Department of Economics Education, Faculty of Economics, Universitas Negeri Semarang, Semarang, Indone-
sia
Abstract
This research was conducted to determine whether learning facilities, teacher teaching skills, and interest
in learning affect the learning outcomes of basic accounting for class X SMK Negeri 1 Surabaya through
learning motivation. This type of research is quantitative research. The study population was class X
students with competency skills in accounting and finance at SMK Negeri 1 Surabaya. The sample used
was 119 students, selected by a simple random sampling technique. Questionnaires and documentation
were used to obtain research data. Data analysis used descriptive statistical analysis techniques and path
analysis. The results showed that there was a direct effect of learning facilities at 4.20%, the teaching
skills of teachers by 19.27%, and interest in learning by 5% on basic accounting learning outcomes. And
there is an indirect effect of learning facilities, teacher teaching skills, and interest in learning on basic
accounting learning outcomes through learning motivation. Based on the results of the study, the role of
learning motivation is not able to mediate perfectly, so it is hoped that further research can examine other
factors that influence learning motivation as a mediating variable. For teachers, it is hoped that they
can be more creative and innovative so that students are motivated, and for students, they are expected
to pay attention to the factors that exist within and outside themselves in achieving learning outcomes
How to Cite
Veronica, Dewi & Listiadi, Agung. (2021). The Role of Learning Motivation to Mediate the
Factors Affecting Basic Accounting Learning Outcomes. Economic Education Analysis Journal,
10(1), 54-64.
Alamat Korespondensi: p-ISSN 2252-6544
FE UNESA e-ISSN 2502-356X
Kampus Ketintang, Jalan Ketintang, Surabaya, 60123
Email: dewiveronica16080304048@mhs.unesa.ac.id
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
55
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
creating and planning learning activities that elements including: (1) showing a person’s
will be applied in the classroom. A learning at- physical activity which is initiated by a change
mosphere with good conditions can be created of energy; (2) it suggests feeling; and (3) arises
by teachers with teaching skills that include as a result of stimulation in the form of goals.
the skills to ask questions, give praise, make Motivation arises because there are motives
variations in teaching, start and end learning, and needs in a person. A motive is an impulse
direct discussions, master classes, and guide for someone to do something, while a need is
small groups and individuals (Mulyasa, 2016). a condition that arises because of an imbalan-
Based on observations made at SMK Negeri 1 ce, incompatibility, or tension that demands a
Surabaya, it is known that accounting teach- decision.
ers already have quite good teaching skills, as Motivation to learn can come from wit-
evidenced by the teacher’s sufficient attention hin oneself (intrinsic) and external circums-
to how much understanding the students have tances (extrinsic). Someone who has an inte-
in their learning. Teachers’ teaching skills can rest will be passionate about learning, so that
contribute 40.7% of the impact on learning interest can be used as the main tool for ge-
outcomes (Suryati, 2016), but this is not in nerating intrinsic motivation (Nuratri, 2016).
line with Budiman’s opinion (2015). Renesius et al., (2014) proved that interest in
Interest is a tendency to pay attention learning has a positive effect on learning mo-
to an activity that is carried out continuously tivation. Kurniawati (2016) said that teachers
accompanied by feelings of pleasure and in- have a role to motivate and provide informa-
terest, and is not forced by others (Slameto, tion to students, so that teacher teaching skills
2015). According to Djamarah & Zain (2014) are important in learning motivation. In addi-
learning is very much influenced by interest, tion, learning facilities that are provided and
because if students have an interest in the te- well cared for in schools can create effective
aching material being studied, they will study learning so that learning motivation will in-
seriously because they are interested and feel crease. Based on this explanation, learning
happy. Meanwhile, teaching materials that are facilities and teacher teaching skills are also
not in demand will be rarely studied, so that thought to have an effect on learning motiva-
the teaching materials are less mastered. Stu- tion. Research conducted by Arsana (2019)
dents at SMK Negeri 1 Surabaya seem to have concluded that teacher teaching skills and
an interest in learning because they often show learning facilities have a positive effect on lear-
curiosity about accounting material. Research ning motivation. The right motivation to learn
conducted by Suryati (2016) concluded that can help students achieve optimal learning
interest in learning affects learning outcomes outcomes. According to Taurina (2015) moti-
by 37%. However, Jamilah and Isnaini’s rese- vation is a very significant factor in achieving
arch (2017) concluded that learning outcomes learning outcomes. Research by Novalinda et
were not influenced by interest in learning. al., (2018) also shows that learning motivation
Students who are motivated to carry out can affect learning outcomes, but this opinion
learning activities with guaranteed continuity contradicts the opinion of Jamilah and Isnaini
and direction, are caused by an effort in them- (2017). According to this explanation and the
selves which is the role of learning motivati- research gap still exists, so researchers are in-
on. A desire to learn, where a person already terested in conducting research to determine
knows and understands what and why stu- the direct and indirect effect of learning faci-
dying it is called learning motivation (Sardi- lities, teacher teaching skills, and learning in-
man, 2012). Mc Donald (in Sardiman, 2012) terest on basic accounting learning outcomes
argues that motivation has 3 (three) important through learning motivation.
56
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
57
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
Standardized
Model Unstandardized Coefficients t Sig.
Coefficients
B Std. Error Beta
(Constant) 9.904 4.029 2.458 .015
Learning Facilities .196 .074 .199 2.672 .009
1
Teacher Teaching Skilss .123 .054 .182 2.299 .023
Learning Interest .575 .105 .475 5.483 .000
Dependent Variable: Learning Motivation
Source: Primary data processed, 2020
From table 2, it is obtained that the R The regression coefficient which is posi-
Square value is 0.495. This value is used to tive in this model proves that the unidirectional
calculate e1. So that the e1 value is obtained relationship with the effect is reinforced by the
of 0.710. The formulations that can be formed significant value of each variable that is smal-
for regression equation 1 are as follows: ler than the alpha value of 0.05. Predictions
Y=p2X1+p2X2+p2X3+e1 of how much influence learning facilities, te-
Y=0.196X1+0.123X2+0.575X3+0.710......(1) acher teaching skills, interest in learning, and
Standardized
Unstandardized Coefficients
Model Coefficients t Sig.
B Std. Error Beta
(Constant) -4.665 6.243 -.747 .456
Learning Facilities .256 .144 .143 2.237 .027
2
Teacher Teaching Skills .433 .083 .353 5.224 .000
Learning Interest .438 .178 .200 2.463 .015
Learning Motivation .588 .141 .324 4.173 .000
Dependent Variable: Learning Outcomes
Source: Primary data processed, 2020
58
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
Model Correlations
Zero-order Partial Part
(Constant)
Learning Facilities .456 .205 .123
2 Teacher Teaching Skills .650 .439 .288
Learning Interest .672 .225 .136
Learning Motivation .692 .364 .230
a. Dependent Variable: Learning Outcomes
Source: Primary data processed, 2020
Model Correlations
Zero-order Partial Part
(Constant)
Learning Facilities .453 .242 .177
1
Teacher Teaching Skills .486 .210 .152
Learning Interest .665 .455 .363
a. Dependent Variable: Learning Motivation
Source: Primary data processed, 2020
motivation to learn on basic accounting lear- 19.27%, 5%, and 13.25% respectivel.
ning outcomes can be seen using this second Likewise, based on table 7, it is found
equation with the following results: that the amount of partial contributions is
Table 4 shows that the R Square values 5.86%, 4.41%, and 20.70% respectively.
is 0.653. This value is used to calculate e2. So
that the e2 value is obtained of 0.589. The The Effect of Learning Facilities on Learn-
regression equation 2 can be formulated as ing Outcomes of Basic Accounting
follows: Based on the regression equation for-
Z=p1X1+p1X2+p1X3+p1Y +e2 med, the learning facility has a positive sign
Z=0.256X1+0.433X2+0.438X3+0.588Y+0.5 on the coefficient value of 0.256. The results
89.........(2) of the hypothesis test ”learning facilities have
A positive regression coefficient value an effect on basic accounting learning out-
means that there is a unidirectional relation- comes” shows a significant amount of 0.027 <
ship whose influence is reinforced by a signifi- 0.05, so H1 is accepted. Thus, if the learning
cant value on each variable that is smaller than facilities are improved, the learning outcomes
the alpha value of 0.05. will be better. In this study, learning facilities
From table 6, it is obtained the amount contributed partially to the learning outcomes
of the partial contribution of each variable of basic accounting by 4.20%.
