Geoff Eagleson
How can we generate options for a new Business Model
whether for an organisation in trouble or for one that
senses an inflection point in its performance?
• What we need is a process – it is all about framing. Source: Coyne, Clifford & Dye (2007)
How do I generate options for a new Business Model?
Leverage
the
experiences
of self and
others
Leverage
existing
R&C
Generating options for a new Business Model
Road Map:
Valuable?
– Relevant to customer needs; contributes to differentiation or cost
advantage
Imitable?
– At risk of imitation by rivals, durability, mobility, substitutability
Rare?
– “Are you, or can you aspire to be best in class among the competition?”
(Quinn & Hilmer, 1993)
Organisation?
– Organizational architecture, property rights, bargaining power,
complementary resources or capabilities
Source: J. Barney, 2007 - Reading 7 in SM 1
Auditing your resources:
Questions to frame your analysis.
Procurement
M argins
Wine
Connoisseur Uninformed Who
Drinker
Price-sensitive
Drinker
How
Convenient
Availability
What did Yellow Tail
Eliminate/Reduce/Raise/Create?
Reduce
Which factors should be
reduced well below
industry standards?
Eliminate A Create
Which of the factors New Which factors should be
that the industry takes Value created that the industry
Curve has never offered?
for granted should be
eliminated?
Raise
Which factors should Eliminated Raised
be raised well above Enological terminology and Price versus budget wines
the industry’s standard? distinctions
Retail Store involvement
Aging qualities
Above-the-line marketing
Reduced Created
Wine complexity Easy drinking
•The pace of technological progress in almost every industry outstrips the ability of
customers in any given tier of the market to make effective use of the improved
versions of a product. Technologies that aren't good enough to address customers'
needs at one point typically improve to provide more than enough performance for
those same customers at a later point.
•Companies earn attractive profit margins when they stretch their products up-market,
targeting customers in a more demanding tier who are not yet satisfied by existing
offerings. A down-market move toward customers who are already satisfied by
available products yields profit margins that aren't nearly as attractive.
•Innovations that help incumbent companies earn higher margins by selling better
products to their best customers are sustaining, not disruptive. Sustaining innovations
comprise both simple, incremental engineering improvements as well as
breakthrough leaps up the trajectory of performance improvement.
Customers not
High satisfied by current
products
Performance
ti ons
n ova
In
in g
u s tain
S Performance that
average customers can utilize
ti o ns
no va
e In Customers over
iv
r upt serviced by current
Dis products
Low
Source: Christensen and Raynor (2003) Time
Generating options for a new Business Model :
Leverage your experience and think like an
entrepreneur.
%
Prior work 58.3
(previous role / employment,
consulting project)
Network
21.7
(social or business)
Thinking by analogy 11.3
Partner
8.7 Source: Timmons & Spinelli (2003)
But be aware of cognitive biases:
• Bisociation
20
Personal attributes sought in leaders of new growth
opportunities:
– External focus
– Imagination and creativity
– Decisive
– Inclusive
– Deep domain expertise.
Generating options for a new Business Model :
Leverage the experiences of others.
• Cirque de Soleil
• Roller Blades.
• Reverse engineer and ask about a great idea: what question would
have enabled me to see this opportunity first?
Generating options for a new Business Model :
Leverage insights about the future.
What we see
Reality
Possible events
http://www.petatv.com/tvpopup/video.asp?video=tyson_heflin&Player=wm
The Basic Scenario Planning Process
• It was the first educational institution that was given the right to pay
above award wages from its own income, on the condition that it
instituted a performance management system “with bite”.
• What could it have done to protect its future? What were the options
for a new Business model apart from introducing an Open Learning
Program (the precursor to the EMBA).
Consider the AGSM in 1988:
Six teams, six tools:
• Resource audit
• Capabilities audit
• Scenario planning
Choose one of the organisations represented in your
team and use a different tool from the one used earlier
to generate options for a new Business Model.
• Resource audit
• Capabilities audit
• Scenario planning
References
Coyne, K. P., Clifford, P. G. & Dye, R. 2007, “Breakthrough thinking from inside the
box”, Harvard Business Review, December, pp.71-78.
Stalk, G., Evans, P. & Shulman, L. E. 1992, “Competing on capabilities: the new
rules of corporate strategy”, Harvard Business Review, March-April, pp.57-69.