KEMENTERIAN PERHUBUNGAN

SEKRETARIAT JENDERAL
JL. MEDAN MERDEKA BARAT Telp: (021) 3811308, 3505006 TLX : 46116 Menhub 1A
NO.8 Fax.: (021) 3522338 Email : pusdatin@dephub.go.id
JAKARTA 10110 SMS Center: +6281311111105 Homepage : www.dephub.go.id

BERITA ACARA PEMBUKAAN DAN EVALUASI

REQUEST FOR EXPRESSION OF INTEREST (EOI) CONSULTING SERVICES
INDONESIA MASS TRANSIT PROJECT
(IMPLEMENTATION PROJECT OF PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM)
LOAN ID NO. IBRD 9340 – ID
BANDUNG BASIN METROPOLITAN AREA (BBMA) BUS RAPID TRANSIT (BRT)
DETAILED ENGINEERING DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISION
CONSULTANT

Nomor : BA.03/WB-CS/UKPBJ/X/2022

1. Sesuai dengan undangan Ketua kelompok kerja Pengadaan Barang/Jasa Paket

Pekerjaan Satuan Kerja Direktorat Angkutan Jalan, Direktorat Jenderal Perhubungan
Darat pada Biro Layanan Pengadaan dan Pengelolaan Barang Milik Negara Tahun
Anggaran 2022 Nomor 02/PHLN/WB-CS/UKPBJ.PHB/IX/2022 tanggal 2 September 2022
sebagai tindak lanjut Penyampaian Dokumen Request for Expression Of Interst (EOI)
Paket Pekerjaan Consulting Services Indonesia Mass Transit Project (Implementation
Project of Public Transportation System) pada hari Senin tanggal 05 September 2022
dimulai pukul 15.00 WIB s.d. selesai, bertempat di Ruang Rapat Biro Layanan
Pengadaan dan Pengelolaan Barang Milik Negara (LPPBMN), Kelompok Kerja telah
melakukan rapat pembahasan dan evaluasi Dokumen Request for Expression of Interest
(EOI) Pekerjaan sebagaimana tersebut diatas serta memperhatikan hasil pembahasan
evaluasi dengan team procurement task Indonesia Mass Transit Project World Bank East
Asia Pacific Region Letter No. 010/MASTRAN/X/2022 tanggal 6 Oktober 2022 perihal No
Objection to Shortlist for BBMA Detailed Enginering Design (DED) and Construction
Supervision Management Consultant – Quality and Cost Based Selection.

2. Rapat dipimpin oleh Ketua Kelompok Kerja, dihadiri oleh Sekretaris dan para anggota
kelompok kerja sesuai dengan hasil pembahasan dan surat dari Team Procuement Task
Indonesia Mass Transit Project World Bank East Asia Pacific Region sebagaimana
tersebut diatas.

3. Adapun proses rapat sebagaimana dimaksud di atas adalah sebagai berikut:

a. Sebagai tanggapan terhadap pengumuman Invitation Request for Expression of
Interest (REOI) for Consulting Services Indonesia Mass Transit Project
(Implementation Project of Public Transportation System) Loan ID No. IBRD 9340
– ID yang dikeluarkan oleh Kelompok Kerja Pengadaan Barang/Jasa Paket
Pekerjaan satuan kerja Direktorat Angkutan Jalan, Direktorat Jenderal Perhubungan
Darat pada Biro Layanan Pengadaan dan Pengelolaan Barang Milik Negara tanggal
09 Agustus 2022 melalui media online Website UNDP dan Media Cetak (The Jakarta
Post), (Media Indonesia) dan Elektronik portal LPSE Kementerian Perhubungan
http://lpse.dephub.go.id/eproc, pendaftaran dan permintaan Request for EOI
dokumen Expression of Interest (EOI) dilaksanakan pada tanggal 09 Agustus s/d
26 Agustus 2022, telah mendaftar 31 (tiga puluh satu) perusahaan, yaitu sebagai
berikut:
 No Nama Perusahaan Negara
1 PT Inacon Luhur Pertiwi Indonesia
2 Dohwa Engineering Co. Ltd South Korea
3 PT Prosys Bangun Persada Indonesia
4 Systra Group France
5 Egis Asia Company Hongkong
6 PT Aecom Indonesia Indonesia
7 PT Lengogeni Indonesia
8 Dong IL Engineering Consultant Co. Ltd South Korea
9 KPMG Siddharta Advisory Indonesia
10 PT Mott Macdonald Indonesia Indonesia
11 Hankuk Engineering Consultant South Korea
12 PT Perentjana Djaja Indonesia
13 PT Winsolusi Konsultan Indonesia
14 Finish Overseas Consultant Ltd (FinnOc) Finland
15 Minconsult Sdn. Bhd Malaysia
16 PT Arup Indonesia Indonesia
17 Dong Myeong Engineering Consultant & South Korea
Architecture
18 PT Virama Karya Indonesia
19 PT Deloitte Consulting Indonesia
20 Padeco Co. Ltd Japan
21 PT Smec Denka Indonesia Indonesia
22 (Pwc) PT PricewaterhouseCoopers Indonesia
Indonesia Advisory
23 PT Delta Tama Waja Corpora Indonesia
24 (CRDS) China Railway Design and Indonesia
Corporation
25 China Railway Siyuan Survey and China
Design Group Co. Ltd
26 PT Vetiga Himais Optima Indonesia
27 Eptisa Turkey
28 PT Bina Karya Indonesia
29 PT Dardela Yasa Guna Indonesia
30 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia
31 PT Bereau Veritas Indonesia Indonesia

b. Selanjutnya perusahaan-perusahaan yang telah mendaftar tersebut dan menerima

Dokumen Expression of Interst (EOI) melakukan Pengunggahan / Submitted
dokumen Expression of Interest (EOI) dimulai pada hari Selasa, 09 Agustus 2022
dan ditutup pada hari Jumat, 26 Agutus 2022 pukul 17.00 WIB.

