INTERACTIONS
& ADVERSE
DRUG
DRUG
INTERACTIO
NS
INSI
Penelitian di Kanada 1 Jan 1994—31 Des 2000
DEN
Case-control
Pasien > 65 th, ranap
Sulfonylurea (glyburide)—sulfonamide 3,8%
hypoglycemia
Digoxin—clarythromycin 2,6% digoxin toxicity
ACE-inhibitor—potassium-sparing diuretic 8,2%
hyperkalemia
MEKANISME
Interaksi obat yg relevan secara klinis: efikasi atau toksisitas suatu obat—
INTERAKSI OBAT
substrat—yg diubah melalui penggunaan obat yg lain
Interaksi farmakodinamik
Perubahan efek tanpa terjadi perubahan konsentrasi
Erythromycin—amiodarone Toksisitas amiodarone (berupa perpanjangan QT)
Acetaminophen—codeineAntinyeri yg efektif
Interaksi farmakokinetik
Perubahan konsentrasi obat pada tempat aksi
Perubahan ADME
Variconazole—simvastatinrhabdomyolisis
PARADIGMA BARU INTERAKSI
Perubahan konsentrasi obat pada fase distribusi akibat ikatan plasma
FARMAKOKINETIK
tidak lagi signifikan sbg penyebab
Bentuk tak terikat (unbound) didorong ke arah eliminasi (metabolisme
atau ekskresi)
E.g. warfarin (99% terikat,Vd = 9 L, fenitoin (90% terikat, Vd = 35 L,
tolbutamid (96% terikat, Vd = 10 L)
METABOLIS
ME OBAT
Neal, MJ, 2002, Medical Pharmacology at a Glance, 4th ed., Blackwell Science, p. 14
LANJUTAN
Kondisi yang mempengaruhi:
METABOLISME...
Reaksi fase I: inflamasi dan infeksi
Reaksi fase II: siroris
Digoxin—erythromycin—Eubacterium lentum
LANJUTAN
DRUG... http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/40623
6_2
LANJUTAN
Influx transporter:
DRUG...
Organic anion transporting protein
(OATP)
Organic cation transporter (OCT)
OATP
Hati, ginjal, intestine, otak, plasenta
Substrat: digoxin, rifampin, statin
Statin—gemfibrozil
OCT
Sekresi tubuler
Probenecid—beta-lactam
BEBERAPA INTERAKSI
OBAT YANG FATAL
Contoh Software
(Compendia)
DRUG-FOOD
INTERACTION
MEKA
NISME
Farmakokinetik, farmakodinamik
Karakteristik obat
Sifat fisika-kimia
Formulasi
Karakteristik makanan
Porsi dan komposisi makanan
Bioavalabilitas obat lipofil dgn makanan berlemak?
Peningkatan kelarutan (albendazole, isotretinoin) atau
Stimulasi sekresi empedu (griseovulfin, halofantrine)
Bioavailabilitas beberapa obat berkurang (digoxin, lovastatin) dgn makanan berserat
Mengapa?
Definisi “tanpa adanya makanan”?
