R J Modi
09-04-07/SSA/DJ
46.3
44.18
41.1
40.0 39.6
Significant progress in clinker factor, thermal energy But no substantial improvement in electrical and CPP PLF At monthly level performance, few plants have already achieved breakthrough performance
(Mj/t
3100
3081
292 6
291 8
290 0
Electrical energy 4 (kwh/t clinker) Electrical energy 5 (kwh/t grind) CPP PLF
73.5
73.3
63.2
61.0 60.5
41.4
41.0
34.4
33.9 32.0
6 (Percent)
ACC Limited
58.3 60.0
82.1
82.5
85.0
Board Presentation
KPI wise absolute performance across plants September 2012 YTD - average ACC
performance
Quartile 4 Quartile 3
BG
Quartile 1
76.9 MK CH TK KY
60.0
BE
53.1 MK CH
DM,EN
JL
SD
BG
40.0
G2,CD
3569
MK JL W1 CH BG KY LK G1 W2
2900
G2
LK, G1
100
MK JL W1 BG CH KY W2, CD
61.0
W1
KO SD W2 G1,G2 LK
CD,TK KY
57.4
DM BG MK CH,JL EN,BE
32.0
45
MK LK W1,TK BG CD JL CH KY
85.0
ACC Limited
Why SPC?
Appraisal Costs
Prevention Costs
Failure Costs
Scrap Rework & rectification Re-inspection Downgrading Waste Failure analysis Customer complaints Warranty claims Liability Loss of goodwill
3
ACC-Q&PD,Thane
02.11-2012
Data Gathering
Flow of Process
Process Control Variables Process Control Variables Process Control Variables
Clinker
Cement
ACC-Q&PD,Thane
02.11-2012
Review Mechanism
Every Shift
Process Engineers
Process Engineer to update process control chart . They should discuss variations in control charts with the Operator during the shift and log the corrective action to be taken to eliminate assignable causes
Daily
PPE
Weekly
Head - Production
Monthly
Plant Head
Shift Operators
. The process
On daily basis review control charts and plan for effective corrective action in the process and equipments.
To hold weekly review meetings with Process engineers and operators and ensure implementation of the acion plan. Development of Control plan and Preparation of SOPs is responsibility of Production Dept.
To review progress on monthly basis with the team and present status in regional monthly review meetings.
X avg
UCL
LCL
Parameter Value
to the next shift operator explaining him about the variations and corrective action taken.
Signal
ACC-Q&PD,Thane
0.35 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19
02.11-2012
21
SCCC EE EXAMPLE
L2
L3 Raw meal preparation Raw mills Sara 2 MTBF, h 22.28 18.05 27.58 PRI, % 95.50 93.90 101.40 NAI, % 92.41 89.77 93.26 False air, % 54.00 31.00 9.00 Fan eff, % Power factor Opportunities Raise MTBF with better maintenance Monitor and raise power factor Start tracking power factor in S2 Lower false air % Monitor/ improve fan efficiency
Sara 2 Sara 2
Sara 2
Sara 3
24.28
27.04
98.68
87.71
92.06
97.50
65.00
23.60 67.50 0.85
Plant name
Clinker production Kiln Sara 2 MTBF, h 961.94 674.55 321.85 PRI, % 100.50 101.24 94.09 NAI, % 81.11 95.89 88.49 False air, % 10.82 10.11 9.30 66.91 PH1 fan eff, % Opportunities Reduce false air % Raise kiln NAI Start tracking fan efficiency in S2 (PH, Baghouse, Coal mill)
L2 - Colour coding is based on ranking across all the plants in region. Top 20% Green, Next 40% Yellow, Next 40% Red Cement grinding metrics Based on technical standards L3 Ball mills and vertical mills have different colour coding thresholds
Cement grinding Cement mills Sara 1 Sara 2 Sara 2 Sara 2 Sara 3 Power absorbed, % 82.50 84.70 83.80 81.30 80.70 MTBF, h 124.54 157.18 96.41 74.09 138.41 PRI, % 90.14 80.34 77.59 73.55 84.11 NAI, % 96.33 98.23 98.04 97.65 92.33 Power absorbed (PG/RP), % 88.00 57.90 56.90 45.20 71.00
2012 Legal entity
Opportunities Room to raise power absorption in mills and pregrinder/roller-presses Raise MTBF PRI needs to be further raised Start tracking false air and fan efficiency in S2
Units
Rank
Plant name Ambuja Nagar 1 Ambuja Nagar 2 Bhatapara 1 Bhatapara 2 Darlaghat Maratha Rabriyawas Rauri 11/26 14/26 15/26 13/26 16/26 23/26 25/26 24/26
361%
100%
0.6%
0.9% 1.3% 0.5% NA
0.3%
0.7% 0.4%
Opportunity to increase AF, AR consumption by increasing the design capacity of plants working at about 100% design capacity utilization (Ambujanagar 1) High potential savings through sourcing and increasing AR utilization in plants having good design capacities (Darlaghat, Rauri)
