College of Business Business Management Department MBA Degree Program A CASE REPORT ON
Group No.2 Castillo Ronald Panopio, Rolalie Reyes, Heinz Zhangpeng, Allen
1. Case Background
Events take place from the viewpoint of Carol Sullivan-Diaz, the 28-year old general manager of Sullivan Ford Auto World.
In 1983, Walter Sullivan purchased a small Ford dealership, which will eventually grow to become Sullivan Ford Auto World (Auto World). Auto World offers both sales (front end) and service (back end) of vehicles.
10 June 2011 GROUP 2: Sullivan Ford Auto World 3
y Walter recently died of a heart attack. y Carol needs to analyze which of two options was the right move to make:
To quickly sell Auto World and move on with her life? or To work on a turnaround and make the company financially viable?
10 June 2011
Auto World Car sales of 1,100 cars per year Total annual revenues of around US$ 29.5 million from both sales and services But Still... Auto World ranked at the lower end of medium sized dealerships Margins were low and gross figures were insufficient to cover the companys fixed expenses
10 June 2011 GROUP 2: Sullivan Ford Auto World 5
Auto Worlds financial situation had been deteriorating for the past 18 months; y New car sales had declined; y Margins had been squeezed by promotions and other efforts to sell; y Due to rising fuel prices, industry and in-house forecasts for future sales were discouraging; and y Service revenues were below average.
10 June 2011
Customer satisfaction surveys showed a problem with the companys delivery of services, to wit:
y
Less than 33% of the respondents said that they had been introduced to someone in Auto Worlds service department Over-all level of satisfaction with Auto Worlds service was consistently ranked Low placing it in the bottom 25% of all Ford dealerships
GROUP 2: Sullivan Ford Auto World 7
10 June 2011
y For interpersonal variables such as attitude of service department personnel, Auto Worlds ratings were relatively poor y More than 50% of respondents indicated that they would use another Ford dealer or some other place for maintenance service. y The rating for overall satisfaction was below average.
10 June 2011 GROUP 2: Sullivan Ford Auto World 8
10 June 2011
To determine what other potentials might exist for Auto World to improve its sales volume and selling gross. To determine how marketing cars is different from marketing service for the same vehicles. To know the differences between the sales and service departments at Auto World. To identify, from a consumer perspective, useful parallels between running a car sales and service dealership and operating health care services? To give Carol Sullivan-Diaz good advice on how to improve service quality in Auto World.
10 June 2011
10
Selling Auto World now would also mean selling it at a loss. Auto Worlds service work order process was still done manually and had not been computerized.
10 June 2011
11
1 PREPURCHASE STAGE
10 June 2011
12
1
AWARENESS OF NEED
4
MAKING A PURCHASE DECISION
PREPURCHASE STAGE
2
INFORMATION SEARCH
3
EVALUATION OF ALTERNATIVE SOLUTIONS & SUPPLIERS
10 June 2011
13
Servuction Model
10 June 2011
14
Fully Focused
Service Focused
Market Focused
10 June 2011
15
10 June 2011
I.Internal analysis Strengths Carols experience, knowledge and expertise Technically skilled and competent staff Attractive showroom Favourable location Well known dealership Huge amount of insurance policy on Sullivans life
16
Weaknesses Inappropriate attitude of service staff Lack of interpersonal skills of service manager Problems with service writers High turnover of service staff Revenues are falling Poor appearance of service department and waiting area Service procedures not customer oriented Inefficient recording and bookkeeping Carol has only six-weeks to resolve the dealership problems
10 June 2011
17
External Analysis Opportunities Develop new markets Change of management by introducing a service culture and providing training programs Use of advanced technology
Advantage
y y
Disadvantage Extended hours are required from Carols Carols heart is not in auto service industry Carol may lack the necessary experience and influence to handle the disagreements between the service and sales departments
y y
Carol is an owner and therefore is expected to y have a high level of loyalty to Auto World y Carol has personal knowledge of Auto Worlds y operations and she knows how to provide good service to their clients and co-employees Carol can apply her experience in the health care industry which revolves around designing new services, handling complaints, & market research Carol is only 28 years old. She brings with her innovative and fresh ideas Carol will have a chance to personally save the business that her father worked so hard to build
10 June 2011
19
6. Alternative Courses of Action (continued) 2. To Engage a Service Marketing Expert With a Background in Sales to Run Auto World
Advantage y Will not require Carol to lose her present job y The new service marketing expert will be able to view things objectively without being affected by existing relationships and biases y Since the new service marketing expert is also good in sales, he or she will be able to formulate strategies to increase profits Disadvantage y Will entail additional cost y The new service marketing expert may not be aware of the existing culture in Auto World since he is an outsider y The level of loyalty may not be as high as that of Carol s
10 June 2011
20
3. To Accept Bills Offer to Buy Auto World on an As-Is Basis at a Low Price
y
y y
Advantage If Auto World is no longer viable, y then selling it now will cut further losses Carol will be able to continue in her y chosen career heath care services There might be a connection between Walters sudden heart attack at a relatively young age and the pressures he was experiencing with his business Carol will be able to avoid this
Disadvantage If Auto World is still viable, then Carol would be missing out on an opportunity to increase profits The act of giving up and selling what her father worked so hard to build might not look good in Carols resume
10 June 2011
21
7. Recommendation
Utilize Carols Background and her Masters Degree In Business Administration To Improve Auto Worlds Quality of Services
Option No.1 is recommended because of the following reasons: Because of her long exposure to her fathers business, Carol is in the best position to pinpoint the areas that need to be improved. Carols MBA degree gives her valuable advantage in terms of scientific methodology and discipline. Carols background as a marketing strategist in the health care industry will be very useful as the auto sales and service industry is similar in many ways.
10 June 2011 GROUP 2: Sullivan Ford Auto World 22
8. Action Plan
Computerise all service operations to cut on turn-around time and avoid clients long waiting hours. Hire service marketing expert to run the service department with a keen sense of salesmanship. Engage services of training consultant to provide customer care programs for the entire service department staff. Service personnel will thereafter be encouraged to meet with clients and to discuss the clients concerns. Design and implement an audit program to check on after-sales services provided to clients. Reward employees with high evaluations and impose sanctions on those who fail. Hire attractive and well trained receptionists for the service department, which should be renovated to have a warm and friendly ambience. Maintain the promotions and discounts to continuously improve the volume of sales. Hire one or more mechanics to maximize the use of equipment and facilities. Monitor if the protocols and process are organized and being followed.
10 June 2011 GROUP 2: Sullivan Ford Auto World 23
10 June 2011
24
THE END