the idea or suggested the movie. Just write plus 1 if you agree with the title.
Final List
Voting 3 out of 4: ++
Score
BY Who?
Movie's Name
Creativity/Originalit Among Personal y in Expression, Who has seen it? Interests of Suggested by whom? Who? T,B T, H, N, B, +2 T,H,B T,B T, + T T,B,H,N, +2 T, N, H, B +2 T, + T,N,B,H T, + T+ B+ T+
1 2 3 4 5 6
4 7 1 5 7 8
T T T T T T 2 3 1
Modern Times (1936) V for Vendetta (2006) RIP: A Remix Manifesto (2009) Bloody Sunday (2002) Lives of Others (2006) Hunger (2008)
T,B
Brazil (1985)
T,H
T,N, H, +2
T,N,H
T+
10
T, +
11 12 13 14
3 3 5 2
T T T T
Julia (1977) Mr. Smith Goes to Washingtom (1939) Grapes of Wrath (1940) Moonlighting (1982) 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968)
"+" H, B H T, + "+"
15
T,H
T, +
T+
16
T, +
17
Cast Away
T, N
18
T, +
19
B, H, T, +2
B, +
B+
20
Philadelfia
B,N
B, +
B+
21 22 23
7 2 2
B B B
T, B, H, +2
24
Mosqito Coast
"+"
25
B, H, T, +2
"+"
B+
26 27 28
3 3 7
B B B 8
Bashu, the Little Stranger They Shoot Horses, Don't They? White Ribbon (2009)
B,H B T,B,H, +2
29
T,B,H,N, +2
B, +
N+
30
3 Brothers (1981)
"+"
31 32 33 34 35
5 1 3 5 3
H H H H H
10
Battleship Potemkin (1921) Salt of the Earth (1953) Dr Strangelove (1964) La Chinoise (1967) Nashville (1975)
T, H H T, B T H
T, H H, + T, H, B H, + H,+ H+
36
11
Underground (1995) The Yacoubian Building (2006) Persepolis (2007) Danton (1983) France One flew over the cuckoo's nest (1975) US Z (1969) Greece Dogville (2003) US Good bye Lenin! (2003)
H, T, B,N, +2
H, B
H++
37 38 39 40
6 3 8 6
H H N N
12
H,+ T, N, B N, + T, N
H++
13 14
N++ N+
41 42 43
5 2 3
N N N
15
T, H, B, +2 T,N, B, +2 N, T
T, + T, N N,H, B N+
Quality of Articles IMDB 7.8 / Awards # of Articles # of Cells > 2:20 hours(-1)
V for vendetta as cultural pastiche, "+" Interesting Article, "+" Interesting Article, "+" Interesting Article, "+" Journalism ethics goes to the movies, "+" Sociology through the projector"+" Sociology through the projector"+", The philosopher at the end of the universe, "+"
8.5 + 8.2 + 7.7, No awards 7.8, Berlin + 8.5 + 7.6, Venice, TIFF, Cannes & New York + 7.1, Berlin +
2:12:00 2:17:00 -
Chaplin, + -
2,+
2,+
8, +
2,+
3,+
Gilliam, +
8, +
4,+
2:20:00, -1
Fincher, +
3,+
Ridley Scott, +
1 2,+ 2,+ 1
1 2,+ 3,+ 1
Zinnemann, + Ford, + -
8.4, +
4,+
2,+
2:20:00, -1
8.5, +
4, +
2, +
2:49:00 , -1
D-Day filming, comparison of "SPR" and combat film by the British Army's film and photographic unit, +
Spielberg, +
Ecology and Nature: A Study of Cast Away., Bereton (not online) Book chapter: Controversial cinema, "+" Bridging Fiction and Documentary in Godard's Notre Musique, a PhD thesis "+" two articles in film magazines (one in Cahiers du Cinema no. 478 (April 1994) p. 73-4), "+"
2:23:00, -1
8.7, +
6.9
2,+
3,+
Performance in and of the Essay film: Jean-Luc Godard plays Jean-Luc Godard in Notre musique (2004) "+"
Godard, +
2, +
