This file contains spreadsheets of information submitted to the CPWF by the project team, and spreadsheets that we have developed to aid our review process. Please change the 'PNX' to identify your project, e.g. Ganges Project 3 would be G3
Table of Contents
1 Title Page with Reviewers' Comments
Tab Name: G4 Title Page This page contains main project information and the contracting and inception reviewers' comments.
Table of Contents
Page 1 of 44
Gantt Chart
Tab Name: G4 Gantt Chart The Gantt Chart focuses on the activities to be carried out to complete the project. This chart contains the project schedule, work breakdown structure, i.e. activities with their milestones as the terminal elements, their start and finish dates, responsible project team member and their affiliations. For more information, visit:
Budget Summary
Tab Name: G4 $ Summary This spreadsheet shows the breakdown of the project budget per line item and per year.
Budget Comments
Tab Name: G4 $ Comments The comments worksheet is where budget explanations and details are explained.
10
11
12
Table of Contents
Page 2 of 44
RQ1: Are documents in order, provide information required, and is there consistency between them?
Documents according to Standard Clauses and Procedures 3.02 and 3.03 (see list below)
Status of changes required after resubmission [to be filled in by the reviewers], round 2
Revised proposal
KM Point Person
First submission 2011.02.28 Revised proposal 2011.04.12 First submission 2011.02.28 Updated CVs 2011.04.12
Revised as per reviewers' suggestions2011.04.12 Revised (an economist and a sociologist has been added to the IWM team) 2011.04.12 Revised by adding schedules for field visits, interaction meetings and stakeholder training/workshops for better communication strategy 2011.04.12 Revised by adding field tour please add the dates/ reports and meeting minutes deadlines for field tours and 2011.04.13 The dates/ meeting minutes deadlines for field tours and meeting minutes have been added 2011.05.15
Contact sheet
Gantt chart
Milestone plan
Page 3 of 44
Reviewer
Remarks on status (inlcude date) First submission 2011.02.28 Revised workbook 2011.04.12
Response from the Project Leader (include date) Revised by changing actors (farmers and fishermen inside polders have been added and development partners have been ommitted); and making the outcomes more specific. 2011.04.12 Revised 2011.04.12
OLM
Status of changes required after resubmission [to be filled in by the reviewers], round 2
OTIP
First submission 2011.02.28 Revised workbook 2011.04.12 First submission 2011.02.28 Revised workbook 2011.04.12
Budget
Revised to a total of $825,000 (IWM Personnel remuneration cost has been reduced by 23%) 2011.04.12
To be provided at inception report. To be provided at inception report.
Plan for baselining of outcome targets Signed MOUs corresponding to milestone plan Third party intellectual audit
Page 4 of 44
Reviewer
Status of changes required after resubmission [to be filled in by the reviewers] Budget share has been adjusted in
line with the decrease in budget ie the % split is the same but everyone has been decreased accordingly.
RQ2: Have there been changes Program in budget share going to Manager partners, and if so, are they consistent with the changes in responsibilities? RQ3: Does the budget appear consistent with the promised outputs? RQ4: Looking at the people responsible for producing the outputs, do these teams contain people with the requisite skill and is team size appropriate? RQ5: Is there a clear assignment of responsibility for producing outputs and milestones to both individuals and organizations? RQ6: Have reviewers' comments been addressed?
Raise the priority to be given to sceanrio analysis on socio-economic drivers, and make sure that the team skills are such that these drivers can be propoerly modeled. Improve cohesiveness with the rest of the BDC. Clarify who and how consideration of the policy arena and input into the policy decision making processes will take place other than through useful references to links with G3. Greater linkages requried with G5 and reconginition of key role and dependencies. Develop a communicatinons strategy involving decision makers from the outset, ideally linked with the G5 communications strategy;
Status of changes required after resubmission [to be filled in by the reviewers], round 2
Yes
MT Point Person
MT Point Person
This concern should not stand in the way of contracting, but should be fully addressed by the time of the inception report.
This concern should not stand in the way of contracting, but should be fully addressed by the time of the inception report.
Page 5 of 44
Reviewer
The proposal as currently designed appears to be around achieveable outputs wwhile identified outcomes reamin very board and unsupported. This needs to be addressed prior to contracting, trhough greater specificity in the project outcome logic model, and improved at the time of the Inception Report.
Status of changes required after resubmission [to be filled in by the reviewers], round 2
Explore links with Topic Working Groups, specially Resilience, but also Global Drivers. This includes the potential to bring in Resilience exptertise that is currently lacking in the team. Revise project to provide a more detailed literature review (including achievements from IGB Phase 1) to identify knowledge gaps and build the projects upon these gaps. Ensure that sufficient checks are incorporated to ensure WEAP model simulations are realistic and possible.
It would be useful if proponents could shed further light on the extent to which BFP results are helpful and relevant to G4.
Proponents note that WEAP model will be validated with available measured water flow data as well as the barrage releases which can be obtained from the irrigation department which is fine for the moment.
Adjust budget lines in accordance with reactions to reviewer comments (noting the desirabaility of the partnerships vs the small number of days/large team situation across IWM personnel). Is 6k for software rental appropriate? Participation in Reflection workshops is too low (10k a year). and IFWF should be 15k a year. Project budget cannot exceed $825k which is the amount specified in the orgininal invitation to submit an EOI.
Software purchased but pay developers a rental fee of approx 6k. Budget for IFWF increased to 15k a year. Budget for Reflection 5k a year which is reasonable since most team members are from Bangladesh.
Software fee Acceptable. Workshop costs Acceptable. IWM team has been increased by one person rather than being consolidated, with decrease in days for senior personnel and adjustments (decreased and increases in time) across all other IWM and other partners in response to the budget cut)
Acceptable.
