,661 -XUQDO+HDOWKRI6WXGLHV

,661
 9RO1R6HSWHPEHUSS

3HQJDUXKWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ
WHUKDGDSWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLSDGDSDVLHQSUHRSHUDVL
I
u  

        u
 

our  
u
       
   
$VUL%DVKLU $UOLQD'HZL$]L]DK.KRLUL\DWL



8QLYHUVLWDV0XKDPPDGL\DK<RJ\DNDUWD,QGRQHVLD
DVULEDVKLU#JPDLOFRP 
FRUUHVSRQGLQJDXWKRU
7DQJJDO6XEPLVL$JXVWXV7DQJJDO3HQHULPDDQ$JXVWXV
$EVWUDN
7HNQLN UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP GDQ WHUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ VDODK VDWX WHUDSL QRQ
IDUPDNRORJL\DQJHIHNWLIXQWXNPHQXUXQNDQWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLSDGDSDVLHQSUH
RSHUDVL'HVDLQSHQHOLWLDQLQLPHQJJXQDNDQPHWRGHSUDHNVSHULPHQGHQJDQGHVDLQSUH
WHVW DQG SRVWWHVW ZLWK FRQWURO JURXS GHVDLQ PHWRGH VDPSOLQJ \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ DGDODK
SXUSRVLYH VDPSOLQJ \DLWX WHNQLN SHQHWDSDQ VDPSHO GHQJDQ FDUD PHPLOLK VDPSHO
GLDQWDUD SRSXODVL VHVXDL GHQJDQ \DQJ GLNHKHQGDNL SHQHOLWL GHQJDQ PHQGDSDWNDQ
UHVSRQGHQ VHEDQ\DN  SDVLHQ +DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ DGD SHQJDUXK \DQJ
VLJQLILNDQWHUKDGDSWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLEHUGDVDUNDQDQDOLVLV:LOFR[RQWHVWSDGD
NHORPSRN LQWHUYHQVL UDWDUDWD WHUMDGL SHQJDUXK \DQJ VDQJDW VLJQLILNDQ GHQJDQ QLODL S
YDOXH VLVWRO  GLDVWRO  GDQ UHVSLUDVL  DUWLQ\D GDWD WHUVHEXW VLJQLILNDQ S
YDOXH6HGDQJNDQSDGDNHORPSRNNRQWUROQLODLSYDOXHXQWXNVLVWROGLDVWRO
 GDQ UHVSLUDVL  GDWD SDGD NHORPSRN NRQWURO PHQXQMXNNDQ S YDOXH ! 
DUWLQ\D WLGDN WHUMDGL SHQJDUXK \DQJ VLJQLILNDQ VHEHOXP GDQ VHWHODK SHQHOLWLDQ
.HVLPSXODQ7HNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQDGDSHQJDUXK
\DQJVLJQLILNDQWHUKDGDSWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLSDGDSDVLHQSUHRSHUDVL
.DWDNXQFLQDIDVGDODPPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQWHNDQDQGDUDKUHVSLUDVL
$EVWUDFW
'HHSEUHDWKLQJUHOD[DWLRQWHFKQLTXHVDQGPXURWWDO$O4XU
DQWKHUDS\DUHHIIHFWLYHQRQ
SKDUPDFRORJLFDO WKHUDSLHV WR UHGXFH EORRG SUHVVXUH DQG UHVSLUDWLRQ LQ SUHRSHUDWLYH
SDWLHQWV 7KH GHVLJQ RI WKLV VWXG\ XVHG D SUHH[SHULPHQWDO PHWKRG ZLWK D SUHWHVW DQG
SRVWWHVWZLWKFRQWUROJURXSGHVLJQWKHVDPSOLQJPHWKRGXVHGZDVSXUSRVLYHVDPSOLQJ
QDPHO\ WKH VDPSOLQJ WHFKQLTXH E\ VHOHFWLQJ VDPSOHV DPRQJ WKH SRSXODWLRQ LQ
DFFRUGDQFHZLWKZKDWWKHUHVHDUFKHUVZDQWHGE\JHWWLQJUHVSRQGHQWVRISDWLHQWV7KH
UHVXOWVRIWKLVVWXG\LQGLFDWHWKDWWKHUHLVDVLJQLILFDQWLQIOXHQFHRQEORRGSUHVVXUHDQG
UHVSLUDWLRQEDVHGRQ:LOFR[RQWHVWDQDO\VLVLQWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQJURXS2QWKHDYHUDJH
WKHUHZDVDYHU\VLJQLILFDQWHIIHFWZLWKDV\VWROHSYDOXHRIGLDVWROHRIDQG
UHVSLUDWLRQRIPHDQLQJWKDWWKHGDWDZDVVLJQLILFDQWSYDOXH:KHUHDVLQ
WKHFRQWUROJURXSWKHSYDOXHIRUV\VWROHZDVGLDVWROHDQGUHVSLUDWLRQ
GDWDLQ WKHFRQWURO JURXS VKRZHGSYDOXH!PHDQLQJWKDWWKHUHZDVQRVLJQLILFDQW
LQIOXHQFHEHIRUHDQG DIWHU WKH VWXG\&RQFOXVLRQ'HHSEUHDWKLQJUHOD[DWLRQWHFKQLTXHV
DQG PXURWWDO $O4XU
DQ WKHUDS\ KDYH D VLJQLILFDQW HIIHFW RQ EORRG SUHVVXUH DQG
UHVSLUDWLRQLQSUHRSHUDWLYHSDWLHQWV
.H\ZRUGVGHHSEUHDWKPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQEORRGSUHVVXUHUHVSLUDWLRQ 


