3991
P-ISSN 0126-1754
E-ISSN 2337-8751
Kata Kunci: flavonoid, Plumeria alba, skoring eritema, SPF, dan UV filter.
ABSTRACT
UV filters are necessary since UV rays are harmful to human skin. UV filter compounds in commercial sunscreen products can cause
adverse effects. Thus, natural UV filters containing flavonoids, e.g. Frangipani (Plumeria alba Linn.) leaves, are needed. This research
examined the use of flavonoids from P. alba leaf as a UV filter with in vitro and in vivo. Maceration was performed with 70% ethyl alco-
hol and liquid-liquid extraction for flavonoid purification. Parameters tested were total flavonoid compounds, SPF value, and clinical
symptoms of the melanogenesis inhibition scoring. The purification result was 43.6%. The flavonoid concentration in pure extract (64.4
mg QE /g) was higher than crude extract (57.6 mg QE/g). The highest SPF value (33.88) was observed in pure extract at 1400 mg/mL,
while the same concentration of crude extract resulted in a lower SPF value (33.06). Pearson correlation analysis (0.536) indicated a di-
rectly proportional relationship between SPF value and extract concentration. In vivo analysis was performed by scoring between 0-4
following the severity of erythema. After 21 days of sunlight exposure, the worst erythema was found in the negative control group (score
1.292). The best result was found in the group treated with pure extract 1400 mg/ml (score 0.542).
*Kontributor Utama
*Diterima: 28 Agustus 2020 - Diperbaiki: 7 November 2020 - Disetujui: 8 Juni 2021
191
Berita Biologi 20(2) - Agustus 2021
Frangipani (Plumeria alba L.) is a plant extraction process lasted for 5 days at 25oC with the
containing flavonoids. Dawood et al. (2016) have jar closed, protected from sunlight, and stirred for
shown that the leaf of P. alba contain flavonoids the first 24 hours. The extract was filtered using
like quercetin and rutin which have been reported filter cloth to separate liquid from the remaining
to act as UV filters (Choquenet et al., 2008; Marcos leaf debris. The filtrate was then evaporated at 40oC
et al., 2016). Frangipani plants are widely for ± 4 hours, until the extract became thick, to
distributed in Indonesia and can grow and produce the crude extract.
reproduce without requiring special treatment
(Wrasiati et al., 2011). Frangipani plants have Purification extract
multiple varieties, one of which is white frangipani Purification of the P. alba leaf extract was done
(P. alba ). to obtain the pure extract which contains flavonoids
Frangipani leaf extract has been utilised as as target metabolic compounds. Purification was
an anti bacterial against Staphylococcus aureus carried out by liquid-liquid extraction method based
(Ningsih et al., 2014), P. alba flower essential oil on Kusnadi and Devi (2017). A total of 50 g of
as mosquito repellent aroma therapy (Nurcahyo and crude extract was placed in separating funnels with
Purgiyanti, 2017), and P. alba flower extract as an 30 mL n-hexane as the solvent, then shaking it until
anti-bacterial against S. aureus and Salmonella the two-phase separation occurred. The upper phase
typhi (Rupianiasih et al., 2019). Based on several is the n-hexane solution with the non-polar
existing studies, the flower is the most commonly compounds from the extract, while the lower phase
utilized component of the plant, while the leaves contains the polar compounds in the extract such as
have seen little research. Seeing the potential of P. flavonoids. The lower phase was then collected on
alba leaf, this study aimed to test the effective ness a porcelain cup and evaporated in the water bath at
of flavonoids from Frangipani leaf extract as UV 40oC until it thickened. This was then categorized
filters on the skin of Wistar rats that exposed to as a pure extract.
sunlight for 21 days.
Determination of the quantity of flavonoid
MATERIALS AND METHODS content
Tools and materials Determination of the quantity of Flavonoid con-
Test tube, micropipette, blender, oven, rotary tent in samples was based on a standard curve that
vacuum evaporator, UV-Vis Spectrophotometer, a uses pure quercetin as a standard solution. Standard
set of surgical instruments (surgical scissors and solutions are made with ethanol 70% as solvent and
scalpel), 100 mesh sieve, 250mL separating funnel, concentrations of 40, 50, 60, 70, 80, 90, and 100
water bath, and filter cloth. ppm quercetin. The concentration of Flavonoids
Plumeria alba leaves were sampled from was analyzed in both crude and pure extract. 1 mL
housing complexes around Kalasan, Sleman, of each sample was analyzed with the addition of
Yogyakarta. The wet weight of P. alba leaf used 0.2mL of 10% AlCl3, 0.2 M of Potassium acetate,
was 7 kg. Male Wistar rats aged 9 weeks weighing and adding up to 10 mL of distilled water. After 30
150–200 g were used as test animals on in vivo SPF minutes, the absorbance of the sample was
value testing, Aquadest, Aluminium chloride measured at a wavelength of 431 nm.
(AlCl3) 10%, Ethanol 70%, n-Hexane, Potassium
Acetate (CH3COOK) 1M, and methanol pro ana-
lyse (p.a). Determination of in vitro SPF value
In vitro SPF measurements were carried out to
Sample preparation test the effectiveness of P. alba leaf extract as a UV
Plumeria alba leaves washed, removed the filter before being tested on animals (in vivo). SPF
major veins, sliced (± 1 cm), and dried in an oven at value measurements were carried out using a spec-
60oC for ± 5 days. The dried leaves were then trophotometer at a wavelength of 290–340 nm with
blended and sifted with a 100 mesh sieve. The intervals of 5 nm. The pure and crude extracts were
resulting sample was stored in a plastic container first diluted in 70% ethanol solution to the concen-
with the addition of silica gel sachets to keep the tration of 600 mg/mL, 800 mg/ml, 1000 mg/ml,
sample in a dry state. 1200 mg/ml, and 1400 mg/ml. The SPF value was
determined using the Mansur et al. (1986)
Extraction formulation (Sayre et al. (1979).
Plumeria alba leaf extraction was carried out
using a maceration method, with ethanol 70% as *CF = Correction Factor (10), EE = Erythemal
solvent. A total of 1.573 g dried P. alba was put Effect of Radiation, I = Solar Intensity Spectrum.
into a glass jar and 70% ethanol was added until the
powder was covered to a height of 3 cm. The Determination of P. alba leaf extract effectivity
192
Artikel Penelitian
Angreini et al. – Effectiveness of Frangipani Leaf Extract as a UV Filter
Table 1.The result of Flavonoid determination of P. alba leaf extract (Hasil pengukuran kadar
Flavonoid dari ekstrak daun P. alba)
193
Berita Biologi 20(2) - Agustus 2021
Figure 1. Calibration curve of quercetin in 431 nm wavelength (Kurva kalibrasi kuersetin pada panjang
gelombang 431 nm)
Determination of in vitro SPF value Pearson correlation value of 0.563 (p < 0.01, R2
The SPF value was determined based on 0.961, Table 4). Pearson’s correlation is considered
Mansur’s (1986) equation, by measuring the strong between 0.40 to 0.599 (Kirom, (2015) in
absorbance at the wavelength of 290 - 320 nm, at 5 Rufaidah et al., (2019)). The R squared (R2) value
nm interval (Sayre et al., 1979). The highest SPF of 0.961 means that 96.1% of the SPF value is
value was obtained in pure extract of 1400 mg/mL, influenced by differences in concentration and type
which was 33.88. Extract concentration and SPF of extracts, while the 3.9% of the SPF value is
value showed a positive correlation both in the influenced by other factors.
crude extract and pure extract as evidenced by the
Table 2.The result determination of in vitro SPF value from P. alba leaf extract
(Hasil Pengujian nilai SPF secara in vitro dariekstrak P. alba).
Comparison between Flavonoid Concentration tion, the higher the flavonoid content and it also
towards SPF Values increases the SPF value. Regression value (R2) ob-
Comparison between extract concentration, fla- tained shows a good level of confidence because it
vonoid concentration and SPF value is directly pro- is close to 1 (Figure 2 and 3).
portional where the higher the extract concentra-
194
Artikel Penelitian
Angreini et al. – Effectiveness of Frangipani Leaf Extract as a UV Filter
Figure 2. Relationship of Flavonoid concentration and SPF value in Crude extract (Hubungan antara konsen-
trasi Flavonoid dan nilai SPF pada sampel ekstrak kasar)
Figure 3. Relationship of Flavonoid concentration and SPF value in pure extract (Hubungan antara konsen-
trasi Flavonoid dan nilai SPF pada ekstrak murni).
195
Berita Biologi 20(2) - Agustus 2021
Determination of P. alba leaf extract effectivity test group animals which received the application
as a UV filter (in vivo Testing) of pure extract of 1400 mg/mL with the lowest av-
Statistical analysis (Annova, R2 0.964, p=0.023) erage erythema score (0.542), while the largest ery-
indicates that there is a significant effect of thema score (1.292) was in the negative group of
treatment on the severity of erythema in the test test animals which only received distilled water
animals’ skin. The best results are observed in the treatment (Table 6).
Table 4. Average scoring of in vivo testing result on white rats (Rattus novergicus)
[Skoring rerata hasil pengujian in vivo pada tikus putih (Rattus novergicus)].
