C, and
then tested in water, at 37
C,
the mean creep strain, after 250,000 cycles, was higher for
Mendec specimens compared with that for KyphX speci-
mens, a trend that was consistent with the trend of higher
density (q) of KyphX cement (and, hence, lower porosity of
KyphX specimens).
47
The signicance of q in creep resist-
ance of a cement is claried when the results from speci-
mens fabricated from a family of cements with essentially
the same composition are considered. Thus, for uncon-
strained hand-mixed specimens immersed in Ringers
solution, at 38.5
C, using a pneumatic
actuator, the creep strain of laboratory-fabricated Palacos R
Cum Gentamicin specimens was signicantly higher than
that of laboratory-fabricated CMW3G specimens,
52
even
though the gentamicin sulfate content of both cements is
REVIEW ARTICLE
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | JUL 2011 VOL 98B, ISSUE 1 173
the same. These results
51,52
indicate that the inuence of
gentamicin sulfate on creep performance is unclear.
Composition of experimental cement. Under quasi-
static compressive stress, reinforcing PMMA bone cement
with either bers or particulates led to substantial reduc-
tion in a specied creep parameter.
35,36,50
These reductions
(relative to the value for unreinforced cement specimens)
amounted to between $33% and $64% in mean creep
strain after a given time when 2 wt/wt % chopped carbon
bers were added to the cement
35,36
; and between $37%
and $68% decrease in creep compliance at 10
5
s when ei-
ther 10 wt/wt % or 20 wt/wt % hydroxyapatite (HA) pow-
der was added to a PMMA bone cement, respectively.
50
For
the carbon ber-reinforced cement, the trends were attrib-
uted to the formation, at a given applied stress, of interpore
cracks in unreinforced cement specimens and their absence
in reinforced cement specimens.
36
For the HA-reinforced
cement, the trends were consistent with the fact that, after
a creep test, the reinforced cement specimens showed
slower and less complete recovery than the unreinforced
ones, which may be attributed to some separation of the HA
particles from the polymer matrix during creep.
50
For a hydrophilic, partially degradable and bioactive
cement, (1) an increase in the amount of the hydrophilic
monomer led to a signicant decrease in the cements creep
rate
45
; (2) consistent with a priori expectation, incorpora-
tion of glass particles into the cement led to a cement with
increased creep resistance under bending, a trend attribut-
able to the formation of an apatitic layer
46
; and (3) in free
swelling, its creep rate is higher than that of commercially
available cements.
45
Monomer-to-polymer ratio (MPR). In the case of two
cements used in VP (Osteopal V and Vertebroplastic), there
was no signicant difference in the creep deformation of
specimens, as obtained in quasi-static four-point bend tests
conducted in distilled water, at 37
C.
49
This trend is
TABLE I. Compositions of a Sample of Commonly Used Commercially Available Injectable Bone Cements
Cement Type/Brand Name Composition/Constituents
a,b
Manufacturer/Supplier
Acrylic Bone Cements
CMW
TM
1 Powder (40.00 g): 35.54 g PMMA, 3.64 g
BaSO
4
, 0.82 g BPO
DePuy CMW Blackpool, UK
Liquid (18.37 g): 18.22 g MMA, 0.15 g
DMPT, 25 ppm HQ
KyphX
VR
HV-R
TM
Powder (20.00 g): 13.60 g MMA-styrene co-
polymer; 6.00 g BaSO
4
, 0.40 g BPO
Medtronic Spinal & Biologics,
Sunnyvale, CA, USA
Liquid (9.00 g): 8.92 g MMA (monomer),
0.08 g DMPT, 75 ppm HQ
Palacos
VR
R Powder (40.00 g): 33.55 g poly(methyl acry-
late, MMA), 6.13 g ZrO
2
, 0.32 g BPO, 1.00
mg chlorophyll
Heraeus Kulzer GmbH, Hanau,
Germany
Liquid (18.78 g): 18.40 g MMA, 0.38 g
DMPT, 0.40 mg chlorophyll
Surgical Simplex
VR
P Powder (40.00 g): 29.40 g poly(MMA, sty-
rene), 6.00 g PMMA, 4.00 g BaSO
4
, 0.60 g
BPO
Liquid (18.79 g): 18.31 g MMA, 0.48 g
DMPT, 80 ppm HQ
Calcium phosphate-based
cements
Biopex
VR
a-TCP, TTCP, DCPD Mitsubishi Materials Corp., Tokyo,
Japan
chronOS Inject
VR
Powder: 42 wt.% b-TCP, 21 wt.% MCPM, 31
wt.% b-TCP granules, 5 wt.% Mg hydro-
gen phosphate trihydrate, < 1 wt.% so-
dium hydrogen pyrophosphate Mg(SO
4
)
2
Oberdorf, Switzerland
Liquid: 0.5% solution of sodium hyalurone
Norian
VR
Skeletal Repair
System
a-TCP, CaCO
3
, MCPM Synthes, Inc.,West Chester, PA, USA
Calcium sulfate-based cements
AlloMatrix
VR
CaSO
4
.0.5H
2
0; demineralized bone matrix Wright Medical Technology,
Arlington, TN, USA
MIIG
VR
X3 CaSO
4
.0.5H
2
0 Wright Medical Technology
Filamentary composite cement
Cortoss
VR
bis-GMA, bis-EMA, TEGDMA, glass
particles
Orthovita, Malvern, PA, USA
a
MMA, methylmethacrylate; BPO: benzoyl peroxide; DMPT, N, N-dimethyl-p-toluidie; HQ, hydroquinone; TCP, tricalcium phosphate; TTCP, tet-
racalcium phosphate; DCPD, dicalcium phosphate dihydrate; MCPM, monocalcium phosphate monohydrate; GMA, glycidyl dimethacrylate;
EMA, ethoxydimethacryylate; TEGDMA, triethyleneglycol dimethacrylate.
b
Compositional details for the acrylic bone cements and chronOs Inject
VR
cement were taken from products brochures.
174 LEWIS VISCOELASTIC PROPERTIES OF INJECTABLE BONE CEMENTS
inconsistent with the relative MPRs for the cements; speci-
cally, MPR for Osteopal V is lower than that of Vertebro-
plastic,
59
leading to the expectation of higher creep resist-
ance of specimens of the former cement.