The Two Japans of "Spirited Away", "+" book: World on film, "+" book: World on film, "+" An Ecological Approach to the Cinema of PeterWeir Gender Hierarchy and Environmental Crisis in Tsai Ming-liang's The Hole, "+" a few online film magazines 3 good articles, "+" 3, not very critical articles book: World on film, "+" Good article on Soviet Montage +1
1 1 1
1 1 1 2:40:00, -1 2:54:00, -1
6.6
7.5, Cannes, +
5, +
7.4 7.9, Bafta, Golden Globe, Oscar,+ 7.8, Palme d'Or, Golden Globe, + 8.0, Golden Globe, +
2, + 3, +
3, + 1 2, + 2:24:00, -1 Graphic novels or novel graphics? The evolution of an iconoclastic genre , 2011, "+" F. Rosi, + Sergei Eisenstein and the Montage. "+" Pollack, +
3,+
3, +
7.3
2, +
2, + 2,+ 2, + 3,+
1 1 3, + 1 1 2:39:00, -1
Eisenstein, +
Godard, +
Cinema in pursuit of 8.1, 1 Palm d' Or, + deconstruction& reconciliation + 7.3 8, + 7.5, BAFTA best foreign film, + 8.9, 5 Oscars, 5 BAFTAs, 5 Golden Globs, + 8.1, 2 Oscars, 1 BAFTA, 2 Cannes's, + 8, 1 Palme d'Or Cannes, + 7.8, 1 Berlin, +
2, +
2:50:00, -1
Kusturica, +
2, + 2, + 3, +
1 1 3, + 1 2:58:00, -1
Costa Gavras, +
Movies Proposer:
Bahar
Tayaz
Hooman
Narges
Movie #1 Proposed
Relavant Reference Relavant Reference Movie #2 Proposed Movie #3 Proposed for movie # 1 for movie # 2
Slavery
Chernobyl disaster
World wars
Dr. Strangelove
1. Nightmare Comedy ..: http://tiny.cc/h8ciz 2. Notes on Spectator Emotion... :http://tiny.cc/ldrr9 3."Dr. Strangelove's America" Google book
Modern Times
http://tiny.cc/wjd6r and http://tiny.cc/3dhud and Modern Times: The Soviet Union and the Interwar Conjuncture* Stephen Kotkin
Hiroshima
Palestine
Unification of Germany
articles (contact Bahar) and Bastien, S. La vie des autres : un hommage Lives of Others(B) l'art. Canadian Journal of Film Studies (Tayaz)
Bashu
Persepolis
Northern Ireland
Hunger
Eye witness memorialising humanity in Steve McQueens Hunger by Eugene McNamee and http://tiny.cc/bd5sf
Bloody Sunday
War on Terrorism
Brazil
Libenan
Great Depression
Grapes of Wrath
http://tinyurl.com/3s 8ggxu & They shoot horses, http://tinyurl.com/3d don't they? gqnum Articles( contact Narges)
September eleven
Dogville
Crisis of Political Modernism http://books.google. ca/books?id=bmpIG _LD7pIC&pg=PA11 9&dq=Political+hist ory+of+cinema&hl= en&ei=JwoSTt35He Tr0gH2ncmODg&sa =X&oi=book_result &ct=result&resnum =7&ved=0CEYQ6A EwBg#v=onepage& q=Political%20histo ry%20of%20cinema &f=false
Cinema, Theory and Political Responsibilty http://books.google. ca/books?id=nFsTm 7jLbmUC&pg=PA33 &dq=cinema,+theor y+and+political+res ponsibility+in+conte mporary+culture+by +P.+McGee&hl=en &ei=txUSTuygAu2n 0AHBoe2kDg&sa=X &oi=book_result&ct =result&resnum=1& ved=0CCkQ6AEwA A#v=onepage&q&f= false
Autonomous Image: Histoire politique du Cinematic Narration cinema: Etats-Unis, & Humanism Europe et URSS http://books.google. ca/books?id=BV4U7 1SMymEC&pg=PR 11&dq=cinema+and +humanism&hl=en& ei=JhgSTo3iHfo0QHt7pW_Dg&sa =X&oi=book_result &ct=result&resnum =3&ved=0CDIQ6AE wAg#v=onepage&q =cinema%20and%2 0humanism&f=false
Tayaz to skim
Bahar to skim
Tayaz to skim
Bahar to skim(?)
