2. Markets and Competitive Space 3. Strategic Market Segmentation 4. Strategic Customer Relationship Management 5. Capabilities for Learning about Customers and Markets 6. Market Targeting and Strategic Positioning 7. Strategic Relationships 8. Innovation and New Product Strategy 9. Strategic Brand Management 10. Value Chain Strategy 11. Pricing Strategy 12. Promotion, Advertising and Sales Promotion Strategies 13. Sales Force, Internet, and Direct Marketing Strategies 14. Designing Market-Driven Organizations 15. Marketing Strategy Implementation And Control
Strategic Marketing
CHAPTER 6
A. Market Targeting and Strategic Positioning
Market Targeting Strategy Targeting in Different Market Environments Positioning Strategy Developing the Positioning Strategy Determining Positioning Effectiveness McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright 2009 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. 6-3 A. MARKET TARGETING STRATEGY
The Marketing Targeting Decision Identities the People or Organizations in a Product-Market Toward Which a Firm Directs Its Positioning Strategy Guided by an understanding of:
The product-market Its buyers Firms capabilities resources Competition -Targeting and positioning strategies consists of: 1.Identifying and analyzing the segments in a product-market, 2.Deciding which segments to target, 3.Desiging and implementing a positioning strategy foe each target. 6-4 1.Targeting Alternatives -The targeting decision determines which customer group the organization will serve. A specific marketing effort(positioning strategy) is directed toward each target that management decides to serve. -Market targeting approaches fall into major categories: i. Segment targeting when segments are clearly defined, ii. Targeting based on product differentiating. As shown by exhibit 6.1,segment targeting ranges from a single segment to targeting all or most of the segments in the market. -Factors influencing targeting decisions- several factors may influence the choice of the targeting strategy: i. Stage of product-market maturity. ii. Extent of diversity in buyer value requirements. iii. Industry structure. iv. The firms capabilities and resources. v. Opportunities for gaining competitive advantage. 6-5 B. Targeting In Different Market Environments -Four lifecycle stages illustrate the range of product market structures: 1.Emerging-product market which are newly formed are categorized as emerging, and are created by factors such as a new technology, the changing needs of buyers, and the identification of unmet needs by suppliers. -There are two type of emerging markets: i. A totally new product market- the emerging market is formed by people/organizations whose needs and wants have not been satisfied by available product. ii. A new product technology entering an existing product market- the market entry provides an alternative value proposition to buyers in an existing market. 6-6 -consideration for emerging markets: i. Buyer Diversity Segmentation limited due to similarity of buyers preferences ii. Industry Structure Typically small new organizations Limited access to resources iii. Capabilities and Resources Unique benefit (differentiation) strategy rather than low-cost First-mover advantage iv. Targeting Strategy Single target or a few broad segments 6-7 2. Growing-these product-markets are experiencing rapid growth. -Identifying customer groups with similar value requirements improves targeting, and experience with the product, process, and materials technologies leads to greater efficiency and increased standardization. -analysis of the characteristics and preferences of existing buyers yields useful guidelines for estimating market potential. i. Product-Market structure-high growth markets are very attractive, and that early entry offers important competitive advantage. ii. Capabilities and Resources-The firms competing in growth markets are likely to follow one of these strategies: a. Pursuit of a market leadership strategy, b. Follow very selective targeting and positioning strategies.
