Pada suatu perusahaan akan dilakukan pengambilan keputusan terkait jenis pompa ESP yang ak

dengan menggunakan metode AHP. Alternatif pilihan pompa ada 2 yaitu Pompa Red-A dan Pom
Centraleft. Sedangkan kriteria pilihan meliputi: daya tahan produk, jumlah maintenance, serta pe
dan reputasi. Hasil pengambilan data terkait dengan pemilihan pompa ESP pada 3 expert judgem
berikut. Dari hasil pengambilan data, tentukan:

a. Bentuk hierarkhi pengambilan keputusan sesuai metode AHP!

b. Nilai matriks untuk setiap kriteria!
c. Nilai matriks untuk keseluruhan kriteria!

Expert Judgement 1
Pompa Red-A 9 7 5 3 1
Daya Tahan Produk
Jumlah Maintenance v
Pengalaman & Reputasi

Expert Judgement 2
Pompa Red-A 9 7 5 3 1
Daya Tahan Produk
Jumlah Maintenance
Pengalaman & Reputasi

Expert Judgement 3
Pompa Red-A 9 7 5 3 1
Daya Tahan Produk
Jumlah Maintenance v
Pengalaman & Reputasi

Tujuan : Pemilihan Pompa ESP dengan kriteria tertentu

Kriteria : - Daya tahan produk Kualitatif
- Jumlah Maintenance Kuantitatif
- Pengalaman & reputasi Kualitatif
Alternatif : Pompa Red A & Centraleft
ait jenis pompa ESP yang akan dipilih Memilih Pompa
yaitu Pompa Red-A dan Pompa ESP
jumlah maintenance, serta pengalaman
pa ESP pada 3 expert judgement sebagai
Daya Tahan Jumlah Pengalaman
Produk Maintenance & Reputasi

Pompa Pompa Pompa Pompa Pompa Pom

Red-A Centraleft Red-A Centraleft Red-A Centr

1/3 1/5 1/7 1/9 Pompa Centraleft

v Jumlah Maintenance
Pengalaman & Reputasi
v Daya Tahan Produk

1/3 1/5 1/7 1/9 Pompa Centraleft

v Jumlah Maintenance
v Pengalaman & Reputasi
v Daya Tahan Produk

1/3 1/5 1/7 1/9 Pompa Centraleft

v Jumlah Maintenance
Pengalaman & Reputasi
v Daya Tahan Produk
 Pengalaman
& Reputasi

Pompa Pompa
t Red-A Centraleft
 Matriks

Expert Judgement 1 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 1 0.333333333333333 1.33333333333333
Daya Tahan Produk 3 1 4
5.33333333333333

Expert Judgement 2 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 1 0.142857142857143 1.14285714285714
Daya Tahan Produk 7 1 8
9.14285714285714

Expert Judgement 3 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 1 0.2 1.2
Daya Tahan Produk 5 1 6
7.2

Total Rata-Rata Geometris

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector
Pompa Red-A 1 0.211967966589665 1.21196796658967
Pompa Centraleft 4.71769398031653 1 5.71769398031653
6.9296619469062

Matrix 1 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 2 0.423935933179331 2.42393593317933
Pompa Centraleft 9.43538796063307 2 11.4353879606331
13.8593238938124

Matrix 2 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 8 1.69574373271732 9.69574373271732
Pompa Centraleft 37.7415518425323 8 45.7415518425323
55.4372955752496

Matrix 3 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 128 27.1318997234772 155.131899723477
Pompa Centraleft 603.864829480516 128 731.864829480516
886.996729203993

Weighted Rating
Pompa Red-A 0.349791368143365
Pompa Centraleft 1.65020863185664

Pompa Red-A 2
Pompa Centraleft 2
Lambda 2

Consistency Index
0

Consistency Ratio 1 Tabel Alonso

0
Normalized Eigenvector
0.25
0.75

Normalized Eigenvector
0.125
0.875

Normalized Eigenvector
0.166666666666667
0.833333333333333

Total Rata-Rata Geometris

Normalized Eigenvector Priority
0.174895684071682 0.1748957 Pompa Red-A
0.825104315928318 0.8251043 Pompa Centraleft

