m
8<GKN
Gg5Q5
N ge55Q ~]_KNV]eMe_
ebT eKG_F @/ .
0. 21435. g]
~
 5uNQ]q
_ M5Qu

~]u
NQ bNK55u]Pu N]]5
5
687 29 Qe :
687 29 5uK5
~ "
_Q .5
Nq0VNVN
N
;
< q|5Mq.]KQ]| Qe < VNQ
N NMQ]5]]KQ] 
> =m
 ?@A@ :
1
F1; /.GD
B$C m !.ED C
I H /
H
J =
m L K ; M. /; FN
C
C . &.ED C
nO . 8.GD C  K QP
RFTUT2V ~ T XWm N_ g5P
S
QNuQ < FQeY Wm uQeQN 5
N!Q < m 0V ] _NKQ
5K 5NKZ Wm [
Wm m .5
u@ _.]` uM5
QKe5P55 J = H / H S \KGb M
5NL ] L H QNNT5N  _^ ]
  ] NQ < g <     QN
NY W _
W    ma
`5 ]M]c b u0@
Q 8 _>
uN@5NKQ5 QN
eMN d!e Wm >f
WmO d d V 5 M
Ng d h
d  
N@& Wm i
W    g
Wm m^ j
 ?@A@ k D MV I> l.14; TO . L.ED C 2N 3
mon Kqp C rtscW>uv w
scWJuv3 Q P
RFTUT2Vyx
P5I < Q5!M_Q 
S

N@ n N |eMIN
qz Qe55 ~NF5V ~NM
)

.N

*

*)

E8

<E8

E8

E8

"

K4X2DCQ>@

24 7698 4

G>

6 2Q8

2Q@ <

4.2D0

2 7632.8SE<

254

('

<E@ 2

>

>

4.<?:=2

?8

>

O8

<T4

>

T4.2

>

:=<?>*@ 7A

X

>

X 2.@5:

>P<

0 UCD254

O8

2Q@5> U<

'

'



*'&

<ESE2

4M<

*' 

>

E8

>



"

2 76 2Q8 F4 T4D>P2.:

U)



'& 

'&

N@#55QGM~{j
\K
]QK5#5KN]]5
]5
| ? T}R ?@ B$C Q.F14; TO . o. C y. N n ~.lN
!
mon ;}O
1  Q3 C
1 }N 3
o. C . Q m  Q14; Y.
5. }135. Q11 n N
F1 Q.F1; nO . . . K o. C m 1
n
N
F1
F14; X.ED mon  P B$C Q.F1; nO . F1 Q.P m
o. ~. nO .
1 TO . .ED C
.Q lP
NN!T]5]KQ]Q 
RFTUTV~x
S
A,  A
~]u
N@<5NK
< 
< N#Nu#K#]K q
5MK5] &5 u50 
~] VNMQ , K
N ]5 GGQ l ]]5]M
 ]eM NNMQ `!KQ5
Q5N_QQNM5uK5NqQNG
3mSj
]5g_>NQKQN 
NQ; F1N
>3QbNFF].0eF]Q
5K5N5 M5Q_eK###NQ 5 Q
N*Q~ be . 2N . m n
e 0]N
<NMQ]FK]]]5M0 95m
eQN]NM@q]VNQN e]>]QNgp
Q u]50N#]5q]Q ]MgMNK#5NK0
NQ<5 5N]NQe55G 
]Q
]KQ5_G5K5 ]N
NMQ :
,G
Meb#e55Q]
@IG]Q@u5NK_
T}RFTO R+
B$C ; eO l; l11 n 1 Q.F14; TO . C Y.
mM ;} M. C . K &


C
,Ge P
m5]Q|555Q!GQ5P
eKg]q5!P
Q5 F3F1 C Q;}. T } QN5N5P
!QM ! N  t1 lQ; Q11 X;
QN . 1 TO . .GD C . J XQ3 , K
N!.5Q0]]NM_5NK#
M5K5 KQbg uQ]NMK
N5Q Ku55gNV >M
uQ5K5GNN|Q~q ,  FNb@K
N M]KQN` _IpQ@ NQ#55K
eG5 MN 5P@ @!5 MM
] ]<MN!N5 N M
N>>]5NN~5 ]g5K
5
K*]5p!QN#<VK
5]eMN
55
`|5 
24