No open storage of clinker, gypsum and other raw material with clear demarcation for different types to avoid mixing Maintain fly ash and cement homogeneity with blending arrangements
Feeding
Monthly optimization of grinding aid dosing rate Increase degree of automation for fly ash / slag / additive feeding system using DCS to control dosing
Grinding
Optimizing mill efficiency using periodical regrading or top ups of the grinding media, longtitudinal sieving and circuit sampling every 15 days Optimizing SO3 in cement using frequent sulphation tests
Plant can improve clinker factor with little capex by improving availability and storage of raw materials Technology can be an important lever to increase clinker factor, but will need capex
Others
Ensure exhasutive SLAs between GU and mother plants to ensure quality of clinker supply Benchmarking of CF across products every quarter
Technology
Plants spend time and resources to explore / study impact of technology changes in mineral component drying, separate grinding of mineral components, blending and mixing, flyash separation
Oranization
Dedicated cross functional team with a champion on clinker factor Separate team in the plant that is focused determine and developing alternate sources of mineral components
Performance management
Review of clinker factor such as in daily operations review, weekly by Head Plant Operations, monthly by Plant Director Training calendar and rewards and recognition mechanism
Academy approach being used to drive performance improvement & capability building across plants
Key activities Dedicated COE champions 8 full time (3 for EE, 3 for CF & 2 for CPP) has been nominated as Centre of Excellence (COE) Champions to drive improvement across plants Module created for three critical areas EE, CF & CPP as guide book to help plants prepare road maps to reach aspiration values Hand books for training of young engineers and plant teams Critical performance & practice KPIs for the respective pillar at L1, L2 and L3 levels Plants to use this as a tool to identify opportunity areas
Heat Maps
COE Champions to conduct plant visit & facilitate individual plant Observe performance and practices followed through plant walkaround Conducting workshop/ training in identified improvement areas
Training centre to be established in the respective model plants (e.g., Chanda for EE & CPP, Tikaria for CF) Model plants will also set example for break through performances for the respective KPIs
ACC Limited
Difference between Q412 YTD 2012 / Q113 - Q412 Q1 201 66.3 3 61.5 63.0 63.0 62.0 My Diff Moo 0.0 60.0 n 0.5 60.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 03 0.5 5.0 0.0 0.0 0.7 0.6 64.0 64.0 62.0
NORT G1 H G2 TK
KY1
Diff 0.1 0.0 2.6 2.7 0.8 1.6 1.6 3.9 2.8 1.9 0.2 3.0 1.8
67.0
65.5
68.9
-
71.6
-
70.0
-
67
-
63.0
-
74.5
74.4 72.1 68.2 68.9 70.6
72.1
76.9 74.8 65.9 64.4 65.8
70.5
73.0 72.0 64.0 64.2 62.8 63.7
70.0
68.0 72.0 64.0 63.5 62.2 63.3
65.5
69.0 69.1 60.0 63.0 60.0
Q4 2012
Q1 2013
67.0 65.5
0.4 60.0
10
Difference between Q412 YTD 2012 / Q113 - Q412 Q1 201 3My Moo n-
201 1 -
YTD SEP -
NORT G1 H G2 TK
KY1
Q4 201 2-
Diff 3.0 0.0 0.9 2.1 1.1 6.0 3.1 0.2 1.4
46.3
47.5
44.3 44.6 50.2
47.0
42.7 43.4 45.1
44.0
42.7 42.5 43.0
42.0
42.5 42.0 42.0
40.0
40.0 40.0
0.2 40.0
44.7
49.2 55.0 49.4 -
41.1
45.0 53.1 47.2 -
40.0
39.0 50.0 47.0 42.8
39.0
38.0 47.0 46.0 41.9
38.0
40.0 40.0 40.0 -
Q4 2012
Q1 2013
46.3 44.2
0.9 39.6
11
Continuous Improvement
Breakthrough projects
Breakthrough activities
Use of micro fine fly ash from last field of ESP Beneficiation of fly ash by removing carbon particles by using
latest technology Separate grinding of fly ash / slag Transfer of surplus mills from Chanda to different locations Outsourcing of blending of grinding aid for PSC Use of a combination of accelerators and grinding aid Use of modified gypsum / low purity gypsum
ACC Limited
12
Lets work rigorously for next four days to prepare a way out for achieving our aspirations
ACC Limited