'RLKWWSVGRLRUJMKHV7KLVLVDQRSHQDFFHVVDUWLFOHXQGHUWKH&&±%<6$OLFHQVH
,661
-XUQDO+HDOWKRI6WXGLHV

9RO1R6HSWHPEHUSS

3(1'$+8/8$1
3HPEHGDKDQPHUXSDNDQVXDWXWLQGDNDQPHGLVXQWXNPHQJDWDVLDWDXPHQDQJDQL
SDVLHQ \DQJ PHQJDODPL JDQJJXDQ DWDX NHODLQDQ SDGD WXEXK 'HQJDQ GLODNXNDQQ\D
SHPEHGDKDQPDNDVDQJDWEDQ\DNVHNDOLUHDNVLILVLRORJLVWLPEXO\DQJELVDPHQ\HEDENDQ
VHVHRUDQJ PHQJDODPL SHUXEDKDQ SDGD WHNDQDQ GDUDK GDQ UHVSLUDVL SDVLHQ 7RPH\ 
$OOLJRRG
7HNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLPHUXSDNDQWDQGDWDQGDYLWDO\DQJKDUXVGLNRQWURO
SDGDSDVLHQVHEHOXPGLODNXNDQQ\DRSHUDVLDSDELODKDOWHUVHEXWWHUXVWHUMDGLPDNDELVD
PHQ\HEDENDQ SHPEDWDODQ RSHUDVL DWDX ELVD MDGL SHQGDUDKDQ SDGD VDDW SHPEHGDKDQ
3HQDWDODNVDQDDQ SDGD SDVLHQ GHQJDQ SHQLQJNDWDQ WHNDQDQ GDUDK GDQ UHVSLUDVL DGDODK
GHQJDQ FDUD PHPEHULNDQ REDWREDWDQ IDUPDNRORJL &DUD ODLQ \DQJ GDSDW GLJXQDNDQ
SDGD SDVLHQ GHQJDQ SHQLQJNDWDQ WHNDQDQ GDUDK GDQ UHVSLUDVL DGDODK GHQJDQ FDUD
UHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ7RPH\ $OOLJRRG
7HNQLNUHODNVDVLDGDODKVDODKVDWXPHWRGH\DQJELVDGLJXQDNDQXQWXNPHQJDWDVL
SDVLHQ \DQJ PHQJDODPL SHQLQJNDWDQ WHNDQDQ GDUDK GDQ UHVSLUDVL GLPDQD OHELK
PHPIRNXVNDQSDGDODWLKDQQDIDVDEGRPLQDO6HGDQJNDQPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQPHUXSDNDQ
VDODK VDWX WHUDSL PXVLN \DQJ PHPLOLNL SHQJDUXK SRVLWLI EDJL SHQGHQJDUQ\D \DQJ ELVD
PHQXUXQNDQWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVL6XPDU\DQL 6DUL
 &DUDODLQGDSDWGLJXQDNDQXQWXNPHQJDWDVLPDVDODKWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVL
DGDODK GHQJDQ WHUDSL PXVLN 0XURWWDO PHUXSDNDQ VDODK VDWX PXVLN \DQJ PHPLOLNL
SHQJDUXK SRVLWLI EDJL SHQGHQJDUQ\D :LGD\DUWL  7HUDSL 0XURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ
PHUXSDNDQ ODQWXQDQ D\DW VXFL $O4XU¶DQ \DQJ PDPSX PHPEHULNDQ HIHN UHODNVDVL
NDUHQD GDSDW PHQJDNWLINDQ KRUPRQ HQGRUILQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ SHUDVDDQ ULOHNV
PHQJDOLKNDQ SHUKDWLDQ GDUL UDVD WDNXW FHPDV PHPSHUEDLNL VLVWHP NLPLD WXEXK
VHKLQJJD PHQXUXQNDQ WHNDQDQ GDUDK GDQ PHPSHUODPEDW SHUQDSDVDQ 6XPDU\DQL 
6DUL
3HQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK 6\DNLU  SDGD SDVLHQ SUH RSHUDVL WHUDSL
PXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQGDSDWPHQGHWHNVLDGDQ\DSHUXEDKDQSDGDWHNDQDQGDUDKSHUQDIDVDQ
GDQ NHNXDWDQ RWRW GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ EDQWXDQ HOHNWURQLN GDQ GDSDW EHUSHQJDUXK
KLQJJD  WHUKDGDS NHWHQDQJDQ MLZD GDQ NHVHPEXKDQ SHQ\DNLW 3HQHOLWLDQ \DQJ
GLODNXNDQ ROHK )DUDGLVL  PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD WHUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ ELVD
PHQXUXQNDQ NHFHPDVDQ SDGD SDVLHQ SUH RSHUDVL +DO LQL GLWXQMXNNDQ GHQJDQ QLODL
VLJQLILNDQ S YDOXH    VHKLQJJD GDSDW GLVLPSXONDQ DGD SHQJDUXK \DQJ
VLJQLILNDQ WHUKDGDS NHFHPDVDQ VHWHODK GLEHULNDQ LQWHUYHQVL WHUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ
3HQGDKXOXDQ KDUXV EHULVL VHFDUD EHUXUXWDQ ODWDU EHODNDQJ XPXP NDMLDQ OLWHUDWXU
VHEDJDLGDVDUSHUQ\DWDDQNHEDUXDQLOPLDKGDULQDVNDKSHUQ\DWDDQNHEDUXDQLOPLDKGDQ
SHUPDVDODKDQSHQHOLWLDQ3DGDEDJLDQDNKLUSHQGDKXOXDQKDUXVGLWXOLVNDQWXMXDQNDMLDQ
QDVNDK WHUVHEXW 'DODP IRUPDW QDVNDK LOPLDK WLGDN GLSHUNHQDQNDQ DGDQ\D WLQMDXDQ
SXVWDND VHEDJDLPDQD GL ODSRUDQ SHQHOLWLDQ WHWDSL GLZXMXGNDQ GDODP EHQWXN NDMLDQ
OLWHUDWXUWHUGDKXOXXQWXNPHQXQMXNNDQNHEDUXDQLOPLDKQDVNDKWHUVHEXW6HOXUXKEDJLDQ
SHQJDQWDU GLMHODVNDQ GDODP SDUDJUDI  WHULQWHJUDVL GHQJDQ SDQMDQJ  GDUL WRWDO
SDQMDQJDUWLNHO