in the second regression analysis equation by As the theory put forward by Djamarah
squaring the partial correlations value, then & Zain (2014) that the learning facilities pro-
converted into a percentage. From the re- vided are complete and well managed by the
sults of these calculations, it was obtained the school can make it easier for students in lear-
amount of the partial contribution of 4.20%, ning activities because they can be used ac-
59
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
cording to their function and are durable. The learning affected 5% of learning outcomes.
achievement of the management objectives of Slameto (2015) argues that interest greatly in-
the facilities and infrastructure is an effort to fluences learning activities. If students have
improve the quality of teaching. The quality an interest in the teaching materials being stu-
of effective teaching means optimal learning died, they will study seriously. Teaching ma-
outcomes. In line with the results of research terials of interest will be easier to study and
by Rahmayanti & Nurkhin (2019) learning store. Meanwhile, if they do not have interest,
outcomes are influenced by learning facilities they will not study seriously, so that the teach-
by 9.55%. ing materials are not mastered. This is in line
with Suryati’s (2016) research which conclu-
The Effect of Teacher Teaching Skills on des that learning outcomes are positively and
Learning Outcomes of Basic Accounting significantly influenced by interest in learning.
Learning outcomes can be improved
by the application of better teacher teaching The Effect of Learning Motivation on Basic
skills, based on the second regression equati- Accounting Learning Outcomes
on shows the teaching skills of teachers have Learning motivation also has a positi-
a positive regression coefficient of 0.433 and ve regression coefficient value of 0.588. The
the results of the hypothesis test ”teacher te- results of the hypothesis test ”learning moti-
aching skills affect basic accounting learning vation has an effect on basic accounting lear-
outcomes” shows a significant amount of ning outcomes” states that it is significant at
0.000 < 0.05, then H2 statement is accepted. 0.000<0.05, so H4 is accepted. This result
In this study, the teaching skills of teachers means that if the motivation to learn is high,
contributed to the partial impact of learning the learning outcomes will also be high. In this
outcomes of basic accounting by 19.27%. study, learning motivation contributed 13.25%
Teachers need teaching skills that con- partially to affect the learning outcomes of ba-
sist of 8 (eight) types to make the learning pro- sic accounting.
cess effective, innovative, and fun (Mulyasa, Sardiman (2012) defines learning moti-
2016). A professional teacher will be able to vation as a condition that encourages a per-
maximum his role well, because the teacher son to be aware of what will be learned and
is both a director and an actor in creating and understood. The emergence of feelings and
planning learning activities that are applied goals in a person can bring motivation to him.
in the classroom. Teachers who can apply te- The emergence of learning activities that are
aching skills well will be able to help students guaranteed to be sustainable and directed at
achieve optimal learning outcomes. Supported students, because this is caused by learning
by Suryati’s research (2016) which concluded motivation. The right and strong motivation
positively and significantly learning outcomes will improve learning outcomes. This is sup-
are influenced by teacher teaching skills. ported by research by Novalinda et al., (2018)
which concluded that learning outcomes were
The Influence of Learning Interests on Basic influenced by 78.5% by learning motivation
Accounting Learning Outcomes
The learning interest variable has a posi- The Effect of Learning Facilities on Learn-
tive sign on the regression coefficient value of ing Motivation
0.438. The results of the hypothesis test ”inte- From the first equation, the learning
rest in learning affects the learning outcomes facilities regression coefficient indicates a
of basic accounting” shows a significant 0.015 positive value of 0.196. The results of the
< 0.05, so H3 is accepted. Thus, high lear- hypothesis test ”learning facilities affect lear-
ning outcomes can be achieved if there is high ning motivation” produce a significant value
interest in learning. In this study, interest in at 0.009 < 0.05, so that H5 is accepted. This
60
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
means that if learning facilities are improved, appears is a form of extrinsic motivation in
learning motivation will increase. The partial students. In line with Kurniawati’s (2016) re-
contribution of learning facilities to learning search which states that learning motivation
motivation in this study was 5.86%. is influenced by the teaching skills of teachers
Sardiman (2012) states that motivation
arises because there are motives and needs. The Influence of Learning Interests on
Students who are aware of meeting the needs Learning Motivation
of learning activities, they will try to achie- From the first equation it can be seen
ve the desired goals. Learning facilities with that the regression coefficient value of interest
good management can improve the quality of in learning has a positive sign of 0.575 and the
teaching. The availability of learning facilities results of the hypothesis test ”interest in lear-
at schools can help the learning process of stu- ning affects learning motivation” states that
dents, because they will find it easier to meet it is significant at 0.000 < 0.05, then the H7
their learning needs and can generate learning statement is accepted. This means that mo-
motivation in themselves. Students who feel tivation to learn increases because there is an
helped in fulfilling the need to achieve their increase in learning interest. In this study, in-
learning goals with learning facilities are one terest in learning has a partial contribution to
form of their having extrinsic motivation. Ac- learning motivation by 20.70%.
