MANAGEMENT
Factor vs Reverse Factor
Wor)in( Caita!#
+ed%ct what "o%
Shareholder4s
Contrib%tion
Cash reserves of
previous "ears
Inventories
Wor) in Pro(ress
7%ndr" +ebtors
7%ndr" creditors
Provisions
Operating C"c!e 5
,(nventory :o!din( <
Receivab!e collection-
eriod
%ash C"c!e5
Operating %ycle )
Accounts *aya&le period
Operating cycle
peratin! cycle " R # $ # F # D C
$ % $a& material storage period
' % 'ork in progress holding period
F % Finished goods storage period
( % (ebtors collection period
C % Credit period availed
Oeratin( C"c!e F!ow
)he operating cycle is the time period from the arrival of stock
until receipt of cash. )he cash cycle begins when cash is paid for
materials and ends &hen cash is collected from receivables.
Oeratin( C"c!e for a
Man%fact%rin( Fir&
Cash Conversion C"c!e for a
Man%fact%rin( Fir&
*urchase of $a&
+aterials
%ale on
Credit
Cash $eceived
From Credit ,ale
&nventory
Conversion 'eriod
(vera!e
Collection 'eriod
peratin! Cycle
Cash Conversion Cycle
'ayable
Deferral *eriod
Cash -utlay
MANAGEMENT OF CA7:
CON=ER7ION C;CLE
Cash Conversion C"c!e 5 ,Oeratin( C"c!e- 6
,Acco%nts Pa"ab!e +eferra! Period-
8* Oeratin( C"c!e 5 The ti&e between orderin( of
raw &ateria!s and receivin( cash fro& credit sa!es
>* Inventor" conversion eriod 5 ti&e re0%ired to
order' rod%ce and se!! fina! rod%cts on credit
?* Avera(e co!!ection eriod 5 ti&e re0%ired to
co!!ect cash fro& credit sa!es
@* Acco%nts a"ab!e deferra! eriod 5 ti&e fir& is
ab!e to de!a" a"&ent for raw &ateria!s' wa(es
and other acco%nts
A* Cash conversion c"c!e 5 ti&e between a"&ents
for raw &ateria!s and !abo%r and cash co!!ection
fro& sa!es
OPERATING AN+ CA7: C;CLE7 FOR +OBG47
+I7TRI$BTOR7 INC*
,In this e9a&!e' we %se avera(e ba!ance b%t co%!d a!so %se
"ear6end fi(%res for inventor"' acco%nts receivab!e and acco%nts
a"ab!e-
8* Inventor" Conversion Period
6 Ass%&e that be(innin( of "ear inventor"
ba!ance was C?D and cost of (oods so!d was
C?AD
days
Sold Goods of Cost
entory AverageInv
# . ./ ./#
.#! 0
1
2 "! .! 30
./#
+
OPERATING AN+ CA7: C;CLE7 FOR
+OBG47 +I7TRI$BTOR7 INC*
>* Receivab!es Conversion Period or Avera(e Co!!ection
Period
6 Ass%&e 8DDE of sa!es are on credit
6 Ass%&e that be(innin( of "ear acco%nts
receivab!e was C>D and sa!es was CADD
days
Sales Credit
ceivables Average
1# . 4 ./#
#!! 0
1
2 .! 1! 30
./#
$e
+
OPERATING AN+ CA7: C;CLE7 FOR
+OBG47 +I7TRI$BTOR7 INC*
?* Pa"ab!es +eferra! Period
6 ass%&e be(innin( of
;ear acco%nts a"ab!e was
C>D
@* Oeratin( C"c!e
5 Inventor" Conversion Period <
Receivab!es Conversion Period
5 ?F*AD da"s < 8G*>A da"s
5 A@*>A da"s
A* Cash C"c!e 5 Oeratin( C"c!e 6 Acco%nts
Pa"ab!e +eferra! Period
5 A@*>A da"s 3 >F*DH da"s
5 >G*8G da"s
days
Sold Goods of Cost
Payables Accounts Average
!5 . 1/ ./#
.#! 0
1
2 .! 1! 30
./#
+
+otal %ost
Carr"in(
Cost
7horta(e
Cost
%urrent Asset
,Optimal-
Carr"in(
costs
and
shorta(e
costs
Goa!s of WORKING CAPITAL
MANAGEMENT
8* 7ti&%!ate sa!es b" offerin( c%sto&ers
credit ,acco%nts receivab!e- and read"
(oods for sa!e ,inventor"- Increase
Profits
>* Mini&i2e costs b" ba!ancin( rod%ction and
sa!es !eve!s thro%(h inventor" Increase
Profits
?* 7ec%re !ow cost financin( Increase Profits
@* Reach above ? (oa!s b%t never r%n o%t of
cash b" havin( eno%(h cash and
&ar)etab!e sec%rities on hand andIor b"
!i&itin( %se of short6ter& debt
Iss%es to 7t%d"#
WORKING CAPITAL
MANAGEMENT
8* What t"es and a&o%nts of c%rrent assets
sho%!d a fir& ho!d.