$VUL%DVKLUHWDO3HQJDUXKWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ
 ,661
-XUQDO+HDOWKRI6WXGLHV

9RO1R6HSWHPEHUSS

0(72'(3(1(/,7,$1
3HQHOLWLDQ LQL PHUXSDNDQ SHQHOLWLDQ 4XDV\([SHULPHQW SHQHOLWLDQ HNVSHULPHQ
VHPX GHQJDQ SUHWHVW GDQ SRVWWHVW GHQJDQ GHVDLQ NHORPSRN NRQWURO \DQJ EHUWXMXDQ
XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL SHQJDUXK SHPEHULDQ UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP GDQ WHUDSL PXURWWDO $O
4XU¶DQWHUKDGDSWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLSDGDSDVLHQSUHRSHUDVLEHGDK1XUVDODP
 7HNQLN SHQJDPELODQ VDPSHO GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ LQL PHQJJXQDNDQ SXUSRVLYH
VDPSOLQJ\DLWXWHNQLNSHQHWDSDQVDPSHOGHQJDQFDUDPHPLOLKVDPSHOGLDQWDUDSRSXODVL
VHVXDL GHQJDQ \DQJ GLNHKHQGDNL SHQHOLWL WXMXDQPDVDODK GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ VHKLQJJD
VDPSHO WHUVHEXW GDSDW PHZDNLOL NDUDNWHULVWLN SRSXODVL 1XUVDODP  5HVSRQGHQ
\DQJ VHVXDL GHQJDQ NULWHULD LQNOXVL EHUMXPODK  UHVSRQGHQ 3HQHOLWLDQ GLODNXNDQ
VHODPDEXODQGLUXDQJUDZDWLQDSEHGDK3HQHOLWLPHPEHULNDQWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDV
GDODP VHEDQ\DN  NDOL  VLNOXV GHQJDQGLVHOLQJLLVWLUDKDWVLQJNDWVHWLDSNDOL \DQJ
GLODNXNDQ VHODPD  PHQLW .HPXGLDQ GLODQMXWNDQ GHQJDQ SHPEHULDQ WHUDSL PXURWWDO
$O4XU¶DQVXUDK$U5DKPDQNDOLVHODPDPHQLWROHK6\HNK$EGXUDUUDKPDQ$O
$XV\GDUL7LPXU7HQJDK\DQJGLSHUGHQJDUNDQPHODOXLHDUSKRQH3HQHOLWLPHPEHULNDQ
WHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQVHEDQ\DNNDOLSHPEHULDQ
SHUWDPD GLEHULNDQ  MDP VHEHOXP SDVLHQ PDVXN UXDQJ RSHUDVL NHPXGLDQ GLXODQJ
NHPEDOL MDPVHEHOXPSDVLHQPDVXNUXDQJDQRSHUDVLGHQJDQGXUDVLSHPEHULDQ
PHQLW 6HWHODK LWX  SHQHOLWL EDUX PHODNXNDQ SRVW WHVW XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL SHUEHGDDQ
WHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLUHVSRQGHQ
+$6,/'$13(0%$+$6$1
+DVLO SHODNVDQDDQ NHJLDWDQ EHULNXW LQL GLVDMLNDQ NDUDNWHULVWLN UHVSRQGHQ
EHUGDVDUNDQMHQLVNHODPLQXPXUSHQGLGLNDQGDQSHNHUMDDQSDGDSDVLHQSUHRSHUDVLGL
568';
7DEHO.DUDNWHULVWLNUHVSRQGHQQ 
.HORPSRN,QWHUYHQVL .HORPSRN.RQWURO
.DUDNWHULVWLN5HVSRQGHQ 39DOXH
Q   Q  
-HQLV.HODPLQ
/DNLODNL     
3HUHPSXDQ    
8PXU
5HPDMD$NKLU    
'HZDVD$ZDO    