cording to Syah (2018) extrinsic motivation Sardiman (2012) states that motivation
appears marked by someone willing to car- is related to experience and attraction. Some-
ry out an activity because of encouragement one who has no interest in an activity that is
from outside circumstances. According to carried out will not gain meaningful experien-
Kurniawati’s research (2016) which conclu- ce because they carry out these activities wit-
ded positively and significantly learning faci- hout being based on motivation. This means
lities affect learning motivation that if students are interested in the learning
activities they are doing, they will gain expe-
The Effect of Teacher Teaching Skills on rience and be able to bring progress to them-
Learning Motivation selves.
From the first regression equation for- According to Slameto (2015) that inte-
med, it can be seen that the regression coef- rest is always followed by feelings of pleasure
ficient value for teacher teaching skills is po- and there is interest, this means that if you are
sitive as big as 0.123 and the hypothesis test interested in learning you will get valuable ex-
results ”teacher teaching skills affect learning periences, so you can increase your motivation
motivation” shows a significant value of 0.023 to learn. The motivation that appears is one
< 0.05, then the H6 statement is accepted. form of intrinsic motivation in students. Also
These results indicate that if the teacher’s te- supported by Nuratri (2016) in his research
aching skills are good, the learning motivation concluded that interest in learning on learning
of students will be even higher. In this study, motivation has a positive and significant effect
the partial contribution of teacher teaching of 19.29%.
skills to learning motivation was 4.41%.
Like Sardiman’s (2012) theory, it is li- The Effect of Learning Facilities on Basic
kely that students are not motivated to learn Accounting Learning Outcomes through
because they do not feel happy following the Learning Motivation as a Mediation Vari-
learning. A teacher has a role to create fun able
learning so that learning is successful, so that The path coefficient of the learning fa-
teachers need a skill. So that teacher teach- cility shows a value of 0.256 and 0.115 (0.196
ing skills are important to help students fos- × 0.588 = 0.115). Hypothesis test results
ter learning motivation. The motivation that ”learning facilities affect learning outcomes
61
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
62
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
63
Dewi Veronica, & Agung Listiadi / EEAJ 10 (1) (2021) 54-64
Variabel Mediasi. Liabilities Jurnal Pendidi- gajar. Bandung: Sinar Baru Algensindo.
kan Akuntansi, 2(1). Suryati, I. (2016). Pengaruh Keterampilan Menga-
Renesius, S., Mashudi, & Asriati, N. (2014). Pen- jar Guru dan Minat Belajar Terhadap Hasil
garuh Status Sosial Orang Tua dan Minat Belajar Siswa Kelas X IIS pada Mata Pela-
Belajar Terhadap Motivasi Belajar Siswa jaran Ekonomi di SMA Negeri 1 Wonoayu
Kelas X. Jurnal Pendidikan dan Pembelajaran Sidoarjo. Jurnal Pendidikan Ekonomi (JUPE),
Khatulistiwa, 3(3). 4(3).
Reski, A. (2018). Pengaruh Fasilitas Belajar Terha- Syah. M. (2018). Psikologi Pendidikan: Dengan
dap Hasil Belajar Fisika Mahasiswa. Musa- Pendekatan Baru. Bandung: PT Remaja Ros-
mus Journal of Science Education, 1(1). dakarya.
Sardiman. (2012). Interaksi dan Motivasi Belajar Taurina, Z. (2015). Students’ Motivation and
Mengajar. Jakarta: Rajawali Pers. Learning Outcomes: Significant Factors in
Slameto. (2015). Belajar dan Faktor-faktor yang Mem- Internal Study Quality Assurance System.
pengaruhi. Jakarta: Rineka Cipta. International Journal for Cross-Disciplinary
Sudjana, N. (2010). Dasar-dasar Proses Belajar Men- Subjects in Education (IJCDSE), 5(4).
64