Page 6 of 44
Reviewer
Status of changes required after resubmission [to be filled in by the reviewers] Checked by Boru Douthwaite as MT lead Sunday 24 April
Status of changes required after resubmission [to be filled in by the reviewers], round 2
Page 7 of 44
Project Partners and Contact Details Please remember to provide a CV for each person listed below as Annex B to your proposal. Indicate in particular who has responsibility for communications, M&E, knowledge sharing and gender analysis. Given Name Family Name Institution Role in the project Professional Email Alternate Email Work Phone Mobile Phone Fax discipline Zahirul Haque Khan IWM Project Leader Water and zhk@iwmbd.org +88-02-8827902, +88-01819432538 +88-02-8827901 Environmental +88-02-8822105Management 6,+88-02-88245901, Ext:161
Postal Address House # 496, Road # 32, New DOHS, Mohakhali Dhaka-1206 Bangladesh
Country Bangladesh
Abu Saleh
Khan
IWM
ask@iwmbd.org
+88-01819238085
+88-02-8827901
Bangladesh
Water management
A. H. M.
Kausher
IWM
ksr@iwmbd.org
+88-01714404293
+88-02-8827901
Bangladesh
Ahmed
IWM
mmz@iwmbd.org
+88-01712863539
+88-02-8827901
Bangladesh
Rubayat
Alam
IWM
Costal Morphology
rba@iwmbd.org
+88-01553113313
+88-02-8827901
Bangladesh
Md. Mobassarul
Hasan
IWM
mbh@iwmbd.org
+88-01675676429
+88-02-8827901
Bangladesh
Page 8 of 44
Institution IWM
Alternate Email
Fax +88-02-8827901
Postal Address House # 496, Road # 32, New DOHS, Mohakhali Dhaka-1206 Bangladesh
Country Bangladesh
Farhana Akhter
Kamal
IWM
+88-01199393285
+88-02-8827901
Bangladesh
IWM
Economics
mcd@iwmbd.org
+88-02-8827902
Bangladesh
Economics
Mustafa Kamal
Hassan
IWM
Consultant (Socioeconomic)
Socio-economics
Bangladesh
Economics
Bharat R.
Sharma
IWMI
b.sharma@cgiar.org
+91-1125840811/12
+91-11-25842075
India
Luna
Bharati
IWMI
Water Resources
L.bharati@cgiar.org
+94-11-2787404
+94 112786854
Sri lanka
Hydrology
Page 9 of 44
Institution IWMI
Professional Email Alternate Email discipline Technical Sciences in yann.chemin@gmail remote sensing/GIS .com applications
Work Phone
Mobile Phone
Fax
Postal Address 2/10 Gunn Drive, Estella, Wagga Wagga, NSW 2650, Australia
Country Australia
Upali
Amarasinghe
IWMI
India
Vladimir
Smakhtin
IWMI
Sri lanka
M. Shah Alam
Khan
IWFM-BUET
msalamkhan@iwfm. buet.ac.bd
A.K.M. Saiful
Islam
IWFM-BUET
akmsaifulislam@iwf m.buet.ac.bd
+88-01716449657
Climate change
Mohammad Asad
Hussain
IWFM-BUET
asadh@iwfm.buet.a c.bd
Water modelling
Page 10 of 44
Institution BWDB
Alternate Email
Work Phone
Fax
Postal Address House # 152/1, Road # 2, Mohammadi Housing Limited, Mohammadpur, Dhaka.
Country Bangladesh
Sarafat Hossain
Khan
BWDB
sarafat.khan@gmail. com
+88-01715038519
House No. D-11, Road No. 03, Banashree Project, Rampura, Dhaka1219
Bangladesh
Water management
Saleh
Ahmed
BWDB
Hydrology
Bangladesh
Water management
Page 11 of 44
Responsible for Guide and supervise the activities of all professionals, ensure the quality of research activities and outputs, responsile for identification of external drivers and devising potential scenarios, involve the caibration and validation of different models and simulation of scenarios, responsible for establishing linkage with other projects and partners, report writing, responsible for personal & project discussion and interaction meetings, dessimination of research results Quality control, supervise the praparatio of GIS maps on inundation depth, salinity zoning map and storm surge risk map, contributing the praparion of bi-annual reports, quality control of outputs
Review of literature, collection of field infromation, assessment of impact of drainage congestion, salinity intrusion in bseline condition, maintaining liason with local stakeholders, BWDB, LGED and WMA
Review of available literature on cyclone induced storm surge risk, assessment of baseline condition on storm surge inundation, assessment of impacts of climate change on storm surge risk, reporting and documentation
Carrying out sediment modellig, assessment of sedimentation rate in the peripherial rivers of the selected polders in baseline condition and for external drivers
Carrying out drainage modelling, calibration and validation of the model, Preparation of drainage and flood depth map
Page 12 of 44
Responsible for Carrying out water flow and saliinity modelling, calibration and validation of the model, Preparation of salinity zoning map
Water flow, salinity, drainage modelling for baseline condition and external drivers
Guide and supervise the assessment of cross-boundary flow, impact of land use on water resources, review of model results and reports
Identification of external drivers, development of scenarios base on external drivers, collection of data and contribution in reports for the Indian part of the Ganges basin, effect of cross-boundary flow, assessment of effect of glacier melt and precipitation on crossboundary flow due to climate change, assessment of the effect of land-use change on water resources interaction with G2 and G3 for planning of cropping system and water governance, contribution to prepare bi-annual and final reports on research findings
Page 13 of 44
Responsible for Model development calibration and validation using SWAT and WEAP, simulation of baseline conditions and climate change scenarios to assess cross-boundary flow, effects of land-use and climate change
Literature review on external drivers, climate change and water management, supervise the climate change modelling using RCM, contributing in selecting external drivers, Review of drainage, salinity, sediment and storm surge modelling results, documentation
Selection of RCMs, selection and simulation of climate change scenarios, calibration and validation of RCMs, assessment of climate change projections using RCMs for 2020, 2030, 2050, documentation
Literature review selection of climate change scenario, contribution in climate change, water flow, storm-surge and sediment modelling
Page 14 of 44
Responsible for Identification of external drivers, collection of field data and information from BWDB offices, review of results on water flow, drainage congestion, salinity intrusion and storm-surge inundation, networkin with BWDB, LGED and MoWR
Identification of external drivers, collection of field data and information from BWDB offices, review of results on water flow, drainage congestion, salinity intrusion and storm-surge inundation, networkin with BWDB, LGED and MoWR
Identification of external drivers, collection of field data and information from BWDB offices, review of results on water flow, drainage congestion, salinity intrusion and storm-surge inundation, networkin with BWDB, LGED and MoWR
Page 15 of 44
Required change in actor KAS Project strategies and Project outputs for change to happen prototypes for bringing about changes
To be able to 'use' something, people usually need to first know/ understand it, and its advantages, and/ or have developed the skills to use it, or at least to believe or trust the benefits of using it. Look at your practice change, and make explicit 2-4 KAS changes that are key to having the actor groups change their practice. How will your project contribute to make these changes happen? What are your ideas on how to help people change? Here, it may help to think what other projects have done before that has NOT worked well- what will your project do that is different? Better? Strategies can be the way (for example, codevelop instead of impose) you do things. Strategies are also the timing, methods, partnerships, language, etc. you choose to use These come straight out of your road map/ research questions and/ or your contracted deliverables. Which is (are) your project's main output (s) related to this 'line of change?