RANGKUMAN OBAT-OBAT YANG
DIREKOMENDASIKAN UNTUK DIGUNAKAN
BERSAMA MAKANAN
Albendazole
Griseofulvin
Isotretinoin
Itraconazole
(kapsul) Lovastatin
Saquinavir
Tacrolimus
RANGKUMAN OBAT-OBAT YANG
DIREKOMENDASIKAN UNTUK DIGUNAKAN TANPA
MAKANAN
Ampicillin
Ciprofloxacin
Didanosine
Erithromycin
Halofantrine
Indinavir
Itraconazole
(sol) MAO
Inhibitor
Spironolactone
Tetracycline
Referensi:
Fuhr, U., 1998, Drug Interactions with Grapefruit Juice Extent,
Probable Mechanism and Clinical Relevance [drug experience],
Drug Safety 18(4):251-272, Adis International Limited
DRUG
INTERACTI
ON WITH
GRAPEFRUI
GJ DAN
FELODIPINE Studi interaksi felodipine-alcohol oleh
Bailey et al. dikonfirmasi oleh 9
studi lainnya
AUC dan Cmax ↑
Half-life tidak berubah
Dosis GJ: 200-500
mL
KANDU
NGAN Citrus paradisi
Naringenin (flavonoid), inhibitor CYP3A4
Turunan coumarin dan psoralen
(furocoumarin)
Psoraleninhibitor poten thd CYP3A4 pada hati
tikus dan manusia
REKOME
NDASI
Hindari konsumsi secara bersamaan (obat yg terbukti maupun diduga berinteraksi
dengan GJ)
Verapamil
Terfenadine
Cyclosporin
Ethinylestradiol
Prednisone
Midazolam
Quinidine
Saquinavir
DRUG-HERBS
INTERACTION
Sebuah survei
2 dari 3 perempuan menggunakan herbal untuk gejala menopause
45% ortu memberikan herbal treatment kpd anaknya
45% perempuan hamil mencoba pengobatan herbal
Produk herbal, natural, dipromosikan tdk berbahaya; tapi tetap tidak bebas dari
adverse effects
Obat-obat herbal biasa berisi lebih dari 100 bahan aktif (! Lihat konteks tulisan)
MEKA
NISME
Farmakokinetik
Penelitian >>
CYP hepatik/intestinal
Herbal, e.g. St. John’s Wort, echinaceae, garlic
Isolat herbal, e.g. flavonoid, coumarin, caffeine
P-glycoprotein,e.g. curcumin, ginsenoside, piperine, catechin
Farmakodinamik
Penelitian <<
Additive (sinergistic), herbal mempotensiasi aksi obat sintetis, e.g. antikoagulan
warfarin dengan herbal antiplatelet
Antagonistic, herbal mereduksi efikasi obat sintetis, e.g. kava dan levodopa
ADVERSE DRUG
REACTIONS
Ref: Edwards, IR, Aronson, JK,
DEFINITION
2000, Adverse drug reactions:
definitions, diagnosis, and
management, The Lancet, 356,
Problems:
Including minor adverse reactions, e.g.?
Excluding error as a source of adverse effects
EDWARDS &
ARONSON, 2000
Proposed definition of adverse drug reaction:
An appreciably harmful or unpleasant reaction, resulting from an intervention
related to the use of a medicinal product, which predicts hazard from future
administration and warrants prevention or specific treatment, or alteration of the
dosage regimen, or withdrawal of the product.
WHO’S ADVERSE DRUG
REACTION TERMINOLOGY
(WHO-ART), 1992
An adverse drug reaction (ADR) is ‘a response to a medicine which is noxious
and unintended, and which occurs at doses normally used in man’.
It concerns:
the response of a patient, in which individual factors may play an important role,
the phenomenon is noxious (an unexpected therapeutic response, for example, may be a side effect
but not an adverse reaction).
N SYSTEM
/7425/1222.full
TY
PES
Old, but commonly used: mnemonic system (ABCDEF)
Newly proposed: DoTS, in relation to dose, time, and
susceptibility
A (AUGMENTED)
BCDEF - MNEMONIC
Dose dependent
Predictable from the known pharmacology of the drug
Common and low mortality
Case:
Digoxin toxicity
Serotonine syndrome with SSRIs
Anticholinergic effects of tricyclic antidepressants
AB
(BIZARRE)
Non dose dependent
CDEF
Unpredictable from the known pharmacology of the drug
Uncommon and high mortality
Case:
Penicillin hypersensitivity
Acute porphyria
Malignant hyperthermia
ABC
(CHRONIC)
Dose-related and time-related
DEF
Uncommon
Related to the cummulative
dose Case:
Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis
supression by corticosteroids
ABCD
(DELAYED)
Time-related and usually dose-related
EF
Uncommon
Occurs or become apparent after some time the use of the drug
Case:
Vaginal adenocarcinoma with diethylstilbestrol
Carcinogenesis
Tardive dyskinesia
ABCDE (END
OF USE) F
Withdrawal
Uncommon
Occurs soon after withdrawal of the drug
Case:
Opiate withdrawal syndrome
Myocardial ischaemia (beta-blocker withdrawal)
ABCDEF
(FAILURE)
Unexpected failure of therapy
Common
Dose-related
Often caused by drug interactions
Case:
Inadequate dosage of an oral
contraceptive when used with specific
enzyme inducers
THE DOTS
CLASSIFICATIO
N
DO (DOSE
RELATEDNESS)
Supratherapeutic doses toxic dose
TS
Collateral effects, at standard/ normal therapeutic dose commonly named side
effect
Hypersusceptibility reactions
DOT (TIME
RELATEDNESS)
Time independent reactions
STime dependent reactions
Rapid reactions, e.g. the red
man syndrome with
vancomycin
First dose reactions, e.g.
