LITERATUR REVIEW
Ruang: .................................................
Oleh :
__________________
NIM
TELAAH JURNAL I
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
Berdasarkan masalah penelitian, apa tujuan dan hipotesis yang ditetapkan oleh
peneliti ?
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
Untuk desain eksperimen:
Apakah menggunakan kelompok kontrol untuk menentukan efektifitas suatu
intervensi ?
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
Berapa jumlah sampel yang digunakan dalam penelitian? Metode atau rumus apa
yang digunakan untuk menentukan jumlah sampel?
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
ANALISIS DATA
Uji Statistik apa yang digunakan untuk menguji hipotesis atau menganalisis data?
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................
Intention to treat adalah menganalisis semua sampel yang megikuti penelitian, baik
yang drop out, loss follow up atau berhenti sebelum penelitian selesai. Sampel yang
drop out dianggap hasil intervensi yang gagal.
On treatment analysis hanya menganalisis sampel yang mengikuti penelitian sampai
selesai saja, sedangkan sampel drop out diannggap tidak mengikuti penelitian dan
tidak diikutkan dalam analisis.
Program atau software statistic apa yang digunakan peneliti untuk menganalisis
data?
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
HASIL PENELITIAN
Bagaimana alur (flow) penelitian yang menggambarkan responden yang mengikuti
penelitian sampai selesai, drop out dan loss follow up?
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
DISKUSI
Bagaimana interpretasi peneliti terhadap hasil penelitian? Apakah peneliti
membuat interpretasi yang rasional dan ilmiah tentang hal-hal yang ditemukan
dalam penelitian berdasarkan teori terkini? Catatan: meskipun hasil penelitian
tidak sesuai dengan hipotesis, namun suatu penelitian tetap berkualitas jika
peneliti mampu menjelaskan rasional secara ilmiah mengapa hipotesisnya tidak
terbukti.
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
Apakah mungkin penelitian ini direplikasi pada setting pratik klinik lainnya?
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
Apakah peneliti menjelaskan kekuatan dan kelemahan penelitian? Apakah
kelemahan ini tidak menurunkan validitas hasil penelitian?
..............................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
B. Ekstraksi Data Jurnal (Critical Appraisal)
NO Penelitian Sampel (karakteristik, Desain/Seleksi Intervensi Hasil temuan/Kesimpulan Level Penelitian Komentar reviewer
(Peneliti & ukuran, setting) responden peneliti (kekuatan dan keterbatasan
Waktu) penelitian)
1 Ismail Populasi penelitian adalah Consekutif Perbandingan efek Penulis menyimpulkan (IIa) Kekuatan : penelitian ini
Jaya, .............. pasien cedera otak sedang sampling pemberian bahwa tidak tampak merupakan penelitian
........................ dengan ............................... hipertonik salin perbedaan bermakna GCS Evidence based dari eksperimen semu, level
............ ........................................... solution 3% dan pasien yang diberikan paling sedikit satu uji penelitian moderate
.......... dengan GCS 9-12 di manitol 20% pada Hipertonik Salin Solution 3 klinik dengan clinical certainly
(2017) RSUP Dr Wahidin pasien trauma % dan Manitol 20 % pada pembanding, tanpa (rekomendasi B)
Sudirohusodo Makassar kepala sedang trauma kepala sedang. RCT
selama masa penelitian. Kelemahan : Faktor-faktor
.............................................. perancu hasil penelitian
Sampel penelitian .............................................. sebaiknya dimasukkan
adalah ................................ .............................................. sebagai kriteria eksklusi.
......................... ............................................. Sebaiknya digunakan alat
ukur dengan akurasi yang
.............................................. baik..........................
..............................................
..............................................
............................................