Hint: Start with this question: if this project is successful, WHO will change? What groups of people or organizations will be affected? Be realistic, and prioritize the most 'affected'. Then, try to be as specific about the actor groups as possible- in some actor groups as possible- in some cases you have the names or exact location of the actor(s)use them here.
Page 16 of 48
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Desired change in actor(s) practice Required change in actor KAS Project strategies and for change to happen prototypes for bringing about changes K : Understanding of the key Engagement of BDC partners external drivers of change Fitting out the information in A : motivation to use new timely manner knowledge and informationin their research S: Improving skill in interpreting maps, charts, data in crop planning and water resources management Project outputs Risks and Assumptions
Outcome Pathway 1
Researchers of G1, G2, G3 and - Use of data and information other projects for Improvement in resource profiling, crop planning and water governance - Development of new database on water resources
Narrative 1
1. List of key external drivers Timely and meaningful 2. Inundation Depth-Duration participation of research Map for previous, current and groups for finalizing the future condition in specific external drivers and outputs polders Availability of reliable data in 3. Isohaline and salinity zoning time map for existing and future Proper and timely input from conditions the partner organizations 4. Flow availability, weekly and seasonal (3monthly) 5. water storage volume inside the polder 6. Present and future Sedimentation 7. Storm surge risk zoning Various external drivers will cause changes on water resources and may have significant effects on flooding, submergence (drainage congestion), salinity intrusion and water availability in the different polders of the coastal zone of the Ganges basin. The list of the drivers will help the researchers to identify the major external drivers that will have significant impacts on water resources. The present and changed inundation depth-duration maps, salinity zoning maps and timeseries, flow availability, water storage volume inside the polders and sedimentation rate in the peripherial rivers will motivate them to incorporate the new knowledge into their research. They may use these data and information in resource profiling, crop planning and water governance. It will also help G1 to develop their database.
Page 17 of 48
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Desired change in actor(s) practice Required change in actor KAS Project strategies and for change to happen prototypes for bringing about changes Change in planning and design K : Acquiring new knowledge Development of operation of water, agriculture and and benefits rule/guidelines for the sluices disaster management projects; A : Encouraged to adopt Frequent interactions with the water managers of BWDB & organizations on research LGED will change their present activities and outputs practice of operation of large regulators for not only flood control but also water uses in agricultural production inside the polders; Project outputs Risks and Assumptions
Outcome Pathway 2
Plan for improvement of drainage channels, sluices and embankments water availability Isohaline map Storm surge risk map
Proper and timely upscaling and downscaling Availability of field information in time Availability of required fund for implementation
Narrative 2
The research outcomes will help these institutions to plan their future srategies to cope with the anticipated changes. They will be encouraged to adopt new water & environmental management plan and improved operation & maintainance of water structures. As a result, the agricultural production will be enhance and food security will be ensured. MoWR, MoEF, C.C. Cell Will change their views in approving their projects in water management K : Understanding of effects of external drivers on water resources A : Motivated and encouraged Workshops, seminars and interaction meetings with the policymakers and beneficiaries to disseminate the impacts of the external drivers and the benefits of the adaptation measures and policy changes; the upscaling will be facilitated by G5 Effects of external drivers on water resources Benefits of adaptation measures Proper upscaling
Outcome Pathway 3
Narrative 3
Understanding of the effects of external drivers & anticipated change of water resources and the benefits of adaptation measures will encourage these policymakers to be motivated to formulate new policies. It will also enable them for advocacy to the development partners and planning commission of Bangladesh.
Impact Narrative
Page 18 of 48
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Desired change in actor(s) practice
Required change in actor KAS Project strategies and Project outputs Risks and Assumptions for change to happen prototypes for bringing about changes Coastal polders of Bangladesh had been built in early 60s and 70s to enhance agricultural production and ensure food and livelihood security of local communities. In the recent years coastal polders have been facing multiple problems and challenges such as drainage congestions, shortage of irrigation water , deterioration of infrastructure, salinity intrusion, sedimentation of rivers, and climate chage challenges. The agricultural production as well as the local community will be affected considerably by external drivers. The present research will assess the present condition and implications of effects of external drivers on water resources. G4 will interact directly with G1, G2, G3 and G5 to provide the outputs of this research for their research activities, especially crop planning system, database development . Workshops, seminars and interaction meetings will be conducted to desseminate research outputs to implementing agencies, andpolicymakers for improvement of present policies, project plan and adaptation measures. This research project will provide plan for improvement of khal systems, sluices and embankments; and implementation of this plan will lead to social, economic and environmental improvements.
