Welcome to our

presentation
Here is
Md. Ashraful Alam
Id. No: 21-046
 We are
Name ID

Md. Ashraful Alam 21-046

Md. Forhad hossain 21-058

Md. Faisal Ahamed 21-178

Md. Mahabub Alam 21-260

Mahatab Uddin Ahmed Moon 21-281

Pranab Chandra ghosh 21-265

Riaduzzaman Kazi 21-285

Anti-dumping
Article vi, Section 2.1
Case summary
Here is
Faisal Ahamed
Id. No: 21-178
 Antidumping Case
Tova Chemical Sova Chemical Other
Complex Ltd. Complex Ltd. Companies
Failed to provide Did not response
much of the Provided all the to the
required information questionnaire
information

Determination of
Spot investigation
normal value on
to obtain the
the basis of
information
domestic sales

Determination of
normal & ex-
factory value
 Determination of Export Price
Tova Chemical Complex Ltd. Sova Chemical Complex Ltd.

Adjustments Value US$/MT

Adjustments Value US$/MT Inland freight ***
Inland freight *** Ocean freight ***

Ocean freight *** Handling cost ***

Bank charges ***
Bank charges ***
Credit Cost ***
Credit Cost *** Misc. expense ***
Duty drawback *** Duty drawback ***
Volume of Dumped Imports

Percentage of import like product

Bangladesh,
28.17

Other sources,
71.83

Bangladesh Other sources

 Volume of HP Imported

DUMPED IMPORT OF HP

100

70.37
54.56
2012 2013 2014

Source: PRAL
 Determination of Dumping Margin

Exporter/Producer Dumping Margin as Dumping Margin as

Percentage of Export Percentage of C & F Price
Price

Tova Chemical Complex Ltd. 13.55 12.14

Sova Chemical Complex Ltd. 11.88 10.67

All others 13.55 12.14

Here is
Md. Mahabub Alam
Id. No: 21-260
 Injury to the Domestic Industry
(Price Effect - Article VI, Section 3.2)
Price Undercutting
13.83

9.54
8.68

2012 2013 2014

Year
 Injury to the Domestic Industry
(Price Depression - Article VI, Section 3.2)

Period Weighted Average Ex- Price Depression

factory Price of
Domestic Like Product

2012 100.00 ---

2013 114.93 ---

2014 110.63 3.74

Source: Applicants
 Injury to the Domestic Industry
(Price Suppression - Article VI, Section 3.2)

Price suppression
140

120
114.93 110.63
100 95.62 96.25
100

80

60

40

20

0
2011.5 2012 2012.5 2013 2013.5 2014 2014.5
Cost Ex-factory price
Source: Applicants
 Injury to the Domestic Industry
(Effect on Domestic Sales - Article VI, Section 3.4)

Domestic Sales
120
114.76
115

110
Volume

104.49
105
100
100

95

90
2012 2013 2014
Year

Source: Applicants
Here is
Md. Forhad Hossain
Id. No: 21-058
 Effect on Profit
Article VI, Section 3.4
Net Profit/(Loss)
40
25.11
20

0 -8.17
2011.5 2012 2012.5 2013 2013.5 2014 2014.5
-20
Amount

-40

-60

-80
-100
-100

-120
Year
Source: Applicants
 Effect on Production & Capacity
Utilization - Article VI, Section 3.4
Capacity Utilization(%)
100
95
95

90 87
85 82
80

75

70
2012 2013 2014

Source: Applicants
 Effect on Market Share
Article VI, Section 3.4
Market Share Trend(%)
100
87.61
90 81.48 79.38
80
70
Market Share
60
50
40
30
20
10 5.29 2.69 3.49
0
2011.5 2012 2012.5 2013 2013.5 2014 2014.5
Year

Domestic Sales Dumped Source

 Effect on Return on Investment
Article VI, Section 3.4
ROI(%)
10
9.01
9
8
7
6
Return

5
4.03 ROI(%)
4
Poly. (ROI(%))
3
2 1.45
1
0
2012 2013 2014
Year
 Effect on Cash Flow
Article VI, Section 3.4
800 Cash Inflow
697.49
700
600
500
400 350.34
300
200
100
100
0
2012 2013 2014
Year
Here is
Mahatab Uddin Ahmed
Moon
Id. No: 21-281
 Effect on Inventories
Article VI, Section 3.4
Period Opening Production Domestic Export Total Sales Closing
Inventory Sales Sales Inventory

2012 4.81 100.00 85.57 18.65 104.22 0.59

2013 0.59 107.30 89.41 16.80 106.21 1.68

2014 1.68 115.94 98.20 18.33 116.53 1.09

Source: Applicants
 Effect on Employment
Article VI, Section 3.4
Period Number of Salaries & Production Productivity Salaries &
Employees Wages Per Worker Wages
RS/MT

2012 100 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00

2013 102 113.36 107.30 104.76 105.65

2014 113 133.44 115.94 102.72 115.11

 Effect on Growth
Other Effects
Effect on Capital
Raising
 Price & Volume of Imports From Other
Sources
Period Volume of Import Weighted Average Weighted Price of
from Other Sources Landed Cost from Domestic Like
(MT) Other Sources Products

2012 100.00 100.00 100.00

2013 145.39 88.61 114.35

2014 71.82 87.17 110.01

Source: PRAL, Applicant

 Total Domestic Market

Total Domestic Market

100

80

60

40

20

0
2011.5 2012 2012.5 2013 2013.5 2014 2014.5
Year

Sales By Domestic Industry Sales from Dumped Source

Sales from Other Source

Source: PRAL, Applicant

 Export Sales of Domestic Industries

Export Sales
102
100
100
98.27
98
96
Quantity

94
92
90.07
90
88
86
84
2012 2013 2014
Year
Source: Applicants
Here is
Riadduzzaman kazi
Id. No: 21-285
 Causation
Article VI, Section 3.5
Increase in dumped imports

Experience of price undercutting, price depression & suppression

Decline in profit & productivity

Negative return on investment

Threat of material injury in the imminent future

 What could be done?

Putting more emphasis by Govt.

Appointment of more expert lawyer.
Collection of more information.
Relationship between dumping and injury.
 Future Suggestions

Expert Training
personnel program

Subsidy

Ministerial Proper data

Strength on management for
Foreign trade lawsuit
Thank you