Polymerization pressure. Polymerization pressure (p)
is the pressure that is applied to the cement dough during
the preparation of a test specimen. For both Mendec and
KyphX cement specimens, over a range 170 kPa p
3200 kPa, mean creep strain, as determined in dynamic
compression tests on specimens in Ringers solution, at
37
C.
40
Similar trends in strength values were attributed
to the formation of laminations within delayed injection
specimens.
60
Length of aging time
Under quasi-static tension loading (stress 3 MPa), the
creep rate of specimens of a PMMA bone cement, at any
creep time, decreased with increase in length of aging (7
24 days) in a given test medium (air, water, Ringers solu-
tion, or Intralipid (a fat solution designed to simulate the
fat in the bone cavity)), a trend that was consistent with
work on physical aging.
42
For unconstrained Surgical Simplex P specimens sub-
jected to quasi-static four-point bending, creep deection
decreased signicantly with increase in the aging time of
the specimens, t
a
(dened as the time interval between
immersion of the specimen in saline at 37
C (1 h t
a
C).
43
This trend was
attributed to the reduction of the plasticizing inuence of
the liquid monomer with increase in t
a
as the monomer
content was reduced by continued polymerization.
43
For unconstrained Palacos RG and SmartSet GHV speci-
mens subjected to quasi-static three-point bending, creep
compliance decreased signicantly with increase in aging
time (dened as the time interval between immersion of
the specimen in water, at 37
C or 40
C), at
any test temperature, was signicantly inuenced by the
test medium, with the rate being similar in distilled water
and Ringers solution, each rate of which was higher than in
Intralipid, which, in turn, was higher than in air. These
trends were explained by the plasticization by each of the
water-based media (water and Ringers solution) and the
increase of leaching of the monomer from specimens tested
in Intralipid.
42
Test medium temperature. Under quasi-static tension load-
ing (stress 3 MPa), the creep rate of specimens of a
PEMA bone cement, tested in a given medium (air, water,
Ringers solution, saline, or Intralipid) increased with
increase in the medium temperature (T); for example, in air,
in the range 24
C T 50
C to 30
C and from
30
C to 40
C and
50
C.
42
In dynamic loading tests on restrained hand-mixed
CMW 1 and Palacos R specimens, creep strain when the
specimens were tested at body temperature was substan-
tially higher than when tested at room temperature, after
the initial creep stage (i.e., at number of test cycles >
1,271,400 cycles).
54
These trends
54
suggest that an increase
in test medium temperature increases the effects of plastici-
zation and are consistent with creep in a given test medium
being considered a thermally activated process.
62
Constraint of test specimen. Under dynamic creep condi-
tions, the creep strain of fully restrained hand-mixed
CMW2000 specimens, in room-temperature air, was signi-
cantly lower than when the specimens were semi-
restrained.
53
This trend is consistent with creep being
described as a consequence of stretching and realignment of
REVIEW ARTICLE
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | JUL 2011 VOL 98B, ISSUE 1 175
TABLE II. Empirical Relationships for Creep Strain of Commercially Available PMMA Bone Cement Specimens
Cement brand Test Conditions Empirical Relationship
a,b
Reference
Cemex Dynamic compression log e 0.3386 log N 4.449 Verdonschot and Huiskes
41
Isoplastic Hand-mixed
Unconstrained
Saline, at 38.5
C
Cemex RX Dynamic compression log e 0.3743 log N 4.366 Verdonschot and Huiskes
41
Hand-mixed
Unconstrained
Saline, at 38.5
C
Cemex Dynamic compression log e 0.3101 log N 4.148 Verdonschot and Huiskes
41
System Mixed within a syringe
Unconstrained
Saline, at 38.5
C
CMW1 Dynamic tension log e [0.13 log r 0.42] log N Jeffers et al.
48
Vacuum-mixed [3.12 log r 2.61]
Unconstrained
Distilled water, at 37
C
CMW1 Dynamic compression e (%) 0.099 ln N 1.178 Liu et al.
54
Hand mixed
Fully constrained
Test medium temperature:
Room temperature
CMW1 Dynamic compression e (%) 0.176 ln N 2.151 Liu et al.
54
Hand mixed
Fully constrained
Test medium temperature:
Body temperature
CMW2000 Dynamic compression e (%) 0.088 ln N 1.029; Liu et al.
53
Hand-mixed r
2
0.925
Fully constrained
CMW2000 Dynamic compression e (%) 0.088 ln N 0.7989; Liu et al.
53
Hand-mixed r
2
0.898
Semiconstrained
Palacos R-40 Dynamic compression e (%) 0.069 ln N 0.622 Liu et al.
54
Hand-mixed
Fully constrained
Test medium temperature:
Room temperature
Palacos R-40 Dynamic compression e (%) 0.2002 ln N 2.371 Liu et al.
54
Hand mixed
Fully constrained
Test medium temperature:
Body temperature
SmartSet Dynamic compression e (%) (0.448N)/(1,063,111 N); Liu et al.
55
GHV Hand mixed r
2
0.96
Semiconstrained
Test medium temperature:
Room temperature
SmartSet Dynamic compression e (%) (1.787N)/(180,332 N); Liu et al.
55
GHV Hand mixed r
2
0.99
Semiconstrained
Test medium temperature:
Body temperature
SmartSet Dynamic compression e (%) (0.410N)/(1,184,562 N); Liu et al.
55
GHV Hand mixed r
2
0.97
Fully constrained
Test medium temperature:
Room temperature
Surgical Dynamic compression e
c
1.22 10
5
N
0.31
10
0.03r
Verdonschot and Huiskes
39
Simplex P Hand-mixed
Unconstrained
Saline, at 38.5
C
Surgical Dynamic compression log e 0.3488 log N 4.426 Verdonschot and Huiskes
41
Simplex P Hand-mixed
Unconstrained
Saline, at 38.5
C
Zimmer Quasi-static compression e 1.76 10
9
r
1.858
t
0.283
Chwirut
36
Regular Hand-mixed e 3.02 10
4
e
(9.37 10-4r)
t
0.283
Unconstrained
Saline, at 37
C
a
e is creep strain; r is applied stress (in MPa) (except, Chwirut,
36
in which r is in lbs in
2
); t is test time (in h); N is number of loading cycles.
b
r
2
is the coefcient of multiple determination of the tted equation.
molecule chains in the cement in that, in a fully restrained
specimen, there is a limited amount of these processes.