Page 19 of 48
Project Name Date No. ACTOR and how they will CHANGE
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Outcome target(s) Indicator(s) of progress towards Outcome Target(s)
What you will observe and measure to know you are moving towards the Outcome Target (other than milestones)?
Taken from the OLM: Actor group and Specific description(s) of who/ how many the practice, knowledge, attitude or skills exactly the project expects to change change (Practice and/or KAS) and by how much, by the end of the Project. There can be more than one Outcome Target per each Outcome line (first column- actor + expected final change)
1 Researchers of G1, G2, G3 and other institutions: They will be encouraged to use the data and information in their studies. They will also formulate new resource profiling, crop planning and water governance for the changed condition due to various external drivers
Data and information are used in their research New database is developed Researchers are motivated and encouraged to use new data, information and knowledge
Reflection of using new data and information in the outputs of the researchers Persuasion for technical sheets, timeseriese data and maps
Page 20 of 44
Project Name Date No. ACTOR and how they will CHANGE 2 BWDB, LGED, DAE, DMB, DOE: They will use improved water and environmental management; they will improve the operation and maintainance of water management infrastructure for enhanced agricultural production
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Outcome target(s) Improvement of drainage channels, sluices and embankments Indicator(s) of progress towards Outcome Target(s) Revised and improved implementation plan changed project documents Tools to measure progress towards Outcome Target(s) Monitoring, evaluation, personal & project discussion and interaction
3 MoWR, MoEF, C.C. Cell: Data and information are used in Understanding of effects of external changing policies drivers on water resources will enable them to change the national water policy, national water management plan, Bangladesh Climate Change Srategy and Action Plan, Disaster Management Policy. The research documents will help them to advocate the development parners for considering the changed conditions in their future projects.
Revised and changed policies, personal & project discussion and national water and crop management interaction plan and BCCSAP
Page 21 of 44
Milestone Plan
Project Name Date To be filled by PLs and Project Teams No. Milestones = your progress markers Deadline Responsible Responsible Staff Outputs required Means of verification Partner Institution Project Member by other projects
For delivery of Milestone, can only be one For delivery of Milestone, can only be one Yes or no? If yes, please specify What the project will deliver to the CPWF as evidence of completion of the Milestone
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone February 28, 2011
0.a Sites selected and partners for research and planning engagment identified and engaged 0.b Project progress reports
2011/06/30
IWM
ZHK
1.a Literature Review and synthesis report 1.b Identified external drivers
IWM
ZHK
G1, G2, G3, G5: Map of selected sites Study location MoU with partners map Workplan, data & Six-monthly reports information needed by G1, G2, G3, G5
IWM IWM
ZHK ZHK G1, G2, G3, G5: Review and priority ranking
Literature Review and synthesis report List of selected external drivers & report Data series
2012/05/30 IWM 2011-06-15 IWM 2011-12-22 2012-03-29 2012-06-21 2012-12-31 2013-03-28 201306-27 2013-12-31 201403-28
ZHK ZHK
Milestone Plan
Page 22 of 44
Project Name Date To be filled by PLs and Project Teams No. Milestones = your progress markers
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone February 28, 2011
Deadline
Responsible Responsible Staff Outputs required Means of verification Partner Institution Project Member by other projects
2.a Selected climate change models 2.b Developed calibrated and validated RCMs 2.c Baseline condition established 2.d Establishment of climate change projections: temperature, precipitation, sea level rise
2011-09-30 2012-03-31 2012-09-30 2013-03-31 2013-09-30 2014-03-30 2011/06/30 2011/12/31 2011/12/31 2012/03/31
List of selected climate change models Report on model development, calibration and validation Baseline data (generated by model) Temperature, precipitation, sea level rise data (generated by model) for climate change scenario in 2020, 2030 & 2050 Report on model development, calibration and validation Report on estimation of the effects of landuse change and population growth Report on assessment of crossboundary flow in baseline condition Report on assessment of crossboundary flow for external drivers Report on selected models
3.a Calibrated and validated SWAT and WEAP models for Ganges 2012/09/30 basin covering India and Bangladesh 3.b Estimate the effects of landuse change and population growth 2013/03/31
IWMI IWMI
BRS BRS
2012/12/31
IWMI
BRS
2013/03/31
IWMI
BRS
4.a Selected model for flooding, drainage congestion, water flow, 2011/12/31 salinity and storm surge
IWM
ZHK
Milestone Plan
Page 23 of 44
Project Name Date To be filled by PLs and Project Teams No. Milestones = your progress markers
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone February 28, 2011
Deadline
Responsible Responsible Staff Outputs required Means of verification Partner Institution Project Member by other projects IWM ZHK Data analysis report
4.b Final selection of climate and cross-boundary flow data for generating boundary for flow and salinity models
2012/03/31
4.c Developed calibrated and validated GBM basin model, SWRM 2012/02/29 and BoB model 4.d Assessed baseline water flow in coastal region of the Ganges 2012/06/30 river (southwest region of Bangladesh)
IWM IWM
ZHK ZHK G1, G2, G3: Required format and data period G1, G2, G3: Required format and data period G1, G2, G3: Required format and data period G1, G2, G3: Required format and data period G1, G2, G3: Required format and data period G1, G2, G3: Required format and data period
Report on model development, calibration and validation Water flow time-series and statistical analysis at various locations of the region Water flow time-series and statistical analysis at various locations of the region Baseline salinity zoning map
