Anda di halaman 1dari 139

DETAIL DESAIN

PLTMH PATAMUAN
KABUPATEN
PASAMAN

2024
PENDAHULUAN

Pembangkit Listrik Tenaga Mikro Hidro (PLTMH) merupakan teknologi yang


memanfaatkan aliran Sungai sebagai tenaga untuk memutar turbin dan generator
sehingga menghasilkan energi Listrik kurang dari 100 kilowatt, sebagai tenaga
penggeraknya seperti ; saluran irigasi, Sungai atau air terjun alam dengan cara
memanfaatkan tinggi terjunan (head) dan jumlah debit air. Mikrohidro merupakan
sebuah istilah yang terdiri kata mikro yang berarti kecil dan hidro yang berarti air.
Secara teknis, mikrohidro memiliki tiga komponen utama yaitu air ( sebagai sumber
energi ), turbin dan generator.

Program pengembangan PLTMH merupakan salah satu perioritas


Pembangunan yang dilaksanakan pemerintah yang diarahkan kepada peningkatan
kondisi ekonomi dan sosial Masyarakat pedesaan. Dalam hal ini penyediaan tenaga
Listrik di pedesaan merupakan salah satu sarana yang akan mempercepat Upaya
peningkatan kesejahteraan bangsa secara keseluruhan.

Oleh sebab itu perlu diupayakan pengembangan dan pemanfaatan sumber


energi baru dan terbarukan dengan tetap berpegang pada prinsip menguntungkan
secara ekonomis, layak secara teknis, diterima secara sosial budaya dan tidak
menyebabkan pengrusakan lingkungan.

1
1. LOKASI PEKERJAAN PLTMH
Kabupaten Pasaman terletak di bagian utara wilayah Provinsi Sumatera Barat
dengan luas 4.447,63 Km² atau setara dengan 10,44% luas Provinsi Sumatera Barat.
Secara geografis Kabupaten Pasaman dilintasi oleh garis khatulistiwa dan berada
pada 0-55’ LU s/d 0-06’ LS dan 99-45’ s/d 100-21’ BT.

Lokasi Pekerjaan PLTMH PATAMUAN

2. DESAIN PEKERJAAN SIPIL PLTMH

Pekerjaan sipil yang berhubungan dengan konstruksi Pembangkit Listrik


Tenaga Mikrohidro antara lain : Bendung – Intake, Sandtrap, Waterway, Headpond,
Penstock, Tailrace dan Power house.

Dalam proses konstruksi, harus ada perencanaan yang matang guna


memenuhi standar keamanan, keselamatan dan kenyamanan pada bangunan.

Untuk PLTMH PATAMUAN, bagian konstruksi yang akan dilakukan cross cek
adalah Konstuksi Waterway, Dinding Penahan Tanah dan Stabilitas Lereng.

2
1. STABILITAS LERENG WATERWAY PLTMH PATAMUAN
 Lokasi lereng waterway

Gambar Lokasi Lereng Waterway

- Kondisi lereng waterway yang akan di Analisa stabilitas nya berada


pada Sta. 0 + 000 dikarenakan kondisi nya ekstrim ( tinggi lereng =
± 21 meter ) dari beberapa Sta. waterway.
 Hasil Analisa stabilitas lereng waterway dengan program GEO 5

A. Kondisi Eksisting

- Pada kondisi eksisting ( masih tanah asli ) nilai Safety Faktor/ SF didapat 0,74 <
1,5 artinya pada kondisi ini stabilitas lereng waterway tidak stabil.

3
B. Kondisi Lereng memakai perkuatan Anchor Bolt atau Spray Concrete

- Pada kondisi ini, nilai Safety Faktor/ SF didapat 1,64 > 1,5 artinya pada kondisi
lereng setelah diperkuat dengan Anchor Bolt atau Spray Concrete Stabilitas nya
menjadi bertambah, sehingga stabilitas lereng nya menjadi stabil.

 Analisa selengkapnya dari Stabilitas Lereng dengan program GEO 5

Slope stability analysis

Input data

Project

Date : 15/01/2024

Settings
Standard - safety factors (23)

Stability analysis

Earthquake analysis : Standard


Verification Safety factors (ASD)
methodology :

Safety factors
Seismic design situation
Safety factor : SFs = 1.50 [–]

Interface

4
Coordinates of interface points [m]
No. Interface location
x z x z x z
1 16.31 3.79 16.81 5.81 17.31 7.81
17.56 8.80 18.56 8.80 18.81 9.81

19.31 11.81 19.80 13.81 20.81 13.80

21.31 15.81 21.81 17.81 22.06 18.80

23.06 18.80 23.31 19.81 23.81 21.81

24.00 22.58 24.68 23.20 25.34 23.80

27.12 25.45 27.45 25.80 27.79 26.18

28.71 27.81
2 27.45 25.80 28.69 25.80 28.71 25.80

3 25.34 23.80 28.71 23.83

4 23.81 21.81 28.71 21.81

5 23.31 19.81 28.71 19.81

6 21.81 17.81 28.71 17.81

7 21.31 15.81 28.71 15.89

5
Coordinates of interface points [m]
No. Interface location
x z x z x z
8 20.81 13.80 28.71 13.81

9 19.31 11.81 28.71 11.83

10 18.81 9.81 28.71 9.81

11 17.31 7.81 28.71 7.81

12 16.81 5.81 28.71 5.81

13 7.13 1.80 8.94 3.80 12.61 3.80


12.91 3.80 12.91 2.50 13.21 2.30

13.71 2.30 14.21 2.30 14.51 2.50

14.51 3.80 14.81 3.80 16.31 3.79

28.71 3.86

14 12.51 1.81 12.51 1.92 12.51 2.30


12.61 3.80

15 14.81 3.80 14.91 2.30 14.91 1.92


14.91 1.81

6
Coordinates of interface points [m]
No. Interface location
x z x z x z

16 12.51 1.92 12.91 1.92 12.91 2.10


13.71 2.10 14.51 2.10 14.51 1.92

14.91 1.92

17 -0.15 1.79 7.13 1.80 12.51 1.81


14.91 1.81 28.71 1.81

18 -0.15 -0.19 28.71 -0.19

Soil parameters - effective stress state

ef cef 
No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3]

1 Pasir Lepas 32.50 23.00 15.10

Soil parameters - uplift

sat s n
No. Name Pattern
[kN/m3] [kN/m3] [–]

1 Pasir Lepas 15.10

7
Soil parameters

Pasir Lepas
Unit weight :  = 15.10 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 32.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Saturated unit weight : sa = 15.10 kN/m3
t

Rigid bodies


No. Name Sample
[kN/m3]

1 Batukali 22.00

Assigning and surfaces

Coordinates of surface points [m] Assigned


No. Surface position
x z x z soil
1 28.69 25.80 28.71 25.80
Pasir Lepas
28.71 27.81 27.79 26.18

27.45 25.80

2 28.71 23.83 28.71 25.80


Pasir Lepas
28.69 25.80 27.45 25.80

27.12 25.45 25.34 23.80

3 28.71 21.81 28.71 23.83


Pasir Lepas
25.34 23.80 24.68 23.20

24.00 22.58 23.81 21.81

8
Coordinates of surface points [m] Assigned
No. Surface position
x z x z soil

4 28.71 19.81 28.71 21.81


Pasir Lepas
23.81 21.81 23.31 19.81

5 28.71 17.81 28.71 19.81


Pasir Lepas
23.31 19.81 23.06 18.80

22.06 18.80 21.81 17.81

6 28.71 15.89 28.71 17.81


Pasir Lepas
21.81 17.81 21.31 15.81

7 28.71 13.81 28.71 15.89


Pasir Lepas
21.31 15.81 20.81 13.80

9
Coordinates of surface points [m] Assigned
No. Surface position
x z x z soil
8 28.71 11.83 28.71 13.81
Pasir Lepas
20.81 13.80 19.80 13.81

19.31 11.81

9 28.71 9.81 28.71 11.83


Pasir Lepas
19.31 11.81 18.81 9.81

10 28.71 7.81 28.71 9.81


Pasir Lepas
18.81 9.81 18.56 8.80

17.56 8.80 17.31 7.81

11 28.71 5.81 28.71 7.81


Pasir Lepas
17.31 7.81 16.81 5.81

12 28.71 3.86 28.71 5.81


Pasir Lepas
16.81 5.81 16.31 3.79

10
Coordinates of surface points [m] Assigned
No. Surface position
x z x z soil
13 12.91 1.92 12.91 2.10
Batukali
13.71 2.10 14.51 2.10

14.51 1.92 14.91 1.92

14.91 2.30 14.81 3.80

14.51 3.80 14.51 2.50

14.21 2.30 13.71 2.30

13.21 2.30 12.91 2.50

12.91 3.80 12.61 3.80

12.51 2.30 12.51 1.92

14 28.71 1.81 28.71 3.86


Pasir Lepas
16.31 3.79 14.81 3.80

14.91 2.30 14.91 1.92

14.91 1.81

15 14.91 1.81 14.91 1.92


Pasir Lepas
14.51 1.92 14.51 2.10

13.71 2.10 12.91 2.10

12.91 1.92 12.51 1.92

12.51 1.81

16 12.51 1.81 12.51 1.92


Pasir Lepas
12.51 2.30 12.61 3.80

8.94 3.80 7.13 1.80

17 28.71 -0.19 28.71 1.81


Pasir Lepas
14.91 1.81 12.51 1.81

7.13 1.80 -0.15 1.79

-0.15 -0.19

11
Coordinates of surface points [m] Assigned
No. Surface position
x z x z soil

18 -0.15 -0.19 -0.15 -5.19


Pasir Lepas
28.71 -5.19 28.71 -0.19

Water

Water type : No water

Tensile crack

Tensile crack not input.

Earthquake

Horizontal seismic coefficient : Kh = 0.3570


Vertical seismic coefficient : Kv = 0.1780

Settings of the stage of construction

Design situation : seismic

Results (Stage of construction 1)

Analysis 3
Circular slip surface

12
Slip surface parameters
x= -1.08 [m] 1 = 36.00 [°]
Center : Angles :
z= 27.74 [m] 2 = 89.44 [°]
Radius : R= 29.59 [m]
The slip surface after optimization.

Slope stability verification (Bishop)


Sum of active forces : Fa = 993.06 kN/m
Sum of passive forces : Fp = 735.34 kN/m

Sliding moment : Ma = 29384.61 kNm/m


Resisting moment : Mp = 21758.58 kNm/m

Factor of safety = 0.74 < 1.50


Slope stability NOT ACCEPTABLE
Optimization of circular slip surface (Bishop)
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
1 -1.12 27.78 29.64 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
2 -1.12 27.78 29.64 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
3 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
4 -15.96 42.49 46.95 1.53 ACCEPTABLE
5 -36.17 57.78 71.44 2.17 ACCEPTABLE
6 -19.75 40.97 48.01 5.96 ACCEPTABLE
7 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
8 -9.17 35.69 38.57 1.05 NOT ACCEPTABLE
9 -19.55 42.71 50.42 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
10 -6.32 29.18 31.61 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
11 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
12 -15.55 36.36 44.95 0.94 NOT ACCEPTABLE
13 -32.16 46.08 63.46 1.19 NOT ACCEPTABLE
14 -4.50 26.82 30.58 1.00 NOT ACCEPTABLE
15 -17.10 33.78 44.10 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
16 -0.51 27.56 29.02 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
17 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
18 -4.19 30.74 32.86 0.85 NOT ACCEPTABLE
19 -7.83 32.88 36.75 0.91 NOT ACCEPTABLE
20 0.35 26.12 26.50 0.89 NOT ACCEPTABLE
21 -3.22 28.16 30.19 0.97 NOT ACCEPTABLE
22 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
23 -3.12 29.69 31.71 0.81 NOT ACCEPTABLE
24 -5.43 30.98 34.12 0.83 NOT ACCEPTABLE
25 -0.23 26.74 27.64 0.83 NOT ACCEPTABLE
26 -2.52 28.01 30.00 0.86 NOT ACCEPTABLE
27 -120.65 89.38 161.50 1.39 NOT ACCEPTABLE