54
Nature of applied loading. The number of test cycles (N)
(and, hence, time) required until the creep strain equals the
elastic strain of an unconstrained cement specimen
(applied stress on specimen/elastic modulus of cement),
at a given stress level, may be computed using a best-t
relationship (derived from experimental results; for exam-
ples, see Table II). This time (which is inversely pro-
portional to the creep rate) was signicantly shorter under
cyclical tensile load than under cyclical compressive load, at
stresses > 5 MPa.
39
Furthermore, these times, as obtained
from dynamic compression tests, were signicantly higher
than under quasi-static compression, at stresses > 5
MPa.
36,39
Magnitude of applied stress
Under quasi-static tension loading, the creep rate of speci-
mens of a PEMA bone cement, in a given test medium (air,
distilled water, Ringers solution, or Intralipid), increased
markedly with increases in the magnitude of the applied
stress, which reects the fact that, with increase in stress in
a given test medium, there is increase in the plasticization
effect of the medium.
42
Empirical relationships and modeling. A number of em-
pirical relationships have been derived from experimental
results (Table II), any of which may be used to obtain esti-
mates of long-term creep strain.
In terms of modeling, the time-temperature superposi-
tion principle (TTSP), Struiks effective time method
(SETM),
63
and the integrated time function method (ITFM)
have been applied to compliance (or creep) results for a
commercial acrylic cement and an experimental cement
(PEMA cement).
44,50
TTSP involves three steps. The rst is to compute the
horizontal shift factor, a
T
, using, in most cases, the Struik
equation for compliance, D, at a given test temperature and
test time, t, along with a
T
. Thus, the governing equation for
D(t) is
63
Dt D
o
expt:a
T
=s
m
; (1)
where D
o
is the initial compliance and s and m are con-
stants. For the PEMA cement, at T 37
C
2
T T
s
(2)
where T is the temperature of the test medium, T
s
is a ref-
erence temperature (usually, taken to be the glass transition
temperature of the cement) and C
1
and C
2
are constants
(Figure 1). The third step is to generate the master time-
temperature extrapolated creep compliance (or creep rate)
plot. For the commercial acrylic cement, it was found that,
with C
1
17.4 and C
2
75 K, the t to the experimental
creep compliance (and, hence, rate) results was excellent
(Figure 2).
SETM is used to account for the inuence of aging of
the specimen. The essence of this method is that it may be
used to determine the effective time of a creep test (k),
which is dened as the time required to achieve the same
creep strain if aging had been ongoing. The expression used
to compute k is as follows:
k t
e
t
c
a
t
e
1
_ _
1=a
1
_ _
(3)
where t
e
is the aging time, t
c
is the actual creep time, and
a (1-l), with l (the aging rate) being the slope of the
plot of log a
T
versus log t
e
. For a PEMA cement with experi-
mentally obtained compliance-time results, at 1 MPa, 37
C,
and 1 day of prior aging, the superior performance of
SETM compared with when TTSP was used is evident
50
(Figure 3).
ITFM involves three steps. The rst is to generate the
momentary creep curve, with physical aging not being con-
sidered important. This is done by obtaining the t between
the experimental creep data, on one hand, and either the
Struick equation [Eq. (4)] or the Williams-Watts equation
65
[Eq. (5)], on the other.
Dt D
0
exp
t
s
_ _
m
(4)
Dt D
o
DD
a
1 expt=s
m
(5)
FIGURE 1. Variation of shift factor, a
T
, with test temperature, T, and
the t between the Williams-Landel-Ferry (WLF) equation and the ex-
perimental results, for a poly (ethyl methacrylate) bone cement. (With
kind permission from Springer ScienceBusiness Media; Journal of
Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, Prediction of the long-term
creep behaviour of hydroxyapatite-lled polyethylmethacrylate bone
cements, volume 18, 2007, page 1854, J. C. Arnold and N. P. Venditti,
Figure 6).
REVIEW ARTICLE
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | JUL 2011 VOL 98B, ISSUE 1 177
where D, t, D
o
, s, and m have the same meanings as given
before and DD
a
is a material constant.
The second step is to use results from a long-term creep
test, where aging is important, to obtain values of C and b
as used in the integrated time function. This is accom-
plished thus: (1) plot the equation
FDt
t
st
(6)
with the F(D(t)) applicable to the Struik equation [see
Eq. (7)] or to the Williams-Watts equation [see Eq. (8)].
Dt D
0
exp
_
t
0
du
u
_
_
_
_
m
(7)
Dt D
0
DD
a
1 exp
_
t
0
du
u
_
_
_
_
m
_
_
_
_
(8)
where u is a dummy time variable.
(2) The slope of this plot [i.e., of Eq. (6)] gives the varia-
tion of s(t), whence C and b may be obtained using the
following equation
_
t
0
du
su
where s
2
t s
2
C
2
t
2b
(9)
The third step is to use the values of the constants
obtained (D
o
, s, m, C, and b, if Eq (7) is used or D
o
, s, m, C,
b, and DD
a
if Eq (8) is used) to construct predictive curves
from which the long-term creep data may be read. For a
PEMA cement, the best-t values of the material constants
found were found to be: D
o
2.558, s 2.097 s, m
0.245, C 0.240, and b 0.817 (for t between Eq. (7)
and the experimental data) and D
o
3.900, s 8.00 10
7
s, m 0.601, C 2820, b 0.674, and DD
a
400 GPa
1
,
(for t between Eq. (8) and the experimental data).
50
A
comparison of the creep compliance versus creep time
results, for one set of experimental conditions, to the predic-
tions using the two variants of the ITFM [i.e., via use of
Eq (7) or of Eq (8)] is shown in Figure 4.
FIGURE 3. Experimentally obtained long-term creep compliance-ver-
sus-test time data (recorded data) for a poly (ethyl methacrylate) bone
cement, together with the master curve generated using the time-tem-
perature superposition method and the data computed using Struiks
effective time method. (Experimental data obtained at 1 MPa; Ringers
solution, at 37
C.)
(With kind permission from Springer ScienceBusiness Media; Jour-
nal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, Prediction of the
long-term creep behaviour of hydroxyapatite-lled polyethylmethacry-
late bone cements, volume 18, 2007, page 1855, J. C. Arnold and N.
P. Venditti, Figure 11).
FIGURE 2. Extrapolated creep compliance results at 37
C and 2 MPa
for a commercial acrylic cement, obtained using the time-tempera-
ture superposition method. The temperatures shown are the test tem-
peratures used. Plots were obtained using the following best-t
values for the parameters in the Williams-Landel-Ferry equation: C1
17.4 and C2 75 K. (With kind permission from Springer Science-
Business Media; Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine,
Creep behavior of bone cement: a method for time extrapolation
using time-temperature equivalence, volume 14, 2003, page 324, R. l.