>* What t"es and a&o%nts of short6ter&
financin( sho%!d a fir& e&!o".
?* :ow do fir&s ens%re the" have eno%(h
cash to &eet on6(oin( ob!i(ations.
@* :ow do fir&s forecast their cash needs.
Wor)in( Caita! Po!icies and the
C%rrent Ratio
Po!icies
.
A((ressive
.
Conservative
7tate&ent of Cash F!ows
Bnderstandin( Cash F!ows
O%t!ine
Prearation of ba!ance
sheet and inco&e
state&ent fro&
transactions
Cash b%d(et
Pro For&a
.
Inco&e 7tate&ent
.
$a!ance 7heet
_
,
_
,
1
]
1
+ a t u r i t y * r i c e C u r r e n t * r i c e
C u r r e n t * r i c e
. / #
( a y s t o + a t u r i t y
Effective Interest Rate on a
7hort6ter& +isco%nt
Instr%&ent
! ! !
" / 6 +
_
,
1
]
1
0 D D !
0 D D !
. / #
D !
,
.
Aro9i&ate Ann%a! ;ie!d
7hort6ter& +isco%nt
Instr%&ent
0 0 D D !
0 D D ! D !
. / #
,
.
! ! !
" ! 6
_
,
X
+ a t u r i t y * r i c e C u r r e n t * r i c e
C u r r e n t * r i c e ( a y s t o + a t u r i t y
. / #
_
,
X
>n the case of t-bills, the approAimate yield is referred to as the bond
e=uivalent yield. )he bond e=uivalent yield on the D!-day t-bill is
sho&n belo&.
Acco%nts Receivab!e
O%t!ine
Ter&s
A C4s of credit
E9ercise U8
Invest&ent 5
C8DD'DDDN?I8>N,86*8D-5C>>'ADD
Financial Forecast
Business 'lan
&ncome or 'rofits
Collateral
)i-uidation .alue
/nforceability
)i-uidity
Credit Conditions
Credit Checks
1erms of )oan
Capital
(de-uate (mount of
)on!-1erm Funds
/specially /-uity
7C:E+BLE OF AGE OF
RECEI=A$LE7
A(e +a"s A&o%nt ,DDD- Percent of Tota!
D 3 ?D C>DD @F*A8E
?8 3 FD 8AD ?@*GGE
F8 3 MD AD 88*F?E
Over MD ?D F*MGE
Tota! C@?D 8DDE
Trade6off $etween Non6Co!!ection and 7trin(ent and
E9ensive Co!!ection Methods as we!! as Loss of C%sto&er
Goodwi!!
Inventor"
Financia! Overview of
Inventor" Mana(e&ent
7e!ection Criteria
Covenants
:pplication
:dministration
Covenants
Collateral
,tructure >ncluding
$epayment ,chedule
@uarantees
*ersonal
$elated Company
)hird *arty
:mount
PRIVATE & CONFIDENTIAL
=ictoria Main Office
8>>A +o%(!as 7treet
=ictoria' $*C*
=GW >EF
>- Achieve Wor)in( Caita! ratio &ini&%& 8*>A#8* ,C%rrent !iabi!ities to e9c!%de
+irectors Wa(es after ta9-*
?- Restrict Ann%a! Caita! E9endit%res to C8'ADD'DDD as detai!ed in Contro!!er
reared Fisca! 8MM? Caita! E9endit%re 7%&&ar"*
P!ease note Caita! E9endit%res at C8'ADD'DDD !eve! are aroved in rinci!e in
that the $an) wi!! be reviewin( the anticiated and res%!tant financin(
re0%ire&ents with "o% in the near f%t%re*
X Revised FCMA A(ree&ent*
X Ins%rance Waiver*
Given the sca!e and co&!e9it" of co&an" financia! oerations' we wo%!d
areciate the oort%nit" to revisit the need for rovision of Ann%a! A%dited "ear
end Financia! 7tate&ents*
cont4d
E9a&!e of T"ica! $an) Loan
Covenants for C!ose!" :e!d Co&an"
_
,
> n t e r e s t F e e s , a v i n g s
C e t : m o u n t B o r r o & e d
. / #
( a y s t o + a t u r i t y
+
+
_
,
1
]
1
Effective Ann%a! Interest Rate on
Re(%!ar Interest Ter& Loan
!
