Continued..
Growth began after 1960. From 1960 to 1971 sales grew from 2.2 million new francs to 12 million new francs. (1 new franc = $ 0.2) On April 1974, Galvor was sold to Universal Electric Company for $4.5 million worth of UEs stock.
Working Style in UE
Business plan preparation annually by each operating units. Acts as Performance evaluation for unit manager
Legal
Dussex Age 32 General Accounting Parel 6 people
Chief Accountant
Vacant
Age 21
June - July
Problems
Overstaffed Language Different Accounting Principles and Standards Problems with the internal records Lack of professional knowledge and training
Question-1
What is your overall assessment of the effectiveness of Universal Electrics(UEs) planning system as it is applied to Galvor?
Continue.
Single controller-Tax specialist Heavy burden in both Time and money Initially no such system existed Lack of employee training Spending 80% of their full time in reporting. Language Problem Different Accounting method Size Vs Cost
Question-2
Identify, in as much detail as possible, all of the new management systems and techniques that UE has required Galvor to establish. In particular, trace the various steps Galvor goes through in preparing its long-range as well as annual plans.
Continue.
New Management Systems and Techniques required
Converting from simple to Centralized System structure Planning and controlling System GALVOR need to change and adopt itself to the current parent company Experts for the new subsidiary Uniform reporting and controlling system INFORMAL WAY of COMMUNICATION
Steps Galvor has gone to prepare long range as well as annual plans
January
January To April Objectives negotiated May Objectives approved by Geneva and US Headquaters
June - July
Continue..
August September October November
Meetings in Geneva for the review of the Business Plan.
Approval Of the Business Plan Requests for major Business Plan changes
Question-3
What is your evaluation of the effectiveness of the working relationships between Hennessy and UE executives in Geneva? What do you infer from the telexes about Hennessys autonomy as a managing director?
Continue
Authoritative working relationship Considerable autonomy.
Question-4
Look at the system from Galvors viewpoint. Suppose Galvor were an independent company. If you were a consultant to Galvor, how would the management planning and control practices you would recommend for the company differ from those imposed by UE?
Continue.
Simple, Informal, De-centralized Less-staff planning Proper cost allocation should be done Reporting should be done Quarterly Training in both language
Question-5
Look at the system from UEs viewpoint. How can UEs imposing planning and control practices different from those required by an independent Galvor be justified?
Continue.
Galvor
No really workable financial statements for 2 years and no reporting system Secrecy of financial reports has been maintained ( No data has been shared even to Top management appointed by UE) Financial Data Only balance sheet and statement of income once a year
UE
Monthly Reporting System Every decision is taken by Top management Monthly Reports-
Statement of preliminary net income Statement of income Balance sheet Statement of changes in retained earnings Statement of cash flow and many others
Continue..
Galvor No planning and controlling System UE Tight Planning and Controlling System
Question-6
To what extent should a large international organization, such as UE, rely on a comprehensive system of financial reporting and control to achieve its strategic objectives?
Continue.
UE has to rely on the financial reporting system. Company has number of subsidiaries along with more than 300 product lines. Do Quarterly reporting
Question-7
What specific changes, if any, would you make in UEs planning systems? In its other management systems? If the management processes need improving, how would you change them?
Continue.
The reporting norms should be made easy Forecasting should be done for a reasonable time period
Thank You.