13
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
28 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
29 -2.46 29.03 31.01 0.78 NOT ACCEPTABLE
30 -3.95 29.84 32.54 0.80 NOT ACCEPTABLE
31 -0.59 27.12 28.38 0.79 NOT ACCEPTABLE
32 -2.08 27.94 29.91 0.81 NOT ACCEPTABLE
33 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
34 -2.04 28.61 30.57 0.77 NOT ACCEPTABLE
35 -3.00 29.13 31.56 0.77 NOT ACCEPTABLE
36 -0.81 27.36 28.84 0.78 NOT ACCEPTABLE
37 -1.78 27.88 29.83 0.78 NOT ACCEPTABLE
38 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
39 -1.76 28.33 30.28 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
40 -2.39 28.67 30.93 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
41 -0.96 27.51 29.15 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
42 -1.59 27.85 29.79 0.77 NOT ACCEPTABLE
43 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
44 -1.58 28.15 30.10 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
45 -2.00 28.37 30.52 5.54 ACCEPTABLE
46 -1.05 27.62 29.35 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
47 -1.47 27.84 29.78 5.56 ACCEPTABLE
48 -0.30 27.49 28.81 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
49 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
50 -1.46 28.03 29.97 5.04 ACCEPTABLE
51 -1.73 28.18 30.25 5.46 ACCEPTABLE
52 -1.12 27.69 29.49 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
53 -1.39 27.83 29.77 5.08 ACCEPTABLE
54 -0.27 27.25 28.64 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
55 -0.60 27.59 29.11 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
56 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
57 0.09 27.47 28.42 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
58 -1.38 27.96 29.89 5.01 ACCEPTABLE
59 -1.56 28.05 30.08 5.02 ACCEPTABLE
60 -1.16 27.73 29.58 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
61 -1.34 27.83 29.77 5.03 ACCEPTABLE
62 -0.59 27.43 29.01 5.32 ACCEPTABLE
63 -0.80 27.66 29.31 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
64 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
65 -0.31 27.57 28.82 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
66 -1.32 27.90 29.84 4.97 ACCEPTABLE
67 -1.45 27.97 29.96 5.38 ACCEPTABLE
68 -0.56 27.51 29.07 4.89 ACCEPTABLE
69 -0.18 27.43 28.63 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
70 -1.18 27.76 29.64 4.98 ACCEPTABLE
71 -0.07 27.38 28.53 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
72 -1.31 27.82 29.76 5.39 ACCEPTABLE
73 -0.58 27.42 29.03 4.90 ACCEPTABLE

14
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
74 -0.42 27.37 28.88 4.89 ACCEPTABLE
75 -0.80 27.56 29.25 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
76 -0.94 27.70 29.45 5.31 ACCEPTABLE
77 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
78 -0.58 27.64 29.09 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
79 -1.29 27.87 29.80 4.97 ACCEPTABLE
80 -1.37 27.91 29.88 5.36 ACCEPTABLE
81 -0.70 27.56 29.21 4.89 ACCEPTABLE
82 -0.77 27.60 29.28 4.90 ACCEPTABLE
83 -0.49 27.55 28.97 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
84 -1.20 27.78 29.68 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
85 -0.42 27.51 28.89 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
86 -1.28 27.82 29.76 4.97 ACCEPTABLE
87 -0.76 27.54 29.23 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
88 -0.61 27.48 29.09 5.27 ACCEPTABLE
89 -0.69 27.52 29.16 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
90 -0.94 27.65 29.42 4.93 ACCEPTABLE
91 -1.03 27.74 29.54 5.32 ACCEPTABLE
92 -0.25 27.47 28.76 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
93 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
94 -0.75 27.68 29.26 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
95 -0.43 27.49 28.92 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
96 -1.27 27.85 29.78 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
97 -0.48 27.54 28.99 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
98 -1.32 27.87 29.83 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
99 -0.36 27.48 28.87 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
100 -0.87 27.64 29.38 5.28 ACCEPTABLE
101 -0.92 27.67 29.43 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
102 -0.70 27.63 29.19 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
103 -1.22 27.79 29.71 4.95 ACCEPTABLE
104 -0.65 27.60 29.14 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
105 -1.27 27.82 29.76 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
106 -0.88 27.62 29.37 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
107 -0.82 27.59 29.31 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
108 -0.87 27.62 29.36 5.30 ACCEPTABLE
109 -1.04 27.71 29.53 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
110 -0.48 27.51 28.97 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
111 -1.09 27.76 29.60 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
112 -0.53 27.56 29.04 4.93 ACCEPTABLE
113 -1.10 27.76 29.61 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
114 -0.87 27.71 29.38 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
115 -0.66 27.58 29.16 5.31 ACCEPTABLE
116 -1.25 27.83 29.76 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
117 -0.69 27.61 29.20 5.31 ACCEPTABLE
118 -1.29 27.85 29.80 4.95 ACCEPTABLE
119 -0.61 27.57 29.12 5.30 ACCEPTABLE

15
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
120 -0.98 27.69 29.50 5.28 ACCEPTABLE
121 -0.57 27.55 29.08 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
122 -1.02 27.71 29.53 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
123 -0.84 27.68 29.34 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
124 -1.22 27.80 29.72 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
125 -0.81 27.66 29.31 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
126 -1.26 27.82 29.76 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
127 -0.96 27.67 29.46 5.30 ACCEPTABLE
128 -0.58 27.54 29.08 5.30 ACCEPTABLE
129 -0.96 27.67 29.46 5.30 ACCEPTABLE
130 -0.55 27.53 29.05 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
131 -0.99 27.68 29.49 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
132 -1.11 27.74 29.61 4.93 ACCEPTABLE
133 -0.69 27.60 29.19 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
134 -1.13 27.77 29.65 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
135 -0.72 27.63 29.23 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
136 -15.96 42.49 46.95 1.53 ACCEPTABLE
137 -13.12 60.88 53.39 62.85 ACCEPTABLE
138 -0.42 27.66 28.93 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
139 -42.71 62.55 79.40 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
140 -24.78 44.86 54.27 5.18 ACCEPTABLE
141 -0.42 27.66 28.93 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
142 -10.38 36.44 39.91 1.17 NOT ACCEPTABLE
143 -22.85 44.83 54.22 1.40 NOT ACCEPTABLE
144 -7.90 30.08 33.32 2.55 ACCEPTABLE
145 -0.42 27.66 28.93 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
146 -17.17 37.21 46.71 0.96 NOT ACCEPTABLE
147 -36.59 48.52 68.42 1.24 NOT ACCEPTABLE
148 -5.26 27.16 31.37 1.01 NOT ACCEPTABLE
149 -19.48 34.96 46.68 1.42 NOT ACCEPTABLE
150 -1.27 27.96 29.79 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
151 -16.87 37.09 46.39 0.96 NOT ACCEPTABLE
152 -35.59 48.03 67.32 1.23 NOT ACCEPTABLE
153 -5.17 27.16 31.28 1.01 NOT ACCEPTABLE
154 -19.02 34.78 46.18 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
155 -1.14 27.91 29.65 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
156 -1.26 27.95 29.77 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
157 -5.08 31.24 33.80 0.86 NOT ACCEPTABLE
158 -9.24 33.68 38.26 0.93 NOT ACCEPTABLE
159 -0.28 26.46 27.14 0.90 NOT ACCEPTABLE
160 -4.27 28.73 31.30 0.99 NOT ACCEPTABLE
161 -1.26 27.95 29.77 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
162 -4.02 30.16 32.64 0.82 NOT ACCEPTABLE
163 -6.65 31.64 35.41 0.85 NOT ACCEPTABLE
164 -0.96 27.12 28.38 0.84 NOT ACCEPTABLE
165 -3.54 28.55 31.06 0.87 NOT ACCEPTABLE

16
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
166 -1.26 27.95 29.77 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
167 -3.36 29.50 31.94 0.79 NOT ACCEPTABLE
168 -5.06 30.42 33.70 0.81 NOT ACCEPTABLE
169 -1.39 27.53 29.18 0.80 NOT ACCEPTABLE
170 -3.07 28.45 30.92 0.82 NOT ACCEPTABLE
171 -1.26 27.95 29.77 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
172 -2.94 29.07 31.50 0.77 NOT ACCEPTABLE
173 -4.05 29.66 32.63 0.78 NOT ACCEPTABLE
174 -1.65 27.78 29.69 0.78 NOT ACCEPTABLE
175 -2.75 28.37 30.82 0.79 NOT ACCEPTABLE
176 -0.09 27.54 28.60 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
177 -1.26 27.95 29.77 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
178 -2.67 28.79 31.21 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
179 -3.40 29.18 31.96 0.77 NOT ACCEPTABLE
180 -1.82 27.94 30.02 0.77 NOT ACCEPTABLE
181 -2.54 28.33 30.76 5.40 ACCEPTABLE
182 0.05 26.96 28.14 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
183 -0.72 27.76 29.23 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
184 -1.26 27.95 29.77 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
185 -2.50 28.61 31.03 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
186 -2.98 28.86 31.52 5.24 ACCEPTABLE
187 -1.93 28.05 30.24 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
188 -2.41 28.30 30.73 5.67 ACCEPTABLE
189 -0.65 27.38 28.94 5.05 ACCEPTABLE
190 -1.17 27.91 29.68 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
191 -1.26 27.95 29.77 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
192 0.55 27.50 27.96 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
193 -2.38 28.49 30.91 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
194 -2.70 28.66 31.23 5.17 ACCEPTABLE
195 -0.62 27.57 29.13 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
196 -2.01 28.12 30.39 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
197 -2.33 28.29 30.72 5.58 ACCEPTABLE
198 -0.29 27.23 28.65 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
199 -1.13 27.67 29.50 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
200 -1.48 28.02 30.00 5.01 ACCEPTABLE
201 -1.26 27.95 29.77 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
202 -0.06 27.66 28.57 0.76 NOT ACCEPTABLE
203 -2.30 28.41 30.83 5.08 ACCEPTABLE
204 -2.51 28.52 31.04 5.11 ACCEPTABLE
205 -0.93 27.70 29.44 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
206 -1.11 27.79 29.62 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
207 0.08 27.51 28.43 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
208 -1.59 28.06 30.11 5.40 ACCEPTABLE
209 -1.78 28.16 30.30 5.04 ACCEPTABLE
210 -0.44 27.46 28.95 5.26 ACCEPTABLE
211 -1.34 27.81 29.76 5.41 ACCEPTABLE

17
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
212 -1.53 27.91 29.95 5.05 ACCEPTABLE
213 -0.77 27.51 29.18 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
214 -1.01 27.76 29.52 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
215 -1.11 27.79 29.62 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
216 -0.33 27.61 28.84 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
217 -1.54 28.01 30.05 5.01 ACCEPTABLE
218 -1.67 28.07 30.18 5.40 ACCEPTABLE
219 -0.65 27.55 29.16 5.27 ACCEPTABLE
220 -0.76 27.61 29.27 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
221 -0.17 27.44 28.61 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
222 -1.37 27.84 29.82 5.39 ACCEPTABLE
223 -0.06 27.39 28.50 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
224 -1.50 27.90 29.95 5.40 ACCEPTABLE
225 -0.57 27.43 29.01 5.30 ACCEPTABLE
226 -0.49 27.38 28.93 5.28 ACCEPTABLE
227 -0.60 27.44 29.05 5.28 ACCEPTABLE
228 -0.98 27.64 29.43 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
229 -1.15 27.81 29.66 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
230 -1.11 27.79 29.62 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
231 -0.59 27.67 29.10 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
232 -1.50 27.97 30.02 5.36 ACCEPTABLE
233 -0.19 27.46 28.70 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
234 -1.59 28.02 30.10 5.38 ACCEPTABLE
235 -0.90 27.66 29.42 4.90 ACCEPTABLE
236 -0.98 27.70 29.49 5.30 ACCEPTABLE
237 -0.48 27.56 28.95 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
238 -1.39 27.86 29.86 4.99 ACCEPTABLE
239 -0.41 27.52 28.87 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
240 -1.48 27.90 29.94 5.01 ACCEPTABLE
241 -0.75 27.55 29.21 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
242 -0.80 27.55 29.26 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
243 -0.87 27.59 29.34 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
244 -1.13 27.73 29.60 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
245 -0.16 27.39 28.62 0.75 NOT ACCEPTABLE
246 -1.24 27.84 29.75 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
247 -0.26 27.50 28.77 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
248 -1.11 27.79 29.62 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
249 -0.77 27.71 29.28 4.98 ACCEPTABLE
250 -0.42 27.50 28.90 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
251 -1.48 27.95 30.00 4.96 ACCEPTABLE
252 -0.49 27.57 29.00 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
253 -1.54 27.98 30.05 4.98 ACCEPTABLE
254 -0.37 27.51 28.88 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
255 -1.08 27.74 29.59 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
256 -0.74 27.66 29.25 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
257 -0.39 27.45 28.87 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE

18
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
258 -1.20 27.81 29.71 4.95 ACCEPTABLE
259 -0.46 27.52 28.97 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
260 -1.25 27.84 29.76 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
261 -0.34 27.46 28.85 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
262 -0.80 27.61 29.31 4.90 ACCEPTABLE
263 -0.85 27.63 29.36 4.91 ACCEPTABLE
264 -0.66 27.59 29.14 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
265 -1.12 27.74 29.60 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
266 -0.61 27.56 29.09 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
267 -1.18 27.76 29.66 4.95 ACCEPTABLE
268 -0.84 27.58 29.32 4.91 ACCEPTABLE
269 -0.73 27.53 29.21 4.90 ACCEPTABLE
270 -0.78 27.56 29.26 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
271 -0.95 27.65 29.43 4.93 ACCEPTABLE
272 -0.44 27.47 28.92 5.31 ACCEPTABLE
273 -1.02 27.72 29.54 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
274 -0.51 27.55 29.02 4.93 ACCEPTABLE
275 -1.08 27.74 29.59 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE
276 -0.85 27.69 29.36 4.95 ACCEPTABLE
277 -0.62 27.54 29.11 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
278 -1.18 27.80 29.69 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
279 -0.67 27.60 29.18 5.31 ACCEPTABLE
280 -1.22 27.82 29.73 4.95 ACCEPTABLE
281 -0.59 27.55 29.10 4.91 ACCEPTABLE
282 -0.92 27.66 29.43 5.28 ACCEPTABLE
283 -0.56 27.54 29.07 4.91 ACCEPTABLE
284 -0.95 27.68 29.46 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
285 -0.80 27.64 29.29 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
286 -1.13 27.75 29.62 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
287 -0.77 27.62 29.26 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
288 -1.17 27.76 29.66 4.94 ACCEPTABLE
289 -0.92 27.63 29.41 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
290 -0.54 27.50 29.03 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
291 -0.87 27.61 29.36 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
292 -0.51 27.49 29.00 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
293 -0.90 27.63 29.39 4.92 ACCEPTABLE
294 -1.02 27.69 29.51 5.31 ACCEPTABLE
295 -0.65 27.56 29.14 4.93 ACCEPTABLE
296 -1.07 27.74 29.58 4.93 ACCEPTABLE
297 -0.70 27.61 29.21 4.93 ACCEPTABLE
298 -1.08 27.74 29.59 0.74 NOT ACCEPTABLE

Analysis 2
Circular slip surface

19
Slip surface parameters
x= -0.42 [m] 1 = 35.40 [°]
Center : Angles :
z= 27.49 [m] 2 = 89.93 [°]
Radius : R= 28.93 [m]
The slip surface after optimization.