c. Dari 31 (tiga puluh satu) perusahaan-perusahaan yang telah mendaftar, dan

terdapat 19 (sembilan belas) perusahaan yang menyampaikan surat permintaan
minat secara resmi kepada kelompok kerja sampai dengan batas waktu yang
ditentukan, dari 19 (sembilan belas) penyedia yang menyampaikan surat minat atas
dokumen Expresstion of Interest (EOI) hanya terdapat 13 (tiga belas) perusahaan
yang menyampaikan / upload dokumen / Submited Expression of Interest (EOI) ,
untuk Pekerjaan Consulting Service Bandung Basin Metropolitan Area (BBMA) Bus
Rapid Transit (BRT) Detailed Engineering Design (DED) and Supervision Consultant
yaitu sebagai berikut:
 No Nama Perusahaan Negara Keterangan
1 Dohwa Engineering Co, Ltd, Korea Menyampaikan Dokumen
PT Lenggogeni Planning Selatan – EOI
Designing & Consulting JV Indonesia
2 Hankuk Engineering Korea Menyampaikan Dokumen
Consultant, Tracom, PT Selatan – EOI
Marga Graha Penta, PT Indonesia
Rayakonsult, JV
3 Dong Myeong Engineering Korea Menyampaikan Dokumen
Consultant & Architecture Selatan - EOI
Co, Ltd (DMEC), Kunhwa Indonesia
Engineering & Consulting Co,
Ltd (Kunhwa), PT Dharma
Kreasi Nusantara, JV
4 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia Menyampaikan Dokumen
EOI
5 Shanghai Municipal China – Menyampaikan Dokumen
Engineering Design Institute Indonesia EOI
(Group) Co, Ltd, PT
Winsolusi Konsultan
6 Systra, PT Jaya CM, JV France – Menyampaikan Dokumen
Indonesia EOI
7 Ardanuy Ingenieria SA, Spain – India Menyampaikan Dokumen
Ardanuy India Private – Indonesia EOI
Limited, PT Perentjana Djaja,
JV
8 Eptisa Servicious de Spain – Menyampaikan Dokumen
ingenieria, SL, Eptisa Turkey EOI
Muhendislik ve mus Hiz Bilg
Ins,Tic, Ltd
9 PT Mott Macdonald Indonesia Menyampaikan Dokumen
Indonesia EOI
10 Smec International Pty, Ltd Australia Menyampaikan Dokumen
EOI
11 Dong Il, Seayoung, PT Delta Korea Menyampaikan Dokumen
Tama Waja Corpora Selatan – EOI
Indonesia
12 China Railway Design and China – USA Menyampaikan Dokumen
Corporation (CRDC), HJI - Indonesia EOI
Group Corporation, PT Bina
Karya, JV
13 Min Consult Sdn, Bhd, Malaysia - Menyampaikan Dokumen
Technica Y Project SA Spain EOI
(Typsa)

d. Dari perusahaan-perusahaan yang telah mengisi Prequalification Criteria (EOI),

kelompok kerja melakukan evaluasi dokumen Prequalification Criteria (EOI)
sebagaimana yang telah ditentukan 2 (dua) kriteria yaitu :
Kriteria 1 Preliminary Screening terdiri dari :
1. Declaration Form;
2. Company Information on suitable Form 01;
3. Firms Experience on suitable Form 02a, 02b;
4. Personel Key Expert on suitable Form 03;
(Not Specified Form Must be the same)

Kriteria 2 the firms will be short-listed based on criteria terdiri dari :

1. A globally recognized engineering consulting firm with a good understanding of
urban transport issues;
2. Evidence of completed and ongoing consulting services related to planning,
detailed engineering design, environmental and social impact assessment,
construction supervision of a successful global standard bus rapid transit system.
3. Should have an international experience in leading and implementing detailed
engineering design of mass transit project, preparing bidding document, and also
supervising the civil works with the minimum value of USD 750,000 in the past
10 years.
4. Minimum of 10 years of international experience in leading and implementing
detailed engineering design of mass transit project, preparing bidding document,
and also supervising the civil works.
5. Relevant experience in South East Asia region (Indonesian Experience is an
added advantage).
6. Average annual turnover for the last three financial years of the bidder should be
at least USD 1,300,000.
7. Availability of relevant Key Professionals with the firm. Specific key experts will
not be evaluated at the shortlisting stage

perusahaan yang sesuai pada Tahapan Prequalification Criteria (EOI) sesuai dengan
persyaratan di dalam dokumen Expression of Interest (EOI), Dari proses evaluasi
dokumen Prequalification Criteria (EOI), perusahaan yang dinyatakan memenuhi
kriteria Prequalification Criteria (EOI) dan masuk dalam urutan calon daftar
pendek/Shortlist yaitu sebagai berikut:

No Nama Perusahaan Negara Keterangan

1 Dohwa Engineering Co, Ltd, Korea Memenuhi
PT Lenggogeni Planning Selatan –
Designing & Consulting JV Indonesia
2 Shanghai Municipal China – Memenuhi
Engineering Design Institute Indonesia
(Group) Co, Ltd, PT
Winsolusi Konsultan, JV
3 Systra, PT Jaya CM, JV France – memenuhi
Indonesia
4 Smec International Pty, Ltd Australia Memenuhi
5 Dong Myeong Engineering Korea – Memenuhi
Consultant & Architecture Indonesia
Co.Ltd (DM EC), Kunhwa
Engineering & Consulting Co,
Ltd, PT Dharma Kreasi
Nusantara, JV
6 Minconsult SDN BHD, Malaysia - Memenuhi
Technica Y Proyectos SA – Spain
Typsa
 Untuk beberapa perusahaan / penyedia yang belum memenuhi persyaratan
sebagaimana criteria yang ditentukan di dalam dokumen Request for Exprestion of
Interest (EOI) adalah sebagai berikut :