4.e Assessed water flow in coastal region of the Ganges river for external drivers
2012/12/31
IWM
ZHK
4.f Generated salinity zoning map in coastal region of the Ganges 2012/07/30 river for baseline condition (southwest region of Bangladesh)
IWM
ZHK
4.g Generated salinity zoning map in coastal region of the Ganges 2013/03/31 river for changed external drivers 4.h Generated srorm surge risk map in coastal region of the Ganges river for baseline condition 2013/09/30
IWM
ZHK
Salinity zoning map for external drivers Baseline srorm surge risk zoning map
IWM
ZHK
4.i Generated srorm surge risk map in coastal region of the Ganges river for changed external drivers
2013/12/31
IWM
ZHK
Milestone Plan
Page 24 of 44
Project Name Date To be filled by PLs and Project Teams No. Milestones = your progress markers
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone February 28, 2011
Deadline
Responsible Responsible Staff Outputs required Means of verification Partner Institution Project Member by other projects IWM ZHK G1, G2, G3: Required format and data period G1, G2, G3: Required format and data period G1, G2, G3: Required format and data period G2: location and time Report on model development, calibration and validation for the three dedicated models Inundation depth-duration map for the selected polders in baseline condition Inundation depth-duration map for the selected polders for changed external drivers Bathymetry maps in the peripherial rivers and khals for selected polders in baseline condition Bed level change maps in the peripherial rivers and khals for selected polders in baseline condition for external drivers
5.a Developed calibrated and validated dedicated drainage and morphological model for polders 3,31, and 43/2F
2012/06/30
5.b Generated inundation depth-duration map for the selected polders in baseline condition
2012/11/30
IWM
ZHK
5.c Generated inundation depth-duration map for the selected polders for external drivers
2013/03/31
IWM
ZHK
5.d Assessed sedimentation pattern in the peripherial rivers and khals for selected polders in baseline condition
2013/09/30
IWM
ZHK
5.e Assessed sedimentation pattern in the peripherial rivers and khals for selected polders for external drivers
2013/12/31
IWM
ZHK
Milestone Plan
Page 25 of 44
For Reporting
For review by BL Review of evidence of delivery of milestone and of research quality and relevance
To be assessed by Basin Leader
For review by CPWF Review of evidence of delivery of milestone and quality check of BLs review
To be assessed by CPWF
Milestone Plan
Page 26 of 44
For review by BL Review of evidence of delivery of milestone and of research quality and relevance
For review by CPWF Review of evidence of delivery of milestone and quality check of BLs review
Milestone Plan
Page 27 of 44
For review by BL Review of evidence of delivery of milestone and of research quality and relevance
For review by CPWF Review of evidence of delivery of milestone and quality check of BLs review
Milestone Plan
Page 28 of 44
For review by BL Review of evidence of delivery of milestone and of research quality and relevance
For review by CPWF Review of evidence of delivery of milestone and quality check of BLs review
Milestone Plan
Page 29 of 44
Gantt Chart
Project Name Date No. Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Activity/ Milestone Q1 Project Implementation Sites selected, partners engaged Project progress reports Sites selected and partners for research and planning engagment identified and engaged 0.b Project progress reports 0 0.1 0.2 0.a 2011 Q2 Q3 2012 Q2 Q3 2013 Q2 Q3 2014 Q2 Q3
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q1
Q4
Activities Milestones
Activities
1 Field visits, interaction meetings, data collection, literature review, driver identification, workshops and trainings 1.1 Review of the existing model studies, literature, available data 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.4 Identification of external drivers and their ranking Workshop for finalizing the external drivers Training/workshop to disseminate the research results Field visits Interaction meetings Collection and analysis of hydrological and morphologic data Literature Review and synthesis report Identified external drivers Processed field data Tour reports Meeting minutes 1.a 1.b 1.d 1.e 1.d 1.d 1.e 1.c 1.d 1.e 1.d 1.d 1.e 1.d 1.e 1.d 1.d 1.e
Milestones
Activities
2 Assessment of climate scenarios and projections 2.1 Selection of suitable climate change models 2.2 Development, calibration and validation of RCMs for baseline condition 2.3 Simulating climate change scenarios
Gantt Chart
Page 30 of 49
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Activity/ Milestone Q1 2011 Q2 Q3 2.a 2.b 2.c 2.d 2012 Q2 Q3 2013 Q2 Q3 2014 Q2 Q3
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q1
Q4
Milestones
Selectied climate change models Developed calibrated and validated RCMs Baseline condition established Establishment of climate change projections: temperature, precipitation, sea level rise
Activities
3 Assessment of cross-boundary flow, effect of landuse change and population growth 3.1 Development, calibration and validation of SWAT model for assessing baseline condition 3.2 Projection of climate change condition using SWAT model 3.2 Development, calibration and validation of WEAP model for assessing baseline condition 3.3 Projection of population growth and landuse for future condition using WEAP model 3.4 Computation of cross-boundary flow 3.a Calibrated and validated SWAT and WEAP models for Ganges basin covering India and Bangladesh 3.b Estimate the effects of land-use change and population growth 3.c Assessed cross-boundary flow in baseline condition 3.d Assessed cross-boundary flow in the Ganges for external drivers 4 Simulation of scenarios and assessment of anticipated changes on water resources 4.1 Selection of suitable models for assessment of flooding, drainage congestion, water availability, salinity and storm surge 4.2 Analysis of climate and cross-boundary flow data for model setup (present and future condition)
Milestones
Activities
Gantt Chart
Page 31 of 49