Movie #1 Proposed
globalization
AIDS
V for Vendetta
Philadelphia
Health-care concerns
The hole
one article
Climate change
War
Dr. Strangelove; It can be easily placed under War/Peace http://tiny.cc/mcn5q categories in Theme B Bloody Sunday Negotiating Peace in Northern Ireland; Sarah Edge
Peace
Religious intolerance
Labour right
1. The book "The Suppression of Salt of the Earth: How Hollywood, Big Labor, and Politicians Blacklisted a Movie in the American Cold War" to be purchased about this movie 24-Track narrative: http://tiny.cc/u60qj 2. Robert Altman: http://tiny.cc/1ngt1 3. Nashville and the American dream: http://tiny.cc/uy5px
National/Local Politics
Nashville
Nationalism
Underground
1. Retrieving Emir Kusturicas Underground as a critique of ethnic nationalism: http://www.ejumpcut .org/archive/jc51.20 09/Kusterica/text.ht ml 2. The (de)construction of Yugostalgia through Kusturicas cinematic eye: http://cc.bond.com.p t/wpcontent/uploads/201 0/07/01_07_Marcos _Farias_Ferreira.pd f BRETT GAYLOR (DIR.) (2009) RiP: A REMIX MANIFESTO by Laura J. Murray
Copyright
Oil & Energy Security vs. Terrorism The white ribbon (B) --> Rural terrorism articles( contact Bahar) 1. Godard and Gorin's left politics, 1967-1972: http://tiny.cc/014g1 2. Toward a NonBourgeois Camera Style: http://tiny.cc/42jab Three brothers (Francesco Rosi)
Revolution
La Chinoise
Danton
Workahalism
Reform
Racism
Bashu
Freedom
V for Vendetta
Intelectual Responsibility
Unions
Censorship
Humanism
The hole
one article
Socialism
http://tinyurl.com/3o u36nc
Political Activism
Hunger
Eye witness memorialising humanity in Steve McQueens Hunger by Eugene McNamee and http://tiny.cc/bd5sf
violence
Social responsibility
Umberto D (De Sica) The earth will tremble (Visconti) La dolce vita
book: World on film book: World on film http://tinyurl.com/3q w5rkk & http://tinyurl.com/3z rjyr6
Industialism
Grapes of Wrath
Left Wing
http://tinyurl.com/3k qufng & http://tinyurl.com/3z n8prt one article one article http://ghaedeyebazi. blogfa.com/post55.aspx and http://psychology.m oelmi.ir/?part=page &id=9
solidarity alianation
war-time immigration
Bashu
Battleship Potemkin
Dr. Strangelove
La Chinoise
Cinma contemporain
world on film
http://books.google.c a/books?hl=en&lr=&i d=rpSTN0DUjsQC&o i=fnd&pg=PR8&dq= The+Battleship+Pote mkin&ots=dfzYhhVy uW&sig=peRjQKSga 8oqG5W5VUohJQR QiIk#v=onepage&q& f=false
http://books.google. ca/books?hl=en&lr= The dipction of late &id=KGrsQOIQgeY 1960's counter C&oi=fnd&pg=PR9 culture in the 1968 &dq=dr+strangelove http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/A films of Jean-Luc &ots=y8zKejchcS&s SIN/0826320287/culturevulturene Godard : ig=kZpLzXSuI17XE http://www.garyelsh TJH_7RsTCmIFkE# aw.com/jlg/Thesis.p v=onepage&q=dr% df 20strangelove&f=fal se
Hooman;The entire book is to be read, but the only first ten pages are available
Hooman;More articles on this film are Hooman Detailed listed here, though to be accessed explanation of later; Ettorre, Emanuela. Godard's Cinema, http://www.lib.berkeley.edu/MRC/Latin to be trimmed and oBib.html#salt selected
Bahar
Bahar
C) Political Notions & Relavant Reference Relavant Reference Movie #1 Proposed Movie #2 Proposed for movie # 1 for movie # 2 Philosophy
