WA-22NCC-326-06/2019

Encl No. 10

H0272101 WA1319286144 01/07/2019 16:56:28

WA-22NCC-326-06/2019
DALAM MAHKAMAH TINGGI MAL AYA
TSP055..........................80.00 x 1
Jumlah RM***************************80.00
DALAM WILAYAH PERSEKUTUAN, MAL AYSI A

(BAH AGI AN DAG ANG)

GUAMAN SIVIL NO.: WA-22NCC-326-06/2019

ANTARA

1. DATUK SERI MAG LIN DENNIS D’CRUZ

(NO. K/P:560227 -10-5057)
2. DATUK SUBRAY AN A/L SELLAPP AN
(NO. K/P:440402 -08-5641)
3. DATO DR LOG A BAL A MOHAN A/L JAG ANATHAN
(NO. K/P:660403 -07-5175)
4. DATO ELAYPPEN A/L MUTHUS AMY
(NO. K/P:631115 -06-5201)
5. DATUK DR K D SIV A KUMAR A/L KRISHNADAS
(NO. K/P:640607 -10-6967
6. DATUK MOHAN A/ L A KANDAS AMY
(NO. K/P:600222 -05-5007)
7. DATUK TIONG YAP CHOON
(NO. K/P:610411-08-5263)
8. S ATHI AH A/L SUDAK AR AN
(NO. K/P:760607 -06-5313)
9. DATUK CHIW TI ANG CHAI
(NO. K/P:570119 -04-5017)
10. DATO’ INDER SINGH A/L BE ANT SINGH
(NO. K/P:670508 -10-5747)
11. SELV ARAJOO A/L PERMAL
(NO. K/P:670418-07-5265)
12. ASECALIN A/L V. FERNANDEZ
(NO. K/P:640626-08-6527)
13. J AYASELAN A/L RAJOO
(NO. K/P:770108 -14-6003) …PLAINTIF-PLAINTIF
(MEMBAW A TUNTUTAN INI DALAM KAP ASITI PERW AKILAN
UNTUK DAN BAGI PIHAK BEKAS AHLI-AHLI myPPP)
DAN

1. TAN SRI DATUK SERI M. KAYVE AS

(NO. K/P:540429 -06-5067)
2. KAYVE AS HOLDINGS SDN BHD
(NO. SYARIKAT: 829080-V)
3. BINTANG IRADAT (M) SDN BHD
(NO. SYARIKAT:510546 -X)
4. DATUK CHANDRAKUMANAN A/L ARUMUG AM
(NO. K/P:611111 -08-5215)

1
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 5. DATO’ LY KIM CHEONG
(NO. K/P:800307 -04-5365)
6. VIJ AYAN A/L SING ARAM
(NO. K/P:601205 -10-6639)
7. SHANKER KANDASWAMY
(NO. K/P.:781015 -14-5339)
8. KUMARA RAJ A A/ L R. ARUMUG AM
(NO. K/P.:610410 -71-5059)
9. DATUK LAU BENG WEI
(NO K/P.:660114 -10-6545)
10. KETUA PENG AR AH INSOLVENSI …DEFENDAN -DEFENDAN

DI HAD AP AN PESURUHJ AYA KEHAKIMAN

ONG CHEE KW AN
P ADA 21 JUN 2019 DAL AM KAM AR

PERINTAH
(Kandungan 7)

AT AS PERMOHONAN Plaintif-Plaintif yang dinamakan di atas

DAN SETELAH PERKAR A INI ditetapkan untuk Pe ndengaran pada 21

Jun 2019 DAN SETELAH MEMBACA Notis Permohonan bertarikh 19

Jun 2019 dan kesemuanya yang difailkan di sini DAN SETELAH

MENDENG AR Encik K. Thavanesan (bersama -sama dengan Encik

Gavin Jayapal, Encik Simon Sabapathy, Cik Santhyaa Venugopal dan

Cik Laavanya Selvaraja) di mana Plaintif mengakujanji untuk mematuhi

apa-apa perintah yang dibuat oleh M ahkamah tentang ganti rugi,

sekiranya Mahkamah berpendapat selepas itu yang Defendan -defendan

telah ditanggungi dengan apa -apa kerugian, disebabkan perintah ini,

yang Plaintif patut bayar, MAKA ADALAH DIPERINTAHKAN BAH AW A:

a. Mahkamah yang Mulia ini membenarkan perintah injunksi ex-parte

interim untuk menghalang Defendan Kedua (Ka yveas Holdings

Sdn Bhd) dan/atau ejen-ejennya, pekerja -pekerjanya, wakil -

2
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 wakilnya atau penama -penamanya daripada memindahkan,

menjual, mencaj, mencagar, memasuki mana -mana transaksi

dan/atau melupuskan mana -mana saham yang dipegang

olehnya di dalam Bintang Iradat (M) Sdn Bhd kepada mana-

mana pihak sementara menunggu pelupusan Guaman Sivil ini;

b. Mahkamah yang Mulia ini membenarkan p erintah injunksi ex-parte

interim untuk menghalang Defendan Pertama (Tan Sri M

Kayveas) dan/atau ejen-ejennya, pekerja -pekerjanya, wakil -

wakilnya atau penama -penamanya daripada memindahkan,

menjual, mencaj, mencagar, memasuki mana -mana transaksi

dan/atau melupuskan mana -mana bahagian hartanah terseb ut

yang terletak di Geran 65301, Lot 1176, Seksyen 69, Bandar

Kuala Lumpur, dengan alamat surat -menyurat di No. 74, Jalan

Rotan, Off Jalan Kampung Attap, 50460 Kuala Lumpur,

Wilayah Persekutuan Kuala Lumpur , kepada mana-mana pihak

sementara menunggu pelupu san Guaman Sivil ini;

c. Mahkamah yang Mulia ini membenarkan injunksi ex-parte interim

untuk menghalang Defendan Ketiga (Bintang Iradat (M) Sdn

Bhd) dan/atau ejen-ejennya, pekerja -pekerjanya, wakil -wakilnya

atau penama-penamanya daripada memindahkan, menjual ,

mencaj, mencagar, memasuki mana -mana transaksi dan/atau

melupuskan mana -mana bahagian hartanah yang terletak di

Geran 65301, Lot 1176, Seksyen 69, Bandar Kuala Lumpur,

3
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 dengan alamat surat -menyurat di No. 74, Jalan Rotan, Off

Jalan Kampung Attap, 50460 Ku ala Lumpur, Wilayah

Persekutuan Kuala Lumpur kepada mana-mana pihak,

sementara menunggu pelupusan Guaman Sivil ini ;

d. Mahkamah Yang Mulia ini menetapkan tarikh untuk permohonan

ini didengar secara inter partes pada 05 Julai 2019; dan

e. Kos adalah di dalam kausa.

Bertarikh pada 21 haribulan Jun 2019

………………………………
Penolong Kana n Pendaftar
Mahkamah Tinggi Mala ya
Kuala Lumpur

NOTIS MENGENAI PERINTAH TERTENTU

(A. 45, k. 7 Kaedah-Kaedah Mahkamah 2012)

Jika kamu, TAN SRI DATUK SERI M. KAYVE AS (NO. K/P: 540429-06-

5067), Defendan Pertama, yang dinamakan dalam ini, mengingkari

perintah ini, kamu akan dikenakan proses perlaksanaan untuk

memaksa kamu mematuhi perintah ini.

Jika Defendan Kedua, iaitu KAYVE AS HOLDINGS SDN BHD (NO.

SYARIKAT: 829080-V), dan/atau Defendan Ketiga, iaitu BINTANG

IRADAT (M) SDN BHD (NO. SYARIKAT:510546-X), mengingkari

4
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 perintah ini, kamu, TAN SRI DATUK SERI M. KAYVE AS (NO. K/P:

540429-06-5067) DAN/ ATAU KALI AMAH A/P V ADIV ALOO (NO. K/P:

361006-08-5022) sebagai pengarah-pengarah KAYVEAS HOLDINGS

SDN BHD dan BINTANG IRAD AT (M) SDN BHD DAN/ ATAU ejen-

ejennya, pekerja-pekerjanya, wakil-w akilnya atau penama -

penamanya akan dikenakan proses perlaksanaan untuk memaksa

kamu mematuhi perintah ini.