Slope stability verification (Bishop)


Sum of active forces : Fa = 994.44 kN/m
Sum of passive forces : Fp = 1630.51 kN/m

Sliding moment : Ma = 28769.20 kNm/m


Resisting moment : Mp = 47170.63 kNm/m

Factor of safety = 1.64 > 1.50


Slope stability ACCEPTABLE
Optimization of circular slip surface (Bishop)
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
1 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
2 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
3 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
4 -15.75 42.30 46.68 2.50 ACCEPTABLE
5 -35.70 57.37 70.84 3.65 ACCEPTABLE
6 -19.15 40.42 47.21 6.63 ACCEPTABLE
7 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
8 -9.02 35.57 38.40 2.20 ACCEPTABLE
9 -19.29 42.50 50.11 2.60 ACCEPTABLE
10 -6.14 29.03 31.40 3.52 ACCEPTABLE
11 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
12 -15.38 36.23 44.76 2.04 ACCEPTABLE
13 -31.85 45.86 63.11 2.39 ACCEPTABLE
14 -4.36 26.71 30.43 2.11 ACCEPTABLE
15 -16.86 33.59 43.82 2.62 ACCEPTABLE
16 -0.43 27.49 28.94 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
17 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
18 -4.07 30.66 32.74 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
19 -7.69 32.77 36.58 2.08 ACCEPTABLE
20 0.47 26.03 26.37 2.06 ACCEPTABLE
21 -3.07 28.04 30.03 2.17 ACCEPTABLE
22 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
23 -3.02 29.61 31.60 1.85 ACCEPTABLE
24 -5.30 30.89 33.98 1.91 ACCEPTABLE
25 -0.11 26.65 27.51 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
26 -2.38 27.91 29.85 1.95 ACCEPTABLE

20
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
27 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
28 -2.36 28.95 30.90 1.79 ACCEPTABLE
29 -3.83 29.75 32.42 1.80 ACCEPTABLE
30 -0.47 27.03 28.25 1.80 ACCEPTABLE
31 -1.95 27.83 29.76 1.84 ACCEPTABLE
32 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
33 -1.93 28.53 30.46 1.74 ACCEPTABLE
34 -2.89 29.05 31.44 1.76 ACCEPTABLE
35 -0.69 27.27 28.71 1.75 ACCEPTABLE
36 -1.65 27.78 29.69 1.77 ACCEPTABLE
37 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
38 -1.65 28.26 30.18 1.70 ACCEPTABLE
39 -2.28 28.59 30.82 1.71 ACCEPTABLE
40 -0.84 27.42 29.02 1.71 ACCEPTABLE
41 -1.47 27.75 29.66 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
42 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
43 -1.47 28.08 29.99 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
44 -1.89 28.30 30.41 5.87 ACCEPTABLE
45 -0.93 27.53 29.22 1.69 ACCEPTABLE
46 -1.35 27.74 29.64 5.51 ACCEPTABLE
47 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
48 -1.35 27.96 29.87 1.66 ACCEPTABLE
49 -1.63 28.11 30.15 5.79 ACCEPTABLE
50 -0.99 27.59 29.36 1.66 ACCEPTABLE
51 -1.27 27.74 29.64 5.42 ACCEPTABLE
52 -0.50 27.52 29.01 5.65 ACCEPTABLE
53 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
54 -1.27 27.88 29.79 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
55 -1.46 27.98 29.97 5.37 ACCEPTABLE
56 -1.03 27.64 29.45 1.65 ACCEPTABLE
57 -1.22 27.73 29.63 5.38 ACCEPTABLE
58 -0.47 27.34 28.88 5.30 ACCEPTABLE
59 -0.70 27.59 29.21 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
60 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
61 -1.22 27.83 29.73 5.32 ACCEPTABLE
62 -1.34 27.90 29.86 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
63 -1.06 27.67 29.51 1.65 ACCEPTABLE
64 -1.18 27.73 29.63 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
65 -0.68 27.47 29.12 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
66 -0.84 27.63 29.35 5.64 ACCEPTABLE
67 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
68 -1.19 27.80 29.70 5.31 ACCEPTABLE
69 -1.27 27.84 29.78 5.32 ACCEPTABLE
70 -0.60 27.49 29.11 5.24 ACCEPTABLE
71 -0.67 27.53 29.18 5.61 ACCEPTABLE
72 -1.08 27.69 29.55 5.67 ACCEPTABLE

21
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
73 -1.16 27.73 29.63 5.31 ACCEPTABLE
74 -0.49 27.39 28.96 5.26 ACCEPTABLE
75 -0.57 27.43 29.04 5.25 ACCEPTABLE
76 -0.82 27.56 29.29 5.64 ACCEPTABLE
77 -0.93 27.66 29.44 5.27 ACCEPTABLE
78 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
79 -1.16 27.77 29.67 5.65 ACCEPTABLE
80 -1.21 27.80 29.72 5.30 ACCEPTABLE
81 -0.76 27.57 29.27 5.61 ACCEPTABLE
82 -0.81 27.60 29.32 5.62 ACCEPTABLE
83 -1.09 27.70 29.57 5.66 ACCEPTABLE
84 -1.14 27.73 29.62 5.31 ACCEPTABLE
85 -0.69 27.50 29.17 5.62 ACCEPTABLE
86 -0.74 27.52 29.23 5.24 ACCEPTABLE
87 -0.92 27.61 29.40 5.28 ACCEPTABLE
88 -0.99 27.68 29.50 5.27 ACCEPTABLE
89 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
90 -0.91 27.68 29.42 5.66 ACCEPTABLE
91 -0.95 27.70 29.46 5.66 ACCEPTABLE
92 -0.65 27.54 29.16 5.62 ACCEPTABLE
93 -0.68 27.56 29.19 5.63 ACCEPTABLE
94 -0.86 27.63 29.36 5.64 ACCEPTABLE
95 -0.90 27.65 29.39 5.30 ACCEPTABLE
96 -0.60 27.50 29.09 5.63 ACCEPTABLE
97 -0.64 27.51 29.13 5.63 ACCEPTABLE
98 -0.75 27.57 29.24 5.28 ACCEPTABLE
99 -0.80 27.62 29.31 5.28 ACCEPTABLE
100 -15.75 42.30 46.68 2.50 ACCEPTABLE
101 -14.04 61.71 54.62 70.74 ACCEPTABLE
102 -0.35 27.62 28.86 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
103 -17.39 43.49 48.62 2.60 ACCEPTABLE
104 -42.10 62.09 78.64 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
105 -24.26 44.44 53.61 6.34 ACCEPTABLE
106 -0.35 27.62 28.86 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
107 -10.26 36.36 39.78 2.24 ACCEPTABLE
108 -22.55 44.62 53.86 2.73 ACCEPTABLE
109 -7.75 29.98 33.16 3.77 ACCEPTABLE
110 -0.35 27.62 28.86 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
111 -17.01 37.12 46.54 2.06 ACCEPTABLE
112 -36.18 48.29 67.96 2.46 ACCEPTABLE
113 -5.18 27.12 31.28 2.13 ACCEPTABLE
114 -19.26 34.84 46.43 2.70 ACCEPTABLE
115 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
116 -16.79 37.05 46.30 2.07 ACCEPTABLE
117 -35.36 47.90 67.06 2.46 ACCEPTABLE
118 -5.09 27.10 31.19 2.13 ACCEPTABLE

22
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
119 -18.84 34.67 45.98 2.70 ACCEPTABLE
120 -1.10 27.88 29.61 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
121 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
122 -5.02 31.20 33.74 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
123 -9.14 33.62 38.15 2.10 ACCEPTABLE
124 -0.21 26.41 27.06 2.09 ACCEPTABLE
125 -4.17 28.66 31.18 2.22 ACCEPTABLE
126 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
127 -3.96 30.13 32.58 1.87 ACCEPTABLE
128 -6.56 31.59 35.31 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
129 -0.88 27.06 28.30 1.91 ACCEPTABLE
130 -3.44 28.48 30.95 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
131 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
132 -3.30 29.46 31.87 1.81 ACCEPTABLE
133 -4.98 30.38 33.62 1.83 ACCEPTABLE
134 -1.31 27.47 29.09 1.83 ACCEPTABLE
135 -2.98 28.38 30.82 1.86 ACCEPTABLE
136 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
137 -2.88 29.04 31.43 1.76 ACCEPTABLE
138 -3.98 29.62 32.56 1.79 ACCEPTABLE
139 -1.57 27.72 29.59 1.77 ACCEPTABLE
140 -2.66 28.31 30.71 1.80 ACCEPTABLE
141 -0.03 27.51 28.54 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
142 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
143 -2.61 28.76 31.15 1.72 ACCEPTABLE
144 -3.33 29.14 31.89 1.74 ACCEPTABLE
145 -1.74 27.89 29.93 1.73 ACCEPTABLE
146 -2.45 28.27 30.66 6.16 ACCEPTABLE
147 0.12 26.91 28.05 1.69 ACCEPTABLE
148 -0.66 27.73 29.17 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
149 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
150 -2.43 28.58 30.96 1.70 ACCEPTABLE
151 -2.91 28.83 31.45 6.00 ACCEPTABLE
152 -1.85 28.00 30.15 1.71 ACCEPTABLE
153 -2.32 28.24 30.63 5.62 ACCEPTABLE
154 -0.57 27.33 28.85 5.44 ACCEPTABLE
155 -1.11 27.88 29.62 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
156 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
157 0.60 27.48 27.91 1.74 ACCEPTABLE
158 -2.32 28.46 30.84 1.69 ACCEPTABLE
159 -2.63 28.62 31.16 5.91 ACCEPTABLE
160 -0.56 27.54 29.07 5.29 ACCEPTABLE
161 -1.93 28.07 30.30 1.69 ACCEPTABLE
162 -2.24 28.23 30.62 5.92 ACCEPTABLE
163 -1.05 27.61 29.41 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
164 -1.42 27.99 29.93 5.39 ACCEPTABLE

23
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
165 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
166 -0.02 27.63 28.53 1.71 ACCEPTABLE
167 -2.24 28.38 30.76 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
168 -2.45 28.49 30.98 5.47 ACCEPTABLE
169 -0.87 27.67 29.38 5.66 ACCEPTABLE
170 -1.05 27.76 29.56 5.32 ACCEPTABLE
171 0.22 27.39 28.19 1.72 ACCEPTABLE
172 -1.98 28.12 30.40 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
173 0.37 27.30 28.04 1.71 ACCEPTABLE
174 -2.18 28.23 30.61 5.48 ACCEPTABLE
175 -0.38 27.37 28.79 5.72 ACCEPTABLE
176 -0.63 27.42 29.03 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
177 -0.80 27.51 29.21 5.33 ACCEPTABLE
178 -1.38 27.81 29.79 5.39 ACCEPTABLE
179 -1.64 28.07 30.15 5.39 ACCEPTABLE
180 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
181 -0.42 27.73 28.93 1.70 ACCEPTABLE
182 -2.19 28.33 30.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
183 -2.33 28.40 30.85 5.45 ACCEPTABLE
184 -1.26 27.85 29.77 5.69 ACCEPTABLE
185 -1.39 27.91 29.90 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
186 -0.26 27.56 28.70 1.70 ACCEPTABLE
187 -2.01 28.15 30.46 5.81 ACCEPTABLE
188 -0.15 27.50 28.59 1.69 ACCEPTABLE
189 -0.65 27.55 29.09 5.36 ACCEPTABLE
190 -1.09 27.67 29.53 5.69 ACCEPTABLE
191 -1.22 27.74 29.66 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
192 -1.61 27.94 30.06 5.75 ACCEPTABLE
193 -1.78 28.12 30.30 5.38 ACCEPTABLE
194 0.07 27.47 28.44 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
195 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
196 -0.68 27.79 29.20 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
197 -0.17 27.47 28.63 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
198 -0.28 27.58 28.79 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
199 -2.25 28.34 30.77 5.42 ACCEPTABLE
200 -0.09 27.49 28.60 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
201 -1.53 27.97 30.04 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
202 -1.62 28.01 30.13 5.72 ACCEPTABLE
203 -0.57 27.68 29.04 1.69 ACCEPTABLE
204 -0.50 27.64 28.96 1.69 ACCEPTABLE
205 -0.83 27.67 29.30 5.73 ACCEPTABLE
206 0.01 27.37 28.45 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
207 -1.41 27.85 29.88 5.34 ACCEPTABLE
208 -1.50 27.90 29.96 5.36 ACCEPTABLE
209 -1.76 28.03 30.23 5.38 ACCEPTABLE
210 -0.24 27.51 28.70 1.68 ACCEPTABLE

