ERROR ANALYSIS SMPN1 Kisaran
ERROR ANALYSIS SMPN1 Kisaran
(SMP N 1 KISARAN)
CREATED BY:
RISKA YANI (20052033)
ISMA WAHYUNI SINAGA (20052051)
ROHNI ANZELINA SARAGIH (30053044)
2. Theory dulay
2.1. Strategy taxonomy by dulay
This category highlights the way surface structures are altered. Analyzing errors from this
taxonomy holds much promise for researchers as it is concerned with identifying cognitive
processes that underlie the learners’ reconstruction of the new language. This also gives us
consideration that students’ errors are not the result of laziness or sloppy thinking but are based on
some logics, as the result of the learners’ use of interim principles to produce a new language
(Dulay, et al,1982, pp. 154-162). Those types of errors which belong to surface strategy taxonomy
are (1) omission, (2) addition, (3) misformation, and (4) misordering.
1). Omission
Omission is a loss of word or part of a sentence there should be.
2). Addition
Addition is Adding words of parts of sentence that shouldn't be exist so that
the sentences become garmmatically wrong.
3). Misordering
Misordering is a mistake placement of a morpheme or group of morphome
in sentences.
4). Misformation
Misformation is use of forms, words, mophemes and structure wrong.
1. Liza Ismawati
I have a friend, his name is Melinda Saptri. She lives in Sentang, She is gender is a girl.
My friens has the characteristics of good, cheer up, generous, helpful, likes to joke. Howevers she’s really
likes to gossip, emotional, perfectionist, talkative, lazy. She has one sister, she’s name is Sholeha Prativi.
She has a sharp nose, She’s jealous.
Analysis
The adjective “good” is correctly.
The adjective “cheerr up” is correctly.
The adjective “generous” is correctly.
The adjective “hepful” is correctly.
The adjective “joke” is correctly.
The adjective “gossip” is correctly.
The adjective “emotional” is correctly.
The adjective “perfectionist” is correctly.
The adjective “talkative” is correctly.
The adjective “lazy” is correctly.
The adjective “jealous” is correctly.
2. Fajri
I have a friend his name is Dil.R.Pasaribu. His live is Kisaran, His’s small, nauahty. His hobby is flaying
foodball and his has skin brown.
Analysis
The adjective “small” is correctly placed before the noun “body”.
The adjective of “nauahty” is wrong. The correct answer is “naughty”. Because the adjective
naughty should be like that
3. Satria
I have a friend, hes name is Rendi. He is kindd out
Analysis
The adjective of “kindd” is wrong. The correct answer is “kind”. Because the adjective kind
should be like that.
6. Melinda Saputri
I have a friend, his name is Liza Ismawati. She lives in Sentang, She is gender a girl.
My friend has the characteristics of good, beatiful, care, affectionate, likes to gossip, crazy. However, she
really likes to mischievous, active. She has one sister, she’s name is Dela Safira. She has a tall body,
brown skin, snub nose.
Analysis
The adjective “good” is correctly.
The adjective “beautiful” is correctly.
The adjective “affectionate” is correctly.
The word “gossip”refers to a noun, not an adjective. If you want to make it into an adjective, you
have to add the letter “y” to the end of the word to make the word “gossipy”.
The adjective “crazy” is correctly.
The adjective “mischievous” is correctly.
The word “activt” is wrong. The “t” at the end should be “e”. which then becomes “active”.
The adjective “tall” is correctly placed before the noun “body”.
The adjective “brown” is correctly placed before the noun “skin”.
7. MHD. Satriadi
I have a teacher her name is mem Arfa . she is teacher in SMPN 1 Kisaran, mem Arfa have the
quality pleasure fussy happiness give.
Analysis:
8. Meilinda Saputri
I have a friend, his name is Liza Ismawati, he lives in sentang he is gender a girl.
My friend has the characteristics of good, beautiful, care, affectionate, likes to gossip, crazy
however , she really likes to mischievous , activt, she has one sister, she’s names is dela safira, she
has a tall body , brownskin, snub nose.
Analysis:
“I have a friend, his name is Liza Ismawati, he lives in sentang he is gender a girl.”
- Correction: “I have a friend; her name is Liza Ismawati. She lives in Sentang, and she is a girl.”
This corrects gender pronouns and adds clarity to the sentence structure.
“My friend has the characteristics of good, beautiful, care, affectionate, likes to gossip, crazy
however , she really likes to mischievous , activt, she has one sister, she’s names is dela safira, she
has a tall body , brownskin, snub nose.”
- Correction: “My friend possesses good, beautiful, caring, and affectionate qualities. She likes to
gossip, is a bit crazy, and particularly enjoys mischief. She is active and has one sister named Dela
Safira, who has a tall body, brown skin, and a snub nose.” This corrects adjective usage, improves
sentence structure, and maintains consistency in tense and gender pronouns.
10. Rendi
He has a friend hes name is satria,he is kind but he’s seings and hes don’t like me. He has high
body, hes shap nose, help fol and nest at there of hes food hes realy smart and not arrogant.
Analysis:
"He has a friend hes name is satria,he is kind but he’s seings and hes don’t like me."
- Correction: "He has a friend; his name is Satria. He is kind, but he seems reserved, and he
doesn't like me." This corrects the pronoun, adds a comma for clarity, and improves the sentence
structure.
"He has high body, hes shap nose, help fol and nest at there of hes food hes realy smart and not
arrogant."
- Correction: "He is tall, has a sharp nose, helps others, and is neat with his food. He is really
smart and not arrogant." This corrects adjective usage, adjusts verb tenses, and enhances overall
clarity in the sentence.
14. Al-Riansyah
He have a good attitude,and very god looking
Analysis
He have a good attitude
- Correction : The adjective of “Good” is true
and very god looking
- Correction : The adjective of “god” is wrong. The correct answer is “good”.
15. Almira Azzahra
She have a brown skin,reasonable tall,and she cute,good attitude, I have friend with her since one
year ago
Analysis
She have a brown skin,reasonable tall,and she cute,good attitude
- Correction : -The adjective of “tall” is true.
-The adjective of “cute” is true.
-The adjective of “good” is true.
I have friend with her since one year ago
- Correction : - I and her have been friends for a year
16. Rifqi Nazhif
He a good friend
Analysis
- Correction :
-The adjective of “good” is true.