Manajemen Proyek ICT

Waterfall, Spiral, XP, Scrum

Kelompok 3
Aldira Putra Raharja Annisa Fitriana Suryana Yunita Yesi Damaryanti Eka Handayani Isma Ramadhani Sunusi 113100037 113100025 113100006 113100116 113100091

IF 34 05

RPL methodologi

Waterfall

Spiral

XP

Scrum

Waterfall

Waterfall (2)
Flexibility Project Size Feedback Resiko Project Schedule : : : : : Tidak Flexible Large Di akhir project High Strict

Spiral

Spiral (2)
Flexibility Project Size Feedback Resiko Project Schedule : : : : : Flexible Large Per fase High (time) Flexible

eXtreme Programming

eXtreme Programming (2)

Flexibility Project Size Feedback Resiko Schedule : : : : : Flexibel Small to medium Per fase High (time) Flexible

Scrum

Scrum (2)
Flexibility Project Size Feedback Resiko Schedule : : : : : Flexible Small Everyday Low Strict

Aspek yang dibandingkan

Flexibility (kemampuan terhadap adanya perubahan requirement) Project Size (luas cakupan project) Feedback (kapan developer menerima feedback dari user) Resiko (probabilitas project gagal -> waktu dan biaya membengkak) Schedule (jadwal pengerjaan strict atau flexible)

Perbandingan
MODEL PROCESS
FLEXIBILITY

PROJECT SIZE

FEEDBACK

RESIKO PROJECT

SCHEDULE

WATERFALL

Tidak Flexible

Large

Di akhir project

High

Strict

SPIRAL

Flexible

Large

Per fase

High(Time)

Flexible

EXTREME PROGRAMMING

Flexible

Small to medium

Per fase

Low

Flexible

SCRUM

Flexible

Small

Everyday

Low

Strict

Kesimpulan
Perbandingan Methodologi Waterfall, Spiral, XP, dan Scrum berdasarkan Flexibility, Project Size, Feedback, Resiko, dan Schedule memiliki kekurangan dan kelebihan masing-masing.

Methodologi Waterfall, Spiral, XP, dan Scrum akan menghasilkan produk yang berkualitas jika ditempatkan pada proyek yang tepat dan begitu juga sebaliknya.

R e f e r e n s i

http://nda-eeea.blogspot.com/p/model-proses-perancangan-pl.html http://segi3hijau.wordpress.com/2012/08/29/tahapan-tahapan-pengembangan-perangkatlunak-dalam-metode-waterfall/ http://perencanaan.blogdetik.com/2011/11/metodologi-waterfall/ http://www.gtislig.org/HamidFaridani_GuideToSelectingSWMethodologies_SOC_PDD _20110305.pdf http://blog.algoworks.com/archives/491 http://repository.cmu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1056&context=silicon_valley http://library.binus.ac.id/eColls/eThesis/Bab1/2011-1-00264-if%201.pdf http://www.extremeprogramming.org/ http://ilmukomputer.org/wpcontent/uploads/2008/05/widhiartha_xtreme_programming.doc http://web.lindarising.info/uploads/IEEEScrum.pdf http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/4798/What-is-SCRUM http://istqbexamcertification.com/what-is-spiral-model-advantages-disadvantages-andwhen-to-use-it/#.USSjeh2LApU http://lecturer.ukdw.ac.id/othie/softwareprocess.pdf http://elista.akprind.ac.id/upload/files/3098_MATERI_1.PDF Buzzle.com/articles/comparison-between-waterfall-model-and-spiral-model http://dhiekalantana.blog.unas.ac.id/2012/10/perbandingan-up-xp-scrum-agile/

Terima Kasih