No Nama Perusahaan Negara Keterangan

1 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia Tidak memenuhi
2 Hankuk Engineering Korea – Tidak memenuhi
Consultant, Tracom, PT Indonesia
Marga Graha Penta, PT
Rayaconsult, JV
3 Ardanuy Ingenieria SA, Spain – India Tidak memenuhi
Ardanuy India Private – Indonesia
Limited, PT Perentjana Djaja,
JV
4 Eptisa Servicious de Spain – Tidak memenuhi
Ingenieria, SI, Eptisa Turkey
Muhendisik ve Mus Hiz Bilg,in
Tic, Ltd
5 PT Mott Macdonald Indonesia Tidak memenuhi
Indonesia
6 Dong IL, Seoyoung, PT Delta Korea – Tidak memenuhi
Tama Waja Corpora Indonesia
7 China Railway Design and China – USA Tidak memenuhi
Corporation (CRDC), HJI – Indonesia
Group Corporation, PT Bina
Karya, JV

e. Selanjutnya Kelompok Kerja menyampaikan dan melaporkan hasil evaluasi

Prequalification Criteria (REOI) kepada penyedia terpilih /shortlist Firm untuk dapat
melanjutkan proses pemilihan dengan mengirimkan kepada mereka dokumen
penawaran (Request for Proposal) beserta kelengkapan dokumen lainnya, serta
menyampaikan penawaran mereka dalam waktu yang telah ditentukan di dalam
Dokumen RFP (request for proposal) tersebut

4. Demikian Berita Acara Hasil Evaluasi Dokumen REOI berdasarkan Criteria Expression of
Interest (EOI) ini dibuat untuk dapat dipergunakan sebagaimana mestinya.
KELOMPOK KERJA PENGADAAN BARANG/JASA
PAKET PEKERJAAN SATUAN KERJA DIREKTORAT ANGKUTAN JALAN
DIREKTORAT JENDERAL PERHUBUNGAN DARAT
PADA BIRO LAYANAN PENGADAAN DAN PENGELOLAAN BARANG MILIK NEGARA
SEKRETARIAT JENDERAL
KEMENTERIAN PERHUBUNGAN
 KEMENTERIAN PERHUBUNGAN
SEKRETARIAT JENDERAL
JL. MEDAN MERDEKA BARAT Telp: (021) 3811308, 3505006 TLX : 46116 Menhub 1A
NO.8 Fax.: (021) 3522338 Email : pusdatin@dephub.go.id
JAKARTA 10110 SMS Center: +6281311111105 Homepage : www.dephub.go.id

BERITA ACARA PEMBUKAAN DAN EVALUASI

REQUEST FOR EXPRESSION OF INTEREST (EOI) CONSULTING SERVICES
INDONESIA MASS TRANSIT PROJECT
(IMPLEMENTATION PROJECT OF PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM)
LOAN ID NO. IBRD 9340 – ID
MEDAN, BINJAI, DELI SERDANG AREA (MEBIDANG) BUS RAPID TRANSIT
(BRT) DETAILED ENGINEERING DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISION
CONSULTANT

Nomor : BA.04/WB-CS/UKPBJ/X/2022

1. Sesuai dengan undangan Ketua kelompok kerja Pengadaan Barang/Jasa Paket

Pekerjaan Satuan Kerja Direktorat Angkutan Jalan, Direktorat Jenderal Perhubungan
Darat pada Biro Layanan Pengadaan dan Pengelolaan Barang Milik Negara Tahun
Anggaran 2022 Nomor 02/PHLN/WB-CS/UKPBJ.PHB/IX/2022 tanggal 2 September 2022
sebagai tindak lanjut Penyampaian Dokumen Request for Expression Of Interst (EOI)
Paket Pekerjaan Consulting Services Indonesia Mass Transit Project (Implementation
Project of Public Transportation System) pada hari Senin tanggal 05 September 2022
dimulai pukul 15.00 WIB s.d. selesai, bertempat di Ruang Rapat Biro Layanan
Pengadaan dan Pengelolaan Barang Milik Negara (LPPBMN), Kelompok Kerja telah
melakukan rapat pembahasan dan evaluasi Dokumen Request for Expression of Interest
(EOI) Pekerjaan sebagaimana tersebut diatas serta memperhatikan hasil pembahasan
evaluasi dengan team procurement task Indonesia Mass Transit Project World Bank East
Asia Pacific Region Letter No. 009/MASTRAN/X/2022 tanggal 6 Oktober 2022 perihal No
Objection to Shortlist for Mebidang Detailed Enginering Design (DED) and Construction
Supervision Management Consultant – Quality and Cost Based Selection

2. Rapat dipimpin oleh Ketua Kelompok Kerja, dihadiri oleh Sekretaris dan para anggota
kelompok kerja sesuai dengan hasil pembahasan dan surat dari Team Procuement Task
Indonesia Mass Transit Project World Bank East Asia Pacific Region sebagaimana
tersebut diatas.;

