ALL NEWS

APPLE GUIDES

ASK ARS REVIEWS

BUSINESS

GADGETS

GAMING

MICROSOFT

OPEN SOURCE

SCIENCE

TECH POLICY

MORE

SEARCH

CONSUMERIZATION OF IT

Upgrade to a Premier Subscription

Customize

OpenForum

Login/Join

We're watching: malls track shopper's cell phone signals to gather marketing data
By Sean Gallagher | Published 7 days ago

Increase text size Reduce text size Print this story Leave a comment (188) http://arst.ch/row

LATEST TOP STORIES Online retailers have long gathered behavioral metrics about how customers shop, tracking their movements through e-shopping pages and using data to make targeted offers based on user profiles. Retailers in meatspace have had tried to replicate that with frequent shopper offers, store credit cards, and other ways to get shoppers to voluntarily give up data on their behavior, but these efforts have lacked the sort of data capacity provided by anonymous store browsersat least until now. This holiday season, shopping malls in the US have started collecting data about shoppers by tracking the closest thing to "cookies" human beings carry their cell phones. The technology, from Portsmouth, England based Path Intelligence, is called Footpath. It uses monitoring units distributed throughout a mall or retail environment to sense the movement of customers by triangulation, using the strength of their cell phone signals. That data is collected and run through analytics by Path, and provided back to retailers through a secure website. On March 31, Path CEO Sharon Biggar presented the tech at the ICSC Fusion conference in Los Angeles. She discussed how data collected by Footpath could be used by retailers to boost revenue. Options include tracking response to mailers and other advertising by providing the equivalent of web metrics like unique visitors, "page impressions" (measuring how many people walked past a display or advertisement), and "clickthrough" (determining how many people who passed an advertisement then visited the store associated with it). "Now we can produce heat maps of the mall and show advertisers where the premium locations are for their adverts," she said, "and perhaps more importantly we can price the advertising differently at each location." In the US, Footpath is being trailed in two malls by Forest City, a mall real estate company that owns malls and shopping centers nationwide. Promenade Temecula in Temecula, California, and Short Pump Town Center in Richmond, Virginia are the sites of choice; the trial starts today, and will run through New Years. In a written statement, Forest City's spokesperson Lindsey Cottone said that Forest City was being "totally transparent" about the trial, posting signage to "inform customers that the survey is taking place."

Setting smart Internet policy requires data we don't have, aren't getting FCC to probe San Francisco subway cell phone "interruption" policy Data caps a "crude and unfair tool" for easing online congestion Verizon snags $3.6B worth of spectrum licenses as AT&T hits FCC roadbloack Markus "Notch" Persson steps down as lead Minecraft developer Bill would end overtime pay requirement for many more IT workers Transparent crab shell holds the secret to bendable screens iPhone battery life issues may continue to vex userseven post iOS 5.1 With WP7 Mango available for all, Microsoft pushes ahead with new updates SOPA on the ropes? Bipartisan alternative

converted by Web2PDFConvert.com

to 'Net censorship emerges Wasps with many queens will remember your face as they sting you Firefox sees Chrome closing in as IE's share holds steady Fight for your right to party rip DVDs legally Apple: Carrier IQ still on iPhone 4, but we don't read your e-mail and texts Wikileaks docs reveal that governments use malware for surveillance

Ars Technica on Facebook

Like 55,783

Forest City

Sign Up

Create an account or log in to see what your friends are doing.

