Market segmentation
• Segmentation for its own sake is of little value, its value comes when it is used to
make decisions about target markets & to establish specific competitive positions
with respect to those targets that bring value to the firm.
• Ultimately, it is the success of differential competitive positioning within markets
that creates success: doing things differently from competitors to establish
advantage( like customized offerings at lower costs)
• Activities required to achieve success are-segmentation, targeting & positioning.
• While all customers are different, some may share similar needs & behaviors. It is
through the of segmentation that a BToB marketer can establish a degree of
homogeneity in respect of different customers in marketplace.
• In this way notional groups of like-minded or like behaved customers are created,
for whom it becomes possible to talk meaningfully about different market
offerings.
• It enables the marketer to research the needs of specific groups , make choices
about which groups are worth the investment of marketing efforts & how that
effot needs to be managed.
Market segmentation
• Thus, market segmentation is a process of
dividing the total market for a product into
several segments or distinct group of buyers.
• Each group of buyers is homogeneous and
may require separate benefits from the
offered product or service.
Introduction
• Organizations & consumers often buy the same products; laptops,
cleaning services, medical services, stationary etc.
• One cannot distinguish between a business market and a consumer
market on the basis of the nature of the product.
• There are certain products that are often bought by organizations and
never by individual consumers, such as management services, forklifts,
cranes etc.
• The key distinguishing feature of a B-TO-B market is that the customer is
an organization rather than an individual consumer.
• Business organizations include manufacturing companies, govt.
undertakings, educational bodies, dealers and distributors etc.
• On the other hand, it is difficult to think of anything that consumer buys
that would not be bought by some organization.
• The generally accepted term for the marketing of goods & services to
organizations is business to business marketing or industrial marketing as
it was called in the 1980s.
INTRODUCTION
• Business markets involve both goods and services.
• Most of the developed economies have a very large & influential
service sector.
• Business markets can be differentiated from consumer markets on
the basis of market structure differences, buying behavior
differences, and marketing practice differences.
• It is not the nature of the product that is bought and sold that
differentiates business markets from consumer markets.
• Business organizations buy products & services to manufacture
goods & services, to make profits.
• Consumers buy products & services for their own consumption.
• So, what are the differences or defining characteristics by which
business markets can be distinguished from consumer markets?
Comparison
• Market Structure Differences:
• Dimension Business Mktg Con.Mkt
• Nature of demand derived direct
– Demand volatility greater less
• Demand elasticity less more
• nature of Customers heterogeneity homoge
• Fragmentation greater less
• Mkt complexity more less
• Mkt size large value smaller
• No of buyers/seller few many
• No of buyers/segment few many
• Size of buyer/seller often similar seller larger
• Geog concentration often clustered dispersed
Comparison
• Buying Behavior Differences
• Dimension B. mktg C. mktg
• Buying influences many few
• Purchase cycles often long short
• transaction value often high small
• Buying complexity complex simple
• Buyer/sellerdepend high low
• Pur professionalism high low
• Imp of relationships important unimp
• Interactivity high low
• Written rules common uncommon
Comparison
• Marketing Practice Differences
• Dimension B. mktg c.mktg
• Selling process system selling prod sell
• Personal selling extensive limited
• Relationships extensive limited
• Pormo strategy cust specific mass mkt
• Web integration greater limited
• Branding limited extensive
• Mkt research limited extensive
• Segmentation unsophisticated sophisticated
• Comp. awareness lower(?) higher
• Product complexity greater lesser
Comparison
• Marketing practice in business markets differs from that in
consumer markets because of the underlying differences in markets
structure, and because of the differences in buying behavior.
• For example, the extensive use of personal selling in business
markets can be traced to the market structure and buying behavior
characteristics commonly found in business markets which are
usually not found in consumer markets.
• Typically, in many business markets, demand is concentrated in the
hands of a few powerful buyers(market structure), who employ
teams of purchasing professionals to do their buying(buying
behavior).
• In most consumer markets demand is dispersed widely throughout
the buying public and no single consumer has any real buying
power(market structure), buyers are not trained
professionals(buying behavior).
Comparison
• Therefore, personal selling makes sense in business markets( concentrated
demand, powerful buyers, trained professional), since trained
organizational buyers expect to hear a well-argued case specifically
tailored to the needs of their organization, and costs of employing a sales
executive are justified by the high potential value of each order.
• The new technologies and the use of CRM software has brought about a
degree of convergence between the marketing practices of consumer and
business markets.
Market Structure Differences
• A. Derived demand:
• Conventionally, in marketing demand by consumers is treated as
direct demand and demand from business as derived.
