2EALIZINGTHE0OTENTIAL

%XPANDING(OUSING/PPORTUNITIES.EAR4RANSIT

%XECUTIVE3UMMARY

2ECONNECTING!MERICAS#ENTERFOR
4RANSIT /RIENTED$EVELOPMENT

!PRIL
!BOUTTHIS2EPORT
2%!,):).'4(%0/4%.4)!,%XPANDING(OUSING/PPORTUNITIES.EAR4RANSIT
WASWRITTENBY2ECONNECTING!MERICAS#ENTERFOR4RANSIT /RIENTED$EVELOPMENT
4HE#ENTERFOR4/$ISTHEONLYNATIONALNONPROlTEFFORTDEDICATEDTOPROVIDING
BESTPRACTICESRESEARCHANDTOOLSTOSUPPORTMARKET BASEDTRANSIT ORIENTED
DEVELOPMENT7EPARTNERWITHBOTHTHEPUBLICANDPRIVATESECTORSTOSTRATEGIZE
ABOUTWAYSTOENCOURAGETHEDEVELOPMENTOFHIGH PERFORMING4/$PROJECTS
AROUNDTRANSITSTATIONSANDTOBUILDTRANSITSYSTEMSTHATMAXIMIZETHE
DEVELOPMENTPOTENTIAL4HE#ENTERFOR4/$ISAPARTNERSHIPOFTHENATIONAL
NONPROlT2ECONNECTING!MERICATHE#ENTERFOR.EIGHBORHOOD4ECHNOLOGY
AND3TRATEGIC%CONOMICSANURBANECONOMICSlRMIN"ERKELEY

4OREADTHEFULLREPORT INCLUDINGDETAILEDCASESTUDIESOFEFFORTSTOPROMOTE
MIXED INCOME4/$IN"OSTON#HARLOTTE$ENVER-INNEAPOLISAND0ORTLANDnVISIT
WWWRECONNECTINGAMERICAORG

!CKNOWLEDGEMENTS
4HE#ENTERFOR4RANSIT /RIENTED$EVELOPMENTWOULDLIKETOTHANKTHE53
$EPARTMENTOF(OUSINGAND5RBAN$EVELOPMENT(5$ ANDTHE&EDERAL4RANSIT
!DMINISTRATION&4! 53$EPARTMENTOF4RANSPORTATIONFORTHEIRlNANCIALAND
TECHNICALSUPPORT

.OTICE
4HISREPORTWASFUNDEDTHROUGHACOOPERATIVEAGREEMENTBETWEEN2ECONNECTING!MERICA
ANDTHE&EDERAL4RANSIT!DMINISTRATION&4! 53$EPARTMENTOF4RANSPORTATIONANDJOINTLY
FUNDEDTHROUGHANINTERAGENCYAGREEMENTBETWEEN&4!ANDTHE53$EPARTMENTOF(OUSING
AND5RBAN$EVELOPMENT(5$ 4HEVIEWSANDPOLICIESEXPRESSEDHEREINDONOTNECESSARILY
REPRESENTTHEVIEWSORPOLICIESOFTHE53$EPARTMENTOF(OUSINGAND5RBAN$EVELOPMENT
ORTHE&EDERAL4RANSIT!DMINISTRATION4HE5NITED3TATESGOVERNMENTASSUMESNOLIABILITY
FORTHECONTENTSORUSEOFTHISREPORT
 /VERVIEW
4(%2)3).'#/343OFTRANSPORTAIONANDHOUSINGARESTRAININGFAMILYHOUSEHOLD
BUDGETS/NERECENTSTUDYFOUNDTHATFOREVERYDOLLARSAVEDONHOUSINGINALOWER
COSTSUBURBANLOCATIONHOUSEHOLDSSPENTANADDITIONALCENTSONTRANSPORTATION
TOGETTHEMTHEREnNEARLYWIPINGTHESAVINGSOUT,OCATIONMATTERSAGREATDEAL
WHENITCOMESTOAFFORDABILITY7HILETHEAVERAGEHOUSEHOLDSPENDSPERCENTOF
ITSINCOMEONTRANSPORTATIONHOUSEHOLDSWITHGOODACCESSTOTRANSITSPENDJUST
PERCENT4HISSAVINGSCANBECRITICALFORLOW INCOMEHOUSEHOLDSTHATNEEDTOMAKE
EVERYDOLLARCOUNT
4HEREALESTATEMARKETTOOHASRECOGNIZEDTHEVALUEOFLOCATIONSNEARTRANSIT
$EMOGRAPHICCHANGESANDTHEUNCEASINGPROBLEMOFTRAFlCCONGESTIONHAVE
COMBINEDTOSUPPORTABUILDINGBOOMINHIGHER DENSITYMULTI FAMILYHOUSINGIN
URBANDOWNTOWNSANDURBANNEIGHBORHOODSANDSUBURBANTOWNCENTERSACROSSTHE
534HISISGOODNEWSFORALLTHOSECONCERNEDABOUTSUSTAINABLEGROWTHCONTINUED
ECONOMICCOMPETITIVENESSDEPENDENCEONFOREIGNOILANDGLOBALCLIMATECHANGE
"UTUNLESSCITIESACTEARLYTOCREATEANDPRESERVEAFFORDABLEHOUSINGNEARTRANSIT
BEFORETHEMARKETHEATSUPRISINGPRICESCOULDFORCELOW INCOMEHOUSEHOLDSWHO
ALREADYLIVENEARTRANSITTOMOVEOUT
)TISCLEARTHATBUILDINGTRANSITANDMIXED INCOMECOMMUNITIESAROUNDTRANSIT
STATIONSISONESTRATEGYTHATMAKESITPOSSIBLEFORHOUSEHOLDSOFALLINCOMELEVELS
TOLEADAFFORDABLECONVENIENTACTIVELIVES4HISREPORTEXAMINESlVECASESTUDY
REGIONSn"OSTON#HARLOTTE$ENVERTHE4WIN#ITIESAND0ORTLANDnANDTHE
PROACTIVESTRATEGIESTHEYAREUSINGTOCREATEANDPRESERVEMIXED INCOMEHOUSING
NEARTRANSIT4HESTRATEGIESCANBEGROUPEDINTOlVEBROADCATEGORIESOFACTION
s)DENTIFYANDUTILIZE4/$OPPORTUNITIESINTHEREGIONANDALONGTRANSITCORRIDORS
s0ROVIDEINCENTIVESTHATHELPCATALYZETHEMARKETFORMIXED INCOME4/$
s2EMOVEREGULATORYBARRIERSTOHIGHER DENSITYMIXED INCOMEDEVELOPMENT
s#OORDINATEHOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATIONPLANSANDINVESTMENTS
s)MPROVELOCALCAPACITYPARTNERSHIPSANDDATACOLLECTION
)TISCLEARTHATALLLEVELSOFGOVERNMENTCANPLAYAROLEINCATALYZINGTHE
MARKETANDENSURINGTHATAMIXOFINCOMESISSERVED4HISREPORTISINTENDEDAS
ANINVENTORYOFEXISTINGPLANNINGPOLICYANDFUNDINGTOOLSINlVEMETROPOLITAN
REGIONSOFTHE5NITED3TATES

)N$ENVERVOTERSPASSEDALOCALSALESTAXINITIATIVE
TOFUNDCONSTRUCTIONOFlVELIGHTRAILLINESINYEARS
,ANDSPECULATIONHASBEGUNBUTTHERESSTILLOPPORTUNITYTO
ACQUIRESITESFORMIXED INCOMEHOUSING4OOLSTOAIDTHIS
EFFORTINCLUDEANINCLUSIONARYZONINGORDINANCEANDA4/$
&UNDTHATPROVIDESMILLIONINBONDINGAUTHORITYFOR
MULTIFAMILYHOUSINGNEARTRANSIT
"UILDING(OUSING.EAR4RANSITAS
AN!FFORDABILITY3TRATEGY
FORMAKINGITPOSSIBLEFORFAMILIESTOREDUCEHOUSEHOLD
4HE/PPORTUNITYANDTHE#HALLENGE EXPENDITURESBYCHOOSINGTOLIVEINNEIGHBORHOODSWITHLOWER
4(%(/53).'-!2+%4INTHE53HASBEENCHANGINGAS TRANSPORTATIONCOSTSBECAUSETHEYARELOCATEDNEARTRANSIT
!MERICANHOUSEHOLDSGETOLDERSMALLERANDMOREDIVERSE ,OCATIONMATTERSAGREATDEAL7HILETHEAVERAGEFAMILY
ANDTRAFlCMAKESLONGCOMMUTESTOTHESUBURBSLESSAND SPENDSROUGHLYPERCENTOFTHEHOUSEHOLDBUDGETON
LESSAPPEALING-EANWHILEBOTHHOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATION TRANSPORTATIONHOUSEHOLDSWITHGOODACCESSTOTRANSITSPEND
COSTSAREONTHEINCREASE/NEINTHREE!MERICANHOUSEHOLDS JUSTPERCENT4HISSAVINGSCANBECRITICALFORLOWER INCOME
NOWSPENDSMORETHANPERCENTOFINCOMEONHOUSINGAND HOUSEHOLDSTHATNEEDTOMAKEEVERYDOLLARCOUNTBECAUSE
ONEINSEVENSPENDSMORETHANPERCENT7HILElNDINGA TRANSPORTATIONCOSTSASAPERCENTAGEOFTHETOTALHOUSEHOLD
LOWER COSTHOUSEINTHESUBURBSUSEDTOBEASTRATEGYTHAT BUDGETVARIESGREATLYACCORDINGTOINCOME4RANSPORTATION
RESULTEDINSAVINGSRECENTSTUDIESSHOWTHEINCREASEDCOST COSTSCONSUMEANAVERAGEOFPERCENTOFTHEHOUSEHOLD
OFTRANSPORTATIONNEARLYWIPESTHATSAVINGSOUT!#ENTER BUDGETFORHIGH INCOMEFAMILIESBUTFORVERY LOW INCOME
FOR(OUSING0OLICYSTUDYINQUANTIlEDTHETRADE OFF FAMILIESTRANSPORTATIONCOSTSCANCONSUMEPERCENTOFTHE
CONCLUDINGTHATFOREVERYDOLLARAWORKINGFAMILYSAVEDON BUDGETORMORE
HOUSINGITSPENTCENTSMOREONTRANSPORTATION $EVELOPINGHOUSINGNEARTRANSITCANBEANAFFORDABILITY

7HILETHEAVERAGEFAMILYSPENDSPERCENTOFTHEHOUSEHOLDBUDGETONTRANSPORTATIONANDHOUSEHOLDSINAUTO DEPENDENTNEIGHBORHOODS

SPENDPERCENTHOUSEHOLDSWITHGOODACCESSTOTRANSITSPENDJUSTPERCENT4HISSAVINGSCANBECRITICALFORLOW INCOMEHOUSEHOLDS
3OURCE#ENTERFOR4/$4RANSPORTAION!FFORDIBILITY)NDEX"UREAUOF,ABOR3TATISTICS

4HESETRENDSAREHAPPENINGCONCURRENTWITHARESURGENCE STRATEGYTHATHELPSFAMILIESOFFSETTHEINCREASINGCOSTSOFBOTH
OFINTERESTINPUBLICTRANSPORTATION4HE!MERICAN0UBLIC HOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATIONWHICHNOWCONSUMESANAVERAGEOF
4RANSPORTATION!SSOCIATIONSAYSTRANSITRIDERSHIPISUP PERCENTOFHOUSEHOLDINCOME&ORALLTHEREASONSCITEDABOVE
PERCENTSINCE4HEREHASBEENACONCURRENTTRANSIT nTRAFlCHOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATIONCOSTSANDDEMOGRAPHIC
BUILDINGBOOMACROSSTHECOUNTRYWITHMORETHANNEW CHANGESnTHEREHASBEENINCREASINGINTERESTINTRANSIT ORIENTED
STATIONSUNDERDEVELOPMENTFORATOTALOFMORETHAN DEVELOPMENT4/$ $EVELOPERSAREINTERESTEDBECAUSETHEY
STATIONS!DDTOTHISTHEFACTTHATURBANNEIGHBORHOODS KNOWURBANMARKETSAREHOTANDSITESNEARTRANSITUSUALLY
ESPECIALLYDOWNTOWNSHAVEBEENRECOGNIZEDASANIMPORTANT PERMITTHEHIGHERDENSITIESANDLOWERPARKINGRATIOSTHATMAKE
NEWMARKETFORINlLLHOUSINGANDMIXED USEDEVELOPMENT THESEINlLLPROJECTSPENCILOUT4RANSITAGENCIESAREINTERESTED
4HERESULTISANOPPORTUNITYUNPRECEDENTEDINRECENTHISTORY BECAUSETHEYKNOW4/$MAKESTRANSITCONVENIENTANDBOOSTS