Morgan, D. F. Farrar, J. Rose, H. Forster, and I. Morgan, Figure 5(b)).
FIGURE 4. Experimentally obtained long-term creep compliance-ver-
sus-test time data (recorded data) for a poly (ethyl methacrylate) bone
cement, together with predictions computed using integrated time
functions given by Sruik [Eq. (7)] and Williams and Watts [Eq. (8)].
(Experimental data obtained at 1 MPa; Ringers solution, at 37
C; and
1 day of aging in Ringers solution, at 37
1
E
r
1 e
t=sr
t
g
1
E
c
1 e
t=sc
_ _
(11)
where E
o
is the modulus of elasticity of the cement; 1/E
r
and s
r
are the weight and time constant of the viscoelastic
relaxation, respectively; g is the viscosity of the cement;
and 1/E
c
and s
c
are the weight and time constant of the pri-
mary creep phase, respectively.
Summary. Two observations are in order here. First, in
spite of the existence of results from a multitude of studies,
the inuence of various intrinsic and extrinsic factors on
the creep performance of commercially available PMMA
bone cement brands is unclear. This is because the majority
of these studies were not designed to delineate these
aspects. As a result, many of the studies are limited by the
presence of confounding variable(s), the most common of
which was the use of different commercially available
brands. This situation makes it difcult to, for example,
assess the impact of a combination of extrinsic factors that
are clinically relevant (for example, cement mixing method,
nature of applied stress, and magnitude of stress) on the
creep performance of a given cement brand. Second, there
is limited information on the appropriate model(s) for the
creep behavior of PMMA bone cements. This hampers the
development of rational method(s) of synthesizing a cement
brand from the perspective of creep deformation.
Stress relaxation
Cement composition and cement brand. For a surgical
grade cement, at a constant compressive strain of 1%, at a
given value of time during the test, the extent of stress
relaxation increased when the cement was reinforced by
incorporating 2 wt/wt % chopped carbon ber into the
cement powder.
35
The rate of stress relaxation was signicantly higher in
Palacos R (stress relaxed to practically zero after 6 weeks)
compared with both CMW1 and Simplex P (in both, stress
relaxed to 100 kPa after one year).
66
During unconstrained stress relaxation tests, conducted
under quasi-static four-point bending, the relaxation of the
load in Surgical Simplex P specimens, with time, when
tested in saline solution at 37
C.)
68
The trend in these results
43,68
was attributed to reduction
of the plasticizing effect of the monomer with increase
in t
m
.
43
Empirical relationships and modeling. The experimental
evidence (Table III) indicates that, for a given cement, the
relaxation of compressive stress with time in the specimen
may be modeled using the Maxwell viscoelastic model.
Experimental data obtained on hand-mixed Surgical Sim-
plex P specimens, tested in four-point bending, in water at
37
_
1
0
Ks expt=sds (13)
REVIEW ARTICLE
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | JUL 2011 VOL 98B, ISSUE 1 179
with K(s) C
2
/s C
3
/s
n
and E
1
, C
1
, C
2
, C
3
, s, and n are
constants. That is, this drop is describable using one main
relaxation time (s
1
) superimposed on a continuous spec-
trum of relaxation times. For example, for Surgical Simplex
P specimens, the best-t values of E
1
, C
1
, C
2
, C
3
, s, and n
were found to be 1000 MPa, 1300 MPa, 130 MPa, 15, 9
10
4
s, and 1.1, respectively.
67
Each of these models [Eqs. (12) and (13)] allows a pre-
diction of the long-term extent of stress relaxation of a
cement specimen on the basis of results obtained in the
short-term.
Summary. The literature is very limited in a number of
respects, such as studies on only a few commercially avail-
able cement specimens, investigations of only a few inu-
encing factors, and a few contributions in the area of
modeling.
Damping
Background. The ability of a viscoelastic material, such as
an ABC, to dissipate strain energy as heat can be deter-
mined using a dynamic test. Such a testing mode is relevant
to ABC being used in a TJR, in which, during activities of
daily living, the cement mantle is subjected to cyclical load-
ing. The essential relationship in damping studies recog-
nizes that a given modulus of the cement is a complex
parameter; for example, the complex elastic modulus (E) is
E E
0
iE
00
(14)
where E
0
is the storage modulus and characterizes the mate-
rials elasticity, and E is the loss modulus and characterizes
its internal damping capacity.
Thus,
Loss=damping factor; tan d E
00
=E
0
(15)
(Note that Eqs. (14) and (15) may also be written in terms
of the shear modulus, G.)
Test mode. With one exception, dynamic mechanical ther-
mal analysis (DMTA) (sometimes referred to as dynamic
mechanical analysis, DMA), operated in three-point bending
mode, has been used to determine E
0
, E
00
, and tan d, as a
function of the cured cement specimens temperature, T
0
(at
a xed test frequency, f).
6971
In a DMTA test, typical speci-
men size is 25.040.0 mm 10.0 mm 1.01.5 mm, and
typical test conditions are: displacement, 64 lm; static force,
60 mN; dynamic force, 40 mN; rate of heating of specimen,
24
C min
1
; range of T
0
: 20200
C; and range of f 1
30 Hz.
6971
The exception is a study in which the DMTA
tests were performed on cured cement specimens, in a dis-
placement control mode; that is, using a frequency sweep
(0.01100 Hz) and a temperature sweep (1757
C).
67
Damping properties may also be obtained using a plate-
plate congured rheometer (typical radius of plates and gap
between them 2025 mm and 2 mm, respectively), oper-
ated in a dynamic oscillation (constant strain) mode
FIGURE 5. Schematic drawing of the spring-dashpot model for the
stress relaxation behavior of a PMMA bone cement. (Reprinted from
Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Jour-
nal of Engineering in Medicine, volume 216, number 3, O. R. Eden, A.
J. C. Lee, and R. M. Hooper, Stress relaxation modeling of polyme-
thylmethacrylate bone cement, pages 195-199, copyright (2002), with
permission from Professional Engineering Publishing).