iii. Targeting Strategy Three possible strategies 1. Extensive market coverage by firms with established businesses in related markets 2. Selective targeting by firms with diversified product portfolios 3. Very focused targeting strategies by small organizations serving one or a few market segments. 6-8 3. Mature- the product markets are shifting from growth to maturity, as indicated by the product lifecycle of the products. a. Buyer Diversity Segmentation essential for competitive advantage b. Product market/Industry Structure Intense competition for market share, Emphasis on cost and service, and increases in the role and importance of value chain strategies. c. Capabilities and Resources Managements objectives: cost reduction, selective targeting, product differentiation d. Targeting Strategy Deciding which segment to serve Firms pursuing extensive targeting strategies may decide to exit from certain segments
6-9 4. Growth Market There are two options of consideration- a. Global Reach and Standardization Identify market segments that span global markets and serve these needs with global positioning strategies b. Local Adaptation Consider requirements of domestic buyers Buyers needs and preferences affected by social, political, cultural, economic, and language differences Targeting Strategy Targeting a single country, regional (multinational) targeting, or global targeting 6-10 Market Targeting and Strategic Positioning
* Core dimensions of market-driven strategy: deciding which buyers to target and how to position the firms products
* Effective targeting and positioning strategies are essential in gaining and sustaining superior performance
6-11 Exhibit 6.1Market Targeting Alternatives Selective Targeting Extensive Targeting Segments Clearly Defined Differentiated But Segments Not Clearly Defined Target Selected Niche(s) Target Multiple Segments Product Variety Product Specialization 6-12 C. Positioning strategy
Deciding the desired perception/ association of an organization/ brand by market target buyersand designing the marketing program to meet (and exceed) buyers value requirements. 6-13 MARKET TARGET POSITIONING EFFECTIVENESS POSITIONING STRATEGY How well managements positioning objectives are achieved for the market target POSITIONING CONCEPT The desired positioning of the product (brand) by targeted buyers The combination of marketing actions used to communicate the positioning concept to targeted buyers STRATEGIC POSITIONING INITIATIVES 6-14 -The positioning concept indicates managements desired positioning of the product (brand) in the eyes and minds of the target buyers. -It is intended to deliver the value requirements appropriate for each market target pursued by the organization. -The positioning strategy is the combination of marketing program(mix) strategies used to portray the positioning desired by management to the target buyers. -this strategy includes the product, supporting services, distribution channels, price, promotion. Positioning effectiveness considers how well managements positioning objectives are being achieve in the market target. As shown in exhibit 6.4 the positioning objective is to have each target customer perceive the brand distinctively from other competing brands and favorably compared to the other brands. 6-15 How Positioning Works * Objective * Match the organizations distinctive capabilities with the customer value requirements for the market target (How do we want to be perceived by targeted buyers?) * Desired result * Gain a relevant, distinct, and enduring position by the targeted buyers that they consider important. * Actions by the organization * Design and implement the positioning strategy (marketing program) for the market target. 6-16
1. Selecting the positioning concept a. The positioning concept indicates how management wants buyers to perceived the companys brand. -The positioning can be central to customers perception and choice decisions. -The positioning concept should be linked to buyers value requirements. -The focus of the concept may be i. A functional concept applies to product that solve consumption-related problems for extremely generated consumption needs. examples of brands using this basis of positioning include Crest toothpaste (cavity prevention). ii. Symbolic positioning relates to the buyers internally generated need for self-enhancement, role positioning, group membership, or ego identification. examples of symbolic positioning are Rolax watches. iii. The experiential concept is used to position products that provide sensory pleasure, variety, and /or cognitive stimulation. 6-17 SELECTING THE POSITIONING CONCEPT Symbolic Functional Experiential
The Perception or Association that Management Wants Buyers to Have Concerning the Brand 6-18 -Three aspects of positioning concept selection are important: i. The positioning concept applies to a specific brand rather than all of the competing brands in a product classification such as toothpaste. ii. The concept is used to guide positioning(marketing program) decisions over the life of the brand ,recognizing the brand specific position may change over time. iii. If two or more positioning concepts, for example, functional and experimental, are used to guide positioning strategy, the multiple concepts are likely to confuse buyers and perhaps weaken the effectiveness of positioning actions. 6-19 b. The positioning decision -It is useful to study the positioning of competing brands using attributes that are important to existing and potential buyers of the competitors brands. -Marketing research may be necessary in identifying customers ideal positioning. 6-20 C.DEVELOPING THE POSITIONING STRATEGY The Positioning Strategy Places the Marketing Program (mix) Components into a Coordinated Set of Actions Designed to Deliver Superior Customer Value PRODUCT PROMOTION PRICE VALUE CHAIN 6-21 i. The positioning concept applies to a specific brand rather than all the competing brands that compose a product classification ii. The concept is used to guide positioning decisions over the life of the brand iii. Multiple concepts are likely to confuse buyers and may weaken the effectiveness of positioning actions. iv. Whether the strategy is brand specific or greater in scope depends on such factors as the size of the product-market, characteristics of he goods or service, the number of product involved, and the product interrelationship in the consumer use situation. 1.Scope of Positioning Strategy 6-22 2. Marketing program Decisions Nokias positioning strategy includes aggressive innovation initiatives, a very effective global value chain network, competitive pricing, and effective promotion strategies matched to its major global markets in Asia, Europe, middle east, Africa and the America. i. The product strategy, indicating how the product(s) will be positioned against the competition in the product-market. ii. The value chain (distribution) strategy to be used.