'HZDVD$NKLU    
/DQVLD$ZDO    
/DQVLD$NKLU    
3HQGLGLNDQ
6'    

603    
60$    
3HNHUMDDQ
%HNHUMD     
7LGDNEHNHUMD    
6XPEHUGDWDSULPHU

 3DGD WDEHO  GDSDW GLNHWDKXL EDKZD GDWD NDUDNWHULVWLN UHVSRQGHQ KRPRJHQ KDO
LQLGLWXQMXNNDQROHKQLODLSYDOXH!\DQJEHUDUWLWLGDNDGDSHUEHGDDQNDUDNWHULVWLN
DQWDUD NHORPSRN LQWHUYHQVL GDQ NHORPSRN NRQWURO 'DSDW GLNHWDKXL EDKZD XVLD

$VUL%DVKLUHWDO3HQJDUXKWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ
,661
-XUQDO+HDOWKRI6WXGLHV

9RO1R6HSWHPEHUSS

WHUEDQ\DNSDGDNHORPSRNLQWHUYHQVLDGDODKXVLDGHZDVDDNKLUWDKXQVHEDQ\DN
RUDQJ GDQ PD\RULWDV UHVSRQGHQ PHUXSDNDQ SHUHPSXDQ GHQJDQ MXPODK  RUDQJ
3HNHUMDDQ UHVSRQGHQ SHQHOLWLDQ SDGD NHORPSRN LQWHUYHQVL \DQJ SDOLQJ EDQ\DN DGDODK
WLGDN EHNHUMD VHEDQ\DN  RUDQJ GDQ PD\RULWDV UHVSRQGHQ SHQHOLWLDQ GHQJDQ WLQJNDW
SHQGLGLNDQ60$VHEDQ\DNRUDQJ
 6HGDQJNDQ SDGD NHORPSRN NRQWURO UHVSRQGHQ WHUEDQ\DN EHUXVLD  WDKXQ
VHEDQ\DNRUDQJGDQPD\RULWDVUHVSRQGHQPHUXSDNDQSHUHPSXDQVHEDQ\DNRUDQJ
3HNHUMDDQUHVSRQGHQSHQHOLWLDQSDGDNHORPSRNNRQWURO\DQJSDOLQJEDQ\DNDGDODKWLGDN
EHNHUMD VHEDQ\DN  RUDQJ GDQ PD\RULWDV UHVSRQGHQ SHQHOLWLDQ GHQJDQ WLQJNDW
SHQGLGLNDQ60$VHEDQ\DNRUDQJ
7DEHO3HUEHGDDQUDWDUDWDWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKGLEHULNDQLQWHUYHQVL
9DULDEHO .HORPSRN 0HDQ“6' 0LQ0D[ 39DOXH
 ,QWHUYHQVLQ    
 3UH “  
6LVWRO 3RVW “  
.RQWUROQ    
3UH “  
3RVW “ 
 ,QWHUYHQVLQ    
 3UH “  
'LDVWRO 3RVW “  
.RQWUROQ    
3UH “  
3RVW “ 
 ,QWHUYHQVLQ    
 3UH “  
5HVSLUDVL 3RVW “  
.RQWUROQ    
3UH “  
3RVW “ 
6XPEHUGDWDSULPHU

%HUGDVDUNDQ WDEHO  GDSDW GLOLKDW KDVLO DQDOLVLV :LOFR[RQ 7HVW PHQXQMXNNDQ
EDKZD WHUMDGL SHUEHGDDQ UDWDUDWD WHNDQDQ GDUDK GDQ UHVSLUDVL SDGD NHORPSRN \DQJ GL
EHULNDQQDIDVGDODPGDQPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQGHQJDQQLODLSYDOXH

7DEHO3HQXUXQDQWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLUHVSRQGHQVHWHODKGLEHULNDQLQWHUYHQVL
$VSHN .HORPSRN 0HDQ“6' 3YDOXH
,QWHUYHQVL “
6LVWRO 
.RQWURO “
,QWHUYHQVL “
GLDVWRO 
.RQWURO “
,QWHUYHQVL “
5HVSLUDVL .RQWURO “ 
6XPEHUGDWDSULPHU

 %HUGDVDUNDQWDEHOGDSDWGLOLKDWEDKZDSHQXUXQDQWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVL
UHVSRQGHQVHWHODKGLEHULNDQLQWHUYHQVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQSDGD
NHORPSRNNRQWUROGDQNHORPSRNLQWHUYHQVLPHPSXQ\DLQLODL\DQJVLJQLILNDQGHQJDQS
YDOXH



$VUL%DVKLUHWDO3HQJDUXKWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ
 ,661
-XUQDO+HDOWKRI6WXGLHV

9RO1R6HSWHPEHUSS


7DEHO3HUEDQGLQJDQWWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLUHVSRQGHQVHWHODKGLEHULNDQLQWHUYHQVL
$VSHN  .HORPSRN 0HDQ“6' 3YDOXH
,QWHUYHQVL “
6LVWRO 6HVXGDK 
.RQWURO “
,QWHUYHQVL “
GLDVWRO 6HVXGDK 
.RQWURO “
,QWHUYHQVL “
5HVSLUDVL 6HVXGDK 
.RQWURO “
6XPEHUGDWDSULPHU