24
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
211 -1.88 28.15 30.40 5.37 ACCEPTABLE
212 -0.35 27.62 28.86 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
213 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
214 -0.86 27.84 29.37 5.44 ACCEPTABLE
215 -0.51 27.61 28.98 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
216 -1.97 28.21 30.49 5.40 ACCEPTABLE
217 -0.58 27.69 29.09 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
218 -2.03 28.24 30.55 5.77 ACCEPTABLE
219 -0.46 27.63 28.97 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
220 -1.55 28.00 30.07 5.35 ACCEPTABLE
221 -0.41 27.61 28.92 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
222 -1.61 28.03 30.13 5.35 ACCEPTABLE
223 -0.78 27.76 29.26 5.81 ACCEPTABLE
224 -1.89 28.13 30.37 5.41 ACCEPTABLE
225 -0.73 27.73 29.21 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
226 -1.95 28.16 30.43 5.42 ACCEPTABLE
227 -0.95 27.75 29.43 5.38 ACCEPTABLE
228 -0.39 27.55 28.86 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
229 -1.47 27.92 29.95 5.73 ACCEPTABLE
230 -0.34 27.53 28.81 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
231 -1.53 27.95 30.01 5.74 ACCEPTABLE
232 -1.71 28.04 30.19 5.39 ACCEPTABLE
233 -0.56 27.64 29.03 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
234 -1.79 28.12 30.31 5.74 ACCEPTABLE
235 -0.63 27.72 29.15 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
236 -1.20 27.91 29.71 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
237 -0.98 27.86 29.49 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
238 -0.73 27.71 29.22 5.40 ACCEPTABLE
239 -1.71 28.11 30.23 5.76 ACCEPTABLE
240 -0.79 27.77 29.30 5.77 ACCEPTABLE
241 -1.75 28.13 30.27 5.76 ACCEPTABLE
242 -0.71 27.73 29.22 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
243 -1.44 27.97 29.95 5.74 ACCEPTABLE
244 -0.68 27.71 29.19 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
245 -1.48 27.99 29.99 5.74 ACCEPTABLE
246 -0.92 27.81 29.41 5.79 ACCEPTABLE
247 -1.66 28.06 30.15 5.78 ACCEPTABLE
248 -0.89 27.79 29.37 5.80 ACCEPTABLE
249 -1.70 28.08 30.19 5.41 ACCEPTABLE
250 -1.04 27.80 29.53 1.66 ACCEPTABLE
251 -0.85 27.79 29.36 5.40 ACCEPTABLE
252 -0.58 27.60 29.05 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
253 -1.59 28.04 30.10 5.75 ACCEPTABLE
254 -0.67 27.70 29.18 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
255 -1.63 28.06 30.14 5.76 ACCEPTABLE
256 -0.59 27.66 29.10 1.66 ACCEPTABLE

25
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
257 -1.32 27.90 29.83 5.71 ACCEPTABLE
258 -0.56 27.64 29.06 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
259 -1.36 27.92 29.87 5.72 ACCEPTABLE
260 -0.76 27.70 29.23 5.78 ACCEPTABLE
261 -1.49 27.95 29.97 5.38 ACCEPTABLE
262 -0.73 27.68 29.20 5.40 ACCEPTABLE
263 -1.53 27.96 30.01 5.75 ACCEPTABLE
264 -0.88 27.69 29.35 5.73 ACCEPTABLE
265 -0.50 27.56 28.97 1.66 ACCEPTABLE
266 -1.22 27.80 29.69 5.35 ACCEPTABLE
267 -0.46 27.54 28.93 1.66 ACCEPTABLE
268 -1.26 27.82 29.73 5.72 ACCEPTABLE
269 -1.38 27.88 29.85 5.37 ACCEPTABLE
270 -0.61 27.62 29.08 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
271 -1.47 27.98 29.98 5.37 ACCEPTABLE
272 -0.70 27.72 29.21 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
273 -0.42 27.49 28.93 1.64 ACCEPTABLE

2. STABILITAS LERENG DINDING PENAHAN TANAH/ DPT ( Tinggi 7 m


dan Lebar 2 meter )
- Dinding penahan tanah ini berada pada lokasi Headpond dengan tinggi 7 meter.

- Hasil Analisa Stabilitas Lereng dengan program GEO 5, diperoleh Safety factor/ SF 2,29 >
1,5 artinya Kondisi stabilitas lereng Dinding Penahan Tanah di lokasi headpond stabil.

- Analisa selengkapnya sebagai berikut :

Slope stability analysis

Input data

Project

Settings
Standard - safety factors (22)

Stability analysis

Earthquake analysis : Standard


Verification Safety factors (ASD)
methodology :

26
Safety factors
Permanent design situation
Safety factor : SFs = 1.50 [–]

Interface

Coordinates of interface points [m]


No. Interface location
x z x z x z
1 -16.25 -5.50 -3.50 -5.50 -0.50 0.50
0.00 0.50 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00

4.00 2.00 8.50 2.00 19.50 2.00

2 0.00 -6.50 8.50 2.00

3 -3.50 -6.50 0.00 -6.50 0.00 -5.50


0.00 0.00

4 -16.25 -6.50 -3.50 -6.50 -3.50 -5.50

Soil parameters - effective stress state

27
ef cef 
No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3]

1 Pasir lepas 32.50 23.00 15.10

Soil parameters - uplift

sat s n
No. Name Pattern
[kN/m3] [kN/m3] [–]

1 Pasir lepas 15.10

Soil parameters

Pasir lepas
Unit weight :  = 15.10 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 32.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Saturated unit weight : sa = 15.10 kN/m3
t

Rigid bodies


No. Name Sample
[kN/m3]

1 Material of structure 22.00

Assigning and surfaces

Coordinates of surface points [m] Assigned


No. Surface position
x z x z soil
1 0.00 -5.50 0.00 -6.50
Pasir lepas
8.50 2.00 4.00 2.00

1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

28
Coordinates of surface points [m] Assigned
No. Surface position
x z x z soil

2 -3.50 -6.50 0.00 -6.50


Material of structure
0.00 -5.50 0.00 0.00

0.00 0.50 -0.50 0.50

-3.50 -5.50

3 -3.50 -6.50 -3.50 -5.50


Pasir lepas
-16.25 -5.50 -16.25 -6.50

4 -16.25 -6.50 -16.25 -11.50


Pasir lepas
19.50 -11.50 19.50 2.00

8.50 2.00 0.00 -6.50

-3.50 -6.50

Surcharge

Location Origin Length Width Slope Magnitude


No. Type Type of action
z [m] x [m] l [m] b [m]  [°] q, q1, f, F q2 unit

1 strip permanent on terrain x = 4.00 l = 6.00 0.00 7.60 kN/m2

2 strip permanent on terrain x = -16.25 l = 12.75 0.00 0.50 kN/m2

Water

Water type : No water

Tensile crack

Tensile crack not input.

Earthquake

29
Horizontal seismic coefficient : Kh = 0.1280
Vertical seismic coefficient : Kv = 0.0640

Settings of the stage of construction

Design situation : permanent

Results (Stage of construction 1)

Analysis 1
Circular slip surface

Slip surface parameters


x= -3.40 [m] 1 = -26.85 [°]
Center : Angles :
z= 6.33 [m] 2 = 70.94 [°]
Radius : R= 13.26 [m]
The slip surface after optimization.

Slope stability verification (Bishop)


Sum of active forces : Fa = 522.07 kN/m
Sum of passive forces : Fp = 1194.43 kN/m

Sliding moment : Ma = 6922.61 kNm/m


Resisting moment : Mp = 15838.13 kNm/m

Factor of safety = 2.29 > 1.50


Slope stability ACCEPTABLE
Optimization of circular slip surface (Bishop)
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
1 -5.49 31.96 38.95 2.82 ACCEPTABLE
2 -5.49 31.96 38.95 2.82 ACCEPTABLE
3 -5.44 31.56 38.55 2.82 ACCEPTABLE
4 -0.86 20.95 27.67 2.76 ACCEPTABLE
5 -1.54 13.16 23.64 2.91 ACCEPTABLE
6 7.61 5.13 12.10 105.22 ACCEPTABLE
7 0.01 5.86 19.67 3.54 ACCEPTABLE
8 -5.03 10.02 19.04 2.60 ACCEPTABLE
9 -2.05 15.55 25.28 2.83 ACCEPTABLE
10 2.04 10.01 19.03 3.11 ACCEPTABLE
11 0.70 2.59 18.60 4.20 ACCEPTABLE
12 -7.43 3.88 12.74 2.92 ACCEPTABLE
13 -6.83 2.18 12.00 3.13 ACCEPTABLE

30
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
14 -2.86 19.39 28.17 2.77 ACCEPTABLE
15 2.19 9.44 18.66 3.16 ACCEPTABLE
16 -287.50 1083.10 1121.91 141.30 ACCEPTABLE
17 -37.31 182.09 188.78 90.70 ACCEPTABLE
18 -246.46 950.50 985.03 91.26 ACCEPTABLE
19 -5.02 10.01 19.03 2.60 ACCEPTABLE
20 0.57 6.69 17.04 3.10 ACCEPTABLE
21 -5.51 7.31 14.07 68.43 ACCEPTABLE
22 -17.31 76.39 81.90 85.53 ACCEPTABLE
23 -9.24 43.69 49.24 75.31 ACCEPTABLE
24 -3.48 15.56 24.52 2.70 ACCEPTABLE
25 -0.32 10.02 19.04 2.82 ACCEPTABLE
26 -1.00 4.65 18.15 3.48 ACCEPTABLE
27 -11.68 21.58 27.43 131.04 ACCEPTABLE
28 -10.36 19.52 25.04 129.56 ACCEPTABLE
29 -6.76 6.10 14.86 2.66 ACCEPTABLE
30 -6.28 4.58 14.04 2.77 ACCEPTABLE
31 -3.44 2.09 10.96 2.71 ACCEPTABLE
32 -3.61 16.13 24.95 2.69 ACCEPTABLE
33 -0.48 10.64 19.46 2.79 ACCEPTABLE
34 -247.72 763.81 803.43 270.00 ACCEPTABLE
35 -243.00 763.81 803.43 130.91 ACCEPTABLE
36 -5.02 10.01 19.03 2.60 ACCEPTABLE
37 -1.88 9.99 19.02 2.70 ACCEPTABLE
38 -5.72 9.42 16.57 24.11 ACCEPTABLE
39 -8.65 33.10 39.30 68.87 ACCEPTABLE
40 -5.59 23.99 30.39 62.19 ACCEPTABLE
41 -4.18 14.35 23.13 2.65 ACCEPTABLE
42 -0.21 3.68 15.68 3.38 ACCEPTABLE
43 -3.72 12.42 21.76 2.69 ACCEPTABLE
44 -1.89 10.02 19.04 2.70 ACCEPTABLE
45 -2.23 6.20 18.10 3.10 ACCEPTABLE
46 -4.09 4.66 13.46 2.57 ACCEPTABLE
47 -0.51 3.39 12.84 2.96 ACCEPTABLE
48 -4.29 3.24 10.32 24.90 ACCEPTABLE
49 -9.02 25.12 31.41 75.86 ACCEPTABLE
50 -4.31 14.53 20.76 69.85 ACCEPTABLE
51 -5.35 11.26 19.89 2.57 ACCEPTABLE
52 -2.31 11.65 20.16 2.64 ACCEPTABLE
53 -6.20 10.86 17.69 61.95 ACCEPTABLE
54 -9.95 38.59 44.51 77.85 ACCEPTABLE
55 -6.57 27.73 33.83 68.28 ACCEPTABLE
56 -4.61 16.19 24.53 2.62 ACCEPTABLE
57 -0.40 4.44 15.98 3.24 ACCEPTABLE
58 -2.21 11.26 19.89 2.65 ACCEPTABLE
59 -2.42 7.04 18.52 3.01 ACCEPTABLE

