Technology
Insert image
here
Fuse
Fuse Switch
ABB Ltd - ATLV - 2 -
Switch fuse
The Great Debate
Overload
Short Circuit
This type of fault can generate high current flows, arcing and fire if not
cleared quickly
ABB Ltd - ATLV - 5 -
The Great Debate
Ultra Reliable
Time (s)
Standard Characteristic
High current limitation
effects
High threshold on low
overloads ( clears overloads
at approx 1.45x rated FLC)
ABB Ltd - ATLV - 7 -
Current (A)
Fuses & their associated switches
Advantages Disadvantages
Lower cost than comparative Expensive to automate
MCCB up to approx 400A (motorise)
Limited data extraction
Fuses readily interchangeable
(ON/OFF, Fuse intact/Blown)
between switches of different
manufacture hence low Single shot protection before
stocking costs for protective manual intervention
element Deterioration of protection
with age and current stress
Test Position for auxiliary
contact testing System protection can be
compromised by use of
Easier discrimination/selectivity increased fuse size or by
due to non-adjustment of defeating fuse ( the old
protective element copper wire trick!!)
ABB Ltd - ATLV - 8 -
Non-adjustment capability
leads to potential oversizing of
cables to achieve
discrimination
Fuseless technology
Magnetic curve
(fixed)
ABB Ltd - ATLV - 10 -
Current (A)
Thermomagnetic MCB & MCCBs
Advantages Disadvantages
Small size at low current
ratings ( MCB)
Limited data extraction
ON/OFF, Tripped (MCCB)
Easily automated shunt trip/
UVR/ Motor operator (MCCB) Expensive replacement of
Difficult to compromise system protection element as
protection switch contacts are used in
Multishot protection before arc clearance
manual intervention ( at least 2
shots) More complex
discrimination
Non-deterioration of protection
element with age or current Poorer current limitation
stress than equivalent fuse
Better overload protection
ABB Ltd - ATLV - 11 -
Current (A)
Electronic ACB & MCCBs
Advantages
Disadvantages
Lower cost at 630A and above
than fuse equivalent Expensive replacement of
Easily automated shunt trip/ protection element as
UVR/ Motor operator switch contacts are used in
Difficult to compromise system arc clearance
protection More complex
Multishot protection before discrimination due to
manual intervention ( at least 2 complexity of protective
shots)
functions
Non-deterioration of protection
element with age or current Poorer current limitation
stress than equivalent fuse
Better overload protection
leads to optimisation of cable
ABB Ltd - ATLV - 13 -
sizing
Complex functionality
Wide ranging data extraction
Relay functionality
Zone Discrimination
Measurements
Amps
Volts
Power
Trip information ( Phase/ current/ date/time)
Data logging
Maintenance indication
No. of operations
Settings
Harmonic content
All capable of being transmitted either visually or by data stream
ABB Ltd - ATLV - 15 -
Conclusions
ABB has been manufacturing both circuit breakers and switchfuses for
many years, research and development within both technologies continues
to increase the capabilities of the products we supply to make sure that
whatever technology you choose, there is a suitable product within the
range to meet your protection requirements .
ABB Ltd - ATLV - 17 -