• The word derived indicates that the demand for something only
exists so long as there is a demand for the goods or services that it
helps to produce.
• The whole chain of derived demand is driven by the direct demand
of consumers.
• The implication of derived demand in business markets is that
marketers must be aware of developments, both upstream and
downstream, that may affect their marketing strategy. (Ex: Demand
for new housing increases the demand for housing materials like
steel, cement, paints timber etc. known as the accelerator effect.)
Market Structure Differences
• B. Market concentration in B-TO-B markets
• B-to-B markets are in general characterized by higher
concentration of demand than consumer markets.
• The measure used is concentration ratio.
• It is defined as the combined market shares of the few(
three or four or five) top largest firms in the market-
oligopoly group of firms in the market.
• The higher the concentration ratio, the more likely it is
that firms in an industry will collude to raise prices
above those that would be found in a truly
competitive market.
Market Structure Differences
• Derived demand, the accelerator effect and concentration ratios
provide a basis for analyzing many of the structural differences
between consumer and business markets.
• Businesses have less freedom simply to stop buying things than
consumers, so that business demand is likely to be less price elastic(
less responsive to price changes) than consumer demand.
• For similar reasons, there will be more instances of reverse price
elasticity of demand in business markets than in consumer markets.
• Businesses need critical inputs if they are to continue trading.
• If due to shortage in supply the price of a critical input increases,
this may lead to an increase in orders in the short term to
guarantee sufficient supply of that input. ( reverse elasticity where
a price rise triggers an increase in demand)
Buying behavior & marketing practice
differences
• Business organizations have more professionalized buying
processes than consumers, involving formal procedures and
explicit decision making practices.
• Transaction values are high. As a result, sellers tend to tailor
their product offerings to the needs of the buyers, seeking
to offer complete solutions to their business problems,
rather than just to sell them a product.
• Conventional tools of consumer mass marketing are
inappropriate here.
• Sales managers and key account executives/managers are
employed to develop and mage relationship between
buying & selling organization.
Classifying business products and
markets
• Basically, key difference between business marketing &
consumer marketing is the nature of the customer rather than
the product.
• In business markets customers are organizations who buy
products that are not bought by consumers—management
consultancy service, heavy engineering equipment etc.
• There are many products bought by both- organizations and
consumers-like PCs, stationary, ACs, etc.
• The product classification is based on the use to which the
products are put, and the extent to which they are
incorporated or enter into the final product.
• Example- services like cleaning are not incorporated in to the
final product of an organization. The difference between
‘entering goods’ and other goods is based on the idea that
something incorporated into the organization’s final products
contribute directly to finished product quality.
Classification of products..
• Installations are major investment items-engineering
equipment which are treated as investment items
which can be depreciated
• Accessory equipment are smaller items like hand tools.
• Maintenance and repair operating supplies are minor
but recurring items of expenditure.
• Raw materials are basic materials like crude oil, steel.
• Manufactured materials and parts are finished goods
and components ready for incorporation into final
product.
• Business services like maintenance and repair services,
business advisory services.
Classification of products…
• Based on the product classification, organizations are classified into
original equipment manufacturers, and others.
• OEMs are manufacturing businesses that buy component parts
from other firms to incorporate into a finished product that is sold
under their brand.[Honda, Toyoya,Leneovo,Dell]
• There is OEM market & after market. Customers in after market
can be either organizations or consumers.
• OEM customers are by definition business customers.
• The demand for industrial products & services is a derived
demand—it does not exist by itself but is derived from the ultimate
demand for consumer goods & services.
• Joint demand for a product occurs when one industrial product is
useful if the other products exist—pump & electric motor or diesel
engine.
Types of business markets
• Commercial enterprises: industrial distributors,
OEMs, manufacturing & non-manufacturing
companies( ad companies, service providers
• Government bodies like central and state
governments, PSUs, railways, other government
departments like defense, road building etc.
• Institutional customers: schools, hospitals,
• Cooperatives: sugar, milk producers
Organizational Buying Behavior
• Process:
• Step-by-step classification of market in terms of sets of meaningful groupings with each further
step to define further subdivisions.
• Then, on the basis of classification criteria, known as segmentation bases, a set of market segments
are created.
• Industry and company size and customer location are the major macro-factors providing a broad
classification of customers.
• Here, the expectation is that companies from the same industry, or of similar sizes or locations,
share similar product needs or usage patterns.
• A) Industry: First step in segmentation is to consider where a product would be used( application of
the product).
• Knowledge of an industry that may have use for its technology enables it to quickly identify
prospects.