iii. The pricing strategy, including the role and positioning of price relative to competition. iv. Promotion strategy: -The advertising and sales promotion strategy and the objectives these promotion components are expected to achieve. -The sales force strategy, direct marketing strategy, and the Internet strategy, indicating how they are used in the positioning strategy.
6-23 D. Determining positioning effectiveness -The marketing offer (product, distribution, price, and promotion) is both distinct and valued in the minds of the customers in the market target. -Positioning evaluation should include customer analysis,competitor analysis,and internal analysis. -managements objective is to gain a distinct positioned in the market of interest. -several methods and metrics are available for analyzing positioning alternatives and determining positioning effectiveness. -These include customer and competitor research, market testing of proposed strategy, and the use of analytical techniques(exhibit 6.6). 6-24 Methods for Determining Positioning Effectiveness Analytical Positioning Models Test Marketing Customer and Competitor Research Exhibit 6.6 determining positioning effectiveness 6-25 1. Customer and Competitor Research * Research Studies * Preference Maps 2. Test Marketing * Generates information about commercial feasibility and marketing program * Provides market (sales forecasts) and effectiveness measures 3. Positioning Models * Incorporates research data into formal models of decision analysis -determining positioning effectiveness: Information is needed as to whether the strategy yields the results which are expected concerning sales, market share, profit contribution, growth rates, customer satisfaction, and other competitive advantages. 6-26 Positioning Errors * Under-positioning customers have only vague ideas about the company and do not perceive anything distinctive about it * Over-positioning Customers have too narrow an understanding of the company, product, or brand * Confused positioning Frequent changes and contradictory messages confuse customers * Doubtful positioning claims made for the product or brand are not regarded as credible 6-27 Positioning in Perspective
* Positioning is a central part of business strategy * Positioning analysis starts with an understanding of the value proposition for the target segment * Value-driven positioning is the objective * Positioning seeks to differentiate the organizations offer from the competition * Positioning seeks to create a unique perception in buyers minds of the target market segment * Positioning is the unifying dimension of market-driven strategy 6-28 Positioning usually means that an overt decision is being made to concentrate only on certain segments. Such an approach requires commitment and discipline because its not easy to turn your back on potential buyers. Yet, the effect of generating a distinct, meaningful position is to focus on the target segments and not to be constrained by the reaction of other segments. Source: Aaker and Shansby, Business Horizons, May-June 1982, 61. 6-29 Illustrative Impacts of Changes in Business Strategy on Targeting and Positioning Strategies Changes in Business Strategy Market Targeting Impact Positioning Impact Rapid Growth/ Retrenchment Market scope may not change although targets may be increased or reduced. Substantial changes in resource allocation, (e.g. advertising expenditures Changing the Product Mix No change is necessary unless increase in product scope creates opportunities in new segments. Changes in product strategy, methods of distribution, and promotional strategies may be necessary. Changing the Market Scope Targeting is likely to change to include new targets. Positioning strategy must be developed for each new target. Repositioning Should not have a major effect on targeting strategy. Product, distribution, price, and promotion strategies may be affected. Value Chain Integration Should have no effect on targeting strategy. Primary impact on channel, pricing and promotion strategies. Diversification Targeting strategies must be selected in new business areas. Positioning strategies must be developed (or acquired for the new business areas. Strategic Alliance Targeting strategy may be affected based on the nature and scope of the alliance. Operating relationships and assignment or responsibilities must be established. 6-30 Product Strategy Promotion Strategy Price Strategy Distribution Strategy Market Target Positioning Strategy Targeting and Positioning