Minority Gender (Women + homosexuality) Silence of the lambs (B) Book: controversial cinema (B) Bastien, S. La vie des autres : un hommage l'art. Canadian Journal of Film Studies - also articles (cotact Bahar) http://tinyurl.com/3k qufng & http://tinyurl.com/3z n8prt http://tinyurl.com/4x 5xh29 & http://tinyurl.com/3o gszcx
Julia
Lives of Others
Pluralism
Cast away
Mosquito coast
Dr. Strangelove
http://tiny.cc/mcn5q
Brazil
Torture
Property
Money
Memorialization
Hunger
Eye witness memorialising humanity in Steve McQueens Hunger by Eugene McNamee and http://tiny.cc/bd5sf
Information
Subjectivity / Individualism
1- Warchol, T., "The Rebel Figure in Milos Forman's American Films," in New Orleans Review , vol. 17, no. 1, 1990 2-
Taboos
Addiction book:World on film +article (Bahar) 1-Andrzej Wajda Reign of Terror: Danton Polish Abiance 2-THE POLITICAL FILMS OF ANDRZEJ WAJDA, Dialogism in Man of Marble, Man of Iron, and Danton Trauma The white ribbon (B) articles( contact Bahar) Waltz with Bachir (B) articles( contact Bahar)
Propaganda
1. Sergei Eisenstein and the Montage : 2. & the same Google Book 3.http://tiny.cc/76hg b http://tinyurl.com/3b 2wvuo & http://tinyurl.com/3r px58y http://tiny.cc/bbyjp and http://tiny.cc/56wh9 http://tinyurl.com/3q w5rkk & http://tinyurl.com/3z rjyr6
Moonlighting
Corruption vs Ethics
Identity
article (Bahar)
Grapes of Wrath
Apocalypse
V for Vendetta
Modernity
Blade Runner
Brazil
http://tinyurl.com/3e hsljv & http://tinyurl.com/3f g9cug & http://tinyurl.com/3v nvjyp 1. The Path of Jihad in the Yacoubian Building: http://tiny.cc/y4p66 2. French article on the movie : http://tiny.cc/jrnxg
Populism
Criticism
Contemporary Art
Capitalism
Fight Club
Media
Public vs. Private Sphere Religion Three brothers book:World on film (Francesco Rosi) -+article (Bahar) >family
Institutions
gender hierarchy
The hole
one article
world cinema
world cinema
Bahar
Bahar
Movie #3 Proposed
Lives of Others
Modern Times
http://tiny.cc/3dhud and http://tiny.cc/7fq2s Modern Times: The Soviet Union and the Interwar Conjuncture* Stephen Kotkin
Now Please Insert these (your proposed) movies in the first sheet if relevant enough and try to find legitimate references. in the meanwhile we can modify the topics, movies and divisions, or add references
102 Movies so far Hooman's Movies Proposal The Birth of a Nation (1915) 2 Battleship Potemkin (1921) 1 Misere au Borinage (1933) 3 Triumph des willens (1935) 1 Citizen Kane (1941) 3 Salt of the Earth (1953) 3 On the Bowery (1956) 3 Dr Strangelove (1964) 2 La Chinoise (1967) 2 In the year of Pig( 1968) 2 Teorema (1968) 3 Warum lauft Herr R. Amok(1970) L aggettivo donna(1971) Macbeth (1971) 3 Nashville (1975) 3 3 Women & Politics: Julia 1977 Pluralism: Mr. Smith Goes to Washingtn 1939 Nature: Voyage To The Edge Of The World 1976 Property: Citizen kane Money: Wall Street 1987 Sharing: Grapes of Wrath 1940 Information: Network 1976 Taboos: La Grande Bouffe 1973 Addiction: More 1998 Trauma: The Birds 1963 Exile: Moonlighting 1982 3 Tayaz Movies Proposal V for Vendetta Modern Times Rip: A Remix Manifesto Bloody Sunday Lives of Others Hunger Wag the Dog Brazil Fight Club Blade runner Saving Private Ryan Some Movies Proposed by Dr. Jahanbegloo