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Activity/ Milestone Q1 4.3 Development, calibration and validation of GBM basin model, SWRM and BoB model 4.4 Assessment of baseline water flow in coastal region of the Ganges river 4.5 Assessment of water flow in coastal region of the Ganges river for external drivers (scenarios) 4.6 Assessment of baseline salinity in coastal region of the Ganges river and selected polders 4.7 Assessment of salinity in coastal region of the Ganges river and selected polders for external drivers (scenarios) 4.8 Assessment of baseline storm surge risk in coastal region of the Ganges river and selected polders 4.9 Assessment of storm surge risk in coastal region of the Ganges river and selected polders for external drivers (scenarios) 2011 Q2 Q3 2012 Q2 Q3 2013 Q2 Q3 2014 Q2 Q3
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q1
Q4
Milestones
4.a Selected model for flooding, drainage congestion, water flow, salinity and storm surge 4.b Final selection of climate and cross-boundary flow data for generating boundary for flow and salinity models 4.c Developed calibrated and validated GBM basin model, SWRM and BoB model 4.d Assessed baseline water flow in coastal region of the Ganges river (southwest region of Bangladesh) 4.e Assessed water flow in coastal region of the Ganges river for external drivers 4.f Generated salinity zoning map in coastal region of the Ganges river for baseline condition (southwest region of Bangladesh)
4.a 4.b
Gantt Chart
Page 32 of 49
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Activity/ Milestone Q1 4.g Generated salinity zoning map in coastal region of the Ganges river for changed external drivers 4.h Generated srorm surge risk map in coastal region of the Ganges river for baseline condition 4.i Generated srorm surge risk map in coastal region of the Ganges river for changed external drivers 2011 Q2 Q3 2012 Q2 Q3 2013 Q2 Q3 2014 Q2 Q3
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q1 4.g
Q4
Q1
Q4
4.h 4.i
Gantt Chart
Page 33 of 49
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Activity/ Milestone Q1 2011 Q2 Q3 2012 Q2 Q3 2013 Q2 Q3 2014 Q2 Q3
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q1
Q4
Activities
5 Simulation of scenarios and assessment of anticipated changes for the selected polders (3, 31 & 43/2F) 5.1 Development, calibration and validation of dedicated drainage and morphological model for polders 3,31, and 43/2F 5.2 Assessment of flooding and drainage congestion inside the selected polders for baseline condition 5.3 Assessment of flooding and drainage congestion inside the selected polders for changed condition 5.4 Assessment of sedimentation pattern in the peripherial rivers and khals for selected polders in baseline condition 5.5 Assessment of sedimentation pattern in the peripherial rivers and khals for selected polders in changed condition
Milestones
5.a Developed calibrated and validated dedicated drainage and morphological model for polders 3,31, and 43/2F 5.b Generated inundation depth-duration map for the selected polders in baseline condition 5.c Generated inundation depth-duration map for the selected polders in changed condition 5.d Assessed sedimentation pattern in the peripherial rivers and khals for selected polders in baseline condition 5.e Assessed sedimentation pattern in the peripheral rivers and khals for selected polders in changed condition
5.a
5.e
Gantt Chart
Page 34 of 49
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone
Comment Due Date Paid on return of the signed Award Letter. These funds are to 138,511 cover the first six months activities of the Project (50% of first year budget) Paid following satisfactory assessment of progress of the first 6 138,511 months of project implementation. (50% of first year budget) Paid following satisfactory assessment of progress of the first 137,557 12 months of project implementation. (50% of second year budget) Paid following satisfactory assessment of progress of the 18 137,557 months of project implementation. (50% of second year budget) Paid following satisfactory assessment of progress of the 24 months of project implementation. The milestone plan for the 122,789 following two years of project activities must also be approved. (50% of final year budget less 10%) Paid following satisfactory assessment of progress of 30 122,789 months of project implementation. (50% of final year budget less 10%) Paid on acceptance of the Project Completion Report and an 27,286 external audit report (10% of final year budget)
6 7
Page 35 of 44
Budget Summary
(Before working on the Personnel budget cells, complete the other spreadsheet named PNXX $ Time Allocation)
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 2011 2012 2013 2014 TOTAL
1 1.1 1.1.1 1.1.2 1.1.3 1.1.4 1.1.5 1.1.6 1.2 1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.3 1.2.4 1.2.5 1.2.6 2 2.1 2.1.1 2.1.2 2.1.3 2.2 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.2.3 2.2.4 2.2.5
PERSONNEL REMUNERATION, TRAVEL AND ACCOMMODATION PERSONNEL Project Leader Principal Investigators (Int'L & Reg'l) Principal Investigators (National) Consultants Support Staff Other Project Participants TRAVEL AND ACCOMMODATION Project Leader Principal Investigators (Int'L & Reg'l) Principal Investigators (National) Consultants Support Staff Other Project Participants RESEARCH OPERATION EQUIPMENT Office equipment Laboratory equipment Field equipment CONSUMABLES General communication expenses Office supplies Laboratory supplies Field research supplies Other support services (IT services, public areas, facilities) COMMUNICATIONS Communications products Team meetings Stakeholders workshops Participation in Reflection Workshops Participation in IFWF3 and IFWF4
6,000 3,000
1,000 200
1,500 200
1,500
500
4,940
8,880
7,360
1,340
2.3 2.3.1 2.3.2 2.3.3 2.3.4 2.3.5 3 3.1 3.2 3.3 4 4.1 4.2
LUMP SUM CONTRACT AGREEMENTS FOR SPECIFIC DELIVERABLES [INSERT NAME OF SUPPLIER -
MISCELLANEOUS CONTINGENCY (% OF BUDGET) OVERHEADS IWMI (21%) [INSTITUTION (% ] [INSTITUTION (% ] [INSTITUTION (% ] [INSTITUTION (% ] 41,250 41,250 -
9,553 9,553
16,970 16,970
11,503 11,503
3,225 3,225
185,320
274,106
274,133
91,442
825,000
* The overheads of IWM, IWFM-BUET and BWDB are included in personnel costs
Budget Summary
Page 36 of 44
Budget Comments
Please provide as much information as possible to enable a good understanding of the key expenditures required.