TABLE III. Empirical Relationships for Stress Relaxation of Commercially Available PMMA Bone Cement Specimens
Cement Test Conditions Empirical Relationship
a,b
Unit for t Reference
Braxell Hand-mixed r 4.18 e
0.0054t
; s De Santis et al.
67
Stored in distilled water, at 37
C, r
2
0.643
for 21 d
Tested in water
Three-point bend loading
Palacos R Hand-mixed r 20.49 e
0.020t
; h Lee et al.
43
Stored in saline, at 37
C, for 7 d r
2
0.766
Tested in saline, at 37
C
Four-point bend loading
Simplex P Hand-mixed r 19.14 e
0.0104t
; min Eden et al.
68
Stored in air, at 37
, for 6 h r
2
0.889
Tested in water, at 37
C
Four-point bend loading
Surgical grade r 18.91 e
0.286t
h Pal and Saha
35
a
r is stress, in MPa.
b
Empirical relationship was given explicitly in the article by Pal and Saha,
35
but each of the other three empirical relationships was derived
by the present author from experimental results given in the original article.
180 LEWIS VISCOELASTIC PROPERTIES OF INJECTABLE BONE CEMENTS
(typically, strain amplitude and frequency 1% and 1
5 Hz, respectively), with the curing cement being tested at a
xed temperature.
7275
Typically, results in a damping study are presented as
(1) the variation of the storage modulus, the loss modulus,
and/or tan d with specimen temperature, at a xed test fre-
quency [Figure 6(a)] and/or (2) the variation of the storage
modulus, the loss modulus, and/or tan d with test time (t)
at a xed combination of T
0
and f [Figure 6(b)].
Inuence of cement composition. In the case of a PMMA
bone cement, in which the radiopacier was provided by
BaSO
4
particles (10% p/p) in the cement powder, when dry
cured specimens were used, the storage modulus, at a given
T
0
, was practically the same as when radiopacity was pro-
vided by incorporating an iodine-containing monomer, 4-
iodophenol methacrylate (IPMA) (520% v/v), in the liquid
phase.
70
The same trend was found for the tan d results.
70
In the case of a PMMA bone cement in which the radio-
pacier was provided by BaSO
4
particles (10%) in the
cement powder, when dry cured specimens were used,
the storage modulus, at a given T
0
(f xed), was practically
the same as when radiopacity was provided by any one of
three other radiopaciers (10% bismuth salicylate (BS)
incorporated in the powder; BS coated with polyethylene
oxide incorporated in the powder (BSPEO); and BS dis-
solved in the liquid monomer (BSDM)).
71
The same trend
was found for the tan d results.
71
Up to t
m
$16 min, the
pattern of increase of G
0
with increase in time from com-
mencement of mixing of the cement, t
m
(at a xed combina-
tion of T
0
and f) was practically the same when the radiopa-
cier was 10 wt % BaSO
4
particles in the powder as when
any one of three other radiopaciers incorporated in the
cement powder (10 wt % strontium hydroxyapatite (SrHA),
10 wt % SrHA treated with MMA (SrHA-m), and 20 wt %
SrHA-m).
75
For t
m
> $16 min, there were similarities and
differences seen in the plots for the four cements: for the
10 wt % BaSO
4
-containing cement, there was a sharp rise
in G
0
(corresponding to an increase in polymerization); for
the 20 wt % SrHA-m-containing cement, there was a slow
rise in G
0
for up to t
m
$10 min, followed by a sharp rise
thereafter; and for each of the other two cements, G
0
increased at the same rate as during t
m
$16 min.
75
All of
the aforementioned patterns were also seen in the G
00
results.
75
Inuence of cement brand. In a displacement control
mode experiment, (1) up to f 10 Hz, the mean value of
tan d for the cured Braxell specimens was about the same
as for the cured CMW1 and Surgical Simplex P specimens;
(2) in the range 10 Hz < f < 100 Hz, tan d for the cured
Braxell specimens was marginally higher than for the other
two cured cement specimens; and (3) the increase in tan d,
with increase in f, was slightly greater for the cured Braxell
specimens compared with those of the other cements.
67
These results suggest that the main factor that inuences
the damping factor in a PMMA bone cement is the constitu-
ent of the main polymer chain; in other words, since PMMA
is the main polymer in Braxell, CMW1, and Surgical Simplex
P, their tan d-f prole was about the same.
67
Inuence of size of PMMA beads. For experimental PMMA
bone cements designed for use in VP and BKP, at a given
value of t
m
(for a xed combination of T
0
and f), a decrease
in the ratio of large PMMA beads (mean diameter 118
lm) to small ones (mean diameter 70 lm) (we designate
this ratio R, in wt /wt %) in the powder led to an increase
in both G
0
and G
00
.
72
This trend was attributed to the disso-
lution of the small beads (and, hence, the beginning of
increasing polymerization rate) appearing earlier as R
increases.
72
Inuence of state of hydration of test specimens. In the
case of a PMMA bone cement in which the radiopacier was
provided either by adding BaSO
4
particles (10% p/p) to the
cement powder or by incorporating IPMA (520% v/v) in
the liquid phase, for both dry and wet cured specimens, at a
given T
0
(f xed), the pattern of change of storage modulus
with test temperature was unaffected by the state of hydra-
tion of the test specimen.
70
For the tan d results, (1) for
each cement, there was a broadening of the plots when wet
specimens were used compared to when dry ones were
used, which was attributed to a plasticizing process
70
; and
FIGURE 6. (a) Typical variation of the storage modulus and the loss
angle (tan d) with temperature of a cured PMMA bone cement speci-
men, obtained at 2 Hz. (b) Typical variation of storage modulus, loss
modulus, and tan d of a curing PMMA bone cement dough, with test
time, obtained at room temperature of 22
C when
dry cured specimens were used to a mean of $115
C when
wet cured ones were used in the case of the BaSO
4
-contain-
ing cement and from a mean of $129
C to a mean of
$116
C.
182 LEWIS VISCOELASTIC PROPERTIES OF INJECTABLE BONE CEMENTS
In the second approach, the viscosity tests were per-
formed using a commercially available device that basically
involved placing the cement dough in a cartridge and con-
tinuously recording the force needed to immerse a cone-
shaped measuring tool (diameter and surface area 28
mm and 610 mm
2
, respectively), at a dened speed (typi-
cally, 0.03 mm/s), into the dough as it polymerizes. In the
present review, we shall designate the plot of the results
obtained using this device as the force viscosity-versus-t
m
plot.