31
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
60 -4.44 5.71 14.05 2.48 ACCEPTABLE
61 -0.99 4.81 13.54 2.74 ACCEPTABLE
62 -4.72 4.16 10.90 70.17 ACCEPTABLE
63 -10.30 29.97 35.93 86.87 ACCEPTABLE
64 -5.37 17.68 23.59 75.93 ACCEPTABLE
65 -5.83 13.09 21.22 2.54 ACCEPTABLE
66 -4.92 9.66 18.80 2.61 ACCEPTABLE
67 -1.30 5.71 14.05 2.64 ACCEPTABLE
68 -3.63 4.78 16.12 3.00 ACCEPTABLE
69 -9.61 11.67 18.34 131.75 ACCEPTABLE
70 -6.76 8.45 14.27 130.31 ACCEPTABLE
71 -7.58 5.71 14.05 18.30 ACCEPTABLE
72 -6.99 3.97 13.11 2.85 ACCEPTABLE
73 -1.49 6.29 14.40 2.59 ACCEPTABLE
74 -260.27 859.53 898.84 196.83 ACCEPTABLE
75 -311.85 1304.13 1342.62 117.68 ACCEPTABLE
76 -257.12 859.53 898.84 135.68 ACCEPTABLE
77 -4.44 5.71 14.05 2.48 ACCEPTABLE
78 -2.47 6.09 14.28 2.52 ACCEPTABLE
79 -4.80 5.15 12.23 27.00 ACCEPTABLE
80 -7.52 17.91 24.58 69.14 ACCEPTABLE
81 -4.48 11.98 18.60 47.69 ACCEPTABLE
82 -5.40 10.49 18.65 2.49 ACCEPTABLE
83 -1.11 2.09 12.32 3.10 ACCEPTABLE
84 -4.80 8.38 17.23 2.56 ACCEPTABLE
85 -2.35 5.71 14.05 2.55 ACCEPTABLE
86 -3.83 5.01 15.34 2.81 ACCEPTABLE
87 -3.77 2.70 10.81 2.53 ACCEPTABLE
88 -7.85 9.58 16.69 87.11 ACCEPTABLE
89 -5.62 7.09 13.62 91.31 ACCEPTABLE
90 -6.53 5.71 14.05 2.60 ACCEPTABLE
91 -5.69 3.22 12.76 2.82 ACCEPTABLE
92 -6.17 4.65 13.45 2.67 ACCEPTABLE
93 -3.66 2.43 10.68 2.57 ACCEPTABLE
94 -5.17 9.68 18.09 2.51 ACCEPTABLE
95 -2.53 6.26 14.39 2.51 ACCEPTABLE
96 -216.20 564.84 605.49 270.26 ACCEPTABLE
97 -248.79 795.49 835.00 145.43 ACCEPTABLE
98 -214.11 564.84 605.49 167.06 ACCEPTABLE
99 -4.44 5.71 14.05 2.48 ACCEPTABLE
100 -3.24 6.30 14.41 2.46 ACCEPTABLE
101 -2.09 7.03 14.88 2.51 ACCEPTABLE
102 -3.57 6.11 13.33 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
103 -2.63 7.27 14.15 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
104 -3.96 5.81 12.28 83.61 ACCEPTABLE
105 -6.07 14.60 20.82 75.30 ACCEPTABLE

32
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
106 -3.97 10.72 16.90 75.47 ACCEPTABLE
107 -4.44 9.81 16.87 6.36 ACCEPTABLE
108 -1.14 3.46 11.74 2.69 ACCEPTABLE
109 -3.77 7.84 15.43 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
110 -2.17 6.11 13.33 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
111 -2.94 5.39 13.86 2.53 ACCEPTABLE
112 -3.23 4.23 11.17 7.36 ACCEPTABLE
113 -6.05 8.90 15.40 89.36 ACCEPTABLE
114 -4.67 7.37 13.50 90.32 ACCEPTABLE
115 -4.97 6.11 13.33 16.72 ACCEPTABLE
116 -4.18 4.10 12.08 2.46 ACCEPTABLE
117 -2.63 2.90 10.38 2.45 ACCEPTABLE
118 -3.62 2.66 11.35 2.63 ACCEPTABLE
119 -4.60 5.18 12.72 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
120 -2.98 3.67 10.82 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
121 -4.14 8.93 16.20 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
122 -2.46 6.83 13.83 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
123 -243.25 754.00 793.66 154.70 ACCEPTABLE
124 -3.57 6.11 13.33 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
125 -2.99 7.02 13.97 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
126 -2.51 8.16 14.83 9.70 ACCEPTABLE
127 -3.33 6.95 13.39 75.81 ACCEPTABLE
128 -4.68 12.63 18.93 72.41 ACCEPTABLE
129 -3.29 10.19 16.45 72.62 ACCEPTABLE
130 -3.64 9.69 16.51 10.11 ACCEPTABLE
131 -1.31 5.09 12.67 2.54 ACCEPTABLE
132 -3.11 8.21 15.39 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
133 -2.06 7.02 13.97 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
134 -2.46 6.38 14.13 2.45 ACCEPTABLE
135 -2.82 5.78 12.52 11.31 ACCEPTABLE
136 -4.71 9.05 15.53 76.04 ACCEPTABLE
137 -3.77 7.97 14.20 78.69 ACCEPTABLE
138 -3.92 7.02 13.97 9.99 ACCEPTABLE
139 -2.30 3.76 11.55 2.49 ACCEPTABLE
140 -1.72 3.24 10.91 2.54 ACCEPTABLE
141 -3.35 5.55 12.96 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
142 -2.32 4.61 11.73 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
143 -2.85 4.27 12.18 2.46 ACCEPTABLE
144 -3.65 6.32 13.47 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
145 -2.59 5.24 12.14 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
146 -3.39 8.99 15.97 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
147 -2.30 7.64 14.43 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
148 -201.32 487.08 528.39 188.15 ACCEPTABLE
149 -215.19 576.60 617.17 147.23 ACCEPTABLE
150 -200.39 487.08 528.39 158.57 ACCEPTABLE
151 -2.99 7.02 13.97 2.31 ACCEPTABLE

33
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
152 -2.69 7.83 14.57 4.20 ACCEPTABLE
153 -3.22 7.01 13.61 35.46 ACCEPTABLE
154 -4.05 10.48 16.99 69.48 ACCEPTABLE
155 -3.14 9.00 15.48 69.29 ACCEPTABLE
156 -3.42 8.77 15.63 6.16 ACCEPTABLE
157 -1.86 5.73 13.07 2.44 ACCEPTABLE
158 -3.07 7.81 14.92 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
159 -2.37 7.02 13.97 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
160 -2.62 6.57 14.05 2.41 ACCEPTABLE
161 -2.88 6.20 13.01 4.15 ACCEPTABLE
162 -4.13 8.36 14.98 49.15 ACCEPTABLE
163 -3.47 7.61 14.06 74.20 ACCEPTABLE
164 -3.61 7.02 13.97 4.21 ACCEPTABLE
165 -2.49 4.72 12.22 2.41 ACCEPTABLE
166 -2.12 4.36 11.78 2.43 ACCEPTABLE
167 -3.24 6.07 13.30 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
168 -2.54 5.38 12.44 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
169 -2.86 5.08 12.66 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
170 -3.43 6.56 13.64 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
171 -3.09 7.29 14.17 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
172 -2.80 8.15 14.82 15.21 ACCEPTABLE
173 -3.33 7.29 13.82 55.87 ACCEPTABLE
174 -4.18 10.86 17.30 70.34 ACCEPTABLE
175 -3.27 9.34 15.76 70.00 ACCEPTABLE
176 -3.54 9.09 15.88 13.80 ACCEPTABLE
177 -1.95 5.96 13.24 2.43 ACCEPTABLE
178 -3.17 8.09 15.12 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
179 -2.47 7.29 14.17 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
180 -2.70 6.81 14.22 2.39 ACCEPTABLE
181 -2.99 6.47 13.20 13.26 ACCEPTABLE
182 -4.25 8.67 15.22 65.27 ACCEPTABLE
183 -3.59 7.92 14.31 75.63 ACCEPTABLE
184 -3.71 7.29 14.17 11.85 ACCEPTABLE
185 -2.57 4.93 12.35 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
186 -2.20 4.56 11.91 2.41 ACCEPTABLE
187 -3.32 6.29 13.46 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
188 -2.63 5.61 12.60 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
189 -2.93 5.29 12.80 2.39 ACCEPTABLE
190 -3.52 6.81 13.82 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
191 -3.20 7.58 14.38 7.90 ACCEPTABLE
192 -3.75 6.80 13.45 40.24 ACCEPTABLE
193 -4.56 10.19 16.75 66.98 ACCEPTABLE
194 -3.65 8.73 15.27 55.41 ACCEPTABLE
195 -3.94 8.52 15.45 10.09 ACCEPTABLE
196 -2.40 5.54 12.95 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
197 -3.61 7.60 14.77 2.32 ACCEPTABLE

34
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
198 -2.90 6.81 13.82 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
199 -3.16 6.38 13.92 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
200 -3.41 5.99 12.86 11.15 ACCEPTABLE
201 -4.65 8.12 14.79 55.05 ACCEPTABLE
202 -3.98 7.37 13.88 77.65 ACCEPTABLE
203 -4.14 6.81 13.82 12.02 ACCEPTABLE
204 -3.04 4.56 12.13 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
205 -2.66 4.20 11.69 2.41 ACCEPTABLE
206 -3.78 5.89 13.18 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
207 -3.08 5.21 12.32 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
208 -3.41 4.92 12.57 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
209 -3.97 6.37 13.51 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
210 -3.25 5.62 12.60 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
211 -3.78 8.08 15.12 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
212 -3.06 7.22 14.11 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
213 -202.70 501.61 542.77 152.90 ACCEPTABLE
214 -211.94 561.30 601.97 139.01 ACCEPTABLE
215 -202.08 501.61 542.77 142.14 ACCEPTABLE
216 -3.52 6.81 13.82 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
217 -3.31 7.34 14.21 6.05 ACCEPTABLE
218 -3.67 6.82 13.58 24.93 ACCEPTABLE
219 -4.19 8.96 15.66 37.69 ACCEPTABLE
220 -3.59 8.04 14.73 28.76 ACCEPTABLE
221 -3.80 7.94 14.89 6.15 ACCEPTABLE
222 -2.77 5.96 13.23 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
223 -3.58 7.34 14.45 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
224 -3.11 6.81 13.82 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
225 -3.27 6.51 13.87 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
226 -3.45 6.27 13.18 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
227 -4.27 7.68 14.46 31.87 ACCEPTABLE
228 -3.81 7.16 13.84 37.31 ACCEPTABLE
229 -3.93 6.81 13.82 8.07 ACCEPTABLE
230 -3.18 5.25 12.63 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
231 -2.93 5.00 12.33 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
232 -3.70 6.21 13.40 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
233 -3.23 5.73 12.81 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
234 -3.42 5.50 12.93 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
235 -3.82 6.52 13.61 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
236 -3.34 6.01 13.00 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
237 -3.13 6.51 13.36 5.68 ACCEPTABLE
238 -3.48 6.00 12.74 24.62 ACCEPTABLE
239 -4.00 8.04 14.73 37.15 ACCEPTABLE
240 -3.40 7.17 13.84 28.35 ACCEPTABLE
241 -3.62 7.09 14.02 6.10 ACCEPTABLE
242 -2.60 5.21 12.46 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
243 -3.40 6.52 13.62 2.31 ACCEPTABLE

35
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
244 -2.93 6.01 13.00 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
245 -3.10 5.74 13.09 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
246 -3.27 5.49 12.38 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
247 -4.08 6.82 13.58 33.39 ACCEPTABLE
248 -3.62 6.33 12.98 39.83 ACCEPTABLE
249 -3.75 6.01 13.00 6.13 ACCEPTABLE
250 -3.01 4.54 11.89 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
251 -2.76 4.30 11.60 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
252 -3.52 5.44 12.61 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
253 -3.05 4.98 12.04 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
254 -3.25 4.78 12.18 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
255 -3.64 5.73 12.81 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
256 -3.16 5.24 12.21 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
257 -3.52 6.81 13.82 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
258 -3.03 6.27 13.18 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
259 -204.86 511.42 552.50 164.32 ACCEPTABLE
260 -211.02 551.22 591.97 150.51 ACCEPTABLE
261 -204.44 511.42 552.50 153.54 ACCEPTABLE
262 -3.34 6.01 13.00 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
263 -3.20 6.35 13.24 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
264 -3.44 6.01 12.83 15.40 ACCEPTABLE
265 -3.77 7.33 14.11 23.21 ACCEPTABLE
266 -3.37 6.76 13.54 15.27 ACCEPTABLE
267 -3.53 6.72 13.67 4.20 ACCEPTABLE
268 -2.85 5.47 12.64 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
269 -3.38 6.35 13.41 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
270 -3.06 6.01 13.00 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
271 -3.18 5.83 13.05 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
272 -3.29 5.66 12.59 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
273 -3.84 6.55 13.38 21.49 ACCEPTABLE
274 -3.52 6.22 12.98 22.84 ACCEPTABLE
275 -3.62 6.01 13.00 4.21 ACCEPTABLE
276 -3.11 5.00 12.23 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
277 -2.94 4.84 12.03 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
278 -3.46 5.64 12.74 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
279 -3.15 5.32 12.35 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
280 -3.27 5.16 12.43 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
281 -3.54 5.83 12.87 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
282 -3.22 5.49 12.47 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
283 -3.46 6.54 13.54 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
284 -3.33 6.90 13.80 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
285 -3.56 6.55 13.38 15.51 ACCEPTABLE
286 -3.89 7.90 14.70 21.86 ACCEPTABLE
287 -3.49 7.32 14.11 15.39 ACCEPTABLE
288 -3.65 7.28 14.24 4.22 ACCEPTABLE
289 -2.96 5.98 13.15 2.34 ACCEPTABLE

