6@**@Uit @ML| |i ,giU|t Lu

@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 5)t|i4t

*TTi aLhL?
N?iht|) Lu @*uLh?@ @| Wh?i

a*) 2ff2

6Lh|UL4?}c
aLh?@* Lu +t! E6@** 2ff2 @?_
@?! Lu ,?}*@?_<t 6?@?U@* 5|@M*|) +ii E#iUi4Mih 2ff2

Sklolssh Mrulrq lv surihvvru ri qdqfh dw wkh Judgxdwh Vfkrro ri Pdqdjhphqw dw wkh Xql0
yhuvlw| ri Fdoliruqld~Luylqh1

Wkdqnv duh gxh wr vhplqdu sduwlflsdqwv dw wkh Edqn ri Hqjodqg1 L dovr dfnqrzohgjh xvhixo
glvfxvvlrqv zlwk Vxoh|pdq Edvdn/ Mhuhp| Ehunrzlw}/ Mlp R*Eulhq/ dqg Ylfwruld Vdsruwd1

Fruuhvsrqghqfh fdq eh dgguhvvhg wr=

Sklolssh Mrulrq/
Judgxdwh Vfkrro ri Pdqdjhphqw
Xqlyhuvlw| ri Fdoliruqld dw Luylqh
Luylqh/ FD <59<:06458
+<7<, ;5708578
H0pdlo= smrulrqCxfl1hgx
 6@**@Uit @ML| |i ,giU|t Lu
@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 5)t|i4t

At T@Tih |@!it @?L|ih *LL! @| @**i}@|L?t |@| ht! 4@?@}i4i?| t)t|i4t
UL?|hM|i |L ?Uhi@ti_ L*@|*|) ? €?@?U@* 4@h!i|tc ? T@h|U*@h _h?} |i
544ih Lu bbH Ai @?@*)tt t|@h|t | @ hii Lu |i *|ih@|hi L? |i
igiU| Lu €?@?U@* i?}?iih?} L? €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t Ai i_i?Ui t |@| €?@?U@*
??L@|L?t hi_Ui L*@|*|) ? €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t M| tii4 |L Mi t)t|i4@|U@**)
M*@4i_ uLh |i LTTLt|i igiU| Ai T@Tih @*tL ThL_it ?i i_i?Ui L? |i
TL|i?|@* igiU| Lu V+M@ti_ 4@h!i| ht! U@h}it uLh UL44ihU@* M@?!t ?_ih
|i @ti* UULh_ W tL |@| V+M@ti_ hi}*@|Lh) U@T|@* U@h}it U@??L|
T*@tM*) Mi M*@4i_ uLh |i L*@|*|) Lu bbHc _i |L |ih ih) t*L hitTL?ti |L
4@h!i| 4Li4i?|t
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 

Ai *@t| _iU@_it @i |?itti_ @ hiL*|L? ? €?@?U@* ht! 4@?@}i4i?| "@?||@|i
|iU?^it tU @t LT|L? ThU?}c TLh|uL*L ?th@?Uic @?_ V@*i @| +t! EV+ @i MiUL4i
itti?|@* |LL*t Lu TLh|uL*L 4@?@}i4i?| Ai UL?UiT|t Lu TLh|uL*L ?th@?Ui @?_ _)?@4U
i_}?} ihi _ii*LTi_ ? |i *@|i b.ft V+ @t €ht| 4i?|L?i_ ? bbc @*|L} |i
UL?UiT| }Lit M@U! |L @h!L|3 EbDb V+ t @? @}}hi}@|i 4i@thi Lu _L?t_i ht!c
_i€?i_ @t |i 4@ 44 *Ltt Lih @ |@h}i| Lh3L? tU |@| |ihi t @ *Lc ThitTiU€i_
ThLM@M*|) |@| |i @U|@* *Ltt ** Mi *@h}ih
Ai }i?ih@*3i_ ti Lu |iti |iU?^itc Liihc @t h@ti_ UL?Uih?t |@| |i) UL*_
@U|@**) 4@!i €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t *itt t@ui |@? MiuLhic M) U@t?} }ih L*@|*|) 5U
UL?Uih?t @i |@!i? @__i_ h}i?U) @t hi}*@|Lht @hi ?L |h??} |L U@T|@* @_i^@U) hi
^hi4i?|t |@| hiiU| |i €?@?U@* ht!t Lu hi}*@|i_ ?t|||L?t 5?Ui )i@hi?_ bb.c ?
T@h|U*@hc UL44ihU@* M@?!t @i Mii? @**Li_ |L ti |ih ?|ih?@* V+ 4L_i*t |L UL4
T|i |ih 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i E+c U tL*_ Mi ULihi_ M) @ 4?44 @4L?| Lu
U@T|@*
L?U_i?|@**)c |i V+M@ti_ 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i U@4i ?|L i t|i?Ui ? bbHc @ )i@h
Lu UL?t_ih@M*i |hM*i?Ui ? €?@?U@* 4@h!i|tc U t|@h|i_ | |i +tt@? _iu@*| @?_
U*4?@|i_ ? |i ?i@hM@?!hT|U) Lu wL?}Aih4 @T|@* @?@}i4i?| EwA
At iTtL_i *i_ |L @ M@U!*@t @}@?t| ht! 4@?@}i4i?| |iU?^it 5L4i LMtihiht ?L|i_
|@| @U|@* *Lttit tgihi_ M) €?@?U@* ?t|||L?t __ i Uii_ V+ 4i@thitc tL4i|4it M)
*@h}i @4L?|t W? u@U|c |t t4T*) hiiU|t i**!?L? *4|@|L?t Lu V+2 ih@Tt tiht
ihi ***i_ ?|L @ u@*ti ti?ti Lu tiUh|)c U t tL4i@| @t|L?t?} t?Ui V+ ?4Miht
tL*_ Mi i Uii_i_ | tL4i hi}*@h|)c | @ uhi^i?U) ?ihti*) hi*@|i_ |L |i UL?€_i?Ui
*ii*
Lhi LhhtL4i t |i U@h}i |@| |i ti Lu V+ *4|t *i_ |L @ RULt U)U*i Lu
TLt|L? U||?} M) |h@_ihtc U T| @__|L?@* _L?@h_ Thitthit L? ThUit 5U U*@4
@t Mii? @_@?Ui_ M) #?M@h E2fff ? t MLL! L? wAc M) iht@_ E2fffc @?_ @t Mii?
4 Wkh Edvho Frpplwwhh rq Edqnlqj Vxshuylvlrq +EFEV, dphqghg wkh ruljlqdo 4<;; Edvho Dffrug wr dgg
d fdslwdo fkdujh iru pdunhw ulvnv1 Vhh EFEV +4<<8,1
5 Vhh wkh uvw hglwlrq ri Mrulrq*v +5333, errn rq YDU1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2

iULi_ ? |i Thitt Ai @h}4i?| t |@| tL4i tLU! ? L*@|*|)c t@) _i |L |i +tt@?
_iu@*|c ?Uhi@tit |i V+ Lu L|t|@?_?} TLt|L?t W? bbbc |i ,UL?L4t| @t @h}i_ |@|c
@t V+ }Lit Tc @ RM@?! t |i? u@Ui_ | |L ULUitG T| ? i |h@ U@T|@* Lh hi_Ui |t
TLt|L?tc @|iih @?_ ihiih |i) 4@) Mi At t @| @TTi?i_ *@t| @|4? t
|i @h}4i?| }Litc tiih@* M@?!t UL*_ ti** |i t@4i @tti| @| |i t@4i |4ic Uhi@|?} }ih
L*@|*|) @?_ ULhhi*@|L?tc U i @UihM@|it |i ?|@* igiU|c uLhU?} @__|L?@* t@*it Ai
ThTLti Lu |t T@Tih t |L @ttitt i|ih tU t|@|i4i?|t @i @?) uL?_@|L? ? hi@*|)
At *?i Lu @h}4i?| tL*_ Mi @ tihLt tLhUi Lu UL?Uih? }i? |i }i?ih@*3i_ |hi?_
|L@h_ ht!ti?t|i U@T|@* @_i^@U) hi^hi4i?|t Ai Uhhi?| hitL? Lu |i @ti* Uhi_|
ht! U@h}itc _MMi_ R@ti* WWc @*tL }L ? |i _hiU|L? Lu 4Lhi ti?t|i ht! U@h}ite Ai
Lhh) t |@| |i _it}? Lu tU U@T|@* @_i^@U) hi^hi4i?|t 4}| _it|@M*3i |i €?@?U@*
t)t|i4c M) ?_U?} M@?!t |L |}|i? Uhi_| @t Uhi_| ht! ?Uhi@titc ThiUti*) @| |i hL?}
|4i ? @ hiUittL? At ThLtTiU| Lu RThLU)U*U@*|) t Tih@Tt |i 4Lt| 4TLh|@?| tti
u@U?} M@?! hi}*@|L? |L_@)D
W| t Mi)L?_ |i tULTi Lu |t T@Tih |L _tUtt ThLU)U*U@*|) Lu Uhi_| ht! h*it Ai
RULt UhU*i @h}4i?| uLh 4@h!i| ht! U@h}itc Liihc t Mi?} }i?ih@*3i_ |L Uhi_| ht!
@t @ Uh|Ut4 Lu @?) ht!ti?t|i U@T|@* hi^hi4i?|tS `i tL*_ @*tL ?L|ic Liihc |@|
tU Uh|Ut4t u@* |L Lgih T*@tM*i @*|ih?@|it Ai t|Lh) Lu u@*hit ? M@?!?} t)t|i4t
@?_ i?Lh4Lt ULt|t L? |i iUL?L4) ThL_it @ TLihu* h@|L?@*i uLh hi}*@|L?. O@?}
?L U@T|@* hi^hi4i?| @| @** t ?L| hi@*t|U *|ih?@|i*)c U@T|@* hi^hi4i?|t |@| @hi ?L|
4@h!i|ti?t|ic tU @t |i Lh}?@* @ti* bbH UULh_c @hi LTi? ?|@|L?t |L hi}*@|Lh)
@hM|h@}i @?_ U@? Tihihti*) ?_Ui M@?!t |L ?Uhi@ti |ih ht!t
At T@Tih ** tL |@| U@T|@* hi^hi4i?|t tL*_ Mi UL?t|hU|i_ tL @t |L Mi hi@
6 Dv txrwhg lq wkh Hfrqrplvw/ Mxqh 45wk 4<<<1 Vhh dovr wkh vwulqj ri Hfrqrplvw duwlfohv +Rfwrehu 4:/ 4<<;,/
+Qryhpehu 47/ 4<<;, rq wkh vdph wkhph1 Wklv olqh ri dujxphqw lv hyhq uhfrjql}hg e| fhqwudo edqnhuv~vhh
Fohphqwl +5334,1
7 Vhh EFEV +5334,1
8 Vhh iru lqvwdqfh Huylq dqg Zlogh +5334, dqg Erulr hw do1 +5334,1
9 Vhh Gdqlhovvrq hw do1 +5334,/ _Dq Dfdghplf Uhvsrqvh wr Edvho LL1%
: Vhh iru lqvwdqfh Fdsulr dqg Nolqjhelho +4<<<,1 Krjduwk dqg Vdsruwd +5334,/ iru lqvwdqfh/ hvwlpdwh wkdw
w|slfdo orvvhv iurp edqnlqj fulvhv frvw dq dyhudjh ri 48 wr 53 ri dqqxdo JGS1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 