 3DGDWDEHOKDVLODQDOLVLV0DQQ:KLWQH\7HVWPHQXQMXNNDQSHUEHGDDQWHNDQDQ
GDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLUHVSRQGHQSDGDNHGXDNHORPSRNLQWHUYHQVLGDQNRQWUROVHWHODK
SRVWSHQHOLWLDQGHQJDQQLODLSYDOXH
%HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO \DQJ GLGDSDWNDQ QLODL UDWDUDWD VLVWRO GDQ GLDVWRO SDGD
NHORPSRN LQWHUYHQVL VHEHOXP GLODNXNDQ SHPEHULDQ WHNQLN UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP GDQ
WHUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ DGDODK  XQWXN VLVWRO GDQ  XQWXN GLDVWRO GDQ
VHWHODKGLODNXNDQSHPEHULDQWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ
PHQXQMXNDQ EDKZD QLODL UDWDUDWD VLVWRO GDQ GLDVWRO PHQJDODPL SHUXEDKDQ \DQJ
VLJQLILNDQ\DLWXXQWXNVLVWROGDQXQWXNGLDVWRO6HGDQJNDQSDGDNHORPSRN
NRQWUROWLGDNWHUMDGLSHUXEDKDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDVHEHOXPGDQVHWHODKSHQHOLWLDQ
3HUXEDKDQ LQL WHUMDGL NDUHQD SHQHOLWL PHPEHULNDQ WHNQLN UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP
VHODPD  PHQLW GHQJDQ ODPEDW GDQ SHUODKDQ NHPXGLDQ SHQHOLWL PHODQMXWNDQ
SHPEHULDQ PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ VHODPD NXUDQJ OHELK  PHQLW VHODPD GXD NDOL  MDP
VHEHOXP RSHUDVL GDQ GLODQMXWNDQ  MDP VHEHOXP RSHUDVL GHQJDQ WHPSR ODPEDW
3HQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK 6DOLP  PHQ\DWDNDQ UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP GDQ
PHQGHQJDUNDQ PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ EHUWHPSR ODPEDW PHPSXQ\DL UHVSRQ \DQJ EDLN
WHUKDGDSWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQGHQ\XWQDGL
7HNQLN UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP \DQJ GLODNXNDQ VHFDUD ODPEDW GDQ SHUODKDQ VHFDUD
WLGDNODQJVXQJGDSDWPHQLQJNDWNDQYHQWLODVLSDUXPHQLQJNDWNDQRNVLJHQDVLGDUDKGDQ
PHQJKLODQJNDQ UHVSRQ ILVLRORJLV \DQJ ELDVDQ\D GLWDQGDL GHQJDQ NHFHPDVDQ \DQJ ELVD
PHQ\HEDENDQSDVLHQWHUMDGLQ\DSHQLQJNDWDQWHNDQDQGDUDKQDGLGDQUHVSLUDVL0XWWDTLQ
VDUL
5HODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPEHUHIHNSDGDSHQLQJNDWDQNRQVHQWUDVLRNVLJHQSDGDDOYHROL
GLIXVLRNVLJHQGDULDOYHROLNHYHQDSXOPRQDOLVPHQLQJNDWGLVHUWDLSHQLQJNDWDQRNVLJHQ
GLSODVPD2NVLJHQ\DQJPHQLQJNDWEHUHIHNSDGDYDVRGLODWDVLSHULIHUVHKLQJJDUHVLVWHQVL
SHULIHU PHQXUXQ GDQ WHNDQDQ GDUDK MXJD PHQXUXQ .RQVHQWUDVL RNVLJHQ \DQJ QRUPDO
SODVPD PHQXUXQNDQ GLWDQJNDS ROHKEDURUHVHSWRUGDQNHPRUHVHSWRUXQWXN PHQXUXQNDQ
IUHNXHQVLQDIDVVHKLQJJDQDIDVPHQMDGLQRUPDO6DQWRVR
3HQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK $QGHUVRQ HW DO  PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD
GHQJDQ SHUQDIDVDQ GDODP GDQ ODPEDW  NDOL SHUPHQLW SDGD RUDQJ GHZDVD DNDQ
PHQLQJNDWNDQ VHQVLWLILWDV EDURUHVHSWRU GHQJDQ PHQVWLPXODVL UHVSRQ VDUDI RWRQRP
PHODOXL SHQJHOXDUDQ QHXURWUDQVPLWWHU HQGRUSKLQ \DQJ EHUHIHN SDGD SHQXUXDQ UHVSRQ
VDUDIVLPSDWLVGDQSHQLQJNDWDQUHVSRQSDUDVLPSDWLVVHKLQJJDGDSDWPHPSHUODPEDWGDQ
PHQ\HLPEDQJNDQ JHORPEDQJ RWDN GDQ SHQJDUXK WHUKDGDS NHVWDELODQ WHNDQDQ GDUDK
QDGLGDQSHUQDIDVDQ%DOO\HWDO

$VUL%DVKLUHWDO3HQJDUXKWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ
,661
-XUQDO+HDOWKRI6WXGLHV

9RO1R6HSWHPEHUSS

0XURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ LQL PHPSXQ\DL WHPSR

VHEHVDUESP7HPSRWHUVHEXWPHUXSDNDQWHPSRODPEDW\DQJPHPSXQ\DLNLVDUDQ
VDPSDLESP7HPSRODPEDWPHUXSDNDQWHPSR\DQJVHLULQJGHQJDQGHQ\XWQDGL
PDQXVLD VHKLQJJD DNDQ PHQJVLQNURQNDQ GHWDNQ\D VHVXDL GHQJDQ WHPSR VXDUD
'RPLQLFNHWDOGDODP0D\UDQL
6XDUDPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQEHUWHPSRODPEDWDNDQGLWHULPDROHKGDXQWHOLQJD\DQJ
GDSDWPHQJJHWDUNDQPHPEUDQWLPSDQL6HWHODKLWXJHWDUDQGLWHUXVNDQKLQJJDRUJDQNRUWL
GDODPNRNKOHDGLPDQDJHWDUDQDNDQGLXEDKGDULVLVWHPNRQGXNVLNHVLVWHPVDUDIPHODOXL
QHUYXV DXGLWRULXV VHEDJDL LPSXOV HOHNWULV,PSXOVHOHNWULVWHUVHEXWEHUODQMXWNHNRQWHNV
DXGLWRULXV 'DUL NRQWHNV DXGLWRULXV \DQJ WHUGDSDW SDGD NRQWHNV VHUHEUL SHQGHQJDUDQ
EHUODQMXWNHVLVWHPOLPELNPHODOXLNRQWHNVOLPELN3UDVHW\R
'DUL NRQWHNV OLPELNMHUDVSHQGHQJDUDQGLODQMXWNDQNHKLSRWDODPXVWHPSDWVDODK
VDWXXMXQJKLSRWDODPXVEHUEDWDVGHQJDQQXFOHLDPLJGDORLG$PLJGDOD\DQJPHUXSDNDQ
DUHD SHULODNX NHVDGDUDQ \DQJ EHNHUMD SDGD WLQJNDW EDZDK VDGDU PHQHULPD VLQ\DO GDUL
NRQWHNV OLPELN ODOX PHQMDODUNDQQ\D NH KLSRWDODPXV 'L KLSRWDODPXV \DQJ PHUXSDNDQ
SHQJDWXUDQ VHEDJLDQ IXQJVL YHJHWDWLI GDQ IXQJVL HQGRNULQ WXEXK VHSHUWL KDOQ\D EDQ\DN
DVSHN SHULODNX HPRVLRQDO MDUDN SHQGHQJDUDQ GLWHUXVNDQ NH IRUPDWLRQ UHWLNXODULV
VHEDJDLSHQ\DOXULPSXOVPHQXMXVHUDWVDUDIRWRQRP6HUDWVDUDIWHUVHEXWPHPSXQ\DLGXD
VLVWHP VDUDI \DLWX VLVWHP VDUDI VLPSDWLV GDQ VLVWHP VDUDI SDUDVLPSDWLV .HGXD VLVWHP
VDUDILQLPHPSHQJDUXKLNRQWUDNVLGDQUHODNVDVLRUJDQRUJDQ*X\WRQ +DOO
0XURWWDO GDSDW PHPDFX VLVWHP VDUDI SDUDVLPSDWLV \DQJ PHQ\HEDENDQ UHODNVDVL
$VWLGDODP:LG\DVWLZL+DOLQLVHEDJDLPDQDGLNHPXNDNDQROHK,VWLTRPDK
 EDKZD GRD PHPEDFD $O4XU¶DQ GDQ PHQJLQJDW $OODK ']LNLU DNDQ
PHQ\HEDENDQ UHVSRQ UHODNVDVL \DQJ DNDQ PHQ\HEDENDQ SHQXUXQDQ WHNDQDQ GDUDK
SHQXUXQDQRNVLJHQNRQVXPVLSHQXUXQDQGHQ\XWQDGLGDQSHUQDIDVDQ
+DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ LQL VHVXDL GHQJDQ KDVLO SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK 6LVZR\R
 PHQGHQJDUNDQ PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ PHPSXQ\DL UHVSRQ \DQJ HIHNWLI WHUKDGDS
WHNDQDQ GDUDK VLVWRO GDQ GLDVWRO SDGD SDVLHQ SUH RSHUDVL 0XURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ WHUEXNWL
PHQXQMXNNDQHIHN\DLWXPHQXUXQNDQIUHNXHQVLGHQ\XWMDQWXQJWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQGDSDW
PHQJXUDQJLNHFHPDVDQ%DOO\HWDO
6HODLQWHNDQDQGDUDKSHQHOLWLMXJDPHOLKDWUHVSLUDVLSDGDSDVLHQGLGDSDWNDQKDVLO
EDKZDWHUMDGLSHUXEDKDQ\DQJVLJQLILNDQWHUKDGDSUHVSLUDVLSDVLHQVHEHOXPGDQVHWHODK
GLEHULNDQ LQWHUYHQVL 1LODL UDWDUDWD UHVSLUDVL SDVLHQ VHEHOXP GLODNXNDQ SHPEHULDQ
WHNQLN UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP GDQ WHUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ DGDODK  GDQ VHWHODK
GLODNXNDQ SHPEHULDQ WHNQLN UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP GDQ WHUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ
UHVSLUDVLSDVLHQEHUXEDKPHQMDGL6HGDQJNDQSDGDNHORPSRNNRQWUROWLGDNWHUMDGL
SHUXEDKDQ\DQJEHUPDNQDVHEHOXPGDQVHWHODKSHQHOLWLDQ
7HUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ PHPEHULNDQ GDPSDN SRVLWLI EDJL SVLNRORJLV (IHN
VXDUD GDUL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ EHUNDLWDQ GHQJDQ SURVHV LPSOXV VXDUD \DQJ
GLWUDQVPLVLNDQ NHGDODP WXEXK GDQ PHPSHQJDUXKL VHOVHO WXEXK 6XDUD \DQJ GLWHULPD
ROHK WHOLQJD NHPXGLDQ GLWHULPD ROHK VDUDI SXVDW NHPXGLDQ GLWUDQVPLVLNDQ NHVHOXUXK
EDJLDQ WXEXK 6HODQMXWQ\D VDUDI YDJXV GDQ VLVWHP OLPELN PHPEDQWX PHQJRQWURO
NHFHSDWDQ GHQ\XW QDGL UHVSLUDVL GDQ PHQJRQWURO HPRVL 7HUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ
GDSDWPHPXQFXONDQJHORPEDQJGHOWDGLGDHUDKIURQWDOGDQVHQWUDOGLVHEHODKNDQDQGDQ