36
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
290 -3.50 6.89 13.96 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
291 -3.18 6.54 13.54 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
292 -3.29 6.34 13.58 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
293 -3.41 6.18 13.12 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
294 -3.96 7.10 13.95 20.77 ACCEPTABLE
295 -3.65 6.76 13.53 23.20 ACCEPTABLE
296 -3.74 6.54 13.54 6.12 ACCEPTABLE
297 -3.23 5.49 12.73 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
298 -3.06 5.32 12.53 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
299 -3.58 6.15 13.27 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
300 -3.27 5.82 12.87 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
301 -3.39 5.66 12.94 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
302 -3.66 6.35 13.41 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
303 -3.34 6.01 13.00 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
304 -3.58 7.09 14.10 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
305 -3.26 6.72 13.67 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
306 -199.38 479.54 520.92 170.56 ACCEPTABLE
307 -203.42 504.93 546.06 155.12 ACCEPTABLE
308 -199.10 479.54 520.92 162.54 ACCEPTABLE
309 -3.46 6.54 13.54 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
310 -3.37 6.78 13.71 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
311 -3.29 7.03 13.89 6.05 ACCEPTABLE
312 -3.44 6.79 13.61 13.48 ACCEPTABLE
313 -3.66 7.70 14.49 19.28 ACCEPTABLE
314 -3.40 7.31 14.10 13.49 ACCEPTABLE
315 -3.50 7.28 14.18 6.09 ACCEPTABLE
316 -3.04 6.40 13.44 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
317 -3.40 7.01 13.99 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
318 -3.19 6.78 13.71 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
319 -3.25 6.64 13.72 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
320 -3.34 6.54 13.43 6.05 ACCEPTABLE
321 -3.71 7.16 13.99 17.51 ACCEPTABLE
322 -3.50 6.93 13.71 19.09 ACCEPTABLE
323 -3.55 6.78 13.71 6.08 ACCEPTABLE
324 -3.20 6.05 13.14 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
325 -3.09 5.93 13.00 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
326 -3.45 6.51 13.52 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
327 -3.24 6.29 13.25 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
328 -3.31 6.16 13.27 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
329 -3.50 6.65 13.62 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
330 -3.41 6.90 13.80 6.07 ACCEPTABLE
331 -3.57 6.66 13.52 13.64 ACCEPTABLE
332 -3.79 7.55 14.39 17.60 ACCEPTABLE
333 -3.52 7.17 14.00 13.55 ACCEPTABLE
334 -3.63 7.14 14.09 4.21 ACCEPTABLE
335 -3.17 6.27 13.35 2.32 ACCEPTABLE

37
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
336 -3.53 6.88 13.90 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
337 -3.32 6.65 13.62 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
338 -3.38 6.51 13.64 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
339 -3.47 6.41 13.34 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
340 -3.83 7.03 13.89 17.65 ACCEPTABLE
341 -3.63 6.80 13.62 17.43 ACCEPTABLE
342 -3.68 6.65 13.62 6.11 ACCEPTABLE
343 -3.34 5.93 13.06 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
344 -3.23 5.81 12.92 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
345 -3.58 6.39 13.44 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
346 -3.37 6.17 13.16 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
347 -3.44 6.04 13.20 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
348 -3.63 6.52 13.53 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
349 -3.42 6.29 13.25 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
350 -3.33 6.53 13.42 6.05 ACCEPTABLE
351 -3.49 6.30 13.14 13.58 ACCEPTABLE
352 -3.71 7.17 14.00 17.52 ACCEPTABLE
353 -3.44 6.80 13.61 15.32 ACCEPTABLE
354 -3.55 6.77 13.71 4.20 ACCEPTABLE
355 -3.09 5.92 13.00 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
356 -3.45 6.52 13.53 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
357 -3.24 6.29 13.25 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
358 -3.31 6.16 13.27 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
359 -3.39 6.06 12.97 5.71 ACCEPTABLE
360 -3.75 6.66 13.51 17.56 ACCEPTABLE
361 -3.54 6.43 13.24 17.33 ACCEPTABLE
362 -3.60 6.29 13.25 6.09 ACCEPTABLE
363 -3.26 5.59 12.71 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
364 -3.15 5.47 12.57 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
365 -3.50 6.04 13.07 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
366 -3.29 5.82 12.80 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
367 -3.37 5.70 12.84 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
368 -3.55 6.16 13.16 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
369 -3.34 5.94 12.89 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
370 -3.25 6.18 13.06 5.69 ACCEPTABLE
371 -3.41 5.94 12.78 13.52 ACCEPTABLE
372 -3.62 6.80 13.62 17.41 ACCEPTABLE
373 -3.36 6.43 13.24 13.42 ACCEPTABLE
374 -3.47 6.41 13.34 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
375 -3.01 5.58 12.64 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
376 -3.37 6.17 13.16 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
377 -3.16 5.94 12.89 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
378 -3.23 5.82 12.92 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
379 -3.31 5.71 12.62 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
380 -3.67 6.30 13.14 17.48 ACCEPTABLE
381 -3.46 6.07 12.87 19.07 ACCEPTABLE

38
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
382 -3.52 5.94 12.89 6.07 ACCEPTABLE
383 -3.18 5.25 12.36 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
384 -3.07 5.14 12.23 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
385 -3.42 5.69 12.72 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
386 -3.21 5.48 12.45 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
387 -3.29 5.36 12.50 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
388 -3.47 5.82 12.80 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
389 -3.26 5.59 12.54 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
390 -3.42 6.29 13.25 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
391 -3.21 6.06 12.97 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
392 -204.29 508.75 549.85 162.65 ACCEPTABLE
393 -207.01 526.17 567.12 156.40 ACCEPTABLE
394 -204.10 508.75 549.85 157.71 ACCEPTABLE
395 -3.34 5.94 12.89 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
396 -3.28 6.10 13.00 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
397 -3.38 5.94 12.82 9.78 ACCEPTABLE
398 -3.53 6.51 13.37 13.60 ACCEPTABLE
399 -3.35 6.27 13.12 9.73 ACCEPTABLE
400 -3.43 6.26 13.19 4.02 ACCEPTABLE
401 -3.12 5.70 12.73 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
402 -3.36 6.09 13.07 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
403 -3.22 5.94 12.89 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
404 -3.26 5.86 12.91 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
405 -3.32 5.79 12.71 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
406 -3.56 6.18 13.06 12.57 ACCEPTABLE
407 -3.42 6.03 12.88 12.85 ACCEPTABLE
408 -3.46 5.94 12.89 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
409 -3.23 5.48 12.53 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
410 -3.16 5.40 12.44 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
411 -3.39 5.78 12.78 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
412 -3.25 5.63 12.60 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
413 -3.30 5.55 12.62 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
414 -3.43 5.86 12.83 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
415 -3.29 5.71 12.65 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
416 -3.39 6.17 13.13 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
417 -3.25 6.02 12.95 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
418 -198.96 477.57 518.98 167.41 ACCEPTABLE
419 -200.75 488.74 530.03 160.85 ACCEPTABLE
420 -198.84 477.57 518.98 164.00 ACCEPTABLE
421 -3.34 5.94 12.89 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
422 -3.30 6.05 12.96 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
423 -3.37 5.94 12.84 6.04 ACCEPTABLE
424 -3.46 6.31 13.20 9.82 ACCEPTABLE
425 -3.35 6.16 13.04 7.92 ACCEPTABLE
426 -3.40 6.15 13.09 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
427 -3.19 5.78 12.78 2.30 ACCEPTABLE

39
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
428 -3.35 6.04 13.01 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
429 -3.26 5.94 12.89 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
430 -3.29 5.88 12.90 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
431 -3.33 5.84 12.77 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
432 -3.49 6.10 13.00 9.64 ACCEPTABLE
433 -3.39 6.00 12.88 9.79 ACCEPTABLE
434 -3.42 5.94 12.89 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
435 -3.27 5.63 12.65 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
436 -3.22 5.58 12.59 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
437 -3.38 5.83 12.81 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
438 -3.28 5.73 12.69 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
439 -3.31 5.68 12.71 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
440 -3.40 5.89 12.85 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
441 -3.30 5.79 12.73 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
442 -3.38 6.10 13.05 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
443 -3.34 6.21 13.13 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
444 -3.41 6.10 13.00 7.76 ACCEPTABLE
445 -3.50 6.48 13.37 9.16 ACCEPTABLE
446 -3.39 6.32 13.20 7.93 ACCEPTABLE
447 -3.44 6.31 13.25 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
448 -3.23 5.94 12.94 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
449 -3.39 6.20 13.17 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
450 -3.30 6.10 13.05 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
451 -3.33 6.04 13.06 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
452 -3.37 6.00 12.93 4.01 ACCEPTABLE
453 -3.53 6.26 13.16 9.16 ACCEPTABLE
454 -3.43 6.16 13.04 9.81 ACCEPTABLE
455 -3.46 6.10 13.05 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
456 -3.31 5.78 12.81 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
457 -3.26 5.73 12.75 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
458 -3.42 5.99 12.97 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
459 -3.32 5.89 12.85 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
460 -3.35 5.83 12.87 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
461 -3.44 6.05 13.01 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
462 -3.34 5.94 12.89 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
463 -3.42 6.26 13.21 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
464 -3.32 6.15 13.09 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
465 -199.26 479.43 520.81 167.64 ACCEPTABLE
466 -200.45 486.87 528.18 161.26 ACCEPTABLE
467 -199.17 479.43 520.81 165.05 ACCEPTABLE
468 -3.38 6.10 13.05 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
469 -3.35 6.17 13.10 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
470 -3.33 6.24 13.15 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
471 -3.37 6.17 13.07 5.90 ACCEPTABLE
472 -3.43 6.42 13.31 7.95 ACCEPTABLE
473 -3.36 6.32 13.20 7.92 ACCEPTABLE

40
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
474 -3.39 6.31 13.23 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
475 -3.25 6.06 13.02 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
476 -3.36 6.24 13.18 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
477 -3.30 6.17 13.10 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
478 -3.31 6.13 13.11 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
479 -3.34 6.10 13.02 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
480 -3.45 6.28 13.18 7.95 ACCEPTABLE
481 -3.39 6.21 13.10 6.07 ACCEPTABLE
482 -3.40 6.17 13.10 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
483 -3.30 5.96 12.93 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
484 -3.27 5.92 12.89 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
485 -3.37 6.10 13.05 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
486 -3.31 6.03 12.97 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
487 -3.33 5.99 12.97 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
488 -3.39 6.13 13.07 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
489 -3.33 6.07 12.99 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
490 -3.37 6.28 13.21 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
491 -3.31 6.21 13.13 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
492 -200.66 487.73 529.03 163.11 ACCEPTABLE
493 -200.61 487.73 529.03 161.73 ACCEPTABLE
494 -3.35 6.17 13.10 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
495 -3.33 6.22 13.13 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
496 -3.36 6.17 13.08 4.01 ACCEPTABLE
497 -3.41 6.34 13.24 5.91 ACCEPTABLE
498 -3.35 6.27 13.17 5.72 ACCEPTABLE
499 -3.38 6.26 13.19 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
500 -3.36 6.31 13.22 4.01 ACCEPTABLE
501 -3.39 6.26 13.17 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
502 -3.44 6.43 13.33 5.92 ACCEPTABLE
503 -3.38 6.36 13.26 5.90 ACCEPTABLE
504 -3.41 6.36 13.28 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
505 -3.31 6.19 13.14 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
506 -3.39 6.31 13.24 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
507 -3.34 6.26 13.19 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
508 -3.36 6.23 13.19 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
509 -3.37 6.21 13.14 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
510 -3.45 6.33 13.24 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
511 -3.40 6.29 13.19 6.08 ACCEPTABLE
512 -3.42 6.26 13.19 4.02 ACCEPTABLE
513 -3.35 6.12 13.08 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
514 -3.33 6.09 13.05 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
515 -3.40 6.21 13.15 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
516 -3.35 6.17 13.10 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
517 -3.37 6.14 13.10 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
518 -3.41 6.24 13.17 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
519 -3.36 6.19 13.12 2.29 ACCEPTABLE