• B) Customer location: Location of a customer will affect the ease with which it can be reached by a
company. Location will influence decisions about where a company makes it presence felt, how it
deploys its staff, or communicates with its customers.
• Its expected that companies from the same industry, or of similar sizes or locations, share similar
product needs or usage patterns.
Segmentation
• Companies providing goods or services that are easily transportable like design
services are not hampered by geographic distances from customers.
• C) Customer size: Size of customer companies as a basis for distinguishing one
from other.
• Size often matters because of its relationship with the scale of the customer
organizations’ needs and therefore for their demands for volume.
• Operating variables: These segmentation criteria variables can be applied singly or
in combination.
• a)company technology: There is an element of technological readiness involved.
Bigger players tend to invest large amounts in technology which is most likely to be
up-to-date.
• Thus, an analysis of technology of companies is valuable in segmentation and
targeting decisions because it gives a strong indication of a company’s buying
needs as well as the ease with which the supplying company can meet those
needs.
Segmentation
• b)Product & brand use status: Companies segment market in order to establish
targets for their products, so they would use the behavior of customers with
respect to brands or products to aid their segmentation.
• Customer reactions to products in terms of readiness to use(for those who are not
yet customers) and usage rate( light , medium or heavy for those who already
purchase) are valuable means of distinguishing one from another.
• Retaining heavy users is the obvious use of segmentation.
• c) Customer capabilities: A supplier might genuinely want to esstablish what
customers are capable of doing with either its product or the process.( Providing
key technical support schemes or inputs to glass processors by glass
manufacturers).
• E) Purchasing approach: How buying companies are organized to buy and the
buying criteria can be a valuable intelligence to marketer, as this information will
enable them to produce an offering that is most valuable to a target segment
defined in terms of purchasing approach.
• Buying companies differ in how they organize themselves for procurement.
Segmentation
• The tests that business markets can use to establish the quality of
segmentation process are:
• 1. Measurable: Segmentation must be clearly measurable—it must be
possible to establish the size of the firm, its capabilities, its purchasing
policies, selection criteria, its size of orders and the attitude to risk.
• 2.Accessable: A segment needs to be accessible to be targeted usefully.
Reach includes physical ease of getting to the customers & the ability to
communicate with them.
• 3.Substantial & profitable: Size & potential profitability of segments are
crucial. Segments must be big enough, be able to pay enough, to justify
the costs of serving them.
• 4.Actionable: The company should be able to bring offerings to bear that
will meet needs of the segment. It should know what capabilities the
company has or needs to develop to serve a segment profitably.
Segmentation
• In short, a common procedure to carry out market segmentation has three steps:
marketing research, analysis to identify segments, profile of segments.
• Secondary marketing research can be done first by collecting information on the
markets from company’s past data, online databases, library scanning, industry
associations etc.
• If primary research data is inadequate, more detailed research can be done from
existing and potential industrial buyers on major purchasing attributes, buyers’
present and future requirements and their purchasing policies, competitors’
information( their present market perception, market share of each, quality,
capacity available, strategies followed in pricing, payment terms, after-sales
service, distribution & promotion strategies, level of technology.
• Analysis of the collected data from secondary & primary research is analyzed using
statistical techniques like factor analysis, cluster analysis.
• Profiling each group of customers by its specific characteristics like use of product,
volume required, location, type of industry, purchasing policies and major
purchasing attributes, buyers personal characteristics, buying behavior.
Segmentation
• Benefits of segmentation:
• 1.It enables the industrial marketer to compare
marketing opportunities of different market
segments by studying customer needs &
potential, competition, satisfaction levels of
customers in each market segment.
• 2. Firms can develop separate marketing
programs to meet the needs of different market
segments.
• 3. Allocation of budgeted resources can be done
effectively to various segments.
Targeting
• To make the best-informed choices about what markets to serve and how to serve
them by devising appropriate strategies.
• Target segment selection: After establishing relevant segments, the firm will have
to consider its possible competitive position in relation to each segment to
determine whether the segments merit the company’s attention.
• The company’s competitive position within a market and its ability to reach the
buyers, the size of a market, the extent to which the segment is compatible with
its objectives & resources, the extent to which the company considers it profitable,
whether the company expects future growth in the sector, segment size, customer
product/service needs and fit with company’s competence in meeting the needs,
how activities of Government or public at large may affect the segment, how
technology impacts it, structure & nature of competition in the segment, are the
most commonly used criteria.
• The evaluation of such factors is followed by an estimation of the demands of the
segment would make in terms of finance, technology, human resources.