$VUL%DVKLUHWDO3HQJDUXKWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ
 ,661
-XUQDO+HDOWKRI6WXGLHV

9RO1R6HSWHPEHUSS

NLUL RWDN 'DHUDK IURQWDO \DLWX VHEDJDL SXVDW LQWHOHNWXDO XPXP GDQ SHQJDWXU HPRVL
$EGXUUDKPDQ
.HWLND SDVLHQ PHQGHQJDUNDQ WHUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ VLVWHP VDUDI
PHQJNRPXQLNDVLNDQ KLSRWDODPXV XQWXN PHQVHNUHVL DWDX PHQLQJNDWNDQ KRUPRQ
HQGRUSKLQGLNHOHQMDUSLXWDU\GDQPHQHNDQKRUPRQVWUHVVHSLQHSULQGDQQRUHSLQHIULQGL
NHOHQMDUDGUHQDOVHKLQJJDWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQPDPSXPHQXUXQNDQWHNDQDQGDUDK
PHQXUXQNDQ GHQ\XW QDGL PHPSHUODPEDW SHUQDSDVDQ GHWDN MDQWXQJ GDQ DNWLYLWDV
JHORPEDQJRWDN+HUX
+DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ LQL VHVXDL GHQJDQ KDVLO SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK )D\D]L
GHQJDQPHQGHQJDUNDQPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQSDVLHQ\DQJDNDQPHQMDODQLRSHUDVL
\DQJ GLEHULNDQ SHUODNXDQ  MDP VHEHOXP RSHUDVL VHODPD  PHQLW WHUMDGL SHUXEDKDQ
\DQJVLJQLILNDQGHQJDQQLODLSYDOXH6HODLQPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQWHNQLNUHODNVDVL
QDIDVGDODPPHUXSDNDQVXDWXDVXKDQNHSHUDZDWDQ\DQJHIHNWLIEDJLSDVLHQ\DQJGDSDW
PHQXUXQNDQ IUHNXHQVL RNVLJHQ IUHNXHQVL SHUQDIDVDQ IUHNXHQVL MDQWXQJ GDQ GDSDW
PHQJXUDQJLNHWHJDQJDQRWRW.XV\DWL
'HQJDQ PHQJNRPELQDVL WHNQLN UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP GDQ PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ
\DQJGLEHULNDQNHSDGDSDVLHQSUHRSHUDVLPDNDHIHN \DQJGLUDVDNDQROHKSDVLHQDNDQ
OHELKEDLN0XURWWDO$O4XU¶DQVXDWXWHUDSL \DQJEHUPDQIDDWEDJLNHVHKDWDQ\DQJELVD
PHQHQDQJNDQMLZDGDQPHJKLODQJNDQUDVDWDNXW6HGDQJNDQUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPVXDWX
WHUDSL \DQJ ELVD PHQJKLODQJNDQ NHWHJDQJDQ RWRW PHQVWDELONDQ IUHNXHQVL QDIDV GDQ
PHPEXDWSDVLHQOHELKQ\DPDQ0XVWDPLU
6,038/$1
$GDSHQJDUXKVLJQLILNDQDQWDUDVHEHOXPGDQVHVXGDKGLEHULNDQWHNQLNUHODNVDVL
QDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQWHUKDGDSWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQUHVSLUDVLSDVLHQ
SUH RSHUDVL GL 568' ; %HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO SHQHOLWLDQ EDKZD VHPXD UHVSRQGHQ
PHQJJXQDNDQ MHQLV RSHUDVL EHGDK PD\RU \DQJ EHUMXPODK  SDVLHQ  NHORPSRN
LQWHUYHQVL GDQ  NHORPSRN NRQWURO %HGDK 0D\RU PHUXSDNDQ SHPEHGDKDQ GL PDQD
VHFDUD UHODWLI OHELK VXOLW XQWXN GLODNXNDQ GDULSDGD SHPEHGDKDQ PLQRU PHPEXWXKNDQ
ZDNWXPHOLEDWNDQULVLNRWHUKDGDSQ\DZDSDVLHQ6\DPVXKLGDMDW
6$5$1
$GDSXQ VDUDQ GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ LQL \DNQL SHUDZDW KDUXV PHQHUDSNDQ WHNQLN
UHODNVDVL QDIDV GDODP GDQ WHUDSL PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ VHEDJDL WHUDSL QRQ IDUPDNRORJL
XQWXNPHPEDQWXPHQXUXNDQWHNDQDQGDUDKGDQPHQRUPDONDQUHVSLUDVLSDGDSDVLHQSUH
RSHUDVL 'LKDUDSNDQ NHSDGD SDVLHQ SUH RSHUDVL ELVD PHQHUDSNDQ ODQJVXQJ UHODNVDVL
QDIDV GDODP GDQ PXURWWDO $O4XU¶DQ VHFDUD EHUNDOD +DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ LQL GLKDUDSNDQ
PHQDPEDK ZDZDVDQ GDQ SHQJHWDKXDQ PDKDVLVZD NHSHUDZDWDQ WHQWDQJ WHUDSL QRQ
IDUPDNRORJL
'$)7$53867$.$
$OOLJRRG 05  7RPH\ $1  1XUVLQJ7KHRULVW DQG 7KHLU :RUN 6L[WK (GLWLRQ
6W/RXLV0RVE\
$O4XU¶DQ GDQ WHUMHPDKDQ  'HSDUWHPHQ $JDPD 5, %DQGXQJ &9 'DUXV
6XQQDK6XUDK$U5D¶GXGDQ$O$¶UDI