Normalized Eigenvector Matrix 1

0.174895684071682 Pompa Red-A
0.825104315928318 Pompa Centraleft

Normalized Eigenvector Matrix 2

0.174895684071682 Pompa Red-A
0.825104315928318 Pompa Centraleft

Normalized Eigenvector Matrix 3

0.174895684071682 Pompa Red-A
0.825104315928318 Pompa Centraleft

Weighted Rating
Pompa Red-A
Pompa Centraleft

Pompa Red-A
Pompa Centraleft
Lambda

Consistency Index

Consistency Ratio
 Total Rata-Rata Geometris
Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector
1 0.225396825396825 1.22539682539683 0.183937823834197
4.43661971830986 1 5.43661971830986 0.816062176165803
6.66201654370668

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

2 0.450793650793651 2.45079365079365 0.183937823834197
8.87323943661972 2 10.8732394366197 0.816062176165803
13.3240330874134

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

8 1.8031746031746 9.8031746031746 0.183937823834197
35.4929577464789 8 43.4929577464789 0.816062176165803
53.2961323496535

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

128 28.8507936507937 156.850793650794 0.183937823834197
567.887323943662 128 695.887323943662 0.816062176165803
852.738117594456

Weighted Rating
0.36787564766839
1.63212435233161

2
 2
2

Consistency Index
0

Consistency Ratio 1 Tabel Alonso

0
 Priority
0.1839378238
0.8160621762
 Matriks

Expert Judgement 1 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 1 3 4
Daya Tahan Produk 0.333333333333333 1 1.33333333333333
5.33333333333333

Expert Judgement 2 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 1 0.333333333333333 1.33333333333333
Daya Tahan Produk 3 1 4
5.33333333333333

Expert Judgement 3 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 1 1 2
Daya Tahan Produk 1 1 2
4

Total Rata-Rata Geometris

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector
Pompa Red-A 1 1 2
Pompa Centraleft 1 1 2
4

Matrix 1 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 2 2 4
Pompa Centraleft 2 2 4
8

Matrix 2 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 8 8 16
Pompa Centraleft 8 8 16
32

Matrix 3 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 128 128 256
Pompa Centraleft 128 128 256
512

Weighted Rating
Pompa Red-A 1
Pompa Centraleft 1

Pompa Red-A 2
Pompa Centraleft 2
Lambda 2

Consistency Index
0

Consistency Ratio 1 Tabel Alonso

0
Normalized Eigenvector
0.75
0.25

Normalized Eigenvector
0.25
0.75

Normalized Eigenvector
0.5
0.5

Total Rata-Rata Geometris

Normalized Eigenvector Priority
0.5 0.5 Pompa Red-A
0.5 0.5 Pompa Centraleft

Normalized Eigenvector Matrix 1

0.5 Pompa Red-A
0.5 Pompa Centraleft

Normalized Eigenvector Matrix 2

0.5 Pompa Red-A
0.5 Pompa Centraleft

Normalized Eigenvector Matrix 3

0.5 Pompa Red-A
0.5 Pompa Centraleft

Weighted Rating
Pompa Red-A
Pompa Centraleft

Pompa Red-A
Pompa Centraleft
Lambda

Consistency Index

Consistency Ratio
 Total Rata-Rata Geometris
Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector
1 1.44444444444444 2.44444444444444 0.590909090909091
0.69230769230769 1 1.69230769230769 0.409090909090909
4.13675213675214

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

2 2.88888888888889 4.88888888888889 0.590909090909091
1.38461538461538 2 3.38461538461538 0.409090909090909
8.27350427350427

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

8 11.5555555555556 19.5555555555556 0.590909090909091
5.53846153846154 8 13.5384615384615 0.409090909090909
33.0940170940171

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

128 184.888888888889 312.888888888889 0.590909090909091
88.6153846153846 128 216.615384615385 0.409090909090909
529.504273504274

Weighted Rating
1.18181818181818
0.81818181818182

2
 2
2

Consistency Index
-2.2204460493E-16

Consistency Ratio 1 Tabel Alonso

-2.2204460493E-16
 Priority
0.5909090909
0.4090909091
 Matriks

Expert Judgement 1 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 1 0.2 1.2
Daya Tahan Produk 5 1 6
7.2

Expert Judgement 2 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 1 0.2 1.2
Daya Tahan Produk 5 1 6
7.2

Expert Judgement 3 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 1 0.142857142857143 1.14285714285714
Daya Tahan Produk 7 1 8
9.14285714285714

