Tunisia
Algeria Morocco
Egypt
Saudi Arabia
Mauritania
Sudan
Yemen
EGYPT
supported by
July 2010
The Regional Solid Waste Exchange of Information and Expertise network in Mashreq and Maghreb countries
EGYPT
July 2010
Developed with the support of Dr. Tarek Zaki and in close coordination with the SWEEP-Net national coordinator in Egypt Mr. Amine Khayal
acknowledgements
The present report owes very much to the contribution and comments of Mr. Amine Khyal, the national coordinator of SWEEP-Net and the head of the central department of solid waste, at Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency (EEAA). The author gratefully acknowledges the comments on this report from Dr. Sherif Arif, the senior environmental consultant of SWEEP-Net, and the collaboration, assistance and support of my colleagues at New center for Integrated studies of Land and Environment (NILE), who provided substantive and editorial inputs towards completion of the report.
Contents
0. Country profile 1. Executive summary 2. Introduction 2.1. Environmental and socio-economic overview 2.2. Waste management overview 3. Current solid waste management situation 3.1. Policy, legal and institutional framework 3.2. Strategy, action plans and priorities 3.3. Planning and investments 3.4. Finance and cost recovery 3.5. Private sector participation 3.6. Public awareness and community participation 3.7. Capacity building and training requirements 3.8. Networking 4. Industrial and hazardous waste management 5. Medical waste management 6. Options for improvement and development 7. Technical assistance partners and donors 8. Opportunities of networking and partnership 9. Needs for technical support and capacity building 10. Case studies, best practices and lessons learned 11. Analysis and priorities for action Annexes 7 9 10 11 11 14 14 15 17 19 19 20 21 22 23 26 27 29 29 32 33 35 37
The regional solid waste exchange of information and expertise network in Mashreq and Maghreb countries
egypt
Population : Municipal solid waste (MSW) generation: Per capita MSW generation: urban areas rural areas
July 2010
Mauritania
Yemen
Background Information
78.2 million (2010) 19.7 million tons (2009) 0.7 1.0 kg/day 0.4 0.5 kg/day 3.4% 40,000 T/year 6.2 MT/year 0.2 MT/year 23 MT/year
15% Others
MSW generation annual growth: Medical waste generation: Industrial waste generation: Hazardous industrial waste generation: Agricultural waste generation:
Waste composition
Technical Performance
Municipal waste - MSW collection coverage : in rural areas in urban areas - MSW final destination: - Composted: - Recycled: - Landfilled : - Open-dumped: - Number of sanitary landfills - Under study: - Under construction: - Built: - Operational: Hazardous and industrial waste - Number of treatment units/centers of industrial wastes (physical chemical treatment) - Under construction: - Built: - Operational: - Types of treatment of medical waste: - - 1 Incineration: 151 units Sterilization (Autoclave): 48 units - 3 5 0 - 35% 40 - 90% 9% 2.5% 5% 83.5%
56% Organic
Legal Framework
Egypt doesnt have a solid waste management (SWM) law. SWM legal framework is scattered in many pieces of legislation. The two most significant pieces of legislations are Law No. 38/1967 on General Public Cleaning and Law No. 4/1994 for the Protection of the Environment and their amendments. The main updates of legislations within 2005-2010 are*: - Law No.10/2005 establishing a solid waste collection fee system ; - Prime Minister Decree No. 1741/2005 amending the Executive Regulations of Law 4/1994 and covering regulations for the selection of sites for recycling and landfilling and equipment requirements for waste collection and transfer ; - Law No. 9/2009 amending Law 4/1994 and regulating collection, treatment and disposal of hazardous waste ; - Presidential Decree No. 86/2010 regulating the closure of existing dumping sites and the landfill at Greater Cairo and allocation of five new sites outside the residential and commercial belt of Greater Cairo.
*Earlier information is available in Egypts Country profile, METAP Regional Solid Waste Management Project (Country Report - Egypt, METAP, 2004)
egypt
Institutional Framework
The Central Government sets up policies, legislations, enforcement means, cost-recovery mechanisms; programs for capacity building and awareness, etc. A steering committee of Ministry of State for Environmental Affairs (MSEA), Ministry of Local Development and Ministry of Finance handles implementation issues. Governorates are responsible for all SWM activities either directly or by contracting private sector companies. Municipalities are responsible for implementation of the system, monitoring, inspection and training. NGOs provide MSW treatment, recycling, community development and public awareness.
For disposal:
ISWM services are responsible for disposal in sanitary landfills or controlled dumping sites.
SWM costs:
Total cost from collection to disposal: 100-110/ton LE in Greater Cairo and Alexandria, and less than 60 LE/ton in other Governorates. The cost recovery: about 70 LE/ton. Total cost recovery: 200 million LE per year.
supported by
Contracts with the private companies have been recently modified to improve SWM in Greater Cairo. Total cost from collection to disposal under the new contracts: 250 LE
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMaRY
The present report has been prepared for the Regional Solid Waste Exchange of Information and Expertise Network in Mashreq and Maghreb Countries (SWEEP-Net). The report contains updated information on the SWM sector in Egypt, since Mediterranean Environmental Technical Assistance Programme (METAP) published Egypt Country Report in January 2004. The report discusses the present status of the solid waste management (SWM) sector, with special focus on: associated policy, legal and institutional framework, strategy and action plans, private sector (formal and informal) involvement, NGOs and donors participation, finance and cost recovery. It gives an overview of industrial and hazardous waste management, medical waste management, and highlights the possible options for improvement and development. It also analyzes and identifies priorities in the short term 1 - 3 years and medium term 3 - 5 years. Moreover, a case study was presented for the Nasreya industrial hazardous waste treatment center at Alexandria, as an example of best practices in the sector. Furthermore, the report discusses the emerging need for building a national network, as a part of SWEEP-Net, to consolidate information on SWM from different institutions and practitioners. Such contribution may have a regional dimension as other countries may transfer and/or adapt this system.
A national workshop had been held on the 10th of May 2010, to introduce SWEEP-Net to national representatives of institutions and practitioners involved in SWM. The workshop was attended by representatives of key ministries, governorates, private sector companies, an NGO, consultancy firms and freelance consultants. The goal, objectives, partner countries and institutions, supporting partners, main mission, network members and its organization and the expected activities of SWEEP-Net were presented. A session was dedicated to a discussion of a proposed roadmap/action plan to setup the national SWM network, as part of the regional network.
There is an emerging need for building an Egyptian national network, as a part of SWEEP-Net, to consolidate information on SWM from different institutions and practitioners.
The present report highlights the goal of initiating the national network, its objectives and expected outputs, primary core team, and means of funding. Moreover, the anticipated technical support and capacity building requirements from SWEEP-Net are presented.
2. INTRODUCTION
Table 1: Key Sector Data
Population` GNI per Capita (US$) Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) Generated Material Composition of MSW (%) 78.2 (2010)1 1,800 (2009) 19.7 MT/year (2009)2 Organic Paper/Paperboard Plastic Glass Metal Other Composition of MSW by Generator (%) Domestic and commercial Industrial Other Per Capita MSW Generation (kg/p/d) MSW Collection Coverage
1
50 60% 8 - 12% 10 - 15% 3 - 4% 1.5 - 2% 7 - 27% 80% 5% 15% 0.4 to 0.5 0.7 to 1.0 0 - 35% 40 - 90% 9% 2.5% 5% 83.5% -
Rural Urban Rural Urban Composted Recycled Disposed in Landfills Disposed in Dumps Other technologies
Estimated Annual Public Expenditures Growth in MSW Generation Medical Waste Generation Industrial Waste Generation Hazardous Waste Generation Agricultural Waste Generation
68.55 Billion USD 3.4% 40,000 Tons/year 6.2 MT/year 0.2 MT/year 23 MT/year
1- Egyptian Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics 2- Waste Management Central Department, Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency (EEAA) 3- Financial Statement of the Draft of States General Budget for Fiscal Year 2008/2009, page 28
10
MS W
31% Delta
7% Alexandria &Matruh
11
12
Although the Egyptian government commenced several initiatives to develop the waste management sector with the start of the new millennium, their efforts resulted in little improvement. Less than 65% of that waste is managed by some form of public or private sector collection, disposal or recycling operation4. The remainder accumulates on city streets and at illegal dumping sites. Moreover, the management of this waste remains, for the most part, both inefficient and inadequate. This is causing serious environmental and public health problems. In fact, the improper disposal of solid waste in waterways and drains has lead to the contamination of water supplies which hinders Egypts natural resources, heritage, and the health and welfare of its people. Figure 2 shows the projected waste generation 2001 2025, as given in Egypts Country Report of 20045. The waste generation is projected to exceed 30 MT yearly by 2025.
Pr oje ct
ed
W MS
10
20
30
40
50
Figur e 2:
Projected total MSW generation (MT) Projected per capita MSW Generation (kg/capita/year)
100
200
300
400
4- Egypt State of Environment Report, 2008 5- METAP, Country Report - Egypt, page 5, 2004
13
or through contracted international companies, local private companies, NGOs and informal sector zabbaleen. The responsibilities of local municipalities or cleansing and beautification authorities include: issuing licenses for private companies, the informal sector zabbaleen and NGOs; street cleansing, collection of waste from vacant lots, gardens waste, market waste, waste generated from canal cleansing activities, etc; operating existing composting plants, either directly or through contracting a private company; final disposal by supervising dumping sites operation either directly or through a private company. Some Non Governmental Organizations (NGOs) have a limited role in the field of solid waste services. Their activities are directed to improving the livelihoods of the zabbaleen and encouraging environmentally sound solid waste collection, transfer, sorting and recycling activities. Moreover, they lead pilot projects for source segregation of household waste in limited areas of Egypt. Annex 2 illustrates the institutional framework.
15
Egypts Country Report5, prepared in 2004 for METAP, covers the policy directives, planning, cost recovery and financing, community participation, and functional waste management objectives given in the strategy. The strategy of the year 2000 had initiated some positive changes in the SWM sector, such as: privatization of service by contracting international companies, in Alexandria and parts of Cairo and Giza, to provide ISWM, and national companies in some other governorates to handle SWM; introducing a partial cost recovery mechanism; and setup tax and customs exemptions to attract investment to the sector. Moreover, extensive effort had been made by MSEA and the Ministry of Local Development to rehabilitate/upgrade the existing dumping sites to controlled dumping sites in Cairo, Giza and Qalyubia Governorates. MSEA in cooperation with the Military Forces National Service Agency had removed 15 million cubic meters of accumulated waste and transferred it to controlled dumping sites. The volume of the remaining accumulated waste that needs to be removed is 25 million cubic meters. Annex 3 shows the strategy initiatives, action plans and priorities. However, many of the recommendations of the strategy did not find their way to proper implementation, though some scattered efforts and attempts for improvements were initiated. Analysis of the relevant performance indicators of the strategy targets and detected gaps are summarized in Table 3. Table 3: Analysis of SWM Strategy Targets, Relevant Performance Indicators and Gaps
National Strategy of the Year 2000 Pursued Target Performance Indicator 5 Years 90% 80% 70% 60% % of landfill vs. total disposed % of landfill vs. total generated 50% 20% % SW separated at source % Reduction referred to normal growth 100% % of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) 0.35% 40% 50% 5% 15% 5% 1% Zero% 65% 0.10% 35% 15% 49% 100% 35% 0.25% 80% 10 Years 99% 90% 80% 70% 90% Present Status of Implementation2 The Gaps
Minimum collection coverage: Collection efficiency Large cities Capitals of governorates Small provincial towns Large villages Sanitary landfill disposal Recovery: Composting Recycling Source separation (wet, dry & hazardous) Source reduction Cost recovery Funding 75% 65% 50% 30 - 40% 10% 24% 25% 30% 35% 80%
A strategic framework for the municipal solid waste recycling sector in Egypt, with a particular focus and action plan for plastic recycling, was designed in 2006, as part of METAP- Regional Solid Waste Management Project (RSWMP) for EEAA. The strategy covered the regulatory issues, waste recycling activities of major recyclable materials, projections for the future (Years 2008 and 2013) and identification and assessment of feasible options to enhance the recycling sector activities.
16
The strategy adopted the following recommendations: promoting source separation of municipal solid waste; establishing central recycling centers on the national level; introducing and implementing the principle of extended producer responsibility; establishing national standards for the recycling industries and products. Regrettably, none of the strategy recommendations were adopted till now. The National Strategy for Healthcare Facility Hazardous Waste Management and its executive plan was developed by the MSEA and received Ministry of Health approval (Hazardous Materials and Wastes Committee) in accordance with the provisions of Article 25, Executive Regulations of the Environment Law 4/1994. Moreover, MSEA issued technical guidelines on designing and operating hazardous waste landfills in highly arid areas, in participation with an expert team from Basel Convention Regional Center at Cairo. Furthermore, MSEA issued a package of technical guidelines to classify, code, temporarily store, transfer, license handling, treatment, and safely dispose hazardous wastes. An Integrated Strategy for Hazardous Substances (HS) and Waste Management (WM) is in the course of preparation and will provide7: A basic vision and aspiration in setting objectives and targets concerning HS and WM for the country as a whole and for the various sectors and how to meet these objectives. Basic instruments of policy implementation which may include: - Setting up a comprehensive regulatory framework(s) - A strategic action plan on required investments and actions leading to sustainable development - Other tools necessary for policy implementation and enforcement.
7- Standard Twinning Project FICHE, Development of Integrated Hazardous Substances and Waste Management System for EEAA(2007 2012)
17
Table 4: Required Investments for the Implementation Plan to Improve MSWM Sector (2000)
Program Cost / million LE Removing Accumulations Improving Controlled Dumping Sites Establishing Transfer Stations Establishing Recycling Centers Establishing Sanitary Landfill Improving Efficiency of Collection & Transfer Total Million LE
Governorate
Cairo Alexandria Giza Kalyobiya Dakahilya Gharbeya Monofiya Beheira Kafr ElShiekh Sharkia Damietta Fayoum Bani Souwaif Menia Assiut Sohag Qena Luxor Aswan Ismailia Port Said Suez Red Sea Matrouh North Sinai South Sinai New Valley Total
13 17 30 19.5 56.5 31.5 33 47 27 48.5 26 20.5 22 28.5 28.5 35 30.5 2 17 17.5 7 7.5 14 26 31 15 15 666
30 5 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 5 5 10 10 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 220
126 42 110 89 172.5 139.5 89 118 83 108.5 64 62.5 65 84.5 72.5 86.5 82 27 46.5 62.5 25.5 30 58.5 51 70 60.5 37 2,063
Presidential directions were made, in February 2010, to the Prime Minister and the Ministerial Committee responsible for SWM to handle the problem of escalation of waste accumulation. The action plan proposed by MSEA and committee members addresses the following. Collection planning New contracts with the informal sector zabbaleen based on door-to-door collection of household waste; New contracts with the international companies.
18
Waste treatment planning Selection and approval of five new locations outside Greater Cairo residential and commercial belt to establish new sanitary landfills; Design and construction of two new transfer stations to be determined, with a design capacity of 2,000 tons/day and operational capacity of 1,000 tons/day in the first stage; Construction of composting plants at the locations of the new landfills for recycling the organic waste and allowing further waste treatment technologies (e.g. biogas and waste-to-energy). Inspection and control Increasing the number of inspectors from 542 to 746; Establishing 30 new monitoring and control units; Automation of the monitoring and control system in cooperation with the Ministry of Communications using the PDA system; Implementing capacity building programs for inspectors. Annex 4 illustrates solid waste management planning and investment programs.
Some local private companies, such as Misr Service, Europa 2000 and Elfostat2, were contracted to collect and transfer household and commercial waste as well. In other Governorates, the municipalities can delegate SWM services to small private companies, NGOs or to the informal sector zabballeen to perform collection, sorting and recycling. Moreover, the authorities started privatizing their 49 composting plants including 88 production lines, by leasing non-operating facilities to private sector companies. The Egyptian Company for Solid Waste Utilization (ECARU), Ama-Arab and Misr Service lease 10, 4 and 1 composting production lines, respectively2. The first waste-to-energy project in Egypt, to be implemented by the private sector in Helwan Governorate, is in the pre-tendering phase. The project involves an advanced waste sorting line and two waste-to-energy units. It will handle 2,400 tons of waste, representing 70% of the daily generated waste in the governorate. The private sector participation is thought to be successful in Alexandria and the municipality in Qena Governorate. In other Governorates, the delegation of SWM services to international companies is facing some difficulties: Conflicts rose between some international companies and authorities in charge of administrating the contracts over interpretations of the contracts, late payments to the companies, and the values of social insurance premiums for employees that companies had to pay, etc. Citizens prefer the door-to-door collection system of household waste, which is generally provided by the informal sector zabbaleen and some private companies. Zabbaleen and NGOs working with them were ignored in the planning phase of privatization. After privatization of the SWM sector, some unsuccessful attempts were made to contain them within the private companies. Currently, in Greater Cairo and Alexandria, the cost per ton for collection and street sweeping, transport, treatment and disposal is 100 110 LE and only 60 LE in other governorates, as indicated in section 3.3. These low contract values lead to poor services that dont meet citizens expectations. Moreover, the quality of the services by the private sector depends on the service provider, location of implementation, coordination with local authorities, community awareness, etc. After the first wave of privatization, the process is now stagnant. The Government introduced investment laws to facilitate importing and manufacturing solid waste equipment. However, these laws were not sufficiently coordinated among concerned ministries and consequently were not attractive to investors. At present, the World Bank PPIAF Program (Public-Private Infrastructure Advisory Facility) supports the development of a private sector participation (PSP) strategy in the SWM sector in Egypt. The study will cover the following: evaluation of the existing PSP experience in the sector and lessons learnt; analysis of the current policy and legal framework; evaluation of the current procedures and management capacity for PSP planning, transaction, structuring, tendering and implementation, monitoring and supervision; and recommendations for a strategic plan to enhance PSP efficiency.
Awareness actions within the SWM sector Currently, there is no formal communication strategy to raise awareness and community participation within the SWM sector; MSEAs efforts are scattered and limited. Awareness actions to citizens The active participation of NGOs, public associations, clubs, youth centres and schools in the creation of a generalized public conscience on SWM issues is of crucial importance. Annex 7 illustrates examples of public awareness and community participation programs and activities with reference to SWM. The prior formation of a public awareness and communications team in Alexandria Governorate facilitated the SWM privatization. This team established goals and strategic programs to support the Governorate. The team aided in developing a unit that coordinated efforts between a range of agencies, organizations and citizens involved in SWM. It is important to mount a strong public awareness campaign on the impact of different types of wastes on human health and environment and to inform citizens of their legal responsibilities and associated penalties for violations. The public should also be informed in advance of the fees they are expected to pay and any plans to change the method of collection or the magnitude of the service. Awareness programs on HHW and electrical and electronic waste e-waste management are urgently needed. Furthermore, public awareness campaigns should be directed to encourage at-source segregation of wastes, reduction of generated quantities of waste, and promote information on recycling activities, its environmental side effects and potential benefits.
3.8. Networking
In Egypt, there is broad experience in the field of municipal solid waste recycling in general and specifically in the composting industry. A group of experts have broad knowledge in these fields; in addition to a national private company, the Egyptian Company for Solid Waste Utilization (ECARU), which has large national, regional and international experience in sorting municipal solid waste and composting its organic portion. Egypt can actively provide technical expertise to SWEEP-Net in the fore-mentioned fields. Furthermore, Egypt has a wide base of universities, research institutes and experts that have extensive experience in the field of hazardous waste management and can provide assistance to SWEEP-Net partner countries in that field.
22
8- Basel Convention, Country Fact Sheets, Egypt, article 1 (1) a Annex I : Y1-Y45
23
The lack of the contractor obligation to maintain integrated accurate information network showing the locations assigned for disposal of wastes and; The absence of incentives in the law to motivate establishments to reduce their rates of waste generation and to practice recycling ; The slack way that Environmental Legislation is enforced in Egypt. Industrial and hazardous waste management The first treatment facility for hazardous waste in Egypt, under the Naserya project (a joint effort between EEAA, Governorate of Alexandria and the Ministry for Foreign Affairs of Finland), was formed in Alexandria in 2000. The project consists of a landfill of 14,000 square meters area designed in accordance with the international standards, a physical-chemical treatment plant for inorganic liquid hazardous waste and a solidification unit, inorganic hazardous waste storage area and organic hazardous waste transfer station. The annual capacity of the physical-chemical treatment plant is 4,000 cubic meter. The problems facing hazardous waste management are9: Insufficient hazardous waste treatment units and insufficient trained staff. Lack of awareness of hazardous waste management. Absence of environmental auditing on hazardous waste producing plants. Absence of an institutional structure (e.g., Ministerial Committee, etc.) consisting of the stakeholders responsible of hazardous waste management. Lack of technical and financial support to hazardous waste management plant at Nassreya Alexandria, particularly for the provision of oil/water separating unit to handle the waste from petroleum plants in Alexandria. Need of training on integrated management of hazardous waste. E-waste management Electric and electronic equipment contain over 1,000 different substances including toxic heavy metals and organics which can pose serious environmental pollution problem upon irresponsible disposal. E-waste has been identified as the fastest growing waste stream in the world. E-waste status in Egypt10 : The number of mobile phone subscribers increased from 4.3 Millions in 2001 to approximately 24 Millions in 2007, and to 44 Millions in 2009. The number of internet subscribers reached 13 Millions in March 2009. Growth in the ICT sector in Egypt exceeds 20% during 2007 and 2008 and expected to be 15% for 2009 due to the global financial crisis.
