Sujata Gupta Principal Investment Specialist Private Sector Operations Asian Development Bank
Outline
ADBs private sector operations Private sector products Areas of operation Public private partnership
Promotes private sector development & catalyzes private financing for infrastructure & capital/financial market transactions
Provides financial support through equity investments, loans & credit enhancement products including guarantees
Shares project risks with private sector investors & financiers no government guarantees
The Private Sector Development Strategy states: The Asian experience shows that growth is the most powerful weapon in the fight against poverty.
generating employment increasing the tax base freeing government resources for social spending
Impact of PSODs interventions on poverty reduction are often indirect but significant.
Develop flexible & innovative products for the unique financing & risk mitigation needs of our clients projects in emerging markets
Equity Investments Directly or indirectly (through funds), includes preferred stock, convertible loans, & other forms of mezzanine financing Lending Long-term, dominated in international or local currency Includes corporate & project Bonds Complementary Financing Scheme B Loan Guarantees Partial Credit & Political Risk Guarantee
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
2001
Housing Finance
1%
Finance Sector
Development
1%
1%
3% Communications
1%
DMC
No. of Projects
AFG
BAN
CAM
IND
12
INO
PRC
LAO
MLD
1
IND
NEP
PAK
PHI
PHI
PRC
7
PAK NEP MLD INO LAO
SRI
THA
VIE
Total
46
ADB RDs
Public Sector
Crowding Out
Private Sector
Model (replicable) projects Pioneering projects (a first) Frontier markets Projects that influence policy, from the bottom up Projects with wider sector / economic impacts Projects with strong poverty reduction elements Projects that promote good governance ADB involvement is catalytic crowds in others Innovative structures Deepening financial & capital markets Bring private sector rigour & management skills into public sector services CPS & LTSF alignment Projects that are financially strong!
RDs/ RMs
ORM
PSOD
OGC
funding, disbursement
safeguards, CDM
TD / CTL
RSDD
too risky too unpredictable too small tariffs too low too opaque too expensive too difficult to leverage too hard to exit too many better opportunities my credit people!!!
Project preparation
insufficient master planning insufficient project preparation bidding process is crucial land issues have to be resolved law & arbitration have to be acceptable government leadership, consistency & staying power are crucial need to chose the best model projects dont be too ambitious right risk balance & government support freedom to earn a decent return
cost recovery (supplied by God) political sensitivity offtaker (status, credit, size, experience) usage conflicts deal size demand projections sector preparation regulation / oversight sponsor appetite? associated facilities interface risk land issues forex issue? environmental / social issues
Challenges
ULB deliver services - but most fiscal authority at state level (= unfunded mandate) ULB typically in charge of O&M but state agencies in charge of capital investment Unable to cover O&M costs (capital investment for expansion?)
Limited government financial resources, lack of technical expertise & inadequate tariff recovery = under funded & unsustainable sector Tariffs not based on economic cost recovery very low with no relationship to actual costs For customers water & sanitation = entitlement not payable service Unsustainably low prices +poor collection gives poor economic signals (= water wasted) Vicious cycle of lack of funds in ULB poor service delivery Recognised need for alternative finance, management & technical approaches = PPP
Population (2007) 400,000 Projections - 654,000 in 2026 & ~ 923,000 in 2031 Detailed town planning schemes in developed area Detailed Project Report (DPR) approved under JNNURM
Grants available for 70% of approved project cost of INR 1.6 bn ($ 33 m). Total cost $50 million.
Project components:
Intake well, pump house, approach bridge & pipeline work; WTP & E Point; UGSR with booster house, E-Point, WDS Headwork & ESRs; Mechanical & Electrical works at intake wells & booster houses; Raw Water Trunk Main & lines; Distribution Network; Metering
Proposed structure
SMC JNNURM GoI + GoG Grant 50%
Private Operator
Debt
Project SPV
SMC
Build network
Provide Connections
Regulation by Contract through Independent Engineer / Independent Auditor & Bid Tariff regulation committee
Lessons Learnt
Careful planning of PPP required (thorough professional FS) Strong Government commitment champion within government Revenue & cost estimates realistic & comprehensively assessed Solid legal/regulatory PPP framework desirable (though not always possible) Contracts need to be clear & complied with Procurement open, transparent & competitive Public buy-in essential public communication & consultation Ability to pay is often not an issue convert ability to willingness Needs of vulnerable groups Initial PPP transaction costs higher Project needs to be sustainable once established Combine grants, project revenues (tariff, secondary), soft loans Safeguards incorporated in design not as afterthought
Lessons Learnt
Develop technical & managerial capacity by training & hiring qualified personnel possibly from private sector Complete success in short run difficult but focus on LT sustainability
Clear economic signal for proper allocation of a scarce resource Sudden tariff increase not politically acceptable phased approach Communicate to public that water a service which costs money
Innovative financial structures may be required Financing cannot make bad project good
Donor/MDB funding available through ODA, soft / commercial loans OBA to incentivise good performance Credit enhancements, TA from MDBs Targeted subsidies for sub-components Municipal bond financing
First BOT scheme under competitive bidding in the PRC which established a new water treatment plant with a capacity of 400,000 in Chengdu, Sichuan Total cost: USD 107.6 mil Shareholders: Veolia Env 60% Marubeni Corp 40% ADB: Loan - USD 26.5 mil B loan - USD 21.5 mil
Key challenges/issues: Credibility of the offtaker & the offtake guarantee by the Chengdu government Foreign exchange risk (mismatch of debt service & local currency revenues) Completion risk of transmission connections to be constructed by Chengdu government
Concession Agreement
MUNICIPAL GOVERNMENT
PROJECT COMPANY
VIVENDI
TA for sponsor selection TA for project document preparation TA for water tariffs Financial advisor:
IMPACTS Addresses water shortage Private sector efficiencies Major investment in inland province First BOT water project model for future IWPs First BOT project without central government support Ensured cost recovery Catalysed commercial funding (B loan) Local currency participation
Thank you
For more information sgupta@adb.org Private Sector Operations ADBs India Resident Mission New Delhi