82,83
In the third approach, the cement dough was placed into
the cup of a rheometer that has a cup-and-plate congura-
tion (or on the lower plate of a rheometer that has a plate-
plate conguration), bringing the plate or top plate to touch
the dough, and then performing the test in a dynamic
oscillation mode (i.e., the plate or top plate is subjected to a
displacement (typically, 6 10 lm) at a xed frequency (typ-
ically, 15 Hz).
7275,8486
) The rheometer is a force-reso-
nance analyzer which means that the peak compressive
force transferred from the curing cement (F) to the plate is
tracked by a force transducer, as a function of t
m
. The F
t
m
results are exported to a computer containing a soft-
ware that converts these results to complex viscosity (g*)-
versus-t
m
results.
8486
Typical g*-t
m
results are given in
Figure 7(b).
The fourth approach involved using a coaxial cylinder-
type self-sensing rheometer that is comprised of an oscillat-
ing spindle that is inserted in the cement dough and is driven
by a computer-controlled electromagnetic actuator.
87
The
actuator uses a model to obtain both the displacement and
the torque without the use of sensors, from which the
storage modulus (G
0
) and the loss modulus (G
00
) of the curing
are obtained. A software package in the computer converts
these moduli to g* using the following relationships:
g
0
G
00
=x; g
00
G
0
=x; g g
0
ig
00
(19)
The issue of comparability in the viscosity-t
m
results
based on the viscosity measurement method used has
received very limited attention, with one study being on
CMW3.
84
For this cement, at a given value of t
m
, it was
found that g* is markedly higher than l, a nding that is in
consonance with the Cox-Merz rules.
88
A caveat should be
attached to this result because, g* was experimentally
determined in one study
84
but the corresponding l result
was taken from another study/report.
17
Categorization of cement brands. Results of the variation
of l with t
m
has been used to categorize commercially avail-
able cements into low-viscosity cements (for example,
Zimmer LVC; l 1 kPa s at t
m
5 min); medium-viscos-
ity cements (for example, Surgical Simplex P; l 5 kPa s
at t
m
5 min) and high-viscosity cements (for example,
Palacos R; l 14 kPa s at t
m
5 min).
89
Explanation of viscosity-time prole. When g* is deter-
mined, it is seen that, with increase in t
m
, there is an initial
steady rise, followed by a nal rapid rise. The former stage
is due to swelling and dissolution of the polymer beads in
the liquid monomer as the powder is wetted by the mono-
mer, while the latter stage is due to the polymerization
reaction.
84,90
Inuencing factors. The importance of the composition of
the powder beads in a PMMA bone cement is exemplied
by the clear differences in the force viscosity-versus-t
results for two commercially available PMMA bone cements;
specically, a tobramycin-loaded cement (Simplex with
Tobramycin) showed a lower initial value of median force
viscosity than a gentamicin-loaded cement (Palacos RG).
In Simplex with Tobramycin, the beads are of MMA-styrene
copolymer and, thus, are more hydrophobic (take longer to
dissolve in the liquid monomer) than the MMA-MA beads in
Palacos RG.
83
On the basis of the force viscosity-versus-time results
obtained from three variants of a commercially available
gentamicin-loaded PMMA bone cement (Refobacin Palacos
R, Palacos RG, and Refobacin Bone Cement), it was sug-
gested that, for a gentamicin-loaded cement, the median
force viscosity, at a given t
m
, may be inuenced by varia-
tion in the polymer/copolymer particle size ratio.
82
Appa-
rent contradictions in the force viscosity-versus-t
m
results
for Palacos RG and Refobacin Bone Cement from the same
research group
82,83
point to the need for further study of
the issue of the signicance of variation in composition of a
given gentamicin-loaded PMMA bone cement vis a vis curing
cement properties.
The fact that cements belong to the same viscosity cate-
gorization group (i.e., high-viscosity, medium-viscosity or
low-viscosity) does not necessarily mean that their g*-t
m
proles are of the same form. Thus, differences were noted
in this prole for Cemex Isoplastic, CMW1, and Palacos R,
each of which is a high-viscosity brand.
73
Specically, dur-
ing the early stages of curing, Cemex Isoplastic was the
most viscous, and Palacos R the least viscous, with CMW1
becoming the most viscous in the latter stages of curing.
73
For an experimental cement, whose radiopacity was pro-
vided by ZrO
2
(530%), for a given amount of ZrO
2
, l was
signicantly higher when cross-linked PMMA nanospheres
were added to the powder than when cross-linked PMMA
macrospheres were added. This was attributed to (1) the
higher surface area of the nanospheres, which translates to
high diffusion of the liquid monomer
81
; and (2) increase in
the volume fraction of particles in the powder mixture.
91
Each of three experimental cements designed for use in
VP and BKP (radiopacier: 10%BaS0
4
; radiopacier: 10%
BaSO
4
5% ciprooxacin (CFX); and radiopacier: 10%
BaS0
4
3% CFX 3% vancomycin) displayed g*-t
m
char-
acteristics, in the initial stage, that are very similar to those
for a commercially available PMMA bone cement (Osteopal
G) at t
m
< $6 min.
74
Because of delayed setting, however,
g* remains constant and low for much longer (up to t
m
>
$11 min) before a nal sharp rise in the case of the experi-
mental cements.
74
The inuence of radiopacier on the g*-t prole of an
ABC depends on the section of the curve being considered.
REVIEW ARTICLE
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | JUL 2011 VOL 98B, ISSUE 1 183
Thus, for an experimental cement, for t
m
$15 min, the
g*-t curve was practically the same when the radiopacier
was 10 wt % BaSO
4
particles in the powder as when any
one of three other radiopaciers (10 wt % SrHA, 10 wt %
SrHA treated with MMA (SrHA-m), and 20 wt % SrHA-m)
was blended into the powder.
75
For t
m
> $15 min, there
were similarities and differences seen in the plots for the
four cements. For the 10 wt % BaSO
4
-containing cement,
there was a very sharp rise in g* (which corresponds to an
increase in polymerization). For the 20 wt % SrHA-m-con-
taining cement, there was a slow rise in g* for 10 min, fol-
lowed by a sharp rise, whereas for each of the other two
cements, g* rose at a moderate rate.
75
Reducing the modulus of a PMMA cement for use in VP
or BKP, by adding N-methyl-pyrrolidone to the liquid mono-
mer (5060%), led to a signicant reduction in the poly-
merization rate, as manifest through a signicant reduction
in g*, at any given t
m
.
