2019
2016
2016
2017 2018
Pedoman PMDT WHO 2008
Pedoman PMDT WHO 2011
Pedoman PMDT WHO 2014
Pedoman PMDT WHO 2016
Update Pedoman PMDT WHO 2019
Mengapa
Pengobatan TB RO
Berubah Terus?
Bagaimana Pengobatan TB RO Yang Ideal?
• Efikasi yang baik
• Durasi 3-6 bulan
• Kombinasi 3-4 OAT
• Tanpa Injeksi
• FDC
• Efek Samping lebih sedikit
• Toksisitas lebih rendah
• Paduan OAT yang sama untuk TB RR/MDR/XDR
• ………..
Inovasi dan studi menuju Pengobatan TB RO yang
ideal masih berlangsung
Evidence Based Decision
• Anonymized individual data yang diperoleh dari clinical trial,
kohort/ studi observasi dan data program (STR dan LTR)
dikumpulkan dalam sebuah individual MDR/RR-TB patient
data base (IPD) yang dikelola oleh McGill University, Canada,
yang dikontrak oleh WHO.
• Metode Cochrane untuk meta-analysis digunakan untuk
menilai kontribusi relatif masing-masing obat pada hasil
pengobatan, desain paduan, lama pengobatan yang paling
efektif dan dampak profil resistensi terhadap hasil
pengobatan.
• WHO membentuk suatu Guideline Development Group yang
melakukan review terhadap hasil serangkaian analisis di atas
menggunakan system GRADE untuk mendapatkan scientific
evidence yang digunakan untuk menyusun suatu pedoman
dan rekomendasi yang evidence-based.
2016: 269 Reports until 2014; 54% supportive, 33% contradictory, & 13%
inconclusive on association of salt reduction with reduction in Cardio-
cerebrovascular disease.
Certainty Definition
High Further research is very unlikely to change our confidence in
the estimate of effect.
Moderate Further research is likely to have an important impact on our
confidence in the effect and may change the estimate.
Low Further research is very likely to have an important impact on
our confidence in the estimate of effect and is likely to
change the estimate.
Very low Any estimate of effect is very uncertain.
[conditional recommendation;
very low certainty in the evidence]
Isoniazid-resistant TB (Hr-TB)
Main recommendations (2)
In patients with confirmed rifampicin-susceptible and
isoniazid-resistant tuberculosis, it is not recommended to
add streptomycin or other injectable agents to the
treatment regimen
* Highly effective agent = Lfx, Mfx, Gfx (if DST=susceptible) and Lzd, Bdq,
Imp-Cln, Mpm (unless resistance documented)
Longer MDR-TB regimens
Revised classification of component medicines
GROUP MEDICINES
Group A Levofloxacin OR Moxifloxacin Lfx / Mfx
Bedaquiline Bdq
Linezolid Lzd
Group B Clofazimine Cfz
Cycloserine OR Terizidone Cs/ Trd
Group C Ethambutol E
Delamanid Dlm
Pyrazinamide Z
Imipenem-cilastatin OR Meropenem Ipm-Cln / Mpm
Amikacin (OR Streptomycin) Am (S)
Ethionamide OR Prothionamide Eto / Pto
p-aminosalicylic acid PAS
Longer MDR-TB regimens
Recommendations for regimen design
Relative risk
Duration Comparator Intervention
(95% CI)
IP: 5-6 mo vs 7-8.5 mo 38/623 145/730 aOR 0.9
(6.1%) (19.9%) (0.4 to 2.3)
IP: 6-7 mo vs 7-8.5 mo 38/623 24/554 aOR 0.2
(6.1%) (4.3%) (0.0 to 1.1)
Total: 18-20 mo vs. 20-22 31/1376 87/1407 aOR 2.1
mo (2.3%) (6.2%) (0.7 to 6.1)
After culture conversion: aOR 5.5
12-15 mo vs 15-17 mo 9/537 23/278
(0.9 to
(1.7%) (8.3%)
33.7)
After culture conversion: 9/537 20/1118 aOR 1.2
17-19 mo vs 15-17 mo (1.7%) (1.8%) (0.4 to 3.7)
Longer MDR-TB regimens
Duration – conditional upon patient response
FQ Resistant
Kelompok Umur Tahap Awal Tahap Lanjutan
Dewasa, Remaja, Anak >12 tahun 6-8 LZD*-BDQ-(DLM/PAS)-CFZ- 12 LZD*-CFZ-TRD-(Hhd/ETO)-Z
(>30kg) TRD-(Hhd/ETO)-Z
Anak < 12 tahun (<30kg) 6-8 PAS-(DLM/BDQ)-LZD-CFZ- 12 PAS-LZD-CFZ-TRD-(Hhd/ETO)-Z
TRD-(Hhd/ETO)-Z
PERTANYAAN
UTAMA: STR
• Pada pasien TB RR/ MDR, apakah STR 9-
12 bulan akan meningkatkan
keberhasilan pengobatan dibandingkan
dengan Paduan Pengobatan Jangka
Panjang?
Shorter MDR-TB regimen
Study results
• STREAM Stage 1 trial showed that in patients eligible for the shorter MDR-TB
regimen, the likelihood of treatment success was close to 80% in both arms
• Higher risk of failure or relapse in the shorter regimen when compared with
longer ones, especially when resistance was present or when Group A agents
were included in longer regimens. The shorter regimen had a lower risk of
treatment interruption.
Shorter MDR-TB regimen
STREAM Stage 1 trial – final results
favourable outcome (follow up: mean 132 weeks)
Relative risk
Population Study regimen Control regimen
(95% CI)
mITT RR 1.88*
26/245 (10.6%) 7/124 (5.6%)
population (0.84 to 4.21)