41
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
520 -3.40 6.33 13.26 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
521 -3.38 6.38 13.30 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
522 -3.41 6.33 13.24 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
523 -3.46 6.50 13.40 6.09 ACCEPTABLE
524 -3.40 6.43 13.33 6.07 ACCEPTABLE
525 -3.43 6.43 13.35 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
526 -3.33 6.26 13.21 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
527 -3.41 6.38 13.31 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
528 -3.36 6.33 13.26 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
529 -3.38 6.30 13.26 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
530 -3.39 6.28 13.21 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
531 -3.47 6.40 13.31 7.95 ACCEPTABLE
532 -3.42 6.36 13.26 5.91 ACCEPTABLE
533 -3.44 6.33 13.26 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
534 -3.37 6.19 13.15 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
535 -3.34 6.16 13.12 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
536 -3.42 6.28 13.22 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
537 -3.37 6.23 13.17 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
538 -3.39 6.21 13.17 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
539 -3.43 6.31 13.24 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
540 -3.38 6.26 13.19 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
541 -3.42 6.40 13.33 4.02 ACCEPTABLE
542 -3.37 6.35 13.28 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
543 -200.76 488.67 529.96 162.46 ACCEPTABLE
544 -200.72 488.67 529.96 160.42 ACCEPTABLE
545 -3.40 6.33 13.26 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
546 -3.39 6.36 13.28 4.02 ACCEPTABLE
547 -3.41 6.33 13.25 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
548 -3.44 6.44 13.36 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
549 -3.40 6.40 13.31 6.08 ACCEPTABLE
550 -3.42 6.39 13.32 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
551 -3.36 6.28 13.23 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
552 -3.40 6.36 13.30 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
553 -3.38 6.33 13.26 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
554 -3.38 6.31 13.26 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
555 -3.40 6.30 13.22 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
556 -3.44 6.38 13.29 7.43 ACCEPTABLE
557 -3.42 6.35 13.26 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
558 -3.42 6.33 13.26 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
559 -3.38 6.23 13.18 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
560 -3.36 6.22 13.17 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
561 -3.41 6.30 13.24 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
562 -3.38 6.27 13.20 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
563 -3.39 6.25 13.20 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
564 -3.42 6.31 13.25 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
565 -3.39 6.28 13.21 2.29 ACCEPTABLE

42
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
566 -3.41 6.38 13.31 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
567 -3.38 6.35 13.27 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
568 -202.41 498.51 539.71 160.54 ACCEPTABLE
569 5.61 4.22 10.82 111.65 ACCEPTABLE
570 -1.24 3.93 17.55 3.53 ACCEPTABLE
571 0.45 16.00 23.48 2.83 ACCEPTABLE
572 -1.01 10.68 22.09 3.05 ACCEPTABLE
573 7.91 3.67 11.51 122.58 ACCEPTABLE
574 0.31 4.45 19.15 3.78 ACCEPTABLE
575 -6.62 15.99 23.47 2.53 ACCEPTABLE
576 -4.96 29.26 36.49 2.79 ACCEPTABLE
577 0.45 15.99 23.47 2.83 ACCEPTABLE
578 0.14 5.25 19.43 3.64 ACCEPTABLE
579 -9.26 9.04 16.04 132.66 ACCEPTABLE
580 -7.80 4.89 13.27 28.12 ACCEPTABLE
581 -0.20 18.44 25.50 2.79 ACCEPTABLE
582 -157.05 232.48 280.06 7283.57 ACCEPTABLE
583 -6.62 15.99 23.46 2.53 ACCEPTABLE
584 -1.90 15.98 23.45 2.64 ACCEPTABLE
585 -8.54 14.88 20.57 118.36 ACCEPTABLE
586 -50.73 199.83 209.08 94.84 ACCEPTABLE
587 1.40 3.54 15.60 3.62 ACCEPTABLE
588 -1.91 15.99 23.46 2.64 ACCEPTABLE
589 -1.75 7.87 19.58 3.07 ACCEPTABLE
590 -5.04 6.11 13.20 27.43 ACCEPTABLE
591 -22.51 55.49 61.33 184.67 ACCEPTABLE
592 -40.46 94.97 104.61 193.75 ACCEPTABLE
593 -8.52 11.57 18.66 87.20 ACCEPTABLE
594 -5.87 3.26 13.43 2.93 ACCEPTABLE
595 -4.76 5.41 12.73 8.46 ACCEPTABLE
596 -5.67 25.11 32.32 2.70 ACCEPTABLE
597 -2.65 18.77 25.77 2.62 ACCEPTABLE
598 -247.57 762.73 802.36 269.09 ACCEPTABLE
599 -242.85 762.73 802.36 130.67 ACCEPTABLE
600 -6.62 15.99 23.46 2.53 ACCEPTABLE
601 -4.21 18.75 25.75 2.56 ACCEPTABLE
602 -8.38 17.21 23.15 99.79 ACCEPTABLE
603 -17.89 71.72 77.24 89.80 ACCEPTABLE
604 -11.99 48.03 53.54 83.23 ACCEPTABLE
605 -1.11 7.08 17.23 2.90 ACCEPTABLE
606 -3.48 15.99 23.46 2.56 ACCEPTABLE
607 -3.15 9.98 20.15 2.79 ACCEPTABLE
608 -5.89 9.91 16.93 38.57 ACCEPTABLE
609 -13.06 30.31 35.93 117.74 ACCEPTABLE
610 -12.50 29.25 34.75 117.22 ACCEPTABLE
611 -7.93 13.11 20.30 58.47 ACCEPTABLE

43
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
612 -5.15 3.83 14.33 2.90 ACCEPTABLE
613 -3.22 2.08 12.29 2.95 ACCEPTABLE
614 -6.23 7.42 16.23 2.59 ACCEPTABLE
615 -4.54 5.95 14.17 2.47 ACCEPTABLE
616 -1.13 5.16 13.71 2.70 ACCEPTABLE
617 -4.84 4.37 11.02 87.07 ACCEPTABLE
618 -10.70 31.34 37.23 89.33 ACCEPTABLE
619 -5.70 18.55 24.38 79.21 ACCEPTABLE
620 -5.97 13.54 21.54 2.53 ACCEPTABLE
621 -5.01 9.93 18.96 2.60 ACCEPTABLE
622 -1.40 5.95 14.17 2.62 ACCEPTABLE
623 -3.69 4.96 16.18 2.97 ACCEPTABLE
624 -9.79 12.11 18.69 138.21 ACCEPTABLE
625 -7.03 8.95 14.71 135.01 ACCEPTABLE
626 -7.68 5.95 14.17 26.67 ACCEPTABLE
627 -7.06 4.14 13.17 2.84 ACCEPTABLE
628 -5.64 12.29 20.60 2.54 ACCEPTABLE
629 -1.62 6.60 14.57 2.56 ACCEPTABLE
630 -259.79 856.03 895.35 197.03 ACCEPTABLE
631 -311.36 1299.75 1338.25 122.88 ACCEPTABLE
632 -256.65 856.03 895.35 135.67 ACCEPTABLE
633 -4.54 5.95 14.17 2.47 ACCEPTABLE
634 -2.61 6.42 14.46 2.49 ACCEPTABLE
635 -4.92 5.38 12.37 37.88 ACCEPTABLE
636 -7.74 18.58 25.15 73.78 ACCEPTABLE
637 -4.68 12.48 18.99 69.24 ACCEPTABLE
638 -5.53 10.86 18.90 2.48 ACCEPTABLE
639 -1.19 2.26 12.35 3.05 ACCEPTABLE
640 -4.89 8.64 17.37 2.54 ACCEPTABLE
641 -2.45 5.95 14.17 2.52 ACCEPTABLE
642 -3.91 5.21 15.41 2.79 ACCEPTABLE
643 -3.88 2.92 10.89 2.50 ACCEPTABLE
644 -7.99 9.93 16.94 92.28 ACCEPTABLE
645 -5.79 7.44 13.88 93.35 ACCEPTABLE
646 -6.63 5.95 14.17 2.59 ACCEPTABLE
647 -5.75 3.36 12.80 2.79 ACCEPTABLE
648 -6.26 4.84 13.53 2.65 ACCEPTABLE
649 -3.75 2.61 10.74 2.54 ACCEPTABLE
650 -5.28 10.00 18.28 2.50 ACCEPTABLE
651 -2.65 6.55 14.54 2.48 ACCEPTABLE
652 -215.69 561.60 602.28 271.16 ACCEPTABLE
653 -248.25 791.57 831.10 145.14 ACCEPTABLE
654 -213.59 561.60 602.28 168.21 ACCEPTABLE
655 -4.54 5.95 14.17 2.47 ACCEPTABLE
656 -3.37 6.60 14.58 2.44 ACCEPTABLE
657 -2.25 7.41 15.12 2.48 ACCEPTABLE

44
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
658 -3.72 6.42 13.53 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
659 -2.83 7.71 14.47 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
660 -4.13 6.13 12.50 84.53 ACCEPTABLE
661 -6.34 15.29 21.42 80.00 ACCEPTABLE
662 -4.22 11.27 17.37 75.03 ACCEPTABLE
663 -4.62 10.26 17.20 18.65 ACCEPTABLE
664 -1.26 3.70 11.85 2.65 ACCEPTABLE
665 -3.91 8.16 15.64 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
666 -2.32 6.42 13.53 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
667 -3.05 5.64 13.99 2.51 ACCEPTABLE
668 -3.40 4.53 11.36 17.17 ACCEPTABLE
669 -6.25 9.32 15.73 90.66 ACCEPTABLE
670 -4.90 7.81 13.85 91.73 ACCEPTABLE
671 -5.12 6.42 13.53 27.50 ACCEPTABLE
672 -2.87 2.16 10.54 2.63 ACCEPTABLE
673 -4.29 4.31 12.18 2.44 ACCEPTABLE
674 -2.75 3.11 10.48 2.42 ACCEPTABLE
675 -3.72 2.84 11.42 2.60 ACCEPTABLE
676 -4.73 5.44 12.87 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
677 -3.12 3.92 10.96 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
678 -4.30 9.31 16.47 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
679 -2.63 7.21 14.09 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
680 -220.99 596.88 637.32 228.38 ACCEPTABLE
681 -242.71 750.20 789.87 155.43 ACCEPTABLE
682 -3.72 6.42 13.53 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
683 -3.18 7.41 14.24 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
684 -4.02 6.33 12.91 63.00 ACCEPTABLE
685 -5.30 11.65 18.09 73.69 ACCEPTABLE
686 -3.93 9.34 15.74 73.93 ACCEPTABLE
687 -4.33 8.93 15.92 10.22 ACCEPTABLE
688 -2.07 4.59 12.35 2.48 ACCEPTABLE
689 -3.86 7.59 14.94 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
690 -2.79 6.42 13.53 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
691 -3.24 5.86 13.79 2.43 ACCEPTABLE
692 -3.53 5.19 12.09 12.48 ACCEPTABLE
693 -5.40 8.32 14.94 80.57 ACCEPTABLE
694 -4.42 7.24 13.60 82.58 ACCEPTABLE
695 -4.65 6.42 13.53 16.49 ACCEPTABLE
696 -3.09 3.35 11.31 2.49 ACCEPTABLE
697 -2.51 2.84 10.68 2.52 ACCEPTABLE
698 -4.12 5.07 12.64 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
699 -3.08 4.15 11.42 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
700 -3.65 3.86 11.93 2.48 ACCEPTABLE
701 -4.40 5.78 13.10 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
702 -3.32 4.71 11.78 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
703 -4.11 8.30 15.45 2.32 ACCEPTABLE

45
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
704 -3.00 6.97 13.92 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
705 -201.02 485.20 526.52 190.02 ACCEPTABLE
706 -214.88 574.52 615.10 147.81 ACCEPTABLE
707 -200.09 485.20 526.52 159.37 ACCEPTABLE
708 -3.72 6.42 13.53 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
709 -3.38 7.13 14.04 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
710 -3.08 7.96 14.66 17.21 ACCEPTABLE
711 -3.62 7.13 13.68 54.99 ACCEPTABLE
712 -4.46 10.64 17.11 71.17 ACCEPTABLE
713 -3.54 9.14 15.59 72.32 ACCEPTABLE
714 -3.82 8.90 15.73 14.59 ACCEPTABLE
715 -2.25 5.82 13.13 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
716 -3.46 7.92 14.99 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
717 -2.76 7.13 14.04 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
718 -3.00 6.67 14.10 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
719 -3.28 6.31 13.08 17.00 ACCEPTABLE
720 -4.53 8.49 15.07 65.23 ACCEPTABLE
721 -3.87 7.74 14.16 76.84 ACCEPTABLE
722 -4.00 7.13 14.04 13.89 ACCEPTABLE
723 -2.87 4.80 12.26 2.39 ACCEPTABLE
724 -2.49 4.44 11.82 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
725 -3.62 6.16 13.35 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
726 -2.93 5.47 12.49 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
727 -3.23 5.16 12.70 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
728 -3.82 6.66 13.70 4.23 ACCEPTABLE
729 -3.11 5.91 12.79 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
730 -3.65 8.43 15.37 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
731 -2.93 7.57 14.36 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
732 -203.29 499.48 540.67 177.51 ACCEPTABLE
733 -212.53 559.03 599.72 152.35 ACCEPTABLE
734 -202.67 499.48 540.67 163.15 ACCEPTABLE
735 -3.38 7.13 14.04 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
736 -3.19 7.70 14.47 11.58 ACCEPTABLE
737 -3.54 7.15 13.81 34.13 ACCEPTABLE
738 -4.07 9.36 15.97 47.31 ACCEPTABLE
739 -3.47 8.42 15.01 41.84 ACCEPTABLE
740 -3.67 8.30 15.15 11.85 ACCEPTABLE
741 -2.62 6.25 13.42 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
742 -3.44 7.66 14.68 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
743 -2.97 7.13 14.04 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
744 -3.12 6.81 14.07 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
745 -3.31 6.59 13.40 13.39 ACCEPTABLE
746 -4.15 8.03 14.71 41.45 ACCEPTABLE
747 -3.69 7.51 14.09 49.57 ACCEPTABLE
748 -3.79 7.13 14.04 9.98 ACCEPTABLE
749 -3.02 5.51 12.79 2.35 ACCEPTABLE