Hypotension after the first dose
of an ACE-inhibitor
Type I hypersensitivity reactions
Early reactions, e.g. Nitrate
induced headache
Intermediate reactions, e.g.
Type II-IV hypersensitivity
reactions
Late reactions, e.g. Adverse effects of corticosteroids, tardive dyskinesia with dopamine receptor
antagonists
Delayed reactions, e.g. Teratogenesis due to thalidomide
DOTS
(SUSCEPTIBILITY
Genetic, e.g.
SOURCES)
Porphyria
Malignant hyperthermia
CYP isoenzyme
polymorphism
Age, e.g.
Neonates and chloramphenicol
Elderly people with hypnotics
DOTS
(SUSCEPTIBILITY
Sex, e.g.
SOURCES)
Alcohol intoxication
Mefloquine and neuropsychiatric effect
ACE-inhibitor and cough
Lupus-like syndrome
Disease, e.g.
Renal insufficiency with lithium
Hepatic chirrosis with morphine
Ref: Agbabiaka, T.B., Savović,
SUSPECT p.21-37.
ED ADR
CAUSAL RELATIONSHIP
BETWEEN DRUG AND
ADVERSE EFFECTS
Method
s
Probabilistic or
Bayesian
Approaches (4)
Algorithm
s (26)
EXPERT JUDGEMENTS OR
GLOBAL INTROSPECTION
Identifikasi ADR sering tergantung pada dokter
Klinisi yang sedang menangani pasien atau
Farmakolog klinis
Individual assessment based on previous knowledge and experience in the field using
no standardidized tool to arrive at conclusions regarding causality
E.g.:
Wilholm (1984)
WHO UMC (2007)
Miremont et al. (1994)
Arimone et al. (2005)
WHO
UMC
WHO
UMC
ALGORI
THMS
Algorithm is a problem-specific E.g.:
flow chart with step-by-step Irey (1976)
instruction on how to arrive at an Karch and Lasagna (1977)
answer. Kramer et al. (1979)
Naranjo et al. (1981)
Sets of specific questions with
RUCAM (Danan and Benichou,
associated scores for calculating the
1993)
likelihood of a cause-effect relationship.
Horn et al. (2007)
Structured and standardized
High degree of consistency and
reproducibility
ALGORI
THMS
Naranjo et al. (1981)
Very simple
Only one drug, not for ADR from drug interactions netween 2
drugs
Not appropriate for DILI (Drug-Induced Liver Injury)
Assessment from 2 physicians and 4 pharmacists
ALGORI
THMS
NARAN
JO’S
ALGORI
THMS
NARAN
JO’S
PROBABILISTIC OR
BAYESIAN APPROACHES
Use specific findings in a case to transform the prior estimate of probability into a
posterior estimate of probability of drug causation.
The prior probability is calculated from epidemiological information
The posterior probability combines background information (the epidemiological information) with
the evidence in the individual case to come up with an estimate of causation.
E.g., spreadsheet:
Marshford (1984) The Australian method
Lane et al. (1987) including Kramer
PROBABILISTIC OR
BAYESIAN APPROACHES
Computer programs:
The Bayesian Adverse Reaction Diagnostic Instrument
(BARDI)
MacBARDI-Q&A including Naranjo
EXAMPLE BY CASES
ARONSON, J.K., DUKES, M.N.G. & MEYLER, L., 2006. MEYLER’S SIDE EFFECTS OF
DoTS classification
Dose-relation: collateral effect
Time-course: time-
independent
Susceptibility factors: genetic (polymorphisms of the bradykinin B2 receptor gene
and the ACE gene); sex (men); exogenous factors (non-smokers).