Community of Practices
By:
Sunil Soni
Visiting Faculty
MS Consultancy
Management Program
CDC - BITS Pilani
Dilbert…
2
“The most important challenge in this
economy is creating conversations.”
- Ravi Arora, TATA Steel
3
Knowledge???
4
Organizational frontline…
• Knowledge economy
• What are communities of practice?
– ..they are groups of people informally bound together by
shared expertise and passion for joint enterprise
• software engineers engaged in developing open source OS and
applications,
• consultants who specialize in strategic marketing and so on.
• It may or may not have agenda and even if it does, it may not follow
the agenda closely.
• Inevitably people in CoP share their experiences and knowledge free-
flowing, creative ways that foster new approaches to problems
5
Communities
• Communities of practice
• Learning networks
• Knowledge communities
• Occupational communities
• Communities of practitioners
• Living networks
6
What are CoPs?
7
Definition of Communities of
Practice
Groups of people who come together to share and to learn
from one another face-to-face and virtually.
• A project team
• An permanent organizational structure
• A Web site
• A roundtable, lunch-n-learn
Caution:
• Communities are most effective when they focus
on people-to-people connections, emphasizing tacit
knowledge transfer. While they often use
technology to enable faster, easier, connections,
just having a website WILL not create a community.
9
Why Are CoPs Important?
10
Examples
11
KM Activities
Networks &
- Communities of Practice
CoPs - Networks
- Virtual teams
Explicit
Lower Human interaction Higher
12
Communities: Potential Problems
• Conformity
• Cliques
• Loss of feeling of individual responsibility
• Shared stereotypes
• Self-censorship
• Illusions of invulnerability, unanimity and
morality
• Group polarisation
• Acceptable rather than optimum decision-
making.
13
Symptoms of “Bad” CoPs
14
Symptoms of “Good” CoPs
15
Principles for cultivating CoPs
16
Steps in Creating CoPs
17
CoP Governance
18
Components of CoP
Primary Component
Community: All participation
and facilitating members
19
Scope of Governance
Framework
Should facilitate all types of participation
20
Governance Roles in a CoP
Executive Sponsor
Leader KM Catalysts
Members
SIG Leader SIG Leader
CoP Guests
Member
Experts
Guests
21
CoP and Organizational
Performance
Organizational
Performance
Improve
Social Capital
Connections
Relationships
Common Context
• Decrease Learning Curve
Create • Increase Customer Responsiveness
• Reduce rework & prevent reinvention
• Increase Innovation
CoP
22
Business outcomes & social capital
link
• Decrease learning curve
– Connections: Find experts
– Relationships: Mentor and coach new employees
– Context: Understand the rules of the organization
• Increase customer responsiveness
– Connections: Find individuals with similar experiences
– Relationships: Develop willingness to respond to random questions
– Context: Understand the common language
• Reduce rework & prevent reinvention
– Connections: Find artifacts and the individuals who developed them
– Relationships: Establish positive reputation
– Context: Understand situational nature of knowledge
• Increase innovation
– Connections: Leverage weak ties that provide exposure to new ideas
– Relationships: Build safe environment for brainstorming and testing
new ideas
– Context: Understand which problems are of common interest
23
Case Study CoPs in IT Services
Company
• Agile • Java Technologies
• Application Management • KEN
– Estimation and Solution
Design • Mainframe Technologies
– Innovation and Competitive • Microsoft Office
Analysis – Excel, Outlook, Power
– ITIL Point, Project, Visio,
– Service Transition Word
– Solution Delivery • Microsoft Technologies
• AS400 – Dot Net , MOSS 2007
• BI-DW • Project Management
• Database – PMP Study Group
– Oracle, SQL Server, Sybase
• Software Estimation
• Enterprise Architecture
– CORBA, Enterprise • Software Requirement
Integration, MDA, SOA & • Telecom Practice
Web Services – Products Group
• ERP • Testing Services
– SAP
• Unix
24
CoPs in Action: Snapshot of
Activities
• Face to face sharing sessions
• Discussion threads
• White papers creation
• Solution offering
• Ask the expert
• K Café
• Debates
• Quiz
• Survey
• Conferences
• Unconference
• Collate best practices / Do’s and Don’t / Tips
• Process improvements
• Benchmarking
• Study tours
25
Knowledge Management
Lecture 14
Measuring Knowledge Management
By:
Sunil Soni
Visiting Faculty
MS Consultancy
Management Program
CDC - BITS Pilani
Chapter Objectives
27
Is Knowledge Manageable ?
29
Classification of KM Measurements
• Qualitative Analysis
• Quantitative Analysis
• Financial Indicator Analysis
• Non-Financial Indicator Analysis
• Internal Performance Analysis
• External Performance Analysis
• Project-Orientated Analysis
• Organizational-Orientated Analysis
30
Qualitative Analysis
31
Quantitative Analysis
32
Qualitative and Quantitative
Assessments of KM
High
Qualitative and Quantitative
Qualitative Measures
Level of Use of
Measures
Quantitative Measures
Low
Low High
Level of Experience with Knowledge Management
33
Financial Indicator Analysis
34
Non-Financial Indicator Analysis
35
Internal Performance Analysis
36
External Performance Analysis
37
Project-Orientated Analysis
38
Organizational-Orientated Analysis
• Organizational-orientated analysis is
focused on the entire organization, on the
multi-dimensional and multi-layering
aspects of the firm.
• Horizontal perspectives
– leadership, cultural, technological, and process
dimensions.
• Vertical perspectives
– strategy, management, and implementation
layers.
39
Popular KM Measurement Tools
40
The Balanced Scorecard (BSC)
• Multidimensional
measurement system
takes into
consideration the
following perspectives
– Financial
– Customer
– Internal Business
Processes
– Learning and Growth
Source www.balancedscorecard.org
41
KM Result Measurement (1)
Human Capital
- Training expenditures
- Organizational learning
- Employee commitment
- Management experience
Innovation Capital
- R&D expenditures
- Percentage of workforce envolved in
innovation
- Product freshness
- Copyright, trademarks/patents
42
KM Result Measurement (2)
Customer Capital
- Satisfaction
- Perceived product/service quality
- Duration of relationship
- Repeat orders
- Sales/customer
KM Process Stage Identification
- Number of contacts in KM database
- Number of topics in KM database
- Hit rate
- Productivity
43
KM Result Measurement (3)
44
Measuring Intellectual Capital (IC)
5 areas of focus
History
• Financial Financial Focus
45
Illustrative Measures of Key Aspects of
KM Solutions
Dimension Illu
Knowledge Nu46
Assessment of Impacts
47
Illustrative Measures of Impacts on
People
Dimension
Employee
learning 48
Illustrative Measures of Impacts on
Organizational Processes
Dimension
Efficiency 49
Illustrative Measures of Impacts on
Organizational Products
D im e n 50
Illustrative Measures of Impacts on
Organizational Performance
51
What is Knowledge Audit
52
Why Audit?
53
Why Audit? (cont.)
54
Why should you conduct Knowledge
Audit
55
Process of Knowledge Audit
56
Knowledge Management
Conclusion to Knowledge
Management
By:
Sunil Soni
Visiting Faculty
MS Consultancy
Management Program
CDC - BITS Pilani
Topics of the Day
• Divesting Knowledge
• Knowledge Worker
• IP protection
• KM Certification
58
KM Cycle
Get Assess
59
Knowledge Divest stage
60
Divesting Knowledge
61
Divestiture decisions
62
Responsibilities of the CKO
63
Role of the CKO
• Agent of change
• Investigator
• Linking pin
• Listener
• Politician
64
Key CKO Attributes
65
CKO’s Success Factors
66
Incentives and Motivation for
Knowledge Workers
67
Relationship of Ethics &
Protecting
Intellectual Property
(IP) & KM
Ethics
• Difficult to define
• Means different thing to
different people
• Ethics is one or all of the :
Fairness, equity, honesty,
trustworthiness and equality
• Principles of right and
wrong. It assumes
individuals are acting as
free moral agents to make
choices to guide their
behavior.
69
Five Moral Dimensions of the Knowledge
Age
• System quality
• Quality of life
70
Few common terms for Knowledge
Ethics
71
Ethical Analysis
72
Ethical Principles
• Golden Rule: Do unto others as you would have them do unto you
• Immanuel Kant’s Categorical Imperative: If an action is not right
for everyone to take, then it is not right for anyone
• Descartes’ rule of change: If an action cannot be taken repeatedly,
then it is not right to be taken at any time
• Utilitarian Principle: Take the action that achieves the greatest
value for all concerned
• Risk Aversion Principle: Take the action that produces the least
harm or incurs the least cost to all concerned
• Ethical “no free lunch” rule: Assume that all tangible and
intangible objects are owned by someone else, unless shown the
contrary. If someone has created something of value to you, that
person probably wants compensation for your use
73
Protecting Intellectual Property (IP)
74
IP losses can happen in many ways:
• Employee turnover.
• Physical theft of sensitive proprietary documents, either by
outsiders or by insiders.
• Inadvertent disclosure to third parties without a non-
disclosure agreement.
• Reverse engineering.
• The Web repository security is breached and unauthorized
access to the proprietary documents takes place.
• Unauthorized parties intercept electronic mail, fax,
telephone conversation or other communications for the
purpose of illicitly acquiring knowledge.
• Attempts by insiders or outsiders to corrupt documents or
databases with false data, information, or knowledge.