! ! , ! ! !
% / . 1 6
. / #
D !
+
+
_
,
1
]
1
1 " 5 1 " D ,
Effective Ann%a! Interest Rate on
+isco%nt Interest Ter& Loan
!
D 4 , 5 # .
% / . 1 D 6
. / #
D !
+
+
_
,
1
]
1
1 " 5 1 " D ,
Line of Credits
!
" ! , ! ! !
% / . / 6
. / #
4 !
+
+
_
,
1
]
1
D 4 / 1 D /
E9ercise U8
E9a&!e# A 8>D6da" C>DD'DDD !ine of credit* The !ine of credit
wo%!d have an ann%a! interest rate of AE and an ann%a!
co&&it&ent fee of 8E of the %n%sed ba!ance* +%rin( the
first FD da"s the !oan is o%tstandin(' CAD'DDD wi!! be
borrowed* +%rin( the !ast FD da"s' C8AD'DDD wi!! be
borrowed*
1!
./#
1
]
1
+
+
E9ercise U>
E9a&!e# A 8GD6da" C?DD'DDD !ine of credit* The !ine of credit
wo%!d have an ann%a! interest rate of FE and an ann%a!
co&&it&ent fee of D*AE of the %n%sed ba!ance* +%rin( the
first 8DD da"s the !oan is o%tstandin(' C8DD'DDD wi!! be
borrowed* +%rin( the !ast GD da"s' C>AD'DDD wi!! be
borrowed*
4!
./#
1
]
1
+
+
Additiona! E9ercises
D 4 6
% 1 . . " # 6
. / #
" # - !
+
_
,
1
]
1
1 6
Factorin( Receivab!es
" ! , ! ! !
% # . ! " 6
. / #
/ !
+
+
_
,
1
]
1
1 5 / 1 1 ! ! ! # ! ! ,
O;Z Cor* c%rrent!" has &onth!" receivab!es of CG?'???*
It advance factors a!! receivab!es to $an)* Receivab!es
t"ica!!" co!!ected on >A
th
of &onth' so ter& 5 >A da"s*
$an) !ends HAE of receivab!es' char(es 8*AE co&&ission
and ?E above Pri&e ,Pri&e5FE-* O;Z Cor' saves C8'DDD
a &onth on boo)6)eein( and co!!ection e9enses* What
is the net cost to O;Z.
Co&&ission 5 D*D8A N G?'??? 5 C8'>AD
7avin(s 5 6C8'DDD
Interest 5 D*DMND*HANCG?'???N,>AI?FA- 5 C?GA*>H
Tota! 5 CF?A*>H
#.D6
0/1,"DD.5#
0/.#.15
k
1#
./#
<:$
,
_
+
E9ercise U8
$ea&scoe &onth!" receivab!es of C@DD'DDD* It advance
factors a!! receivab!es to $an)* Receivab!es t"ica!!"
co!!ected at the end of each &onth' so ter& 5 8 &onth*
$an) !ends HDE of receivab!es' char(es D*AE co&&ission
and >E above Pri&e ,Pri&e5ME-* $ea&scoe' saves
C8'DDD a &onth on boo)6)eein( and co!!ection e9enses*
What is the net cost.
Co&&ission 5 D*DDA N @DD'DDD 5 C>'DDD
7avin(s 5 6C8'DDD
Interest 5 ,D*DMI8>-ND*HN@DD'DDD 5 C>'AFH
Tota! 5 C?'AFH
/."6
014!,!!!
0.,#/5
k
1
<:$
,
_
+
E9ercise U>
Ratio Ana!"sis
O%t!ine
Ratios
+% Pont Ana!"sis
Ratio Ana!"sis
G
Financial ratios sho& relationships among financial statement
accounts.
G
>nvestors predict future earnings and dividends of firm in order
to value shares
G
Creditors predict likelihood of default by firm on claim
G
+anagement decides upon investment in short and long-term
asset and establish amount and type of credit financing
Ratio Ana!"sis
,teps:
)ype:
. (ecide on ratios that are appropriate
1. Calculate ratios
.. Compare ratios to industry norms
". <valuate reasons for discrepancies
from industry norms
#. >dentify trends in ratios over time
/. <valuate reasons for trends
5. >f discrepancies arose because of
underlying problems, evaluate
alternative solutions to problems.