Bertarikh pada 21 haribulan Jun 2019

………………………………
Penolong Kanan Pendaftar
Mahkamah Tinggi Mala ya
Kuala Lumpur

PERINTAH ini telah difailkan oleh GAVIN J AYAP AL , Peguamcara bagi

Plaintif-plaintif dengan alamat penyampaian di No. 25-5, Blok H, Jalan
PJU 1/37, DATARAN PRIMA, 47301 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul
Ehsan.
Tel : +603 -7887 2173 Faks: +603 -2037 2713
Emel: gavin@gavinjayapal.com
[Ruj.: G AV.277]

5
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 PENTERJEMAHAN
TRANSLATION

S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 IN THE HIGH COURT OF MAL AY A

IN THE FEDERAL TERRITORIES, MALAYSI A

(COMMERCI AL DIVISION)

CIVIL SUIT NO.: WA-22NCC-326-06/2019

BETWEEN

1. DATUK SERI MAG LIN DENNIS D’CRUZ

(NRIC NO.:560227 -10-5057)
2. DATUK SUBRAY AN A/L SELLAPP AN
(NRIC NO.:440402 -08-5641)
3. DATO DR LOG A BAL A MOHAN A/L JAG ANATHAN
(NRIC NO.:660403 -07-5175)
4. DATO ELAYPPEN A/L MUTHUS AMY
(NRIC NO.:631115 -06-5201)
5. DATUK DR K D SIV A KUMAR A/L KRISHNADAS
(NRIC NO.:640607 -10-6967
6. DATUK MOHAN A/ L A KANDAS AMY
(NRIC NO.:600222 -05-5007)
7. DATUK TIONG YAP CHOON
(NRIC NO.:610411 -08-5263)
8. S ATHI AH A/L SUDAK AR AN
(NRIC NO.:760607 -06-5313)
9. DATUK CHIW TI ANG CHAI
(NRIC NO.:570119 -04-5017)
10. DATO’ INDER SINGH A/L BE ANT SINGH
(NRIC NO.:670508 -10-5747)
11. SELV ARAJOO A/L PERMAL
(NRIC NO.:670418 -07-5265)
12. ASECALIN A/L V. FERNANDE Z
(NRIC NO.:640626 -08-6527)
13. J AYASELAN A/L RAJOO
(NRIC NO.:770108 -14-6003) …PLAINTIFFS
(BRINGING THIS CLAIM IN A REPRESENTATIVE CAP ACITY
FOR AND ON BEHALF OF THE FORMER MEMBERS OF myPPP)

AND

1. TAN SRI DATUK SERI M. KAYVE AS

(NRIC NO.:540429 -06-5067)
2. KAYVE AS HOLDINGS SDN BHD
(COMP ANY NO.: 829080-V)
3. BINTANG IRADAT (M) SDN BHD
(COMP ANY NO.:510546 -X)
4. DATUK CHANDRAKUMANAN A/L ARUMUG AM
(NRIC NO.:611111 -08-5215)

1
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 5. DATO’ LY KIM CHEONG
(NRIC NO.:800307 -04-5365)
6. VIJ AYAN A/L SING ARAM
(NRIC NO.:601205 -10-6639)
7. SHANKER KANDASWAMY
(NRIC NO.:781015 -14-5339)
8. KUMARA RAJ A A/ L R. ARUMUG AM
(NRIC NO.:610410 -71-5059)
9. DATUK LAU BENG WEI
(NRIC NO.:660114 -10-6545)
10. DIRECTOR GENERAL OF INSOLVENCY …DEFENDANTS

BEFORE JUDICI AL COMMISSIONER

ONG CHEE KW AN
ON 21 JUNE 2019 IN CHAMBERS

ORDER
(Enclosure 7)

