Design directly influences more than 70% of the product life cycle cost; companies with high product development effectiveness have earnings three times the average earnings; and companies with high product development effectiveness have revenue growth two times the average revenue growth." "40% of product development costs are wasted!"
From start until FDA approval, medical device evolution will typically include:
Conceptual idea development (material selection, manufacturability) Check for patent infringements Develop initial drawings
Maximize stiffness Maximize surface area for drug coating Maximize radiopacity Minimize the delivery size so that it can fit on the smallest possible catheter Maximize flexibility for ease in deployment Meet strength and fatigue requirements
Changing any one of these design variables may adversely affect others
Use Finite Element Analysis Use Finite Element Analysis Material selection
Minimize the delivery size so that it can fit on the smallest possible catheter.
Design layout Use Finite Element Analysis Use Finite Element Analysis
Finite Element Analysis (FEA) is a requirement to achieve Food & Drug Administrations (FDA) approval for many devices that are implanted in the body. FEA is used in the design, verification, and validation of medical devices through the use of thermal, fluid, electromagnetic and structural models. Current analysis models are used to predict:
Ultimate strength and fatigue failure loads. Flexibility Recoil or springback Vessel damage
Nonlinearities in Analysis
!
Material nonlinearities
Plasticity Super-elasticity (Nitinol) Hyperelasticity (model of tissue, plastics, rubber materials etc.)
Geometric nonlinearities
Deployment of device Localized large strains
Contact nonlinearities
Part-to-part (self-contact)
Stent Angioplasty balloon
Solution steps:
The polished laser cut tubing is starting point. Crimp onto balloon. Expansion to insertion diameter. Released to vessel diameter.
Cyclic response for fatigue Radial compression simulation
10
11
0.3
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
12
Parametric input Design optimization Validated models Proof of concept Material property development Design confirmation
13
Geometry:
2-D drawing or 3D CAD model Geometry of test sample for validation Geometry of loading device Stress vs. strain Force vs. deflection for test data Pressure Temperature Acceleration Angular Velocity Cyclic loading for fatigue
Material properties:
Loading conditions:
14
Parametric simulations allow variations of the design to be analyzed quickly and effectively in an automated fashion using variable input/output parameters. A single base model is built and analyzed and perturbations about this design can be automatically performed.
15
Design verification of existing or new designs Design optimization to design a better device. Sensitivity studies on product performance Quality assurance
Set manufacturing tolerances Meet six sigma requirements Satisfy ISO 9001:2000 regulations
16
17
Parametric modeling
Strut diameters, radii, widths Number of repeating segments Tubing thickness
Geometry generation
Scripted based on parameters
2D base revolved to 3D
18
Strains
Extent of permanent deformation Elastic springback
19
Once a parametric model exists, the design can be optimized using automated techniques.
Initial Design Parametric Model & Loading Solution Parametric Results Analysis File Optimize the Design Explore the Design Domain
20
The goal of the analysis is to determine the configurations of the eyeglass frame that can tolerate being stepped on and still be capable of recovery meeting stiffness design requirements.
21
Meshing, material properties, boundary conditions, and solution controls are defined in a solution tool that is linked directly to the CAD system Toggling between the design and analysis tools is possible at any time
22
Prior to the sensitivity study, an initial solution is generated by solving in the simulation environment. This is not a required step, but it is always recommended, particularly for debugging the nonlinear solution.
23
24
Once the initial solution is resolved, input and output variables for the sensitivity study are defined in the simulation environment. Input and output variables are defined by checking the box to the left of the parameter. In this case we specify the defining geometric parameters as the input variables
25
The output variables for this study are the Von Mises stress and the deformation in the load direction. The stress can be used to simulate the elastic response, while the displacement is used to measure stiffness
26
27
Input Distributions
28
DOE Solution
Sensitivity of Max. Von Mises stress vs. frame thickness and frame bottom radius are illustrated in the figure As expected the larger the bottom radius & thinner frame produces the lowest stress values Specific data is extracted from the Response Tabs
29
Conclusions
!
Sensitivity results (example on right) provide valuable data for the design engineer to quickly determine the most relevant design parameters Optimization routines can be used to develop more robust designs Probabilistic evaluations can be used to quantify tolerances required to meet quality control
30
Inferior Vena Cava (IVC) Filters prevents the passage of large lifethreatening emboli to the lungs. Treatment is an alternative to anticoagulant therapy Analyses provide:
Understanding of the filter-vesselflow interaction Opportunity for design iterations to modify flow field, limit filter deformations reduce filter stresses, etc.
31
Structural Geometry from CAD Model (Pro/E, Unigraphics, Design Modeler, etc.) Computational mesh generated in Ansys Mapped mesh using extrusion and sweep meshing techniques Boundary Conditions created in ANSYS GUI.
32
Similar to structural analysis modeling Symmetric model with symmetry BCs Vessel supported on Ends to prevent rigid body motion Fluid structure interaction defined with surface loading Total time and time step setup matches CFX input Forces passed from CFX to ANSYS Displacements passed from ANSYS to CFX
Computer Aided Engineering Associates, Inc. 33
! ! !
Flow domain generated by ANSYS Design Modeler Computational mesh generated by ANSYS CFXMesh 4 filter legs attached to vessel walls 12 legs unattached 150 K elements symmetry of model
Computer Aided Engineering Associates, Inc. 34
Solid surfaces act as interface between fluid and solid domains CFD solution provides unsteady pressure loads on solid surfaces Solid deformations constitute new boundary for CFD Two-way interactions, fully coupled iterative solutions at each time level
Computer Aided Engineering Associates, Inc. 35
36
Flow animations
38
39