Abstract: This study aims to analyze women oppression and struggle in the novel Moxie, this novel tells
East Rockport High school because sexism and the patriarchy system act as triggers for sexual violence
and sexism in schools. Using Marion Young's iris theory to find out various kinds of oppressions
occurred in novel Moxie and women's resistance using 2 theories of feminism, radical feminism by
Alison M. Jaggar is used to analyze how the patriarchy system triggers sexual coercion and
multicultural feminism. This theory is used to analyze the patriarchy system that triggers sexual
coercion that happens because of race and black skin. The methodology in this research is qualitative
descriptive. This research resulted in women oppression such as sexual harassment, intimidation, and
rape as a form of sexual coercion contained in the novel. This research also shows how women struggle
against oppression that occurs because of the patriarchy system and sexism at school.
Abstrak: Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk menganalisis penindasan dan perjuangan perempuan dalam
novel Moxie, novel ini menceritakan East Rockport Highschool karena seksisme dan sistem patriarki
berperan sebagai pemicu kekerasan seksual dan seksisme di sekolah. Menggunakan teori iris Marion
Young untuk mengetahui berbagai macam penindasan yang terjadi. Perlawanan perempuan pada
novel ini menggunakan 2 teori feminisme yaitu feminisme radikal oleh Alison M. Jaggar digunakan
untuk menganalisis bagaimana sistem patriarki memicu pemaksaan seksual dan feminisme
multikultural digunakan untuk menganalisis sistem patriarki yang memicu pemaksaan seksual yang
terjadi karena ras dan kulit hitam. Metodologi penelitian dalam penelitian ini adalah deskriptif
kualitatif, dimana data yang relevan dikumpulkan dari teks atau kata-kata yang ditemukan dalam novel
Moxie. Penelitian ini menunjukan penindasan terhadap perempuan seperti pelecehan seksual,
intimidasi, dan pemerkosaan sebagai bentuk pemaksaan seksual yang terdapat dalam novel Moxie.
Penelitian ini juga menunjukkan bagaimana perjuangan perempuan melawan penindasan yang terjadi
karena sistem patriarki dan seksisme di sekolah.
In real life, people do not escape 2018). Young (1990) defines oppression as when
oppression. Oppression includes exploitation, people make others less human. It can mean
imperialism, violence, and the use of force, threats, their language, education, and other opportunities
or coercion to abuse or intimidate another person. that might make them less than human in mind and
This behavior can result in a habit and involve an body. According to Kilas (2017), the oppression of
women has been carried out since the days of
Women Oppression And Struggle in the Novel Moxie ….(Cita Hikmah Yanti dan Dini Anggraini) 167
hunting and gathering, more precisely in the phase that women in Indonesia are still stuck in the
of barbarism. In this phase, the concept of domination of men. The struggle of women occurs
ownership has emerged, which is controlled by the as a result of gender inequality in many sectors of
family institution. Men in this phase are the ones society. They are given unequal treatment or
who work more and control the means of discrimination as compared to men.. The struggle
production. Meanwhile, women are only of women is not only found in the real world but
considered as reproductive machines and take care also reflected in literary works. The issue of
of the domestic sphere. In the long term, feminism is found in many modern literary works,
oppression of women has become a common thing which play an important role in determining the
in people's lives and women's as male victims fate of gender equality. It is that women are still
continue to be preserved. There are many reasons struggling to live a normal life under a patriarchy
that give very powerful legitimacy to the unfair system. Women's struggle is the result of women's
treatment of women. These reasons are motivation to achieve women's goals for equality.
indoctrinated through various social institutions Struggle is to make strenuous or violence
and traditions that are ingrained in people's in the face of adversity or opposition (Merriam-
consciousness and are carried out by the Webster, 1828). There are those who believe that
patriarchy. we do not need feminism and that nothing could be
Patriarchy means that men are dominant further from the truth. Women have fought for
over women. According to Bressler (2007), equality and against oppression for centuries, and
patriarchy is a social system that employs men as although some battles have been partially won –
the main central authority figures in a social such as the right to vote and equal access to
organization. Fathers have authority over women, education – women are still disproportionately
children, and property. Implicitly, this system affected by all forms of violence and
institutionalizes male government and privileges discrimination in every aspect of life. The struggle
and demands the subordination of women. of women occurs as a result of gender inequality in
Otherwise, women seem to be considered weak many sectors of society. They are given unequal
creatures who need men to get protection from treatment or discrimination as compared to men.
dangers and uncertainties in this dynamic life Discrimination against women leads to unfair
(Mandrastuty, 2010). According to Yudi and treatment and opportunities for women in society.
Haryadi (2017), discussing the oppression of According to Wollstonecraft (1995), on
women, major cases related to women in the form feminism, she argues that there are social
of sexual violence and identity theft. Women are inequalities between the sexes, in terms of
treated as second-class beings because they are education and experience. This gap is an obstacle
weak and powerless. This discrimination occurs in or barrier in the formation of modern society.
several countries in the world. For example, According to her, without social justice, there
discrimination against women in Indonesia means would be no social life. Feminism theory is a
Women Oppression And Struggle in the Novel Moxie ….(Cita Hikmah Yanti dan Dini Anggraini) 169
Rum's A Woman is No Man” by Salvianny and explanation in the written form of words.
Nurcahyani (2020) which discusses about how Descriptive is: "data collected in the form of
women experience oppression and their actions words, pictures, and not numbers. This is due to
against it which are described by three generations the application of qualitative methods." According
of Arab-American female characters using to Moleong (2017), qualitative research is a
Patrichia Hill Collins' theory of the matrix of research procedure that produces descriptive data
domination and self-definition. Second, “Main in the form of spoken words from the person or
Characters Struggle against Woman Oppression in behavior being studied, such as perceptions,
“Marlina The Murderer In Four Acts” Movie” by motivations, actions, and so forth. The object of
Simanjuntak, Tambunan and Tetty (2021) which this study is the novel "Moxie" (2017) by Jennifer
discusses the struggle of the main character in the Mathieu. The writers focused on the oppression of
Marlina Murderer in Four Acts movie, the purpose women by looking at the characters, dialogue, and
of this study is to find out the oppression narrative in the novel Moxie by Jennifer Mathieu.
experienced by the main character in the struggle After that, the data were be determined or
against oppression and how the main character specialized into the oppression experienced by the
struggles against oppression using Young theory women characters in the novel. The writers also
and the theory of liberal feminism and radical focused on analyzing the struggles of women
feminism. Third , "Structural Oppression in characters against oppression by men in this novel.
Bernardine Evaristo Novel Girl, Women and Other The results of the analysis are combined to obtain
2019" by Asih and Al-Hafizh (2019) which good results and conclusions. The writers collected
discusses the issue of structural oppression against the data by (1) reading the novel "Moxie" by
black women and the struggle against structural Jennifer Mathieu, (2) underlining the data that
oppression in the novel Girl, Women and Other shows the types of oppression that happen in the
using the concept of intersectionality from the novel and the struggles of the women characters
feminist study proposed by Patrichia Hill Collins, against the oppression. The data were in the form
the concept of structural oppression proposed by of word, phrase and sentences, (3) Classifying data
Sally Has Langer and supported by the concept of that relate to the discussions based on the problems
power by Robert Dahl and Michel Foucault. of the study. Meanwhile, in analyzing the data,
Firstly, the writers classified the data that shows
the types of women's oppression that occur in the
2. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY novel Moxie by using the theory of Iris Marion
Young. Secondly, the writers analyzed the data
In this study, the writers used qualitative that shows the resistance of women toward
research methods. Qualitative research can be in oppression in the novel Moxie by using 2 theories:
the form of descriptive. Data was collected in the (1)The theory of radical feminism by Alison
form of words as a descriptive method of Jaggar (2) The Theory of Multicultural Feminism
to other groups. The last is violence related to novel. The conversation is a dialogue
people who suffer or are humiliated because of between Vivian and Claudia, where Claudia
status or class. Moreover, violence against women tells Vivian. When she met Mitchell, a
occurs in three forms: physical, sexual, and male student at East Rockport High School,
psychological. she was sexually harassed in the school
Discussing the oppression of women, it hallway outside the locker room. The
can be concluded that injustice the condition
form of physical sexual harassment Claudiaexp
occurs between women and men. Oppression is
erienced was known as "bumping,"during
carried out by men against women. Oppression
which Claudia was pinned to a wall and
itself comes from the patriarchy system or
Mitchell fondled her breasts. Because of the
patriarchy ideology especially in dominance of
values, expectations, attitudes, and customs. In the
abuse, when Claudia told Vivian about it, she
Women Oppression And Struggle in the Novel Moxie ….(Cita Hikmah Yanti dan Dini Anggraini) 171
For physical violence, the novel refers “Oh, shit, look at what he has on,
‟Claudia mutters. Another one of his
to the following dialogue:
gross shirts.‟ Under his football jersey,
“I told him to stop it. That he was Jason is wearing a white T-shirt with big
hurting me. And he just, like, laughed off, black letters. It reads GREAT LEGS –
you know? He just made me stand there WHEN DO THEY OPEN?(Mathieu,
like that for what felt like forever, just 2017, p. 28)
pawing at me. I could feel his hot breath
on my neck. And it hurts. It hurts so The dialogue is another dialogue
much.‟ . . . „How did you get away?‟ I
between the characters Claudia and Vivian
ask. Claudia closes her eyes. „I didn‟t.