$VUL%DVKLUHWDO3HQJDUXKWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ
,661
-XUQDO+HDOWKRI6WXGLHV

9RO1R6HSWHPEHUSS

A

 N 
 
 
 
 

 
 



 O
 


  
 
 

! "# 

!


-XUQDO NHSHUDZDWDQ 3HQJDUXK 7HUDSL 0XURWWDO 7HUKDGDS 3HQXUXQDQ
.HFHPDVDQ3DVLHQ3UH2SHUDVL&D0DPPDH'L5XDQJ%HGDK5XPDK6DNLW,EQX
6LQD0DNDVVDU
,

A
  D
$
   %    &  
' &(!(
 !!


!
 "
i
 # # 
 N
(
 



 




 


  O
 -XUQDO .HSHUDZDWDQ 9RO  1R  

R ( i
!i


#
 O 
 3URVHV .HSHUDZDWDQ GDQ 3HPHULNVDDQ )LVLN J
!

)
 #

!

&((F % 
!(   .HSHUDZDWDQ.HVHKDWDQ.RPXQLWDV
 #
!


J
!

*
 A *  RR
 D

&
$
 
' 
 
!
 
 g A+

 

 

!

 




 a  

! N a
D
 -D
!


-XUQDO0XKDPPDGL\DK8QLYHUVLW\RI<RJ\DNDUWD9RO1R
J
 J   
 
 7KH (IIHFW RI 5HFLWLQJ WKH :RUG ³$OODK´ RQ
9LWDO6LJQVDQG6S2RI3DWLHQWV$IWHU&RURQDU\$UWHU\%\SDVV*UDIW6XUJHU\$
5DQGRPL]HG&OLQLFDO7ULDO9RO
D
  y0HWRGH 6XSHUQRO 0HQDNOXNNDQ 6WUHV -DNDUWD +LNPDK 3XEOLVKLQJ
+RXVH6KHUZRRG/DXUD,HH)LVLRORJL0DQXVLD J
!

) &*
N
  F
D
.  % 
 R
 a  
  &(( (   / 0

A
 ”  1
 
 O  (
 A( 
D AD D


*
( D ) A 
 . 
 
 -XQGLVKDSXU -RXUQDO &KURQLF

'LVHDVH&DUH 
,2 )333
4
3ii4''2
N

 
' .RQVHS GDQ 0HWRGHORJL 3HQHUDSDQ 3HQHOLWLDQ ,OPX .HSHUDZDWDQ
J
!

)
 #
!

  F N 
'3HQJDUXK 7HPSR 0XVLN &HSDW GDQ /DPEDW 7HUKDGDS 7HNDQDQ
'DUDK GDQ 'HQ\XW -DQWXQJ MXUQDO 5R
 !
 





-XUQDONHSHUDZDWDQ9RO1R


D
 %
 
 
 
#
 A+






 ND

D
! 
S "
 aD
) ! A
! 

 A


 
-DNDUWD 37 .DZDQ 3XVWDND 7RPE 'DYLG $  ' %XNX 6DNX 3VLNLDWUL
J
!

) &*

i

i
 %  J 
 ! Ai
 "  
 J
!

) &*

1#! 
 !
i
 !
$

 i$
 J
!

) &*

/
D
 
 &(!R
 
 
 
 
 ! 
! 




 !
 


 
O
  !

 -XUQDO,OPLDK

.HVLKDWDQ 9 )333

''3624 42 6y'yd

$VUL%DVKLUHWDO3HQJDUXKWHNQLNUHODNVDVLQDIDVGDODPGDQWHUDSLPXURWWDO$O4XU¶DQ