196
Artikel Penelitian
Angreini et al. – Effectiveness of Frangipani Leaf Extract as a UV Filter
Non-polar phase
Polar phase
Figure 4. Purification process of Plumeria alba leaf extract (Proses purifikasi dari ekstrak daun Plumeria
alba)
The resulting flavonoid content in pure extract spread of melanin in cells (Muller and Rees, 2014).
was higher than in the crude extract (Table 3). This The test was carried out by exposing the rats to the
showed that flavonoid isolation carried out had sun for 1 hour per day (11.00 to 12.00 WIB) for 21
separated the flavonoids from other remaining non- days. The treatment was divided into 3 groups
polar compounds in the crude extract. Previous namely the positive group which received
studies of flavonoid concentration in frangipani (P. commercial sunscreen before exposure, the
alba) leaf have been carried out by Dawood et al. negative group only received distilled water before
(2016), using methanol as a solvent, with a final exposure and the treatment group which received
flavonoid concentration of 74.7 mg QE/g. The dif- PE extract with a concentration of 1400mg/mL,
ference in this result is possibly due to the different which had the best SPF value. The application
solvent that was used. The higher flavonoid content process was carried out 30 minutes before
in the pure extract compared to crude extract was exposure. Observation of test animals was done
also supported by the SPF value that higher in the every 3 days based on the statement of Baumanand
pure extract (Table 5). The concentration of extract Saghari (2009) that pigmentation begins 2-3 days
was shown to have a significant and positive linear after exposure.
relationship with the SPF value evidenced by the The results revealed that the application of pure
positive Pearson correlation value and p < 0.001. he extract with a concentration of 1400 mg/mL(group
highest SPF value was found in the pure extract C) produced the lowest score (0.542), followed by
with the concentration of 1400 mg/mL (SPF 33.88). the positive control group (group B) that received
Based on the categorisation of sunscreen according commercial sunscreen (0.792), and the highest was
to the Food and Drug Administration, The SPF the negative control group (group C) (1.292). The
value of 33.88 is in ultra-protection category which deviation score between the positive control group
indicates that the pure extract of 1400 mg/mL has a and the negative control group was 0.25 which was
high ability to protect against UV rays (Ismail et not very large. It is suggested that the lower scoring
al., 2014). The higher the concentration of the of erythema in thetreated rat group compared to the
extract used, the higher the concentration of positive control was due to the higher SPF value in
flavonoid it contains. This increases the ability of the extract. In other ways, the extract’s color which
the extract to function as a UV filter as evidenced is black-green also affecting the result, supported
by an increase in the SPF value (Table 4). The by Wilson et al. (2018), where dark color such as
concentration with the highest SPF value (pure dark green, red, dark blue and black providing good
extract, 1400 mg/mL) was used in in vivo testing to protection through UV rays, while the darker
determine its effectiveness against erythema shades have been associated with the higher UV
prevention. protection value.
In vivo testing used male Rattus novergicus of The appearance of rat skin from the positive
the age 8-12 months, to avoid other effects such as control group and the treatment group immediately
the estrogen hormone which plays a role in and 30 minutes after application can be seen in
increasing the amount of melanin in cells and the Figures 5 and 6. The red circle indicates the
progesterone hormone which can increase the application area.
197
Berita Biologi 20(2) - Agustus 2021
Figure 5. Positive control group (a) afterthe basting of comercial sunscreen (b) 30 minutes after the basting
[Kelompok kontrol positif (a) setelah pengolesan tabir surya komersil (b) 30 menit setelah
pengolesan]
Figure 6. Treatment group (a) after the basting of Pure extract 1400 mg/mL (b) 30 minutes after the basting
[Kelompok perlakuan (a) setelah dioles ekstrak murni 1400mg/mL (b) 30 menit setelah pengolesan]
The results of the average erythema scoring had a large effect on the fluctuation of three daily
value obtained an R square (R2) value of 0.964 erythema scoring of the rats. Fluctuation in the
which showed that 96.4% of erythema observed on score at each observation day indicates that UV
the skin of test animals was influenced by filter testing with in vivo method using sun
differences in treatment while the rest (3.6%) was exposure is less effective. Documentation of the
influenced by factors other than differences in the appearance of rat’s back skin before sun exposure
treatment. Some of these factors include the can be seen in Figure 3 and the appearance of rat’s
behavior of the rats to lie over each other when back skin after 21 days of exposure can be seen in
exposed to sunlight which causes differences in Figure 4, where the erythema is marked by a red
scores between mice within a group. Weather also circle.
Figure 7. Rat’s skin on the first day before sun exposure (H 0) (a) Group of negative control (b) Group of
positive control (c) Treatment group [Kulit tikus sebelum dipapar matahari (H0) (a) Kelompok
kontrol negatif (b) Kelompok kontrol positif (c) Kelompok perlakuan].
198
Artikel Penelitian
Angreini et al. – Effectiveness of Frangipani Leaf Extract as a UV Filter
Figure 8. Rat’s skin on the 21th day after sun exposure (H21) (a) Group of negative control (1.242) (b) Group
of positive control (0.792) (c) Treatment group (0.542) (Kulit tikus setelah 21 hari pemaparan (H21)
(a) Kelompok control negatif (1.242) (b) Kelompok kontrol positif (0.792) (c) Kelompok perlakuan
(0.542)).
199
Berita Biologi 20(2) - Agustus 2021
200