Perencanaan Transportasi

Tugas
Nama
NIM

Dewangga Megaloka Putri

I0612011

Metode Tanpa Batasan

Masa Sekarang
Zona
1
1
30
2
40
3
20
4
50
5
55
dd
195
Dd
214.5
Ed
1.1

2
20
20
10
10
10
70
140
2

3
50
10
20
10
10
100
110
1.1

4
60
10
10
20
10
110
121
1.1

5 oi
55
10
10
10
20
105
115.5
1.1

Metode Tanpa Batasan

Masa Yang Akan Datang
Zona
1
1
192
2
256
3
128
4
320
5
352
dd
1248
Dd
214.5

2
128
128
64
64
64
448
140

3
320
64
128
64
64
640
110

4
384
64
64
128
64
704
121

5 oi
352
64
64
64
128
672
115.5

Oi
215
90
70
100
105
580

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1

719
6.4

Oi
1376
576
448
640
672
3712

236.5
180
77
110
115.5
719

Metode Satu Batasan

Masa Sekarang
Zona
1
1
30
2
40
3
20
4
50
5
55
dd
195
Dd
214.5
Ed
1.1

2
20
20
10
10
10
70
140
2

3
50
10
20
10
10
100
110
1.1

4
60
10
10
20
10
110
121
1.1

2
24.79
24.79
12.40
12.40
12.40
86.78
140
1.61

3
61.98
12.40
24.79
12.40
12.40
123.97
110
0.89

4
74.38
12.40
12.40
24.79
12.40
136.36
121
0.89

Metode Satu Batasan (Tarikan)

Masa Sekarang
Zona
1
2
1
30
20
2
40
20
3
20
10
4
50
10
5
55
10
dd
195
70
Dd
214.5
140
Ed
1.1
2

3
50
10
20
10
10
100
110
1.1

4
60
10
10
20
10
110
121
1.1

5 oi
55
10
10
10
20
105
115.5
1.1

Masa Yang Akan Datang

Zona
1
1
33
2
44
3
22
4
55
5
60.5
dd
214.5
Dd
214.5
Ed
1

3
55
11
22
11
11
110
110
1

4
66
11
11
22
11
121
121
1

5 oi
60.5
11
11
11
22
115.5
115.5
1

Masa Yang Akan Datang

Zona
1
1
37.19
2
49.59
3
24.79
4
61.98
5
68.18
dd
241.73
Dd
214.5
Ed
0.89

2
40
40
20
20
20
140
140
1

5 oi
55
10
10
10
20
105
115.5
1.1

Oi
215
90
70
100
105
580

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1

719
1.24

5 oi
Oi
68.18
266.53
12.40
111.57
12.40
86.78
12.40
123.97
24.79
130.16
130.16
719
115.5
0.89

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5
719
1

Oi
215
90
70
100
105
580

1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1

719
1.24

Oi
254.5
117
86
119
124.5
701

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

0.93
1.54
0.90
0.92
0.93

719
1.03

1. Metode Rata-rata
Tabel 1.1 MAT masa sekarang dengan prediksi Oi dan Dd masa mendatang
Zona
1
2
3
4
5 oi
1
30
20
50
60
55
2
40
20
10
10
10
3
20
10
20
10
10
4
50
10
10
20
10
5
55
10
10
10
20
dd
195
70
100
110
105
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
115.5
Ed
1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1
Tabel 1.2 MAT masa datang dengan metode rata-rata
Zona
1
2
3
4
1
33
22
55
66
2
62
40
15.5
15.5
3
22
11
22
11
4
55
11
11
22
5
60.5
11
11
11
dd
232.5
95
114.5
125.5
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
Ed
0.922581 1.473684 0.960699 0.964143

5 oi
60.5
15.5
11
11
22
120
115.5
0.9625

Oi
215
90
70
100
105
580

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1

719
1.24

Oi
236.5
148.5
77
110
115.5
687.5

Tabel 1.3 MAT masa datang dengan metode rata-rata

Zona
1
2
3
4
1 31.72258 16.21053 53.91921 64.81673
2 66.17576 35.72568 16.83935 16.86605
3 21.14839 8.105263 21.56769 10.80279
4 52.87097 8.105263 10.78384 21.60558
5 58.15806 8.105263 10.78384 10.80279
dd
230.0758 76.25199 113.8939 124.8939
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
Ed
0.932302 1.836018 0.965811 0.968822

5
59.36563
16.85331
10.79375
10.79375
21.5875
119.3939
115.5
0.967386

oi
Oi
226.0347
152.4602
72.41787
104.1594
109.4375
664.5096

Tabel 1.4 MAT masa datang dengan metode rata-rata

Zona
1
2
3
4
1 31.38317 15.57041 54.24571 65.3068
2 69.91264 38.72072 18.07239 18.12644
3 21.1016 7.911501 21.88133 10.97615
4 52.56366 7.85793 10.90184 21.87452
5 57.80036 7.852898 10.8982 10.93361
dd
232.7614 77.91346 115.9995 127.2175
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
Ed
0.921544 1.796865 0.94828 0.951127

5
59.77185
18.10065
10.95921
10.92036
21.83342
121.5855
115.5
0.949949

oi
Oi
226.2779
162.9328
72.82979
104.1183
109.3185
675.4773

Ei
236.5
1
180 1.212121
77
1
110
1
115.5
1
719
1.05

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

1.0463
1.180636
1.063273
1.056074
1.055397

719
1.08

Tabel 1.5 MAT masa datang dengan metode rata-rata

Zona
1
2
3
4
5 oi
Oi
1 30.86094 14.62091 54.06819 65.18604 59.62612 224.3622
2 70.83178 38.43199 18.55158 18.63286 18.59569 165.0439
3 20.87796 7.514951 21.94194 11.02218 10.99871 72.35574

236.5
180
77
110
115.5

Ei
1.045175
1.10475
1.05726
1.05649
1.056546

719
1.06

Ei
236.5 1.054099
180 1.090619
77 1.064186

dd
Dd
Ed

4 51.98638 7.458634 10.92785 21.95783 10.95552 103.2862

5 57.16717 7.454249 10.92449 10.97555 21.90432 108.4258
231.7242 75.48074 116.414 127.7745 122.0804 673.4738
214.5
140
110
121
115.5
0.925669 1.854778 0.944903 0.946981 0.946098

110 1.065002
115.5 1.065245
719
1.07

Tabel 1.6 MAT masa datang dengan metode rata-rata

Zona
1
2
3
4
1 30.54876 14.29282 54.04122 65.22125
2 71.40864 38.87119 18.88108 18.98316
3 20.77207 7.416616 22.04166 11.08372
4 51.74389 7.366675 10.98197 22.08939
5 56.90746 7.364024 10.97992 11.04265
dd
231.3808 75.31132 116.9258 128.4202
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
Ed
0.927043 1.85895 0.940767 0.94222

5
59.632
18.93708
11.05527
11.01632
22.02855
122.6692
115.5
0.941557

oi

Tabel 1.7 MAT masa datang dengan metode rata-rata

Zona
1
2
3
4
1 30.30578 14.04271 53.98222 65.1974
2 71.56446 38.92339 19.05184 19.16863
3 20.6789 7.334655 22.09405 11.11811
4 51.56156 7.298434 11.01863 22.17918
5 56.71689 7.298202 11.0185 11.08946
dd
230.8276 74.89739 117.1652 128.7528
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
Ed
0.929265 1.869224 0.938845 0.939785

5
59.59043
19.11582
11.08591
11.05745
22.11464
122.9642
115.5
0.939297

oi
Oi
223.1185
167.8241
72.31163
103.1152
108.2377
674.6072

Tabel 1.8 MAT masa datang dengan metode rata-rata

Zona
1
2
3
4
1 30.14273 13.91162 53.95036 65.18959
2 71.62945 39.01756 19.1604 19.28687
3 20.6179 7.299508 22.13471 11.1438
4 51.45928 7.276639 11.04955 22.25185
5 56.6137 7.278647 11.05123 11.12762
dd
230.4631 74.78398 117.3462 128.9997
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
Ed
0.930735 1.872059 0.937397 0.937987

5
59.56874
19.22907
11.10882
11.09098
22.18533
123.1829
115.5
0.93763

oi

Tabel 1.9 MAT masa datang dengan metode rata-rata

Zona
1
2
3
4
1 30.0282 13.82468 53.92509 65.17827
2 71.63322 39.0551 19.22523 19.35781
3 20.57329 7.27624 22.16054 11.16009
4 51.39154 7.264992 11.07181 22.30324
5 56.54704 7.26889 11.07503 11.15486
dd
230.1733 74.68991 117.4577 129.1543
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
Ed
0.931907 1.874417 0.936507 0.936864