75
How to protect the organization
from IP losses
• Non-disclosure Agreements
• Patents: Grant to the creator of an invention
granting the owner an exclusive monopoly on the
ideas behind an invention for 20 years
• Copyrights: Statutory grant protecting intellectual
property from being copied for the life of the author,
plus XX years
• Trade Secrets: Intellectual work or product
belonging to business, not in the public domain
• Designing policies to limit employee turnover
• Educating employees about the types of
knowledge they should not share with their
peers in other organizations
76
IP protection awareness creation
effort
• Academic institutions
• Research and development institutions
• Industry ( goods and service)
• Government departments and ministries
( law making, regulating, funding for
research )
• Attorney firms
• Courts
• NGO
77
Legal Issues of Knowledge Based
Systems
78
KM Certification
KM Institute
80
KM Professionals/KM Practitioners - Your
Benefits
• The KM Institute provides instructional and non-instructional KM content for
both KM professionals and knowledge workers. It partner with KM providers
who have proven KM solutions to form a complete KM solution infrastructure.
• KM Institute is developing the KM Body of Knowledge and it continues to
enrich its broad KM curriculum, unequaled anywhere. A curriculum that
includes "Personal KM" and other special topics. KM Institute has become
the acknowledged global standard for KM certification programs.
• Blended training programs include face-to-face and virtual
workshops, and selected components of the eCKM™ programs, as
well as live-over-internet viewing (this is already being delivered in India).
• Local KM Institutes have already formed in Australia, India, Kuwait,
Malaysia, Romania, Singapore, South Africa, Switzerland, the United
Kingdom, and the U.S., with further expansion planned to serve the KM
learning needs of the world.
• Local KM Institute Chapters are forming in major cities. Since there
are no KM Institute membership fees; any dues are optional.
81
How to Contact KM Institute
General: info@kminstitute.org
Training: training@kminstitute.org
Partnering Opportunities:
partner@kminstitute.org
KM Body of Knowledge:
kmbok@kminstitute.org
82
e-Certified Knowledge Manager eCKM™
• Who Should Take the eCKM?
– KM Practitioners tasked to lead a KM initiative - from mid to senior-level managers.
• Learn to:
– Perform KM using KM Metrics, KM Sciences and Benchmarking
– Build Collaborative Environments; better communication, spark innovation
– Transform your organization or customer into a true "Learning Organization"
– Establish a Knowledge Audit, plus innovative ways to do Knowledge Mapping
– Create the KM Vision for your company, including a solid strategy to get there
– Initiate with peers successful Communities of Practice
– Discover usable, real-world KM principles and keys to success
– Show employer or customer you can lead a successful KM initiative!
• What You Will Get:
– Full content of the acclaimed Certified Knowledge Manager course
– Approx. 20 hours of in-class video from actual CKM workshops
– 4 Themes/50 modules: Compelling animated graphics and additional interactive content
– Interactive quizzing throughout
– Live Mentoring sessions with Instructor
– CKM designation/certification awarded upon completion and successful evaluation
– Acceptance into the official CKM Alumni Association - a global network of CKM Grads
– And, the eCKM features internationally acclaimed speaker/instructor, Douglas Weidner
(KM Institute Chairman), as your instructor and mentor!
• Pricing
– The eCKM is listed at US$2,995 in the U.S., but varies in price depending on your country
of residence.
83
Conclusion
KM: A new Paradigm for Decision-
Making
• The development of MIS, Decision Support
Systems, and KMS has been influenced by the
works of five influential philosophers, namely,
Leibniz, Locke, Kant, Hegel, and Singer.
• Recent developments in KMS have also
enabled to extend the reach of those involved
in the solution, through group support systems.
• As globalization expands, the number of
stakeholders affected by the organization
increases.
85
KM helps Decision making based on
multiple perspectives
• Technical perspective
• Personal and individual perspective
• Organizational and social perspective
• Ethics and aesthetics perspective
86
Looking at the future
87
…from progress in information
technologies
• KM will benefit from continual, and even more
dynamic, progress in information technologies
• Improvements in cost/performance ratios of IT
have caused the cost of digitizing information to
approach zero, and the cost of coordinating across
individuals, organizational sub-units, or
organizations to approach zero as well.
• "evolutionary agents" may be dramatically
different in their abilities to:
– build theories and create a world of their own
– assume any virtual identity they wish
– possess free will
– develop a moral code and a value system of their own
88
toward integrating knowledge from differe
perspectives
• KM will continue the shift toward bringing together, and
effectively integrating, knowledge from a variety of
different perspectives.
• KM originated at the individual level, focusing on the
training and learning of individuals.
• The impact of KM is expected to continue with its use
across networks of organizations and across
governments, enabling collaborations across historical
adversaries and integrating knowledge across highly
diverse perspectives and disciplines.
89
…make trade-offs in numerous
important areas
• Same communication technologies that
support the sharing of knowledge within
an organization also enable the knowledge
to leak outside the organization to its
competing firms.
• It is essential to maintain a balance
between using technology as substitutes
for people (e.g., software agents) and
using technology to enable collaboration
from a wider range of people within and
across organizations.
90
KMS Topics Covered
91
Conclusions
92