2.:

>

6 OST2.8

>

6 2Q8

4Q2D0

>

?8

?8

O8

C E@5@ 2Q4X ?8

2 76 2.8SE<

> H@ ?>F<?>

>

2Q@ <

2WC E84D>@ < O8>

CD<
<

>

E84

092

E8

0H>@ <E84

0 O8 6H> =>

2

<E8

> =>

C ?8 UC

Y>> O8 6KX

4.2D02 7632.8 F4 T45>F2.:

<E>

E8

<E8

4 O8 6

>

G>

E8

?8 2

4<

09<?>F<

O8>*4

.2RC.>

28 2F63<?> OSE2

?8

>

6 2.8

2.@

O8SE<E@ U<E8&>

W

'

 N

<

O>

*

E8 X E4 O> OSE2

092*Y8 O>F2

G"

>

<E>

O8 O:

4.2Q4

K<

2 76

2W2

.2DC.>G>

> UCD< 4
>

>

E8

2BC ?8 45>*@R< O8>

4

>

?8

E> U2.8>

D2545>

<

@ 2 P8

?@5:=<

4.<E>

E8

>

2WC -2

2D<T45>M4

<E@R254

C U2.8>*4

X&4.2


092.@

(



-N



Ec+E/:M+L+oFEEl~I> EE O O>El^>+ Z


> lEql+QM+EE^> J2^ o+GolE^JQ+^E>G
FMyE IF +>+U+o>

Bookstein Method

EllipseSpecific Method

e_e5 ]NM_ 55]


M  5_ g
5Q 9m|QN
]M N Q11 T F15 5N] V]NM
M.].5
`|

`|5 !~K I]]5 uQ#]NMI.]e


5NM5g5gNMeQ KqN
M]0QM5] QN_N] | ~G
 N>eMIe_eQV~


"

X > UCD<

d g
P PG0 p
`|_KVNqKN@geM KqNKq5q]NM
M.].<_QN] `|PI9#MNKNN]]
MN]_ g
5QNFuQ
MGQ>NNIN. ~ ]M N NG .
 QN5 N]5Q5]Q>5]
e]|5uN5.]N8M.]eFQ5K5
 55K5MN5NMQ 5 ]M# N
l11 T 1N~K<5
`|5I]
`| K<5] .5 _M_K9]
@ NQNQN<5Q .F1 K 
 .]] 5]Q]K5NQ] M5 NQ
<  QQ5<MN_NG8gNQ._ eM!
N_ NP.Q
5_
M]
QeMuQ<5K5 GuQPN 5
|5@uK5V]5QNg KT| >eNQ
MN]gN]5<K _5NQFQ5gN
5QMQ055N_ #0]eMIe_e
_mGNnM ] Qg5 G5Q
N~Qq5N eMU b Q~_5uQ
K T_5 ~~5N5M_#
]~ M
Y `|5  N
u5]5#]]0eQ
5nQ
_Nm|Q &n8Q5N QN n_N q5]
_MNVQ5>MN5MNQN
N


NM.].#N5]
5GNgN_M]5] 5]
~NKNQ5K5NMK!!5 N5]5
Q~5gN8M.]e#5P NQ5]5 N]c b
QN|Q U b V.e]5qN@ ]uQ
] _~Q55]g<0K!
`|_ Qe NV ]uN@ ]<eNm5] 
Q5 N5MQ MN5]QF5
Q55NK <M5
]Pe> Q
eN5K5u_M5Q uN & @
QN<Q5Q5._]_NQVN
`| K<5.5N *5].]m
e5]M ]3% @FP5.5]5

G"

> UCR<





HX<E@R<

UC

K

-

"

-

4.<E:H2

,)

"