Forest City's senior vice president of marketing, Jane Lisey, emphasized that the company was not collecting personally identifiable information about shoppers from their phones, and that customers' phone numbers and other information were protected by their wireless carriers. "Before agreeing to test this technology it was essential to determine and guarantee that the personal information of our shoppers would be completely anonymous to all parties," she said. While Footpath uses only the signal fingerprint of the phone, it does give a fairly accurate record of where the phone has travelled through a mall. According to the editor of trade site Storefront Backtalk, Evan Schuman, the data can be paired with other sources of data, including surveillance video and point-of-sale transaction information. If they went this route, retailers would get a very detailed profile of who's carrying each phone. "Some malls are even using facial recognition software," Schuman told Ars Technica in a phone interview, with the primary purpose of "loss prevention"identifying shoplifters. But that data, he said, could be tied to location data to be turned into customer relationship management data. Mall operators could then theoretically sell data to retailers, alerting them when big-ticket shoppers were approaching so that they could be given personalized service. There's just one problem with this type of detailed tracking: it's technically illegal, according to Mark Rasch, the director of cybersecurity at CSC. Thanks to court interpretations of provisions in the USA PATRIOT Act, he said in a recent blog, devices that measure cell phones' signal strength could be considered to be "pen registers"monitoring devices that require a warrant. "Although this mall technology might not identify specific individuals, it raises a bunch of privacy red flags," he wrote. "First, the instant the consumer identifies himself or herself anywhere in the mall (say, by using a credit or debit card to buy something), it is a trivial task to cross reference the cell phone data with the payment data and realize that the person hanging around outside the Victorias Secret dressing room was your 70-year-old neighbor." That's more information than many consumers are interested in divulging. So far, however, there's been no sign that the legality of the service will be tested in court. And retailers could conceivably use the same justification for the technology that they use for facial recognition software: "loss prevention." In many jurisdictions, real estate owners are given wide latitudes about what they monitor on their own premises.
Photograph by Ralph Aichinger

Wikileaks docs reveal that governments use malware for surveillance 473 people recommend this. US judge orders hundreds of sites "deindexed" from Google, Facebook 1,060 people recommend this. Sen. Franken demands answers from Carrier IQ, suggests phone snooping violates federal law 196 people recommend this. Startup hopes to hack the immigration system with a floating incubator 788 people recommend this. Groups accuse Siri of being "pro-life," Apple says it's beta side effect 150 people recommend this.
F acebook social plugin

Disable Facebook on Ars

Click here to view the 188 comments on this story DON'T MISS: PROMOS & INSIGHT
Like 1k 59 Share 195

946

Share/Email

Read more stories

Recommend this? | Recommended by 3 people

< Older Story | Newer Story > Promo: Consumerization of IT: Ars explores mobility, social media, and rapid development cycles.

Job.Ars: looking for a new job?

PHP Developer at The Nerdery
Minneapolis, MN

Former Reddit coowner arrested for excessive JSTOR downloads

The dumbest attack Is gamification of on the Netflix "free driving the answer to ride" you have ever urban speeding? read

US judge orders hundreds of sites "de-indexed" from Google, Facebook

iPad 3: super-highres displays a go, but yields will be low

Software Engineer - Research Team at Castlight Health

San Francisco

DESIGN TECHNOLOGIST at New York Media

New York, NY

converted by Web2PDFConvert.com

Back-end Developer at Centre for Global eHealth Innovation

T oronto, Ontario

Advanced PHP web application developer at www.konnectology.com

T elecommute

Flex Developer at Yes Energy, LLC

Chicago, Denver/Boulder, Boston

Software Engineer, iOS/OS X at Acres 4.0

Las Vegas, NV

Director of Software Development/Senior Software Developer at NOTION Music, Inc.

Greensboro, NC or T elecommute

Software Engineer, Web at Blizzard Entertainment

Irvine, CA

Software Engineer, Web at Blizzard Entertainment

Irvine, CA

MORE JOB LISTINGS

Serving the technologist for 1.3496 10 -1 centuries

SITE LINKS Front Page About Us Advertise with us Press Information Ars Technica TV SITE HELP Contact Us General F AQ Reprints

SUBSCRIPTIONS Subscribe to Ars Subscription F AQ MORE READING RSS Feeds Twitter Newsletters

COND NAST SITES Reddit Wired Vanity Fair Style Details Visit our sister sites Subscribe to a magazine View mobile site

Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our user agreement and privacy policy (REVISED AUGUST 1, 2011). Ars T echnica 2011 Cond Nast Digital. All rights reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast Digital. Ad Choices

converted by Web2PDFConvert.com