tL?@M*) Rt4LL| Lih |4ic Mi |i) uLh 4@h!i| Lh Uhi_| ht! At u@U| @t itU@Ti_ 4Lt|
Lu |i *|ih@|hi L? V@*i@|+t!c ihi |i uLUt @t Mii? ?i@hi U*ti*) L? _ii*LT
?} @UUh@|i _@) L*@|*|) uLhiU@t|t ?i ?L|@M*i i UiT|L? t ht|Lgihti? @?_ #iML*_
E2fffc L tL |@| |ihi t tU@?| i_i?Ui Lu Thi_U|@M*|) Lu L*@|*|) @| Lh3L?t *L?}ih
|@? |i? _@)t|ih 4TLh|@?| LMiU|itc Mi)L?_ @UUh@U)c @hi |i @ih@}i *ii* Lu U@T|@*
@t i** @t U|@|L?t ? U@T|@* hi^hi4i?|t
Ai ThTLti Lu |t T@Tih t |L i @4?i t)t|i4@|U@**) i|ih 4@h!i| ht! U@h}it @i
@_ @ _it|@M*3?} igiU|c T@h|U*@h*) _h?} bbH Ai T@Tih t44@h3it |i *|ih@|hi L?
|LTUt tU @t |i igiU| Lu ht! 4@?@}i4i?| |LL*t @?_ ThL_it ?i i4ThU@* i_i?Ui L?
|i @U|@* Mi@Lh Lu 4@h!i| ht! U@h}it W| @*tL _h@t *ittL?t uLh |i ULUi Lu L*@|*|)
4L_i*t @?_ t4LL|?} Lu U@T|@* U@h}it
`i @?@*)3i |hii hi*@|i_ ttitc U @hi U*@tt€i_ ?|L Ru@**@Uit h|Ut Lu €?@?U@*
i?}?iih?} t@**) t|@h| | |i LMtih@|L? |@| €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t @i hiUi?|*) MiUL4i
4Lhi L*@|*ic UL?Uhhi?|*) | |i _itThi@_ ti Lu ht! 4@?@}i4i?| |iU?^it At t
@| i U@** R6@**@U) G Ai }i Lu 6?@?U@* W?t|@M*|)c U t @?@*)3i_ ? 5iU|L? 
5iU|L? 2 |i? |h?t |L @ hii Lu |iLhi|U@* @?_ i4ThU@* i_i?Ui L? R6@**@U) 2G Ai
+L*i Lu 6?@?U@* ,?}?iih?} 6?@**)c 5iU|L?  |@!it @ _i|@*i_ *LL! @| R6@**@U) G Ai
+L*i Lu V+ Ai *@t| tiU|L? UL?|@?t tL4i UL?U*_?} LMtih@|L?t
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit e

 6@**@U) G Ai }i Lu 6?@?U@* W?t|@M*|)

h|Ut4t Lu 4L_ih? ht! 4@?@}i4i?| t)t|i4t t@**) t|@h| | |i U@t@* LMtih@|L?
|@| €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t @i *@|i*) MiUL4i 4Lhi L*@|*iH b
u|ih @**c |ihi L*_ Mi *itt
hi@tL? uLh UL?Uih? u |t @t ?L| |i U@ti
,@U €?@?U@* Uhtt tii4t |L }i?ih@|i @ TihL_ Lu ?|i?ti hiiU|L? @t |L |i U@ti Lu |i
*@|it| Uhttc @t i** @t @ hh) Lu hi4@h!t |@| tU Uhtit @hi MiUL4?} 4Lhi uhi^i?| ?
|i L|ih @?_c |ihi t ?L tU ht |L i T*@? ) 4@h!i|t @i MiUL4i *@|i*) tL T*@U_
i? ?L|?} @TTi?t
Bi? |i @ttih|L? |@| E €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t @i MiUL4i hiUi?|*) ?t|@M*ic @?_ |@|
E2 ht! 4@?@}i4i?| 4i|L_t @i Mii? _ii*LTi_ hiUi?|*)c |t @ttLU@|L? t i |i?_i_ |L
U@t@|L? W? L|ih Lh_tc ht! 4@?@}i4i?| |iU?^it @hi t@_ |L *i@_ |L }ih L*@|*|)
wi| t €ht| i @4?i |i Thi4ti Lu |i R@}i Lu €?@?U@* ?t|@M*|) @h}4i?|
4L?} i4ih}?} 4@h!i|tc i tii4 |L @i i Tihi?Ui_ 4@?) hiUi?| €?@?U@* Uhtit
,i? u |t ihi |i U@tic Liihc | t ?L| U*i@h |@| €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t Lh ht! 4@?@}i4i?|
|iU?^it tL*_ Mi M*@4i_ Li4i?|t ? €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t ?i|@M*) @UUL4T@?) €?@?
U@* *Mih@*3@|L? Ai T t_i Lu L*@|*|) t @UUitt |L L|t_i U@T|@*c U t @ tMt|@?|@*
Mi?i€| u | ?_Uit }ih *L?}|ih4 iUL?L4U }hL| W? @__|L?c L?i UL*_ @h}i |@|
|i hiUi?| L*@|*|) ? i4ih}?} 4@h!i|t t _i |L ?tt|@?@M*i }Lih?4i?| TL*Uitf
Lhi u?_@4i?|@**)c i4ih}?} 4@h!i|t @hi |i hL?} T*@Ui |L *LL! uLh |i igiU| Lu
ht! 4@?@}i4i?| |iU?^itc U @hi Uih|@?*) 4Lhi it|@M*ti_ ? tLU@**i_ R_ii*LTi_
4@h!i|t 5Lc |i ^it|L? tL*_ Mic Wt |ihi @?) i_i?Ui |@| 4@Lh €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t @i
; Vhh _Wkh Djh ri Ilqdqfldo Lqvwdelolw|/% Ilqdqfldo Wlphv/ 46 Mxqh 53341
< Lw frxog eh dujxhg wkdw juhdwhu yrodwlolw| lq qdqfldo pdunhwv lv dfwxdoo| ehqhfldo
li lw gdpshqv yrodwlolw|
lq wkh uhdo hfrqrp|1 Frqvlghu/ iru h{dpsoh/ wkh fkrlfh ehwzhhq d h{leoh h{fkdqjh udwh dqg d {hg udwh/
lqfoxglqj wkh h{wuhph fdvh ri d frpprq fxuuhqf|1 D frpprq fxuuhqf| wudqvplwv vkrfnv dfurvv hfrqrplhv
dqg pd| fuhdwh juhdwhu yrodwlolw| lq rxwsxw dqg hpsor|phqw1 Shukdsv lw lv ehwwhu iru ulvnv wr dsshdu lq
qdqfldo pdunhwv/ zkhuh wkh| fdq eh khgjhg dqg glyhuvlhg/ udwkhu wkdq ehlqj vkliwhg wr wkh uhdo hfrqrp|1
43 Pruh jhqhudoo|/ wkh odwh Ilvfkhu Eodfn +4<<8, hyhq dujxhg wkdw jryhuqphqwv duh uhvsrqvleoh iru fuhdwlqj
v|vwhplf ulvn1 Kh lqfoxghv dv h{dpsohv lqwhuihuhqfh zlwk exvlqhvv/ zlwk wkh hqirufhphqw ri frqwudfwv/ dv
zhoo wkh fuhdwlrq ri ghew jxdudqwhhv1 Lqghhg/ edqnlqj v|vwhpv wkdw jr edqnuxsw duh qhduo| dozd|v gxh wr
jryhuqphqwv1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit D

MiUL4i 4Lhi L*@|*i ? hiUi?| |4itq

AL ti_ tL4i *}| L? |t ttic 6}hi  T*L|t |i 4L?|*) L*@|*|) uLh N5 i^|it
Lih |i *@t| Ui?|h) Ai }h@T _Lit ?L| }i @?) tTTLh| |L |i |iLh) Lu }ih hiUi?|
ht! VL*@|*|) @TTi@ht |L Mi hi4@h!@M*) t|@M*i Lih |iti *@t| ?_hi_ )i@ht W? u@U|c |i
*@h}it| ThUi 4Lit LUUhhi_ _h?} |i _iThittL? Lu |i bft Ai Uh@t Lu bH. @t @
*@h}i *Lttc M| Uih|@?*) ?L| L| Lu *?i | L|ih iTtL_it _h?} |t Ui?|h)

6WBN+,  L?|*) +i|h?t L? N5 ,^|itG bff2fff

% p e r m o n th
40

30

20

10

-1 0

-2 0

-3 0
1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990

A@M*i  }it @?L|ih TihtTiU|ic UL?|?} LUUhhi?Uit Lu 4L?|*) *Lttit }hi@|ih |@?
DI L? N5 t|LU!t M) _iU@_i Lit }hi@|ih |@? DI @hi @*tL hiTLh|i_ uLh }L*_ @?_ |i
#%m i U@?}i h@|i Ai |@M*i }it ?L ?_U@|L? |@| |iti 4@h!i|t @i hiUi?|*) MiUL4i
4Lhi L*@|*i W?t|i@_c |i bbft i Tihi?Ui_ @ML| @*u |i LUUhhi?Uit Lu *@h}i *Lttit |@?
|i bHft VL*@|*|) ? |iti 4@h!i|t tii4t |L Mi }L?} _L?c ?L| T
*|ih?@|i*)c i U@? i @4?i |i uhi^i?U) Lu €?@?U@* Uhtit _h?} |t Ui?|h) Lh_L
i| @* E2fff ThL_i @ *t| Lu Uhhi?U) @?_ M@?!?} Uhtit t?Ui HHf uLh @ € i_ t@4T*i Lu 2
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit S

UL?|hit 6}hi 2 _tT*@)t |i ?4Mih Lu Uhtit Tih _iU@_i t |iti @|Lht ?_U@|ic
RUhtit ihi UhL?U ThLM*i4t ?L| t| Lu |i bbft M| ? |i ThiUi_?} )i@ht @t i**

Aw,  UUhhi?Uit Lu w@h}i L?|*) @h!i| Li4i?|t

wLttit Lit Lit
: DI : DI : DI
#iU@_i 5: BL*_ #%m
bfft e
bft f
b2ft b
bft D
beft 
bDft D
bSft f
b.ft e ef H
bHft b e 2
bbft D H 2
5LhUiG |Lh<t U@*U*@|L?t

At i_i?Ui t tTTLh|i_ M) *L?}|ih4 t|Lhit Lu L|ih 4@h!i|t ?_ihtL? @?_ hii
_L? E2fffc uLh i @4T*ic i @4?i €u|) )i@ht Lu @tti| ThUi L*@|*|) ? |i N?|i_ k?}_L4
Ai) hiTLh| |@| |i L*@|*|) Lu t|LU!t @?_ ?|ihit| h@|it i?| T ? |i i@h*) b.ftc U
@t @ TihL_ Lu } ?@|L?c M| @i Mii? L? @ _L?@h_ |hi?_ |ihi@u|ih Ah??} |L
U@tit Lu ThUi L*@|*|)c |i) €?_ ?L i_i?Ui Lu @?) *?! |L €?@?U@* ??L@|L? Lh hi}
*@|L? W?t|i@_c @tti| ThUi L*@|*|) tii4t t|hL?}*) ?i?Ui_ M) ?@|L? ht!c L|T|
}hL| ht!c @?_ 4@UhLiUL?L4U TL*U) hi}4it W? L|ih Lh_tc @tti| ThUi L*@|*|) t
4@?*) _hi? M) u?_@4i?|@*t ,i? tLc hiUi?| L*@|*|) @t Mii? *Lih |@? @ih@}i
Atc |i @h}4i?| Lu R|i @}i Lu €?@?U@* ?t|@M*|) tii4t |L Mi @i_c @t €?@?U@*
4@h!i|t @i Mii? ?L 4Lhi ?t|@M*i hiUi?|*) |@? Lih |i T@t| Ui?|h)

44 D_fxuuhqf| fulvlv% lv ghqhg iurp hlwkhu d fkdqjh lq sdulw| ydoxh/ ru odujh mxps lq d frpelqdwlrq ri
wkh vsrw udwh/ lqwhuhvw udwh/ ru ohyho ri uhvhuyhv1 D _edqnlqj fulvlv% lv lghqwlhg zlwk wkh hurvlrq ri prvw ri
wkh fdslwdo ri wkh edqnlqj v|vwhp1 Wkh frxqwulhv duh Dujhqwlqd/ Dxvwudold/ Ehojlxp/ Eud}lo/ Fdqdgd/ Fkloh/
Ghqpdun/ Ilqodqg/ Iudqfh/ Jhupdq|/ Juhhfh/ Lwdo|/ Mdsdq/ Qhwkhuodqgv/ Qruzd|/ Sruwxjdo/ Vsdlq/ Vzhghq/
Vzlw}huodqg/ XN/ dqg wkh XVD1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit .

6WBN+, 2 6hi^i?U) Lu 6?@?U@* htit E2L?|h) 5@4T*i

Number per decade
40

35
Banking Crises
30
Currency Crises
25

20

15

10

0
1880 1890 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990

2 6@**@U) 2G Ai +L*i Lu 6?@?U@* ,?}?iih?}

Ai tiUL?_ 4@Lh u@**@U) UL?tt|t Lu M*@4?} 4L_ih? €?@?U@* i?}?iih?}c tU @t TLh|uL*L
?th@?Ui Lh V+ t)t|i4tc uLh Uhi@|?} i Uitt L*@|*|) ? €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t

2 Ai +L*i Lu Lh|uL*L W?th@?Ui

Lh|uL*L ?th@?Ui @4t @| @Ui?} T@)Lg T@||ih?t t4*@h |L *L?} LT|L? TLt|L?t t t
i** !?L?c @ *L?} TLt|L? ? @ T| U@? Mi hiT*U@|i_ M) L*_?} @ uh@U|L?c {c Lu |i @tti|
| tL4i MLhhL?} Lh *i?_?}  Ai T| t hiT*U@|i_ M)

R' {7 n E

6Lh ?t|@?Uic | 7 ' mff @?_ 2SI @??@* L*@|*|)c @ )i@h @||i4L?i) T| UL*_ Mi
hiT*U@|i_ M) @ TLt|L? Lu { ' fe. ? |i @tti| T*t *i?_?} L|  ' mD.c uLh @ |L|@*
L|*@) Lu R ' mf
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit H

 !i) ?t}| Lu |i *@U!5UL*it Eb. LT|L? ThU?} 4L_i*c t |@|c uLh *L?} LT|L?
TLt|L?tc |i i_}i h@|L t @? ?Uhi@t?} u?U|L? Lu |i tTL| ThUi Wu 7 _hLTt |L t@) mbfc
{ }Lit |L fS2c U hi^hit ti**?} fD ?|t Lu |i @tti| At *i@_t |L @ T@||ih? Lu
|h@_?} ihi u@**t ? 7 Uhi@|i *Lih E?i}@|i _i*|@tc @?_ i?Ui 4Lhi ti**?} wL?} LT|L?
TLt|L?t U@? Mi _)?@4U@**) hiT*U@|i_ M) ti**?} ? u@**?} 4@h!i|t2 Mti?| @?) L|ih
igiU|c |t UL*_ Mi |L}| Lu ?Uhi@t?} L*@|*|)
W?_ii_ TLh|uL*L ?th@?Ui @t Mii? _i*) M*@4i_ uLh @}}h@@|?} |i Uh@t Lu bH.
Ai tLU@**i_ Rh@_) +iTLh| |LL! |i TLt|L? |@| TLh|uL*L ?th@?Ui @t |i Ui?|h@*
U@ti Lu |i bH. Uh@t At i t _i*) _tT|i_c Liih
**ih Ebb @h}i_ |@| |i Uh@t Lu bH. @t _i |L @ Mhi@!_L? ? 4@h!i| t|hU|hitc
i |i @__|L?@* ?Uih|@?|) _i |L |i ?@M*|) Lu |i v5, |L @?_*i @M?Lh4@* |h@_?}
L*4it W? u@U|c L?i Lu |i ui hiUL44i?_@|L?t Lu |i h@_) hiTLh| @t |L ?t|||i
|h@_?} @*|tc U LTiu**) tL*_ }i i?L} |4i |L ThiT@hi uLh 4@h!i|t |L U*i@h
? |i |iLhi|U@* uhL?|c |i *@|it| Lh! t |@| Lu @t@! E2fffc L UL?t_iht @ }i?ih@*
i^*Mh4 4L_i* Lu |i iUL?L4) | TLh|uL*L ?th@?Ui 5U 4L_i*t @hi tiu*c @t |i)
UL?t_ih |L|@* @**LU@|L? igiU|t ? @ 4*|T*iTihL_ uh@4iLh!
Ot UL?U*tL? t |@| 4@h!i| L*@|*|) @U|@**) _iU*?it i? 4Lhi ?it|Lht Mi@i @t
TLh|uL*L ?thiht Ai ?||L? t |@| TLh|uL*L ?thihtc L @hi 4Lhi ht! @ihti |@?
L|ihtc U@? tu| UL?t4T|L? uhL4 }LL_ t|@|it Lu |i Lh*_ |L M@_ L?itc ?Uhi@t?} |i @*i
Lu |i 4@h!i| ? M@_ t|@|it Lu |i Lh*_ ? |i L|ih @?_c @__?} R|hi?_U@tiht @t @?
@4M}Lt igiU| L? 4@h!i| L*@|*|)
?i _h@M@U! Lu |iLhi|U@* 4L_i*t t |@| | t tL4i|4it _U*| |L |i** i|ih |ih
4T*U@|L?t _iTi?_ i@*) L? |ih @tt4T|L?tc U U@? Mi tMiU| |L _gihi?Uit Lu
LT?L? 5|**c |iLhi|U@* 4L_i*t ThL_i *||*i tTTLh| uLh |i i |@| TLh|uL*L ?th@?Ui
?Uhi@tit 4@h!i| ht!t
t uLh |i i4ThU@* i_i?Uic |i U@**i?}i t |L _it}? |it|t |@| tiT@h@|i L| |i igiU|
45 Vhh Uxelqvwhlq +4<;8, iru dowhuqdwlyh sdwkv wr sruwirolr lqvxudqfh1
46 Irupdoo|/ e| wkh Suhvlghqwldo Wdvn Irufh rq Pdunhw Phfkdqlvpv +4<;;,1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit b

Lu ht! 4@?@}i4i?| |LL*t uhL4 L|ih igiU|t ?i tU T@Tih t |@| Lu +L** EbHHc L
i @4?it |i Uh@t Lu bH. @UhLtt |i Lh*_ Oi UL?U*_it |@| TLh|uL*L ?th@?Ui tL*_
?L| Mi M*@4i_ @t |i @ih@}i _iU*?i ? |i D 4@h!i|t ? U | @t ti_ @t *itt |@?
|i @ih@}i _iU*?i Lu |i H 4@h!i|t ? U | @t ?L| ti_

22 Ai +L*i Lu |ih |L4@|U Ah@_?} +*it

,i? tLc | tL*_ Mi TL?|i_ L| |@| 4@?) L|ih |h@_?} h*itc *L?} it|@M*ti_ MiuLhi
TLh|uL*L ?th@?Ui Lh 4L_ih? ht! 4@?@}i4i?| |iU?^itc U@? @*tL UL?|hM|i |L @ Th@U|Ui
Lu ti**?} ? @ u@**?} 4@h!i|

 AiU?U@* Ah@_?} +*itG Ahi?_uL**L?} t)t|i4t @*tL ti** @u|ih ThUi _hLTt

 @h}? @**tG wiih@}i_ ?it|4i?|t U@? *i@_ |L 4@h}? U@**t uLh *L?} TLt|L?t @u|ih
ThUit @i u@**i?c *i@_?} |L uLhUi_ *^_@|L? u ?it|Lht U@??L| UL4i T | |i
hi^hi_ @__|L?@* 4@h}?

 +iM@*@?U?} | wiih@}iG 5U?@t @?_ 54| E2fff _i4L?t|h@|i |@| |i Th@U
|Ui Lu hiM@*@?U?} |L € i_ i}|t | *iih@}i @*tL Uhi@|it t4*@h |h@_?} T@||ih?t
At @t ?L|?} |L _L | 4@h}? U@**t M| ?t|i@_ t _i |L |i u@U| |@|c @u|ih @
ThUi u@**c |L|@* i@*| _hLTt u@t|ih |@? |i ThUic ?iUitt|@|?} @ _iUhi@ti ? |i ht!)
TLt|L?e

 5|LTwLttitG Ai Th@U|Ui Lu U||?} *Lttit @u|ih @ u@** ? |i ThUi 4@) Mi Th_i?|
M| @*tL ?L*it ti**?} @? @tti| @u|ih |t ThUi @t u@**i?

,@U Lu |iti h*it UL*_ Mi RM*@4i_ uLh ?Uhi@t?} ht! @h}?t uLh ?__@* ?it|Lhtc
uLh ?t|@?Uic @i *L?} Mii? UL?t_ihi_ | ttTUL? W?_ii_ |ihi @t @ _i*) i*_ i
@t |@| |i Uh@t Lu U|LMih b2b @t RU@ti_ M) |i €?@?U@* *^_@|L? Lu t@hit ?
47 Frqvlghu iru lqvwdqfh d srvlwlrq ri '433 lqyhvwhg dv 533( lq d ulvn| dvvhw zruwk '433 dqg 0433( lq fdvk1
Li wkh sulfh idoov wr ';3/ wkh sruwirolr lv qrz zruwk '93/ ru '493 lq wkh dvvhw dqg 0'433 lq fdvk1 Uhedodqflqj
wr {hg zhljkwv/ zh kdyh '453 lq wkh dvvhw dqg 0'93 lq fdvk1 Khqfh/ wklv lqyroyhv vhoolqj wkh dvvhw diwhu wkh
sulfh ihoo1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit f

hitTL?ti |L 4@h}? U@**t t @ hit*|c |i 5iUh|it @?_ , U@?}i U| Lu be |h@?tuihhi_
4@h}?ti||?} @|Lh|) |L |i 6i_ih@* +itihi 5)t|i4
5?Ui |i?c Liihc |t i @t Mii? _tUhi_|i_D Oti @?_ **ih Ebbfc uLh
?t|@?Uic i @4?i |i Thit4i_ *?i Lu U@t@|L? uhL4 *Lih 4@h}?t |L }ih L*@|*|)
Ai) €?_ ?L i4ThU@* i_i?Ui |L tTTLh| |t W?t|i@_c |i) tL |@| }ih 4@h}?
Uhi_| L*4i ELh 4Lhi MLhhL?} t hi*@|i_ |L *Lih L*@|*|) 5?Ui *Lih 4@h}?t *i@_t |L
}ih 4@h}? Uhi_| L*4ic |i *?i Lu U@t@|L? t @U|@**) LTTLt|i |L |i UL44L? iG
*Lih 4@h}?t Uhi@|i 4Lhi tTiU*@|L?c 4Lhi *^_|) @?_ @U|@**) *Lih L*@|*|)
54*@h ttTUL?t tii4 |L thhL?_ @?) €?@?U@* ??L@|L? u|ih i^|) LT|L?t ihi
?|hL_Ui_ L? |i U@}L L@h_ T|L?t , U@?}i ? b.c |i 5, 4TLti_ @ 4Lh@|Lh4
|@| ttTi?_i_ |i ?|hL_U|L? Lu ?i LT|L?t Ai ui@h @t |@| |iti ?i ?t|h4i?|t
UL*_ _it|@M*3i 4@h!i|t W? u@U|c tMti^i?| @U@_i4U hiti@hU @t uL?_ |@| |i ?|hL
_U|L? Lu LT|L?t t @U|@**) @ttLU@|i_ | *Lih L*@|*|) Lu ?_ih*)?} t|LU!tS
W? @ tTiU@* U@|i}Lh) @hi UL?|?}i?| hi^hi4i?|t At ?L*it tiUh|it | U*@tit
|@| }i ?it|Lht @TT@hi?| ThL|iU|L? ? U@ti |i MLhhLih<t Uhi_| h@|?} Lh t|LU! ThUi
_i|ihLh@|it ?i |)Ti ?L*it LT|L?t }?} ?it|Lht |i h}| |L ti** |ih t|LU! Lh ML?_t
|L |i €h4 ? i U@?}i uLh @ € i_ @4L?| Lu U@t ?L|ih @hi Rh@|?}t |h}}ihtc U
Uhi@|i @__|L?@* hi^hi4i?|t uLh |i MLhhLih tL*_ | Uhi_| h@|?} _iU*?i `*i tL4i
@hi Mi?}?c tU @t |i LM*}@|L? |L ?Uhi@ti ULTL? T@)4i?|tc L|iht U@? hi^hi u**
hiT@)4i?| Lu |i _iM| 5U U*@tit @hi TLT*@h | MLhhLihtc L U@? *Lih |ih ULt|tc
@?_ ?it|Lhtc L Mi*ii |@| tU tiUh|it @hi t@uih |i? L|ihti
L?|?}i?| hi^hi4i?|t U@? U@ti tihLt |hLM*i Ai) Uhi@|i U@**t L? *^_|) ThiUti*)
? t|@|it Lu |i Lh*_ ihi |i UL4T@?) t u@h?} M@_*)c T||?} uh|ih Thitthit L? |i
UL4T@?)<t *^_|) W?_ii_ |h}}iht ? tL4i Lu ,?hL?<t tiUh|it uLhUi_ |i UL4T@?) |L
4@!i *@h}i U@t T@)4i?|t @?_ ThLTi**i_ | ?|L M@?!hT|U) +@|ih |@? Lgih?} ThL|iU|L?c
48 Vhhwkh uhylhz e| Nxslhf +4<<;,1
49 Vhh Ghwhpsoh dqg Mrulrq +4<<3, iru hylghqfh rq X1V1 vwrfnv1 Vlplodu uhvxowv zhuh irxqg iru Fdqdgldq
dqg X1N1 vwrfnv1 Dv rswlrqv lqyroyh kljk ohyhudjh dqg wkh htxlydohqfh ri vkruw0vhoolqj/ wkhvh uhvxowv fdq eh
lqwhusuhwhg lq whupv ri plwljdwlrq ri vkruw0vdohv frqvwudlqwv1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 

|iti U*@tit U@? |h}}ih M@?!hT|U)c @giU|?} @** Uhi_|Lht @_ihti*) `*i |iti U*@tit
@hi }*) ?@_t@M*ic |i) @hi ? @ tTiU@* U@|i}Lh) MiU@ti |i) Uhi@|i _hiU| U*@4t L?
@ UL4T@?)<t *^_|) *tLc MiU@ti |i U*@tit @hi MLhhLihtTiU€Uc |i) _L ?L| Uhi@|i
t)t|i4U ht!
|ihtic @** Lu |iti h*it }i?ih@|i T@||ih?t Lu |h@_?} t4*@h |L TLh|uL*L ?th@?Uic
M| @i Mii? ? i t|i?Ui uLh 4U *L?}ih Ai *@|it| ??L@|L? t |@| Lu ht!ti?t|i
U@T|@* hi^hi4i?|tc tU @t |Lti M@ti_ L? V+

 6@**@U) G Ai +L*i Lu V+

t i T*@?i_ ? |i ?|hL_U|L?c V+ @t Mii? M*@4i_ uLh U@t?} ?Uhi@ti_ L*@|*|)
_h?} 544ih bbH Ai @h}4i?| t |@| tL4i i L}i?Lt L*@|*|) tLU!c i |i +tt@?
_iu@*|c *i_ |L @? ?Uhi@ti ? V+ 4i@thit `| UL44ihU@* M@?!t tMiU| |L V+M@ti_
U@T|@* @_i^@U) hi^hi4i?|tc @? ?Uhi@ti ? V+c @tt4?} | t M?_?}c tL*_ *i@_
|L @ hi^hi4i?| |L h@ti @__|L?@* U@T|@* Lh |L U| TLt|L?t tL @t |L _iUhi@ti V+.
5?Ui h@t?} U@T|@* t ?L| ui@tM*i ? @ hh)c UL44ihU@* M@?!t Thit4@M*) U| TLt|L?tc
ThLL!?} t@*it |@| uh|ih ?Uhi@ti_ L*@|*|)
At V+ RULt UhU*i )TL|ittc _i |L iht@_ E2fffc t _itUhMi_ ? 6}hi H
Ai |hLM*?} UL?U*tL? t |@| V+ |LL*t ?Uhi@ti L*@|*|) @?_ @hi ?ihi?|*) _@?}ihLt
At t|Lh)c Liihc @t tiih@* @t 6ht|c | @tt4it |@| @** V+UL?t|h@?i_ |h@_iht
@i |i t@4i TLt|L?t |ihtic |i) UL*_ t4T*) UhLtt |ih |h@_it | *||*i igiU| L?
ThUit N*|4@|i*)c TLt|L?t U@??L| Mi _hiU|*) UL4T@hi_ @t |iti _@|@ @hi ThLThi|@h) @?_
i@*Lt*) }@h_i_ ih!L|3 @?_ <hi? E2ffc Liihc ?_hiU|*) @__hitt |t tti M)
4: Wkhuh frxog eh vrph ihhedfn hhfw gxh wr pdunlqj0wr0pdunhw orvvhv rq fdslwdo1 Pdq| edqnv glg vxhu
wudglqj orvvhv lq 4<<;/ zklfk frxo ohdg wr srvlwlrq fxwwlqj1 Wklv kdv qrwklqj wr gr zlwk YDU/ ru dq| ulvn0
vhqvlwlyh ulvn phdvxuh/ krzhyhu1 Dq| uxoh edvhg rq vd|/ wkh udwlr ri qrwlrqdo wr fdslwdo zrxog jlyh wkh vdph
uhvxowv1
4; Shuvdxg +5333, dovr uhihuhqfhv zrun rq _khuglqj% e| Pruulv dqg Vklq +4<<<,1 Wkh sureohp zlwk wkh
wkhruhwlfdo olwhudwxuh rq khuglqj lv wkdw wkhvh prghov duh yhu| vhqvlwlyh wr wkh dvvxpswlrqv1 Khlqhpdqq
+5333,/ iru h{dpsoh/ kdv vkrzq wkdw wkh frqfoxvlrqv ri Pruulv dqg Vklq +4<<;,/ zklfk duh wkh edvlv iru wkhlu
pruh uhfhqw sdshu/ fdq eh ryhuwxuqhg lq d pruh jhqhudo prgho1 Elnkfkdqgdql dqg Vkdupd +5334, surylgh d
xvhixo uhylhz ri wkh olwhudwxuh rq khuglqj lq qdqfldo pdunhwv1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2

*LL!?} @| ULhhi*@|L?t Lu _@*) |h@_?} hii?it uLh @ }hLT Lu t N5 UL44ihU@* M@?!t
Ai @ih@}i ULhhi*@|L? uLh :w t f2 L?*) uLh |i TihL_ a@?@h) bbH |L @hU 2fffb
At ThL_it ?L tTTLh| uLh |i )TL|itt |@| |iti UL44ihU@* M@?!t @_ ?i@h*) _i?|U@*
TLt|L?t

6WBN+,  Ai V+ VULt hU*i O)TL|itt

R is e in m a rk e t v o la tility

V A R lim its o f
s o m e b a n k s a re h it

The VAR S e v e ra l b a n k s
lim its o f m o re s e ll s a m e a s s e t
b a n k s a re h it a t th e s a m e tim e

M a erk
M a rk t voelattilitvyoala
n d tility a n d
c
c oo
rrerre
la tiola
n s tio
ris e n s ris e

5iUL?_c |i @ti* ht! U@h}it L?*) @TT*) @| |i }it| *ii* Lu UL44ihU@* M@?!t |ih
€?@?U@* ?t|||L?t tU @t ?it|4i?| M@?!t Lh i_}i u?_t _L ?L| @i tU hi}*@|Lh)
hi^hi4i?|t ,i? uLh UL44ihU@* M@?!tc @U|@* U@T|@* h@|Lt ihi u@h ? i Uitt Lu hi}*@
|Lh) hi^hi4i?|tc tL |@| 4@h!i| ht! U@h}it ihi ?L| M?_?} Ai u@U| |@| V+M@ti_
4@h!i| ht! U@h}it ihi ?|hL_Ui_ ? bbH @?_ |@| 4@h!i|t i Tihi?Ui_ @ Uhtt ? bbH
t Thi UL?U_i?Ui
Ah_c @t i ** tL Mi*Lc U@T|@* @_i^@U) hi^hi4i?|t 4Li tL t*L*) |@| |i)
UL*_ ?L| @i TLttM*) U@ti_ T@?U ti**?} AL ThLi |tc i ?ii_ |L hii |i t|hU|hi
Lu |i @ti* V+ @TThL@U
4< Lqd odwhu sdshu/ wkh dxwkruv uhsruw wkdw fruuhodwlrqv ryhu orqjhu shulrgv ulvh e| d idfwru ri wzr1 Hyhq d
fruuhodwlrq ri 3157/ krzhyhu/ lv qrw yhu| kljk1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 

 Ai @ti* V+

AL ti |i ?|ih?@* 4L_i* @TThL@Uc M@?!t @i |L t@|tu) @hLt ^@*|@|i hi^hi4i?|t
€ht| Ai M@?! 4t| _i4L?t|h@|i |@| | @t @ tL?_ ht! 4@?@}i4i?| t)t|i4c U 4t|
Mi ?|i}h@|i_ ?|L 4@?@}i4i?| _iUtL?t L|@M*)c |i M@?! @t |L ti |i hi}*@|Lh) V+
uLhiU@t| _hiU|*) uLh 4@?@}i4i?| _iUtL?t At TL?| t 4TLh|@?|c @t | uLhUit UL44ihU@*
M@?!t |L ti |i t@4i T@h@4i|iht @t _U|@|i_ M) |i @ti* h*it
`i? |t t t@|t€i_c |i 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i t M@ti_ L? |i uL**L?} ^@?||@|i
T@h@4i|iht uLh V+G E @ Lh3L? Lu f |h@_?} _@)tc Lh |L U@*i?_@h ii!tc E @ bb
TihUi?| UL?€_i?Ui ?|ih@*c E @? LMtih@|L? TihL_ M@ti_ L? @| *i@t| @ )i@h Lu t|LhU@*
_@|@ @?_ T_@|i_ @| *i@t| L?Ui @ ^@h|ih W? Th@U|Uic M@?!t @hi @**Li_ |L UL4T|i |ih
f_@) V+ M) tU@*?} T |ih _@) V+ M) |i t^@hi hLL| Lu f
Ai @h!i| +t! @h}i t |i? UL4T|i_ @t |i }ih Lu |i ThiLt _@)<t V+c Lh
|i @ih@}i V+ Lih |i *@t| Sf Mt?itt _@)tc |4it @ R4*|T*U@|i u@U|Lh &
Sf
 [
-| ' @%E& T -|3 c T -|3  E2
Sf '

ihi & t |L Mi _i|ih4?i_ M) *LU@* hi}*@|Lhtc tMiU| |L @? @MtL*|i LLh Lu 2f

TT@hi?|*)c |i igiU| Lu |iti h*it L? |i + @t ?L| Mii? u**) @TThiU@|i_ At
t |i €ht| T@Tihc |L Lh !?L*i_}ic |@| tTiU€U@**) @?@*)3it |i |4itihit Mi@Lh Lu
|i 4@h!i| ht! U@h}it ) ?Lc |ihi t @? i?Lh4Lt *|ih@|hi L? V+c _ihi_ uhL4
t|@|t|U@* |4itihit |iU?^it U ?@hhL*) uLUtit L? _@) V+ @UUh@U) ttit2
Oihic |L t4LL|?} 4iU@?t4t @hi ?L*i_ Ai €ht| t |i hi^hi4i?| |@| |i
4L_i* Mi M@ti_ L? @| *i@t| @ )i@h Lu t|LhU@* _@|@ Lhi ThiUti*)c |i R@ih@}i *ui Lu
i}|t L? T@t| LMtih@|L?t 4t| Mi @| *i@t| t 4L?|t At hi^hi4i?| U@? Mi |h@Ui_
|L |i LMtih@|L? Lu a@U!tL? i| @* Ebb. |@| tLh| ?_Lt U@? *i@_ |L ?@UUh@|i V+
|c @t i ** tLc |t hi^hi4i?| @*tL @t |i igiU| Lu Uhi@|?} V+ 4i@thit |@| @hi
ih) t|@M*i Lih |4i Ai tiUL?_ 4iU@?t4 UL?tt|t Lu |@!?} |i @ih@}i V+ Lih t |)
53 Ljqrulqj wkh vshflf ulvn fkdujh/ zklfk lv h{sodlqhg lq pruh ghwdlo lq wkh Edvho Dphqgphqw +4<<9e,1
54 Vhh Khqgulfnv +4<<9,/ Mdfnvrq hw do1 +4<<:,/ Fkulvwrhuvhq +4<<;,/ Orsh} +4<<<,/ dprqj rwkhuv1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit e

_@)t

2 L_i**?} #@*) V+

wi| t i @4?i €ht| |i hi^hi4i?| Lu @ 4?44 ?_L uLh UL4T|?} _@*) V+ ?4
Miht `| |i t|LhU@*t4*@|L? 4i|L_c |i ?_L 4t| Mi @| *i@t| L?i )i@h +i
^h?} @| *i@t| 2Df _@)t tii4t hi@tL?@M*i @t |t L*_ )i*_ @? i TiU|i_ 2D LMtih@|L?t
? |i *iu| |@* | |i?c @t tL? M) h|t!ih E2ffc |i V+ ht! uLhiU@t| ** ?L| Mi
ih) hitTL?ti |L U@?}it ? hiUi?| L*@|*|)c _i |L |i u@U| |@| i@U LMtih@|L? ? |i
2Df_@) ?_L @t @ hi*@|i*) t4@** i}| Lu E%2Df `i L*_ ?ii_ |L @i tiih@*
LMtih@|L?t Mi*L |i ThiLt ^@?|*i |L t|@h| 4L?} V+ 4i@thit
*|ih?@|i*)c UL?t_ih T@h@4i|hU V+ 4L_i*t M@ti_ L? |i t|@?_@h_ _i@|L? 5U
4L_i*t U@? @UUL44L_@|i |4i@h@|L? ? ht! 4Lhi i@t*) Lhi hiUi?| 4L_i*t 4 t
|LhU@* t4*@|L?t | T@h@4i|hU L*@|*|) 4L_i*?}22 L?t_ihc uLh ?t|@?Uic @ t4T*i
+t!i|hUt|)Ti , TL?i?|@**) `i}|i_ L?} ih@}i E,` uLhiU@t| Ai UL?_
|L?@* @h@?Ui uLhiU@t| tG
| ' b|3 n E  bo|23 E

ihi b  t |i _iU@) u@U|Lh @?_ o |i h@|i Lu hi|h? L? |i @tti|
`| @ TLt|L? Lu `|3 ? |i ht!) @tti|c V+ U@? Mi UL4T|i_ @t T - ' `|3 
s
2 | c @| |i bbI *ii* @tt4?} @ UL?_|L?@* ?Lh4@* _t|hM|L? At UL*_ Mi i |i?_i_
|L L|ih T@h@4i|hU _t|hM|L?tc Liihc | @ _gihi?| 4*|T*U@|L? u@U|Lh
+iT*@U?} hiUhti*)c |t )i*_t }iL4i|hU@**) _iU*??} i}|t

| ' E  bdo|23 n bo|232 n   o Ee

Ai @ih@}i *ui t |i?

"
[ 
b3 E  b ' ED
'
E  b
6Lh i @4T*ic |i @ih@}i *ui Lu |i +t!i|hUt 4L_i* | b ' fbe t S. _@)tc Lh ffS.
)i@htc @tt4?} @ 2Df_@) )i@h At t ?L| @**Li_ ?_ih |i @ti* h*itc Liih `i ?ii_
55 Vhh iru lqvwdqfh Erxgrxnk hw do1+4<<;, dqg Kxoo dqg Zklwh +4<<;,1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit D

b |L Mi @| *i@t| fbb2 |L @Uii @? @ih@}i *ui Lu @*u @ )i@h *|ih?@|i*)c M@?!t UL*_
ti @ 4L?} @ih@}i Lih L?i )i@hc | i^@* i}|t |? |i ?_L
2Df
[
| ' E*2Df o|23 ES
'

6}hi e UL4T@hit |i iL*|L? Lu _@*) V+ 4L_i*t uLh |i #%m h@|i t?Ui bHf
6ht|c ?L|i |@| |i t|LhU@*t4*@|L? 4L_i* }i?ih@**) )i*_t @ }ih bbI V+ |@? |i
L|ih 4L_i*t At hiiU|t |i i**!?L? LMtih@|L? |@| _@*) €?@?U@* tihit @i |@*t
u@||ih |@? |i ?Lh4@*2
W? |i |LT }h@Tc |i ,` | b ' fbe t ?_ii_ ih) L*@|*ic _i |L |i }ih
i}| L? hiUi?| _@|@ At t ?L| hi*i@?|c Liihc t?Ui tU u@t|4L?} 4L_i*t @hi ?L|
@**Li_ ?_ih |i @ti* h*it Ai ML||L4 }h@T tLt |@| |i ?Lh4@* 4L_i* M@ti_
L? @ 4L?} ?_L Lu 2Df _@)t t 4U t4LL|ih Ai t|LhU@*t4*@|L? 4i|L_ t
4Lhi L*@|*ic M| t|** 4U t4LL|ih |i? |i ,` 4L_i* | _iU@) Lu fbe 6?@**)c
|i ,` | fbb2c U t |i 4?44 _iU@) @**Li_ ?_ih @ti* h*itc t ?i@h*) @t
t4LL| @t |i ?Lh4@* 4L_i*
Ai u@U| |@| M@?!t @hi UL?t|h@?i_ |L ti t*L4L?} V+ uLhiU@t|t i T*@?t |i
€?_?} M) ih!L|3 @?_ <hi? E2ff |@| M@?!t< V+ uLhiU@t|t U@? Mi Mi@|i? M) @ t4T*i
B+O 4L_i* @TT*i_ |L |i t|Lh) Lu :w | €ht| t}|c |iti €?_?}t @hi thTht?} t?Ui
B+O 4L_i*t @i ?L ?uLh4@|L? L? U@?}?} TLt|L?t ?i ?|ihThi|@|L? t |@| R|iti
hit*|t 4@) hiiU| tMt|@?|@* UL4T|@|L?@* _U*|it ? UL?t|hU|?} *@h}itU@*i t|hU|h@*
4L_i*t Lu |h@_?} ht!t uLh *@h}ic UL4T*i TLh|uL*Lt ?L|ih ?|ihThi|@|L?c Liihc t
|@| |i M@?!t<t t|hU|h@* 4L_i*t @hi t4T*) @4t|h?} M) |i @ti* hi^hi4i?|t ?_c
|t 4@) Mi @ h@|L?@* L|UL4i t?Ui |i ThTLti Lu |iti V+ 4L_i*t t |L ThL_Ui @ t4LL|
U@T|@* hi^hi4i?| @?_ ?L| ?iUitt@h*) |L 4i@thi ?i | _@)<t ht! | |4Lt| @UUh@U)

56 Vhh Khqgulfnv +4<<9,1

 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5

0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
Dec-80 Dec-80

Dec-81 Dec-81

Dec-82 Dec-82

Dec-83 Dec-83

Dec-84 Dec-84

99% daily VAR (%)

99% daily VAR (%)

Dec-85 Dec-85

Dec-86 Dec-86

Dec-87 Dec-87

Dec-88 Dec-88
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit

Dec-89 Dec-89

EW MA-decay=0.992
Dec-90 Dec-90
EW MA-decay=0.94

Dec-91 Dec-91

Normal model-250-day SD
Dec-92 Dec-92

Historical simulation-250 days

Dec-93 Dec-93
6WBN+, e L4T@htL? Lu V+ L_i*tG #%m +@|i

Dec-94 Dec-94

Dec-95 Dec-95

Dec-96 Dec-96

Dec-97 Dec-97

Dec-98 Dec-98

Dec-99 Dec-99

Dec-00 Dec-00
S
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit .

 `U V+ t ?_?}q

Ai 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i t UL4TLti_ Lu |i 4@ 44 Lu |L |ih4t `U Lu |iti |ih4t ?
,^@|L? E2 ** Mi M?_?}q Ai €ht| |ih4c U t |hii |4it |i Sf_@) @ih@}ic ** ?
}i?ih@* Mi }ih |@? )it|ih_@)<t V+c @?_ |t ** Mi M?_?} Ai M@?! L*_ @i |L
i Tihi?Ui @? i?Lh4Lt ?Uhi@ti ? |i ThiLt _@)<t V+ uLh | |L MiUL4i |i _L4?@?|
u@U|Lh
AL tii |t TL?|c @tt4i |@| V+ t t|@M*i @| T -f uLh |i *@t| Sf_@) TihL_c i UiT|
uLh @ tT!i L? |i *@t| _@) Ai tiUL?_ |ih4 ? ,^@|L? E2 ** Mi M?_?} i?

T -|3 : E*SfdT -|3 n DbT -f oc E.

U 4T*it
T -|3 : E  Db*D.  T -f '   T -f EH

At UL*_ @TTi? ? L?i Lu |L @)t tt4?} t|@M*i ht! u@U|Lhtc |t UL*_ Mi
@Uii_ u |i i TLthi `|3 c Lh t3i Lu TLt|L?tc t 4*|T*i_ M) @ u@U|Lh }hi@|ih |@?
 *|ih?@|i*)c | UL?t|@?| i TLthitc |t UL*_ @*tL Mi @Uii_ M) @? ?Uhi@ti ? |i
s
L*@|*|) Lu ht! u@U|Lht |  Ai *@||ih t 4U *itt *!i*)c Liih
A@M*i 2 _tT*@)t |i hi^hi_ *@|it| hi|h?c i Thitti_ ? |ih4t Lu L*@|*|)c tU |@| |i
tiUL?_ |ih4 t M?_?}c uLh @hLt @*it Lu |i _iU@) T@h@4i|ih uLh |i ,` 4L_i*c @t
i** @t |i 2Df_@)  wLih @*it uLh b 4T*) }hi@|ih i}| L? |i *@t| LMtih@|L?
Oi?Uic @ t4@**ih 4Li4i?| t hi^hi_ uLh |i *@|it| LMtih@|L? |L Mi M?_?}
Ai |@M*i tLtc uLh ?t|@?Uic |@| | b ' fbec i hi^hi @ tLU! 2 |4it |i _@*)
t|@?_@h_ _i@|L? At @TTi?i_ L?*) L?Ui ? Lh i^|) @?_ Uhhi?U) t@4T*ic _h?} |i
Uh@t Lu U|LMih bc bH. `| |i *Lit| _iU@) @**Li_c b ' fbb2c i ?ii_ @ 4Li4i?|
Lu 2b |4it |i t|@?_@h_ _i@|L? uLh |i *@|it| V+ |L Mi M?_?} `| @ t4T*i 4L?}
@ih@}i Lih |i *@t| )i@hc |i hi^hi_ 4Li 4T*it @ u@U|Lh Lu eSD W| t }*) ?*!i*)
|@| @? i L}i?Lt tLU! |L L*@|*|) UL*_ ?_Ui )it|ih_@)<t V+ |L Mi M?_?} AihiuLhic
? @| uL**Ltc i ** @tt4i |@| |i 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i t _hi? M)  |4it |i @ih@}i
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit H

V+ At t ?L| |L t@)c Liihc |@| |i tiUL?_ |ih4 ? |i 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i t ti*itt
W| tihit |L U@|U M@?!t |@| t__i?*) ?Uhi@ti |ih TLt|L?t

Aw, 2 +i^hi_ +i|h? uLh w@t| V+ Aih4 |L Mi ?_?}

L_i*G ,`c #iU@) Eb 
@h@4i|ihtG fb2 fbe fbS fbH fbb2 2Df _@)t
+i^hi_ hi|h? fej 2fj e.j 2fHj 2bj eSDj
5LhUiG |Lh<t U@*U*@|L?t

e ,@*@|L? Lu |i @ti* @h!i| +t! @h}i

Ai UL?|i?|L? t |@| V+M@ti_ U@T|@* hi^hi4i?|t i Tihi?Ui_ t@hT ?Uhi@tit _h?}
544ih bbHc *i@_?} |L uLhUi_ TLt|L? U||?} Ai ^it|L? tc OL __ |i ?Uhi@ti_
L*@|*|) Lu €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t @giU| |i @ti* U@T|@* hi^hi4i?|tq
6}hi D _tT*@)t 4Li4i?|t ? |i 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i uLh @ € i_ TLt|L? ? |i m%#
i U@?}i h@|i L|i L t4LL| |i *?it @hi UL4T@hi_ |L |Lti ? |i ThiLt }h@T At
t _i |L |i @ih@}?} Lih |i *@t| Sf _@)t Ai €}hi _Lit ?L| ?U*_i |i ?Lh4@*,`
4L_i* | _iU@) Lu fbe t?Ui | t ?L| @**Li_ Ai }h@T tLt ?L i_i?Ui Lu t@hT*)
}ih 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i _h?} bbH Ai U|@|L?t ? 4@h!i| ht! U@h}it ? bbH @hi
@U|@**) *Lih |@? Lih |i hit| Lu |i t@4T*i TihL_
?i UL*_ @h}i |@| L*@|*|) @t UL?€?i_ |L L|ih 4@h!i|tc Liih 5Lc i |h? |L
N5 i^|it 6}hi S T*L|t |i + uLh @ € i_ TLt|L? ? N5 t|LU!t Aihi t tL4i
i_i?Ui Lu @? ?Uhi@ti ? |i + _h?} bbHc M| ?L| L| Lu *?i | |i t|Lh) Lu |i
*@t| |i?|) )i@ht
6}hi . }it 4Lhi _i|@* uLh bbH Ai }h@T tLt |@| |i ?Uhi@ti ? |i + @t
ih) t*L W| @t M@hi*) ?L|Ui@M*i uLh |i ?Lh4@* 4L_i* | @ 2Df_@)  @?_ uLh |i
,` | _iU@) Lu fbb2 Aihi t @ }hi@|ih ?Uhi@ti uLh |i t|LhU@* t4*@|L? 4i|L_c
M| _i |L |i @ih@}?} ThLUittc |i + L?*) hi@Uit @ Ti@! M) |i i?_ Lu Li4Mihc M)
U |4i |i Uhtt @t Lih
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit b

6WBN+, D @h!i| +t! @h}iG #%m +@|i

10

2
Historical simulation-250 days
Normal model-250-day SD
1
EWMA-decay=0.992
0
Dec-80

Dec-81

Dec-82

Dec-83

Dec-84

Dec-85

Dec-86

Dec-87

Dec-88

Dec-89

Dec-90

Dec-91

Dec-92

Dec-93

Dec-94

Dec-95

Dec-96

Dec-97

Dec-98

Dec-99

Dec-00
6WBN+, S @h!i| +t! @h}iG N5 ,^|it

25

Historical simulation-250 days

20
Aug 1998
Normal model-250-day SD
EWMA-decay=0.992
15

10

0
Dec-80

Dec-81

Dec-82

Dec-83

Dec-84

Dec-85

Dec-86

Dec-87

Dec-88

Dec-89

Dec-90

Dec-91

Dec-92

Dec-93

Dec-94

Dec-95

Dec-96

Dec-97

Dec-98

Dec-99

Dec-00
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2f

6?@**)c 6}hi H T*L|t |i + uLh @ tLh| TLt|L? ? f)i@h Ahi@th) ?L|it }@?c
|ihi t ?L i_i?Ui Lu t@hT 4Li4i?|t ? |i + uLh |i O5 @?_  4L_i*t `*i
|i bHft ihi 4U 4Lhi L*@|*i |@? |i bbft uLh Ahi@thitc bbH @t Uih|@?*) ?L| @?
ii?|u* )i@h ? |ih4t Lu |i @ti* 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i W? UL?U*tL?c | tii4t ?@TThLTh@|i
|L M*@4i ?Uhi@tit ? V+ 4L_i*t uLh TLt|L? U||?}

D MiU|i 6?U|L?t uLh V+ L_i*t

Ai ThiLt tiU|L? ?_U@|it |@| t4LL|?itt ? |i V+M@ti_ U@T|@* U@h}i t @ _ith@M*i
ThLTih|) At @t Mii? *@h}i*) }?Lhi_ ? |i V+ *|ih@|hic U @t uLUti_ L? Thi*)
t|@|t|U@* ttit tU @t M@t @?_ M?U?}
R@t ?_U@|it |i i |i?| |L U |i ^@?|*i t i** U@*Mh@|i_ W| t 4i@thi_ |
|i TihUi?|@}i Lu i UiT|L?tc Lh *Lttit Lht| |@? |i bbI V+ Lh4@**)c |t tL*_ Mi
I `i|ih _i@|L?t @hi t}?€U@?| U@? Mi |it|i_c uLh ?t|@?Uic | @ |t|@|t|U
R?U?} ?_U@|it |i i |i?| |L U i UiT|L?t @hi }hLTi_ ? |4i W_i@**)c _i
@|L?t tL*_ Mi ?uLh4*) tThi@_ Lih |4i At U@? Mi 4i@thi_c uLh ?t|@?Uic M) |i
w?}L "t|@|t|U Lu @|LULhhi*@|L?t ? i UiT|L?tc U t _t|hM|i_ @t @ Ut^@hi
t|@|t|U `| D *@}tc i U@??L| hiiU| u |i ?4Mih t *itt |@? 2D @| |i bDI UL?€_i?Ui
*ii* Ai ^it| uLh *L M?U?} @t *i_ |L 4Lhi hitTL?ti V+ 4i@thitc tU @t B+O
Lh ,` 4L_i*t
Aiti t|@|t|U@* 4i@thitc Liihc _L ?L| UL?t_ih |i igiU| L? U@T|@* U@h}it **
i*ti i^@*c @ M@?! L*_ @?| *L @?_ t|@M*i U@T|@* U@h}it Ai ThLM*i4 t |@| |iti
iUL?L4U }L@*t @hi ? _hiU| UL?U| | |i t|@|t|U@* LMiU|it
wLih U@h}it UL*_ Mi @Uii_ @| |i ULt| Lu 4Lhi i UiT|L?t Aihi t ?L ^it|L?c
Liihc |@| @ V+ t)t|i4 tL*_ Mi @t ?M@ti_ @t TLttM*i At t ) |i @ti*
L44||ii @t it|@M*ti_ @ M@U!|it|?} uh@4iLh! | Ti?@*|it uLh M@?!t |@| ?Uh |LL
4@?) i UiT|L?t
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2

6WBN+, . @h!i| +t! @h}i ? bbHG N5 ,^|it

16

14

12

10

4 Historical simulation-250 days

2
Normal model-250-day SD
EWMA-decay=0.992
0
May-98
Jan-98

Feb-98

Mar-98

Jun-98

Aug-98

Sep-98
Dec-97

Apr-98

Jul-98

Oct-98

Nov-98

Dec-98
6WBN+, H @h!i| +t! @h}iG N5 Ahi@thit
12

Historical simulation-250 days

10 Normal model-250-day SD

Aug 1998
EWMA-decay=0.992
8

0
Dec-80

Dec-81

Dec-82

Dec-83

Dec-84

Dec-85

Dec-86

Dec-87

Dec-88

Dec-89

Dec-90

Dec-91

Dec-92

Dec-93

Dec-94

Dec-95

Dec-96

Dec-97

Dec-98

Dec-99

Dec-00
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 22

54*@h*)c *itt @h@M*i U@T|@* U@h}it UL*_ Mi @Uii_ @| |i i Ti?ti Lu 4Lhi M?U?}
witt @h@M*|) t iUL?L4U@**) Mi?i€U@* Wu U@T|@* U@??L| Mi h@ti_ ^U!*)c Lh TLt|L?t
@_t|i_ ^U!*)c 4Lhi @h@M*i U@T|@* U@h}it 4T*) |@| |i ?t|||L? @t |L L*_ 4Lhi
tT@hi U@T|@* |L @MtLhM Ti@!t ? |i U@T|@* U@h}i `i|ih M?U?} t ?|h?tU@**) M@_c
Liihc t ?L| tL LMLt
Aiti |h@_iLgt @hi **t|h@|i_ ? A@M*i c U UL4T@hit |i TihuLh4@?Ui Lu €i V+
4L_i*t ? |ih4t Lu @hLt LMiU|i u?U|L?t Ai |@M*i hiTLh|t M@tc M?U?}c @t i** @t
|i @ih@}i @?_ t|@?_@h_ _i@|L? Lu |i _@) bbI V+ uLhiU@t| @?_ |i U@T|@* U@h}i
M@ti_ L? |i Sf_@) @ih@}i
Ai t4*@|L?t ti _@*) _@|@ uhL4 bHf |L 2ffc uLh N5 t|LU!tc N5 ML?_t EhiThiti?|i_
M) @ tLh| TLt|L? ? f)i@h Ahi@th) ?L|itc @?_ |i #%m h@|i At hiThiti?|t @ML|
DcfDf i TLt| LMtih@|L?t ** 4L_i*t @hi Thi*) @?|UT@|ic M@ti_ L? |i *@t| 2Df _@)t Lu
_@|@
Ai R?Lh4@* @?_ R5|_i?| 4L_i*t @hi M@ti_ L? |i t|LhU@* t|@?_@h_ _i@|L? @?_
|i @TThLTh@|i _i@|ic i} 2 uLh ?Lh4@* _@|@c @?_ |i ULhhitTL?_?} ?4Mih uhL4 |i
5|_i?| _t|hM|L?c | _i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 it|4@|i_ uhL4 4@|U?} |i !h|Ltt Lih |i
*@t| )i@h Ai ,` 4i|L_t ti @ _iU@) b ' fbe R,`n @tt4it @ UL?_|L?@*
?Lh4@* _t|hM|L?( R,`nO5 MLL|t|h@Tt |i tU@*i_ hit_@*t2e
Ai *iu| UL*4?t _tT*@) M@t uLh i@U 4L_i* @?_ 4@h!i| Ai R?Lh4@* 4L_i* tM
t|@?|@**) ?_iht|@|it |@* ThLM@M*|it @?_ @TTi@ht M@_*) M@ti_ ? @** 4@h!i|t Ai |@*
TihUi?|@}i h@?}it uhL4 D2 |L bfIc U t t}?€U@?|*) }ih |@? |i i TiU|i_ ffI
At hiiU|t |i i**!?L? LMtih@|L? |@| €?@?U@* tihit @i u@||ih |@*t |@? |i ?Lh
4@* _t|hM|L? Lhi ?i TiU|i_ t |i LMtih@|L? |@| |i ,`n 4L_i* @t ii?
Lhti M@t uLh |iti |hii 4@h!i|t Ai L|ih 4L_i*tc |i R5|_i?|c O5c @?_ ,`nO5c
@hi 4U Mi||ih U@*Mh@|i_

57 Wklv kdv ehhq xvhg/ iru lqvwdqfh/ e| Kxoo dqg Zklwh +4<<;,1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2

Aw,  L4T@htL? Lu ihuLh4@?Ui Lu V+ L_i*t

Eldv Exqfklqj 40Gd| YDU Fdslwdo +930Gd|,
H{fhswlrqv Omxqj0Er{ Dyhudjh V1Ghy1 V1Ghy1 Dyhudjh V1Ghy1 V1Ghy1
Shufhqw W0whvw "2 0whvw Ohyho Fkdqjh Ohyho Fkdqjh
YDU Prgho
X1V1 Htxlwlhv
Qrupdo 4185 61:7- ;7139- 51576 31;63 3135< 51569 31;47 3133:
Vwxghqw 4144 31:; :6164- 51836 31<69 31369 517<8 31<48 3133;
Klvw1Vlp1 414: 4153 9;19:- 518<6 41643 313:5 518;6 415:7 31346
HZPD.Q 41:7 8163- 691:5- 514:3 4138; 3149; 5149: 31<36 3134<
HZPD.KV 31<: 03155 4;1<< 51:7< 41896 3157: 51:75 41663 3135<
X1V1 Erqgv
Qrupdo 4199 719;- 7:183- 419;3 318;9 31345 419<7 3193: 31336
Vwxghqw 413; 3189 791;7- 41;:: 31984 3134< 41;<5 319:8 31336
Klvw1Vlp1 31:; 0418: 6<15;- 51353 31:;: 31366 5136: 31;3< 31338
HZPD.Q 41<; 91<8- 5;1;;- 418;7 3194: 313<7 41933 318<: 31343
HZPD.KV 4135 3146 45135 41<:: 31:88 31459 41<<3 319<: 31346
GP2' Udwh
Qrupdo 41<3 9179- 541<4 41897 31598 3133< 41899 31598 31335
Vwxghqw 4154 4186 5:1<6- 41:95 315:: 3134: 41:98 315:9 31335
Klvw1Vlp1 31<5 0318; 6913;- 41<59 316:5 31363 41<63 31694 31337
HZPD.Q 513: :1:5- 4:1;6 41849 3174< 313;3 4184< 31676 3133<
HZPD.KV 31;3 04175 561;; 41<48 3195: 3144< 41<53 3184: 31346

Qrwhv= Wkh wdeoh frpsduhv wkh shuirupdqfh ri ydulrxv YDU prghov lq whupv ri ydulrxv remhfwlyh
ixqfwlrqv1 Uhmhfwlrq dw wkh <8( vljqlfdqfh ohyho ghqrwhg e| -1
_Eldv% lv phdvxuhg dv wkh shufhqwdjh ri h{fhswlrqv/ ru orvvhv zruvw wkdq wkh <<( YDU> wkh w0vwdwlvwlf
whvwv zkhwkhu wkh dfwxdo shufhqwdjh lv vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw iurp 41331 _Exqfklqj% lv phdvxuhg e|
wkh Omxqj0Er{ T0vwdwlvwlf ri dxwrfruuhodwlrqv lq h{fhswlrqv zlwk 48 odjv> wkh fkl0vtxduh0vwdwlvwlf whvwv
zkhwkhu wkh ghyldwlrqv duh lqghshqghqw ryhu wlph/ dqg fdqqrw uhmhfw li wkh qxpehu lv ohvv wkdq 58
dw wkh <8( frqghqfh ohyho1 Wkh _40Gd| YDU% froxpqv jlyh wkh dyhudjh dqg vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq ri
wkh YDU iruhfdvw1 Wkh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq lv uhsruwhg iru wkh ohyho ri YDU dqg wkh 40gd| fkdqjh1
Wkh _Fdslwdo% froxpqv jlyh wkh dyhudjh dqg vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq ri wkh Pdunhw Ulvn Fkdujh xvlqj wkh
dyhudjh ri wkh YDUv ryhu wkh odvw 93 gd|v1
Gdlo| gdwd duh xvhg iurp 4<;3 wr 5334/ zklfk uhsuhvhqwv derxw 8/383 h{ srvw revhuydwlrqv1 Doo prg0
hov duh edvhg rq wkh odvw 583 gd|v ri gdwd1 Wkh _qrupdo% dqg _Vwxghqw% prgho duh edvhg rq wkh
vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq dqg wkh ghyldwh/ h1j1 5166 iru qrupdo gdwd/ dqg wkh fruuhvsrqglqj qxpehu iurp
wkh Vwxghqw glvwulexwlrq/ zlwk ghjuhhv ri iuhhgrp hvwlpdwhg iurp pdwfklqj wkh nxuwrvlv ryhu wkh odvw
|hdu1 _Klvwrulfdo Vlpxodwlrq% lv d errwvwuds phwkrg xvlqj wkh hpslulfdo <<( txdqwloh1 Wkh _H{srqhq0
wldoo| Zhljkwhg Prylqj Dyhudjh% +HZPD, phwkrgv xvh d frqglwlrqdo iruhfdvw ri wkh yduldqfh zlwk
ghfd|  @ 3=<7/ wkh vdph dv UlvnPhwulfv1 Wkh _HZPD.Q% phwkrg dvvxphv d frqglwlrqdo qrupdo
glvwulexwlrq1 Wkh _HZPD.KV% phwkrg errwvwudsv wkh vfdohg uhvlgxdov1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2e

Ai ?i | UL*4? tLt |@| |i €ht| |hiic ?UL?_|L?@*c 4L_i*tc @** @i |LL 4U
M?U?} Ai t|@|t|Ut hiiU| |i )TL|itt Lu ?L M?U?} Ai ,` 4L_i*t }i?ih@**)
_i@* i** | i|ihLt!i_@t|U|)
Ai ?i | UL*4?t _tT*@) |i @ih@}i @?_ t|@?_@h_ _i@|L? Lu |i _@) V+ @?_ Lu
|i Sf_@) @ih@}i 6LUt?} €ht| L? |i @ih@}ic |i |@M*i tLt |@| 4L_i*t |@| @i
} M@t @i *L @ih@}i V+c @?_ Ui iht@  }hi@|ih TihUi?|@}i Lu i UiT|L?t *i@_t
|L *L @ih@}i U@T|@* U@h}it At t ) M@U!|it|?} t ?ii_i_
5|@?_@h_ _i@|L?t @hi hiTLh|i_ uLh V+ 4i@thit ? *ii*tc i hi*@|i |L |i *L?}|ih4
@ih@}ic @?_ ? _@*) U@?}it Ai *@||ih 4i@thi }it @ Mi||ih ?_U@|L? Lu tLh||ih4
U|@|L?t ? V+ Ai |@M*i hii@*t @ ?4Mih Lu ?|ihit|?} hi*@|L?tTt 6ht|c U
|@|L?t uLh |i ?Lh4@* @?_ 5|_i?| 4L_i*t @hi t)t|i4@|U@**) *itt |@? |Lti M@ti_ L?
t|LhU@* t4*@|L?t At t _i |L t@4T*?} @h@M*|) ? |i O5 it|4@|Lh2D 5iUL?_c
U|@|L?t uLh |i ,` 4L_i*t @hi t)t|i4@|U@**) }hi@|ih |@? |Lti M@ti_ L? ?UL?_
|L?@* _t|hM|L?t Ah_c @t ThiLt*) ?L|i_c U|@|L?t ? |i Sf_@) @ih@}i @hi 4U
t4@**ih |@? |Lti ? |i _@) V+c M) @ u@U|Lh Lu D |L f A@M*i  @*tL _i4L?t|h@|it |i
?|h?tU UL?U| Mi|ii? *L M?U?} @?_ t|@M*i U@T|@* U@h}it Ai ,` 4L_i*t @i
*Lih M?U?} |@? |i L|iht M| 4U 4Lhi @h@M*i U@T|@* U@h}it
ih@**c |i Mit| 4L_i* @UhLtt |iti UL?U|?} LMiU|it tii4t |L Mi |i R5|_i?|
4L_i* W| Lgiht *L M@tc hi*@|i*) *L @ih@}i U@T|@*c @?_ *L L*@|*|) ? |i U@T|@*
U@h}i

e L?U*tL?t
At T@Tih @t |@!i? @?L|ih *LL! @| @**i}@|L?t |@| ht! 4@?@}i4i?| t)t|i4t UL?|hM|i
|L ?Uhi@ti_ L*@|*|) ? €?@?U@* 4@h!i|tc ? T@h|U*@h _h?} |i 544ih Lu bbH `i
t|@h|i_ M) tL?} |@| 4@Lh €?@?U@* 4@h!i|t @i Mii? ?L 4Lhi L*@|*i ? hiUi?| )i@htc
58 Dv Mrulrq +4<<9, kdv dujxhg/ phwkrgv edvhg rq wkh vdpsoh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq duh pruh urexvw dv wklv
vwdwlvwlf xvhv wkh zkroh glvwulexwlrq1 Wkh klvwrulfdo vlpxodwlrq phwkrg xvhv wkh 4 shufhqw txdqwloh/ zklfk lv
pxfk pruh lpsuhflvho| hvwlpdwhg/ hvshfldoo| lq d vdpsoh dv vkruw dv 583 gd|v1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2D

U @i |?itti_ 4@?) €?@?U@* ??L@|L?t

Ai _iM@|i @ML| |i hL*i Lu €?@?U@* i?}?iih?} Mi@ht @? iihi hiti4M*@?Ui |L _tUt
tL?t Lu TLh|uL*L ?th@?Uic U @t Mii? _i*) M*@4i_ uLh |i Uh@t Lu U|LMih bH.
Aihi t t|** UL?t_ih@M*i UL?|hLiht)c Liihc @ML| |i @U|@* igiU| Lu TLh|uL*L ?th@?Ui
Ai t@4i ht |L _}4i?| @t @*tL LMtihi_ | 4@h}?t _h?} |i Uh@t Lu b2b @?_
i? u|hit @?_ LT|L?t ihi ?|hL_Ui_ W?t|i@_c |i i4ThU@* i_i?Ui t}}it|t |@|
€?@?U@* ??L@|L?t ThL_i @ t|@M*3?} ?i?Ui
At T@Tih ThL_it ?i i_i?Ui |@| V+M@ti_ hi}*@|Lh) U@T|@* U@h}it uLh UL4
4ihU@* M@?!t U@??L| T*@tM*) Mi M*@4i_ uLh |i L*@|*|) Lu bbH @h!i| ht! U@h}it
4Li ih) t*L*) ? hitTL?ti |L U@?}?} 4@h!i| UL?_|L?tc _i |L |i @ih@}?} Lih |i
*@t| t |) _@)t @?_ t*L T_@|?} 4TLti_ M) |i @ti* h*it
 ?i ?t}| Lu |t @?@*)tt t |@| ht!ti?t|i t)t|i4t tL*_ ?ULhTLh@|i t4LL|?}
4iU@?t4t Ai ^it| uLh @UUh@U) ? V+ 4i@thitc U L*_ _U|@|i u@t|4L?}
t)t|i4t tU @t B+Oc tL*_ |@!i tiUL?_ T*@Ui |L t|@M*|) ? |i 4@h!i| ht! U@h}i
At t ?L| |L t@)c Liihc |@| V+ t)t|i4t tL*_ Mi ii_ @t @ T@?@Ui@ Ai)
ThL_i ?L }@h@?|ii |@| *@h}i *Lttit ** ?L| LUUh W? @__|L?c |h@_iht UL*_ **u**)
@||i4T|t |L R}@4i |ih V+ M) @*|ih?} |i _t|hM|L? Lu :w |L t@|tu) @ € i_ V+ @|
|i i Ti?ti Lu @ t4@** ThLM@M*|) Lu *@h}i *Lttit5U TLttM*|it @i Mii? @?@*)3i_ M) a
@?_ i@htL? Ebbbc M| @hi 4Lhi *!i*) @| |i *ii* Lu |h@_iht< _it!t |@? |i L*i ?t||
|L? h|3?ih i| @* Ebbb ThLTLti ?t|i@_ @ R|@* *Ltt 4i@thic U t |i i TiU|@|L? Lu
|i *Ltt L?Ui V+ t i Uii_i_ 5U 4i@thit UL*_ tiu**) tTT*i4i?| V+ ?4Miht2S
At i T*@?t ) |i ?_t|h) @?_ hi}*@|Lht i4T@t3i |i 4TLh|@?Ui Lu t|hitt |it|tc
U ThiUti*) i @4?i |i igiU| Lu ?t@* 4@h!i| 4Li4i?|t
ih@**c | t u@h |L UL?U*_i |@| |ihi t ?L i_i?Ui |L tTTLh| |i @ttih|L? |@|
V+M@ti_ ht! 4@?@}i4i?| t)t|i4t _it|@M*3i |i €?@?U@* t)t|i4