3. Adapun proses rapat sebagaimana dimaksud di atas adalah sebagai berikut:

a. Sebagai tanggapan terhadap pengumuman Invitation Request for Expression of
Interest (REOI) for Consulting Services Indonesia Mass Transit Project
(Implementation Project of Public Transportation System) Loan ID No. IBRD 9340
– ID yang dikeluarkan oleh Kelompok Kerja Pengadaan Barang/Jasa Paket
Pekerjaan satuan kerja Direktorat Angkutan Jalan, Direktorat Jenderal Perhubungan
Darat pada Biro Layanan Pengadaan dan Pengelolaan Barang Milik Negara tanggal
09 Agustus 2022 melalui media online Website UNDP dan Media Cetak (The Jakarta
Post), (Media Indonesia) dan Elektronik portal LPSE Kementerian Perhubungan
http://lpse.dephub.go.id/eproc, pendaftaran dan permintaan Request for EOI
dokumen Expression of Interest (EOI) dilaksanakan pada tanggal 09 Agustus s/d
26 Agustus 2022, telah mendaftar 31 (tiga puluh satu) perusahaan, yaitu sebagai
berikut:
 No Nama Perusahaan Negara
1 PT Inacon Luhur Pertiwi Indonesia
2 Dohwa Engineering Co. Ltd South Korea
3 PT Prosys Bangun Persada Indonesia
4 Systra Group France
5 Egis Asia Company Hongkong
6 PT Aecom Indonesia Indonesia
7 PT Lengogeni Indonesia
8 Dong IL Engineering Consultant Co. Ltd South Korea
9 KPMG Siddharta Advisory Indonesia
10 PT Mott Macdonald Indonesia Indonesia
11 Hankuk Engineering Consultant South Korea
12 PT Perentjana Djaja Indonesia
13 PT Winsolusi Konsultan Indonesia
14 Finish Overseas Consultant Ltd (FinnOc) Finland
15 Minconsult Sdn. Bhd Malaysia
16 PT Arup Indonesia Indonesia
17 Dong Myeong Engineering Consultant & South Korea
Architecture
18 PT Virama Karya Indonesia
19 PT Deloitte Consulting Indonesia
20 Padeco Co. Ltd Japan
21 PT Smec Denka Indonesia Indonesia
22 (Pwc) PT PricewaterhouseCoopers Indonesia
Indonesia Advisory
23 PT Delta Tama Waja Corpora Indonesia
24 (CRDS) China Railway Design and Indonesia
Corporation
25 China Railway Siyuan Survey and China
Design Group Co. Ltd
26 PT Vetiga Himais Optima Indonesia
27 Eptisa Turkey
28 PT Bina Karya Indonesia
29 PT Dardela Yasa Guna Indonesia
30 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia
31 PT Bereau Veritas Indonesia Indonesia

b. Selanjutnya perusahaan-perusahaan yang telah mendaftar tersebut dan menerima

Dokumen Expression of Interst (EOI) melakukan Pengunggahan / Submitted
dokumen Expression of Interest (EOI) dimulai pada hari Selasa, 09 Agustus 2022
dan ditutup pada hari Jumat, 26 Agutus 2022 pukul 17.00 WIB.

c. Dari 31 (tiga puluh satu) perusahaan-perusahaan yang telah mendaftar, dan

terdapat 17 (tujuh belas) perusahaan yang menyampaikan surat permintaan minat
secara resmi kepada kelompok kerja sampai dengan batas waktu yang ditentukan,
dari 17 (tujuh belas) penyedia yang menyampaikan surat minat atas dokumen
Expresstion of Interest (EOI) hanya terdapat 10 (sepuluh) perusahaan yang
menyampaikan / upload dokumen / Submited Expression of Interest (EOI), untuk
Pekerjaan Consulting Service Medan, Binjai, Deli Sedang Area (Mebidang) Bus Rapid
Transit (BRT) Detailed Engineering Design (DED) and supervision Consultant yaitu
sebagai berikut:
 No Nama Perusahaan Negara Keterangan
1 Hankuk Engineering Korea Menyampaikan Dokumen
Consultant, Tracom, PT Selatan – EOI
Marga Graha Penta, PT Indonesia
Rayakonsult, JV
2 Dong Myeong Engineering Korea Menyampaikan Dokumen
Consultant & Architecture Selatan - EOI
Co, Ltd (DMEC), Kunhwa Indonesia
Engineering & Consulting Co,
Ltd (Kunhwa), PT Dharma
Kreasi Nusantara, JV
3 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia Menyampaikan Dokumen
EOI
4 Shanghai Municipal China – Menyampaikan Dokumen
Engineering Design Institute Indonesia EOI
(Group) Co, Ltd, PT
Winsolusi Konsultan
5 Systra, PT Jaya CM, JV France – Menyampaikan Dokumen
Indonesia EOI
6 Ardanuy Ingenieria SA, Spain – India Menyampaikan Dokumen
Ardanuy India Private – Indonesia EOI
Limited, PT Perentjana Djaja,
JV
7 Eptisa Servicious de Spain – Menyampaikan Dokumen
ingenieria, SL, Eptisa Turkey EOI
Muhendislik ve mus Hiz Bilg
Ins,Tic, Ltd
8 Smec International Pty, Ltd Australia Menyampaikan Dokumen
EOI
9 China Railway Design and China – USA Menyampaikan Dokumen
Corporation (CRDC), HJI - Indonesia EOI
Group Corporation, PT Bina
Karya, JV
10 Minconsult Sdn, Bhd, Malaysia - Menyampaikan Dokumen
Technica Y Project SA Spain EOI
(Typsa)

d. Dari perusahaan-perusahaan yang telah mengisi Prequalification Criteria (EOI),

kelompok kerja melakukan evaluasi dokumen Prequalification Criteria (EOI)
sebagaimana yang telah ditentukan 2 (dua) kriteria yaitu :
Kriteria 1 Preliminary Screening terdiri dari :
1. Declaration Form;
2. Company Information on suitable Form 01;
3. Firms Experience on suitable Form 02a, 02b;
4. Personel Key Expert on suitable Form 03;

Kriteria 2 the firms will be short-listed based on criteria terdiri dari :

1. A globally recognized engineering consulting firm with a good understanding of
urban transport issues;
2. Evidence of completed and ongoing consulting services related to planning,
detailed engineering design, environmental and social impact assessment,
construction supervision of a successful global standard bus rapid transit system.
3. Should have an international experience in leading and implementing detailed
engineering design of mass transit project, preparing bidding document, and also
supervising the civil works with the minimum value of USD 750,000 in the past
10 years.
4. Minimum of 10 years of international experience in leading and implementing
detailed engineering design of mass transit project, preparing bidding document,
and also supervising the civil works.
5. Relevant experience in South East Asia region (Indonesian Experience is an
added advantage).
6. Average annual turnover for the last three financial years of the bidder should be
at least USD 1,300,000.
7. Availability of relevant Key Professionals with the firm. Specific key experts will
not be evaluated at the shortlisting stage

perusahaan yang sesuai pada Tahapan Prequalification Criteria (EOI) sesuai dengan
persyaratan di dalam dokumen Expression of Interest (EOI), Dari proses evaluasi
dokumen Prequalification Criteria (EOI), perusahaan yang dinyatakan memenuhi
kriteria Prequalification Criteria (EOI) dan masuk dalam urutan calon daftar pendek
/ shortlist yaitu sebagai berikut:

No Nama Perusahaan Negara Keterangan

1 Shanghai Municipal China – Memenuhi
Engineering Design Institute Indonesia
(Group) Co, Ltd, PT
Winsolusi Konsultan, JV
2 Systra, / ICA, PT Jaya CM, JV France – memenuhi
Indonesia
3 Smec International Pty, Ltd Australia Memenuhi
4 Dong Myeong Engineering Korea – Memenuhi
Consultant & Architecture Indonesia
Co.Ltd (DM EC), Kunhwa
Engineering & Consulting Co,
Ltd, PT Dharma Kreasi
Nusantara, JV
5 Minconsult SDN BHD, Malaysia - Memenuhi
Technica Y Proyectos SA – Spain
Typsa

Untuk beberapa perusahaan / penyedia yang belum memenuhi persyaratan

sebagaimana criteria yang ditentukan di dalam dokumen Request for Exprestion of
Interest (EOI) adalah sebagai berikut :

No Nama Perusahaan Negara Keterangan

1 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia Tidak memenuhi
2 Hankuk Engineering Korea – Tidak memenuhi
Consultant, Tracom, PT Indonesia
Marga Graha Penta, PT
Rayaconsult, JV
3 Ardanuy Ingenieria SA, Spain – India Tidak memenuhi
Ardanuy India Private – Indonesia
Limited, PT Perentjana Djaja,
JV
4 Eptisa Servicious de Spain – Tidak memenuhi
Ingenieria, SI, Eptisa Turkey
 Muhendisik ve Mus Hiz Bilg,in
Tic, Ltd
5 China Railway Design and China – USA Tidak memenuhi
Corporation (CRDC), HJI – Indonesia
Group Corporation, PT Bina
Karya, JV

e. Selanjutnya Kelompok Kerja menyampaikan dan melaporkan hasil evaluasi

Prequalification Criteria (REOI) kepada penyedia terpilih /shortlist Firm untuk dapat
melanjutkan proses pemilihan dengan mengirimkan kepada mereka dokumen
penawaran (Request for Proposal) beserta kelengkapan dokumen lainnya, serta
menyampaikan penawaran mereka dalam waktu yang telah ditentukan di dalam
Dokumen RFP (request for proposal) tersebut

4. Demikian Berita Acara dan Evaluasi Dokumen REOI berdasarkan Criteria Expression of
Interest (EOI) ini dibuat untuk dapat dipergunakan sebagaimana mestinya.

KELOMPOK KERJA PENGADAAN BARANG/JASA

PAKET PEKERJAAN SATUAN KERJA DIREKTORAT ANGKUTAN JALAN
DIREKTORAT JENDERAL PERHUBUNGAN DARAT
PADA BIRO LAYANAN PENGADAAN DAN PENGELOLAAN BARANG MILIK NEGARA
SEKRETARIAT JENDERAL
KEMENTERIAN PERHUBUNGAN
 MINUTES OF MEETING

On Evaluation of Consultants’ Expression of Interest Indonesia Mass Transit Project for

Implementation Project of Public Transportation System
Loan ID No IBRD 9340 – ID
Bandung Basin Metropolitan Area (BBMA) Bus Rapid Transit (BRT)
Detailed Engineering Design and Construction Supervision Consultant

No. BA.03/WB-CS/UKPBJ/X/2022

The Procurement Committee for Consulting Services Package Indonesia Mass Transit Project for
Implementation Project of Public Transportation System Loan ID No IBRD 9340 – ID for Bandung
Basin Metropolitan Area (BBMA) Bus Rpid Transit (BRT) Detailed Engineering Design (DED) and
Construction Supervision Consultant here in after referred to as “Pokja Pemilihan Penyedia
Barang/Jasa untuk Satuan Kerja Direktorat Angkutan Jalan, Direktorat Jenderal Perhubungan
Darat”, held a meeting on Thursday / September 05th 2022 at Biro LPPBMN Room Meeting, The
meeting was held to evaluation the submitted Expression of Interest (EOI) from consulting firm
for the package. The evaluation was carried out for preparing short-list consultants.

The deadline for submission of EOI was August 26th 2022 at 17.00 UTC (WIB) there are 31 (Thirty
one) consulting firms to register the package the EOIs as follows:

No Nama Perusahaan / Company Negara / Country

1 PT Inacon Luhur Pertiwi Indonesia

2 Dohwa Engineering Co. Ltd South Korea
3 PT Prosys Bangun Persada Indonesia
4 Systra Group France
5 Egis Asia Company Hongkong
6 PT Aecom Indonesia Indonesia
7 PT Lengogeni Indonesia
8 Dong IL Engineering Consultant Co. Ltd South Korea
9 KPMG Siddharta Advisory Indonesia
10 PT Mott Macdonald Indonesia Indonesia
11 Hankuk Engineering Consultant South Korea
12 PT Perentjana Djaja Indonesia
13 PT Winsolusi Konsultan Indonesia
14 Finish Overseas Consultant Ltd (FinnOc) Finland
15 Minconsult Sdn. Bhd Malaysia
16 PT Arup Indonesia Indonesia
17 Dong Myeong Engineering Consultant & South Korea
Architecture
18 PT Virama Karya Indonesia
19 PT Deloitte Consulting Indonesia
20 Padeco Co. Ltd Japan
21 PT Smec Denka Indonesia Indonesia
22 (Pwc) PT PricewaterhouseCoopers Indonesia
Indonesia Advisory
23 PT Delta Tama Waja Corpora Indonesia
 24 (CRDS) China Railway Design and Indonesia
Corporation
25 China Railway Siyuan Survey and Design China
Group Co. Ltd
26 PT Vetiga Himais Optima Indonesia
27 Eptisa Turkey
28 PT Bina Karya Indonesia
29 PT Dardela Yasa Guna Indonesia
30 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia
31 PT Bereau Veritas Indonesia Indonesia