% 8 % # 5 4 ) 6 %3 5 - - ! 29 
 RIDERSHIP#ITIESAREINTERESTEDBECAUSETHEYSEETHAT4/$CAN s3ITESFOR4/$PROJECTSOFTENREQUIRELANDASSEMBLYAND
SPARKECONOMICDEVELOPMENTTHATPROVIDESVALUEANDBENElTS REZONINGWHICHCANLEADTOLENGTHYACQUISITIONAND
TOBOTHNEWANDEXISTINGRESIDENTSTHUSRAISINGTHETAXBASE PERMITTINGPROCESSESWHICHINCREASEDEVELOPMENTCOSTS
2ENTERSANDBUYERSAREINTERESTEDBECAUSETHEYARELOOKINGFOR s0ARKINGREQUIREMENTSFOR4/$AREUNNECESSARILYHIGHWHICH
CONVENIENCEAFFORDABILITYANDTHEAMENITIESTHEYCANlNDIN ALSODRIVESUPCOSTS
DOWNTOWNSURBANNEIGHBORHOODSANDSUBURBANTOWNCENTERS
4HE#ENTERFOR4RANSIT
/RIENTED$EVELOPMENTHASESTIMATED s#OMMUNITYOPPOSITIONTODENSITYANDAFFORDABLEHOUSINGIS
THEDEMANDFORHOUSINGNEARTRANSITTOINCREASETOALMOST HARDTOOVERCOME
MILLION53HOUSEHOLDSBYTHEYEARROUGHLYAQUARTER
OFALLRENTERSANDBUYERS7HILEMARRIEDCOUPLESWITHCHILDREN 0ORTLANDUSEDDEVELOPMENT
MADEUPTHEVASTMAJORITYOFHOUSEHOLDSAFTER77))BOOSTING AGREEMENTSTOTIEPUBLICINVESTMENT
INTERESTINTHEDETACHEDSINGLE
FAMILYHOMEINTHESUBURBS INTHESTREETCARTOPRIVATEINVESTMENT
ANDTHEAUTOMOBILESINGLEADULTSWILLSOONCOMPRISETHENEW INAFFORDABLEHOUSING
MAJORITYANDTHEYAREINTERESTEDINADIFFERENTLIFESTYLE!LL
THEDEMOGRAPHICGROUPSTHATAREINCREASINGINSIZEINTHIS
COUNTRYnOLDERSMALLERHOUSEHOLDSANDSINGLESANDNON

WHITEHOUSEHOLDSnARETHESAMEGROUPSTHATHAVEHISTORICALLY
PREFERREDURBANLIVINGANDTHATDOUSETRANSIT
4RANSIT
ORIENTEDDEVELOPMENTISTYPICALLYUNDERSTOODTO
BEAHIGHER
DENSITYMIXED
USESINGLEPROJECTADJACENTTOA
TRANSITSTATIONBUTITNEEDSTOBEUNDERSTOODASSOMETHING
MORETHECREATIONOFANEIGHBORHOODORDISTRICTCOMPRISED
OFSEVERALPROJECTSANDARICHMIXOFUSESINANENVIRONMENT
THATPROMOTESWALKINGANDTRANSPORTATIONCHOICES4HESE
TRANSIT
ORIENTEDDISTRICTSCANBEAROUNDHEAVYRAILLIGHTRAIL
STREETCARSOREVENBUSANDTHEYCANBEINEITHERURBANOR
SUBURBANLOCATIONS4HEGOALISTOMAKEITPOSSIBLEFORRESIDENTS 4HENATIONAL4/$MARKETDEMANDESTIMATECITEDABOVESHOWS
TOLIVECONVENIENTAFFORDABLEACTIVELIVESBYPROVIDING THATPERCENTOFTHEDEMANDFORHOUSINGNEARTRANSITISLIKELY
MULTIPLEHOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATIONCHOICESINCLUDINGACCESSTO TOCOMEFROMHOUSEHOLDSWITHINCOMESBELOWTHEAREAMEDIAN
REGIONALTRANSIT INCOMEROUGHLY4HESEARETHEHOUSEHOLDSTHATARE
"UTASTHEMARKETFORTRANSIT
ORIENTEDDEVELOPMENTHEATS ALSOMOSTLIKELYTONEEDASSISTANCEINlNDINGHOUSINGTHATIS
UPANDTHESENEIGHBORHOODSPROVEPOPULARWITHRENTERSAND AFFORDABLE#ONSIDERABLEDEMANDWILLALSOCOMEFROMMODERATE

BUYERSTHEREISANINCREASINGNEEDANDCHALLENGETOENSURE INCOMESINGLESANDCOUPLESWITHOUTCHILDRENMAKING
THATDEVELOPMENTINCLUDESHOUSINGFORALLINCOMELEVELS4HISIS TO4HESEAREALSOTHEHOUSEHOLDTYPESTHATAREMOST
DUEINPARTTOTHEFACTTHATCITIESANDTRANSITAGENCIESMAYNOT LIKELYTOUSETRANSIT

WHICHHELPSTOFULLYREALIZETHEBENElTOF
UNDERSTANDTHEIMPORTANCEOFDEVELOPMENTNEARSTATIONS&EW BUILDINGHOUSINGNEARTRANSIT
TOOLSEXISTTODIRECTAFFORDABLEHOUSINGTONEIGHBORHOODSWITH !RECENTREPORTFUNDEDBYTHE&ORD&OUNDATIONlNDSTHAT
TRANSITSERVICE%XISTINGPLANNINGANDZONINGOFTENLIMITTHE NEIGHBORHOODSINTHEHALF
MILERADIUSAROUNDTRANSITALREADY
DEVELOPMENTPOTENTIALOFSTATIONAREASSUCHASWITHSINGLE
SUPPORTMORERACIALANDECONOMICDIVERSITYTHANTHEAVERAGE
USEZONINGPARKINGMINIMUMSANDSOON-OREOVERTHERE CENSUSTRACTANDTHATTHEYAREHOMETOAGREATERSHAREOFA
ISNTMUCHAVAILABLELANDORMANYREADY
TO
GODEVELOPMENT REGIONSLOWER
INCOMEHOUSEHOLDS4HEDATAALSOSHOWSTHAT
SITES4HERESULTISTHATTHISKINDOFINlLLDEVELOPMENTISTIME
INTHREE
QUARTERSOFTHESEhTRANSITZONESvnDElNEDHEREAS
CONSUMINGANDEXPENSIVETOBUILDWHICHCAUSESDEVELOPERSTO THEHALF
MILERADIUSAROUNDSTATIONS

HOUSEHOLDSHAVEONE
BUILDTOTHEHIGHENDOFTHEHOUSINGMARKET CARORNOCARS4HISLOW
RATEOFAUTOOWNERSHIPINDICATESTHAT
RESIDENTSDOREALIZETHECOST
SAVINGSTHATCOMESFROMLOWER
/BSTACLESTOBUILDINGMIXED
INCOME4/$HOUSINGINCLUDE AUTOOWNERSHIP"UTASTHEDEMANDINCREASESANDTHEMARKET
s,ANDPRICESAROUNDSTATIONSAREHIGHORINCREASEBECAUSEOF
SPECULATIONONCEANEWTRANSITLINEISANNOUNCED
INCOME
s!FFORDABLEHOUSINGDEVELOPERSDONTHAVETHECAPITALTO
ACQUIRELANDBEFORETHEPRICESGOUPANDTHENHOLDITUNTIL
ITSREADYTODEVELOP
ORIENTED
INCOMEHOUSINGISBUILTNEAR
HEATSUPFORLANDANDHOUSINGINTHESENEIGHBORHOODSTHE
THREATSOFGENTRIlCATIONANDDISPLACEMENTOFLOWER
HOUSEHOLDSAREVERYREAL
/NEWAYTOEASETHESEPRESSURESANDKEEPRENTSANDHOME
PRICESDOWNISTOINCREASETHEOVERALLSUPPLYOFTRANSIT
DEVELOPMENT)FMOREMIXED
s&UNDINGFORBUILDINGAFFORDABLEHOUSINGISLIMITED TRANSITGENTRIlCATIONPRESSURESINDESIRABLENEIGHBORHOODS
s-IXED
INCOMEANDMIXED
USEPROJECTSREQUIRECOMPLEX COULDLESSEN/THERWISETHISWILLBEANENORMOUSMISSED
lNANCINGSTRUCTURES OPPORTUNITYTOUSETHEMARKETTOHELPADDRESSTHENATIONS

2 % ! , ) : ) . '4 ( %0 /4 % . 4 ) ! ,

GROWINGAFFORDABILITYCRISISBYTACKLINGTHEESCALATINGCOST ANDPOTENTIALFUTUREDEMANDFORHOUSINGNEARTRANSIT
OFBOTHHOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATIONATTHESAMETIME4HIS 7HILESIGNIlCANTVARIATIONEXISTSTHEREAREALSOSIMILARITIES
STRATEGYMAYPROVIDETHEADDITIONALBENElTSOFADDRESSINGTHE %ACHREGIONCANBECHARACTERIZEDASAhWARMvORhHOTvHOUSING
PROBLEMOFTRAFlCCONGESTIONANDEXPANDINGACCESSTOJOBS MARKETWHERERISINGPRICESAREOUTPACINGINCREASESININCOME
EDUCATIONALOPPORTUNITIESANDPROSPERITY !LLTHEREGIONSAREINVESTINGINTRANSITANDPROMOTING4/$
)NORDERTOBETTERUNDERSTANDHOWTHESEOPPORTUNITIES $IFFERENTCHALLENGESANDOPPORTUNITIESEXISTFORAREGIONLIKE
ANDCHALLENGESAREPLAYINGOUTINDIFFERENTREGIONSANDTHE "OSTONWITHITSWELL
ESTABLISHEDDENSELYPOPULATEDURBAN
EFFECTIVENESSOFSTRATEGIESTOENSURETHEREISMIXED
INCOME NEIGHBORHOODSANDMATURE
STATIONSYSTEMTHANFOR
HOUSINGNEARTRANSITTHISREPORTEXAMINESlVECASESTUDY $ENVERWHICHHASASMALLRELATIVELYNEWSYSTEMTHATISBEING
REGIONS!DVANCINGTHESTATEOFTHEPRACTICEOFLINKINGMIXED
RAPIDLYEXPANDEDANDWHICHHASFAST
GROWINGAUTO
DEPENDENT
INCOMEHOUSINGTOTRANSITINVESTMENTSREQUIRESGREATER SUBURBANCOMMUNITIES
CREATIVITYANDCOMMITMENTBYALLLEVELSOFGOVERNMENT4HE &ORSOMEREGIONSSUCHAS0ORTLANDWHERETHEREISSTRONG
FUNDINGSTRATEGIESANDTOOLSTHATHAVEBEENDEVELOPEDIN COORDINATIONOFTRANSPORTATIONINVESTMENTSANDLANDUSE
THECASESTUDYREGIONSANDTHELEADERSHIPTHATHASEMERGED DECISIONSBYALLLEVELSOFGOVERNMENTBILLIONSOFPRIVATESECTOR
ISENCOURAGING"UTTHEREISSOMUCHPOTENTIALDEMANDFOR DOLLARSHAVEBEENINVESTEDINMIXED
INCOMEDEVELOPMENT
HOUSINGNEARTRANSITANDSOFEWDEVELOPABLESITESTHATCITIES ALONGITSSTREETCARSYSTEM)N"OSTONINCONTRASTTHE3TATE
ANDREGIONSNEEDTOBEPROACTIVEINORDERTOACCOMMODATE HASTAKENANINCENTIVE
BASEDAPPROACHTOINCREASINGHOUSING
INCOMEDIVERSITYIN4/$4HISWILLHELPENSURETHATASTHIS
COUNTRYMOVESTHROUGHTHEUPSANDDOWNSOFREALESTATEMARKET
GROWINGMETROREGIONWHERETHELOCALGOVERNMENTHAS
CYCLESPEOPLEOFDIVERSEINCOMESWILLBEABLETOTAKEADVANTAGE
OFTHEPUBLICINVESTMENTINTRANSIT
PRODUCTIONPARTICULARLYINAREASSERVEDBYTRANSIT#HARLOTTEIS
AFAST
TAKENLEADERSHIPINCRAFTINGASTRATEGYFORREINVIGORATINGTHE
CITYANDCURBINGSPRAWLBYCHANNELINGGROWTHANDINVESTMENT
ALONGATRANSITSYSTEMTHATHASYETTOBEBUILT$ENVERANDTHE
,ESSONS,EARNEDINTHE#ASE3TUDY 4WIN#ITIESWHILEDIFFERENTAREBOTHREDISCOVERINGTHEPOWER
#ORRIDORSAND2EGIONS OFTHEIRNEWSYSTEMSTOSHAPEDEVELOPMENTANDTOLINKREGIONAL
DESTINATIONS
4(%&)6%-%42/0/,)4!.2%')/.3CHOSENASCASESTUDIES
!MONGTHECASESTUDYREGIONSTRANSPORTATIONANDHOUSING
n"OSTON#HARLOTTE$ENVERTHE4WIN#ITIES0ORTLANDnVARY
COSTSVARYSIGNIlCANTLYBYINCOMEANDBYREGION"UTINALL
INSIZETHEEXTENTANDMATURITYOFTHEIRTRANSITSYSTEMSAND
REGIONSTHEAVERAGECOSTOFHOUSINGISLESSTHANPERCENT
THESTRENGTHOFTHEIRHOUSINGMARKETS4HESEFACTORSAFFECTTHE
nTHESTANDARDFORAFFORDABILITY

