Program Dinamik Bellman dalam Pengoperasian Waduk

Tabel 1 : Diskretisasi Trajectoire Bellman F(S,t)

2. Objektif : optmal Tajectoire Bellman (tahun Normal ), Nilai Marginal valeur du Stock
Bila G R in 50=0

3. Konstrain Waduk

a) Keseimbangan Masa : St+1= St + A- T

b) Batasan Stok : 0 < St< 70
c) Batasan : 0 < T <30 ..... 0<Pv< 7
d) Batasan harga Listrik : 4<Np< 10
Tentukan Jalur optimal dari sistem dinamik dengan G R initial 50 = 0
Mulai dari Bulan : Des – Nov – Okt – Sep – Ags – Juli – Juni – Mei (D-N-O-S-A-J-J-M)
Apports, A 0 0 10 20 40 60 40 20 20 10 10 0
Turbin
NP 10 9 8 7 5 4 4 4 6 7 8 9
Mois J F M A M J J A S O N D
R max 70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
R min

Langkah-langkah dalam menghitung nilai gain di tiap R dengan menggunakan sistem dinamik.
1. Menghitung besar debit yang keluar dari waduk
Hukum Kekekalan Massa
S(t+1) = St + A t - Tt
Tt = St + A t -S(t+1)
Keterangan:
Tt = Debit yang keluar dari waduk pada bulan ke t
At = Debit yang masuk dari waduk pada bulan ke t
St = Debit waduk pada bulan ke t
S(t+1) = Debit waduk pada bulan ke (t+1)
2. Menentukan nilai PV dengan memanfaatkan grafik PV terhadap Tt yang telah baku.
3. Menghitung keuntungan (gain) pada bulan ke t
Persamaan Gain
 G t = NPt ×PVt
Keterangan:
Gt = Keuntungan pada bulan ke t
NPt = Harga baru pada bulan ke t
PVt = Produksi turbin pada bulan ke t
4. Jumlahkan nilai keuntungan sesuai jalur perhitungan, dan tentukan jalur optimal

Iterasi 1

I. D-N : A=0,NP=9 , R50=O

1.1 Trajec 50-70 St+1=St+A-T ...50=70+0 –T......T=20 ...PV=6 ... G=0 + 54=54
1.2 Trajec 50-60 St+1=St+A-T ...50=60+0 –T......T=10......Pv=4 .....G= 0+36 =36
1.3 Trajec 50-50 St+1=St+A=T 50=50+0=T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=0+0=0

II.D-N-O : A=10 ,NP=8

2.1. Trajec 50-70-70.... ..70=70+10-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=0+54+32=86

Trajec 50-70-60......70=60+10=T T=0 Pv=0 G=0+54+0=54
2.2. Traject50-60-70 ....60=70+10-T ....T=20..Pv=6 G=0+36+48=84
Trajec50-60-60 . 60=60+10-T ....T=10....Pv=4 G=0+36+32=68
Trajec50-60-50 60=50+10-T.....T=0 .....Pv=0 G=0+36+0= 36
2.3. Trajec50-50-70........50=70+10-T.......T=30.....PV=7 G=0+0+56=56
Trajec 50-50-60 . . 50=60+10-T .....T=20...Pv=6....G=0+0+48=48
Trajec50-50-50........50=50+10-T ....T=10 Pv=4 G=0+0+32=32
Trajec50-50-40....... 50=40+10-T.......T=0 ......Pv=0 G=0+0+0=0

Pemilihan Trajec optimal

2.1 Trajec 50-70-70.... 70=70+10-T ...T=10 .....Pv=4 G=0+54+32=86
Traject50-60-70 ....60=70+10-T ....T=20.....Pv=6 G=0+36+48=84
Tarjec50-50-70.......50=70+10-T.......T=30.....PV=7 G=0+0+56=56
2.2 Trajec 50-70-60.......70=60+10=T T=0 Pv=0 G=0+54+0=54
Trajec50-60-60 60=60+10-T ....T=10....Pv=4 G=0+36+32=68
Trajec 50-50-60 .. 50=60+10-T .....T=20...Pv=6....G=0+0+48=48
2.3. Trajec50-60-50 60=50+10-T.....T=0 .....Pv=0 G=0+36+0= 36
Trajec50-50-50......50=50+10-T ....T=10 Pv=4 G=0+0+32=32
2.4. Trajec50-50-40..... 50=40+10-T.......T=0 ......Pv=0 G=0+0+0=0