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone
COMMENTS MATCHING FUND (if any) PERSONNEL REMUNERATION, TRAVEL AND ACCOMMODATION PERSONNEL Project Leader
1 1.1 1.1.1
Salary for analysing model results,guiding and supervising the research team, preparation of communication materials, Dissemination of the results to stakeholders, interaction meetings, quality control, report writing, attending workshops Salary for modelling, generating cross-boundary flow, assessment of effect of climate change and landuse on water flow, research quality control, interaction meetings, report writing Salary for literature review, simulation of different scenarios, report writing, interaction meetings, attending workshops Remuneration for consultancy (such as evaluating socioecomics of the local people, genrating future scenarios and so on) Salary for data collection and processing, development of models, processing of model results, preparation of communication materials, preparation of GIS maps
1.1.2
1.1.3
1.1.4
Consultants
1.1.5
Support Staff
field visits, visit to Indian part of the Ganges Basin, attending interaction meetings with different organizations, air ticket, transport, accomodation, per diem field visits, attending interaction meetings with different organizations, air ticket, transport, hotel fare, per diem, attending inception workshop field visits, visit to Indian part of the Ganges Basin, attending interaction meetings with different organizations, air ticket, transport, accomodation, per diem
1.2.2
1.2.3
Budget Comments
Page 37 of 44
2 2.1 2.1.1 2.1.2 2.1.3 2.2 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.2.3 2.2.4 2.2.5
RESEARCH OPERATION EQUIPMENT Office equipment Laboratory equipment Field equipment CONSUMABLES General communication expenses Office supplies Laboratory supplies Field research supplies Other support services (IT services, public areas, facilities)
Meetings, fax, email, telephone Sediment laboratory tests Rental for computer, printer, plotter, and database development, Research coordination and quality control, research support
COMMUNICATIONS Communications products Team meetings Stakeholders workshops Participation in Reflection Workshops Participation in IFWF3 and IFWF4 LUMP SUM CONTRACT AGREEMENTS FOR SPECIFIC DELIVERABLES [INSERT NAME OF SUPPLIER
Reports, maps, charts and other communication materials Meetings with national and international researchers Organizing workshops involving stakeholders Participation by national and international researchers Participation, air tickets, hotel fare, per diem
overhead costs for IWMI is included in this section. The overheads of IWM, IWFM-BUET and BWDB are included in personnel costs. Institutional overheads
Budget Comments
Page 38 of 44
Entries from Column S are added for reviewers' comments and to note items for clarification. There should be a clear assignment of outputs. Mark (with 1) lead and contributed outputs in columns (S) to (X)
Outputs
Total
2013
2012
2013
2014
IWM
RO
Guide and supervise the activities of all professionals, ensure the quality of research activities and outputs, responsile for identification of external drivers and devising potential scenarios, involve the caibration and validation of different models and simulation of scenarios, responsible for establishing linkage with other projects and partners, report writing, responsible for personal & project discussion and interaction meetings, dessimination of research results
55
88
88
44
275
470
25,850
41,360
41,360
20,680
129,250
1.1.2 PI (Int'l)
Bharat R. Sharma
IWMI
CGIAR
Guide and supervise the ssessment of cross-boundary floe, impact of land use on water resources, review of model results and reports Identification of external drivers, development of scenarios base on external drivers, collection of data and contribution in reports for the Indian part of the Ganges basin, effect of cross-boundary flow, assessment of effect of glacier melt and precipitation on cross- boundary flow due to climate change, assessment of the effect of land-use change on water resources interaction with G2 and G3 for planning of cropping system and water governance, contribution to prepare biannual and final reports on research findings
10
15
10
41
800
8,000
12,000
8,000
4,800
32,800
Luna Bharati
IWMI
CGIAR
15
40
20
80
650
9,750
26,000
13,000
3,250
52,000
Yann Chemin
IWMI
CGIAR
Model development calibration and validation using SWAT and WEAP, simulation of baseline conditions and climate change scenarios to assess crossboundary flow, effects of land-use and climate change
10
20
10
40
450
4,500
9,000
4,500
18,000
22,250
47,000
25,500
8,050
102,800 0 0
1.1.2 PI (Reg'l)
0 0
Page 39 of 44
No.
Personnel
Name
Institution
Type of Institution
Brief Description of Contribution to Project, as described in G1 Contacts (Project Workbook) 2011 2012
Personnel Costs
Total (US$)
Outputs
Total
2013
2012
2013
2014
1.1.3 PI (Nat'l)
IWM
RO
Quality control, supervise the praparatio of GIS maps on inundation depth, salinity zoning map and storm surge risk map, contributing the praparion of bi-annual reports, quality control of outputs
15
470
2,350
2,350
2,350
7,050
A. H. M Kausher
IWM
RO
Review of literature, collection of field infromation, assessment of impact of drainage congestion, salinity intrusion in bseline condition, maintaining liason with local stakeholders, BWDB, LGED and WMA
22
362
1,810
1,810
1,810
2,534
7,964
IWM
RO
Review of available literature on cyclone induced storm surge risk, assessment of baseline condition on storm surge inundation, assessment of impacts of climate change on storm surge risk, reporting and documentation Carrying out sediment modellig, assessment of sedimentation rate in the peripherial rivers of the selected polders in baseline condition and for external drivers Carrying out drainage modelling, calibration and validation of the model, Preparation of drainage and flood depth map Carrying out water flow and saliinity modelling, calibration and validation of the model, Preparation of salinity zoning map Water flow, salinity, drainage modelling for baseline condition and external drivers Economic analysis Literature review on external drivers, climate change and water management, supervise the climate change modelling using RCM, contributing in selecting external drivers, Review of drainage, salinity, sediment and storm surge modelling results, documentation
15
33
60
362
2,172
5,430
11,946
2,172
21,720
Rubayat Alam
IWM
RO
16
38
60
362
2,172
5,792
13,756
21,720
IWM
RO
33
51
51
22
157
287
9,471
14,637
14,637
6,314
45,059
Shume Akhter
IWM
RO
10
35
45
95
206
2,060
7,210
9,270
1,030
19,570
IWM
RO
66
88
124
22
300
206
13,596
18,128
25,544
4,532
61,800
IWM IWFM-BUET
RO RO
11 22
11 30
13 22 10 84
206 300
2,266 6,600
2,266 9,000
2,678 6,600
3,000
7,210 25,200 1
1 1 1 1
1 4
A. K. M. Saiful Islam
IWFM-BUET
RO
Selection of RCMs, selection and simulation of climate change scenarios, calibration and validation of RCMs, assessment of climate change projections using RCMs for 2020, 2030, 2050, documentation
25
30
17
79
265
6,625
7,950
4,505
1,855
20,935
Page 40 of 44
No.