9- EU, Egypt, Country Strategy Paper, 2007-2013, Annex 3: Egypt Environment Profile 10- Hani Moubasher, Basel convention Regional Center for training and Technology Transfer for the Arab States, BCRC-Egypt E-waste Activities - 2006-2009,
24
Import of used personal computers and CRT monitors has increased dramatically since 2001 (the number increased approximately 6-8 times in five years). In 2007, the Minister of Trade and Industry issued a decree prohibiting importing personal computers that are older than 5 years (it was 10 years before). In 2010, another decree was issued that reduced it to 3 years. Few collection programs for end of life mobile phone batteries were initiated by local mobile operators but not publicly propagated. No records regarding e-waste generation rates are available. An e-waste forum initiated by Egypt Cleaner Production Center and the regional organizations CEDARE and BCRC-Egypt was established. An inter-ministerial committee with members from the private sector and national and regional organizations is formed and is currently discussing a roadmap for e-waste management in Egypt. Problems Facing E-Waste Management10: Awareness for e-wastes and its possible impacts; generation rates and impact scenarios should be the alarming vehicle for awareness. Legislative framework for e-waste management that incorporates responsibilities to importers, manufacturers, and owners. Need to enhance and collect accurate data on quantities and types of e-waste generated and appear in waste streams. Need to enhance participation of the concerned stakeholders in e-waste management. Need to develop a proper collection, transportation, recycling, and exporting or disposal system. Need to build local capacity/experts on e-waste management. Need to identify recycling technologies for known e-waste stream.
25
11- Gehad Abo-El Atta, Essential Steps for Preparing a Plan for Medical Waste Management in Healthcare Units, 2004 12- WHO, Healthcare Waste Management, Detailed Information on Selected Country: Egypt
26
Legal Framework
Establishing a national SWM law.
SWM Enhancement
Increasing the efforts of removing the accumulated solid waste in rural and urban areas. Extending SWM services in the rural areas as a priority and involving NGOs and local contractors Reducing the gap between the current performance and the strategy targets by: improving the collection coverage; closing the existing dumping sites and establishing sanitary landfills for disposal; enhancing waste recovery procedures; and adapting source separation and source reduction mechanisms.
Waste Valorisation
Developing the recycling sector by establishing central recycling centers on the national level and setting up national standards for the recycling industries and products. Adapting new waste utilization technologies such as biogas and waste-to-energy projects Establishing recycling centres for e-waste, using proper treatment technologies.
Public Awareness
Establishing a communication strategy and action plan to raise awareness and community participation. Launching public media campaigns to raise awareness on hazardous household waste and e-waste. One of the components of the European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP) of the joint EU-Egypt Action Plan (AP), is a program (2011-2013) focusing on the implementation of the national strategy for integrated municipal solid waste management, through the introduction of efficient and cost-effective systems for dealing with large volumes of solid waste, with the objective of improving the safety and quality of life for the populations concerned. Approximately 20 million Euro are allocated towards the start of the programming period13. The specific objectives of the program are: improved SWM including collection, recycling, disposal and treatment of domestic, industrial and agricultural waste; sustainable country-wide waste management policies and related institutional structures; and increased coordination with all relevant stakeholders, including private sector.
28
29
The objectives of the network are: Establishing SWM think tank (steering committee, terms of reference, members, regular meetings, etc). Preparing, sharing, maintaining a database of contacts, areas of expertise and any relevant information about institutions and practitioners involved in SWM. Sharing technical expertise, information, educational resources and opportunities between network members and organizations. Establishing Egyptian SWM knowledge hub. Developing a set of indicators to assess the network progress. Creation of a shared electronic environment. The expected outputs of the network are: Enhancing connections and communication between members, information providers, donor representatives, other stakeholders and the regional SWEEP-Net. Disseminating information and relevant reports.
Network Coordinator
Network Consultant
Information Officer
MSEA Representative(s)
Governmental Representatives
Consultants
NGO Team
MSEA Sectors
Ministry-1,2, Rep.
SWMSP1
Consultancy Firms
NGO-1 Rep.
Governorate 1, 2, Rep
SWMSP2
Free Lancers
NGO-2 Rep.
30
Regular meetings discussing common solid waste issues, planning network activities, sharing success stories, etc. Creation of a website serving the network purposes, activities and supporting the members with all needed information and references. This website should be linked to SWEEP-Net. Providing awareness programs for improving the SWM sector (such as source separation and source reduction) within this website. Adding discussion forums or blogs on the internet for members to post their thoughts or questions where others can give their input. Providing technical assistance, technical support and training programs. The core team of the national network can basically start with limited number of members, then based on needs and with the development of the network, the team can be expanded. The proposed core team consists of: a network coordinator; a consultant; an information officer; representatives of MSEAs sectors; and representatives of other related ministries, governorates, municipalities, beautification and cleansing authorities, private companies, research institutes, consultants, NGOs, etc. The main roles of those representatives are being the bridgehead for communications with their organizations. The proposed initial structure of the network is shown in the Figure 3.. On discussing the legal status of the network, stakeholders recommended to be hosted by the organization of the national coordinator of SWEEP-Net in Egypt, MSEA. Before network startup, full terms of reference governing the network shall be published including: Guiding Principles in which ethical values and principles of collaboration between members are written down; Operational Guidelines that define the workflow, processes, structures, memberships, responsibilities, etc in addition to the copyrights and ownership of shared/produced information, that should be agreed before network startup. There is no defined funding model for the network at the moment; however, the support for covering the cost of planned activities in Egypt can be obtained from one or more from the following entities: national donors (e.g. ministries, major industrial firms interested in waste management, telecom operators interested in e-waste management, etc.); and international donors. A detailed operational plan should be developed prior to network startup. Within this plan, the normal dayto-day activities are listed. This plan should include: objectives; activities and actions; required outcomes; time plan; and responsibilities. As there will be different stakeholders and contributors interested in different SWM fields (e.g. municipal waste, e-waste, industrial hazardous wastes, medical waste, etc.), focus groups shall be created inside the network in order to cope with this situation and to avoid sharing of irrelevant information with some members, thus wasting their time and effort. Targeted information shall be created based on the definition of focus groups.
31
32
33
Recommendations: Initiating a mechanism for the continuous technical and financial support for the center. Enforcement of law 4/1994 for the protection of the environmental and its amendment Law 9/2009 to persuade industries to treat and dispose their hazardous waste. Increase awareness of the industrial sector about the activities and services provided by Nasreya center. Extending the activities of the center to include collection, treatment and disposal of e-waste and acid batteries. References: 1. Nasreya Industrial Hazardous Waste Treatment Center, (http://www.nasreya.com/english/for%20more%20details%20About%20Project.htm) 2. Waste Management Central Department, Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency, (EEAA)
34
35
- Adapting new technologies - Adapting new technologies to generate revenue such to generate revenue such as, as, waste-to-energy and waste-to-energy and biogas biogas projects projects Private Sector Participation 9 Service companies, including 3 international companies, currently working in Cairo, Giza and Alexandria Re-initiating the involvement of the private sector, both nationally and internationally in priority Governorates Establishing and implementing a communication strategy to raise awareness and community participation - Providing training programs for labor - Placement of collection bins for different types of waste - Providing suitable transportation and handling equipment for the waste - Establishing transfer stations, recycling centers and landfills Rehabilitation of composting plants, capacity building of employees at the plants, and adaptation of environmental management systems. - Assessment of annual generation of e-waste - Establishing a legal framework - Raising awareness and community participation - Capacity building and training Enhancing the involvement of the private sector, both nationally and internationally in all governorates Enhancing awareness and community participation
Public Awareness/ Poor media coverage Community of the issue and limited Participation community participation
Infrastructure
E-Waste Management
Lack of e-waste generation assessment, legislative framework, management program and awareness
Establishing an e-waste management program for collection, transportation, recycling, and exporting or disposal
36
annexeS
37
Domestic, municipal and industrial wastes Domestic, municipal and industrial wastes
Waste collection, transfer and disposal Waste collection, disposal Delegates responsibility for physical and social infrastructure to city councils Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, Ministry of Health and Population Waste collection, treatment, disposal Peoples Assembly EEAA (mainly), Ministry of Housing (for selecting disposal sites) Collection fee depending on area of residence and income level
Law 48/1982 for the Protection of the River Nile and Waterways against Pollution Law 4/1994 for the Protection of the Environment Law 10/2005 for Public Cleanliness amending Law 38/1967 Law 9/2009 amending Law 4/1994 for the Protection of the Environment Decree Ministry of Housing Decree 134/1968, implementing Law 38 / 1967
Policy/regulatory
Waste disposal
Policy/regulatory
Enforcement, monitoring
Policy/regulatory
Policy/regulatory
Hazardous waste collection, treatment and disposal Regulations for identification and selection of sites for municipal waste recycling and landfilling and equipment requirements for waste collection and transfer Transferred jurisdiction for general cleaning from the Ministry of Housing to local administrative units