III. D-N-O-S : A=10, NP=7

3.1 Trajec 50-70-70- ?... G=0+54+32+?=86+?
Trajec 50-70-70-70.... 70=70+10-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=0+54+32+28 =114
Trajec 50-70-70-60.... 70=60+10-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=0+54+32+0=86
3.2. Trajec50-60-60 -? .. G=0+36+32+?=68+?
 Trajec50-60-60 -70 60=70+10-T ....T=20....Pv=6 G=0+36+32+42=110
Trajec 50-60-60 =60 60=60+10-T ....T=10....Pv=4 G=0+36+32+28=96
Trajec50-60-60 =50 60=50+10-T ....T=0....Pv=0 G=0+36+32+0=68
3.3. Trajec50-60-50-? G=0+36+0+?= 36+?
Trajec50-60-50-70 50=70+10-T..... T=30 .....Pv=7 G=0+36+0+49=85
Trajec50-60-50-60 50=60+10-T.......T=20 .....Pv=6 G=0+36+0+42=78
Trajec50-60-50-50 50=50+10-T.......T=10 .....Pv=4 G=0+36+0+28=64
Trajec50-60-50-40 50=40+10-T.......T=0 ........Pv=0 G=0+36+0+0=36
3.4. Trajec50-50-40- ?..... G=0+0+0+?=0+?
Trajec50-50-40-70.....40=70+10-T.......T=30 ......Pv=7 G=0+0+0+49=49
Trajec50-50-40-60.....40=60+10-T.......T=30 ......Pv=7 G=0+0+0+49=49
Trajec50-50-40-50.....40=50+10-T.......T=20 ......Pv= 6 G=0+0+0+42=42
Trajec50-50-40-40.....40=40+10-T.......T=10 ......Pv= 4 G=0+0+0+28=28
Trajec50-50-40-30.....40=30+10-T.......T=0 ......Pv= 0 G=0+0+0+0=0

Pilihan Trajec optimal

3.1 Trajec 50-70-70-70.... 70=70+10-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=0+54+32+28=114
Trajec50-60-60 -70 60=70+10-T ....T=20....Pv=6 G=0+36+32+42=68+42=110
Trajec50-60-50-70 50=70+10-T..... T=30 .....Pv=7 G=0+36+0+49= 36+49=85
Trajec50-50-40=70.....40=70+10-T.......T=30 ......Pv=7 G=0+0+0+49=0+49=49
3.2 Trajec 50-70-70-60.... 70=60+10-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=0+54+32+0=86+0=86
Trajec50-60-60-60 60=60+10-T ....T=10....Pv=4 G=0+36+32+28=96
Trajec50-60-50-60 50=60+10-T.......T=20 .....Pv=6 G=0+36+0+42= 36+42=78
Trajec50-50-40=60.....40=60+10-T.......T=30 ......Pv=7 G=0+0+0+49=0+49=49
3.3. Trajec50-60-60-50 60=50+10-T .... T=0....Pv=0 G=0+36+32+0=68
Trajec50-60-50-50 50=50+10-T.......T=10 .....Pv=4 G=0+36+0+28= 36+28=64
Trajec50-50-40=50.....40=50+10-T.......T=20 ......Pv= 6 G=0+0+0+42=0+42=42
3.4. Trajec50-60-50-40 50=40+10-T.......T=0 ........Pv=0 G=0+36+0+0=36
Trajec50-50-40=40.....40=40+10-T.......T=10 ......Pv= 4 G=0+0+0+28=0+28=28
3.5. Trajec50-50-40-30.....40=30+10-T.......T=0 ......Pv= 0 G=0+0+0+0=0