Personnel
Name
Institution
Type of Institution
Brief Description of Contribution to Project, as described in G1 Contacts (Project Workbook) 2011 2012
Personnel Costs
Total (US$)
Outputs
Total
2013
2012
2013
2014
IWFM-BUET
RO
Literature review selection of climate change scenario, contribution in climate change, water flow, storm-surge and sediment modelling Identification of external drivers, collection of field data and information from BWDB offices, review of results on water flow, drainage congestion, salinity intrusion and storm-surge inundation, networkin with BWDB, LGED and MoWR
24
37
31
15
107
230
5,520
8,510
7,130
3,450
24,610
Md Mahfuzur Rahman
BWDB
GO
12
22
22
10
66
200
2,400
4,400
4,400
2,000
13,200
BWDB
GO
Identification of external drivers, collection of field data and information from BWDB offices, review of results on water flow, drainage congestion, salinity intrusion and storm-surge inundation, networkin with BWDB, LGED and MoWR
12
22
22
10
66
200
2,400
4,400
4,400
2,000
13,200
Saleh Ahmed
BWDB
GO
Identification of external drivers, collection of field data and information from BWDB offices, review of results on water flow, drainage congestion, salinity intrusion and storm-surge inundation, networkin with BWDB, LGED and MoWR
11
11
33
200
1,200
2,200
2,200
1,000
6,600
60,642
91,733
111,226
32,237
295,838 0
IWMI
CGIAR
Consultation 0 7,000 8,000 5,000 20,000 1 11 11 22 206 2,266 9,266 2,266 10,266 11,616 5,000 12,144 2,904 4,532 24,532 31,944 1 1 1 1
RO IWM
Social Consultation
Junior Researcher Junior Researcher Mid-level Researcher GIS Specialist GIS Specialist Data Analyst
IWM
RO Data preapation and processing, analysis of field data and modelling results
40
88
92
22
242
132
5,280
IWM
RO Data preparation and processing, analysis of field data and modelling results Surveying and data collection and processing GIS maps for the outputs GIS maps for the outputs Data entry, word processing, editing and formatting of reports
22
88
88
198
132
2,904
11,616
11,616
26,136
RO RO RO RO
22 22 22 10
22 22 22 30 22 22 30 44 44 10
44 110 110 80
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 3 3 1
TOTAL
136,932
225,131
213,854
75,887
651,804
93
Page 41 of 44
Institution IWM IWMI IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 1 IWM Output No. 2: Literature review IWMI IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 2 IWM Output No. 3: Climate change IWMI projections IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 3 Output No. 4: Processed primary and IWM IWMI secondary data IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 4 IWM Output No. 5: Cross-boundary flow IWMI (present and future conditions) IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 5 IWM Output No. 6: Effect of land-use change and climate change on water IWMI IWFM-BUET resources BWDB Total for Output 6 IWM Output No. 7: Flow availability IWMI (present and future conditions) IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 7 IWM Output No. 8: Salinity zoning map IWMI (present and future conditions) IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 8
Page 42 of 44
Project Name Date Output Output No. 9: Storm surge risk map (present and future conditions)
Assessment of the impact of anticipated external drivers of change on water resources of the coastal zone April 12, 2011 Institution IWM IWMI IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 9 IWM IWMI IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 10 IWM IWMI IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 11 IWM IWMI IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 12 IWM IWMI IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 13 IWM IWMI IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 14 IWM IWMI IWFM-BUET BWDB Total for Output 15 $ value of the budget % share of the budget 44550.00 5.40% 0.00% 4950.00 0.60% 0.00% 49500.00 6.00% 51975.00 6.30% 9900.00 1.20% 4125.00 0.50% 0.00% 66000.00 8.00% 13200.00 1.60% 0.00% 3300.00 0.40% 0.00% 16500.00 2.00% 36300.00 4.40% 0.00% 4950.00 0.60% 0.00% 41250.00 5.00% 12375.00 1.50% 4950.00 0.60% 0.00% 7425.00 0.90% 24750.00 3.00% 12375.00 1.50% 4950.00 0.60% 0.00% 7425.00 0.90% 24750.00 3.00% 21450.00 2.60% 9900.00 1.20% 4950.00 0.60% 4950.00 0.60% 41250.00 5.00%
Output No. 10: Flood inundation depth-duration map for polders 3, 31 and 43/2F (present and future conditions) Output No. 11: Water storage volume inside polders 3, 31 and 43/2F (present and future conditions)
Output No. 12: Sedimentation rate in peripheral rivers of polders 3, 31 and 43/2F (present and future conditions)
Output No. 13: Plan for improvement of khal system, sluices and embankments (present and future conditions) Output No. 14: Operation rules for sluices (present and future conditions)
TOTAL
825000.00
100%
Page 43 of 44
BWDB
33,000
TOTAL
825,000
100%
* IWFM-BUET and BWDB team preferred their expense for travelling and participation in IFWF3 and IFWF4 to be born by IWM due to their administrative difficulties.
Page 44 of 44