Waste disposal
Policy/regulatory Operations and types Operations and types Policy/regulatory Policy/regulatory and types
Collection of garbage and solid Establishing Cairo and Giza wastes and their disposal in Beautification and Cleansing special areas Authorities Waste collection, transfer, treatment, disposal Waste collection Regulations for selection of sites for recycling and landfilling and equipment requirements for waste collection and transfer Waste collection entities Local Council Collection of SWM fee on the electricity bill
Prime Ministers Decree 338/1995 Cabinet Decree, 2000 Prime Ministers Decree 1741/2005 amending Decree 338/1995
Domestic, municipal and hazardous waste All solid waste types Municipal waste
14 - Based on and including updates, Table 2: SWM Legal framework, Country Report: Egypt, METAP, page 9, 2004
38 39
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT ELEMENTS Type of Instrument Decree Name of Instrument Governor of Cairo Decree 4775/2009 Waste types addressed Municipal waste Functional responsibilities addressed Policy/regulatory Waste management system components addressed Waste monitoring unit Institutional roles addressed Transferring the units from Cleansing and Beautification Authorities to the General Department for follow-up at Cairo Municipality Transferring all dumping sites and the landfill out of Greater Cairo Recycling, treatment Ministry of Housing, Local Council, EEAA Ministry of Housing, Local Council, EEAA Financing and cost recovery provisions Other
Presidential Decree 86/2010 Other (Policy, Bill, draft regulation, etc.) EEAA Guidelines for selection sites for recycling and treatment facilities EEAA Guidelines for Landfill
Policy/regulatory Policy/regulatory
Policy/regulatory
Waste disposal
40
41
Ministry of Housing, Utilities & Urban Development Ministry of Trade & Industry Ministry of Health Ministry of Local Development MSEA/EEAA
Municipalities Cleansing and Beautification Authorities International Private Companies National Private Companies Informal Sector Zabbaleen NGOs
15- Based on Table 5.1: Solid Waste Management Stakeholders, Arab Republic of Egypt, Country Environmental Analysis (19922002), Water and Environment Department, The Middle East and North Africa Region, the World Bank, page 66, published in April 2005
42
Law 10/2005
The Government of Egypt issued international tenders The establishment of a ministerial to privatize solid waste services in a Alexandria and SWM committee to facilitate and Cairo. follow-up privatization efforts at the different governorates. Some NGOs work in SWM (collection, transfer, sorting and/or recycling) and adopt programs for improving the livelihoods of the Zabbaleen. Moreover, pilot projects for source segregation of household waste were implemented in limited areas of Egypt. The informal sector Zabbaleen perform door-todoor collection of household waste, transfer, sorting and/or recycling. There is need to integrate the informal sector in the privatization mechanism of the sector. Siting of facilities gives effect to need for composting expressed in national SWM strategy.
Community
Waste Management The number of constructed composting plants are 88. System/ Technologies The Government of Egypt had identified 53 landfill sites, of which 41 accepted by inter-ministerial national committee, and 12 to be finalized. However, only 6 landfills are operating now and 3 under construction. Solid waste recycling is considered to be a priority in solid waste management. The Social Fund for Development is financing micro recycling projects either through 100% grant or loan with subsidized interest. Establishing Nasreya hazardous waste treatment center in Alexandria consisting of a physicalchemical treatment unit, for inorganic waste, and a solidification unit to match landfill criteria for hazardous waste. First greenhouse gas emission reductions purchase in Egypt for a municipal solid waste composting project at Cairo Southern Zone composting and sorting facility. The facility features waste sorting for recovery of recyclables and aerobic composting of organic waste, reducing the amount of methane and other greenhouses gases caused by landfill. Landfill Gas Capture and Flaring Project at Borg El Arab and El Hammam landfills, registered by the Executive Board of the UNFCCC. The project reduces the fugitive emissions of methane, a greenhouse gas which contributes to global warming and climate change.
Selling 325,480 tons of carbon dioxide equivalent greenhouse gas emission reductions to the Carbon Fund for Europe, managed by the WB.
Estimate total emission reductions to be realized are 3,715,266 tCO2eq over the crediting period starting the 1st January 2006 ending the 31st December 2015.
16- Based on and including updates. Table 4: Strategies and Priorities, Country Report: Egypt, METAP, page 15, 2004
43
Investment commitments Investment commitment LE 370 million as capital investment Annual contract value: LE 94.6 million Start Date: 2003 Duration of Contract: 15 years Annual contract value: LE 107.1 million Start Date: 2003 Duration of Contract: 15 years Annual contract value: LE 16.1 million Start Date:2004 - Duration of Contract: 7 years MSW/Cairo MSW/Giza Annual contract value: LE 13.2 million Start Date:2007 - Duration of Contract: 5 years Annual contract value at start of service: LE 36 million Start Date: 2003 Duration of Contract: 15 years MSW/Giza Annual contract value at start of service: LE 44.9 million Start Date: 2003 Duration of Contract: 15 years MSW/ Alexandria MSW/Aswan Annual contract value: LE 115 million Start Date: 2002 Duration of Contract: 15 years Annual contract value at start of service: LE 9 million Start Date: 2003 Duration of Contract: 15 years MSW/Seuz Annual contract value at start of service: LE 9 million Start Date: 2003 Duration of Contract: 15 years
* The National and Governorates projected investment requirements and the contract values were updated and two companies were added 17- Based on and including updates, Table 3: Solid Waste Management Planning and Investment Programmes, Country Report: Egypt, METAP, page 12, 2004
44
45
46
EEAA, EMUs
