Commentary
First QUARTER 2009
ECONOMICS
Bailout-Version 2.0
Bailout! The markets abhor uncertainty. We were reminded of this in spades when our new Secretary of the Treasury, Timothy Geithner, first spoke about the bailout package on February 10th. From that day to March 10 the Dow Jones fell about 2,000 points, or 21.6%. When we finally got some details about the plan on March 23rd, the market responded with a 500 point (6.8%) rise and has since climbed back to 7,609. Will the plan work? Yes. Is it the best plan? No. It is the most politically expedient plan that will quickly help turn the economy around. However, it will come at a large future cost. Essentially, the Obama Administration, Congress and the Federal Reserve have concluded that the easiest way to solve the crisis is to reignite inflation. This will eventually cause home prices to rise and thus allow homeowners who are under water to pay off their mortgages. The banks that hold these mortgages and the investors who bought the bonds backed by these mortgages will get paid and the loans and mortgagebacked-securities (MBS) will rise in price. Mr. Geithners plan, the PPIP (Public-Private Investment Program) is a deal that Wall Street cannot pass up. Some of the details are as follows: 15% down. The Fed will provide qualified private investors with cheap government financing. These investors will buy up the toxic mortgages and MBS that are at the heart of the crisis. The private investors will get to keep 50% of the profit and the Government will keep the rest. Who is likely to be deemed qualified? It will be the largest financial firms which have a cadre of staff experienced in the mortgage securities business. But arent these the same folks who created all these securities and should have seriously known what a mess they were creating in the first place? As an example, a group of former Countrywide Financial executives has started a new firm that has been buying delinquent home mortgages that the government took over from failed banks at steep discounts to their original value. Though the thought of this new firm profiting from the very problem they helped to create is distasteful, it is this activity that will ultimately lead to stable pricing of these toxic securities.
INDEX PERFORMANCE Dow Jones Industrials Standard & Poors 500 EAFE (international stocks) Russell 2000 (small stocks) Lehman Intermediate Lehman Municipal Q109 -12.48 -10.98 -13.95 -14.95 -0.04 4.21 YTD -12.48 -10.98 -13.95 -14.95 -0.04 4.21
: : Bailout-Version 2.0
ASSET MANAGEMENT
Once the toxic junk is off of the banks books, happy days will be here again, right? The answer is yes, at least for awhile. There are two risks to investing in mortgages. First is the risk of default, that is, will the borrower remain current with payments and be able to repay the loan when due? Default risk is the current problem and stimulus and bailout funds are focused on addressing this. The second risk is the prepayment risk. Will investors get their principal back when they expect it? When rates fall, borrowers re-finance their loans, if they can, and MBS investors get back their principal sooner than they want it. Conversely, when rates rise, borrowers postpone selling or refinancing and the MBS
www.nelsonroberts.com | 650.322.4000
investors see prepayment speeds slow down. This causes MBS bond duration to extend and the market price of their bonds to fall. The longer the duration, the greater the resulting price decline will be in a rising interest rate (inflationary) market. (See the Commentary article on the bond market.) Our government is already in the process of massively expanding governmental borrowing and the money supply. It will take some time for the impact to be felt. Much of the money from the bailout is not yet in circulation as initial recipients have absorbed these funds to
Inflation Expectations
Ma rch 31 Jun e3 0
(from 0.5% to over 1.0%). We expect this figure will be over 2.5% before year end. For most of this decade, 2.5% has been the average level of expected inflation. As a result of the governments increased borrowing and money supply, inflation expectations could easily move well beyond this average.
3.0%
PePSico
2.5%
During his campaign, President Obama promised a number of significant social programs. The most costly of these likely will be the universal healthcare initiative. How this might work and what it will cost is pure speculation at this point, but when the government decides to pay for services that were not previously March 31, 2008 - March 31, 2009 available, the result is usually inflationary. When 1 0 we add the impact of keeping these campaign 31 h3 t3 c p rc Se De Ma promises to the fiscal and monetary stimulus to date, we conclude that inflation will be an enormous problem in the next few years. As Margaret Thatcher once observed the problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other peoples money. The only solution then would be to print more money, which would result in runaway inflation and a very weak dollar. We believe it unlikely that the Fed will be able to tighten fast enough to avoid a new era of inflation.