FORALLHOUSEHOLDS7HILE
DEGREETOWHICH4/$CANSERVEASANORGANIZINGFRAMEWORK
THEREISNORECOGNIZEDSTANDARDOFTRANSPORTATIONAFFORDABILITY
FORGROWTHANDWHETHERASIGNIlCANTNUMBEROFHOUSEHOLDS
ONAVERAGE!MERICANHOUSEHOLDSSPENDPERCENTTHE
CANBENElTFROMREDUCEDTRANSPORTATIONEXPENDITURES4ABLE
SECONDHIGHESTHOUSEHOLDEXPENSEAFTERHOUSING5SINGA
!PROVIDESCOMPARISONSAMONGTHEREGIONSINTERMSOFTHE
TRANSPORTATIONMODELDEVELOPEDFORAPREVIOUSSTUDYCOMBINED
NUMBEROFHOUSEHOLDSINTRANSITZONESINCOMESHOUSINGCOSTS

4ABLE!COMPARESTHECASESTUDYREGIONSINTERMSOFTHENUMBEROFHOUSEHOLDSINTRANSITZONESTRANSITSYSTEMSIZEANDMATURITY
MEDIANINCOMEHOUSINGCOSTSANDPOTENTIALFUTUREDEMANDFORHOUSINGNEARTRANSIT

FOROWNEDHOUSINGUNITSWITHAMORTGAGE\

4OTAL4/$$EMANDREFERSTOTRANSITREGIONSONLY\53#ENSUS"UREAU!MERICAN#OMMUNITY
3URVEY3ELECTED(OUSEHOLD#HARACTERISTICS\#ENTERFOR#ENTERFOR4RANSIT/RIENTED$EVELOPMENT0RESERVINGAND0ROMOTING$IVERSITY.EAR4RANSIT
$ECEMBER\#ENTERFOR4RANSIT /RIENTED $EVELOPMENT(IDDENIN0LAIN3IGHT#APTURINGTHE$EMANDFOR(OUSING.EAR4RANSIT2ECONNECTING
!MERICA!PRILUPDATEFORTHCOMING3PRING 3OURCE#ENTERFOR4RANSIT /RIENTED $EVELOPMENT#ENSUS$ATAAND.ATIONAL4/$$ATABASE

% 8 % # 5 4 ) 6 % 3 5 - - ! 29 
 4HEREARELIMITEDOPPORTUNITIESFOR
REDEVELOPMENTALONGTHE&AIRMOUNT )NDIGO
COMMUTERRAILLINEIN"OSTONWHERETHE
MAJORITYOFUNDERUTILIZEDSITESARESMALL
INlLLPARCELSANDTHEFEWLARGEINDUSTRIAL
SITESAREPROBABLYCONTAMINATED
-OREOVERDEVELOPERSAREFRUSTRATEDWITH
AZONINGANDREGULATORYENVIRONMENT
THATDOESNTSUPPORTTRANSIT SUPPORTIVE
LANDUSESANDTHETRANSITAGENCYFACES
lNANCIALSHORTFALLSTHATLIMITITSABILITYTO
SERVEASAlNANCIALPARTNER4HEFOURNEW
STATIONSONTHISLINEHOWEVERWILLPROVIDE
SUBSTANTIALDEVELOPMENTOPPORTUNITY

2 % ! , ) : ) . '4 ( % 0 /4 % . 4 ) ! ,
TRANSPORTATIONANDHOUSINGCOSTSACCOUNTFORANESTIMATED COMMONWEALTHBOTHSHARETHEGOALOFINCREASINGHOUSING
AVERAGEOFPERCENTOFHOUSEHOLDBUDGETSFORHOUSEHOLDSIN PRODUCTIONMAINTAININGNEIGHBORHOODSTABILITYANDPROMOTING
FOUROFTHECASESTUDYREGIONS4HE4WIN#ITIESREGIONHASTHE DEVELOPMENTNEARTRANSIT4HECOMMONWEALTHHASCREATEDA
LOWESTHOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATIONCOSTSWHEREAS"OSTONAND MILLION4/$)NFRASTRUCTUREAND(OUSING3UPPORTPROGRAM
0ORTLANDAREONTHEHIGHEREND ANDNEWSMARTGROWTHHOUSINGLAWSPROVIDElNANCIALINCENTIVES
)NEACHOFTHECASESTUDYREGIONSTHESTUDYFOCUSEDONA FORMORECOMPACTHOUSING-"4!HASANEXTENSIVEINVENTORYOF
SINGLETRANSPORTATIONCORRIDORINORDERTOTAKEACLOSERLOOK LANDANDAIRRIGHTSATSTATIONSANDPARTNERSWITH-ASS(OUSING
ATHOWDIFFERENTTRANSITTECHNOLOGIESnLIGHTRAILVERSUSHEAVY A3TATEAGENCYTHATWORKSTOINCREASEAFFORDABLEHOUSINGTO
RAILVERSUSSTREETCARSFOREXAMPLEnAFFECTTHEHOUSINGMARKET PROVIDETECHNICALASSISTANCEANDRESOURCES-ASS(OUSINGPROVIDES
TRANSITRIDERSHIPWHICHAFFECTSTOTALHOUSEHOLDCOSTS AND MILLIONFORMIXED INCOMEHOUSINGPROJECTSWITHSPECIlC
GENTRIlCATIONANDDISPLACEMENT4HECASESTUDIESSHOWTHERE FUNDSSETASIDEFORAFFORDABLEPROJECTSNEARTRANSIT
ISNOSINGLE MOST EFFECTIVEAPPROACHTOPROMOTINGMIXED 4HEREARELIMITEDREDEVELOPMENTOPPORTUNITIESINTHE
INCOMEHOUSINGBUTTHEREAREIMPORTANTMODELSTHATCOULDBE &AIRMOUNT)NDIGOCORRIDORASTHEMAJORITYOFUNDERUTILIZED
APPLICABLEINMANYCOMMUNITIES SITESARESMALLINlLLPARCELSANDTHEFEWLARGEINDUSTRIALSITES

"OSTONSMASSTRANSITSYSTEMISRECOGNIZEDASONEOFTHEREGIONS

" / 34/. MOSTUNDERVALUEDASSETS7ITHMORETHANSTATIONSITSTHE

lFTHLARGESTSYSTEMINTHEIN53
42!.3)4#/22)$/2
&AIRMOUNT )NDIGO,INEA MILECOMMUTER
RAILCORRIDORWITHSTOPSANDNEWSTATIONS
PROPOSEDSERVICEBEGANIN
2)$%23()0
DAY
2%3)$%.43).42!.3)4:/.%34: 
RESIDENTSHOUSEHOLDS
$%.3)49
DWELLINGUNITSPERACRE
-%$)!.).#/-%
IN4:INREGION

4HE(OUSING-ARKET
4HE"OSTONREGIONISAHOTHOUSINGMARKETANDALMOSTHALF
THEHOUSINGSTOCKISSINGLE
FAMILY

AHIGHPERCENTAGEINONE
OFTHENATIONSHIGHEST
PRICEDMARKETS(OMEVALUESINCREASED
PERCENTTOFROMTOANDRISINGPRICES
AREBLAMEDFORCONTINUEDPOPULATIONDECLINEINTHEREGION AREPROBABLYCONTAMINATED7HILENEWSTATIONSCOULDSTIMULATE
DEVELOPMENTOFUPTONEWHOUSINGUNITSTHISWOULDFALL
4HE#ASE3TUDY#ORRIDOR FARSHORTOFTHEPROJECTEDDEMAND-OREOVERDEVELOPERSARE
4HE&AIRMOUNT)NDIGO,INERUNSTHROUGHLOW
ANDMIXED
FRUSTRATEDWITHTHEZONINGANDREGULATORYENVIRONMENTANDIT
INCOMECOMMUNITIES4HENUMBEROFSTATIONSWASDECREASED ISCLEARTHATZONINGISNEEDEDTHATMANDATESTRANSIT
SUPPORTIVE
FROMTOINTHESASTHEWHITEPOPULATIONMOVEDOUT LANDUSES$EVELOPERSLACKCERTAINTYABOUTWHATKINDANDHOW
ANDRIDERSHIPDECLINED4HE-ASSACHUSETTS"AY4RANSPORTATION MUCHDEVELOPMENTWILLBEPERMITTEDWHICHADDSTIMEANDCOST
!UTHORITY-"4! NOWPLANSTOBUILDFOURNEWSTATIONSAND TOPROJECTS-"4!MEANWHILEFACESlNANCIALSHORTFALLSLIMITING
MAKEOTHERINFRASTRUCTUREIMPROVEMENTS-"4!OPERATES THEAGENCYSABILITYTOHELPOUTASAlNANCIALPARTNER
RAILLINESWITHSTATIONS,ESSTHANPERCENTOFRESIDENTS "UTTHESIZEOFTHETRANSITSYSTEMISRECOGNIZEDASONEOFTHE
COMMUTEBYTRANSITWHICHISMORETHANDOUBLETHENATIONAL
AVERAGEOFPERCENTBUTBELOWTHEAVERAGEOFPERCENTFOR
ESTABLISHED
METROREGIONSWITHPOPULATIONSOFMORETHANMILLION
REGIONSMOSTUNDERVALUEDASSETSANDNEWSTATIONSWILLPROVIDE
SUBSTANTIALDEVELOPMENTOPPORTUNITY3EVERALWELL
COMMUNITYDEVELOPMENTCORPORATIONS#$#SARELEADINGTHE
CAMPAIGNTOIMPROVETHELINEANDCREATEMIXED
INCOMEPROJECTS
,OCAL0OLICYAND&UNDING ANDTHEYAREABLETOSECUREFUNDINGLEVERAGEASSETSAND
-ASSACHUSETTSISANATIONALLEADERINPROMOTINGMIXED
INCOME ENGAGETHECOMMUNITY-OREOVERTHECORRIDORHASNTSEENMUCH
4/$4HEREISBETTERCOORDINATIONATALLLEVELSOFGOVERNMENT MARKET
RATEDEVELOPMENTANDNOWTHATTHEHOUSINGMARKETHAS
THANINANYOTHERCASESTUDYREGIONEVENTHOUGHHOMERULE SOFTENEDAFFORDABLEHOUSINGDEVELOPERSHAVEBEENWORKINGWITH
RESTRICTIONSLIMITLOCALDECISION
MAKINGPOWER4HECITYAND THE-"4!THE3TATEANDTHECITYTOSECUREPROPERTIES