Total Rata-Rata Geometris

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector
Pompa Red-A 1 0.178780707019314 1.17878070701931
Pompa Centraleft 5.59344471040698 1 6.59344471040698
7.7722254174263

Matrix 1 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 2 0.357561414038627 2.35756141403863
Pompa Centraleft 11.186889420814 2 13.186889420814
15.5444508348526

Matrix 2 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 8 1.43024565615451 9.43024565615451
Pompa Centraleft 44.7475576832559 8 52.7475576832559
62.1778033394104

Matrix 3 Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector

Pompa Red-A 128 22.8839304984721 150.883930498472
Pompa Centraleft 715.960922932094 128 843.960922932094
994.844853430566

Weighted Rating
Pompa Red-A 0.303331579749692
Pompa Centraleft 1.69666842025031

Pompa Red-A 2
Pompa Centraleft 2
Lambda 2

Consistency Index
0

Consistency Ratio 1 Tabel Alonso

0
Normalized Eigenvector
0.166666666666667
0.833333333333333

Normalized Eigenvector
0.166666666666667
0.833333333333333

Normalized Eigenvector
0.125
0.875

Total Rata-Rata Geometris

Normalized Eigenvector Priority
0.151665789874846 0.1516658 Pompa Red-A
0.848334210125154 0.8483342 Pompa Centraleft

Normalized Eigenvector Matrix 1

0.151665789874846 Pompa Red-A
0.848334210125154 Pompa Centraleft

Normalized Eigenvector Matrix 2

0.151665789874846 Pompa Red-A
0.848334210125154 Pompa Centraleft

Normalized Eigenvector Matrix 3

0.151665789874846 Pompa Red-A
0.848334210125154 Pompa Centraleft

Weighted Rating
Pompa Red-A
Pompa Centraleft

Pompa Red-A
Pompa Centraleft
Lambda

Consistency Index

Consistency Ratio
 Total Rata-Rata Geometris
Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector
1 0.180952380952381 1.18095238095238 0.153225806451613
5.52631578947368 1 6.52631578947368 0.846774193548387
7.70726817042606

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

2 0.361904761904762 2.36190476190476 0.153225806451613
11.0526315789474 2 13.0526315789474 0.846774193548387
15.4145363408521

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

8 1.44761904761905 9.44761904761905 0.153225806451613
44.2105263157895 8 52.2105263157895 0.846774193548387
61.6581453634085

Pompa Red-A Pompa Centraleft Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

128 23.1619047619048 151.161904761905 0.153225806451613
707.368421052632 128 835.368421052631 0.846774193548387
986.530325814536

Weighted Rating
0.30645161290323
1.69354838709677

2
 2
2

Consistency Index
0

Consistency Ratio 1 Tabel Alonso

0
 Priority
0.1532258065
0.8467741935
 Matrix
Expert Judgement 1 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance
Daya Tahan Produk 1.000 0.333
Jumlah Maintenance 3.000 1.000
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.200 0.333

Expert Judgement 2 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance

Daya Tahan Produk 1.000 0.143
Jumlah Maintenance 7.000 1.000
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.200 3.000

Expert Judgement 3 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance

Daya Tahan Produk 1.000 0.200
Jumlah Maintenance 5.000 1.000
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.143 1.000

Rata - Rata Geometris

Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance
Daya Tahan Produk 1.000 0.212
Jumlah Maintenance 4.718 1.000
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.179 1.000

Matrix 1 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance

Daya Tahan Produk 3.000 6.017
Jumlah Maintenance 9.614 3.000
Pengalaman & Reputasi 5.075 2.038

Matrix 2 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance

Daya Tahan Produk 124.704 59.334
Jumlah Maintenance 201.762 124.704
Pengalaman & Reputasi 50.044 42.767

Matrix 3 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance

Daya Tahan Produk 39493.844 25028.951
Jumlah Maintenance 64329.541 39493.844
Pengalaman & Reputasi 21110.235 13635.802
 Matrix 4 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance
Daya Tahan Produk 4779965581.453 3016996657.990
Jumlah Maintenance 7573915703.657 4779965581.453
Pengalaman & Reputasi 2544633532.455 1605427510.826

Weighted Rating
Daya Tahan Produk 1.384
Jumlah Maintenance 2.193
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.737

Daya Tahan Produk 4.313

Jumlah Maintenance 4.313
Pengalaman & Reputasi 4.313
lambda 4.313

CI 0.657

Cr 1.252 0.525
(Tidak Konsisten)
Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector
5.000 6.333 0.426
3.000 7.000 0.471
1.000 1.533 0.103
14.867