IV. D-N-O-S-A : A=20, NP=6

4.1 Traject 50-70-70-70-70 70=70+20-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=0+54+32+28+36=150
Traject 50-70-70-70-60 70=60+20-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=0+54+32+28+24=138
Traject 50-70-70-70-50 70=50+20-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=0+54+32+28+0=114
4.2 Traject 50-60-60-60-70 60=70+20-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=0+36+32+28+42=138
Traject 50-60-60-60-60 60=60+20-T ....T=20 Pv=6 G=0+36+32+28+36=132
Traject 50-60-60-60-50 60=50+20-T ....T=10 Pv=4 G=0+36+32+28+24=120
Traject 50-60-60-60-40 60=50+20-T ....T=0 Pv=0 G=0+36+32+28+0=96
4.3 Traject 50-60-60-50-60 50=60+20-T .... T=30 Pv=7 G=0+36+32+0+42=110
 Traject 50-60-60-50-50 50=50+20-T .... T=20 Pv=6 G=0+36+32+0+36=104
Traject 50-60-60-50-40 50=40+20-T .... T=10 Pv=4 G=0+36+32+0+24=92
Traject 50-60-60-50-30 50=30+20-T .... T=0 Pv=0 G=0+36+32+0+0=68
4.4 Traject 50-60-50-40-50 40=50+20-T..... T=30 Pv=7 G=0+36+0+0+42=78
Traject 50-60-50-40-40 40=40+20-T..... T=20 Pv=6 G=0+36+0+0+36=72
Traject 50-60-50-40-30 40=30+20-T..... T=10 Pv=4 G=0+36+0+0+24=60
Traject 50-60-50-40-20 40=20+20-T..... T=0 Pv=0 G=0+36+0+0+0=36
4.5 Traject 50-50-40-30-40 30=40+20-T.......T=30 Pv=7 G=0+0+0+0+42=42
Traject 50-50-40-30-30 30=30+20-T.......T=20 Pv=6 G=0+0+0+0+36=36
Traject 50-50-40-30-20 30=20+20-T.......T=10 Pv=4 G=0+0+0+0+24=24
Traject 50-50-40-30-10 30=10+20-T.......T= 0 Pv=0 G=0+0+0+0+0=0

Pemilihan Traject Optimal

4.1 Traject 50-70-70-70-70 70=70+20-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=0+54+32+28+36=150
Traject 50-60-60-60-70 60=70+20-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=0+36+32+28+42=138
4.2 Traject 50-70-70-70-60 70=60+20-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=0+54+32+28+24=138
Traject 50-60-60-60-60 60=60+20-T ....T=20 Pv=6 G=0+36+32+28+36=132
Traject 50-60-60-50-60 50=60+20-T .... T=30 Pv=7 G=0+36+32+0+42=110
4.3 Traject 50-70-70-70-50 70=50+20-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=0+54+32+28+0=114
Traject 50-60-60-60-50 60=50+20-T ....T=10 Pv=4 G=0+36+32+28+24=120
Traject 50-60-60-50-50 50=50+20-T .... T=20 Pv=6 G=0+36+32+0+36=104
Traject 50-60-50-40-50 40=50+20-T..... T=30 Pv=7 G=0+36+0+0+42=78
4.4 Traject 50-60-60-60-40 60=50+20-T ....T=0 Pv=0 G=0+36+32+28+0=96
Traject 50-60-60-50-40 50=40+20-T .... T=10 Pv=4 G=0+36+32+0+24=92
Traject 50-60-50-40-40 40=40+20-T..... T=20 Pv=6 G=0+36+0+0+36=72
Traject 50-50-40-30-40 30=40+20-T.......T=30 Pv=7 G=0+0+0+0+42=42
4.5 Traject 50-60-60-50-30 50=30+20-T .... T=0 Pv=0 G=0+36+32+0+0=68
Traject 50-60-50-40-30 40=30+20-T..... T=10 Pv=4 G=0+36+0+0+24=60
Traject 50-50-40-30-30 30=30+20-T.......T=20 Pv=6 G=0+0+0+0+36=36
4.6 Traject 50-60-50-40-20 40=20+20-T..... T=0 Pv=0 G=0+36+0+0+0=36
Traject 50-50-40-30-20 30=20+20-T.......T=10 Pv=4 G=0+0+0+0+24=24
4.7 Traject 50-50-40-30-10 30=10+20-T.......T= 0 Pv=0 G=0+0+0+0+0=0

