Session 2010-12
DECLARATION
I the undersigned solemnly declare that the report of the project work entitled PARTICIPATORY MONITORING AND EVALUATION
SYSTEM FOR WADI AND WATERSHED, is based my own work carried out during the course of my study under the supervision of Prof. Nandini Sen and Prof. T.Kumar.
I assert that the statements made and conclusions drawn are an outcome of the project work. I further declare that to the best of my knowledge and belief that the project report does not contain any part of any work which has been submitted for the award of any other degree/diploma/certificate in this University or any other University.
(Signature of the Candidate) Name of the Candidate Ranjan Prasad (10201040) Sri Niwas (10201054) 2010-12
CERTIFICATE BY GUIDE
This to certify that the report of the project submitted is the outcome of the project work entitled Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation System for WADI and Watershed Development Program carried out by Ranjan Prasad (10201040) & Sri Niwas (10201054) carried by under my guidance and supervision for the award of Degree in Master of Business Administration in Rural Management of KIIT School of Rural Management, KIIT University Bhubaneswar, Odisha, India. To the best of the my knowledge the report i) ii) iii) Embodies the work of the candidate him/herself, Has duly been completed, Fulfils the requirement of the ordinance relating to the MBA degree of the University and iv) Is up to the desired standard for the purpose of which is submitted.
_______________________ (Signature of the Guide) Name: Prof. Nandini Sen Prof. T. Kumar Department: KSRM, KIIT University Bhubaneswar, Odisha
The project work as mentioned above is hereby being recommended and forwarded for examination and evaluation.
Participatory
Ranjan Prasad (10201040) & Sri Niwas (10201054) has been examined by the undersigned as a part of the examination for the award of Master of Business Administration in Rural Management from KIIT School of Rural Management, KIIT University, Bhubaneswar, Odisha. Name & Signature of Internal Examiner Date: . Name & Signature External Examiner Date:
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
In preparing the report a considerable amount of thinking and informational inputs from various sources were involved. We would like to take this opportunity to duly acknowledge the contribution of a number of people without whom the MTS-II would not have been a successful exercise. This MTS is a mix of different components in which people other than the members of this project have valuably added.
We take this opportunity to thanks dignitaries of Gramin Vikas Trust, our Reporting Officer Mr. Vishv Bhushan, who really showed his special interest to make us understand about the project and guidelines for successful completion of our project and report. We would like to thank Mr. MahiPal Singh Maderna (Team Leader Watershed), Mr. Mukesh Khatariya (Team Leader WADI), Mr. Puspendra and other field staffs such as for their consistent support throughout the study period. But not least we would like to thank our MTS-II Coordinator, Prof. Prasun Kumar Das, who deputed us in Gramin Vikas Trust, Dahod (Gujarat), and our faculty guide Prof. Nandini Sen and Prof. T Kumar for their insight and valuable support.
Thank you.
Contents
CHAPTER 1: [INTRODUCTION] .............................................................................................................. 9 1.1 Background....................................................................................................................................... 10 1.1.1 Geography: ................................................................................................................................ 10 1.1.2 Social: ........................................................................................................................................ 11 1.1.3 Population: ................................................................................................................................ 11 1.1.4 Natural Resources and Livelihood ............................................................................................ 11 1.2 Objective of the study: ...................................................................................................................... 11 CHAPTER 2 : [METHODOLOGY]........................................................................................................... 12 2.1 Limitation of the study ..................................................................................................................... 12 2.2 Organization profile:......................................................................................................................... 12 2.2.1 Organizational Setup ................................................................................................................. 13 2.2.2 What they do?............................................................................................................................ 13 2.3 Objectives of GVT: .......................................................................................................................... 14 2.3.1 Main Approaches ...................................................................................................................... 14 2.3.2 They work with ......................................................................................................................... 14 2.4 The Western India Rain-fed Farming Project (WIRFP) ................................................................... 15 2.5 Project components and approaches: ............................................................................................... 15 2.5.1Component A ............................................................................................................................. 15 2.5.2Component B: ............................................................................................................................ 15 2.5.3Component C: ............................................................................................................................ 15 2.6 Project area: ...................................................................................................................................... 16 2.7 Strength of GVT ............................................................................................................................... 16 2.8 Thematic Areas: ................................................................................................................................ 17 CHAPTER 3: [WADI DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM]............................................................................. 22 3.1Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 22 3.2 Wadi System ..................................................................................................................................... 23 3.3 Wadi plot: ......................................................................................................................................... 23 3.4 Tree based farming: .......................................................................................................................... 23 3.5 Horticulture and kitchen gardening: ................................................................................................. 24 3.6 Area Selection: ................................................................................................................................. 24 3.6.1 Total area coverage for Wadi: ................................................................................................... 25 3.7 Participants: ...................................................................................................................................... 25 3.8 Implementation stage:....................................................................................................................... 25 3.9 Number of Plants Required for Wadi in different stages.................................................................. 26 3.10 Success points for project ............................................................................................................... 26 3.11 Selected Species: ............................................................................................................................ 27