• Whether the management wants to pursue a segment as a part of strategic
development.
• After these steps, the company can decide on targeting strategy it should adopt.
Targeting
f) In order to select target segments and decide which market strategy to adopt, a
company should evaluate market segments by analyzing four factors –size & growth,
profitability analysis, competitive analysis, company objective & resources.
1.Size & growth: what is the size or market potential of such a market segment. The
current & future market potential can be obtained by using demand forecasting methods
such as time-series analysis, regression analysis, econometric models, sales force
estimates, and expert opinion.
Targeting
2. Profitability analysis involves analyzing profitability of each potential
segment.
a) Market potential, which is estimating the quantity & value of a product
that the total market will purchase within a time period.
b) Sales forecast is to estimate the company’s sales based on its share out of
the market potential in a specified period.
• Sales forecast are based on informed judgment of sales persons & dealers
to estimate the market share of a company.
• This can be done by detailed analysis of customers, individually or in a
group, to estimate the market potential while taking into consideration
competitors’ position.
• c) Profitability refers to difference between sales revenue and marketing
costs of servicing & maintaining customers.
• Marketing costs are sales force costs, advertising & sales promotion costs,
new variant product development costs, discounts, warehousing and
inventory carrying costs.
• 3) Competitive analysis is the careful analysis of strengths & weaknesses
of competitors. The analysis must be done for all competitors in areas like
manufacturing, R&D, finance, technology, delivery performance, sales
force, advertisement, distribution, management etc.
Targeting
• After selecting target markets, the industrial marketer should decide positioning
strategy for each target market.
• The offering from a marketer /company occupies a space in the minds of the
buyer( Dell was perceived as a customized and low priced product).
• This position establishes the supplier in an idealized position that most closely
represent the customer need.
• This relative position becomes the basis by which the supplier is compared to
other competitors .
• It is necessary to ensure that this relative position occupied in the buyer’s mind is
most favorable.
• Thus, positioning is defined as the distinct place a product/service occupies in the
minds of the target customers relative to other competing products/services.(high
tech products, specialised applications, custom-made products etc)
• It is how a firm wants its products/ services to be perceived by the target
customers on important attributes or benefits.( TCS, L&T)
• In establishing the relative position a firm has to be clear where its strengths lie.
• The positioning it adopts must be clear and clearly communicated to buyers.
Positioning
• --Second, how the target customers perceive the company’s products or service
with respect t
• After knowing the customer’s perceptions o these important attributes.
• -- Service variables like pre-sales services(providing assistance in arriving at
specific requirement of a product in terms of capacity, like air conditioning or
steam requirement or arriving at a solution to a problem).
• --Third, how the target customers perceive the competitors’ products or services
with respect to the same attributes.
• --After knowing the customer’s perspectives based on the interactions over a
period of time, a statistical analysis can be carried out.
• This is called perceptual map, which helps in deciding the positioning strategy.
• Communicating company’s positioning:
• --The industrial marketers must communicate their positioning strategy effectively
to target markets.
• --In consumer markets the positioning strategy is mainly communicated through
advertisements.
Positioning
• Based on these points, product strategies are decided like which of the existing
products be continued, modified, or dropped and which new products need to be
developed.
• (A product may only capture physical aspects and attributes which is a part of an
overall offering. There are huge service elements involved for which customers pay
a lot more than market prices due to the value of the offering.)
• Product strategy in industrial markets needs to be flexible.
• Industrial firms need to change their product strategy because of changes in
customer needs, technology, government policies, product life-cycle.
• Customer needs: To succeed and survive in competitive markets, an industrial firm
must continuously monitor changes in the needs of its target customers and
continue to satisfy customers by making changes in product line.
• Customer needs change because of changes in environment.
• Technology: Changes in technology require either product modification or new
products as existing ones become obsolete.
• Government policies/law: Open policies after liberalization has helped many
Indian industries.
Product Decisions
• Product life-cycle: There are four major stages in the product life cycle-
introduction, growth, maturity, decline.
• There is also substantial activity before launch in development and in preparation
for launch( pre-launch stage).
• In industrial markets, the time from product concept to market launch may be
substantial, even when directly working with customer that has a particular
product need.
• 1. Introduction stage:
• --There can be huge development costs involved.
• --During introductory phase it will be costing more money than it is bringing in,
since there are marketing tasks to be carried out.
• --Up to the launch and after that, customers need to be made aware of the
product, so there are many communication activities like demonstrations,
exhibitions, trade shows etc.
• --If it is a completely new concept for the market, there is a need to generate
primary demand for the product.
• --There can be trial offers from existing key customers, especially if they are
important reference customers.
Product Decisions
• --Field sales time is likely to be invested in communicating its value( advice giving),
so the sales force must be trained in the product and shown how to demonstrate
its benefits to customers.
• -- Distribution channels must be set up.
• --All these activities are likely to continue until sales start to rise, indicating market
acceptance.
• --By this time, early problems with the offering can be identified and resolved and
experience learned in the entire process of offering stabilization will enhance sales
training.( Chesterton).
• 2. Growth stage:
• --As the offering is increasingly gets accepted in the market, and sales and profits
begin to rise more rapidly than before, the nature of the demands on the business
marketer change.
• --Competition is likely to increase resulting a pressure on prices, and as this
pressure creates greater demand thus fueling further growth.
• --For innovative products, competition is likely from copycat products tapping into
the same primary demand without costs of development in creating the demand.
Product Decisions
• --Develop a trend analysis for last three to five years based on information to be
collected for an industrial firm for factors like industry profits as a percentage of
sales, value of sales, market share number of competitors, pricing trends.
• --Analysis of competitor’s market share product performance, new product
introduction, diversification and expansions.
• Estimate and project sales & profits of the product over next three to five years
• From the above analysis, fix the product’s position on its life cycle curve.
• Managing new product development:
• Development and marketing new industrial products is vital for a profitable growth
of a firm.
• It tests a firm’s market knowledge, technical competence, financial strength, ability
to compete.
• Products that have entered the decline stage must be replaced by new products to
maintain profitability and growth.
• A firm’s value creating potential may stem from its production innovations, process
innovations, marketing innovations, organizational or management innovations.
Product Decisions
• While managing innovation to create advantage, the key questions are how the
firm should be organized to encourage innovation and the role that relationships
with external partners have in aiding this process.
• Organizing innovation: Companies need to create an environment where creative
individuals can harness their creativity to meet the market needs & opportunities.
• Some of the requirements to create the right environment are:
• --commitment to long-term growth rather than short-term profits
• --awareness of threats and opportunities
• --invest in long-term development of technology
• --ability to be aware of & take advantage of externally developed technology
• --readiness to accept change
• New products can be a) innovative & new to the world/market b) products that
are new to the company c) revisions or improvements to the existing products in
the existing markets d) additions to existing products lines with additional markets
e) repositioning existing products to new markets f) products with substantial cost
reductions but without reductions in performance
Product Decisions
• Remaining ideas will be subjected to further screening and investigation like how
customers will react to the offering & how competitors will react.
• Customer reaction focus will be on certain segments & aspects of the new offering
concept that will be attractive to them.
• On the basis of further evaluation, some more ideas will be discarded.
• 3.Analysing the business case: Further screening of ideas for finding those having
the greatest business potential.
• Business analysis involves careful financial estimates of market size, growth rate &
potential for each product offering idea.
• Business case analysis needs to establish what the development costs are likely to
be for each new idea before it can be brought to market.
• These costs include capital investment needed, staff costs, break-even level and
payback period, rate of return on investment.
• When each new offering is seen in these financial terms, it becomes possible to
compare them as prospective projects.
• 4.Developing the concept & specifying the features: The clear identification of the
likely targets & their reactions to the offerings helps to specify the features.
Product Decisions
• It becomes possible to state what the concept is and the benefits it brings to
customers and the use of such offering.
• A likely price can be estimated.
• 5. developing prototypes & developing marketing support: Having arrived at the
clear concept, the offering can be prototyped.
• A prototype is a facsimile of final product offering that enables evaluation of the
form, design, performance & material composition.
• The intention is to develop a series of working prototypes that can be fine-tuned
towards final offering.
• Simultaneously, the marketing support activities can commence—activities like
pricing, packaging, labeling, promotional plans, for final commercial launch.
• 6.Limited scale trial marketing: Successive refinements in product offering will lead
to fewer & fewer changes and the offering is ready to be used by customers.
• If feasible, test marketing in a small market or area can be beneficial in obtaining
feedback on pricing product use, marketing activities & communication.
Product Decisions
• Price has a direct & substantial effect on profitability, hence a critical part of
industrial marketing strategy.
• Pricing strategy is related to market segmentation strategy, product strategy,
distribution strategy, promotion strategy.
• On average, a 5% price increase can increase earnings before interest and
taxes(EBIT) by 22%, whereas a 5% increase in sales turnover increases EBIT by
12%, and a reduction of 5% in costs of goods sold increases CBIT by 10%.
• When a buying firm buys a product from a supplier ( which is in competition with
many other suppliers in the market), it means that the buying firm perceives that
the said supplier offered the highest delivered value( Delivered value is the
difference between the overall perception of value and the total cost to the buying
firm).
• The total cost to the buying firm includes not only the price of the product, but
cost of transportation, transit insurance cost, installation cost etc.
• The buying firm also takes the risks of product failure, delivery delays, lack of
technical support or service.
• Hence, the supplier offering the lowest price may not be the lowest in the total
cost, if other costs and risks are considered.
Pricing Decisions
• To calculate full average cost of production the fixed overheads of business have to
be allocated, and this allocation is based on a sales volume estimate.
• If sales volume is overestimated then fixed costs per unit of production will be
higher than expected, and the firm will make less than target profit margin.
• If sales volume is underestimated, fixed costs per unit will be lower than expected,
the profit margin will be above target.
• The basic questions for managers will face concerning pricing decisions are—a) If
price is cut, then by how much sales volume will increase so that profits are
increased? b) If we raise price, then by how much can sales decline before we
incur a loss?
• These questions can be answered by break-even sales analysis or cost-volume-
profit analysis.
• It’s a technique used to consider different prices and their possible effects on sales
volume and profits.
• It is calculated by the formula– break even volume= fixed costs/selling price-
variable cost
Pricing Decisions
Price Price
Demand Demand
Pricing Decisions
• Market segment illustrated in curve A exhibits elastic demand, meaning a 1% change in price
causes a change in demand of more than 1%.
• Segment B shows inelastic demand where a substantial change(more than just 1%) is needed
to cause change in demand as a 1% change in price will cause far less than 1% change in
demand.
• Demand will be inelastic for industrial products where customers need is urgent, products
are strongly differentiated, compete against few alternatives, are complex & difficult to
compare, involve high switching costs, customers see price as being a quality indicator.
• Competitor analysis: Under oligopolistic market conditions, the decisions of each competitor
directly affects its rivals(interdependence).
• The legal price behavior under oligopoly is price leadership, where the industry leader is
closely watched by rivals who follow its lead in pricing decisions.
• When demand is slack & there is overcapacity, the price leader is the first one to reduce
prices giving rivals a signal to do accordingly.
• When industry is operating at near to capacity the leader will be the first to raise price, and
rivals will follow.
• There are illegal or unethical ways of price fixing by collusion.( anti-competitive pricing, price
fixing, price discrimination, predatory pricing or dumping).
• Pricing is more or less a continuous process, in which pricing decisions must be constantly
updated to account for factors like new product features, competitor pricing strategies,
technological changes, changes in taxation or raw material costs like fuel, electricity etc.
Pricing Decisions
• Most common pricing objectives are profits, sales volume, sales revenue, market
share, image creation, survival competitive parity, barriers to entry.
• Depending on the pricing objective followed, each competitor will have different
response to price changes.
• If the objective is to increase market share, then competitor is most likely to match
price reduction.
• If the objective is to maximize profits, then the competitor’s response to price cut
will be different , such as improvement in quality or customer service.
• A competitor’s response to a price change depends on his mind set. Hence, it is
essential to understand and study business philosophy, internal culture, past
practices to competing firms so as to predict his response.
• Some may react strongly to a price cut, some may react very selective way.
• Government regulations: Industrial firms must be aware of the effect of
government regulations on pricing decisions.
• To protect consumer interests, government makes certain laws making price fixing
or price cartels illegal. In India, we have CCI to look after such issues and
investigate issues relating to price fixing by industrial firms.
Pricing Decisions
• Each bidder’s price and commercial terms are read out during the opening and
order is placed on the lowest price bidder.
• If the volumes or value is large, the government buyer may decide to place orders
not only on L1 but also on L2 & L3.
• These orders will be placed on the decreasing percentage of share of total share
provided L2 & L3 agree to match L1 prices.
• In open or negotiated tender bidding, suppliers submit bids and the buyer after
studying the product and prices as well as terms & conditions negotiates technical,
commercial, delivery issues with each bidder who is short-listed.
• Such a method is followed in private sector.
• Open bidding is a combination of bidding & negotiation.
• Competitive bidding : The strategy used is probabilistic bidding which assumes
that the pricing objective I profit maximization and secondly the buying
organization will decide the order on the lowest price bidder.
• Variables used are a) the amount of price or the price bid b) expected profit if the
bid price is accepted & c) the probability of acceptance of the bid price.
Pricing Decisions
• An industrial marketer seeks to optimize the trade-off between the bid price or
profit on the one hand and the probability of winning the contract on the order.