Regarding to the 31 (thirty one) companies that have registered, and there are 19 (nineteen)
companies that submit a letter of interest formally to the Procurement Committee / working group
up to the specified time limit, from 19 (nineteen) providers who submit a letter of interest on the
expression of Interest (EOI) Document, there are only 13 (thirteen) companies that submit /
upload document / submitted expression of interest (EOI), for consulting service work in Bandung
Basin Metropolitan Area (BBMA) Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) Detailed Engineering Design (DED) and
Supervision Consultant are as Follows :

No Nama Perusahaan Negara

1 Dohwa Engineering Co, Ltd, PT Lenggogeni Korea Selatan – Indonesia
Planning Designing & Consulting JV
2 Hankuk Engineering Consultant, Tracom, Korea Selatan – Indonesia
PT Marga Graha Penta, PT Rayakonsult, JV
3 Dong Myeong Engineering Consultant & Korea Selatan - Indonesia
Architecture Co, Ltd (DMEC), Kunhwa
Engineering & Consulting Co, Ltd
(Kunhwa), PT Dharma Kreasi Nusantara, JV
4 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia
5 Shanghai Municipal Engineering Design China – Indonesia
Institute (Group) Co, Ltd, PT Winsolusi
Konsultan
6 Systra, PT Jaya CM, JV France – Indonesia
7 Ardanuy Ingenieria SA, Ardanuy India Spain – India – Indonesia
Private Limited, PT Perentjana Djaja, JV
8 Eptisa Servicious de ingenieria, SL, Eptisa Spain – Turkey
Muhendislik ve mus Hiz Bilg Ins,Tic, Ltd
9 PT Mott Macdonald Indonesia Indonesia
10 Smec International Pty, Ltd Australia
11 Dong Il, Seayoung, PT Delta Tama Waja Korea Selatan – Indonesia
Corpora
12 China Railway Design and Corporation China – USA - Indonesia
(CRDC), HJI Group Corporation, PT Bina
Karya, JV
13 Min Consult Sdn, Bhd, Technica Y Project Malaysia - Spain
SA (Typsa)

The Procurement Committee / Pokja conducted the EOI evaluation based on the following criteria:
Criteria 1 Preliminary Screening:

1. Declaration Form;
2. Company Information on suitable Form 01;
3. Firms Experience on suitable Form 02a, 02b;
4. Personel Key Expert on suitable Form 03;

(Not Specified Form Must be the same)

Criteria 2 Evaluation of Project Experience:

1. A globally recognized engineering consulting firm with a good understanding of urban transport
issues;
2. Evidence of completed and ongoing consulting services related to planning, detailed
engineering design, environmental and social impact assessment, construction supervision of
a successful global standard bus rapid transit system.
3. Should have an international experience in leading and implementing detailed engineering
design of mass transit project, preparing bidding document, and also supervising the civil
works with the minimum value of USD 750,000 in the past 10 years.
4. Minimum of 10 years of international experience in leading and implementing detailed
engineering design of mass transit project, preparing bidding document, and also supervising
the civil works.
5. Relevant experience in South East Asia region (Indonesian Experience is an added advantage).
6. Average annual turnover for the last three financial years of the bidder should be at least USD
1,300,000.
7. Availability of relevant Key Professionals with the firm. Specific key experts will not be evaluated
at the shortlisting stage

The Procurement Committee / Pokja announce there are 6 (six) firms from the above consultants,
that are declared to meet the prequalification criteria and are included in the order of candidates
for the shortlist are as follows:
No Nama Perusahaan / Company Negara / Country Keterangan / Remark

1 Dohwa Engineering Co, Ltd, PT Korea Selatan – Complied / Passed

Lenggogeni Planning Designing & Indonesia (Qualified for shortlist)
Consulting JV
2 Shanghai Municipal Engineering China – Indonesia Complied / Passed
Design Institute (Group) Co, Ltd, (Qualified for shortlist)
PT Winsolusi Konsultan, JV
3 Systra, PT Jaya CM, JV France – Indonesia Complied / Passed
(Qualified for shortlist)
4 Smec International Pty, Ltd Australia Complied / Passed
(Qualified for shortlist)
5 Dong Myeong Engineering Korea – Indonesia Complied / Passed
Consultant & Architecture Co.Ltd (Qualified for shortlist)
(DM EC), Kunhwa Engineering &
Consulting Co, Ltd, PT Dharma
Kreasi Nusantara, JV
6 Minconsult SDN BHD, Technica Y Malaysia - Spain Complied / Passed
Proyectos SA – Typsa (Qualified for shortlist)
To be proposed to the shortlist, the applicant shall meet a criteria above

The Procurement Committee / Pokja announce there are 7 (seven) firms from the above
consultants, that are declared Not Qualified for shortlist / to meet the prequalification criteria
and are included in the order of candidates for the shortlist are as follows

The narrative evaluation was as follows for not qualified firms:

No Nama Perusahaan / Company Negara / Country Remarks

1 Dohwa Engineering Co, Ltd, PT Korea Selatan –

Lenggogeni Planning Designing Indonesia
& Consulting JV
2 Hankuk Engineering Korea Selatan – TRACOM's experiences are
Consultant, Tracom, PT Marga Indonesia specified for the technology
Graha Penta, PT Rayakonsult, design, not for the detailed
JV engineering design BRT system
2. The JV does not have
experience in BRT construction
supervision
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
3 Dong Myeong Engineering Korea Selatan -
Consultant & Architecture Co, Indonesia
Ltd (DMEC), Kunhwa
Engineering & Consulting Co,
Ltd (Kunhwa), PT Dharma
Kreasi Nusantara, JV
4 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia The company does not submit
the EOI documents
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
5 Shanghai Municipal China – Indonesia
Engineering Design Institute
(Group) Co, Ltd, PT Winsolusi
Konsultan
6 Systra, PT Jaya CM, JV France – Indonesia
7 Ardanuy Ingenieria SA, Spain – India – The company does not submit
Ardanuy India Private Limited, Indonesia the EOI document
PT Perentjana Djaja, JV (Not Qualified for Shortlist)
8 Eptisa Servicious de ingenieria, Spain – Turkey The JV does not have any
SL, Eptisa Muhendislik ve mus experience in DED of BRT
Hiz Bilg Ins,Tic, Ltd Systems 2. The JV does not
have any experience in South
East Asia
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
9 PT Mott Macdonald Indonesia Indonesia The company does not have
experience in construction
supervision of BRT or
international mass transit
project
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
 10 Smec International Pty, Ltd
11 Dong Il, Seayoung, PT Delta
Tama Waja Corpora
12 China Railway Design and
Corporation (CRDC), HJI Group
Corporation, PT Bina Karya, JV
13 Min Consult Sdn, Bhd, Technica
Y Project SA (Typsa)
Australia
Korea Selatan – The JV does not have any
Indonesia international DED experience
of mass transit project in the
last 10 years
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
China – USA - The JV does not have any DED
Indonesia experience of BRT Systems
and international mass transit
project
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
Malaysia - Spain

The Procurement Committee for Consulting Services Package Indonesia Mass Transit Project
for Implementation Project of Public Transportation System Loan ID No IBRD 9340 – ID for
Bandung Basin Metropolitan Area (BBMA) Bus Rpid Transit (BRT) Detailed Engineering Design
(DED) and Construction Supervision Consultant
For Satuan Kerja Direktorat Angkutan Jalan Direktorat Jenderal Perhubungan Darat
 MINUTES OF MEETING

On Evaluation of Consultants’ Expression of Interest Indonesia Mass Transit Project for

Implementation Project of Public Transportation System
Loan ID No IBRD 9340 – ID
Medan, Binjai, Deli Serdang Area (Mebidang) Bus Rapid Transit (BRT)
Detailed Engineering Design and Construction Supervision Consultant

No. BA.04/WB-CS/UKPBJ/X/2022

The Procurement Committee for Consulting Services Package Indonesia Mass Transit Project for
Implementation Project of Public Transportation System Loan ID No IBRD 9340 – ID for Bandung
Basin Metropolitan Area (BBMA) Bus Rpid Transit (BRT) Detailed Engineering Design (DED) and
Construction Supervision Consultant here in after referred to as “Pokja Pemilihan Penyedia
Barang/Jasa untuk Satuan Kerja Direktorat Angkutan Jalan, Direktorat Jenderal Perhubungan
Darat”, held a meeting on Thursday / September 05th 2022 at Biro LPPBMN Room Meeting, The
meeting was held to evaluation the submitted Expression of Interest (EOI) from consulting firm
for the package. The evaluation was carried out for preparing short-list consultants.

The deadline for submission of EOI was August 26th 2022 at 17.00 UTC (WIB) there are 31 (Thirty
one) consulting firms to register the package the EOIs as follows:

No Nama Perusahaan / Company Negara / Country

1 PT Inacon Luhur Pertiwi Indonesia

2 Dohwa Engineering Co. Ltd South Korea
3 PT Prosys Bangun Persada Indonesia
4 Systra Group France
5 Egis Asia Company Hongkong
6 PT Aecom Indonesia Indonesia
7 PT Lengogeni Indonesia
8 Dong IL Engineering Consultant Co. Ltd South Korea
9 KPMG Siddharta Advisory Indonesia
10 PT Mott Macdonald Indonesia Indonesia
11 Hankuk Engineering Consultant South Korea
12 PT Perentjana Djaja Indonesia
13 PT Winsolusi Konsultan Indonesia
14 Finish Overseas Consultant Ltd (FinnOc) Finland
15 Minconsult Sdn. Bhd Malaysia
16 PT Arup Indonesia Indonesia
17 Dong Myeong Engineering Consultant & South Korea
Architecture
18 PT Virama Karya Indonesia
19 PT Deloitte Consulting Indonesia
20 Padeco Co. Ltd Japan
21 PT Smec Denka Indonesia Indonesia
22 (Pwc) PT PricewaterhouseCoopers Indonesia
Indonesia Advisory
23 PT Delta Tama Waja Corpora Indonesia
 24 (CRDS) China Railway Design and Indonesia
Corporation
25 China Railway Siyuan Survey and Design China
Group Co. Ltd
26 PT Vetiga Himais Optima Indonesia
27 Eptisa Turkey
28 PT Bina Karya Indonesia
29 PT Dardela Yasa Guna Indonesia
30 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia
31 PT Bereau Veritas Indonesia Indonesia

Regarding to the 31 (thirty one) companies that have registered, and there are 17 (seventeen)
companies that submit a letter of interest formally to the Procurement Committee / working group
up to the specified time limit, from 17 (seventeen) providers who submit a letter of interest on
the expression of Interest (EOI) Document, there are only 10 (ten) companies that submit /
upload document / submitted expression of interest (EOI), for consulting service work in Medan,
Binjai, Deli Serdang Area (Mebidang) Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) Detailed Engineering Design (DED)
and Supervision Consultant are as Follows :