3.12 Criteria for Species Selection and Yield (Estimated) ..................................................................... 27 3.13 Source of Plants:......................................................................................................................... 28 3.14 Estimated Yield from Wadi: ........................................................................................................... 28 3.15 PROJECT COMPONENTS ........................................................................................................... 29 CHAPTER 4: [IMPLEMENTATION] ....................................................................................................... 31 4.1 IMPLEMENTATION OF MONITORING SYSTEM FOR WADI PROJECT: ............................. 31 4.2 Monitoring and Evaluation Diary: .................................................................................................... 32 4.3 Findings: ........................................................................................................................................... 32 CHAPTER 5 : [WATERSHED DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM] .............................................................. 34 5.1 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 34 5.2 Major Problems of the Watershed Area: .......................................................................................... 34 5.3 Why watershed a need? .................................................................................................................... 35 5.4 WDP- Gramin Vikas Trust ............................................................................................................... 35 5.5 Selection Criteria for Watershed Development Program ................................................................. 36 5.6 Physiographic and Drainage for WDP ............................................................................................. 37 5.7 Necessity for Participatory Approach for the WDP ......................................................................... 37 5.8Purpose for WDP ............................................................................................................................... 38 5.9Formation of Village Watershed Committee (VWC) ........................................................................ 39 5.10 Activates Involved in Watershed Development Program ............................................................... 39 5.11Phases of WDP ................................................................................................................................ 39 CHAPTER 6[ BUSINESS PLAN] ............................................................................................................. 40 6.1Business Plan: .................................................................................................................................... 40 6.2FLOW CHART OF BUSINESS MOEDL ........................................................................................ 42 6.3DAIRLY AVTIVITIES ..................................................................................................................... 43 6.4TECHNICAL ANALYSIS OF BUSINESS PLAN .......................................................................... 44 6.5ASSUMPTIONS- .............................................................................................................................. 45 6.6OVERALL PROJECT COST............................................................................................................ 46 6.7PRODUCTION SHEET OF OKRA AND CLUSTER BEANS FOR TWO SEASONS .................. 47 6.8PRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................. 48 6.9SALES OF OKRA AND CLUSTER BEANS .................................................................................. 48 6.10FARMERS EXPENSE SHEET (2 SEASONS) ............................................................................. 49 6.11TRANSPORTATION COST .......................................................................................................... 49 CHAPTER 7 [ CONCLUSION] ................................................................................................................. 50 CHAPTER 8 [ANNEXURE] ...................................................................................................................... 50
List of Abbreviations
GVT-Gramin Vikas Trust IGWDP- Indo-German Watershed Development Program NABARD- National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development VWC- Village Watershed Committee SWC- Soil Water Conservation CBP- Capacity Building Phase FIP- Full Implementation Phase FSR- Feasibility Study Report AH- Agro Horticulture CCT- Continuous Contour Trench WAT- Water Absorption Trench SCT- Staggered Contour Trench AF- Afforestation DH- Dry Land Horticulture LSW- Lady Social Worker SO- Stone Outlet SO (LS) - Stone Outlet Local Stone SB- Stone Bund SB (LS) - Stone Bund (Local Stone) SGP- Stone Gully Plug FB- Field Bund DLT- Drainage Line Treatment
CHAPTER 1: [INTRODUCTION]
Many complexities attached with tribal way of life due their historical, socio-cultural and geographical situations. Some approach of development being attempted to reduce it but unfortunately not met with desired success. In this way with the help of Government and NGOs in different part of country made some demonstrative models of development, Among them the Wadi approach adopted by an NGO, BAIF Development Research Foundation (BAIF), Pune. It left a good impact in a short span of time and stands out as sustainable model for replication in other tribal areas. WADI (Small Orchard) program introduced during 80s in Vansda District in Gujrat by BAIF Development Research Foundation, Pune as comprehensive Tribal Development Program. This program is basically an agriculture based farming system in the rain fed tribal areas envisaged empowering women through community participation, initiative as processing and marketing of products. The main focus is on development of small fruit orchard (Wadi), Agriculture improvement and restoration of waste land through ecological intervention and soil and moisture conservation measures. NABARD became the nodal agency for the program and has created a dedicated fund for the project namely Tribal Development Fund (TDF). WADI in Gujarati means a small orchard covering one or two acres. This may be of mango or cashew or Amla or any fruit crop suitable to the area or combination of these tree crops, with forestry species on the periphery of the land holding. Two or more trees crops are selected in the WADI model to minimize biological and marketing risks. An one acre model of WADI accommodates around 40 fruit plants and 320 forestry plants. In five years, a poor village of 100 families gets converted into an orchard of a 100-150 acre producing hundreds of tones of fruits.
1.1 Background
Dahod along with Godhara, Kalol and Jhalod was one of the Five (Panch) Mahals of Panchmahal District. Dahod is considered as the birth place of the Mughal emperor Aurangazeb. The district came into existence in 1997 when the seven blocks of Panchmahal district namely Dahod, Garbada, Jhalod, Fatehpura, Limkheda, Dhanpur and Devgadh Baria wer carved away to form a separate unit with Dahod town as the district headquarters. Dahod is located near the boundaries of two states, Rajasthan and Maddhyapradesh.
1.1.1 Geography: Dahod is a tribal dominated district situated in the eastern part of Gujrarat. It is surrounded by Panchmahal district in the west, Banswara district of Rajasthan to the North, Jhabua District of Madhya Pradesh to the east and Vadodara district to the south. The district has an area of 3943 Sq km. There are seven talukas in the district like Dadhod, Garbada, Jhalod, Fatehpura,
10
Limkheda, Dhanpur and Devgadh Baria. These seven talukas are divided into 696 villages with 470 Gram Panchayats. 1.1.2 Social: Out of total population in this district 90 % inhabitants residing in villages. As Dahod is predominantly inhabited by tribals. The main tribal groups are Bhils, Pateliyas, Nayaks, and Rathwas. The villages are divided into different hamlets called Falia. High rates of migration, lack of awareness and social bindings are the main causes of the backward area. 1.1.3 Population: According to the 2011 census population of Dahod District is 2126558 comprising 1123279 male and 1003279 female. The district has a population density of 582 inhabitants per square kilometer. Its population growth rate over the decade 2001-2011 was 29.95 %. Dahod has sex ratio of 986 females for every 1000 males and literacy rate of 60.16% 1.1.4 Natural Resources and Livelihood The district is having rich water resources and the main rivers of the district are Anas, Machan, Khan Kali 1 and 2, Hadaf, Panam and Kabutri while river Sipi, Dausi, Wankdi and Sukhi Nafdi are tributeries of main river Hadap. Kind of soil is hard and rocky. The types of soil are clayey and sandy loam with water holding capacity of 40 to 50%. The main occupation of the district is agriculture. Rearing of small livestock is another source of income for the poor of the region where as the larger animals are reared by the comparatively better of families. Very few families have taken up micro enterprise like grocery shops, micro level trading etc.
11
CHAPTER 2 : [METHODOLOGY]
Currently Wadi and Watershed project is running in 17 village of Dahod District. Field staffs like Community Organizers (CO) and Jaankars are responsible for entire implementation, monitoring and execution on the field level activities. Jaankars and Community Organizers are headed by Program Manager in District office. Discussion with field staffs such as Jankar, APO, PO, Agriculture Officer, Engineer and Village Watershed Committee. Interviews and focused group discussion with WADI and Watershed beneficiaries. Reports and records as Secondary data from GVT and NABARD office. Initially as a pilot test, we structured a farmers diary consisting of all activities related to Wadi and Livelihood. One day training in field organized for all jaankars and COs that how to maintain the diary and if there is some lacuna then make some improvement in farmers diary for a better monitoring system. Under each Jaankar 5 farmers are selected for pilot and diary given to each for 15 days.
12
Exemption under section 197 (1) of the Income Tax Act 1961. GVT is registered under Foreign Contribution Regulation Act (FCRA), 1976, with registration no. 231660318.
2.2.1 Organizational Setup GVT is headed by a Board of Trustees, consisting of 7 (seven) Ex-Officio Members comprising of Chairman, Vice Chairman, Managing Director, Finance Director and Marketing Director of KRIBHCO and two nominees from the Department of Fertilizers, Govt. of India. Four nominated members are also on the board having expertise in the field of Agriculture and Agricultural Research, Rural Development, Non-Government/Voluntary Sector and Social Sciences.
Figure 2: Organogram
2.2.2 What they do? To Serve the local communities and bring about rural prosperity GVT has adopted a number of villages for their integrated development and has prepared a participatory action plan based on the available local resources of villages and thereby supplementing the efforts of the local bodies and Government agencies in making the village self-reliant in meeting its needs.
13
2.3.2 They work with Commitment Team Work Honesty and Integrity Innovation and Creativity Professionalism Community Participatory Approach And finally dedication & passion
14
15
Madhya Pradesh Project area District covered Cluster undertaken No. Of Core villages currently working No. Of dissemination villages No. of dissemination villages in which project is working
Source secondary data
Rajasthan Gujarat Ratlam 2 24 60 175 144 2 8 20 75 75 1 14 50 105 105 Jhabua 2 19 72 180 142
The project works in the areas of soil and water conservation, crop, tree and livestock development, micro-enterprise and social development with local government and self help groups.
Long experience in sustainable livelihoods support in the Rainfed and resource poor tribal areas.
Successful participatory models in farming system development. Experience of on & off-farm income generating activities (IGA). Experienced and qualified Field Expertise in Watershed Management, Agriculture, Livestock, SWC & WRD, Social Development and Aquaculture etc.
Programs being implemented and disseminated through a cadre of more than 6000 Jankars (trained para -professionals).
16
A. Social
Mobilization
and
Institutional
Development: GVT has developed a comprehensive and proven method for community mobilization and strengthening grass root institutions through
Self Help Group's, rapport building, participatory planning process, community problem analysis and community need analysis through PRA and IFPRA, well being ranking, village work plans, capacity building of community groups, PRIs and CBOs.
B. Livelihood and Enterprise GVT has been focusing its activities for the sustainable enhancement of livelihoods for the rural poor through farm and non-farm activities since the past one and half decades. Multispectral approaches with holistic interventions are being implemented with participation of the communities. Communities are being organized into Self Help Groups and are empowered to plan and implement various programs. The groups are able to access the project funds based on their actual needs and also identify the beneficiaries. Need based activities, costs, time-line and the beneficiaries are approved by a resolution in the Self Help Groups, then funds are accessed and utilized by self-help-groups members.
17
Practical Session of Mason skill Development training at Vocational Training Centre Dahod (Gujarat)
C. Women Empowerment and Equity: Poverty reduction and livelihood enhancement activities are being carried out with a focus on gender and equity. Women empowerment and gender sensitization process are taken up at village level. Many livelihood activities such poultry, flourmill, grocery/bangle shops, block printing work are exclusively provided to women beneficiaries and women groups. A cadre of women Jankars have been identified and are working as trained village level Para-Professional to spearhead women empowerment activities under GVT. Capacity building/training, exposure programs, women participation in Self Help Groups and other community institutions are ensured to participate in decision making process, benefit sharing and to access livelihood opportunities to improve their socio-economic status. The entire livelihood activities under Rain fed farming programs are implemented through selfhelp groups; hence the total cost of the project is utilized through the groups. This has resulted in wider opportunities for the community contribution and thus creating room for the Self Help Groups to generate more group funds through savings and credit activities. The group funds are mainly used for promoting entrepreneurial activities based on the local needs, resources, skills as well as market opportunities for various products. D. Renewable Natural Resources Management & Watershed Development:
Intensive Natural Resource Management activities are carried out through Soil & Water Conservation, Water Resource Development, Joint Forest Management, Common Property Resource Development, formation of user beneficiaries group, Watershed approach by following ridge to valley treatment measures, contour and staggered trenches, gully plugs and check dams. Besides these, community leaders are empowered through intensive training in Participatory Watershed Management to build the element of sustainability.
18
Participatory Technology Generation and Participatory Varietal Selection are initiated in collaboration with State Agriculture Universities. GVT Regularly conducts farmers managed participatory trials in agriculture crops such as, Rice, Maize, Black gram, Pigeon Pea, Chickpea, etc. and has released four varieties of crops.
Crop Demonstration plot and seed bank development F. Innovative Migrant Labor Support Programs:
Migration is an indispensable means of livelihood for many rural poor in the rain fed areas. Due to degraded, unproductive land, and lack of alternative employment opportunities, the rural communities are forced to migrate to urban areas in search of employment. GVT worked with these migrant laborers to facilitate and support them and reduce their sufferings during migration 19
and improve their livelihoods. Special training centers have been opened in different localities where migrant laborers get relevant information on their rights. Special Information and Communication Centers, PSKs (Palayan Sewa Kendras) have been opened in different cluster areas so that migrant laborers could know the employment opportunities, build legal awareness, the human rights and other laws of contract labor. Special identity cards have been issued to these migrant laborers. PSKs and MRCs (Migration Resource Centers) have been opened for a smooth functioning between their native places and the place of work. GVT is facilitating better services for migrant road construction workers at Ratlam district in Madhya Pradesh through a ADB funded pilot project. The project area is a tribal dominated area and most of the communities work as construction laborer. Awareness generation and capacity building are the key component of the project. GVT's Sustainable Livelihoods Approaches (SLAs) are centered on people and their livelihoods. GVT prioritize people's assets (tangible and intangible); their ability to withstand shocks (the vulnerability context); and policies and institutions that reflect poor people's priorities, rather than those of the elite.
H. Skill Development through Vocational Training: Vocational training means a training related to livelihood intervention and job oriented. So after the training a person has able to do the work in a proper way or income oriented. Realizing the need for enhancing vocational skills of the rural workforce, GVT has been providing skill up gradation training program for the unskilled rural workers in collaboration with Govt.,
20
Construction Industry Development Council (CIDC), New Delhi and Larsen & Turbo
Practical Training Session Ltd. The vocational skill training on Masonry, Carpentry, Plumbing, and Electrical trades were regularly conducted under the Certification of IGNOU, New Delhi and Larsen & Toubro.
Special Focus:
1. Institutional building, capacity building and diversification of Self Help Groups and Community Based Organizations. 2. Working for Gender equity and empowerment of rural women through participation in Panchayati Raj Institutions and Group activities. 3. Influencing Government Institutions in Policy making, program execution & capacity building and rendering favorable support to Self Help Group. 4. To enable poor women to make use of choices, spaces and opportunities in the economic, social and political spheres for their improved well-being.
21
3.1Introduction:
Many complexities attached with tribal way of life due their historical, socio-cultural and geographical situations. Some approach of development being attempted to reduce it but unfortunately not met with desired success. In this way with the help of Government and NGOs
in different part of country made some demonstrative models of development, Among them the Wadi approach adopted by an NGO, BAIF Development Research Foundation (BAIF), Pune. It left a good impact in a short span of time and stands out as sustainable model for replication in other tribal areas. WADI (Small Orchard) program introduced during 80s in Vansda District in Gujrat by BAIF Development Research Foundation, Pune as comprehensive Tribal Development Program. This program is basically an agriculture based farming system in the rain fed tribal areas envisaged empowering women through community participation, initiative as processing and marketing of products. The main focus is on development of small fruit orchard (Wadi), Agriculture improvement and restoration of waste land through ecological intervention and soil and moisture conservation measures. NABARD became the nodal agency for the program and has created a dedicated fund for the project namely Tribal Development Fund (TDF). WADI in Gujarati means a small orchard covering one or two acres. This may be of mango or cashew or Amla or any fruit crop suitable to the area or combination of these tree crops, with forestry species on the periphery of the land holding. Two or more trees crops are selected in the WADI model to minimize biological and marketing risks. An one acre model of WADI accommodates around 40 fruit plants and 320 forestry plants. In five years, a poor village of 100 families gets converted into an orchard of a 100-150 acre producing hundreds of tones of fruits.