Underground (1995) - 3 Ratiziti Lihiyot Gibor( 2004) The last Communist(2006) 2 The Yacoubian Building (2006) 3 Persepolis(2007) 2 The World Without US (2008) 3 In the loop (2009) 3 I want to include Persepolis under category one, the theme of Iranian Political cinema, but have not been able to find any good resource for it. So let me know if you can find any. Hooman
Identity: The 25th Hour 2002 Modernity: The Leopard 1963 Technology and Science: 2001: A Space Odyssey Populism: The Best man 1964 Religion: Shoes of the Fisherman 1968 Contemporary Art: Lust for Life 1956
Bahar's Movies Proposal The Shawshank redemption (1994)-3 Life is beautiful (1997)-2,3 Frida(2002)-----3 White ribbon(2009) ---3 In the time of butterflies(2001)----3 The party (1968)-----3 Its a wonderful life(1946)----3 Malena(2000)---3 Dead poets soceity(1989)----3 A prophet(2009) Waltz with Bashir(2008)---2,3 Our music(2004)---2,3 Far from heaven(2002)---3 Guess whos coming to dinner(1967)----3 When Father Was Away on Business(1985)--Welcome(2009) It all starts today (1999) Missing(1982) Amen(2002) Head-on (2004) 3 brothers(1981) A Passage to India (1984) House of Spirits (1993) Cast Away
Narges Movies Proposal Danton (1983) France Z (1969) Greece One flew over the cuckoo's nest (1975) US Lenin:The train (1988) Good bye Lenin (2003) Germany Water (2005) India sag koshi (2001) Iran Waltz with Bashir (2008) Lebanon Dogville (2003) US
Siience of the Lambs Notre Musique Philadelfia Spiritied away The Earth will Tremble La Dolce Vita Mosqito Coast the hole bashu they shoot horses don't they?
Plus 1
Bahar plus 1
Narges
Hooman Plus 1
Personal Interest
plus 1
I think we should have a rule that Each oh us has 5, each person could +1 points to give to only use 3 of his/her movies we are votes for the interested movies he'she has selected. More than "7.8" score imdb: +1 ponts plus 2 for over 8 , plus 1 for 7.5-8
Plus 1
Only one person has seen it + IMDB more than # Creativity or Originality on Expression of the political Idea More than 2.5 hours In more than one list Technical/Cinemati c articles 9 Circles of Contents and one for each If the movie's category falls within the main theme that we'll decide for this season (this main theme will be more specific than " political cinema". It'll be our main framework and objective during this season
Neg 1
+1 points
plus 1
Plus 1
Plus 2 points
Plus 1
plus 3 points
Plus 1
# of Artices
plus 1 point
plus 1
Plus 1
quality of the articles or references (decided by at least 2 of us) if the movie is from a famous director who we haven't watched any of his works in last two seasons
plus 2 points
+1 point
plus 1
Plus 2 points
Plus 1
Plus 1
plus 1
Plus 1 point
IMDB 7.8 and famous awards(Baftra, Cannes, Oscar, Berlin, Golden Globe): +1
if the movie has won a famous awards like Oscar,BAFTA, Cannes, Berlin just for the catagory of the best film/ or best foreign film
Maximum: 12
Result
highest points The ones with the (preferably more most +1s are than 6 out of 9) selected
The ones within the top 70% point range that make the overall proposal diverse, unique and all encomapassing in covering the main themes.