2009 Bloomberg Finance L. P.
bolster their balance sheets. Similarly, consumers are conserving funds now that the rainy day has arrived. Eventually, these increased savings will go back into circulation. When this happens the velocity of money goes up and magnifies the impact of the increased supply. When the supply of money rises, the demand for goods also rises and this increases the price of those goods. The markets are already beginning to anticipate this rising inflation (see chart) with 5 year inflation expectations doubling in the last two weeks of March
Despite our concerns, we have faith that the capital markets will moderate the actions of the government and the Fed. Over the longer term, businesses will adjust to the stimulus and the inflationary impact, just as they have during past bouts with inflation. Todays capital creation will create economic value and equity investors will be rewarded. Our efforts to research and invest in those businesses that will prosper the most in this environment are ongoing. The road will continue to be bumpy, however. In the meantime, we are enjoying the rally from the March 10th lows.
ASSET MANAGEMENT
V
value
COMMENTARY
How a bond performs can be counterintuitive. Here are some guiding principles:
Bond return is comprised of two components, interest income and the change in price The interest earned on a bond is a fixed amount The price of a bond fluctuates with changes in interest rates When interest rates go higher, bond prices go lower When interest rates go lower, bond prices go higher The longer the time until the bond matures the more sensitive the price is to a change in interest rates Expectations of higher inflation will result in higher interest rates
www.nelsonroberts.com | 650.322.4000
Firm Updates
::
After 21/2 years of outstanding performance as a member of Nelson Roberts Investment Advisors Terrence Boyd, Jr. has accepted a position with the Alameda County Retirement System. We wish Terrence success in his newest endeavor.
COMMENTARY
Notable Quotes
Unlike the banking industry, however, our people understand that without real cash profits, there can be no real cash bonuses. Pete Rose, CEO, Expeditors I have failed to become depressed in the last thirty days. Nobody has told us they are changing any of their delivery dates because of macroeconomic conditions. Tim Guertin, CEO, Varian There are a large number of business uncertainties that make the year difficult to forecast. Art Levinson, CEO, Genentech
The Nelson Roberts Investment Advisors quarterly commentary will be available electronically in future quarters. If you would like to continue to receive this piece in hard copy, please contact Tien Tran at ttran@nelsonroberts.com
www.nelsonroberts.com | 650.322.4000
Investment Team
Brooks Nelson, CFA Brian Roberts, CFA, MBA Steve Philpott, MBA Dennistoun Brown, MD Ann Oglesby, MD, MBA
WEALTH MANAGEMENT
When market participants think that current expectations are too negative, the market rallies dramatically. From the lows of early March to today, we have experienced a single session rally of nearly 500 points and an over 1,100 point rally in less than three weeks. A market rally can be swift even if the economic recovery is measured. The following chart from the State of Wisconsin Investment Board shows the dangers of being out of the stock market during these good days. Performance can be dramatically affected by missing the best days of market returns. We continue to believe that the stock market will provide superior long term returns for our investors and are committed to finding the companies that will help us get there. Investing $1,000 in S&P 500 Index 1988-2007
Minus 40 best days Minus 30 best days Minus 20 best days Minus 10 best days
Continually invested
$0
$2,000
$4,000
$6,000
$8,000
$10,000
Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. There are risks involved in investing, including possible loss of principal. This information is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute a recommendation for any investment strategy, security or product described herein. Please contact us for a complete list of portfolio holdings. For additional information on the services of Nelson Roberts Investment Advisors, or to receive our Newsletters via e-mail or be removed from our mailing list, please contact us at 650-322-4000.
1950 University Avenue, Suite 202 East Palo Alto, CA 94303 tel 650-322-4000 web www.nelsonroberts.com email invest@nelsonroberts.com