Chapter Two

Stakeholder And Issues Management Approaches

Copyright 2003 by SouthWestern, a division of Thomson Learning

Chapter Topics
1. Why use a stakeholder management approach for business ethics? 2. Stakeholder management approach defined 3. How to execute a stakeholder analysis 4. Stakeholder approach and ethical reasoning 5. Moral responsibilities of functional area professionals 6. Three issues management approaches 7. Two crisis management approaches
Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning 2

Why Use A Stakeholder Management Approach For Business Ethics?

The stakeholder approach is a response to the growth and complexity of understanding and study of the modern corporation and its influence on the environment. The ethical dimension of this approach is based on the view that:
Profit maximization is constrained by justice Regard for individual rights should be extended to all constituencies that have a stake in the affairs of a business Organizations are not simply or only economic in nature but can and do act in socially responsible ways, not only because it is the right thing to do, but also to ensure their legitimacy

Examine the Microsoft case

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Stakeholder Management Approach Defined

The stakeholder approach provides a framework that enables users to map and ideally, manage the corporations relationships, both present and potential, with groups to reach win-win collaborative outcomes. It does not have to result from a crisis or controversial situation. It can be used as a planning method to anticipate and facilitate business decisions, events, and policy outcomes. Business units, teams, and groups can use this approach.
4

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Stakeholder Management Approach Defined

Stakeholder: any individual or group who can

affect or is affected by the actions, decisions, policies, practices, or goals of the organization. Primary stakeholders of a firm: owners, customers, employees, and suppliers. Secondary stakeholders: all other interested groups such as the media, consumers, lobbyists, courts, governments, competitors, the public, and society. Stakes: any interest, share, or claim that a group or individual has in the outcome of a corporations policies, procedures, or action toward others.
5

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

How To Execute A Stakeholder Analysis

The stakeholder approach is a pragmatic way of identifying and understanding multiple, often competing, political, social, legal, economic, and moral claims of many constituencies. The stakeholder analysis is a series of steps aimed at the following tasks:
Mapping stakeholder relationships Mapping stakeholder coalitions Assessing the nature of each stakeholders interest Assessing the nature of each stakeholders power Constructing a matrix of stakeholder moral responsibilities Developing specific strategies and tactics Monitoring shifting coalitions
6

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Stakeholder Approach And Ethical Reasoning

The stakeholder analysis is an analytical method where no prescribed ethical principles or responsibility rules are built-in. Ethical reasoning in the stakeholder analysis means asking:
What is equitable, just, fair, and good for those who affect and are affected by business decisions? Who are the weaker stakeholders in terms of power and influence? Who can, who will, and who should help weaker stakeholders make their voices heard and encourage their participation in the decision process and outcomes?
7

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Moral Responsibilities Of Functional Area Professionals

One goal of a stakeholder analysis is to encourage and prepare organizational managers to articulate their own moral responsibility, as well as the responsibilities of the company and their profession, toward their different constituencies. Stakeholder analysis focuses the enterprises attention and moral decision-making process on external events. This approach applies internally, especially to individual managers in and across traditional function areas.
8

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Moral Responsibilities Of Functional Area Professionals

Traditional functional and expert areas include:
Marketing Research and development (R& D) Manufacturing Public relations Human resource management (HRM)

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Three Issues Management Approaches

First Approach: 6-Step Issue Management Process
Most straightforward More appropriate for companies or groups trying to understand, manage, and control their internal environments Involves the following steps:
Environmental scanning and issues identification Issues analysis Issues ranking and prioritizing Issues resolution strategizing Issues response and implementation Issues evaluation and monitoring
10

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Three Issues Management Approaches

Second Approach: 7-Phase Issue Development Process
Issues are believed to follow a developmental life cycle Life-cycle stages suggested for tracking an issue:
A felt need arises Media coverage is developed Interest group development gains momentum Policies are adopted by leading political jurisdictions The federal government gives attention to the issue Issues and policies evolve into legislation and regulation Issues and policies enter litigation
11

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Three Issues Management Approaches

Third Approach: 4-Stage Issue Life Cycle
Thomas Marx observed that issues evolve from social expectations to social control through the following steps:
Social expectations Political issues Legislation Social control
12

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Two Crisis Management Approaches

First Approach: Precrisis Through Resolution
According to this model, a crisis consists of four stages:
Prodromal (precrisis)
Warning stage

Acute
Damage has been done

Chronic
Clean-up phase

Resolved
The crisis management goal
13

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Two Crisis Management Approaches

Second Approach: Reaction Through Accommodation
Five phases of corporate social response to crises related to unsafe products, or product crisis management include:

Reaction
A crisis has occurred The company is overwhelmed by public attention

Defense Insight

Most agonizing time

Addressing public pressure and anxiety Company attempts to understand the causes
14

Accommodation Agency

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Two Crisis Management Approaches

Suggestions that corporations can follow to respond more effectively to crises include:
Face the problem Take your lumps Recognize that there is no such thing as a secret or private crisis Stage war games Use the firms philosophy, motto, or mission statement Use the firms closeness to customers and end users for early feedback
15

Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning

Two Crisis Management Approaches

Issues and crisis management methods and preventive techniques are effective in corporations only if:
Top management is supportive and participates Involvement is cross-departmental The issues management unit fits with the firms culture Output, instead of process, is the focus
Copyright 2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning 16