Collective Memory
Ancient issue but renewed interest Many disciplines involved
History (Nora, Novick) Sociology (Halbwachs) Psychology (Middleton) Anthropology (Cole) Communication/media studies (Schudson) Education (Wineburg, Seixas) Literature (Fussell)
Collective Memory
Little agreement on terminology (vs. study of individual memory in psychology):
Collective memory (Halbwachs) Public memory (Bodnar) Cultural memory Historical memory Historical consciousness (Seixas)
Sasha: a post-Soviet account: informed and with access to information Not recognized or transparent to Sasha: just telling us What really happened
Probably not open to revision based on disconfirming evidence A very neat narrative; impatient with ambiguity (Novick), complexity, disconfirming evidence
Triumph-over-Alien-Forces SNT
Russian version:
Russia was peaceful and not interfering with others Russia is viciously and wantonly attacked without provocation Russia almost loses everything in total defeat Through heroism and exceptionalism, and against all odds, Russia triumphs
Conclusions
Collective memory
Distributed version
Collective remembering = active agent using particular textual means (especially narratives) Textual means are often transparent Textual means belong to, and characterize a collective
Distinguishes one group from another Source of memory borders
Conclusions
Collective remembering is not analytic history