>. 9i=uidity
>>. :sset +anagement $atios
>>>. (ebt +anagement $atios
>H. *rofitability $atios
H. +arket Halue $atios
&&2 (sset Mana!ement Ratios
- measures ho& effectively management is utiliIing the companys assets
1urnover Measures
2 >nventory EtiliIation % ,ales?>nventory
)oo JhighK )oo Jlo&K
- loss of profitable sales - obsolescence
from stock outs - &arehousing constraints
-costs from eAcessive - financing and insurance
reordering costs are eAcessive
12 :verage Collection *eriod % $eceivablesLLLL
:verage ,ales per (ay
)oo Jlo&K )oo JhighK
- loss of profitable sales from - bad debt
tight credit terms - financing costs
.2 FiAed :sset EtiliIation % ,ales?Cet FiAed :ssets
"2 )otal :sset EtiliIation % ,ales?)otal :ssets
&&&2 Debt Mana!ement 3)evera!e4 Ratios
- measures eAtent to &hich non-e=uity financing is used
2 )otal (ebt?)otal :ssets
12 )otal (ebt?)otal <=uity
.2 9ong-term (ebt?Common <=uity
- measures ability of company to meet fiAed financing charges &ith operating
income
2 )imes >nterest <arned
% <arnings Before >nterest and )aAes 3<B>)2
>nterest Charges
12 FiAed Charge Coverage $atio
)evera!e
- creditors &ill charge higher financing rates to firms &hich are highly
levered
2 @reater likelihood of bankruptcy because of added
interest costs
12 9oss of creditors upon li=uidation of firm is likely higher because
amount of debt increases but li=uidation value of assets does not.
.2 Common shareholders have smaller stake in firm that is financed by
debt rather than solely by e=uity - may lead them to misappropriate firm
assets or take eAcessive risks especially &here firm is nearing
bankruptcy.
if firms are too highly leveraged, they may be unable to obtain
financing from creditors.
(dvanta!es to %hareholders from )evera!e
2 leverage allo&s firms to eAperience higher returns in
JgoodK times 3but lo&er returns in JbadK times2 -
generally eApected <*, increases to compensate for
greater risk &ith higher leverage
12 eAisting shareholders can maintain control by
borro&ing debt rather than issuing ne& common shares
esp. important for shareholders &ho are also managers -
leverage buy outs
.2 taA advantages - interest charges are deductible from
taAable income &hile dividends are not
&.2 'rofitability Ratios
- measure combined effect of li=uidity, asset management and leverage on
operating results
2 @ross *rofit +argin on ,ales % @ross +argin?,ales
12 Cet *rofit +argin on ,ales % Cet >ncome :vailable to
Common ,hareholders? ,ales
.2 Basic <arning *o&er $atio % <B>)?)otal :ssets
"2 $eturn on )otal :ssets % Cet >ncome :vailable to
Common ,hareholders? )otal :ssets
#2 $eturn on <=uity % Cet >ncome?Common <=uity
- *rofitability analysis often focuses on means to improve the gross margin
through ne& pricing policies, changes in product lines and methods to reduce
the cost of goods sold.
.2 Market .alue Ratios
- measures the stock markets evaluation of li=uidity, asset
management, debt management and profitability
2 *rice <arnings $atio % *rice per share?<*,
12 +arket?Book $atio % ,tock *rice ?
Book Halue *er ,hare
Book Halue *er ,hare % ,hareholders
Common <=uity ? ,hares -utstanding
The +%ont e0%ation
1
]
1
Equity
ebt
! t turnover total asse in t m net profi "#E
nover asset tur in ! total t m net profi "#A
Assets
Sales
Sales
$et Income
Sales
Sales
Assets
$et Income
"#A
Assets
$et Income
"#A
Equity
ebt
"#A
Equity
Assets
"#A "#E
Equity
Assets
Assets
$et Income
Assets
Assets
Equity
$et Income
"#E
Equity
$et Income
"#E
arg
arg
(uto
'arts
Buildin!