5
59.54778
19.29637
11.12308
11.11461
22.23569
123.3175
115.5
0.936606

oi

Oi

223.736
167.0811
72.36934
103.1982
108.3226
674.7074

236.5
180
77
110
115.5

Ei
1.057049
1.077321
1.063987
1.06591
1.066259

719
1.07

236.5
180
77
110
115.5

Ei
1.059975
1.072551
1.064836
1.066768
1.067096

719
1.07

Oi

222.763
168.3233
72.30475
103.1283
108.2565
674.7759

236.5
180
77
110
115.5

Ei
1.061666
1.06937
1.064937
1.066633
1.06691

719
1.07

222.504
168.5677
72.29324
103.1462
108.2815
674.7927

Oi
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

Ei
1.062902
1.06782
1.065107
1.066447
1.066664

719
1.07

Tabel 1.9 MAT masa datang dengan metode rata-rata

Zona
1
2
3
4
1 29.93267 13.75428 53.93315 65.20723
2 71.58146
39.036 19.27538 19.41401
3 20.53051
7.2542 22.18828 11.17735
4 51.31914 7.252105 11.09309 22.35269
5 56.4735 7.25747 11.09752 11.1808
dd
229.8373 74.55406 117.5874 129.3321
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
Ed
0.933269 1.877832 0.935474 0.935576

5
59.56362
19.34895
11.1383
11.13727
22.28343
123.4716
115.5
0.935438

oi
Oi
222.3909
168.6558
72.28863
103.1543
108.2927
674.7824

236.5
180
77
110
115.5

Ei
1.063443
1.067262
1.065174
1.066364
1.066554

719
1.07

2. Metode Detroit
Tabel 1.1 MAT masa sekarang dengan prediksi Oi dan Dd masa mendatang
Zona
1
2
3
4
5 oi
1
30
20
50
60
55
2
40
20
10
10
10
3
20
10
20
10
10
4
50
10
10
20
10
5
55
10
10
10
20
dd
195
70
100
110
105
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
115.5
Ed
1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1

Oi
215
90
70
100
105
580

Tabel 1.2 MAT masa sekarang dengan prediksi Oi dan Dd masa mendatang
Zona
1
2
3
4
5 oi
Oi
1 29.28234 35.49374 48.80389 58.56467 53.68428 225.8289
2 70.98748 64.53408 17.74687 17.74687 17.74687 188.7622
3 19.52156 17.74687 19.52156 9.760779 9.760779 76.31154
4 48.80389 17.74687 9.760779 19.52156 9.760779 105.5939
5 53.68428 17.74687 9.760779 9.760779 19.52156 110.4743
dd
222.2796 153.2684 105.5939 115.3547 110.4743 706.9708
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
115.5
Ed
0.965
0.913
1.042
1.049
1.045

236.5
180
77
110
115.5
719

236.5
180
77
110
115.5
719

Ei
1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1

1.24

Ei
1.047253
0.953581
1.009022
1.041727
1.045492

1.02

3. Metode Furness
Tabel 1.1 MAT masa sekarang dengan prediksi Oi dan Dd masa mendatang
Zona
1
2
3
4
5 oi
1
30
20
50
60
55
2
40
20
10
10
10
3
20
10
20
10
10
4
50
10
10
20
10
5
55
10
10
10
20
dd
195
70
100
110
105
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
115.5
Ed
1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1

215
90
70
100
105
580

Tabel 1.2 MAT masa sekarang dengan prediksi Oi dan Dd masa mendatang
Zona
1
2
3
4
5 oi
1
33
22
55
66
60.5
236.5
2
80
40
20
20
20
180
3
22
11
22
11
11
77
4
55
11
11
22
11
110
5
60.5
11
11
11
22
115.5
dd
250.5
95
119
130
124.5
719
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
115.5
Ed
0.856287 1.473684 0.92437 0.930769 0.927711

Tabel 1.2 MAT masa sekarang dengan prediksi Oi dan Dd masa mendatang
Zona
1
2
3
4
5 oi
1 28.25749 32.42105 50.84034 61.43077
172.9496
2 68.50299 58.94737 18.48739 18.61538
164.5531
3 18.83832 16.21053 20.33613 10.23846
65.62345
4 47.09581 16.21053 10.16807 20.47692
93.95133
5 51.80539 16.21053 10.16807 10.23846
88.42244
dd
214.5
140
110
121
0
585.5
Dd
214.5
140
110
121
115.5
Ed
1
1
1
1 #DIV/0!

Oi

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

1.1
2
1.1
1.1
1.1

719
1.24

Oi

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

1
1
1
1
1

719
1.00

Oi

Ei
236.5
180
77
110
115.5

1.36745
1.093872
1.173361
1.170819
1.306229

719
1.23