22
interspaces of trees, their yield is additional and not at the expense of fruit / nut yield of the horticultural crops. The third component of the Wadi system is forestry species like Suable,Sagwan, Teak and Ber. These multipurpose trees are planted at relatively close spacing along the border of the designated Wadi plot. The shift from the rainfall-dependent single crop to at least three species in the Wadi enhances the ecological sustainability of the farm. At the same time, the product diversity in the form of food, fodder, fuel wood and small timber increases the economic sustainability of the farmer.
23
introduced under the Project. The types of fruit species are determined through feasibility study. Farmers preferences are also considered before selecting the species.
24
Serial No. 1
Border Fencing and boundaries Water Harvesting Structure Nursery and other activity
25
3920
3.7 Participants:
Small and marginal farmers of ST communities owing not more than 5 acre are eligible to participate in the program. The supports from the fund are to the extent of development of maximum one acre per family or equivalent cost. The participating families should be agree to work together with other families in groups and also provide family labor required for completion of core activity. Further they should be agreeable adopt the project discipline. The tribal participants should commit themselves to make periodic, regular contributions to create a common village fund and to constitute, at the village level, a representative body for managing the program and maintaining all the valuable assets created and generated by the project.
25
Quantity 29 11 320
Ist Batch (200 2nd Batch (400 3rd Batch ( 400 Wadi) Wadi) wadi) 5800 11600 11600 2200 4400 4400 64000 128000 128000 72000 144000 144000 7200 79200 14400 158400 14400 158400
The
project
will
include
other
income
generating
activity
such
as
horticulture/agriculture/forestry, dairy, micro enterprises etc. Social aspects such as women empowerment, health development etc have an equal bearing on the overall success of the program.
Owing the project by the participants:
The project participants should wholeheartedly own the project and contribute for the successful implementation and maintenance thereafter.
Family Labor:
It may be ensured that enough trained manpower is available end if necessary suitable orientation program could be organized to develop such skills.
Active involvement of women:
Women participation should be ensured in all the process of project implementation, as bulk of the farm related work are carried out by then, besides playing the role of transmitters of culture and values to the children.
26
Seasonality: The project activities should be undertaken keeping in view the appropriate season.
Apart from these plants GVT also facilitating the technical knowledge and support to the group to get the other crop like Vegetables, Pulses, Oilseed, Fodder cultivation and different cash crop etc. Intercropping like Maize with Ground Nut, Maize with Pulses etc are also promoted to improve the soil fertility as well as to improve the nutritional value in food. These all activities will increase the net return from one acre land cultivation. The project also facilitates the tribal community to undertake different livestock activities as their situation and capability like poultry and goatry. Training and Exposure are provided to upgrade their technical skill and capacity. The project also facilitate the group to develop it a viable unit for enhancement of their family income. In non-farm based livelihood intervention the project facilitates the process and provide technical support to the group member to undertake different nonfarm based activates specially local needs and resource based activities and further diversification and scaling up for higher income. Group members are exposed to local market and to nearest town for marketing the product either individually or through group federation.
Agro climatic conditions of the region Farmers preference Marketability of produce Possibility of value addition
Serial No.
Crops
Source 1. National Livelihoods Resource Institute (GVT) Ratlam 2.Central Horticulture Experimentation Station (ICAR), Vejalpur, Gujrat 3. Govt. of Gujrat, Horticulture Dept. 4. Private Nurseries
Mango
1. National Livelihoods Resource Institute (GVT) Ratlam 2.Central Horticulture Experimentation Station (ICAR), Pomegranate Vejalpur, Gujrat 3. Govt. of Gujrat, Horticulture Dept. 4. Private Nurseries Forestry Above same and Nursery Raising within the village
Mango 0 0 0 0 5 10 Pomegranate 0 0 0 0 5 10
28
The soil and water conservation component in the Project helps the ST farmers address threats to soil, water and related natural resources and make cost-effective changes to cropping systems, soil & moisture conservation activities including construction of farm ponds, bandhs, watershed development, grazing management, nutrient management and irrigation. The nature of the interventions are taken on the terrain and Component 2 Irrigation: The construction of water harvesting structures such as check dams in the catchment area of the village tanks allow water conservation and silt harvesting in the upper regions of the project area. While check dams and group wells are the devices to build water storage, the harvesting of this water requires a distribution and conveyance system. For the group wells and medium and large size check dams that are proposed under the Project, creation of community Lift Irrigation scheme for the distribution of water to the fields has been envisaged. The Project also support the construction of the check dams and also link it to the development of lift irrigation schemes wherever feasible to improve the productivity of the land. To enhance the water use efficiency, micro irrigation (MI) systems are promoted for ST farmers, especially those engaged in horticulture and floriculture. Component 3 - Agricultural Diversification and Wadi Development This component seeks to increase the productivity of ST farm lands. Improved crop varieties are promoted with enhanced productivity and quality. The availability of good quality saplings are also in priority areas. Agricultural diversification through the Integrated Wadi and Agricultural Diversification Project is a recent initiative applicable to small plots of land, and has been beneficial for ST farmers. The initiative, in addition to increasing the income from fruits, flowers and vegetables in several tribal pockets, also provided food security and reduced the drudgery of collecting fuel wood and fodder. Overall, after ensuring water security through water harvesting and lift irrigation, there is considerable potential for agricultural diversification as it can be implemented effectively with good returns to farmers even in small plots of land. With vary for Wadi plots located along undulating