He just stopped, eventually. And he, like, during a football game. Claudia told Vivian to
walked off.‟ Her brown eyes open, and
look at Jason shirt, which had sexual
she looks at me again. „And you know
what was so creepy? While he was comments against women written on it. The
messing with me, he had this look on his
words written on Jason‟s shirt read “GREAT
face. This dead look. Like I could have
been anyone. Or anything.‟ (Mathieu, LEGS – WHEN DO THEY OPEN?” are
2017, p. 189-190
classified by the writer as a form of verbal
beetween Vivian and Claudia after the bump explicit meaning by men against women. The
and grab incident. Mitchell made the bump and sexual comment on Jason shirt means that a
grabbed Claudia so that she would engage in man adores a woman‟s legs solely just so the
sexual activities with him, only for her to woman would engage in sexual.
Women Oppression And Struggle in the Novel Moxie ….(Cita Hikmah Yanti dan Dini Anggraini) 173
& think….”that march madness is just women as objects and desires. To pit students
one more way for certain boys at ERHS
in East Rockport against each other and the
to treat girls like object ? Plus it pits up
girlsagainst one another. It creates flyer itself and remind that what happens in
competition where there should be unity.
schools because of injustice and sexism
It idealizes one type of beauty (white &
thin) over all others. It shame us and will always be monitored. From the writers
humiliates us.It’s sick,
description, the writers classify the indications
gross,and essentially condoned by the sc
ooland Community…”MARCH MADNE above as types of injustice and female beauty
SS IS FUCKED UP. DON’T FORGET
based on skin type and race. The flyer is a
IT,
REMEMBER…. MOXIE IS ALAWYS WA form of struggle carried out by the moxie girl
TCHING”.(Mathieu, 2017,p. 249-25)
to fight injustice because of the difference
“ Marisela posts that she’s tired of boys between white and black people. The form of
at east rockport acting like assholes and
struggle shown by the flyer is by threatening
treating girls like property. People agree
with her but some boys start posting that the male students at East Rockport
she’s accusing all boys of being jerks
Highschool that the moxie girls will fight and
and huge debate follows. Kiera posts a
picture of Wonder Woman and a quote always watch his actions.
by a woman named Angela Davis. …“
The dialogue shows the narration that
When on commits one self to the
struggle, its must be for a life Marisela posted the behavior and attitudes of
time.”…..”I look her up and read about
boys on social media and in the post, according
how angela davis was a black feminist
who was imprisoned for fighting for her to the writers point of view, Marisela invites
beliefs. It makes a walkout look pretty
her online friends to be vigilant and fight
minor in comparison, to be
honest”.(Mathieu, 2017, p. 295) together against boys at East Rockport
Highschool and Kiera posted a Wonder
The conversation is confirmed by
Woman picture of Angela Davis' quote saying
words in a flyer that unfold anonymously at
that fighting is a lifelong struggle and Angela
East Rockport excessive school. Even though
Davis is a black feminist. From the writers
created anonymously, it's far from clear to the
description, the writers classifies the
writers that the flyer was made by means of a
indications above as types of injustice that
female. The flyer contains threats to schools
occur because of male students and harassment
and boys at East Rockport High School and the
of female students who are only considered
flyer shows that someone who is tired of being
property by male students and injustice
silent and silent sees the sexism that occurs in
because of skin type. The words in their posts
schools and differences in skin types and
show that women must not be silent because of
always treats women as schools and
this injustice, Women must join forces to fight
differences in skin types and always treats
Women Oppression And Struggle in the Novel Moxie ….(Cita Hikmah Yanti dan Dini Anggraini) 175
heard in class. By drawing a star and love in students to join in the fight against injustice
the hand, it means that the woman who draws caused by the patriarchy system and invites
the star and love in the hand is a woman who them to draw stars and love on their hands
participates in fighting and fighting the at school before October 5th. From the
injustices that occur. writers description, the writers classify the
The dialogue shows the phrase in a indications above as a form of struggle against
flayer distributed anonymously at East injustice that occurs and opinions that are not
Rockport High School. Although created heard in class. By drawing a star and love in
anonymously, it is clear to the writers that the the hand, it means that the woman who draws
flyer was made by a girl. The flyer contains an the star and love in the hand is a woman who
invitation to students to be aware of the unfair participates in fighting and fighting the
dress code for female students and invites injustices that occur. The naration above also
other female students to wear bathrobes on show that the struggle of women against
Tuesdays when going to school.Flayer points injustice has become a feminist and says that a
out that his next course of action is to protest feminist is the worst.
dress code checks being carried out on girls. As a feminist, women must be able to
From the writers description, the writers support each other to get justice in society and
classifies these indications as a type of in the school environment. From the writers
injustice that occurs to female students because description, the writers classify the indications
the dress code only applies to female students. above as a form of women's struggle to
The words in the pamphlet show the form of become a feminist by fighting the injustices
the moxie girls struggle against the dress code that occur because of male students and
and the invitation to wear a bathrobe and on injustice for female students.
Tuesday all the moxie girls wear robes to fight Based on the dialogue of the data that
the injustice of clothing that only applies to the writers obtained above, things that happen
women. to women are due to the patriarchy system,
The flyer shows the form of struggle racism and sexuality. Where women are
carried out by the moxie girl by means of an considered inferior to men. Women are entitled
invitation to fight the injustices that occur at to their rights and have equal opportunities
East Rockport High School which always puts regardless of gender differences. Men
boys first and invites other students to realize shouldn't treat women the way they want. In
the injustices that occur. The flyer shows that addition, men should not force women to do
Moxie next struggle is to get other female something that women do not like to do. To
Women Oppression And Struggle in the Novel Moxie ….(Cita Hikmah Yanti dan Dini Anggraini) 177
occurs because of the patriarchy system in Moleong, L. J. (2017). Metode Penelitian
Kualitatif. PT. Remaja Rosdakarya
schools and sexism.
Offset.
Salvianny, F. N. and Nurcahyani, E. (2020).
„Women‟s resistance towards
oppression in etaf rum ‟ s a woman is
REFERENCES no man‟. Okara: Jurnal Bahasa dan
Sastra 14(4), pp. 239–254.
Simanjuntak, T. & T. (2021). Main
Alison M, J. (1983). Feminist politics and character‟s struggle againsts woman
human nature. Row Man & Allanheld oppression in “marlina the murderer in
Publisher. four acts” movie, Linguistica 10(01),
Asih, B. D. and Al-hafizh, M. (2019). pp. 418–427.
„Structural Oppression in Bernardine Wallstonecraft, M. (1995). A Vindication of
Evaristo ‟ s Novel Girl , Women and the rights of men,in a letter to the right
Other ( 2019 )‟. E-Journal of English honourable Edmund Burke. Cambridge
Language & Literature 10 (4), pp 96- University Press.
110
Webster, M. (1828). Struggle definition
Bressler, C. E. (2007). Literary criticism: An & meaning.Available at :https://www.m
introduction to theory and practice. 4th erriam-webster.com/dictionary/struggle.
Edition. Person Education. [ Accessed 05 August 2022 ]
Collins, P. H. (2000). Black feminist thought.
Second Edition. Routledge Classics Young, I. M. (1990). Justice and politics of
difference. Princeton University Press.
Louis N, & D. (2018). „Discrimination and Yudi, P. & H. (2017). „Kekerasan terhadap
Oppression of Women: A social work tokoh perempuan dalam novel seperti
exploration in zimbahwe‟, Sociology dendam rindu harus dibayar tuntas dan
and Criminology 6(2), pp. 1–5 lelaki harimau karya eka kurniawan‟,
Mandrastuty, R. (2010). Novel Tarian Bumi Seloka, 6(2), pp. 152–160.
Karya Oka Rusmini: Kajian Feminisme.
Sebelas Maret University, Surakarta
Indonesia.
Mathieu, J. (2017). Moxie. Roaring Book.