V. D-N-O-S-A-J : A=20, NP=4

5.1 Traject 50-70-70-70-70+? G=0+54+32+28+36+?=150+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70 70=70+20-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=150+24=174
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60 70=60+20-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=150+16=166
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-50 70=50+20-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=150+0=150
5.2 Traject 50-70-70-70-60+? G=0+54+32+28+24+?=138+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-70 60=70+20-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=138+28=166
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-60 60=60+20-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=138+24=162
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50 60=50+20-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=138+16=154
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40 60=40+20-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=138
 5.3 Traject 50-60-60-60-50+? G=0+36+32+28+24+?=120+?
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-60 50=60+20-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=120+28=148
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-50 50=50+20-T ....T=20 Pv=6 G=120+24=144
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-40 50=40+20-T ....T=10 Pv=4 G=120+16=136
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-30 50=30+20-T ....T=0 Pv=0 G=120
5.4 Traject 50-60-60-60-40+? G=0+36+32+28+0+?=96+?
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-50 40=50+20-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=96+28=124
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-40 40=40+20-T ....T=20 Pv=6 G=96+24=120
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-30 40=30+20-T ....T=10 Pv=4 G=96+16=112
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-20 40=20+20-T ....T=0 Pv=0 G=96
5.5 Traject 50-60-60-50-30+? G=0+36+32+0+0+?=68+?
Traject 50-60-60-50-30-40 30=40+20-T .... T=30 Pv=7 G=68+28=96
Traject 50-60-60-50-30-30 30=30+20-T .... T=20 Pv=6 G=68+24=92
Traject 50-60-60-50-30-20 30=20+20-T .... T=10 Pv=4 G=68+16=84
Traject 50-60-60-50-30-10 30=10+20-T .... T=0 Pv=0 G=68
5.6 Traject 50-60-50-40-20+? G=0+36+0+0+0+?=36+?
Traject 50-60-50-40-20-30 20=30+20-T..... T=30 Pv=7 G=36+28=64
Traject 50-60-50-40-20-20 20=20+20-T..... T=20 Pv=6 G=36+24=60
Traject 50-60-50-40-20-10 20=10+20-T..... T=10 Pv=4 G=36+16=52
Traject 50-60-50-40-20-0 20=0+20-T..... T=0 Pv=0 G=36
5.7 Traject 50-50-40-30-10+? G=0+0+0+0+0+?=0+?
Traject 50-50-40-30-10-20 10=20+20-T.......T=30 Pv=7 G=0+28=28
Traject 50-50-40-30-10-10 10=10+20-T.......T=20 Pv=6 G=0+24=24
Traject 50-50-40-30-10-0 10=0+20-T.......T=10 Pv=4 G=0+16=16

Pemilihan Traject Optimal

5.1 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70 70=70+20-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=150+24=174
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-70 60=70+20-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=138+28=166
5.2 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60 70=60+20-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=150+16=166
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-60 60=60+20-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=138+24=162
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-60 50=60+20-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=120+28=148
5.3 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-50 70=50+20-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=150+0=150
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50 60=50+20-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=138+16=154
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-50 50=50+20-T ....T=20 Pv=6 G=120+24=144
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-50 40=50+20-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=96+28=124
5.4 Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40 60=40+20-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=138
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-40 50=40+20-T ....T=10 Pv=4 G=120+16=136
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-40 40=40+20-T ....T=20 Pv=6 G=96+24=120
Traject 50-60-60-50-30-40 30=40+20-T .... T=30 Pv=7 G=68+28=96
5.5 Traject 50-60-60-60-50-30 50=30+20-T ....T=0 Pv=0 G=120
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-30 40=30+20-T ....T=10 Pv=4 G=96+16=112
Traject 50-60-60-50-30-30 30=30+20-T .... T=20 Pv=6 G=68+24=92
Traject 50-60-50-40-20-30 20=30+20-T..... T=30 Pv=7 G=36+28=64
 5.6 Traject 50-60-60-60-40-20 40=20+20-T ....T=0 Pv=0 G=96
Traject 50-60-60-50-30-20 30=20+20-T .... T=10 Pv=4 G=68+16=84
Traject 50-60-50-40-20-20 20=20+20-T..... T=20 Pv=6 G=36+24=60
Traject 50-50-40-30-10-20 10=20+20-T.......T=30 Pv=7 G=0+28=28
5.7 Traject 50-60-60-50-30-10 30=10+20-T .... T=0 Pv=0 G=68
Traject 50-60-50-40-20-10 20=10+20-T..... T=10 Pv=4 G=36+16=52
Traject 50-50-40-30-10-10 10=10+20-T.......T=20 Pv=6 G=0+24=24
5.8 Traject 50-60-50-40-20-0 20=0+20-T..... T=0 Pv=0 G=36
Traject 50-50-40-30-10-0 10=0+20-T.......T=10 Pv=4 G=0+16=16

VI. D-N-O-S-A-J-J : A=40, NP=4

6.1 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-? G=150+24+?=174+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60 70=60+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=150+24+28=174+28 = 202
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50 70=50+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=150+24+24=174+24 = 198
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40 70=40+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=150+24+16=174+16 = 190
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-30 70=30+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=150+24+0= 174+0 = 174
6.2 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-? G=150+16+?=166+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-50 60=50+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=150+16+28=166+28 = 194
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40 60=40+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=150+16+24=166+24 = 190
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-30 60=30+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=150+16+16=166+16 = 182
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-20 60=20+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=150+16+0=166+0 = 166
6.3 Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-? G=138+16+?=154+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-40 50=40+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=138+16+28=154+28 = 182
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-30 50 =30+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=138+16+24=154+24 = 178
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-20 50=20+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=138+16+16=154+16 = 170
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-10 50=10+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=138+16+0=154+0 = 154
6.4 Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-? G=138+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-30 40=30+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=138+28 = 166
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-20 40=20+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=138+24 = 162
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-10 40=10+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=138+16 = 154
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-0 40=0 +40-T ... T=0 Pv=0 G=138+0 = 138
6.5 Traject 50-60-60-60-50-30-? G=120+?
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-30-20 30=20+40-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=120+28 = 148
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-30-10 30=10+40-T ....T=20 Pv=6 G=120+24 = 144
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-30-0 30=0+40-T .... T=10 Pv=4 G=120+16 = 136
6.6 Traject 50-60-60-60-40-20-? G=96+?
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-20-10 20=10+40-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=96+28 =124
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-20-0 20=0+40-T .... T=20 Pv=6 G=96+24 = 120
6.7 Traject 50-60-60-50-30-10-? G=68+?
Traject 50-60-60-50-30-10-0 10=0+40-T .... T=30 Pv=7 G=68+28 =96

Pemilihan Traject Optimal

 6.1 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60
6.2 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-50
6.3 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-40
6.4 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-30
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-30
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-30
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-30
6.5 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-20
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-20
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-20
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-30-20
6.6 Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-10
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-10
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-30-10
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-20-10
6.7 Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-0
Traject 50-60-60-60-50-30-0
Traject 50-60-60-60-40-20-0
Traject 50-60-60-50-30-10-0
70=60+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=150+24+28=174+28 = 202
70=50+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=150+24+24=174+24 = 198
60=50+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=150+16+28=166+28 = 194
70=40+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=150+24+16=174+16 = 190
60=40+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=150+16+24=166+24 = 190
50=40+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=138+16+28=154+28 = 182
70=30+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=150+24+0= 174+0 = 174
60=30+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=150+16+16=166+16 = 182
50 =30+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=138+16+24=154+24 = 178
40=30+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=138+28 = 166
60=20+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=150+16+0=166+0= 166
50=20+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=138+16+16=154+16 = 170
40=20+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=138+24 = 162
30=20+40-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=120+28 = 148
50=10+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=154+0= 154
40=10+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=138+16 = 154
30=10+40-T ....T=20 Pv=6 G=120+24 = 144
20=10+40-T ....T=30 Pv=7 G=96+28 =124
40=0 +40-T ... T=0 Pv=0 G=138+0 = 138
30=0+40-T .... T=10 Pv=4 G=120+16 = 136
20=0+40-T .... T=20 Pv=6 G=96+24 = 120
10=0+40-T .... T=30 Pv=7 G=68+28 =96

VI1. D-N-O-S-A-J-J-M : A=60, NP=4

7.1 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60-? G=150+24+28+?=174+28+? = 202+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60-50 60=50+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=202+28 = 230
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60-40 60=40+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=202+24 = 244
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60-30 60=30+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=202+16 = 218
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60-20 60=20+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=202+0 = 202
7.2 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50-? G=150+24+24+?=174+24+? = 198+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50-40 50=40+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=198+28 =226
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50-30 50=30+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=198+24 =222
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50-20 50=20+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=198+16 =214
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50-10 50=10+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=198+0 =198
7.3 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40-? G=150+24+16+?=174+16+? = 190+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40-30 40=30+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=190+28 = 218
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40-20 40=20+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=190+24 = 214
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40-10 40=10+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=190+16 = 206
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40-0 40=0+40-T ... T=0 Pv=0 G=190+0 = 190
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40-? G=150+16+24=166+24+?= 190+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40-30 40=30+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=190+28 = 218
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40-20 40=20+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=190+24 = 214
 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40-10 40=10+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=190+16 =206
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40-0 40=0+40-T ... T=0 Pv=0 G=190+0 =190
7.4 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-30-? G=150+16+16+?=166+16+?= 182+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-30-20 30=20+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=182+7 = 189
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-30-10 30=10+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=182+24 = 206
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-30-0 30=0+40-T ... T=10 Pv=4 G=182+16 = 198
7.5 Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-20-? G=138+16+16+?=154+16+? = 170+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-20-10 20=10+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=170+28 = 198
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-20-0 20=0+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=170+24 = 194
7.6 Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-10-? G=154+0+?= 154+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-10-0 10=0+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=154+28= 154+28 = 182
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-10-? G=138+16+?= 154+?
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-10-0 10=0+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=154+28 = 182

Pemilihan Traject Optimal

7.1 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60-50
7.2 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60-40
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50-40
7.3 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60-30
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50-30
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40-30
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40-30
7.4 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-60-20
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50-20
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40-20
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40-20
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-30-20
7.5 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-50-10
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40-10
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40-10
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-30-10
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-20-10
7.6 Traject 50-70-70-70-70-70-40-0
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-40-0
Traject 50-70-70-70-70-60-30-0
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-20-0
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-50-10-0
Traject 50-70-70-70-60-40-10-0
60=50+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=202+28 = 230
60=40+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=202+24 = 244
50=40+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=198+28 =226
60=30+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=202+16 = 218
50=30+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=198+24 =222
40=30+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=190+28 = 218
40=30+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=190+28 = 218
60=20+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=202+0 = 202
50=20+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=198+16 =214
40=20+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=190+24 = 214
40=20+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=190+24 = 214
30=20+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=182+7 = 189
50=10+40-T ...T=0 Pv=0 G=198+0 =198
40=10+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=190+16 = 206
40=10+40-T ...T=10 Pv=4 G=190+16 =206
30=10+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=182+24 = 206
20=10+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=170+28 = 198
40=0+40-T ... T=0 Pv=0 G=190+0 = 190
40=0+40-T ... T=0 Pv=0 G=190+0 =190
30=0+40-T ... T=10 Pv=4 G=182+16 = 198
20=0+40-T ...T=20 Pv=6 G=170+24 = 194
10=0+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=154+28 = 182
10=0+40-T ...T=30 Pv=7 G=154+28 = 182