topography with high to medium rainfall, and those plots located in plains
29
inter cropping and agricultural diversification, it is possible for the farmers to generate cash income quickly and with less risks. Component 4: Post Harvest Storage, Processing, Packaging and Marketing The aim of this component is to bring about improvements in post-harvest handling and marketing for fewer losses and reduced price fluctuations. Focus on this Project component will result in better handling, cold chain management, and packaging which will improve the quality of products when they reach the market. Reducing post-harvest losses would make agricultural diversification more attractive for small-scale farmers. Since local and regional consumption usually utilizes majority of the production, upgrading the existing traditional market chains will also be prioritized. Component 5 Community Participation through Users Groups and Self Help Groups One of the major conditions for the implementation of the proposed Project is to ensure an undertaking from the community that it will manage the Project in an independent and collective manner under user groups. This ensures future operation and maintenance responsibility by the user group and thus sustainability of the Project. The ownership of the Project by the target groups are ensured through community participation from planning stage to project implementation and by transferring the post-project management to the community institutions set up for the specific purpose. Village level institutions in the form of user groups are formed to largely focus on equity, efficiency, participation, sustainability and accountability. The project also get support from the running SHGs of savings and credit activities and capacity building. It increases the capacity of the groups credit-worthy so that they can access funds from banks and government schemes for productive purposes. The members of the SHGs are ST poor both men and women, who are below the poverty line. It provides them financial backup for investment in Agri-input investment in their crops. Component 6 - Training and Capacity Building Under the proposed project, this component is considerably strengthened and include the
capacity building of ST beneficiaries womens and participating official members. The trainings, exposure visits and demonstrations are the prime training tools that is used for ST farmers. The major areas where training are given to project participants include agriculture, natural resource management, capacity building and community-organization related procedures.
30
CHAPTER 4: [IMPLEMENTATION]
4.1 IMPLEMENTATION OF MONITORING SYSTEM FOR WADI PROJECT:
Monitoring and Reporting Structure for Wadi Project under GVT, Dahod District Gujarat....
Under Wadi Project total number of farmers are 919. On village ground level different individual farmers make a Farmers Club and above Farmers Club there is Gramin Vikas Samiti who supervise the all activities related to Wadi development. Jaankar is responsible for all activities related to Farmers. Jaankars are under APO (Assistant Program Officer) and above
31
APO there is PO (Program Officer) . These all are headed by RPO (Regional Program Officer) and he is responsible for submit the report to NABARD office. Timely supervision of project is done by NABARD officials including financial as well as physical. The reporting time varies on level to level.
making this diary is to ensure that Jaankars regularly visit the farmers field or not???. This will also ensure the suggestions and information given by Jaankar and other field staff to the Wadi beneficiaries. After visiting the Wadi farm field staffs will make a comment on farmers diary with signature and date and farmers will make a sign on field staffs diary on same with date and time. This will ensure the regular monitoring of Wadi with proper direction.
4.3 Findings:
Benefits from the Wadi for farmers. 1. Productive utilization of wasteland for Wadi purpose. 2. Conservation of natural Resource like soil and water. 3. Self Employment creation for rural people. 4. Increase in production of fruits as well as other crops. 5. Reduce in migration rate. 6. Social Status 7. Women Empowerment as well as community development through active participation in Community Development. 8. Improved health and life style. 9. Promotion of Micro Enterprises for land less people. 32
Though from Wadi, beneficiaries are not getting so much return as program is in implementation stage the produce starts coming from 5th year of plantation. Thus, this gap period is very crucial for farmers, during these period the families under Wadi need some support in the form of
employment to sustain their livelihood and basic needs. For this different activities like nursery raising, vegetable cultivation and cattle raring (goat, poultry etc..) support are being provided by GVT. They are advised to take care of Wadi properly so that this will give them a good return
after 4 to 5 years. This help them to do not migrate to urban areas. Other income activities help them to remain with family and to maintain the Wadi properly. With the help of Wadi they will get fuel, fruits, fodder and timber in future that will reduce the dependency of forest areas as forest areas are also reducing. Now the new initiative taken by the GVT to make a group of vegetables farmers which produce the vegetables and GVT will help them in Marketing. For this organization will provide them all inputs and technology as well as other requirements. Wadi plots are maintained by farmers carefully though some Wadi plots which are in first year need to fencing properly for the safety purpose from animals. Regular and proper guidelines are required much in initial stage as probability of mortality rate are higher in starting years.
33
5.1 Introduction
A Watershed can be defined as an independent hydrological unit. It is a drainage basin or catchment area of a particular stream or river. In simple terms, it refers to the entire upstream topography around a defined drainage channel which feeds water to the lands below. A watershed may vary from a few hectares to several thousands of hectares.
Watershed development refers to the conservation, regeneration, and the judicious use of human and natural (like land, water, plants, animals) resources within a particular watershed. Watershed development attempts to bring about the best possible balance in the environment between natural resources on one side and man and grazing animals on the other. It requires peoples participation because conservation is possible only through the whole hearted involvement of the entire community.