5N

=

9N

4.<E:H2

QNNQ&K5 QKQ5]P 
N 95uN% #K 5]%
55MgN e5NMN ] # ]Q
  ]]QNPe]MuQeuQ
Nu5 QQ
55 M5Q`!QPK !
G]QNK5Nu 5KKg5]5
G5<eM_PN5 N~e_m_b
N_ ]eM_#5N_N]]#Q
u3NG~Qg~u
@m|]Q uNQ_!5NKG5uNN
5]M_#QNe5]>T
QPNQ<Q|] e@]uM5e M5
]]]]GQPQ5g
5
 5]5#M]55QQ. !5]
|Q U b Q5qN NM_]eM_ @Q
NQM]G <5eQ @I ]
KNN_m5 QN5G]NMP8e_eq
gN.NF5 QN]c b F].M]#
N]<. g
M_N&]#MK
`N Ne5_
5]5MG G5 .]]_Q_KebM
<
m < _m3I5]5
eK|Qg b b.5N
F p]m5] g
]nqQeQ NQN_Q_K5
_| |QNQ|e]5
3g  K9MNK_
eK#5NF5uQ5K P_K]
5_M.]
5 QN]c b Qe<|Q I b ]
)

LN

.N

?

"

N#

-N

@R2RC 4.2

H

=4.<?:=2

ST<?@ U<E8

CR2

(

 T)

~  
8N>NQ.
N@
N_M]5]Q]eM]>5NQ5]
#GG.]eF]NM_0N_m
K<u ]5NG
5uN
N8M.]eg5K
>Q5|5NK~~5b.5 5 ]M~
 
.]GNG]0NV#N5
N]55.u_ F55 NM


9N

uwvx y{zn|A}~ "88 gnn|n2z[}


8u5
- - 2[~8gO }C[ Ap z[ -8|Cv 8' -

u55
-2'~8l 0nlz[' 0}l|_[p Az[g2|lCv W\AA8 A2-$
u5 -2~8 O 0 v?pn'8|zn2Lpz[2|Cv
 L [ " 6 
u
An\~ ? } }n2\? } 'y\AA } L-\ R
-z[ 28}} C?}?zn~ P}
u
\2  p 8' }_$ }"
P n[
? n[CR
u5"]v 2|AzA} C?} ?}An|n||}nn2 p;n 28}l}C?}?zn~ P}
A R


Sigma=0.03

Sigma=0.05

Sigma=0.07

Sigma=0.09

Sigma=0.13

5 e]55%N5]M
]]n05KGbN8M.].q Q! KG 
 M5 KG||Q ~q ]NMI.]e
MNK %N MQ5QN&_m5 _5]M!
NQN 5GQ5
NN
`|

N "

L

1

Sigma=0.10

Sigma=0.10

Sigma=0.10

Sigma=0.10

Sigma=0.10

e Pe]5 .]]FNN
P KQNM #K5]Nm %5KG
N8M.].5  KG N
Q
KG  ~F N8M.]eMKFu
uQ5@ M5 
`|

G

-

NW"

FQNe uQQK5N]].]Q
NM5M0085~]5]]5NpgN
5M_5KQN5N~`|5^=#]V!K
]5Q V5.]55 QNQ
5m5  ]NMK5P@KQ K C r 
] mO . P QO P P P ; F; m  
t11 >  . X.P C &1
8#]55G5
55]m5N 
NM uN]Q 
5]<eK#N_  =@IF]K_55.]
N8M.].5P gN]NNF
]
Qp]MuK_
5K#NN5e
9
]Qe5]GN
e]]
#F5]5]M
Q.5M 
I

S 4

?8

O09<

[I

O2D0 O<9C

>*>7X

&:H<

PX

>

2Q:

092-:

>:

  !"$#%'&)(+*-,.0/21/23546/872,:9;*<>= *?.A@0/8*727CBD<A=E3'FG


<A3-.0HIKJLBKMNOMPGRQ;SOTO(UMTWVX(Y/2Z[.03LH72HZ\@A.03'F]/2Z<^_Q;`]/2<69;3-.0ab9;*<
=]*-.A@0/8*727CBdc,]F]IHIJPBegfih4MjlkmNg.n*FL@gNWjWo-Spoq'rs ''tP^