80
This trend is attractive in that it
shows an approach that may be taken to widen the window
for injecting the cement into the cannula during VP or BKP.
The importance of the dispersal of an additive in the
cement on the viscosity-time characteristics is illustrated by
results from two variants of an experimental cement, one in
which a clay (2% sodium montmorillonite (SMMT) or 2%
organophilic montmorillonite (OMMT)) was blended with
the powder and the other in which the clay was added to
the liquid monomer. In each variant, there was an increase
in g*, at a given t
m
(relative to case for the plain cement),
with this trend being likely due to the clay increasing the
shear modulus of the cement.
85
More importantly, however,
at a given t
m
, a cement in which OMMT was added to the
liquid monomer showed the highest g*, this trend being
attributed to the clay in this cement being well dispersed.
85
For Palacos R, a decrease in the temperature at which
the cement was stored prior to mixing (T
st
) led to a
decrease in l throughout the polymerization period.
79
Alter-
natively, for this cement, the time taken to reach a specied
viscosity increases with increase in T
st
.
79
These trends may
be explained in terms of the fact that lowering of T
st
leads
to delay of generation of free radicals, which translates to
delaying the initiation of the polymerization process.
79
The time taken to reach a specied viscosity decreases
with increase in the temperature of the room in which the
cement is mixed (T
a
).
90
This observation highlights the need
to ensure that, during a cemented TJR procedure, the tem-
perature of the operating room does not uctuate at the
early stages; that is, during the time interval between
cement preparation and hardening of the cement in the
bone bed.
The method used to mix the cement is an important
inuencing factor. Thus, for each of three commercially
available PMMA bone cements (Antibiotic Simplex, DP-Pour,
and Vertebroplastic), mean l, at a given time (t
m
), was
markedly higher when the cement was hand/manually
mixed compared to when it was mixed using an oscillating
machine (shaking stroke amplitude and frequency 20 mm
and 10 Hz, respectively).
78
This trend was attributed to the
pseudoplastic behavior of PMMA bone cements; that is, the
thinning of the cement when subjected to a large shear strain
as is experienced during oscillatory mixing. Furthermore, at a
given t, the coefcient of variation (standard deviation/
mean) of the l results, which is a measure of their reprodu-
cibility, was markedly lower when oscillatory mixing was
used compared with when hand mixing was used.
78
This was
attributed to the fact that the oscillatory mixing conditions
were controlled (xed shaker stroke amplitude and fre-
quency) whereas the hand mixing conditions were not.
78
For a given cement, for a given t
m
, l decreases with
increase in shear rate, c, in a manner describable by the fol-
lowing power equation
92
l a
t
t
s
_ _
b
_ _
c
c
s
_ _
ct=tsd
(20)
where t
s
is a characteristic time, c
s
is a characteristic shear
rate, and a, b, c, and d are constants, all of whose values are
determined from the t between the experimental data and
Eq. (20). For example, for Surgical Simplex P, for 3.0 min
t
m
5.0 min and 0.4 s
1
c 100 s
1
, the best-t values
of the constants in Eq. (20) were found to be: t
s
1.0 min,
c
s
1.0 s
1
, a 590.0 Pa s, b 1048.8 Pa s, c
0.026, and d 0.290.
92,93
This observation of l decreas-
ing with increasing c, which shows that curing cement is a
pseudoplastic material, has clinical relevance in that it could
be used by orthopaedic surgeons in making a decision as to
whether to insert the cement dough into the prepared bone
bed rapidly or slowing. Any such decision, however, should
also take cognizance of the inuence of delivery speed on
cement interdigitation; specically, interdigitation is facili-
tated by slow delivery of the cement dough. This same
trend, namely, decrease of viscosity with increase in shear
rate, at given value of t, was seen when g* results were
used.
86
Summary. There is a sizeable literature on the inuence of
an assortment of intrinsic factors, such as cement composi-
tion, and extrinsic factors, such as cement mixing method,
on the viscosity-time prole of a PMMA bone cement. The
ensuing databank of results allows the identication of fac-
tors to be used in order to obtain a desired prole of vis-
cosity-time following commencement of cement mixture.
Relationship between handling, viscosity,
and damping parameters
Three handling parameters that are related to the viscosity-
versus-t
m
prole are: (1) the time of onset of cure
(t
ons
),
72,74
(2) the critical cure rate (CCR),
84
and (3) the
cure time (t
cur
).
73
Both t
ons
and CCR were estimated from
the g*-t
m
results. t
ons
was dened as the time at which
there was a signicant increase in g*
84
or as the time at
which the intersection of the linear ts of the initial and
nal zones in an g*-t
m
plot occurs.
72
From a phenomeno-
logical perspective, t
ons
may be regarded as the time at
which the process that accounts for the viscosity of the
cement changes from dissolution of the PMMA beads in the
liquid monomer to polymerization.
72
CCR was dened as
184 LEWIS VISCOELASTIC PROPERTIES OF INJECTABLE BONE CEMENTS
the value of the time derivative of the best-t equation to
the initial stage of the g*-t
m
results with t
m
being put equal
to t
ons
in that derivative.
84
For example, for CMW3, the
aforementioned best-t equation was found to be
84
:
g 1713:655t
m
1:691
for 0 t
m
8:5 min r 0:998
(21)
Since t
ons
was found to be 12.03 min,
84
CCR 1.62
10
4
Pa s min
1
.
For PMMA bone cements for use in TJRs, both t
ons
and
CCR increased signicantly with increase in both the rela-
tive amount of small-sized PMMA beads (mean diameter, d,
between 0 and 40 lm) in the cements powder (we desig-
nate this ratio, a) and the relative amount of large-sized
PMMA beads (d > 75 lm) in the cements powder (we des-
ignate this ratio, b).
84
This was explained as follows: during
polymerization, the small-sized PMMA beads are completely
dissolved in the liquid monomer, while the dissolution of
the large-sized PMMA beads takes a longer time; thus, high
a leads to high CCR and high b leads to high t
ons
.
84
Bead size is also important for PMMA bone cements for
use in VP and BKP. For one experimental formulation of such
a cement, an increase in the proportion of small PMMA beads
(mean diameter 70 lm) to large ones (mean diameter
118 lm) (we designate this ratio, H, in wt/wt %) led to an
increase in t
ons
.
72
For example, t
ons
was 7 min and $13 min
for H 0.11 and 9.00, respectively.