UPON THE APPLICATION of the Plaintiff s abovenamed AND

THIS MATTER BEING SET FOR HEARING ON 21 June 2019 AND

HAVING RE AD the Notice of Application dated 19 June 2019 and all

filed herein AND HAVING HE ARD Mr K. Thavanesan (Mr Gavin

Jayapal, Mr Simon Sabapathy, Ms Santhyaa Venugopal and Ms

Laavanya Selvaraja together with him) where the Plaintiffs undertook to

comply with any orders granted by this Court in relation to damages, in

the event this Court considers thereafter that the Defendants have

incurred any loss, caused by th is order, which the Plaintiffs ought to

pay, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AS FOLLOWS :

a. That this Honourable Court orders a n interim ex-parte injunction

to restrain the 2 n d Defendant (Ka yveas Holdings Sdn Bhd)

and/or its agents, servants, representatives or nominees from

2
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 transferring, selling, charging, pledging, entering into any

transaction and/or disposing of any of the shares held by it in

Bintang Iradat (M) Sdn Bhd to any party pending the disposal of

this Civil Suit;

b. That this Honourable Court orders a n interim ex-parte injunction

to restrain the 1 s t Defendant (Tan Sri M Ka yveas ) and/or his

agents, servants, representatives or nominees from transferring,

selling, charging, pledging, entering into any transaction and/or

disposing any part of that property located at Geran 65301, Lot

1176, Seksyen 69, Bandar Kuala Lumpur, w ith a

correspondence address at No. 74, Jalan Rotan, Off Jalan

Kampung Attap, 50460 Kuala Lumpur, Wila yah Persekutuan

Kuala Lumpur to any party, pending the disposal of this Civil

Suit;

c. That this Honourable Court orders a n interim ex-parte injunction

to restrain the 3 r d Defendant (Bintang Iradat (M) Sdn Bhd)

and/or its agents, servants, representatives or nominees from

transferring, selling, charging, pledging, entering into any

transaction and/or d isposing any part of that property located at

Geran 65301, Lot 1176, Seks yen 69, Bandar Kuala Lumpur,

with a correspondence address at No. 74, Jalan Rotan, Off

Jalan Kampung Attap, 50460 Kuala Lumpur, Wilayah

3
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 Persekutuan Kuala Lumpur to any party, pending the disposal of

this Civil Suit;

d. This Honourable Court set for an inter partes hearing on 05 July

2019; and

e. Costs in the cause.

Dated this 21 s t day of June, 2019

…..………………………………
Senior Assistant Registrar
High Court of Malaya
Kuala Lumpur

NOTICE ON CERTAIN JUDGMENTS

(O. 45, r. 7 Rules of Court 2012)

If you, the w ithin named TAN SRI DATUK SERI M. KAYVE AS (NO.

K/P:540429-06-5067) the 1 s t Defendant, disobe y this order, you w ill

be liable to process of execution for the purpose of compelling you

to obe y the same.

If the 2 n d Defendant, KAYVE AS HOLDINGS SDN BHD (COMP ANY

NO.: 829080-V), and/or 3 r d Defendant, BINTANG IRADAT (M) SDN

BHD (COMP ANY NO.:510546-X), disobe y this order, you, TAN SRI

4
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
 DATUK SERI M. KAYVE AS (NO. K/P: 540429-06-5067) AND/OR

KALI AMAH A/P V ADIV ALOO (NO. K/P: 361006-08-5022) as the

directors of KAYVE AS HOLDINGS SDN BHD and BINTANG IRADAT

(M) SDN BHD AND/OR its agents, employees, representatives

and/or nominees w ill be liable to process of execution for the

purpose of compelling you to obe y the same.

Dated this 21 s t day of June, 2019

…..………………………………
Senior Assistant Registrar
High Court of Malaya
Kuala Lumpur

This ORDER is filed by G AVIN J AYAP AL , Solicitors for the Plaintiffs

with an address for service at No. 25 -5, Block H, Jalan PJU 1/37,
DATARAN PRIMA, 47301 Petaling Jaya, Selangor Darul Ehsan.
Tel : +603 -7887 2173 Fax: +603-2037 2713
Email: gavin@gavinjayapal.com
[Ref.: G AV.277]

5
S/N EV1kuGLyo0ycYQgWvJOEAA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal