tionghoa-net
<-- Terurut Topik --> <-- Terurut Waktu --> Cari sejarah islam di nusantara
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
indoshepherd
Fri, 11 Nov 2005 19:06:27 -0800
Pak Chan CT yth.,
Dibawah ini saya lampirkan bukti2/fakta2 sejarah yang bertentangan
dengan gagasan anda, bahwa (1) Islam di Nusantara disebarkan oleh
orang2 Cina, dan (2) bahwa sebagian (besar) dari Walisongo itu
keturunan Cina.
(1) Yang benar, laksamana Ceng Ho memang seorang Muslim. Alasannya
mudah ditebak, untuk menimbulkan SIMPATI dari negara2 yang
dikunjunginya, yang SUDAH DIKETAHUI oleh Kaisar Tiongkok
majoritasnya beragama Islam. Ini adalah politik yang sama, kenapa
Amerika mengangkat wanita kulit hitam Condoleeza Rice sebagai wakil
dari State Department dalam perundingan2 dengan negara2 Arab.
Samasekali TIDAK ADA BUKTI bahwa Islam di Jawa disebarkan oleh anak
buah Ceng Ho (Saya tantang anda untuk membuktikan kata2 anda).
http://www.mail-archive.com/tionghoa-net@yahoogroups.com/msg06137.html (1 of 20)21-Mar-08 12:36:02 PM
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[2] Babad Tanah Jawa dan Serta Kanda yang diandalkan oleh MO
Parlindungan dan prof. Slamet Mulyana itu TIDAK BISA DIPERCAYA sebab
bercampur-aduk dengan dongeng, mistik dan tahayul:
http://www.theswanker.com/macammacam/history/
http://www.theswanker.com/macammacam/2004/06/the_walisongo_j_1.html
June 18, 2004
The Walisongo, Java's muslim saints: an introduction
In the story of Islam's spread in Indonesia, the Walisongo hold a
special place. Said to have been a group of nine missionaries that
http://www.mail-archive.com/tionghoa-net@yahoogroups.com/msg06137.html (2 of 20)21-Mar-08 12:36:02 PM
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
lived during the 15th and 16th centuries AD, the Walisongo used
combined pious acts, supernatural displays of power, political
manoeuvring and outright military conquest, to extend Islam's reach
across Java and neighbouring islands. Their tombs are popular places
of pilgrimage, drawing devotees from all over Java and indeed,
Muslim South-East Asia.
These early missionaries of Islam were elevated to the status of
walis (an Arabic term for `saint') and ascribed the title Sunan (a
Javanese epithet akin to "Honourable"). Over the centuries many
stories surrounding the lives of these men and their exploits have
been told.
Much of what we know comes from a collection of QUASI-FACTUAL
Javanese manuscripts collectively known as Babad Tanah Jawi
("History of the land of Java). There is NO ATTEMPT TO SEPARATE THE
FACT FROM THE FICTION and no indication to laypersons such as myself
what can or has been corroborated by archaeological evidence. Yet
legends or myths still reveal much that can be of assistance to the
historian or fact seeker, especially if they still hold sway in the
hearts and minds of believers.
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
<http://www.lonelyplanet.com/mapshells/south_east_asia/vietnam/vietna
m.htm>)
Sunan Ampel (also Raden Rakhmat) who did his work in Surabaya, and
spread Islam in East Java. Sunan Ampel was the original leader of
the walisongo. He was a nephew of the King of Majapahit, and a
cousin to Raden Patah, first Sultan of Demak. He was actually born
in Champa, an Islamic kingdom located where the southern part of
Vietnam is today. Sunan Bonang and Sunan Drajad were both his sons.
Sunan Giri lived with him alongside his sons as a young man.
<http://solo.manuatele.net/farwest.htm>
1447 AD: Kertawijaya, brother of Suhita, becomes King of Majapahit.
He converts to Islam on the advice of his wife, Darawati, a princess
of Champa (in what is now Vietnam). Sunan Ampel, nephew of
Kertawijaya, works to spread Islam around Surabaya. Sunan Ampel in a
traditional portrait. Sunan Ampel was the first notable member of
the Nine Walis or Walisongo, Islamic teachers who worked to spread
Islam around Java in the late 1400s and early 1500s.
[5] TIME LINE SEJARAH RESMI PENYEBARAN ISLAM di INDONESIA:
Earlier history on the spread of Islam in Indonesia & Malaysia:
1405 AD: Chinese Admiral Cheng Ho visits Semarang.
1406 AD: Wirabumi is executed, and his head is brought to the court
of Majapahit. The war of succession ends.
1409 AD: Cheng Ho visits Melaka for the first time.
1411 AD: Paramesvara visits Beijing on a state visit.
1414 AD: (Indonesia) Paramesvara converts to Islam, and takes the
name Iskandar Syah, after marrying the daughter of the Sultan of
Pasai. Melaka is now an Islamic sultanate. Islam, one of Indonesia's
five religions. The Islamic religion had been common among traders
in Sumatra and Java for some time. The Singhasari and Majapahit
kingdoms probably had a few Muslims involved in their courts. Largescale conversions to Islam began when local kings adopted the new
religion. Aceh and Melaka were among the first. Most of Java did not
become Muslims until the early 1500s. (Today, over 85% of
Indonesians are Muslims.)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
<http://www.country-studies.com/singapore/history.html>
A Malay seventeenth-century chronicle, the Sejarah Melayu (Malay
Annals), recounts the founding of a great trading city on the island
in 1299 by a ruler from Palembang, Sri Tri Buana, who named the city
Singapura ("lion city") after sighting a strange beast that he took
to be a lion. The prosperous Singapura, according to the Annals, in
the mid-fourteenth century suffered raids by the expanding Javanese
Majapahit Empire to the south and the emerging Thai kingdom of
Ayutthaya to the north, both at various times claiming the island as
a vassal state.
The Annals, as well as contemporaneous Portuguese accounts, note the
arrival around 1388 of King Paramesvara from Palembang, who was
fleeing Majapahit control. Although granted asylum by the ruler of
Singapura, the king murdered his host and seized power. Within a few
years, however, Majapahit or Thai forces again drove out
Paramesvara, who fled northward to found eventually the great
seaport and kingdom of Malacca. In 1414 Paramesvara converted to
Islam and established the Malacca Sultanate, which in time
controlled most of the Malay Peninsula, eastern Sumatra, and the
islands between, including Singapura. Fighting ships for the
sultanate were supplied by a senior Malaccan official based at
Singapura. The city of Malacca served not only as the major seaport
of the region in the fifteenth century, but also as the focal point
for the dissemination of Islam throughout insular Southeast Asia.
[7] JATUHNYA KERAJAAN2 HINDU DI ASIA TENGGARA
(menurut sumber/website agama Hindu)
<http://www.sulekha.com/expressions/column.asp?cid=(0475>
Indian website on History of Hinduism
Fall of Hinduism in South East Asia
The failure of leadership is strikingly seen in the fall of Hinduism
in South East Asia. Let us examine the conversion of the Malay and
Indonesian archipelago to Islam. The following account has been
gleaned from the Indonesian time line[20] and an analysis of the
defeat is offered. In the 1300s, Indonesia and Malaysia were being
ruled by the powerful Hindu-Buddhist Majapahit empire but its
influence was declining towards the end of the 14th century.
In 1401 a war of succession began in Majapahit, lasting four years
and the power of Majapahit begins to lessen. At this time,
http://www.mail-archive.com/tionghoa-net@yahoogroups.com/msg06137.html (5 of 20)21-Mar-08 12:36:02 PM
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[9] Babad Tanah Jawi TIDAK PERNAH MANYATAKAN Sunan Ampel orang Cina:
<http://www.seasite.niu.edu/Indonesian/Islam/Ibrahim.htm>
Maulana Malik Ibrahim, atau Makdum Ibrahim As-Samarkandy
diperkirakan lahir di Samarkand, Asia Tengah, pada paruh awal abad
14. BABAD TANAH JAWI VERSI MEINSMA menyebutnya Asmarakandi,
mengikuti pengucapan lidah Jawa terhadap As-Samarkandy, berubah
menjadi Asmarakandi.
http://www.mail-archive.com/tionghoa-net@yahoogroups.com/msg06137.html (6 of 20)21-Mar-08 12:36:02 PM
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[11] Penyebaran Islam diAsia menurut sumber2 sejarah lain yang bisa
dipercaya:
<http://www.ccg.org/english/s/b7_9.html>
The Origins and Method of Islams' Arrival in Sumatra
According to Ethnic Groups of Insular Southeast Asia vol 1, Human
Relations Area Files Press, New Haven,1972, pp. 15ff. at p.16,
Chinese sources dating from as early as 500 AD contain references to
the Kingdom of Poli in North Sumatra, within the present bounds of
Aceh, which apparently was ruled by Buddhists of Indian extraction.
In the middle of the fourteenth century. Ibn Battuta found at Pase a
flourishing Islamic state, which had evidently been in existence for
some time before his arrival. By the beginning of the sixteenth
century, the center of power had moved to the valley of the Aceh
http://www.mail-archive.com/tionghoa-net@yahoogroups.com/msg06137.html (10 of 20)21-Mar-08 12:36:02 PM
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
River, and from 1507 until the beginning of the twentieth century a
long line of sultans existed here, whose domain at some periods
extended over most of Sumatra but whose actual power was quite
limited outside the confines of Great Aceh.
The Acehnese people:
have been divided by some into hill people (ureueng tunong) and
lowland people (ureueng baroh) on the basis of physical type and
minor cultural differences. Racially, they are a product of many
centuries of interbreeding of indigenes with Bataks, Hindus,
Dravidians, Javanese, Arabs, Chinese, and Niasan slaves. No good
anthropometric data exist, but observers agree that there is
considerable physical divergence between the inland population, of a
fairly homogeneous proto-Malay type, and the coastal Acehnese, who
are physically quite heterogeneous, although relatively slim, tall
and almost Caucasoid in appearance (Kennedy 1935).
According to William Dampier in 1688 (Voyages and Discoveries, ed. C
Wilkinson, London, Argonaut Press 1931), as well as importing the
majority of their rice, agriculture was by:
... Slaves brought lately by the English and the Danes from the
Coast of Coromandel, in the Time of a Famine there, I spoke of
before, who first brought this Sort of Husbandry into such Request
among the Acehnese. Yet neither does the Rice they have this way
supply one Quarter of their Occasions, but they have it brought to
them from their Neighbouring Countries." (Quoted by A Reid in Trade
and the Problem of Royal Power in Aceh. Three Stages: c. 15550-1700
in Monographs of the Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society,
No. 6, Pre-Colonial State Systems in Southeast Asia, Anthony Reid et
al, Kuala Lumpur, Rajiv Printers 1975, p 54).
This influx of Indian slaves is confirmed later by Charles Lockyer
and Snouck Hurgronje (see ibid., p. 54).
The use of slaves, or bondmen, by the lowland city groups is noted
by Reid in Southeast Asia in the Age of Commerce 1450-1560 Vol. 1:
The Lands below the Winds at pp. 131 ff.
This form of labour was common over an extended period. The hill
peoples provided the labour either selling captives or more often
simply being raided for slaves. The city populace often had to
provide half their time in labour to the king. So often it was more
profitable to enter into bondship. This was sometimes abused and was
denounced, according to Reid, by some monarchs. It is obvious from
this practice that tribal custom would be syncretised repeatedly.
It is clear that by 1281 Islam had made some progress in Sumatra at
Malayu as the Chinese chose to dispatch the Muslims, Sulaiman and
http://www.mail-archive.com/tionghoa-net@yahoogroups.com/msg06137.html (11 of 20)21-Mar-08 12:36:02 PM
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
before any of the others, even before the king of Pase" (II:245 cf.
Drewes p. 11) is devalued by Drewes although it is logically
possible. Pires described Pasai as a rich city, containing many
Moorish and Indian traders, among whom the Bengalis were the most
important. He distinguishes further Rumis, Turks, Arabs, Persians,
Gujeratis, Klings, Malays, Javanese and Siamese. The people
consisted mainly of Bengalis or people of Bengal origin. The people
under Moorish influence appointed a 'Moorish king of the Bengali
caste' but the countryside was still heathen, although Islam was
progressing daily. The kings were killed on a repetitive basis, as
in Bengal and whoever killed him provided he was Muslim succeeded in
his place. Drewes considers Pires may have been told this by a
Bengali, out of nationalistic exaltation.
This information of Pires is the basis for the assertions of the
Bengal origin of Islam in Indonesia and was taken up by Professor
S.Q. Fatimi in 1963 (Islam Comes to Malaysia, Malaysian Sociol,
Research Institute Ltd. Singapore). He refers (from Parker) to the
Chinese report of the Chinese traveller at Qui[l]lon in South India
in 1282 meeting with the official from Su-mu-ta (Samudra) who was
urged to send envoys to China. Soon after the envoys Hasan and
Suleiman were sent, thus it was taken that they were Muslim. But
note the Chinese mission of 1281 above. It may have been deemed
politic to send Islamic Samudran envoys after receiving Islamic
Chinese ones. Another alternative is that the accounts themselves
have been confused. Certainly the title of the Samudran King at this
time was ta-kur which is of North Indian derivation and not Muslim.
Drewes notes from the Chinese report of 1282 (cf. Parker 'The Island
of Sumatra" in The Imperial and Asiatic Quarterly Review, 3rd
series, vol. IX, 1900 and referred to by Drewes p.13). It is
apparently derived from the Hindi thakur or the Sanskrit thakkura
meaning lord or master and which occurs in many North Indian
languages, but sometimes in other meanings (see Turner A Comparative
Dictionary of the Indo-Aryan Languages No. 5488).
Both Fatimi and Drewes are in agreement on one fundamental point and
that is that, long before Islam, relations existed between Bengal
and the Indonesian Archipelago. It was by travelling from the port
of Tamralipta in Bengal, as well as overland that the Sailendra
realm received the form of Mahayana Buddhism, which became dominant
in the Archipelago.
It has been mentioned above that in the middle of the 9th century
the Sumatran Sialendra king Balaputra Deva, founded a Buddhist
monastry at Nalanda in Bengal, setting aside the five villages
http://www.mail-archive.com/tionghoa-net@yahoogroups.com/msg06137.html (15 of 20)21-Mar-08 12:36:02 PM
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II)
[t-net] Re: Cheng Ho, Islam dan Indonesia ==> Chan CT (bagian ke-II) indoshepherd
Kirimkan email ke
indoshepherd