`|5 =
5 KI!!Q N]]5K5Q
NGeM_ 55
BZ

w>WW>W # O
C[K ^ ^O3L3'aP<@0H/2F^ /C@A@0/2F]DZ[3'F]/2Z<AHZ\@0/83F]<)@03:<AZ*?@A@0H[.0HI
I]*?@n*^ W]R\;\P[EnL;An\00P
) s+*\& tr s'sP^
?K ^^ /C@01'/2JJE3'F("^4/272,*F]Ijb^ g^ /2<A`]H[.^p/C.0HZ[@
72H*<@{<0L, *?.0H<W@A@0/8F>3cH7278/2=<AH<^{Fwn]R\nE-E-
\0\ n>-UR\n"lA00]] ,]',<@ s'sr^WQ3 =G
=EH*-.^
-K ^ ^ /2@01['/2J]JE3FU*F]IYjb^ g^ /2<A`]H[.^ J,BLH[. <,]/8IHO@03
Z3'F/2Zl@A@0/8F^ERF>;An00-Pp  \A
"nPE
 0
 \0\En\$/2. /2F* + s'stL^

^Np*F]IH[.]N^ S^PNW3'72,]J ]*-F Ij{^MP@A.0HJEH7^H*<@AG<0L, *-.0H
]@A@0/2F]b3cZ/C.0Z72H<l*F]I>H[7872/2=]<AH[<^  )
*\& ttqt'-q s'sQ
^
t fK^'f{*-F *?@n*F]/^]MP@n*?@0/2<@0/8Z*7]J/8*<63cEZ[3'F]/2Z_@A@0/2F]p*-F I{.0HF]3-.AG
>*72/21*-@0/23F^


]]\[{R\n
lE' -0E
"nP$pnR[ 8L\ \\ r ) *\& '? ' rP s'sQ
^
r 
 ^4 3.A.0/2727^ /C@A@0/2F]H7272/8=<AH<*-F I=.0HI/2Z[@0/2F])Z3 K IHFZH
HF H723'=EH[<g,<A/8F>*KJ]/8*<lZ3-.A.0HZ[@0HI+f{*-7 >*-FY 7C@0H[.^nL
E
 05W]P]q ) *\ HJ.0, *-.AB s'sc'^
4 ^ 6^ jl3'<A/2F^ F]3@0H3F"@0`H78H*<@<0P,]*-.0H<O@A@0/8FY3-cH7CG
72/8=<AH<^{R\n"000
\R\\0 )
F*\& -s's?Lq 'q6TWZ\G
@03'JEH[. s's ^
q 4 ^ 6^jl3'<A/2Fm*F]IXN^ ^_wH<@^iMPH H[FP@0/2FZ,. 'H<d/2FL@03
72/8FH<*F]I*?.0Z<^DRFD;An0APU ]
Pn]R\nE'
 'W \0\ \U g PR\
 0=]*H<>Q
?-q
TW<0*a*  *=]*F pHZ[H JEH[. s'sc'^
s 4 ^ 6^jl3'<A/2F *F I5N^ ^ H<@^Vg3'FG=]*-.n* H\@A.0/8Z><AH HFG
@n*-@0/23'F 3cgZ,. H<b/8FL@0
3 *-.0/23',<.0H=.0H[<AHFL@n*-@0/23'F<^5 Yn
)? *\& 
+'  t pH[ZH JEH\. sstP^
C ' 4 ^ ^pM* =<A3'F^ /2@A@0/2F:Z3F]/2Z<AHZ[@0/23F]<+@0
3 H[.ABm<AZ*?@AG
@0H[.0HII]*-@n*P&U*-F:/C@0H[.n*-@0/ Hd.0H[ FH HFL@3-cp@0`]HY_3L3'aP<@0H/2F
*72'3-.0/C@0!` +^-W PR\>;AnP[ KnKLW;An\00P
) q *\& s' ''qP s'q ^
C'\ N^ Q *,J]/2F^Wh6<@0/ >*?@0/23'F3c=]78*F]*-.pZ[,. H<$<A,.Ac*-ZH<O*-F I
F]3FG=]78*F]*-.<A=]*ZHWZ,. H[<;IH\ F]HI>JLB/ =78/2Z/C@HP,]*-@0/23'F<
9/C@0`*==]72/2Z*-@0/23F]<p@03YHI'H*F]I).n*-F]'H/ >*-'H<AH HFL@n*?G
@0/23'F^_


D +n )' *\& '' t ' qVW"3 H JEH[. s's ^
C?#
 ^lS^;D/872aP/2F]<A3F$
^ ]' L %[5\8L\' &-' ]Y A( %8\^
k_78*-.0HI3'F)4.0H<A<$T )Pc3-.nI ]hF'78*F]I srtP^

Anda mungkin juga menyukai