% 8 % # 5 4 ) 6 % 3 5 - - ! 29
 ,ESSONS,EARNED ,OCAL0OLICYAND&UNDING
s4HE3TATECANBEAPOWERFUL4/$PARTNER#REATINGA 4HECITYAND-ECKLENBURG#OUNTYSHAREJURISDICTIONAND
3TATEWIDE4/$FRAMEWORKENCOURAGESGREATERREGIONAL THECITYMANAGESTHE#HARLOTTE!REA4RANSPORTATION3YSTEM
COORDINATIONANDLEVELSTHEPLAYINGlELDBETWEENCITIESAND #!43 WHICHHASENHANCEDTHECOORDINATIONOFTRANSPORTATION
SUBURBS3TRONG"ROWNlELDLEGISLATIONALSOPROVIDESFUNDING ANDLANDUSEPLANNINGANDINITIATIVES4HECITYAPPROVEDA
ANDLIABILITYPROTECTIONFORNON RESPONSIBLEPARTIESANDALLOWS COMPREHENSIVELANDUSEPLANINTOMANAGETHEREGIONS
FOR PROlTANDNONPROlTENTITIESTOACCESSASSUMABLETAXCREDITS RAPIDGROWTHBYCOORDINATINGDEVELOPMENTWITHTRANSIT
FORREDEVELOPMENTPROJECTS ANDlVENEWLIGHTRAILLINESANDAMODERNSTREETCARLINEARE
s#$#SCANPLAYACRITICALROLEESPECIALLYWITHSMALLSITES PLANNED!TPRESENTTHEREISONLYABUSSYSTEMWHICHCARRIESA
#$#SHAVEACOMMUNITYBASEANDACCESSTOOUTSIDEFUNDING RELATIVELYLOWPERCENTAGEPERCENT OFCOMMUTERS
ANDTHEIRORGANIZINGEXPERIENCECANHELPALLAYCONCERNSABOUT 4HECOMPREHENSIVEPLANLAIDOUTAPROCESSFORPLANNING
DENSITYTRAFlCANDGENTRIlCATION#$#SSHOULDBEINCLUDEDIN ANDIMPLEMENTINGLANDUSEREGULATIONSANDINFRASTRUCTURE
PLANNINGINITIATIVESANDGIVENACCESSTOPUBLICRESOURCESAND IMPROVEMENTS7ALKINGAREASHAVEBEENDElNEDFORTHEHALF
TECHNICALASSISTANCE MILERADIUSAROUNDSTATIONSANDSTATIONAREAPLANSTRANSIT
s#REATEmEXIBLEAFFORDABLEHOUSINGFUNDS#$#SAREUSEDTO SUPPORTIVEZONINGANDhPEDSCAPESvHAVEBEENADOPTEDINSOME
ASSEMBLINGAPATCHWORKQUILTOFFUNDINGSOURCESnEACHWITH NEIGHBORHOODS4HECITYDEVELOPEDTRANSIT SUPPORTIVEOVERLAYS
DIFFERENTREQUIREMENTSANDTIMEFRAMESnFORASINGLEPROJECT TOBEGINTRANSITIONINGOTHERSTATIONAREASTOAPPROPRIATELAND
'OVERNMENTSHOULDMAKETHESEFUNDSMOREmEXIBLEAND USESANDISIMPROVINGSIDEWALKSBIKEPATHSMEDIANSPARKAND
ACCESSIBLEWITHLIMITEDAPPLICATIONANDREPORTINGREQUIREMENTS RIDELOTSANDDRAINAGEAROUNDSTATIONS
4HECITYHASCREATEDA4/$2ESPONSE4EAMTOASSIST
DEVELOPERSINOBTAININGENTITLEMENTSNECESSARYPUBLIC
# ( ! 2 ,/ 4 4 % IMPROVEMENTSANDlNANCIALASSISTANCE4HE#HARLOTTE
-ECKLENBURG0LANNING#OMMISSIONHASALSOBEENPROACTIVE
42!.3)4#/22)$/2
WITHSITE SPECIlCRE ZONINGSFOR4/$INAREASWHERESTATION
 MILESOFLIGHTRAILWITHSTATIONSSERVICETO
BEGININ AREAPLANSHAVENOTBEENADOPTED!3OUTH#ORRIDOR,AND
!CQUISITION&UNDWASCREATEDTOENABLEPUBLICASSEMBLYOF
2)$%23()0 KEYOPPORTUNITYSITESACRITICALTOOLFORCREATINGDEVELOPMENT
ESTIMATEDTOBEDAY
OPPORTUNITIESATASCALETHATCANBEPROlTABLEAND
2%3)$%.43).42!.3)4:/.%34:  TRANSFORMATIVE
RESIDENTSHOUSEHOLDS
$%.3)49
DWELLINGUNITSPERACRE
#HARLOTTEHASCREATEDA4/$2ESPONSE
-%$)!.).#/-% 4EAMTOASSISTDEVELOPERSINOBTAINING
IN4:INREGION ENTITLEMENTSNECESSARYPUBLIC
IMPROVEMENTSANDlNANCIALASSISTANCE
4HE(OUSING-ARKET
#HARLOTTESSPRAWLINGMODERATELYPRICED
HOUSINGMARKETISGROWINGRAPIDLYPERCENT
OFHOMESARESINGLEFAMILYWITHMORETHAN
PERCENTBUILTAFTER4HISRAPIDINCREASEIN
HOUSINGPRODUCTIONAPPEARSTOBECONSTRAINING
PRICES&ROMTOPRICESINCREASEDJUST
PERCENTTOCOMPAREDTOANATIONAL
AVERAGEOFPERCENT4HEREGIONISONEOF
THENATIONSFASTESTGROWINGANDISEXPECTED
TOGROWPERCENTTOHOUSEHOLDS
PERCENTOFWHICHCANBEEXPECTEDTOWANTTO
LIVENEARTRANSIT

4HE#ASE3TUDY#ORRIDOR
4HECASESTUDYFOCUSESONTHE3OUTH#ORRIDOR
LIGHTRAILLINESCHEDULEDTOBEGINOPERATIONIN
WHICHWILLCONNECT#HARLOTTES5PTOWN
NEIGHBORHOODTOSUBURBAN0INEVILLE%XISTING
HOUSINGSTOCKALONGTHELINEISLOW DENSITY

2 % ! , ) : ) . '4 ( % 0 /4 % . 4 ) ! ,
5NLIKETHE&AIRMOUNT )NDIGOLINEIN"OSTON
#HARLOTTES3OUTH#ORRIDORLIGHTRAILLINEHAS
MANYLARGEUNDERUTILIZEDCOMMERCIALAND
INDUSTRIALPROPERTIESAROUNDSTATIONS3ITING
ALINEWHERETHEREISTHISMUCHPOTENTIALFOR
DEVELOPMENTANDCREATINGPLANSANDTOOLS
TOCREATEANDPRESERVEINCOMEDIVERSITY
WILLBEAPOTENTCOMBINATION(OWEVER
TRANSFORMINGTHESENEIGHBORHOODSINTO
WALKABLEMULTIMODALMIXED USEPLACES
WILLTAKETIMEANDREQUIRESIGNIlCANT
INVESTMENTSTOIMPROVECONNECTIVITYSAFETY
ANDNEIGHBORHOODCHARACTER

% 8 % # 5 4 ) 6 % 3 5 - - ! 29
 $ENVERISONEOFTHEFEW#OLORADOCITIESWITHAN
INCLUSIONARYHOUSINGORDINANCEANDTHEREISALSO
A4/$&UNDPROVIDINGMILLIONINBONDING
AUTHORITYFORMULTI FAMILY4/$HOUSING

4HECITYCOUNTYAND#!43AREALLWORKINGTOLINKAFFORDABLE ,ESSONS,EARNED

HOUSINGTO4/$BUTITSTOOEARLYTOASSESSTHEIREFFORTS! s0LANFORSUCCESSWITH4/$
SUPPORTIVEZONINGANDPUBLIC
FAIR
SHAREHOUSINGPOLICYLIMITSTHENUMBEROFSUBSIDIZEDUNITS IMPROVEMENTS!LLTHEPUBLICPARTNERSHAVEWORKEDHARD
TOPERCENTINANYhNEIGHBORHOODSTATISTICALAREAvBUTAN TOCREATEANINTEGRATEDPOLICYFRAMEWORKTOSUPPORT4/$
EXCEPTIONHASBEENMADEALLOWINGFORPERCENTWITHINA ANDMIXED
INCOMEHOUSINGUSINGSTATIONAREAPLANS
QUARTERMILEOFSTATIONS4HECITYANDCOUNTYAREPROVIDING ZONINGUPDATESTHEIDENTIlCATIONOFCRITICALINFRASTRUCTURE
GAPlNANCINGTOHELPPROPOSEDPROJECTSSCOREBETTERINTHE
COMPETITIONFOR3TATEAFFORDABLEHOUSINGFUNDS"UT3OUTH
#ORRIDORNEIGHBORHOODSAREHIGHER
INCOMETHANTHOSEALONG
IMPROVEMENTSANDAREVISIONOFTHECITYSAFFORDABLEHOUSING
POLICY
s0LANNEDGROWTHCORRIDORSLIKETHE3OUTH#ORRIDORREQUIRE
THE&AIRMOUNT)NDIGOLINEIN"OSTONWITHITSLONGHISTORYOF
COMPREHENSIVEIMPLEMENTATIONTOOLS4HECITYANDITS
#$#INVOLVEMENTANDSUPPORTFORAFFORDABLEHOUSINGANDTHEY
PARTNERSHAVECREATEDIMPORTANTTOOLSINCLUDINGTHE
DONTVIEWAFFORDABLEHOUSINGASANASSET
VOTER
APPROVEDMILLIONINFRASTRUCTUREBONDTOFUND
4RANSFORMINGNEIGHBORHOODSALONGTHE3OUTH#ORRIDORINTO
IMPROVEMENTSINTHECORRIDORANDTHELANDACQUISITIONFUND
WALKABLEMULTI
MODALMIXED
USEPLACESWILLTAKETIMEAND
THE4/$2ESPONSE4EAMWITHDEDICATEDSTAFFANDAJOINT
REQUIRESIGNIlCANTINVESTMENTSTOIMPROVECONNECTIVITYSAFETY
DEVELOPMENTPROGRAM
ANDNEIGHBORHOODCHARACTER4HESEIMPROVEMENTSCOULDPULL
SOMEOFTHEMOMENTUMOFTHEDOWNTOWNHOUSINGMARKET
SOUTHALONGTHECORRIDORBUTCOULDALSOTAPOUTFUNDING
OTHERWISEAVAILABLEFORAFFORDABLEHOUSING4HE5PTOWNAND
$%.6%2
3OUTH%NDNEIGHBORHOODSnWHERESTATIONSWILLBEBUILT

ARE 42!.3)4#/22)$/2
COMPLEXURBANENVIRONMENTSWITHMANYUSESSTREETNETWORKS 7EST#ORRIDOR
MILELIGHTRAILLINEWITH
ANDPHYSICALCHARACTER4HEREAREMANYLARGEANDUNDERUTILIZED STATIONSSERVICETOBEGIN
INDUSTRIALANDCOMMERCIALSITESTHATWILLPROVIDESIGNIlCANT 2)$%23()0
REDEVELOPMENTOPPORTUNITIES4HECITYNEEDSTOPRESERVESOME ESTIMATEDTOBEDAYIN
COMMERCIALUSESHOWEVERTOMAINTAINADIVERSEANDHEALTHY 2%3)$%.43).42!.3)4:/.%34: 
ECONOMY RESIDENTSHOUSEHOLDS
4HE#HARLOTTELIGHTRAILCORRIDORISDIFFERENTFROMTHE $%.3)49
OTHERCASESTUDYCORRIDORSINTHATTHEREARESOMANYLARGE DWELLINGUNITSPERACRE
UNDERUTILIZEDCOMMERCIALANDINDUSTRIALPROPERTIESAROUND
-%$)!.).#/-%
STATIONS4HETRANSITINVESTMENTHASTHEPOTENTIALTOCATALYZE
IN4:INREGION
NEWDEVELOPMENT