72
This trend was attrib-
uted to the dissolution of the beads (and, hence, the onset of
polymerization) appearing earlier as H increases
72
For experimental cements designed for use in VP and
BKP, there is a linear relationship between t
ons
and setting
time (as determined using the international materials test-
ing standard, ISO 5833).
72
This relationship points to,
among other things, the potential of rapid estimation of t
ons
via the testing standard because there is widespread famili-
arity with the standard.
From results of the variation of G
0
, G
00
, and tan d with t
m
,
t
cur
was obtained as the time at which these parameters
reach a maximum, minimum, and minimum, respectively.
73
With this approach, for Cemex Isoplastc, CMW1, and Palacos
R, t
cur
decreased by $50% when the temperature at which
the measurements were made was increased from 25
C to
37
C,
73
which reiterated the point that cement curing is a
thermally activated (Arrhenius) process.
62
Strain rate dependence of mechanical properties
With increase in the strain rate used in a test (e
:
), marked
increases in various mechanical properties of different
cement brands have been reported. Specically, for (1)
shear strength increased by 30% when e
:
was increased
from 0.001 s
1
to 0.1 s
194
; (2) compressive strength of a
commercially available antibiotic-loaded PMMA bone
cement (AKZ) increased by 50% and 67% when the speci-
mens were loaded at 1.8 s
1
and 5.2 s
1
, respectively
(increase relative to value obtained when specimens were
loaded quasi-statically)
95
; and (3) for a carbon ber-rein-
forced PMMA bone cement, compressive strength increased
27% when e
:
was increased from 6.2 10
4
s
1
to 1.24
10
2
s
1
.
96
These ndings,
9496
which underscore the fact that
PMMA bone cement is a viscoelastic material, highlight the
need to state, in comparisons of results from various litera-
ture studies of a specied mechanical property for a given
cement, the loading rates used in these studies.
CALCIUM PHOSPHATE CEMENTS
Viscosity-time and damping proles
Method of determination. For viscosity determination,
two types of rheometers have been used. One is a capillary
rheometer, which leads to determination of false or appa-
rent viscosity (l).
78,97100
The other is a cone-and-plate sys-
tem, in which a predetermined shear rate-versus-time wave
is imposed on the CPC slurry, allowing determination of
shear stress-versus-shear strain rate curve and, hence, if
desired, dynamic viscosity (g*)-versus-t
m
prole.
101103
An adjunctive test, performed in a cone-and-plate rhe-
ometer, involves applying a small-amplitude sinusoidal oscil-
lation strain to the CPC slurry, and then using the resulting
shear stress and shear strain values to determine G
0
and G
00
.
101103
Characteristic features. At a given combination of condi-
tions in a dynamic viscosity test (i.e., for a xed combination
of applied frequency and strain), G
0
, G
00
, and g all increase
with increase in t
m
, in accordance with the following
power-law relationship
S a expbt
m
; (22)
where S is a given rheometric parameter (that is, G
0
, G
00
, or
g*), a represents the initial value of the parameter (i.e., a
value that denotes the state of the grains in the CPC slurry
prior to commencement of the setting reaction), and b is
related to the rate of the setting reaction.
103
For example,
using G
0
results for a slurry of a CPC (powder: equimolar
TTCP (mean particle diameter: 13.3 lm) and dicalcium
phosphate anhydrous (DCPA; mean particle diameter: 0.63
lm); liquid: deionized water), the best-t values of a and b
were found to be 1621 Pa and 6.45 10
3
s
1
, respec-
tively, when the slurry powder-to-liquid ratio (PLR) and test
temperature were 2.00 g mL
1
and 37
C, respectively.
103
The existence of a hysteresis loop in the shear stress-
versus-shear rate prole of a CPC, as obtained from viscos-
ity tests (Figure 8), demonstrates that the slurry is a thixo-
tropic material.
100,103
At a given setting time, there is an
overshoot of the shear stress in the initial stage of the vis-
cosity-versus-shear rate prole when shear rate was less
than 1.5 s
1
(Figure 8), indicating the existence of a yield
stress in the slurry.
103
A CPC slurry is a non-Newtonian
uid that displays shear thinning, evidenced by the facts
that (1) its viscosity decreases with increase in shear rate
(after a critical shear rate, such as 1.5 s
1103
or 15.0 s
1100
;
(2) G
0
, G
00
, and g* all decrease with increase in the shear
strain used in a dynamic viscosity test, for a given test fre-
quency (x)
103
; 3) at x greater than a critical value (for
example, 0.2 rad s
1103
), g* decreased with increase in x
103
REVIEW ARTICLE
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | JUL 2011 VOL 98B, ISSUE 1 185
and (4) at x greater than a critical value (for example, 0.7
rad s
1103
), both G
0
, G
00
decreased with increase in x.
103
Inuencing factors. The viscosity of a CPC slurry is sensi-
tive to the incorporation of additives to the basic constitu-
ents of the powder. (Basic constituents are herein dened
to be the various CaP compounds.) Thus, at a given shear
rate, the viscosity of an experimental CPC (powder: 50 wt/
wt % amorphous calcium phosphate (ACP) 50 wt/wt %
DCPD; median powder particle diameter: 3.0 lm; liquid:
deionized water; PLR 2.0 g mL
1
) decreased signicantly
with increase in the amount of strontium carbonate (SrCO
3
;
median diameter; 2.5 lm) added to the cement powder,
over the SrCO
3
content range of 020 wt/wt %.
98
For exam-
ple, at 1 10
2
s
1
, viscosity decreased by a factor of 10
when the content was increased from 0 to 12 wt/wt %.
98
This trend, together with other results (radiopacity, inject-
ability, compressive strength, and pore distribution) sug-
gests that this CPC containing 12 wt/wt % SrCO
3
may have
promise for use in VP and BKP.
98
The particle size in the powder suspension of a CPC
exerts a marked inuence on the viscosity of its slurry. For
example, at a given PLR, the viscosity of a slurry of a b-TCP
CPC increased with increase in the time over which the
powder was milled in a planetary mill, t
m
(3 t
m
C T
sl
37
C),
103
consistent
with setting of the CPC slurry being an Arrhenius process.
62
FIGURE 8. Variation of shear stress with shear strain rate for a CPC
slurry after 30 s of setting (CPC powder mixed with deionized water
using a powder-to-liquid ratio of 2.25), obtained using dynamic rheo-
logical testing at 37