35
b) Villages with noticeable soil erosion, land degradation, resource depletion of water scarcity problems. c) Villages in the upper part of drainage systems d) The size of a watershed project should be around 1000ha (but not less than 500ha). e) Well defined watersheds with the village boundaries coinciding to the greatest extent possible with the watershed boundary. As far as possible, Watershed encompassing one village is ideal. Socio-economic characteristics. a. Predominantly poor villages. b. High proportion of ST in the total population. c. There should not be much difference in the size of the land holdings. d. Villages that have shown concern for resource conservation.
Village Commitment a) To ban clear felling of trees. b) To ban free grazing and in treated areas for protecting vegetation. c) To reduce the livestock population if in excess, and maintain the same at the carrying capacity of the watershed (number which can be supported by the watershed).
d) To ban cultivation of water intensive crops like sugarcane and banana or at least not to increase the area under such crops from the present position, e) To contribute initially four days of Shramadan on watershed treatment works by the entire village community and later, once selected for the program to contribute by way of shramadan
36
f) Promote equity for women and poor through preferential allocation of usufruct right in common lands.
g) To start and contribute a Watershed Maintenance Fund, from the second or third year onwards to maintain and upgrade the treatments and assets created under the project at a rate of Rs.100/- per land owning families. h) To take all such steps as are necessary for achieving and maintaining a sustainable production system.
i) To constitute, at the village level, a body called the Village Watershed Committee (VWC) which would have to be registered during the implementation phase within 6monthsof the commencement of the work, so that it can undertake responsibility for maintenance of all the valuable assets created and generated by the project.
The people voluntarily must come together and accept full responsibility for regenerating their environment from concept to planning, implementation, supervision, maintenance of 37
project measures and associated practices. This would imply consensus in arriving at a common understanding regarding rules and regulations and the setting up of mechanisms of organization of works, sharing of benefits and resolution of conflicts. To make the project sustainable, it is necessary for all the key actors, like the Watershed Community, NGOS, Banks, Government institutions and Technical Service
Organizations, participate actively and in close coordination with each other. Participatory watershed development must be implemented on a large enough scale in different places to create many success stories, each of which can act as nuclei, becoming a source to inspiration and demonstration for neighboring villages. This would provide a major impetus for the unfolding of peoples movement for regeneration of environment.
To develop the sustainable linkage of the village institutions with Banks and financial Institutions.
5.11Phases of WDP
Capacity Building Phase- The CBP is for one year and consist of following activities: 39
One VWC at watershed level already exists, which include the representative of Gram Panchayat, women and each hamlet. Conduct training programs for all the stake holders for effective interventions in watershed Conduct village level meeting regularly and discussing the problems, solutions and planning. Organizing exposure visits to various successful watershed projects to understand the concept of watershed, implementation process, impacts, etc Organizing cultural activities, training programs, to capacitate the community as per need and requirement as a part of watershed development activities Implementation of soil and water conservation activities with vegetative measures in micro watershed area (i.e., Contour Bunding, Continuous Contour Trenching, Afforestation, Gully plugs, Farm Bunding etc.) Full Implementation Phase: - The FIP is for 4 years and involves completion of all the work mentioned in the CBP and Feasibility Study Report (FSR).
would insists farmers with good quality of seeds resistant to pest or requires less pesticide, high yielding variety, have good quality and uniform production throughout the season. The proposed model has been selected for 350 farmers which will be given okra and cluster bean. The farmers would be asked to buy seeds of particular variety and fertilizer and pesticides would be provided from GVT under WADI development program. The area under cultivation would be 284 acres out 350acres excluding area for mango and pomegranate i.e. the thala area of 1*1 sq m. The farmers would be recommended to buy high yielding variety seeds of okra and cluster beans. The capable farmers who can buy seeds of their own can buy the recommended seeds and the farmers who dont have enough money to buy seed
should take loan from their respective SHGs. The SHG would provide loan to farmers. The Gramin Vikas Trust and SHG in association would work and provide appropriate price and help in providing market linkage. Gramin Vikas Trust will also ensure BUY BACK GURANTEE to farmers. The fund provided by NABARD would utilized in providing agri-inputs and establishing collection centre, purchasing weighing machine, crates, packaging materials, stationeries and bearing the administration cost for the whole business setup. The profit earned by the SHG would be used in wages of the workers and bearing administration cost of the collection centre. The benefits that can be harvested from such business model are as followed: a) Farmers would be able to get market linkage for their agro-produce. b) Appropriate price c) Transportation cost reduced d) Large margin of profit earned e) Fertility of the soil maintained as alternate growing of crops leguminous and nonleguminous f) SHG able to provide employment to the farmers g) Reduction in migration h) Increase in social capital and economical status of farmers. The overall project cost would be Rs. 99, 91,900 (including fixed cost). The overall production of okra and cluster beans assuming that 120 farmers/day would be providing on regular basis in two seasons would be 88.6927mt. The overall sales for two seasons would be Rs. 11431090. The overall profit earned would be Rs. 1439190. The investment per farmer for two seasons would approx. Rs.36400. The production per farmer in two seasons of okra and cluster beans would be 2054kg and 1642kg respectively. The selling 41
price per kg for okra and cluster beans is Rs 10 and Rs 12 respectively. The overall sells for both would be Rs 20540 and Rs 19704. The net profit earned in a year would be Rs 3844.
