Bab 11
Bab 11
Schools
BAB 11
MyCounselingLab®
Kunjungi situs MyCounselingLab® untuk Intervensi Pengembangan Karir, Edisi Kelima, untuk
meningkatkan pemahaman Anda tentang konsep bab. Anda akan memiliki kesempatan untuk berlatih
menerapkan apa yang Anda pelajari dalam bab ini dengan menyelesaikan latihan berbasis video dan
kasus di MyLab. Mengikuti Kuis Lisensi akan membantu Anda mempersiapkan diri untuk ujian sertifikasi
Antonio adalah orang baru di sekolah itu. Dia dan orang tuanya baru saja pindah dari Los Angeles ke
pedesaan Pennsylvania. Sebagai siswa kelas tujuh di L.A., Antonio memiliki banyak teman,
mengenal sebagian besar gurunya, dan merupakan salah satu pemain bintang di tim sepak bola. Di
Belltoona, Pennsylvania, Antonio masih baru, bingung, dan tidak yakin akan dirinya sendiri. Dia
marah tentang
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 308
Schools
306
bergerak; dia merasa sendirian, dan dia depresi. Orang tua Antonio memperhatikan bahwa dia telah
menjadi apatis dan tidak terlibat dalam banyak kegiatan yang pernah memberinya rasa puas dan
bangga.
pendidikan dan karier mana yang paling masuk akal bagi mereka. Hal ini tidak berarti bahwa penekanan
pada kesadaran diri dan kesadaran karir di sekolah dasar sudah selesai. Faktanya, konselor sekolah harus
membantu siswa mengembangkan kesadaran yang lebih canggih di bidang ini karena mereka
mendorong siswa untuk mengeksplorasi kemungkinan masa depan. Lebih khusus lagi, konselor sekolah
SMP / SMA
Situasi Antonio mewakili apa yang dialami banyak siswa sekolah menengah. Siswa di tingkat
sekolah menengah dihadapkan dengan serangkaian tugas perkembangan yang lebih canggih daripada
yang mereka alami selama tahun-tahun sekolah dasar mereka. Erikson (1963) mencatat bahwa antara
usia 12 dan 18 remaja harus mengklarifikasi identitas mereka. Jika klarifikasi identitas tidak tercapai,
maka remaja akan mengalami kebingungan ketika mereka mencoba untuk menegosiasikan tugas-
tugas yang diberikan kepada mereka. Secara khusus, Havighurst (1972) menyarankan bahwa remaja
harus menyelesaikan tugas-tugas perkembangan berikut:
1. Mencapai hubungan baru dan lebih canggih dengan rekan-rekan
2. Mencapai kemandirian emosional dari orang tua dan orang dewasa lainnya
3. Tetapkan tujuan kejuruan
4. Mempersiapkan pernikahan dan kehidupan keluarga
5. Mengembangkan keterampilan untuk kompetensi kewarganegaraan
6. Memperoleh seperangkat nilai dan sistem etika sebagai panduan perilaku
7. Tetapkan tujuan yang realistis dan buat rencana untuk mencapai tujuan ini
Tugas-tugas ini menghadirkan tantangan yang menakutkan bagi kaum muda saat mereka
bergerak dari masa kanak-kanak ke remaja dan dewasa awal. Pengalaman transisi yang sering penuh
badai dari masa kanak-kanak ke remaja tidak hanya menghadirkan tantangan bagi orang muda yang
mengalami transisi ini tetapi juga bagi mereka yang merupakan bagian dari jaringan sosial orang
muda tersebut. Ekspektasi perkembangan sosial mendorong praremaja untuk mengambil langkah
menuju kemandirian. Namun, langkah menuju kemandirian seringkali disertai dengan perasaan tidak
aman, konflik, ketakutan, dan kecemasan; sebagai Vernon (1993) menyatakan, "Perubahan dramatis
dalam kognisi dan intensifikasi pengaruh berkontribusi pada rasa diri yang berfluktuasi" (hal. 10).
Bireley dan Genshaft (1991) menggambarkan masa remaja awal sebagai proses "berjuang menuju
kedewasaan" (hal. 1). Sebagai hasil dari perkembangan mereka yang maju, siswa sekolah menengah
disibukkan dengan rasa memiliki dan dipengaruhi secara signifikan oleh teman sesama jenis mereka.