No Nama Perusahaan Negara

1 Hankuk Engineering Consultant, Tracom, PT Korea Selatan – Indonesia
Marga Graha Penta, PT Rayakonsult, JV
2 Dong Myeong Engineering Consultant & Korea Selatan - Indonesia
Architecture Co, Ltd (DMEC), Kunhwa
Engineering & Consulting Co, Ltd (Kunhwa), PT
Dharma Kreasi Nusantara, JV
3 PT Indra Karya (Persero) Indonesia
4 Shanghai Municipal Engineering Design Institute China – Indonesia
(Group) Co, Ltd, PT Winsolusi Konsultan
5 Systra, PT Jaya CM, JV France – Indonesia
6 Ardanuy Ingenieria SA, Ardanuy India Private Spain – India – Indonesia
Limited, PT Perentjana Djaja, JV
7 Eptisa Servicious de ingenieria, SL, Eptisa Spain – Turkey
Muhendislik ve mus Hiz Bilg Ins,Tic, Ltd
8 Smec International Pty, Ltd Australia
9 China Railway Design and Corporation (CRDC), China – USA - Indonesia
HJI Group Corporation, PT Bina Karya, JV
10 Minconsult Sdn, Bhd, Technica Y Project SA Malaysia - Spain
(Typsa)

The Procurement Committee / Pokja conducted the EOI evaluation based on the following criteria:

Criteria 1 Preliminary Screening:

1. Declaration Form;
2. Company Information on suitable Form 01;
3. Firms Experience on suitable Form 02a, 02b;
4. Personel Key Expert on suitable Form 03;
(Not Specified Form Must be the same)
Criteria 2 Evaluation of Project Experience:

1. A globally recognized engineering consulting firm with a good understanding of urban transport
issues;
2. Evidence of completed and ongoing consulting services related to planning, detailed
engineering design, environmental and social impact assessment, construction supervision of
a successful global standard bus rapid transit system.
3. Should have an international experience in leading and implementing detailed engineering
design of mass transit project, preparing bidding document, and also supervising the civil
works with the minimum value of USD 750,000 in the past 10 years.
4. Minimum of 10 years of international experience in leading and implementing detailed
engineering design of mass transit project, preparing bidding document, and also supervising
the civil works.
5. Relevant experience in South East Asia region (Indonesian Experience is an added advantage).
6. Average annual turnover for the last three financial years of the bidder should be at least USD
1,300,000.
7. Availability of relevant Key Professionals with the firm. Specific key experts will not be evaluated
at the shortlisting stage

The Procurement Committee / Pokja announce there are 6 (six) firms from the above consultants,
that are declared to meet the prequalification criteria and are included in the order of candidates
for the shortlist are as follows:

No Nama Perusahaan / Company Negara / Country Keterangan / Remark

1 Shanghai Municipal Engineering China – Indonesia Complied / Passed

Design Institute (Group) Co, Ltd, (Qualified for shortlist)
PT Winsolusi Konsultan, JV
2 Systra, PT Jaya CM, JV France – Indonesia Complied / Passed
(Qualified for shortlist)
3 Smec International Pty, Ltd Australia Complied / Passed
(Qualified for shortlist)
4 Dong Myeong Engineering Korea – Indonesia Complied / Passed
Consultant & Architecture Co.Ltd (Qualified for shortlist)
(DM EC), Kunhwa Engineering &
Consulting Co, Ltd, PT Dharma
Kreasi Nusantara, JV
5 Minconsult SDN BHD, Technica Y Malaysia - Spain Complied / Passed
Proyectos SA – Typsa (Qualified for shortlist)

To be proposed to the shortlist, the applicant shall meet a criteria above

The Procurement Committee / Pokja announce there are 6 (six) firms from the above consultants,
that are declared Not Qualified for shortlist / to meet the prequalification criteria and are
included in the order of candidates for the shortlist are as follows

The narrative evaluation was as follows for not qualified firms:

No Nama Perusahaan / Company Negara / Country Remarks

1 Hankuk Engineering Korea Selatan – TRACOM's experiences are

Consultant, Tracom, PT Marga
Graha Penta, PT Rayakonsult,
JV
2 Dong Myeong Engineering
Consultant & Architecture Co,
Ltd (DMEC), Kunhwa
Engineering & Consulting Co,
Ltd (Kunhwa), PT Dharma
Kreasi Nusantara, JV
3 PT Indra Karya (Persero)
4 Shanghai Municipal
Engineering Design Institute
(Group) Co, Ltd, PT Winsolusi
Konsultan
5 Systra, PT Jaya CM, JV
6 Ardanuy Ingenieria SA,
Ardanuy India Private Limited,
PT Perentjana Djaja, JV
7 Eptisa Servicious de ingenieria,
SL, Eptisa Muhendislik ve mus
Hiz Bilg Ins,Tic, Ltd
8 Smec International Pty, Ltd
9 China Railway Design and
Corporation (CRDC), HJI Group
Corporation, PT Bina Karya, JV
10 Min Consult Sdn, Bhd, Technica
Y Project SA (Typsa)
Indonesia specified for the technology
design, not for the detailed
engineering design BRT system
2. The JV does not have
experience in BRT construction
supervision
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
Korea Selatan -
Indonesia
Indonesia The company does not submit
the EOI documents
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
China – Indonesia
France – Indonesia
Spain – India – The company does not submit
Indonesia the EOI document
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
Spain – Turkey The JV does not have any
experience in DED of BRT
Systems 2. The JV does not
have any experience in South
East Asia
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
Australia
China – USA - The JV does not have any DED
Indonesia experience of BRT Systems
and international mass transit
project
(Not Qualified for Shortlist)
Malaysia - Spain

The Procurement Committee for Consulting Services Package Indonesia Mass Transit Project
for Implementation Project of Public Transportation System Loan ID No IBRD 9340 – ID for
Medan, Binjai, Deli Serdang Area (Mebidang) Bus Rpid Transit (BRT) Detailed Engineering
Design (DED) and Construction Supervision Consultant
For Satuan Kerja Direktorat Angkutan Jalan Direktorat Jenderal Perhubungan Darat