Collection Centre by SHG members (collection, sorting, grading, washing, packaging, loading)
42
6.3DAIRLY AVTIVITIES
Price Discovery at Mandi by Gvt. Member/ Jankar/ SHG member Early Morning Morning Revelation of price to Jankar at village level
Primary Processing at Collection centre by SHG members (sorting, grading, packaging, loading) Afternoon
Evening
43
Seeds both Okra/cluster bean Required kg/acre 6 Seed Required for 0.81 acre both okra and cluster beans/ farmer Rs 4.86 Cost of Okra Cost of cluster beans Rs Rs 8748 1458
44
Cost of Okra seed required for cultivation of 175 acre land Cost of Bean seed required for cultivation of 175 acre land Total cost of seeds for 1 phase Yield of okra Total overall exected production of Okra Yield of Cluster beans Total overall expected production of Cluster Bean Total Production - Technical analysis of Business Model
kg Kg Rs Q/acre Q Q/acre Q Q
6.5ASSUMPTIONSAssumption Particulars
Collection Centre Weighing Balance (capacities 300kg) Cost of 1 electronic balance Total Cost Crates (capacities 40kg)crates/cc Cost of 1 crates Total cost of Crates Stationary expenses Total stationary expense For 4 collection centres Electricity Consumption / CC/ month Total Cost for electricity for 4 CC Electricity Bill for 8months No. of Labor employed at each collection centre Wage Rs Rs Rs Rs/Centre Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs
Unit
No
4 4 5000 20000 50 420 21000 2000 8000 400 1600 12800 3 3000
45
Total no. of labor Total wage for 4 centres/month Total wage for 8months Collection Centre Rent/month Total Room rent for 4 centres Rent for the 12 months Other Expenses for 12months Total Expenses for 4 centres Cost of agri-inputs excluding seed/acre Cost of agri-inputs 350 farmers Transportation Cost(10 tonnes) Total cost of transport for 210 days
Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs Rs
12 36000 288000 2000 8000 96000 5000 20000 5000 1750000 11000 2310000
Unit
Amount
Variable Cost
Seed Cost of Okra/cluster beans (2phase) Cost of Agro-inputs Electricity Bill Rs Rs Rs 3572100 3500000 12800
46
Rs Rs Rs Rs
6.8PRODUCTION
Production Sheet
PARTICULARS(1st Phase) SOWING PERIOD 1Feb-14Mar HARVESTING PERIOD 15 31Mar 34714 Mar1Apr30Apr 69429 1Sept30Sept 77760 1May-31May 71743 1Oct-31Oct 80352 196992 1Jun-30jun 69429 245314 TOTAL
Okra
Cluster Bean
1Jul-15Aug
16Aug31Aug 38880
2nd Phase
Sowing Period HARVESTING PERIOD 15Mar31Mar 38880 1Apr30Apr 77760 1Aug31Aug 71743 1May31May 80352 1Sept30Sept 69429 1oct31oct 71743 247629 196992 Total
Cluster Beans
1Feb-14Mar
Okra
1Jun-15Jul
15Jul-31Jul 34714
48
Avg. Selling Price of Okra Avg. S.P of Cluster bean Total Sales of Okra Total Sales of cluster bean Grand Total Profit
Rs/kg Rs/kg Rs Rs Rs Rs
Sales
Particulars Cost of okra seed Cost of cluster bean seed Agri-input cost excluding seed Miscellaneous Expense(including labor cost) Total
Unit
Rs Rs Rs Rs
6.11TRANSPORTATION COST
Particulars Dahod to Surat Dahod to Mumbai Truck 6 wheeler capacity Truck 10 wheeler capacity Truck (6 wheeler) to Surat/trip Truck (10 wheeler) to Surat/trip Truck (6 wheeler) to Mumbai market/trip Truck (10 wheeler) to Mumbai Market/trip
49
CHAPTER 7 [ CONCLUSION]
Though from Wadi and Watershed beneficiaries are not getting so much return as program is in implementation stage the produce starts coming from 5th year of plantation. Thus, this gap period is very crucial for farmers, during these period the families under Wadi need some support in the form of employment to sustain their livelihood and basic needs. For this different activities like nursery raising, vegetable cultivation and cattle raring (goat, poultry etc..) support are being provided by GVT. They are advised to take care of Wadi properly so that this will give them a good return after 4 to 5 years. This help them to do not migrate to urban areas. Other income activities help them to remain with family and to maintain the Wadi properly. With the help of Wadi they will get fuel, fruits, fodder and timber in future that will reduce the dependency of forest areas as forest areas are also reducing. Now the new initiative taken by the GVT to make a group of vegetables farmers which produce the vegetables and GVT will help them in Marketing. For this organization will provide them all inputs and technology as well as other requirements.Wadi plots are maintained by farmers carefully though some Wadi plots which are in first year need to fencing properly for the safety purpose from animals. Regular and proper guidelines are required much in initial stage as probability of mortality rate are higher in starting years.
CHAPTER 8 [ANNEXURE]
1. Monitoring diary and cover pages of Wadi 2. Monitoring diary and cover pages of Watershed.
50