Dengan demikian, konselor yang memberikan intervensi karir untuk siswa sekolah menengah perlu
menantang siswa untuk menjadi agen aktif dalam proses pengembangan karir sementara pada saat
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 309
Schools
yang sama menawarkan bantuan yang mendukung saat siswa memperoleh informasi diri dan karir
tambahan (American School Counselor Association, 2004)
Orang tua Antonio meminta konselor sekolahnya untuk bertemu dengan Antonio. Mereka ingin
Antonio menjadi lebih terhubung dengan sekolah dan mulai bekerja lebih keras untuk mendapatkan
teman baru. Selama pertemuan mereka, penasihat Antonio meyakinkannya untuk mengikuti kegiatan
sekolah. Bersama-sama, mereka menjelajahi berbagai kegiatan yang tersedia di sekolah Antonio.
Konselor sekolah juga mendorong Antonio untuk mengeksplorasi berbagai pilihan dengan orang
tuanya. Setelah diskusi ini, Antonio dengan enggan setuju untuk bergabung dengan kelompok
pengabdian masyarakat di sekolah tersebut. Konselor juga meminta kapten tim sepak bola sekolah
menengah untuk "membimbing" Antonio dan membantunya menjadi lebih akrab dengan sekolah dan
siswa lainnya. Antonio bertemu dengan penasihatnya secara teratur selama paruh pertama tahun
ajaran dan jelas menjadi lebih terhubung dengan sekolah dan mendapatkan teman baru. Antonio dan
penasihatnya membahas berbagai topik, termasuk pengalaman Antonio dalam kelompok pengabdian
masyarakat. Diskusi-diskusi ini juga berfokus pada bidang-bidang lain yang menarik bagi Antonio.
Seorang pemimpin yang tampaknya alami, penasihat Antonio mendorongnya untuk mengambil peran
kepemimpinan dalam kelompok layanan masyarakat. Antonio suka "bertanggung jawab" dan pada
pemilihan petugas kelompok berikutnya, dia terpilih sebagai presiden. Karena Antonio tidak terlalu
memikirkan kehidupan setelah sekolah menengah, penasihatnya menyarankan agar mereka
meluangkan waktu untuk mendiskusikan rencana kariernya. Tak lama kemudian, Antonio
danpenasihatnya mulai mengeksplorasi bagaimana minatnya terkait dengan berbagai pilihan
pekerjaan.
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 310
Schools
To provide a broader context for Antonio’s career development experiences, it is important
to note that 93% of middle school students report that their goal is to attend college. Only 44%,
however, eventually do, and only 26% graduate with a college diploma within six years of
enroll- ing (Conley, 2012). This aspiration and completion disparity underscores the need for
college and career support for students, beginning in middle school (Berardi-Demo, 2012). As a
seventh-grader, Antonio is at a critical career transition. His parents may sense this, and that
may be what propelled them to seek assistance for Antonio.
Understanding the career development status of middle school students is crucial for devel-
oping goals for career development interventions. As is true at the elementary school level,
coun- selors in middle school settings should view providing career assistance to students as
central to their work (American School Counselor Association, 2003; Campbell & Dahir,
1997). Career assistance provided to middle school students must be sensitive to the contextual,
physical, and emotional transitions that students experience. Akos (2004) highlights the shifts
occurring from elementary to middle school, noting that rising middle school students
encounter “multiple teachers, larger school buildings, block scheduling, lockers, and new
and different peers” (p. 881). These contextual changes occur concurrently with significant
physical and emotional development changes during puberty. Researchers have found that
students making the transi- tion to middle school often experience decreases in self-esteem,
increases in psychological dis- tress, and decreases in academic achievement (Akos).
Akos, Konold, and Niles (2004) found that middle school students exhibit distinct patterns
of needs regarding developing their readiness for career decision making. Some students reflect
developmentally appropriate career indecision or moratorium status, some indicate the need for
more focused and intense personal and career counseling interventions, whereas others may
highlight premature career identity foreclosure and are disengaged from the career decision-
making process. Understanding a student’s career decision-making needs helps counselors to
identify specific career development interventions that may be most useful in fostering a
student’s career development. Here again, data from the National Assessment of Educational
Progress’s Project on Career and Occupational Development provide useful information for
understanding the career development status of middle school students. For example, survey
results from a
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 311
Schools
national sample of 38,000 13-year-olds indicate that young people at this age have made prog-
ress in crystallizing their self-concepts, as exemplified by the fact that they tend to be able to
identify their strengths and weaknesses. Students at this age also evidence a growing
understand- ing of the world-of-work. Often this progress is the result of students participating
in school activities, hobbies, and/or part-time work. Boys and girls at age 13 tend to be equally
knowledge- able about highly visible occupations and can link at least one school subject to a
job. Most stu- dents at this age indicate that they have at least started the process of thinking
about a future job. Interestingly, their choices for future jobs tend to be occupations requiring
college degrees or lengthy training periods beyond high school, rather than jobs now held by
the majority of the workforce (i.e., those not requiring a college degree). Of most concern in the
data provided by the National Assessment of Educational Progress’s Project on Career and
Occupational Develop- ment is the fact that racial minority students and students living in
economic poverty tend to lag behind other students in their career development. Thus, the
effectiveness of current career development interventions provided to middle school students is
variable.