59 Edvdn dqg Vkdslur +5334, h{dplqh wkh hhfw ri wklv jdplqj dw wkh ohyho ri wkh lqvwlwxwlrq rq qdqfldo
pdunhwv1 Wkh| vkrz wkdw vwulfw YDU olplwv frxog lqgxfh edqnv wr wdnh rq pruh ulvn lq edg vwdwhv ri wkh
zruog/ l1h1 diwhu YDU olplwv kdyh ehhq euhdfkhg/ zklfk frxog fdxvh kljkhu yrodwlolw| lq qdqfldo pdunhwv1
Wkh dxwkruv vkrz wkdw wkhvh vkruwfrplqjv duh uhphglhg e| wdlo orvv phdvxuhv1
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2S

+iuihi?Uit
h|3?ihc *TTic 6hi__) #i*M@i?c ai@?@hU ,Mih @?_ #@_ Oi@|c bbbc RLihi?|
i@thit Lu +t!c @|i4@|U@* 6?@?Ui b Ea*)c 2f22H
?_ihtL?c UL*@ @?_ 6h@?Ut hii_L?c 2fffc R6u|) )i@ht Lu Nk @tti| ThUi L*@|*|)c
aLh?@* Lu +t! 2 E5Th?}c S..
@t@!c 5*i)4@? @?_ *i 5@ThLc 2ffc RV@*i@|+t! @ti_ +t! @?@}i4i?|G T
|4@* L*Uit @?_ tti| hUitc +ii Lu 6?@?U@* 5|_it e E544ihc .efD
@t@!c 5*i)4@?c 2ffc R L4T@h@|i 5|_) Lu Lh|uL*L W?th@?Uic uLh|UL4?}c
aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Ut #)?@4Ut @?_ L?|hL*
@ti* L44||ii L? @?!?} 5TihtL?c bbDc ? W?|ih?@* L_i*@ti_ TThL@U |L
@h!i| +t! @T|@* +i^hi4i?|tc @ti*c 5|3ih*@?_G W5
@ti* L44||ii L? @?!?} 5TihtL?c 2ffc ihi Lu |i i @ti* UULh_c
@ti*c 5|3ih*@?_G W5
!U@?_@?c 5t* @?_ 5?* 5@h4@c 2ffc ROih_ i@Lh ? 6?@?U@* @h!i|tc
W6 5|@g @Tiht e. E5iT|i4Mihc 2.bf
ih!L|3c aihi4) @?_ a4 <hi?c 2ffc ROL @UUh@|i @hi |i @*i @| ht! 4L_i*t
@| UL44ihU@* M@?!tq `Lh!?} @Tihc L@h_ Lu BLih?Lht Lu |i 6i_ih@* +itihi
5)t|i4
*@U!c 6tih @?_ )hL? 5UL*itc b.c RAi hU?} Lu T|L?t @?_ LhTLh@|i w@M*
|itc aLh?@* Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4) Hc S.Db
*@U!c 6tUihc bbD ROi_}?}c 5TiU*@|L? @?_ 5)t|i4U +t!c aLh?@* Lu #ih@|it
2 E544ihc SH
Lh_Lc c  ,Ui?}hii?c # k*?}iMi* @?_  @h|?i3ih@c 2ffc RWt |i htt
hLM*i4 BhL?} Lhi 5iihiq ,UL?L4U L*U) 2 ETh*c DH2
LhLc *@_Lc h@} 6h€?i @?_ *T wLic 2ffc hLU)U*U@*|) Lu |i €?@?U@* t)t|i4
@?_ €?@?U@* t|@M*|)G Wttit @?_ TL*U) LT|L?tc @?tUhT|c W5G @ti*
L_L!c a@ULMc @||i +U@h_tL? @?_ +LMih| `|i*@c bbHc RAi it| Lu L|
`Lh*_tc +t! E@)c SeS.
@ThLc Bih@*_ @?_ #@?i*@ k*?}iMi*c bbbc R,TtL_it Lu 5)t|i4U @?_ Lh_ih*?i 6
?@?U@* htitc `Lh*_ @?! `Lh!?} @Tihc `@t?}|L?c #
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2.

ht|Lgihti?c i|ihc @?_ 6h@?Ut #iML*_c 2fffc ROL +i*i@?| t VL*@|*|) 6LhiU@t|?}
uLh 6?@?U@* +t! @?@}i4i?|q +ii Lu ,UL?L4Ut @?_ 5|@|t|Ut H2 E6iMh@h)c
222
ht|Lgihti?c i|ihc bbH R,@*@|?} W?|ih@* 6LhiU@t|tc W?|ih?@|L?@* ,UL?L4U
+ii b ELi4Mihc HeHS2
*i4i?|c #@_c 2ffc R@?!t @?_ 5)t|i4U +t!  AiLh) @?_ ,_i?Uic 5TiiU @|
@?! Lu ,?}*@?_ L?uihi?Uic E@)
#@?i*ttL?c aL?c @* ,4MhiU|tc @h*it BLL_@h|c L? ki@|?}c 6i* i??Uc
*ih +i?@*|c @?_ O)? 5L?} 5?c 2ffc R? U@_i4U +itTL?ti |L @ti* WWc
44iL w5, 6?@?U@* @h!i|t BhLT
#i|i4T*ic aihL4i @?_ *TTi aLhL?c bbfc RT|L? wt|?} @?_ 5|LU! +i|h?tG ?
,4ThU@* W?it|}@|L?c aLh?@* Lu @?!?} @?_ 6?@?Ui e E5iT|i4Mihc .HHf
#?M@hc UL*@tc 2fffc W?i?|?} L?i)c `*i)G i vLh!
,h?c `*tL? @?_ AL4 `*_ic 2ffc RhLU)U*U@*|) ? |i i @ti* UULh_c +t!c
EU|LMih 52H52
Oi?i4@??c 6h@?!c 2fffc RN?^i ,^*Mh4 ? @ L_i* Lu 5i*u6*€**?} hhi?U)
||@U!tG L44i?|c 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +ii bf E@hUc SH
Oi?_hU!tc #@hh)**c bbS R,@*@|L? Lu V@*i@|+t! L_i*t Nt?} Ot|LhU@* #@|@c
6i_ih@* +itihi @?! Lu i vLh! ,UL?L4U L*U) +ii 2c bSb
OL}@h|c B*i?? @?_ VU|Lh@ 5@TLh|@c 2ffc RLt| Lu @?!?} 5)t|i4 W?t|@M*|)G 5L4i
,4ThU@* ,_i?Uic 6?@?U@* 5|@M*|) +ii f Ea?ic @?! Lu ,?}*@?_G wL?_L?
Otic #@_ @?_ ih|L? **ihc bbfc R@h}? +i}*@|L? @?_ 5|LU! @h!i| VL*@|*|)c
aLh?@* Lu 6?@?Ui eD E@hUc 2b
O**c aL? @?_ *@? `|ic bbHc RW?ULhTLh@|?} VL*@|*|) NT_@|?} ?|L |i Ot|LhU@*
54*@|L? i|L_ uLh V@*i@|+t!c aLh?@* Lu +t!  E6@**c Db
kTiUc @*c bbHc R@h}? hi^hi4i?|tc L*@|*|)c @?_ 4@h!i| ?|i}h|)G `@| @i
i *i@h?i_ t?Ui |i Uh@tq aLh?@* Lu 6?@?U@* 5ihUit +iti@hU  Ea?ic 2
2DD
a@U!tL?c @|hU@( @_ic #@_ @?_ `**@4 ihh@_?c `**@4c bb.c R@?! @T|@*
@?_ V@*i @| +t!c aLh?@* Lu #ih@|it e E5Th?}c .Hb
aLhL?c *TTic 2fff@c V@*i @| +t!G Ai i i?U4@h! uLh @?@}?} 6?@?U@*
+t!c UBh@O**G i vLh!
aLhL?@h!i| +t! @?@}i4i?| 6@**@Uit 2H

aLhL?c *TTic bbSc R+t!2 G i@th?} |i +t! ? V@*i|+t!c 6?@?U@* ?@*)t|t
aLh?@* D2 ELi4Mihc e.DS
ac jL?} @?_ i* i@htL?c bbbc Nt?} @*i @| ht! |L UL?|hL* ht! |@!?}G OL
hL?} U@? )L Miq aLh?@* Lu +t!  E`?|ihc DS
w)L?tc +U@h_c 2ffc Ai UhLt|hU|hi TThL@U |L , U@?}i +@|itc WA hittG @4
Mh_}i
@h!L|3c Oc bDbc Lh|uL*L 5i*iU|L?G ,Ui?| #iht€U@|L? Lu W?it|4i?|tc i
vLh!G `*i)
**ihc ih|L?c bbc 6?@?U@* W??L@|L?t @?_ @h!i| VL*@|*|)c *@U!i**G @4M
_h}i
Lhhtc 5|iTi? @?_ O)? 5L?} 5?c bbbc R+t! @?@}i4i?| | W?|ih_iTi?_i?|
LUic 6?@?U@* 5|@M*|) +ii . ELi4Mihc eDf
Lhhtc 5|iTi? @?_ O)? 5L?} 5?c bbH@c RN?^i ,^*Mh4 ? @ L_i* Lu 5i*u
6*€**?} hhi?U) ||@U!tc 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +ii HH Ea?ic DH.Db.
iht@_c ?@tc 2fffc R5i?_?} |i Oih_ g |i *g ,_}iG Ai #t|hM?} W?|ih@U
|L? Mi|ii? Oih_?} @?_ @h!i|5i?t|i +t! @?@}i4i?| h@U|Uitc aLh?@* Lu
+t! 6?@?Ui 2c DbSD
h|t!ihc @||c 2ffc RAi O__i? #@?}iht Lu Ot|LhU@* 54*@|L?c `Lh!?} @Tihc
L@h_ Lu BLih?Lht Lu |i 6i_ih@* +itihi 5)t|i4
+L**c +U@h_c bHHc RAi W?|ih?@|L?@* h@t Lu U|LMih bH.c 6?@?U@* ?@*)t|t
aLh?@* ee E5iT|c bD
+M?t|i?c @h! @?_ O@)?i wi*@?_c bHc R+iT*U@|?} T|L?t | Lt|L?t ? 5|LU!
@?_ @t 6?@?U@* ?@*)t|t aLh?@* . Ea*)c S.2
5U?@tc B@hh) @?_ + AL__ 54|c 2fffc RLh|uL*L #iht€U@|L?c wiih@}ic @?_ 6
?@?U@* L?|@}L?c W6 5|@g @Tiht e. E#iUi4Mihc Db.S
hit_i?|@* A@t! 6LhUi L? @h!i| iU@?t4t EUL*@t h@_)c @h4@?c bHHc +iTLh|
Lu |i hit_i?|@* A@t! 6LhUi L? @h!i| iU@?t4tc `@t?}|L?c #G Ahi@th)
#iT@h|4i?|