Workshops: Municipal solid waste MSEA & Ministry of management and CDM projects Local Development Workshops / on the job training: Sanitary landfill operation and maintenance On the job training: Municipal waste collection, transport, sorting treatment Workshops / on the job training: Recycling and composting: Techniques, leasing contracts, manufacturing, development of equipment, maintenance & repair Workshops: Integrated hazardous MSEA, Ministry of waste management Local Development, Ministry of Industry
Governorates & Municipalities Governorates & Municipalities Governorates & Municipalities Governorates & Municipalities
EEAA, EMUs, private companies EMUs, private companies EMUs , private companies EMUs, private companies
Decision makers, graduates Graduates, operators NGOs, Zabbaleen, Operators Graduates / Technicians
Governorates, Municipalities
EEAA, EMUs, Industrial manufacturing companies, service provider companies EEAA, EMUs, Industrial manufacturing companies, private service companies EEAA, EMUs, manufacturing companies, private companies
On the job training: Hazardous waste handling, transport, recycling and disposal activities
Governorates, Municipalities
Graduates, operators
MSEA, Ministry of Communication & Information Technology, Ministry of Local Development, Ministry of Industry
Governorates, Municipalities
47
48
Cairo Eastern Zone Medical waste Alexandria Medical waste Port Said Medical waste Suez Medical waste Beni Suef Medical waste Health Directorates in Governorates Medical waste
4 ton/day
FCC
Mr. Manuel Ramirez Mr. Hassan Abaza Gen. Ghonimy Samra Mr. Salah El-Borno Mr. Mohamed El-Kalawi
Incinerator Incinerator
50 ton/day
Healthcare Facilities
Different governorates
49
Zabbaleen Environmental Development Programme (ZEDP) Pilot/Demonstration Project for Hospital Waste Management Solid Waste Management Project Establishing a SWM system Establishing a SWM system
Moqattam area, Cairo Cairo University Hospitals Kom Ombo/Daraw El-Ramad district, Beni165.000 LE Suef Qanater City Cairo, Qalubyia, Alexandria National National
Privatization of waste management (part of EEPP II) Establishing the National Strategy for Integrated Solid waste Management Landfill identification project
USAID
EU Landfill identification project Finland GTZ USAID KfW, GTZ Netherlands Hazardous waste management Establishing a pilot landfill Hazardous waste management Privatization of waste management services ISWM Mediterranean Urban Waste Management Project financed by the EC-SMAP 1 Integrated Industrial Solid Waste Management
UNDP/ MEDCITIES
Alexandria
18- Based on and including updates, Table 6: Solid Waste Management Donor/Lender Activity, Country Report: Egypt, METAP, page 21, 2004
50
51
Donor/Lender
Name of Project
Project Start/Finish Dates Start: 2001 Finish: 2003 Start: 2003 Finish: 2003 Start: 2002 Finish: 2004 Start: June 2002 Finish: June 2005
Project Location
Project Objectives Building regulatory framework to safely manage hazardous waste and preparing 7 brochures on Hazardous Waste Management System Review and analysis of existing SWM laws and regulations Institutional, information, technical and financial needs for a sound and effective SWM system in ElMinya Governorate.
USAID USAID
Government of the Italian Egyptian-Italian Environmental Cooperation Program, EIECP Republic National programme for the privatisation of solid waste management (NPPSWM) Solid Waste Management Project Regional Solid Waste Management Project financed by SMAP II National program for the privatization of waste management in Egypt ISWM for Al Fayoum and Etsa
GTZ
National
Improving the conditions of private sector participation (PSP) in the communal SWM in the frame of the national program of solid waste management. SWM facilities and provision of waste disposal site. Strategic Framework for Enhancing Solid Waste Recycling in Egypt with Special Focus on Plastics Recycling; Development of SWM guidelines Improving the conditions of private sector participation in municipal waste management.
Finland EU, METAP, World Bank GTZ EC-LIFE 3rd countries DANIDA
Beni- Suef Start: 2002 Finish: 2005 Start: Jan. 2003 Finish: Jun. 2005 Start: Dec 2004 Finish: Dec 2006 Start: April 2005 Finish: 2007 National National Cities of Al Fayoum and Etsa Beni Suef and EL Fashn 299,900 Euro
Developing a safe and environmentally sound Integrated Waste Management System Support planning and implementation of new waste collection and source separation systems; proper service and maintenance procedures for collection trucks and other SWM equipment;
EMG Component, ESP, SWM Improvement Project. Demo project for the Abatement of GHG from Solid Waste landfills in Egypt. Feasibility Study for a Solid Waste Management Project
CIDA KfW
Methane Recovery from Landfills, Bioreactor (Digester) Landfill Cells Demonstration Project Enhancing private sector participation in the SWM sector on the level of governorates Survey of mercury wastes in general and fluorescent bulbs wastes containing mercury. Capacity building through local and international training of EEAAs staff working in the field of hazardous wastes. Establishing a unit for recycling fluorescent bulbs One of the program components is waste management system for South Sinai, closing 6 existing dumpsites and two landfills will be rebuild according to standards, and closed and two landfills will be rebuild according to standards Strengthening EEAAs institutional and policy capacities and adopting relevant EU best practices in Hazardous Substances and Waste Management System Evaluation of the existing PSP experience; analysis of the current policy and legal framework; evaluation of the current procedures and management capacity for PSP planning, transaction, structuring, tendering and implementation, monitoring and supervision;; recommendations for a strategic plan to enhance PSP efficiency Dr. Khaled Metwally Programme Director/Authorising Officer Khaled.Metwally@ eu-ssrdp.org Mr. Osama Abd Elsalam Tel: +202- 25266016 irts@eeaa.gov.eg Mr. Jaafar Sadok Friaa Tel: + 1202 473 7124 jsfriaa@worldbank. org
Start: 2007
National
3 million USD
EC
Running
South Sinai
EU, GTZ
Standard Twinning Project FICHE Development of Integrated Hazardous Substances and Waste Management System
National
Private sector participation (PSP) strategy in the solid waste sector in Egypt
Start: 2010
National
200,000 USD
52
53
SWEEP-Net The regional solid waste exchange of information and expertise network in Mashreq and Maghreb countries July 2010