Google Ordered to Stop Copyright Violations on YouTube...

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/21/technology/google-...

HOME PAGE

TODAY'S PAPER

VIDEO

MOST POPULAR

Edition: U.S. / Global

Subscribe: Digital / Home Delivery

Search All NYTimes.com

bb6bb7x

Help

Technology
WORLD AUTOS U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL JOBS REAL ESTATE

Business Day

Google Ordered to Stop Copyright Violations on YouTube

By KEVIN J. O'BRIEN Published: April 20, 2012

BERLIN In a provisional victory for musicians, filmmakers and other creators of art and entertainment, a court in Hamburg on Friday ordered Google to install filters on its YouTube service in Germany to detect and stop people from gaining access to material for which they do not own the rights. The judge, Heiner Steeneck, agreed in his ruling that Google was not directly responsible for the uploaded material. But he said the company needed to do more to

FACEBOOK TWITTER GOOGLE+ EMAIL SHARE

Related
Times Topics: Google Inc. | YouTube

PRINT REPRINTS

stop violations. This is a victory along the way to what will be a very important case, Peter Hempel, a spokesman for GEMA, the German association that levies and collects royalties on recorded media. This case, when it is eventually decided, will set a precedent for the legal responsibilities of online platform operators such as Google in Germany. The judge rejected a request by GEMA that Google sort through its entire online music archive and purge its system of all copyrighted material. Google is expected to appeal the ruling. The company, based in California, characterized the decision as a partial victory. Todays ruling confirms that YouTube is a hosting platform and cannot be obliged to control all videos uploaded to the site, Google said. The ruling is a partial success for the music industry in general, for our users as well as artists, composers, YouTube and other Web platforms in Germany. Google also said it would return to the negotiating table to resume halted talks on royalty payments. The stalemate has kept copyrighted material controlled by GEMA off YouTube since 2009, when the previous agreement expired. GEMA sued Google over 12 illegally uploaded videos in 2010. The lack of an agreement has made many popular songs and videos unavailable on YouTube in Germany. When a person calls up a copyrighted video in Germany, Google displays a disclaimer that blames GEMA: Unfortunately, this video is not available in Germany because it may contain music for which GEMA has not granted the respective music rights. In their negotiations, GEMA has been seeking as much as 0.6 euro cent per video stream from Google. Google has rejected a flat fee, instead offering a percentage of Web advertising revenue. Under the previous agreement, which ran from 2007 through mid-2009, Google paid GEMA a percentage of Web advertising revenue but declined to give GEMA user data to corroborate the amount of the payments, said Mr. Hempel, who is based in Munich. Google had also argued that it had a system in place under which copyright holders could object and ask Google to remove copyrighted material from YouTube.

Get the TimesLimited E-Mail

Subscribe to Technology RSS Feeds

Technology News
Internet Business Computing Start-Ups Companies

Bits Blog Personal Tech Pogues Posts

MOST E-MAILED

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

23

articles in the past month

bb6bb7x@yahoo.com All Recommendations

1. From the U.S., a Future Supply of Livestock for China 2. Google Ordered to Stop Copyright Violations on YouTube

In the United States, services like YouTube are protected from legal challenge by the 1998 Digital 3. Forced to Retire at 22 Millennium Copyright Act, which largely frees network operators and online Web sites from legal MORE IN TECHNOLOGY (8 OF 34 ARTICLES) liability for the content that is exchanged or displayed by users. Hillman Curtis, a Pioneer in Web Design, Dies The U.S. law has primarily benefited the computer industry and electronics companies, while at 51
Read More

1 of 2

04/21/2012 07:56 PM

Google Ordered to Stop Copyright Violations on YouTube...

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/21/technology/google-...

hurting the music and film businesses and other copyright holders by hindering their ability to sue the digital distributors of copyrighted songs, videos and films. But in Germany, that balance could eventually be tipped in favor of songwriters, artists and other creators should the Hamburg court ruling ultimately be upheld. Florian Sievers, an intellectual property lawyer in Berlin, said it would probably take years before the case would be ultimately decided by the top civil court in Germany, the Bundesgerichtshof. This ruling today was important, Mr. Sievers said. It is definitely a victory for GEMA, and one that could have huge consequences, if upheld, for digital platform operators in Germany. Robert Levine, the author of a book on the digital legal dispute between content creators and online distributors, said the German court ruling was a sensible compromise that could improve the ability of copyright owners to receive payment for their work. Since other companies, like TV and radio stations, have to make sure theyre not infringing the copyrights of others, theres no reason YouTube cant cope with this cost as well as they can, Mr. Levine said. I hope the filtering requirements arent too strict, but I think Google will be able to find a technology that both sides can live with.
A version of this article appeared in print on April 21, 2012, in The International Herald Tribune.
FACEBOOK TWITTER GOOGLE+ EMAIL SHARE

ADVERTISEMENTS

Confronting the Scars of Battle

Get 50% Off The New York Times & Free All Digital Access.

INSIDE NYTIMES.COM
MOVIES FASHION & STYLE OPINION REAL ESTATE OPINION N.Y. / REGION

Op-Ed: Deportations That Hurt Kids

The government should focus its deportation of immigrants on violent offenders, not struggling parents.

A Film Settles Accounts From the 60s

Home World U.S.

Watching Every Click You Make

N.Y. / Region Business

The City of Sky-High Rent

Op-Ed: Voting for Yesterday in France

Style Travel RSS Help Jobs

When Pineapple Races Hare, Students Lose

Autos Site Map Advertise

Technology

Science

Health

Sports

Opinion

Arts

Real Estate

2012 The New York Times Company

Privacy

Your Ad Choices

Terms of Service

Terms of Sale

Corrections

Contact Us

Work With Us

MORE IN TECHNOLOGY (8 OF 34 ARTICLES)

Hillman Curtis, a Pioneer in Web Design, Dies at 51

Read More

2 of 2

04/21/2012 07:56 PM