• The most difficult task is to estimate the probability of the acceptance of its bid
price as being the lowest.
• This depends on the marketer’s knowledge of the competitors’ costs, strengths &
weaknesses & the mind set.
• Pricing new products: Price-positioning strategy takes into account these factors-
the price itself, customer benefits derived from using the product or service,
competitor positioning.
• The strongest price-benefits tradeoff is offered by the market ruler position.
• This position is difficult to achieve because delivering enhanced benefits to
customers generally involves additional costs, making it difficult to offer low price
while achieving an acceptable profit margin.
• The pricing strategies available for new product at the introductory stage are
skimming(high initial cost) strategy & penetration(low initial price) strategy.
• To decide on any strategies, the marketer must study the price from industrial
buyers’ perceptions.
Pricing Decisions
• Another factor to be considered is how soon the company should recover the
investment on the new product.
• Skimming strategy is used for new product which is to be purchased by a market
segment that is not sensitive to initial high price.
• It has the advantage of recovering the investment sooner by generating larger
profits.
• Thereafter, the price will be reduced to reach other price sensitive segments.
• The disadvantage is that it attracts competition due to high profits.
• Hence such a policy is used for new products which are distinct, high in
technology, or capital intensive( which can create barrier to competition).--
Electronic items like new models of smart phones.
• Penetration strategy is used when price elasticity of demand is high or buyers are
price sensitive and when strong threats exist from potential competitors, when
there are possibilities of unit cost reduction & distribution with volume increases.
• This can give a company cost leadership over competition and can achieve long-
term profitability goal through large market share.
Pricing Decisions
• Pricing policies for industrial products can change as the product moves through
various stages of life-cycle.
• Pricing policy is a key factor in each of the stages.
• During growth phase, new competitors enter the market & more customers use
the product.
• So, the marketer of an industrial product will face pressure of lowering prices
below the introduction stage.
• In the growing market, new competitors will enter and the marketer will be force
to differentiate the product & seek new markets.
• As more & more competitors enter with similar offerings, buyers of the industrial
product will develop more than one supplier, thereby putting more pressure on
the firm which introduced the product first in the market.
• In the maturity stage, when competitor products are well established and there is
fierce competition, the marketer has to fight for market share of his competitors
by pricing strategy of matching the competitor prices by lowering it, if required.
• In a declining stage of the cycle, if the product quality reputation is good, the firm
can depend on cost reductions rather than price cutting to make more profits.
Pricing Decisions
• One more strategy is to cut prices to increase sales volumes & use this product to
help sell other products in the product-mix.
• Industrial marketers deal with different types of customers– users, OEMs, dealers,
bulk users—who buy in various quantities and are located in different
geographical locations.
• To account for these differences, pricing policies are evolved.
• Industrial firms generally do not set a single price but a set of price structure that
cover different product items having different sizes, and specifications of a
product.
• The pricing plan will be determined by analysis of current situation(overview of
market & SWOT analysis), strategy determination(strategy & objectives), and
implementation & control process.
• A wide range of different functions within a company have interest in pricing
decisions. Examples are senior management, sales, marketing, finance, operations,
customer service.
• Pricing is a cross functional activity involving several people from different
departments. Hence, some companies have pricing committees comprising these
stakeholders as each brings in his own perspectives & concerns.
Pricing Decisions
• Each department tends to have its own perspective on pricing decisions, and these
perspectives may conflict, thus influencing pricing decisions.
• Sales force has an important role to play in mediating between the company & its
customers with respect to pricing decisions.
• Since sales people are closest to customers they are expected to understand
customer’s valuation of the company’s product offerings better than anyone else
in a company.
• Competitive bidding : Four basic auction mechanisms are English, Dutch, first-
price sealed bid & second price sealed bid auctions.
• The English auction is an ascending price auction in which the last remaining
bidder receives the goods by paying the amount.
• The Dutch auction starts at a high level & the price falls until the first participant
finds the price low enough to submit a bid and thus he receives the goods at the
price lower than the start of auction price.
• These two types of auctions are real time auctions.
• Sealed –bid auctions are not real time where a bidder submitting highest bid price
is the winner.
Pricing Decisions
• Ethical issues: The main ethical issues that arise in B TO B pricing decisions are
anti-competitive pricing, price fixing, price discrimination and predatory pricing or
dumping.
• Anti-competitive pricing arises when a group of producers collude to raise prices
above the level that would apply in a freely operating market.
• Such pricing policies are unfair and damaging to the free enterprise system and is
prohibited by law in India and many other countries.(US, EU, Japan).
• Companies may be tempted to enter explicit or implicit price-fixing arrangements
because they believe that otherwise there is a risk of a price war leading to
financial losses.
• Unethical pricing practices arise particularly in industries where competitive
tendering is common.
• Collusive tendering occurs where there is an agreement between competitors
either not to tender or to tender in such a manner as not to be competitive with
one of the other renderers'.(defense, construction)
• The essence of collusion in tendering is that there is an agreement between
bidders to win the contract for one bidder with others getting benefits.
Pricing Decisions
• Brands can be narrowly defined as name, term, sign or symbol or design, but more
broadly brand represents a shared desirable & exclusive idea embodied in
products, services, places or experiences.
• A brand consists of tangible features & intangible associations or functional &
emotional values.
• At the company level, corporate brand identity is developed within an
organization, resulting in the expression to target audiences of a company’s
enduring traits via selected symbols, behavior and communication activities.
• In contrast, corporate brand image assumes an external perspective & signifies the
meaning by which an organization is known & the way people describe, relate or
remember it.
• Communication strategy involves planning, implementing, & controlling an
organization’s communication with target markets, audiences to achieve specified
objectives with each audience.
• A variety of tools are used such as advertising, sales promotion, public relations,
personal selling, direct marketing.
• These are combined into a communications program to enable a company to
engage buyers, other stakeholders.
Communication
• Communication Objectives: Objectives are related to what a firm wants its target
audience to do with the information transimitted via its communication tools.
• Many objectives are associated with “buyer readiness states”.
• Various stages in communication are related to the process enacted by a firm to
acquire & retain customers.
• Awareness is developed when potential customers become familiar with a product
or a brand.
• At this stage a company is trying to generate leads by directing its communication
campaign to all potential customers within a target market segment.
• Here a company will use mass communication, interpersonal tools like
advertisement & PR ,DM.
• Interest is next step, showing buyers’ desire to learn more about what(product,
brand, company), and it is trying to trigger a response from target audience to
generate enquiries and encourage the audience to seek out more information.
• Desire is the recognition by the buyer that when a supply needs arise, a particular
brand or a product is a preferred option.
• To reach this point, target customers will evaluate the product, the brand &
company information available from alternative suppliers.
Communication
• These various stages of the state of buyer readiness that is assumed to be rational
over which marketer has control.
• Marketer sends messages via communications tools to affect the attitudes &
behavior of target audiences.
• In reality, customers are not passive recipients of messages who search the
information they want & also send messages to marketing organizations.
• The key to success is to understand the type of information & messages preferred
by customers and the format in which they are required.
• Communications mix: Promotional tools at the business marketer’s disposal are
not interchangeable & their effects at the different stages of purchase process are
not the same.
• So, a company has to select tools and their relative importance in the
communications mix to reflect marketing communication objectives and the way
in which information is used by its target audience.
• Personal, advertising, trade shows, technical literature are most important.
• Now, digital media is added to the list of very important source of communication.
Communication
• Trade shows are the venues where potential buyers visit prospective sellers.
• Most visitors have a specific plan to buy a product or influence the purchase
decision for a particular product.
• In consumer markets intermediaries like retailers, distributors are the means
through which producers are able to present their products to target customers.
• In business markets, distributors as well as producers /suppliers will participate
directly in shows that are specific to their industry.
• There are many sites in different countries where trade shows for different
products are held either once a year or once in two years. (Hannover is the largest,
Mila, Frankfurt, Cologne, Paris etc).
• They can be regional or within a country or international.
• Trade shows can be used to showcase a country’s expertise in a specific industrial
sector. Farnborough Air Show).
• Trade shows perform selling & non selling tasks.
• Non-selling functions include building & maintaining company image, gathering
competitor information, product testing/evaluation, sometimes trying to know the
latest technology available, etc.
Communication
• Key sales related functions are –identification of prospects; gaining access to key
decision makers; disseminating facts about vendor products, services & personnel;
actually selling products; servicing problems of current customers through
contacts.
• A company’s exhibition strategy should complement other communication tools.
• Trade shows are useful in the early stages of the purchase decision process and in
identifying & qualifying prospective new customers.
• As customers progress to evaluating potential suppliers to reach purchase
decision, for closing a sale or service issue, trade shows are less valuable than
personal selling.
• These shows are costly as they demand investments, but can be economical in
terms of company benefits.
• For example, it can cost less to make an initial contact through trade shows
compared to personal visits by sales person.
• A salesperson might be able make 4 to 6 calls a day, trade show participation can
generate 40 to 50 leads in a day.
Communication