Materials
5old and
'recious
Metals
Food and
Bevera!e
1echnolo!y 'ipelines
)i-uidity
Current 1./D .D/ !.5 1.5/ 1."5 !.5
Muick ./! .! D./5 .#5 .41 !.#
(sset
Mana!ement
(ays ,ales
-utstanding
"".5 #D.D 1.1 .#.D 5!./ "/.#
>nventory
)urnover
5.// .# 5.5/ .! .".#1 1/.11
9ong-term
:sset $atio
#.!. ..4" !.#D /."! D.4# !.4D
Debt
Mana!ement
)otal (ebt to
)otal :ssets
!..! !../ !.1# !."D !..# !./5
)imes >nterest
<arned
/1..5 4." 35/.!42 D.!! 1...# .D5
:verage >ndustry $atios
Avera(e Ind%str" Ratios ,Contin%ed-
(uto
'arts
Buildin!
Materials
5old and
'recious
Metals
Food and
Bevera!e
1echnolo!y 'ipelines
'rofitability
+argin 362
#.D/
#.15
351.52
#.D/
31.!2
#.!.
$eturn on
:ssets 362
4../
5.14
3D.#12
5./
!.!D
/.4
$eturn on
<=uity 362
".1D
.!/
31#./42
1.!D
3!.4.2
1.14
Market
:verage *?<
4.5
1D.4
#!.1
/.1
1/.!
#.
(ividend Field
362
.1"
!.5
!.1#
.51
!..D
".1!
,ource: >ndustry $eports 3Nuly #, DD42 )he Financial *ost
(atagroup.
Castone Case# Wor)in(
Caita! and Financia!
7tate&ent Ana!"sis
$ea&scoe Canada
Castone Case# Wor)in(
Caita! and Financia!
7tate&ent Ana!"sis
)he chart belo& sho&s the price of the stock of Beamscope, a
distributor of electronics products in Canada and ,outh
:merica, from DD5 to 1!!.
$ea&scoe4s Wor)in( Caita!
Mana(e&ent
$atio DD/ DD5 DD4 DDD 1!!!
Current .D. ./ .5! ..# .!
Muick ..4 .!/ .!/ !.#4 !.""
:verage Collection *eriod /1 4" 4! #" #!
(ays >nventory 1D "/ #. /" //
(ays *ayable #. 5 /D "5 "D
-perating Cycle D . .. 4 #
Cash Cycle .4 /! /" 5 /5
)hree maOor problems occurred &ith &orking capital in DD5-DD4:
. Company couldnt cope &ith gro&th in managing inventory P :$
1. Company didnt properly process goods returned from customers.
.. Company didnt have an ade=uate returns policies &ith suppliers.
$ea&scoe4s +ebt Mana(e&ent
$atio DD/ DD5 DD4 DDD 1!!!
)otal (ebt?)otal :ssets 0,!9 0,": 0,"# 0,#1 0,##
)otal (ebt?<=uity n.a. 0,!3 0,33 1,2: 1,3#
,hort-term (ebt?<=uity n,a, 0,23 0,19 1,0# 1,38
)imes >nterest <arned n.a. :,8: 9,"0 -",2! -2,82
>ncreased (ebt 9evels $elative )o <=uity
. >ncrease in :ccounts $eceivable and >nventory needed to be financed.
1. Company &rote off Encollectible :ccounts $eceivable and -vervalued
>nventory in DDD.
9o&er (ebt ,ervicing :bility because of higher interest and lo&er profits.
$ea&scoe4s Profitabi!it"
$atio DD/ DD5 DD4 DDD 1!!!
;ross Pro4it <ar$in :,9A :,8A :,2A 2,!A !,1A
=et Pro4it <ar$in 2,0A 1,"A 1,#A -3,!A -2,9A
,ales?)otal :ssets 3,8 2,3 2,! 2," 2,!
$eturn on :ssets 5.16 3,"A ".6 -4.#6 -8,#A
)otal :ssets?<=uity 1,:3 2,!" 2,3" 3,!1 !,3"
$eturn on <=uity ..D6 9,8A D./6 -1D.!6 -1D.6
Company became very unprofitable in DDD
. Both gross and net profit margins shrunk because of &riteoffs in that year.
1. (u*ont analysis reveals that the lack of operating profitability after DD4 is
maOor reason for lo& return.
Three Methods of Lendin(
,Tondon Co&&ittee- ,8-
>
nd
Method of Lendin( ,>-
%RE"(+ <O=(+OR(=9
ARRA=9E<E=+ ,%<A-
CM( data is a tool used by the bankers to assess the
re-uirement of workin! capital2 &t is divided into six parts:
Form & 'articulars of /xistin! 6 'roposed )imits
Form && peratin! %tatement
Form &&& (nalysis of Balance %heet
Form &. Comparative %tatement of Current (ssets 6
Current )iabilities
Form . Computation of M'BF
Form .& Funds Flow %tatement