This variability points to the importance of being clear about the societal expectations
placed on students in middle school. As these students transition between Super’s growth and
explora- tion stages, they encounter the task of crystallizing occupational preferences. They are
expected by teachers, counselors, and designers of the school curriculum to develop a realistic
self- concept and to acquire additional information about more opportunities (Super, 1984).
Specifi- cally, middle school students are required to learn about themselves and the world-of-
work and then translate this learning into an educational plan for the remainder of their
secondary school education. Super, Savickas, and Super (1996) refer to the crystallization
process by noting that “when habits of industriousness, achievement, and foresight coalesce,
individuals turn to day- dreaming about possible selves they may construct. Eventually, these
occupational daydreams crystallize into a publicly recognized vocational identity with
corresponding preferences for a group of occupations at a particular ability level” (p. 132).
Thus, to establish an appropriate course of action for high school and beyond, career
development interventions during middle school must be directed toward helping students cope
successfully with the tasks of crystallizing and specifying occupational preferences (Super et
al., 1996).
The ASCA National Standards (ASCA, 2003, 2012) also provide direction for professional
school counselors as they construct career development interventions for middle school stu-
dents. Specifically, the standards indicate that middle school students should “(a) acquire the
skills to investigate the world-of-work in relation to knowledge of self and to make informal
career decisions, (b) employ strategies to achieve future success and satisfaction, and (c) under-
stand the relationship between personal qualities, education and training, and the world-of-
work” (p. 17).
During his meetings with his counselor, Antonio discussed how working in the community
service group helped him feel less lonely and better about himself in general. Antonio enjoyed
planning and organizing the group’s service activities. He had quickly become a leader in this
group and enjoyed this role as well. Antonio confided to his counselor that he had often
dreamed about being a CEO for a company that does something to help others. He stated that
“being in charge” and “helping others” were two things that were fun and important to him.
Antonio’s counselor carefully listened to Antonio’s important self-referent statements. The
counselor helped underscore for Antonio how this self-knowledge could be used to direct
Antonio’s further explo- ration of career options. Specifically, Antonio’s counselor suggested
that he use the computer information delivery system available at the school to find out which
occupations would provide
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 312
Schools
him with opportunities to “be in charge” and “help others.” After generating a list from the
com- puter, Antonio met with his counselor to discuss the options on the list and determine
where he could get more information about the options that interested him the most.
MyCounselingLab®
Summary
Middle school represents a transition point at which understanding of the interrelationship of life roles.
students must become actively engaged in preparing Concurrently, school counselors must offer supportive
for the significant educational choices they will assistance to help middle school students cope with
make as they enter high school. Thus, professional the myriad academic, career, social, and emotional
school counselors at the middle-school level challenges they experience. As middle school students
empower stu- dents to become active agents in the develop more advanced self-awareness and career
career develop- ment process through activities that awareness than they possessed in elementary
foster greater self-understanding, occupational school, they use their advanced knowledge to
knowledge, stronger decision-making skills, and a consider future possibilities and prepare to enter
more sophisticated high school.
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 318
Schools
Case stuDy
James is a 13-year-old African American boy in the Interpersonally, James is a friendly, but shy,
eighth grade. His parents were divorced when he boy. Lately, he has started to associate with a group
was in the first grade. Since then, James has had of boys in his neighborhood who tend to get into
sporadic contact with his father (although his father trou- ble at school. A few have even gotten into
seems to genuinely care about him). After the minor problems (e.g., vandalism) with the law.
divorce, James’s mother relocated to an upper-class James has not been a disciplinary problem.
suburban town in New Jersey. James lives with his In school, James has been an average to above
mother and older sister (age 18). James’s father average student. He finds history and English to be
lives in the town where James was born, which is interesting but struggles with mathematics. Not sur-
two hours away. James’s other sister (age 16) lives prisingly, his favorite class is physical education.
with her father and his second family. Although his James has a general lack of confidence when it
par- ents’ divorce was very difficult, no one in the comes to his academic ability. He likes school
family has received any counseling relative to this because it is where he gets to play sports with his
event. friends. His mother would like you to help him
James’s parents are college graduates. James’s identify some career goals. Ideally, James’s mother
father has a master’s degree in educational thinks he should be a lawyer because they “earn a
leadership and has worked as a middle school good living and it is a prestigious occupation.” But
teacher. How- ever, he is currently employed as the James thinks it would be “fun” to be a coach.
head of the per- sonnel department for the National James’s mother dismisses this as an appropriate
Guard. He changed occupations to increase his occupation, telling James that he will “never make
salary (“You can’t pay the bills on what they pay you any money as a coach” and that one day he will be
as a teacher”). James’s mother is employed as a high “too old” to be involved in sports. James and his
school Spanish teacher. James’s older sister is an father have never discussed what James might do
airline ticket agent. His younger sister is a “when he grows up.” His mother has spo- ken with
successful athlete and good student in the eleventh the school principal about having the school
grade. counselor give James some sort of test that will
Until now, James has given very little attention iden- tify appropriate career options for him. The
to his career. His major interests revolve around principal has asked you (the school counselor) to
sports. He plays baseball, basketball, and football. help out.
He follows the local sports teams as well as the
professional sports teams in his area. His heroes What are James’s career development needs? What
are all professional athletes and James dreams of other issues does James present? What career tasks
being a professional athlete one day. He has no must he complete to begin to engage in effective educa-
other hobbies. tional and career planning? How will you work with
James to help him move forward?
stuDent aCtIvItIes
1. What career development tasks do you think 3. What are three strategies you could use to
are most important to help middle school foster positive career development in middle
students address? school students?
2. What factors do you think could negatively in- 4. What do you think is the most common type
fluence the career development of middle of career assistance provided to middle school
school students? students? Do you think this type of assistance is
helpful? If so, why? If not, why not?
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 319
Schools
5. How could you help parents/guardians to help 10. What do you think is the most common type
their middle school students experience of career assistance provided to middle school
positive career development? students? Do you think this type of assistance is
6. Interview a middle school student about his or helpful? If so, why? If not, why not?
her career development. Ask this person what 11. How could you help parents/guardians to help
occupations s/he thinks are possible for him/ their middle school students experience
her. Ask your interviewee whether there are positive career development?
any occupations that are not possible for
him/her. Ask the person to discuss why certain 12. Ask a group of middle school students (or one
occupa- tions may not be possible. Ask what student if a group is not available) what life
occupation your interviewee would choose if roles they hope to play when they are adults
s/he could choose anything. Then, explore with (you will need to provide examples of life
your inter- viewee what s/he thinks is attractive roles). Then, ask if they think they will be able
about that occupation. to perform well in each of those life roles. Ask
how they think they will learn the skills
7. What career development tasks do you think required for suc- cessful performance in each of
are most important to help middle school those life roles.
students address?
13. Refer to the MyCounselingLab® Video and
8. What factors do you think could negatively in- Resource Library and select the video entitled
fluence the career development of middle 21st Century Career Development Interventions
school students? in the School: An Interview with Dr. Carol Dahir.
9. What are three strategies you could use to How would you draw upon Dr. Dahir’s
foster positive career development in middle comments to convince your principal and
school students? school board of the importance of career
development interventions in middle school
settings?
Note: Please note that most of these activities are readily adaptable to high school students.
Values Sorting
natIonal Career Development guIDelInes: Personal materIals: Handouts of the values list and five slips
Social Domain: PS1.K4; PS1.A4; PS1.R4; Career of paper per participant
Management Domain: CM2.K5; CM2.A5; CM2.R5
IntroDuCtIon: Introduce this activity as an exercise
asCa stanDarDs: Standard A—Students will ac- that helps participants identify and define important
quire the skills to investigate the world-of-work in values in their lives.
relation to knowledge of self and to make informed
career decisions. aCtIvIty: To start this activity, give participants a list
of values such as this one:
purpose: Good career decisions are values based.
However, few career options provide individuals values lIst
with the opportunity to express all of their important Financial
security values. Thus, we must prioritize values and identify Job security
those that are most important to us. We must be Good family relationships
clear as to which values we are willing to part with,
if necessary. Each decision we make requires us to A world that is free of discrimination
sort our values and make choices accordingly. Being Creativity
able to select career options that provide us with Having a set routine
maximal opportunities for values expression requires
Time by myself
us to subjectively define our important values. For
example, although many people value “financial Community activities
rewards,” this value is defined somewhat differently Physical activities
across individuals. Understanding how we define An attractive physical appearance
the most important values in our lives helps us to
Variety
determine which options fit best. Finally, it is impor-
tant to understand how values are connected to our Power
participation in the life roles we play. Recognition
obJeCtIves: As a result of participating in this Prestige
activity, participants will (a) learn the importance of Freedom from stress
values clarification, (b) become aware of their most Associating with people I like
important values, and (c) understand the importance
of considering values in career decision making and Success
career planning. Freedom to live where I choose
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 322
Schools
Leisure time
of their top 5 values, with definitions, in descending
Fame order. For example, here are five value definitions:
Strong religious faith
1. Financial rewards: having an income of more
Adventure than $45,000/year with good health and
World peace retirement benefits
Helping others 2. Autonomy: being able to make my own
decisions as to how to best accomplish my
Having children job duties but having a colleague who can
Good health give me advice when I need it
A beautiful home 3. Associating with people I like: being friends
with my coworkers and doing things
Autonomy
together outside of work
Other 4. Good health: eating right and exercising three
Other times per week
5. Strong religious faith: going to church on a reg-
Instruct students to identify their top 10 values from
ular basis and volunteering at a soup kitchen
this list by putting an X next to the values that are
most important to them (the values chosen are not DIsCussIon: After completing the exercise, explain
ranked at this point). Then, after discussing their how the activity relates to career decision making.
experience of conducting this initial values sort, pro- Explain that in every decision there is the promise
vide participants with five slips of paper. Ask them of gain and the threat of loss (otherwise, one could
to identify their top 5 values from the list of their sim- ply choose the “perfect” option in every
top 10 and to write one value on each slip of paper instance). The risk involved in decision making is
(again these values are not ranked). Participants are lessened when op- tions are selected based on the
then informed that the activity leader will be taking individual’s key values.
a value from them, one at a time. Thus, participants
Closure: Encourage participants to consider how
must now decide which of their top 5 values they
they spend their time in the course of a typical
are willing to part with first. At this point, the activity
week and if they spend time in activities reflecting
leader actually goes around the room taking a value
their top values. If the answer is no, then
from each participant.
encourage participants to identify strategies for
Immediately after students give a value to the
increasing their participation in activities reflecting
leader, instruct the participants to record and define
their values (e.g., agreeing to a moderate exercise
what that value means to them (e.g., “financial re-
program, identify- ing opportunities for
wards: having an income of more than $45,000/year
volunteering).
with good health and retirement benefits”). Continue
this process for each of the remaining values. At the tIme: Approximately 30 minutes
conclusion of the exercise, participants have a list
evaluatIon/assIgnment: Students will list their five
most important values and identify three jobs in
which they could express these values.
Time Capsule
natIonal Career Development guIDelInes: Personal materIals: Ask students to bring a valued object
Social Domain: PS1.K4; PS1.A4; PS1.R4; Career from home that tells something about them that
Management Domain: CM2.K5; CM2.A5; they might leave behind in an imaginary time
CM2.R5 capsule for future generations of middle school
asCa stanDarDs: Standard A—Students will ac- students.
quire the skills to investigate the world-of-work in IntroDuCtIon: Ask students to bring an item from
relation to knowledge of self and to make informed home to show other participants. Students should
career decisions; Standard B—Students will employ be prepared to explain what the item is and why it
strategies to achieve future career goals with suc- is important to them.
cess and satisfaction; Standard C—Students will
understand the relationship between personal quali- aCtIvItIes: Each student will describe the posses-
ties, education, training, and the world-of-work. sion, explain why it is important to him or her, how
it reflects something about the student, and what
purpose: To explore what possessions are valuable he or she would like to communicate to future
to students and why. middle school students by placing this item in an
obJeCtIve: Students will learn about themselves imaginary time capsule.
and others by examining a valued possession; stu- DIsCussIon: Students may discuss the items, any
dents will explore what they would like future gen- common concerns/messages for future
erations of people to know about them. Students generations, what they would like others to know
will also discuss how the possessions they value are about them, what is valued and why, and so on.
influenced by the culture in which they live. Students will also discuss the group similarities and
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 325
differences Schools
in the items they chose as valuable. Students can
CHAPTER 11 Career Development Interventions in Middle 326
Schools
discuss how these items might be different if they
us the object). The uniqueness of the objects se-
lived in another country.
lected tells us something important about ourselves.
Closure: Students can discuss the fact that the
tIme: 45 minutes to 1 hour
things we value are reflected in the things that
are valuable to us. They are, in essence, symbolic evaluatIon/assIgnment: Students will complete the
rep- resentations of things that are important to us following sentences: “Three things that are
due to a variety of reasons (e.g., what the objects impor- tant to me are .” and “These objects are
repre- sent, because a person who is important to impor- tant to me because .”
us gave