RESIDENTIALDEVELOPMENTINPARTICULAR


ONASCALETHATCOULDTRANSFORMTHECHARACTERANDLIVABILITY
OFTHESENEIGHBORHOODS3ITINGATRANSITLINEWHERETHEREISA
4HE(OUSING-ARKET
4HE$ENVERREGIONISAMODERATELYGROWINGHOUSINGMARKET
HIGHPOTENTIALFORTRANSIT
SUPPORTIVEDEVELOPMENTANDTHEN
PERCENTOFHOMESARESINGLE
FAMILYSIMILARTOTHENATIONAL
CREATINGPLANSANDTOOLSINTENDEDTOCREATEANDPRESERVE
AVERAGEWITHPERCENTBUILTINORLATER4HEINCREASE
INCOMEDIVERSITYWILLBEAPOTENTCOMBINATIONTHATCANBE
INHOUSINGPRODUCTIONISCONSISTENTWITHPOPULATIONGROWTH
ADOPTEDANDADAPTEDBYOTHERCOMMUNITIES

2 % ! , ) : ) . '4 ( %0 /4 % . 4 ) ! ,

(OUSINGPRICESROSEPERCENTMORESLOWLYTHANTHEAVERAGE "ECAUSETHELINEWONTOPENFORSIXYEARSTHEMARKETHAS
NATIONALINCREASETOFROMTO4HEREGIONS YETTORESPOND,ANDSPECULATIONHASBEGUNBUTTHERESSTILL
POPULATIONISEXPECTEDTOGROWPERCENTFROMMILLION ANOPPORTUNITYFORTHECOMMUNITYTOACQUIRESITESFORMIXED

HOUSEHOLDSINTOMILLIONINWITHPERCENT INCOMEHOUSING'IVENHIGHLANDPRICESHOWEVERRESIDENTIAL
EXPECTEDTOWANTHOUSINGNEARTRANSIT DENSITYWILLBENECESSARYTOMAKEPROJECTSPENCILOUTANDTHIS
WILLTRANSLATEINTOSIGNIlCANTINFRASTRUCTURECOSTS5PGRADING
4HE#ASE3TUDY#ORRIDOR SEWERLINESCANBEEXPENSIVEFOREXAMPLEESPECIALLYINOLDER
)N$ENVERVOTERSPASSEDTHE&AS4RACKSINITIATIVE COMMUNITIES!FFORDABLEHOUSINGDEVELOPERSCANRARELYTAKEON
DEDICATINGAHALF
CENTSALESTAXTOCONSTRUCTIONOFlVENEWRAIL THESElNANCIALBURDENS
LINESINYEARSABILLIONINVESTMENT)NPERCENT
OFWORKTRIPSWEREBYTRANSIT4HE7EST#ORRIDORLIGHTRAILLINEWAS ,ESSONS,EARNED
CHOSENASTHECASESTUDY)TWILLCONNECTDOWNTOWNWITHMANY s6OTERSSUPPORTTRANSITAND4/$&ASTRACKSSENTTHEPOWERFUL
REGIONALDESTINATIONSANDEXISTINGBUSANDRAILSERVICE,AND MESSAGETHATITSPOSSIBLETOGENERATEBROADREGIONALSUPPORT
USESAREPRIMARILYCOMMERCIALANDCIVICINCLUDINGTHE*EFFERSON FORLOCALTRANSITANDTHESCALEOFTHISINITIATIVEHASATTRACTED
#OUNTY'OVERNMENT#ENTER&EDERAL#ENTERANDFOURCOLLEGES NATIONALDEVELOPERS
ANDITISBUILT
OUTWITHRESIDENTIALANDCOMMERCIALUSES s$ONTUNDERESTIMATETHEPOTENTIALFORLANDSPECULATION)TISA
2EDEVELOPMENTOPPORTUNITIESWILLDEPENDONTHEAVAILABILITY FORMIDABLEOBSTACLETOAFFORDABILITY!CQUIRINGANDHOLDINGLAND
OFUNDERUTILIZEDPROPERTIESANDhGREYlELDSv3IGNIlCANT REQUIRESCONSIDERABLECAPITALANDISBEYONDTHEMEANSOFMOST
OPPORTUNITYEXISTSFORREINVESTMENTINESTABLISHEDHOUSING DEVELOPERS&URTHERMOREMANYTRADITIONALFUNDINGSOURCESFOR
STOCKHOWEVERANDTWOSTATIONAREASINCLUDEDISTRESSEDPUBLIC
HOUSINGPROJECTS4HEREARECONCERNSABOUTDISPLACEMENTOF
LOWER
INCOMEHOUSEHOLDSASARESULTOFTHEREDEVELOPMENT
,OCAL0OLICYAND&UNDING
AFFORDABLEHOUSINGCANNOTBEUSEDTOPURCHASELAND2EGIONS
WITHAMBITIOUSTRANSITEXPANSIONPLANSMAYWANTTOHELPPUBLIC
ANDPRIVATEACTORSACQUIREANDHOLDLANDINTANDEMWITHTHE
SITINGOFLINESANDSTATIONS
s$EVELOPHOUSINGTRANSITIONSTRATEGIESFORDISTRESSEDAREAS
0LANNINGANDREZONINGEFFORTSAREUNDERWAYANDPEDESTRIAN 4HESTATIONJUSTWESTOFDOWNTOWNINCLUDESTWOOFTHEPUBLIC
LINKAGESAREBEINGEXAMINED4HETRANSITAGENCYSPONSOREDA HOUSINGPROJECTSANDACRESOFUNDERUTILIZEDLANDWITHSTRONG
PLANNINGCHARETTETOBETTERUNDERSTANDHOWTHELOCATIONAND REDEVELOPMENTPOTENTIAL4HECITYCOULDHELPREBUILDTHESE
DESIGNOFSTATIONSCOULDCATALYZEORINHIBITDEVELOPMENT4HE PROJECTSASMIXED
INCOMEHOUSINGANDSETGOALSFORRELOCATING
REGIONISALSODEVELOPINGTOOLSANDINCENTIVESFORHOUSING THEBALANCEOFAFFORDABLEUNITSAMIXED
INCOMEDEVELOPMENT
ALONGTRANSITCORRIDORSANDTOGETHERWITHTHETRANSITAGENCY
INCOMERESIDENCES 
ISPROVIDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDOTHERSUPPORTTOLOCAL
GOVERNMENTSFORSTATIONAREAPLANNING
$ENVERISONEOFTHEFEWCITIESIN#OLORADOWITHAN
ISUNLIKELYTOREPLACEALLOFTHEEXISTINGLOW
4HECITYANDCOUNTYSHOULDLEADAPLANNINGEFFORTTHATBRINGS
STAKEHOLDERSTOGETHERAROUNDACOMPELLINGVISION
INCLUSIONARYZONINGORDINANCEBUTITONLYPERTAINSTONEW
HOMEOWNERSHIPUNITSANDHOUSEHOLDSWITH
PERCENTOF 4( %47) .# )4) %3
AREAMEDIANINCOMELIMITINGTHEDEPTHOFAFFORDABILITY5NITS 42!.3)4#/22)$/2
MUSTREMAINAFFORDABLEFORJUSTYEARSALSOLIMITINGLONG
(IAWATHA#ORRIDOR
MILELIGHTRAILLINEWITH
TERMAFFORDABILITY(OWEVERTHE-ETRO-AYORS#AUCUSAND STOPSSERVICEBEGANIN
#OLORADO(OUSINGAND&INANCE!UTHORITYHAVECREATEDA4/$
2)$%23()0
&UNDTHATPROVIDESMILLIONINBONDINGAUTHORITYTOlNANCE
ESTIMATEDTOBEDAYIN
THECONSTRUCTIONACQUISITIONANDREHABOFMULTIFAMILY4/$
HOUSINGNEARTRANSIT 2%3)$%.43).42!.3)4:/.%34: 
4HE7EST#ORRIDORINCLUDESAHIGHPERCENTAGEOFLOW
INCOME RESIDENTSHOUSEHOLDS
HOUSEHOLDSSOASSURINGLONG
TERMAFFORDABILITYANDACCESS $%.3)49
TOTRANSITISIMPORTANT!TTHESAMETIMEREALIZINGTHEFULL DWELLINGUNITSPERACRE
POTENTIALFORTRANSIT
ORIENTEDDEVELOPMENTINTHECORRIDORWILL -%$)!.).#/-%
REQUIREADDRESSINGTHECHALLENGESOFCONCENTRATEDPOVERTY IN4:INREGION
4HEREAREPRESENTLYTHREEDISTRESSEDPUBLICHOUSINGSITES
LOCATEDWITHINWALKINGDISTANCEOFPROPOSEDTRANSITSTOPSAND 4HE(OUSING-ARKET
THECRIMEANDDISINVESTMENTOFTHESEPROPERTIESISLIKELYTO 4HEHOUSINGMARKETINTHE4WIN#ITIESISHOTFAST
GROWING
ACTASADISINCENTIVETOPRIVATEDEVELOPERS7ITHOUTTARGETED ANDSPRAWLINGPERCENTOFHOMESWERESINGLEFAMILYIN
STRATEGIESTOPRESERVETHEIRHOUSINGOPTIONSTHESELOW
INCOME SLIGHTLYABOVETHENATIONALAVERAGEWITHPERCENTBUILT
HOUSEHOLDSWILLPROBABLYBEDISPLACEDASTHECORRIDORDEVELOPS INORLATER(OUSINGPRODUCTIONISNTKEEPINGPACEWITH
GIVENTHATTHELINECONNECTSTODOWNTOWNANDSOMANYREGIONAL POPULATIONGROWTHANDPRICESHAVERISENALMOSTPERCENT
DESTINATIONS FROMTOTODOUBLETHENATIONALAVERAGE

% 8 % # 5 4 ) 6 % 3 5 - - ! 29
 4HEAMOUNTOFDEVELOPERINTERESTIN
-INNEAPOLIS(IAWATHALIGHTRAILLINE
HASSURPRISEDPLANNERSANDRESIDENTS
ANDPROJECTSAREGOINGUPALLALONGTHE
LINE7HILEMOSTOFTHEDEVELOPMENTIS
CONCENTRATEDDOWNTOWNSMALLER SCALE
PROJECTSARENOWBEINGBUILTINOLDER
ESTABLISHEDNEIGHBORHOODSASWELL4HESE
NEIGHBORHOODSAREWHERESOMEOFTHE
REGIONSMOSTAFFORDABLEHOUSINGISLOCATED
ANDANXIETYISGROWINGOVERGENTRIlCATION
ANDNEIGHBORHOODCHANGE

2 % ! , ) : ) . ' 4 ( % 0 / 4 % . 4 ) ! ,
 2ESIDENTIALTOWERSHAVESPRUNGUPAROUND
FOURDOWNTOWNSTATIONSIN-INNEAPOLISAND
INDUSTRIALAREASHAVEBEENREDEVELOPEDAS
HIGH DENSITYMIXED USEPROJECTS

4HEREGIONISEXPECTEDTOGROWPERCENTBYFROM
MILLIONHOUSEHOLDSTOMILLIONWITHPERCENTEXPECTEDTO
WANTHOUSINGNEARTRANSIT

4HE#ASE3TUDY#ORRIDOR
4HE(IAWATHALIGHTRAILCORRIDORSUBJECTOFTHECASESTUDY
WASTHElRSTINASERIESOFTRANSITIMPROVEMENTSPLANNEDFORTHE
NEXTYEARS)NRIDERSHIPONTHELINEEXCEEDEDTHE
PROJECTIONSBYPERCENT&OURPERCENTOFCOMMUTETRIPSARE
BYTRANSITINTHEREGION4HE(IAWATHALINECONNECTSDOWNTOWN
TOSUBURBAN"LOOMINGTONHOMEOFTHE-ALLOF!MERICAAND
THE-INNEAPOLIS 3T0AUL)NTERNATIONAL!IRPORTASWELLASJOBS BEENREDEVELOPEDASHIGH DENSITYMIXED USEPROJECTS4HIS
SPORTSANDTHEATEREVENTSHOSPITALSRETAILANDOPENSPACE DEVELOPMENTISORIENTEDTOWARDTRANSITANDPROVIDESALIVELY
$EVELOPMENTISOCCURRINGALLALONGTHELINECONCENTRATED WALKABLEENVIRONMENTINWHICHTOLIVEANDWORK
MOSTLYINDOWNTOWNTHOUGHSMALLER SCALEPROJECTSARE
APPEARINGINOLDERESTABLISHEDNEIGHBORHOODSWHICHOFFER ,ESSONS,EARNED
SOMEOFTHEREGIONSMOSTAFFORDABLEHOUSING4HEAMOUNTOF s/UTREACHANDCOORDINATIONARENECESSARYDURINGTHEPLANNING
DEVELOPERINTERESTHASSURPRISEDPLANNERSANDRESIDENTS ANDDESIGNOFNEWLINES4HE3TATE$EPARTMENTOF4RANSPORTATION
PLAYEDACRITICALROLEINTHEENGINEERINGDESIGNANDCONSTRUCTION
,OCAL0OLICYAND&UNDING OFTHE(IAWATHALINE"UTMOREOUTREACHANDCOORDINATION
-ETRO4RANSITISOVERSEENBYTHE-ETROPOLITAN#OUNCIL WITHCITYSTAFFCORRIDORRESIDENTSANDTHEPRIVATESECTORWOULD
THEREGIONALPLANNINGORGANIZATIONWHICHFUNDEDPLANNING HAVELEDTOBETTERDECISIONSABOUTSITINGTHELINEANDSTATIONS
EFFORTSDURINGCONSTRUCTIONOFTHELINETHECITYMEANWHILE TOPROVIDEBETTERPEDESTRIANACCESSANDMOREDEVELOPMENT
DEVELOPEDSTATIONAREAPLANSWITHNEIGHBORHOODINPUT4HEREIS OPPORTUNITIES
GROWINGANXIETYOVERGENTRIlCATIONANDNEIGHBORHOODCHANGE s"ESTTOPROACTIVELYADDRESSCOMMUNITYCHANGE-OST
INDICATINGTHEIMPORTANCEOFCOMMUNICATINGCLEARLYABOUTTHE DEVELOPMENTHASHAPPENEDDOWNTOWNBUTPUBLICINTERVENTIONTO
TYPEANDAMOUNTOFPLANNEDDEVELOPMENTANDTHECOMMITMENT CREATEANDPRESERVEAFFORDABLEHOUSINGMAYBENECESSARYIFTHE
TOAFFORDABILITY MARKETMOVESSOUTHINTOLOW INCOMENEIGHBORHOODS0OCKETSOF
4HECITYCOUNTYANDREGIONALLHAVEAFFORDABLEHOUSING CONCENTRATEDPOVERTYALONGTHELINECOULDBENElTFROMMIXED
PROGRAMSANDGAPlNANCINGISPROVIDEDBYTHECITYAND INCOMESTRATEGIES4HISWOULDREQUIREENGAGINGTHEPRIVATESECTOR
COUNTYWITHINCENTIVESFORPROXIMITYTOTRANSIT4HECOUNTY ANDPROVIDINGGAPlNANCINGRENTALSUBSIDIESOROTHERINCENTIVES
ALSOPROVIDESlNANCIALSUPPORTFOR4/$BUTHASFUNDEDMOSTLY s4HEMARKETCANLEVERAGECOMMUNITYBENElTSPROJECTS
MARKET RATEPROJECTS3OMESITESWOULDQUALIFYFOR"ROWNlELD HAVEBEENPLANNEDORBUILTDOWNTOWNSINCEMOSTARE
FUNDINGPROVIDEDBYTHE-ETROPOLITAN#OUNCILANDTHECITY RESIDENTIALANDSEVENINCLUDEINCOME RESTRICTEDANDRENT
OWNSSEVERALVACANTPARCELSTHATCOULDBEDEVELOPEDASMIXED SUBSIDIZEDUNITS)MPACTFEESAREILLEGALIN-INNESOTABUT
INCOMEHOUSINGANDCATALYZETHEMARKET!VARIETYOFOTHER4/$ DEVELOPMENTAGREEMENTSCOULDBEUSEDTOLEVERAGECOMMUNITY
TOOLSEXISTBUTTHEYMAYNOTNECESSARILYSTRENGTHENTHELINK BENElTSFROMLARGEPROJECTSLINKINGINCREASESINDENSITYOR
BETWEENAFFORDABILITYANDTRANSIT OTHERENTITLEMENTSTOINVESTMENTSINAFFORDABLEHOUSING
-ORETHANHALFTHEUSESINTHECORRIDORARECIVICWHICHIS 4HESEAGREEMENTSNEEDTOBENEGOTIATEDBEFOREREZONINGAND
BOTHOBSTACLEANDOPPORTUNITY0UBLICPROPERTYOWNERSHAVE COORDINATEDWITHPUBLICINFRASTRUCTUREIMPROVEMENTS
MORERESOURCESANDAMANDATETOBEMORETRANSIT ORIENTED s,ARGE ANDSMALL SCALE4/$PROJECTSAREREQUIRED"OTHARE
WHENREDEVELOPINGTHEIRPROPERTIES"UTCIVICUSESTENDTO REQUIREDTOCREATETHEDENSITYANDPEDESTRIANACTIVITYTHAT
BElXEDANDINDIFFERENTTOTHEMARKETANDREDEVELOPMENT SUPPORTSRETAIL!HIGHPERCENTAGEOFTHEDEVELOPMENTALONG
ISCOMPLICATEDANDDIFlCULTTOINTEGRATEWITHOTHERUSES THE(IAWATHACORRIDORWILLBEONSMALLERPARCELSWHEREDENSITY
-OREOVERSTRATEGICPLANNINGNEEDSTOINVOLVEMULTIPLEPUBLIC BONUSESCOULDLEVERAGECOMMUNITYBENElTSINCLUDINGAFFORDABLE
PARTNERSINCLUDINGTHE&EDERALGOVERNMENTAMAJORPROPERTY UNITSGREENBUILDINGOPENSPACEANDSIDEWALKANDSTREETSCAPE
OWNERINTHECORRIDORTHEMETROPOLITANAIRPORTAUTHORITY IMPROVEMENTS
(ENNEPIN#OUNTYTHE#ITYOF-INNEAPOLISWITHSTATIONS  s2EGIONALLEADERSHIPISNECESSARY.EWTRANSITPROJECTSCREATE
ANDTHE#ITYOF"LOOMINGTONTHREESTATIONS  TREMENDOUSPOTENTIALFORMIXED INCOMEHOUSINGNEARTRANSIT"UT
(OWEVERINVESTMENTINTHELINEBOLSTEREDTHEMARKET THISREQUIRESTOOLSBEYONDWHATANYONEJURISDICTIONCANPROVIDE
AROUNDFOURDOWNTOWNSTATIONSWHEREHIGH RISEANDMID RISE 3TRONGREGIONALCOORDINATIONOFINVESTMENTSANDPOLICIESIS
CONDOMINIUMTOWERSHAVESPRUNGUPANDINDUSTRIALAREASHAVE IMPORTANTTOTHEOVERALLEFlCACYOFANYONEOFTHEM

% 8 % # 5 4 ) 6 %3 5 - - ! 29 
 0UBLICINVESTMENTINTHE0ORTLANDSTREETCAR
HELPEDLEVERAGEPRIVATEINVESTMENTINPARKS
ANDHIGH QUALITYPUBLICSPACETHATMAKEFOR
SUBLIMECITYLIVINGEVENFORFAMILIES

CITEDFORTHEIRINNOVATIVEANDCOMPREHENSIVE
APPROACHTOPROMOTING4/$ANDTRANSPORTATION
ALTERNATIVESINCLUDINGAMODERNSTREETCARAND
AERIALTRAM4HE3TATEALSOSUPPORTS4/$BY
AUTHORIZINGTAXABATEMENTSTOPROVIDEADDITIONAL
INCENTIVES4RI-ETPLAYSANACTIVEROLEINACQUIRING
LANDANDESTABLISHINGDEVELOPMENTCRITERIATHROUGH
ITSJOINTDEVELOPMENTAUTHORITY!LLVISIONINGAND
PLANNINGISDONEWITHSIGNIlCANTCOMMUNITYINPUT
ANDTHEPRIVATESECTORHASBEENINSTRUMENTALIN
IMPLEMENTINGTHEVISIONOFANENVIRONMENTALLYAND
0/ 24 , ! . $ SOCIALLYSUSTAINABLEREGION
42!.3)4#/22)$/2 !PPROXIMATELYBILLIONINDEVELOPMENTHASOCCURRED
 MILESTREETCARLINEWITHSTOPSSERVICE ALONGTHESTREETCARLINEINTHE0EARL$ISTRICT ASUBSTANTIAL
BEGANINTOTHE0EARL$ISTRICTAND RETURNONTHEMILLIONTRANSITPROJECTnANDANOTHERNEW
INTHE3OUTH7ATERFRONT NEIGHBORHOODCALLED3OUTH7ATERFRONTISBEINGDEVELOPED
2)$%23()0 ONUNDERUTILIZEDINDUSTRIALLANDTHATISALSOCONNECTEDTO
DAYIN DOWNTOWNBYTHESTREETCAR/NCEANABANDONEDRAILYARDONTHE
RIVERNEARDOWNTOWNTHE0EARLISNOWHOMETOAVIBRANTMIXOF
2%3)$%.43).42!.3)4:/.%34: 
USESINCLUDINGRESIDENTIALUNITSPERCENTOFWHICHARE
RESIDENTSHOUSEHOLDS
AFFORDABLE
$%.3)49 4HE#ENTRAL#ITY0LANINTRODUCEDTHEIDEAOF
DWELLINGUNITSPERACRE REDEVELOPINGTHESETWOLARGEPARCELSINTOHIGH DENSITY
-%$)!.).#/-% MIXED USENEIGHBORHOODSSERVEDBYTHESTREETCAR"OTHWERE
IN4:INREGION ESTABLISHEDASURBANRENEWALAREASANDALOCALIMPROVEMENT
DISTRICTASSESSEDNON OWNER OCCUPIEDRESIDENCESTOHELPPAY
4HE(OUSING-ARKET FORTHESTREETCARANDOTHERIMPROVEMENTS4HE#ENTRAL#ITY
0ORTLANDISAHOTMODERATELYGROWINGHOUSINGMARKET 0LANWASREINFORCEDBYBOTHREGIONALAND3TATELAND USE
PERCENTOFHOUSINGUNITSARESINGLEFAMILYWITHPERCENT POLICIESASWELLASCONTINUEDINVESTMENTINPEDESTRIANBICYCLE
BUILTINORLATER4HEGROWTHINHOUSINGUNITSCOMBINED ANDTRANSITINFRASTRUCTURE!NDITWASSUPPORTEDBYPOLITICAL
WITHTHEINCREASINGATTRACTIVENESSANDHIGHMEDIANINCOMESIN LEADERSPOWERFULNEIGHBORHOODASSOCIATIONSANDCIVIC MINDED
THEREGIONHAVEPUTPRESSUREONPRICESWHICHROSEPERCENT DEVELOPERS
BETWEENANDTOHIGHERTHANTHENATIONAL 'IVENTHEINDUSTRIALNATUREOFTHERAILYARDSANDTHE
AVERAGE4HEREGIONISEXPECTEDTOGROWPERCENTFROM LARGEPARCELSOFLANDTHE0EARLLACKEDEVENTHEMOST
TOMILLIONHOUSEHOLDSINWITHPERCENT BASICINFRASTRUCTURENECESSARYTOACCOMMODATERESIDENTIAL
EXPECTEDTOWANTTOLIVENEARTRANSIT DEVELOPMENT-OREOVERTHEPROPERTYWASCONTAMINATED
CREATINGDELAYSANDADDITIONALCOSTSWHICHWEREEVENTUALLY
4HE#ASE3TUDY#ORRIDOR RECOVEREDFROMTHEFORMERLANDOWNERS4HE0ORTLAND
4HECASESTUDYCORRIDORISALONGTHESTREETCARWHICHOPENED $EVELOPMENT#OMMISSION0$# THECITYSURBANRENEWAL
INTWOEXTENSIONSTO0ORTLAND3TATE5NIVERSITYANDTO HOUSINGANDECONOMICDEVELOPMENTAGENCYnWASTHECONDUIT
THE3OUTH7ATERFRONTREDEVELOPMENTDISTRICTHAVEOPENED FORMILLIONSOFDOLLARSOFPUBLICINVESTMENTINTHE0EARLAND
SINCEANDMOREEXTENSIONSAREPLANNED4HESTREETCARCONNECTS 3OUTH7ATERFRONTANDUSEDDEVELOPMENTAGREEMENTSTO
TOTHEREGIONALLIGHTRAILTRANSITSYSTEM2EGIONALTRANSITUSAGE LEVERAGEPUBLICOBJECTIVESLIKEAFFORDABILITYPARKSANDDENSITY
BYCOMMUTERSISPERCENTABOVETHENATIONALAVERAGEANDAN 4HE0$#WHICHHADNOlNANCIALRESOURCESTOBRINGTOTHE
ADDITIONALPERCENTOFWORKTRIPSAREMADEBYBICYCLEORON TABLENEGOTIATEDADEALWITH(OYT3TREET0ROPERTIESTHE
FOOTWELLABOVETHENATIONALAVERAGEOFPERCENT SINGLELARGESTLANDOWNERTHATCENTEREDONTHECITYMAKINGTWO
IMPROVEMENTS4HECITYWOULDREMOVEANOVERHEADRAMPTHAT
,OCAL0OLICYAND&UNDING RANTHROUGHTHEMIDDLEOF(OYT3TREETSACRESRENDERING
4HECITYAND-ETROWHICHISTHEREGIONALGOVERNMENT ADJACENTLANDUN DEVELOPABLEIFTHEDEVELOPERWOULDCOMMIT
TOGETHERWITH4RI-ETTHEREGIONALTRANSITAGENCYAREOFTEN TOBUILDINGAMINIMUMOFDWELLINGUNITSPERACREDUA 4HE

2 % ! , ) : ) . '4 ( % 0 /4 % . 4 ) ! ,
CITYALSOAGREEDTOCHOOSEASTREETCARALIGNMENTADJACENTTO
(OYT3TREETSPROPERTYIFDENSITYWEREFURTHERINCREASEDTO
ZONING4HISINCREASEDVALUEHELPED
DUA$ENSITYWASBOOSTEDTODUAWHENTHECITYCOMPLETED
APARKONLANDDONATEDBYTHEDEVELOPER4HEDEVELOPERALSO
CONTRIBUTEDNEARLYMILLIONTOTHECITYANDLOCALIMPROVEMENT
PORTIONSOFTHERAILYARDPRIORTOTHEESCALATIONINVALUETHAT
TYPICALLYACCOMPANIESUP
PAYFORINFRASTRUCTUREANDAMENITIESTHROUGHTHEUSEOFTAX
INCREMENTlNANCING(OYT3TREETDEVELOPER(OMER7ILLIAMSHAD
MOSTLYDONESINGLE
FAMILYPROJECTSBEFORETHE0EARLANDHETOOK
DISTRICTDONATEDOTHERRIGHTSOFWAYANDAGREEDTOMEETTHE ONSIGNIlCANTRISKFORTHISUNPROVENHOUSINGPRODUCT7ILLIAMSIS
CITYSAFFORDABILITYREQUIREMENTS4HESEDENSITIESWOULDNOT NOWAKEYOWNERANDDEVELOPERIN3OUTH7ATERFRONT
HAVEBEENPOSSIBLEWITHOUTTHESTREETCARBECAUSEDEVELOPERS
WOULDHAVEHADTOPROVIDESIGNIlCANTLYMOREPARKINGnMOST ,ESSONS,EARNED
PROJECTSAREPARKEDATMUCHLOWERRATIOSTHANELSEWHEREINTHE s$EVELOPMENTAGREEMENTSAREANIMPORTANTVALUE
CAPTURETOOL
REGIONnWHICHWOULDHAVEDRAMATICALLYINCREASEDTHECOSTOF #OMPREHENSIVEAGREEMENTSOUTLININGTHERESPONSIBILITIESOFALL
DEVELOPMENTANDREDUCEDTHENUMBEROFHOUSINGUNITS PARTIESAREANIMPORTANTTOOLFORCOMPLEXLARGE
SCALEPUBLIC
4HELARGESINGLE
OWNERPARCELSPROVIDEDMAJORDEVELOPMENT PRIVATEPROJECTS4HEYMOTIVATEDEVELOPERSWHILEENSURINGTHAT
OPPORTUNITIESnWHOLENEWNEIGHBORHOODSWEREBEINGBUILT PUBLICGOALSAREMETANDTRUSTISMAINTAINED$EVELOPERSWILLHELP
ALLOWINGFORTHECREATIONOFAVERYDIFFERENTURBANENVIRONMENT PAYFORINFRASTRUCTUREAFFORDABLEHOUSINGANDOTHERAMENITIESIN
0RIORTOTHESTREETCARTHEREWASVERYLITTLEHOUSINGDOWNTOWN RETURNFORENTITLEMENTSANDOTHERPUBLICSUPPORT
ANDHIGH
QUALITYHIGH
DENSITYDEVELOPMENTANDTHELIFESTYLEIT
s!4/$FRAMEWORKISCRITICAL(AVINGACLEARREDEVELOPMENTPLAN
SUPPORTSWEREUNKNOWNIN0ORTLAND4HEPENT
UPDEMANDFOR


THE#ENTRAL#ITY0LANnANDAPPROPRIATEZONINGWASCRITICALFOR
HIGHER
DENSITYHOUSINGNEARTRANSITCOINCIDEDWITHDEMOGRAPHIC
NEGOTIATIONSIMPLEMENTATIONANDSUCCESSFULPLACE
MAKING
CHANGESACROSSTHECOUNTRYRESULTINGINSMALLEROLDERMORE
DIVERSEHOUSEHOLDSBOOSTINGTHEMARKETFORURBANHOUSING s&LEXIBILITYISKEY-ARKETCHANGESANDUNEXPECTEDCOSTSRESULTED
-OREOVERBECAUSETHEREWERENOEXISTINGRESIDENTSTHEREWAS INADIFFERENTSCENARIOTHANORIGINALLYPLANNEDINTHE0EAR$ISTRICT
NOCOMMUNITYOPPOSITION &LEXIBILITYISNECESSARYTOENABLETHEDEVELOPERTOPROlT!BROAD
(OYT3TREET0ROPERTIESANDTHECITYHADACQUIREDLARGE RANGEOFUSESWEREALLOWEDTHOUGHBUILDINGSHADTORESPONDTO
DESIGNSTANDARDS
s5NDERUTILIZEDINDUSTRIALLANDPRESENTSSIGNIlCANT
OPPORTUNITIESFOR4/$,ARGEPARCELSCANPROVIDEFOR
4HE0ORTLAND$EVELOPMENT#OMMISSION WHOLENEWHIGHER
DENSITYTRANSIT
ORIENTEDURBAN
USEDDEVELOPERAGREEMENTSTOLEVERAGE NEIGHBORHOODS3IGNIlCANTPUBLICINVESTMENTMAY
AFFORDABLEHOUSINGIN0ORTLANDS0EARL BENEEDEDBUTITPROVIDESANOPPORTUNITYFORPUBLIC

$ISTRICTWHEREINPERCENTOF PRIVATEPARTNERSHIPS
NEWHOUSINGUNITSWEREAFFORDABLE
s$IFFERENTTOOLSAREREQUIREDFORDIFFERENT
REDEVELOPMENTOPPORTUNITIES4HEDEVELOPMENT
AGREEMENTISAGOODTOOLFORLARGEPARCELSBUTNOT
FORBUILT
OUTAREASWITHSMALLINlLLPARCELS
s)NCLUSIONARYZONINGISNTTHEONLYTOOLFOR
AFFORDABLEHOUSING0ORTLANDUSEDDEVELOPMENT
AGREEMENTSANDSETAGOALOFBUILDINGTHESAME
PERCENTAGEOFAFFORDABLEUNITSASEXISTEDCITYWIDE
4HEMIXOFAFFORDABLEUNITSISRE
EVALUATEDATEACH
PHASEOFTHEPROJECT
s6ALUECAPTURESTRATEGIESSHOULDFUNDANARRAYOF
BENElTS!VARIETYOFCOMMUNITYBENElTSBESIDES
AFFORDABILITYARENECESSARYTOMAKEANEIGHBORHOOD
WORK4HEGOALOFAFFORDABILITYMUSTBEBALANCED
WITHTHENEEDFOROPENSPACETRANSITDENSITY
WHEREITINVOLVESMOREMARKETRISK ANDOTHER
PUBLICAMENITIES#OMMUNITYINPUTISREQUIREDTO
DETERMINETHEBESTBALANCE
s#REATEEQUALOPPORTUNITYFORDEVELOPERS4AX
ABATEMENTSAREANOTHERPOWERFULTOOLTOSHAPE
DEVELOPMENT)NCENTIVESSHOULDBEAVAILABLETOBOTH
FOR
PROlTANDNONPROlTDEVELOPERSTOSTIMULATETHE
PRODUCTIONOFAFFORDABLEHOUSING

% 8 % # 5 4 ) 6 % 3 5 - - ! 29
 #HALLENGESTOBUILDINGMIXED INCOMEHOUSINGNEARTRANSITINCLUDE
ESCALATINGLANDPRICESTHENEEDFORLANDASSEMBLYANDCOMMUNITY
OPPOSITION"UTPROACTIVESTRATEGIESBYGOVERNMENTATALLLEVELS
CANCATALYZETHEMARKETANDHELPBUILDAFFORDABLEHOUSING

#ONCLUSIONS AND
2ECOMMENDATIONS
4(%&)6%#!3%345$)%3DEMONSTRATETHATWHILETHEREARE MIXED INCOMEHOUSING,ANDBUILDINGSANDEXCESSFACILITIESCANBE
CHALLENGESTOPROVIDINGMIXED INCOMEHOUSINGNEARTRANSIT DEVELOPEDASMIXED INCOMEHOUSINGANDHELPCATALYZETHEMARKET
PROACTIVESTRATEGIESONTHEPARTOF3TATEREGIONALANDLOCAL
GOVERNMENTSCANSERVEASACATALYSTFORTHEMARKETANDHELP "0ROVIDEINCENTIVESTHATHELPCATALYZETHEMARKET
ENSURETHATHOUSINGNEARTRANSITSERVESAMIXOFINCOMES4HESE FORMIXED INCOME4/$
STRATEGIESCANBEBROADLYCHARACTERIZEDINTOlVECATEGORIES
s#REATEINCENTIVESATTHELOCALJURISDICTIONLEVELTOBUILDAT
OFACTIONDETAILEDBELOW4ABLESPECIlESWHETHEREACH
TRANSIT APPROPRIATEDENSITIES"OTHTRANSITANDAFFORDABLE
OFTHESESTRATEGIESAPPLIESTO3TATEREGIONALANDLOCAL
HOUSINGARESIGNIlCANTPUBLICINVESTMENTS3OMEREGIONSMAKE
GOVERNMENTSANDTHEPRIVATESECTOR4HEREAREDESCRIPTIONSOF
FUNDINGFORNEWTRANSITPROJECTSCONTINGENTON4/$ SUPPORTIVE
&EDERALACTIONSTHATMAYBEUNDERTAKENTOSUPPORT3TATEAND
PLANNINGANDZONINGINCLUDINGDENSITYBONUSESANDLOWER
LOCALDECISIONSABOUTHOUSINGANDPUBLICTRANSPORTATIONATTHE
PARKINGREQUIREMENTS BYLOCALGOVERNMENTSINAPROPOSED
ENDOFTHISREPORT
CORRIDOR

0ROACTIVE3TRATEGIESFOR-IXED )NCOME4/$ s&ACILITATETHEUSEOFVALUECAPTURETOOLSFORAFFORDABLEHOUSING

AND4/$4/$CANBEVERYEXPENSIVEBECAUSEOFTHETIMEAND
!)DENTIFYANDUTILIZE4/$OPPORTUNITIESINTHEREGION COMPLEXITYINVOLVEDANDADDINGINTHECOSTSOFAFFORDABLEUNITS
ANDALONGTRANSITCORRIDORS CANMAKEPROJECTSINFEASIBLE"UTVALUECAPTURETOOLSSUCHAS
s4ARGETASIGNIlCANTPERCENTAGEOFREGIONALGROWTHINTOTRANSIT TAXINCREMENTlNANCINGBUSINESSIMPROVEMENTDISTRICTSAND
CORRIDORS!STRANSITSYSTEMSEXPANDANDCONNECTTOMOREJOBS DEVELOPERAGREEMENTSCANHELPUNDERWRITEMIXED INCOME4/$
ANDDESTINATIONSTHEOPPORTUNITYTOPROVIDEMOREHOUSINGFORA
WIDERRANGEOFINCOMESINCREASES s#REATE4/$LANDACQUISITIONLANDBANKINGFUNDS4HESE
FUNDSCANBEUSEDTOPURCHASELANDANDHOUSINGNEARSTATIONS
s!SSESSTHEPOTENTIALFOR4/$TOMITIGATENEGATIVEOUTCOMESOF BEFORETHEMARKETHEATSUP$EVELOPMENTFEESmEXIBLE3TATE
DISPLACEMENTINTHESTATIONAREASWHEREDISPLACEMENTOFEXISTING TRANSPORTATIONANDHOUSINGFUNDSANDFOUNDATIONFUNDINGCAN
LOW INCOMERESIDENTSCOULDOCCUR BEUSED
s5TILIZEPUBLICLY OWNEDPROPERTIESALONGTRANSITCORRIDORSFOR s-ODIFYLOW INCOMEHOUSINGTAXCREDITSTOOFFERGREATER

2 % ! , ) : ) . '4 ( % 0 /4 % . 4 ) ! ,
INCENTIVESFORLOCATINGNEARTRANSIT&OURKEYCHANGESWOULDGO )NADDITIONTHEREARElVEPRIMARYRECOMMENDATIONSFOR
ALONGWAY /FFERPOINTSFORPROXIMITYTOTRANSIT )NCREASE FURTHERACTIONSPECIlCTOTHE&EDERALGOVERNMENT
THESUBSIDYFORTRANSIT
ORIENTEDPROJECTS %NABLELARGER4/$
s(5$AND&4!SHOULDEXAMINEEXISTINGPOLICYANDFUNDING
PROJECTSTOBENElTFROMLOWINCOMEHOUSINGTAXCREDITS
PROGRAMSATEACHAGENCYINORDERTOIMPROVETHECOORDINATION
0RIORITIZETAXCREDITSFORTHEPRESERVATIONOFEXISTINGAFFORDABLE
ANDFACILITATIONOFAFFORDABLEHOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATION
HOUSINGANDCONSOLIDATETHEUNDERWRITINGPROCESSTOAPPLYFOR
INVESTMENTSSUBJECTTOFUNDINGAVAILABILITIES
TAXCREDITSANDOTHERRESOURCESSIMULTANEOUSLY
s(5$SHOULDEXPLOREREGULATORYANDPOLICYAPPROACHESTHAT
#2EMOVEREGULATORYBARRIERSTOHIGHERDENSITY MAYINCREASETHESUPPLYOFAFFORDABLEORMIXED
INCOMEHOUSING
MIXED
USEDEVELOPMENT WITHINTRANSITCORRIDORS4HESEWOULDFOCUSONPRESERVATIONOF
s2EMOVINGBARRIERSHELPSREDUCETHECOSTOF4/$:ONINGCODES EXISTINGRENTALHOUSINGNEARTRANSITANDNEWCONSTRUCTIONOF
SHOULDSUPPORTHIGHERDENSITYMIXED
USEDEVELOPMENTPARKING AFFORDABLEANDMIXED
INCOMEHOUSING
REQUIREMENTSSHOULDBEREDUCEDANDTHEENTITLEMENTAND s&4!SHOULDCONTINUETOEVALUATEANDRATEPROPOSEDMAJOR
APPROVALSPROCESSSHOULDBESHORTENEDANDSIMPLIlED TRANSITINVESTMENTSKNOWNAS.EW3TARTSAND3MALL3TARTS
s%NCOURAGEPROACTIVESTATIONAREAPLANNINGANDZONING4HIS 53# UNDER#ONGRESSIONALLY
MANDATEDCRITERIA5NDER
HELPSPROVIDECERTAINTYFORDEVELOPERSANDFOREXISTINGRESIDENTS &4!SCURRENTEVALUATIVEPROCEDURESPROJECTSINAREASWITHHIGH
ANDMINIMIZESCOMMUNITYOPPOSITION POPULATIONDENSITIESTENDTOEARNBETTERRATINGSBECAUSEMORE
PEOPLECANWALKTOTRANSITLEADINGTOHIGHERRIDERSHIPAND
$#OORDINATEHOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATIONPLANS RESULTINGBENElTS&4!ALSOGIVESHIGHERRATINGSTOPROJECTSTHAT
ANDINVESTMENTS SERVEHIGHERNUMBERSOFLOWER
INCOMETRANSIT
DEPENDENTPEOPLE
s#OORDINATELONG
RANGEHOUSINGLANDDEVELOPMENTAND #ONSEQUENTLYTHENETEFFECTISTHATTHEHIGHERTHEPOPULATION
TRANSPORTATIONPLANNINGPROCESSES"OTH(5$AND&4!REQUIRE OFLOWER
INCOMERESIDENTSNEARATRANSITSTATIONTHEBETTERTHE
LONG
RANGEPLANS#OORDINATIONCANRESULTINMORESUSTAINABLE PROJECTSANTICIPATEDRIDERSHIPANDMOBILITYBENElTS&4!IS
GROWTHANDGREATEREFlCIENCIESANDCOST
SAVINGSFORLOCAL EXPLORINGOTHERAPPROACHESFORRATINGPROJECTSTHATDEMONSTRATE
GOVERNMENTSANDRESIDENTS
s4ARGETFUNDINGTOSUPPORTTHECREATIONANDPRESERVATION
OFAFFORDABLEHOUSINGINTRANSITCORRIDORS2ESOURCESSHOULD
BEDIRECTEDTOTHOSELOCATIONSTHATCANPROVIDEADDITIONAL
AFFORDABILITYBENElTSBECAUSEHOUSEHOLDTRANSPORTATIONCOSTS
ARELOWER
YEARRESEARCHANDACTIONPLANTOSUPPORTTHESE
THEPOTENTIALFORHIGHERRIDERSHIPBYTRANSITDEPENDENT
POPULATIONS
s(5$AND&4!SHOULDESTABLISHANINTERAGENCYWORKINGGROUP
THATISRESPONSIBLEFORCONTINUINGCOLLABORATIONBETWEENTHETWO
AGENCIESTOMAXIMIZETHEOPPORTUNITIESFORCOORDINATED(5$
AND&4!ACTIONS!PRIMARYFUNCTIONOFTHISGROUPWILLBETO
DEVELOPAlVE
%)MPROVELOCALCAPACITYPARTNERSHIPSANDDATA COLLABORATIVEEFFORTS
COLLECTION s(5$AND&4!SHOULDCONTINUETOSTUDYTHERELATIONSHIPS
s#REATETHECAPACITYWITHINHOUSINGANDTRANSPORTATION BETWEENHOUSINGMARKETSANDTRANSITINVESTMENTS4HISSTUDY
AGENCIESTOFACILITATE4/$3TAFFISNEEDEDTOMONITORAND ISTHElRSTINMANYYEARSTOEXAMINETHELINKAGESBETWEENTHE
SUPPORTDEVELOPMENTATSTATIONSCOORDINATEWITHOTHER MARKETTRANSITINVESTMENTSTRAVELPATTERNSANDDEVELOPMENT
AGENCIESANDWORKWITHTHEREALESTATEANDDEVELOPMENT
COMMUNITIES
s5TILIZE&4!SJOINTDEVELOPMENTPOLICYTOEMPHASIZE
INCOME
CONSTRUCTIONOFHOUSINGINTRANSITZONES2EALESTATETHATSBEEN
TRENDS-OREANALYSISISNEEDEDTOESTABLISHPERFORMANCE
MEASURESANDDETERMINETHEEFlCACYOFSTRATEGIESBEING
IMPLEMENTEDINCOMMUNITIESTHATARECREATINGMIXED
HOUSINGNEARTRANSIT
ACQUIREDFORRIGHTSOFWAYSTATIONSPARKINGLOTSANDSTAGING
AREASANDEVENAIRRIGHTSCANPROVIDESIGNIlCANTDEVELOPMENT
OPPORTUNITY&4!SNEWJOINTDEVELOPMENTPOLICYPROVIDES &OOTNOTES

#ENTERFOR.EIGHBORHOOD4ECHNOLOGY#.4 ANDTHE#ENTERFOR4RANSIT

UNPRECEDENTEDmEXIBILITYFORLEASINGANDEVENSELLINGTHIS
/RIENTED$EVELOPMENT#4/$ 0RESERVINGAND0ROMOTING$IVERSE4RANSIT

PROPERTYFORTRANSIT
SUPPORTIVEPURPOSES /RIENTED.EIGHBORHOODS#.4.OVEMBER

#ENTERFOR.EIGHBORHOOD4ECHNOLOGYAND6IRGINIA4ECHh(OUSINGAND
s-ONITORANDTRACKDATAONDEVELOPMENTACTIVITYDEMOGRAPHIC
4RANSPORTATION#OST4RADE
/FFSAND"URDENSOF7ORKING(OUSEHOLDSIN
TRENDSANDPROPERTYVALUESATBOTHTHECORRIDORANDSTATION
-ETRO!REASvA7HITE0APERPREPAREDFORTHE#ENTERFOR(OUSING0OLICY
AREALEVELS#OMMUNITYCHANGEISDIFlCULTANDACCURATEDATA 4HEEXPENDITUREPERCENTAGESAREBASEDONWEIGHTEDAVERAGENUMBERS
ISAPOWERFULTOOLTOHELPKEEPLINESOFCOMMUNICATIONOPENBY FORHOUSEHOLDSFOREACHINCOMELEVELINEACHTRACTFORTHEMETROPOLITAN
MINIMIZINGRUMOR AREASANALYZED4RANSPORTATIONCOSTSARECALCULATEDBASEDONSEVERALDATA
SOURCESINCLUDINGTHE#ENSUS#ENSUS4RANSPORTATION0LANNING0ACKAGE
s%NCOURAGEPUBLIC
PRIVATEPARTNERSHIPS%NGAGINGTHE ANDLOCALTRANSITDATA!DESCRIPTIONOFTHESESOURCESANDTHEMODEL
COMMUNITYASAFULLPARTNERMAKESITPOSSIBLETOBUILDTRUSTAND ISPROVIDEDIN4HE!FFORDABILITY)NDEX!.EW4OOLFOR-EASURINGTHE4RUE
ACHIEVECOMMUNITYGOALS0ARTNERINGWITHDEVELOPERSREALTORS !FFORDABILITYOFA(OUSING#HOICE"ROOKINGS)NSTITUTION5RBAN-ARKETS
ANDBUSINESSESMAYALSOLEVERAGEPRIVATEDOLLARS )NITIATIVE-ARKET)NNOVATION"RIEF*ANUARY

% 8 % # 5 4 ) 6 % 3 5 - - ! 29
4HE#ENTERFOR4RANSIT /RIENTED$EVELOPMENT
ISAPARTNERSHIPOF2ECONNECTING!MERICA
THE#ENTERFOR.EIGHBORHOOD4ECHNOLOGY
AND3TRATEGIC%CONOMICS

FXbcXe[sNXj_`e^kfe;%:%sCfj8e^\c\js:_`ZX^fs9\ib\c\p

2ECONNECTING!MERICATH3T3UITE

/AKLAND#!  
WWWRECONNECTINGAMERICAORG