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

5.000 6.143 0.329
0.333 8.333 0.446
1.000 4.200 0.225
18.676

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

7.000 8.200 0.473
1.000 7.000 0.404
1.000 2.143 0.124
17.343

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector Priority

5.593 6.805 0.433 0.321
1.000 6.718 0.428 0.508
1.000 2.179 0.139 0.171
15.702

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

11.399 20.416 0.285
28.388 41.002 0.573
3.000 10.113 0.141
71.532

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

239.216 423.254 0.339
279.920 606.386 0.486
124.704 217.516 0.174
1247.155

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

76271.104 140793.900 0.322
118078.931 221902.316 0.508
39493.844 74239.881 0.170
 436936.097

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

8979870018.370 16776832257.814 0.321
14233266972.034 26587148257.144 0.508
4779965581.453 8930026624.734 0.171
52294007139.692

Tabel Alonso
 Rata - Rata Aritmatik
Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance
Daya Tahan Produk 1.000 0.225
Jumlah Maintenance 5.000 1.000
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.181 1.444

Matrix 1 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance

Daya Tahan Produk 3.152 8.636
Jumlah Maintenance 10.261 4.213
Pengalaman & Reputasi 7.584 2.930

Matrix 2 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance

Daya Tahan Produk 186.977 97.768
Jumlah Maintenance 312.376 197.841
Pengalaman & Reputasi 85.155 89.887

Matrix 3 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance

Daya Tahan Produk 95673.489 69471.948
Jumlah Maintenance 152530.202 103799.331
Pengalaman & Reputasi 60759.068 43798.359
 Matrix 4 Daya Tahan Produk Jumlah Maintenance
Daya Tahan Produk 30266914820.134 21438924941.618
Jumlah Maintenance 46251954862.117 32779326110.197
Pengalaman & Reputasi 18753084217.859 13279456107.750

Weighted Rating
Daya Tahan Produk 1.542
Jumlah Maintenance 2.358
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.956

Daya Tahan Produk 4.856

Jumlah Maintenance 4.856
Pengalaman & Reputasi 4.856
lambda 4.856

CI 0.928

Cr 1.769 0.525
(Tidak Konsisten)
Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector Priority
5.667 6.892 0.406 0.318
1.444 7.444 0.439 0.486
1.000 2.625 0.155 0.197
16.962

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

11.659 23.447 0.280
31.222 45.697 0.546
4.112 14.626 0.175
83.770

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

354.327 639.072 0.336
379.568 889.785 0.468
196.801 371.842 0.196
1900.699

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

173092.320 338237.757 0.318
260476.763 516806.296 0.486
103021.324 207578.751 0.195
 1062622.804

Pengalaman & Reputasi Eigenvector Normalized Eigenvector

52488374404.238 104194214165.990 0.318
80273781355.744 159305062328.058 0.486
32538776093.063 64571316418.673 0.197
328070592912.721

Tabel Alonso
 Rata - Rata Geometris
Pompa Red-A
All Kriteria Priority
Daya Tahan Produk 0.175
Jumlah Maintenance 0.500
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.152

Pompa Centraleft
All Kriteria Priority
Daya Tahan Produk 0.825
Jumlah Maintenance 0.500
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.848
Rata - Rata Geometris
Pompa Red-A
Weighted Criterion Alternatif Pilihan
0.321 0.056
0.508 0.254
0.171 0.026
Total 0.336 Pilihan Kedua
Pompa Centraleft
Weighted Criterion Alternatif Pilihan
0.321 0.265
0.508 0.254
0.171 0.145
Total 0.664 Pilihan Pertama
 Rata - Rata Geometris
Pompa Red-A
All Kriteria Priority Weighted Criterion Alternatif Pilihan
Daya Tahan Produk 0.184 0.318 0.058
Jumlah Maintenance 0.591 0.486 0.287
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.153 0.197 0.030
Total 0.376
Pompa Centraleft
All Kriteria Priority Weighted Criterion Alternatif Pilihan
Daya Tahan Produk 0.816 0.318 0.259
Jumlah Maintenance 0.409 0.486 0.199
Pengalaman & Reputasi 0.847 0.197 0.167
Total 0.624
 Pilihan Kedua

Pilihan Pertama