46
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
750 -2.77 5.26 12.48 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
751 -3.55 6.49 13.59 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
752 -3.08 6.01 12.99 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
753 -3.26 5.76 13.09 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
754 -3.67 6.82 13.82 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
755 -3.20 6.31 13.20 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
756 -3.56 7.99 14.92 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
757 -3.08 7.43 14.26 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
758 -204.30 509.73 550.83 157.99 ACCEPTABLE
759 -210.46 549.46 590.22 145.33 ACCEPTABLE
760 -203.89 509.73 550.83 146.87 ACCEPTABLE
761 -3.38 7.13 14.04 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
762 -3.26 7.52 14.33 7.90 ACCEPTABLE
763 -3.49 7.15 13.89 20.97 ACCEPTABLE
764 -3.83 8.57 15.28 29.23 ACCEPTABLE
765 -3.43 7.97 14.66 24.86 ACCEPTABLE
766 -3.58 7.90 14.77 8.01 ACCEPTABLE
767 -2.87 6.54 13.62 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
768 -3.42 7.49 14.46 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
769 -3.10 7.13 14.04 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
770 -3.20 6.91 14.05 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
771 -3.34 6.77 13.61 9.75 ACCEPTABLE
772 -3.89 7.73 14.48 27.24 ACCEPTABLE
773 -3.58 7.38 14.06 30.54 ACCEPTABLE
774 -3.66 7.13 14.04 8.03 ACCEPTABLE
775 -3.13 6.02 13.17 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
776 -2.97 5.85 12.97 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
777 -3.49 6.71 13.74 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
778 -3.18 6.38 13.33 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
779 -3.29 6.19 13.38 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
780 -3.58 6.92 13.89 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
781 -3.26 6.58 13.48 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
782 -3.14 6.96 13.75 9.68 ACCEPTABLE
783 -3.37 6.59 13.32 22.66 ACCEPTABLE
784 -3.71 7.97 14.67 29.98 ACCEPTABLE
785 -3.31 7.38 14.07 22.82 ACCEPTABLE
786 -3.46 7.33 14.19 7.95 ACCEPTABLE
787 -2.76 6.02 13.08 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
788 -3.30 6.93 13.90 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
789 -2.98 6.58 13.48 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
790 -3.08 6.37 13.51 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
791 -3.22 6.23 13.06 9.69 ACCEPTABLE
792 -3.77 7.15 13.90 26.84 ACCEPTABLE
793 -3.46 6.81 13.49 30.27 ACCEPTABLE
794 -3.54 6.58 13.48 7.98 ACCEPTABLE
795 -3.01 5.51 12.65 2.33 ACCEPTABLE

47
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
796 -2.85 5.35 12.45 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
797 -3.37 6.18 13.19 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
798 -3.06 5.85 12.80 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
799 -3.17 5.68 12.85 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
800 -3.46 6.38 13.34 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
801 -3.14 6.04 12.93 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
802 -3.38 7.13 14.04 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
803 -3.06 6.77 13.62 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
804 -205.32 516.24 557.27 155.80 ACCEPTABLE
805 -205.05 516.24 557.27 149.56 ACCEPTABLE
806 -3.26 6.58 13.48 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
807 -3.18 6.83 13.66 7.86 ACCEPTABLE
808 -3.33 6.59 13.38 15.23 ACCEPTABLE
809 -3.55 7.49 14.25 19.17 ACCEPTABLE
810 -3.29 7.10 13.86 15.24 ACCEPTABLE
811 -3.39 7.08 13.95 7.92 ACCEPTABLE
812 -2.92 6.20 13.21 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
813 -3.29 6.81 13.76 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
814 -3.08 6.58 13.48 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
815 -3.14 6.44 13.49 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
816 -3.23 6.35 13.20 7.86 ACCEPTABLE
817 -3.60 6.96 13.76 17.87 ACCEPTABLE
818 -3.39 6.73 13.48 18.96 ACCEPTABLE
819 -3.44 6.58 13.48 6.08 ACCEPTABLE
820 -3.09 5.86 12.91 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
821 -2.98 5.74 12.78 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
822 -3.34 6.31 13.29 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
823 -3.13 6.09 13.02 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
824 -3.20 5.97 13.05 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
825 -3.39 6.45 13.39 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
826 -3.18 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
827 -3.10 6.47 13.29 7.83 ACCEPTABLE
828 -3.25 6.22 13.00 15.65 ACCEPTABLE
829 -3.47 7.10 13.86 19.06 ACCEPTABLE
830 -3.21 6.73 13.48 15.16 ACCEPTABLE
831 -3.31 6.71 13.57 7.89 ACCEPTABLE
832 -2.85 5.85 12.85 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
833 -3.21 6.45 13.38 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
834 -3.00 6.22 13.11 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
835 -3.06 6.09 13.13 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
836 -3.15 5.99 12.84 6.01 ACCEPTABLE
837 -3.51 6.59 13.37 19.11 ACCEPTABLE
838 -3.31 6.36 13.10 18.86 ACCEPTABLE
839 -3.36 6.22 13.11 6.07 ACCEPTABLE
840 -3.01 5.51 12.56 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
841 -2.90 5.40 12.43 2.32 ACCEPTABLE

48
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
842 -3.26 5.96 12.93 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
843 -3.05 5.74 12.66 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
844 -3.12 5.62 12.70 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
845 -3.31 6.09 13.02 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
846 -3.10 5.87 12.75 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
847 -3.26 6.58 13.48 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
848 -3.05 6.35 13.20 4.16 ACCEPTABLE
849 -204.45 512.38 553.45 150.17 ACCEPTABLE
850 -3.18 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
851 -3.13 6.39 13.23 7.83 ACCEPTABLE
852 -3.23 6.22 13.04 11.52 ACCEPTABLE
853 -3.37 6.80 13.60 13.44 ACCEPTABLE
854 -3.20 6.56 13.35 13.32 ACCEPTABLE
855 -3.27 6.54 13.42 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
856 -2.96 5.98 12.94 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
857 -3.20 6.37 13.29 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
858 -3.06 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
859 -3.10 6.13 13.12 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
860 -3.16 6.07 12.93 6.01 ACCEPTABLE
861 -3.40 6.47 13.29 13.45 ACCEPTABLE
862 -3.26 6.31 13.10 13.35 ACCEPTABLE
863 -3.30 6.22 13.11 4.19 ACCEPTABLE
864 -3.07 5.74 12.74 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
865 -2.99 5.67 12.65 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
866 -3.23 6.05 12.99 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
867 -3.09 5.90 12.81 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
868 -3.14 5.82 12.83 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
869 -3.27 6.13 13.05 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
870 -3.13 5.98 12.87 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
871 -3.23 6.46 13.35 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
872 -3.09 6.30 13.17 4.16 ACCEPTABLE
873 -199.28 480.95 522.32 157.72 ACCEPTABLE
874 -199.15 480.95 522.32 157.26 ACCEPTABLE
875 -3.18 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
876 -3.14 6.33 13.19 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
877 -3.21 6.22 13.06 7.85 ACCEPTABLE
878 -3.31 6.60 13.43 9.73 ACCEPTABLE
879 -3.19 6.44 13.27 7.85 ACCEPTABLE
880 -3.24 6.44 13.31 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
881 -3.03 6.06 13.00 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
882 -3.19 6.32 13.23 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
883 -3.10 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
884 -3.13 6.16 13.12 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
885 -3.17 6.12 12.99 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
886 -3.33 6.38 13.23 9.74 ACCEPTABLE
887 -3.24 6.28 13.11 9.70 ACCEPTABLE

49
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
888 -3.26 6.22 13.11 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
889 -3.10 5.90 12.86 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
890 -3.06 5.85 12.80 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
891 -3.21 6.11 13.03 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
892 -3.12 6.01 12.91 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
893 -3.15 5.95 12.92 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
894 -3.24 6.16 13.07 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
895 -3.14 6.06 12.95 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
896 -3.22 6.38 13.27 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
897 -3.12 6.28 13.15 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
898 -199.57 482.81 524.16 159.92 ACCEPTABLE
899 -199.49 482.81 524.16 157.88 ACCEPTABLE
900 -3.18 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
901 -3.16 6.29 13.16 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
902 -3.20 6.22 13.08 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
903 -3.26 6.47 13.33 7.87 ACCEPTABLE
904 -3.19 6.37 13.22 5.69 ACCEPTABLE
905 -3.22 6.36 13.25 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
906 -3.08 6.11 13.03 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
907 -3.19 6.29 13.19 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
908 -3.13 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
909 -3.14 6.18 13.11 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
910 -3.17 6.15 13.03 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
911 -3.28 6.33 13.19 7.87 ACCEPTABLE
912 -3.22 6.26 13.11 7.86 ACCEPTABLE
913 -3.23 6.22 13.11 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
914 -3.13 6.00 12.94 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
915 -3.10 5.97 12.90 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
916 -3.20 6.14 13.06 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
917 -3.14 6.08 12.98 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
918 -3.16 6.04 12.98 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
919 -3.22 6.18 13.08 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
920 -3.16 6.11 13.00 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
921 -3.20 6.33 13.22 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
922 -3.14 6.26 13.14 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
923 -199.77 484.05 525.38 155.98 ACCEPTABLE
924 -199.72 484.05 525.38 156.33 ACCEPTABLE
925 -3.18 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
926 -3.16 6.27 13.15 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
927 -3.19 6.22 13.09 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
928 -3.24 6.39 13.25 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
929 -3.18 6.32 13.18 6.01 ACCEPTABLE
930 -3.21 6.32 13.20 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
931 -3.11 6.15 13.06 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
932 -3.19 6.27 13.16 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
933 -3.14 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE

50
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
934 -3.16 6.19 13.11 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
935 -3.17 6.17 13.06 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
936 -3.25 6.29 13.16 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
937 -3.20 6.25 13.11 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
938 -3.22 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
939 -3.20 6.27 13.15 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
940 -3.23 6.22 13.09 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
941 -3.28 6.39 13.25 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
942 -3.22 6.32 13.18 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
943 -3.25 6.32 13.20 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
944 -3.15 6.15 13.06 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
945 -3.23 6.27 13.16 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
946 -3.18 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
947 -3.20 6.19 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
948 -3.21 6.17 13.06 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
949 -3.29 6.29 13.16 7.88 ACCEPTABLE
950 -3.24 6.25 13.11 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
951 -3.26 6.22 13.11 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
952 -3.19 6.08 13.00 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
953 -3.16 6.05 12.97 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
954 -3.24 6.17 13.07 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
955 -3.19 6.12 13.02 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
956 -3.21 6.10 13.02 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
957 -3.25 6.19 13.09 4.01 ACCEPTABLE
958 -3.20 6.15 13.04 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
959 -3.24 6.29 13.18 4.01 ACCEPTABLE
960 -3.19 6.25 13.13 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
961 -199.90 484.87 526.20 155.19 ACCEPTABLE
962 -199.87 484.87 526.20 154.45 ACCEPTABLE
963 -3.22 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
964 -3.21 6.25 13.13 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
965 -3.23 6.22 13.10 4.01 ACCEPTABLE
966 -3.26 6.33 13.20 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
967 -3.22 6.29 13.16 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
968 -3.24 6.28 13.17 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
969 -3.18 6.17 13.08 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
970 -3.22 6.25 13.15 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
971 -3.20 6.22 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
972 -3.20 6.20 13.11 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
973 -3.22 6.19 13.07 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
974 -3.26 6.27 13.14 7.86 ACCEPTABLE
975 -3.24 6.24 13.11 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
976 -3.24 6.22 13.11 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
977 -3.20 6.12 13.03 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
978 -3.18 6.11 13.02 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
979 -3.23 6.19 13.09 4.01 ACCEPTABLE

51
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
980 -3.20 6.16 13.05 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
981 -3.21 6.14 13.05 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
982 -3.24 6.20 13.10 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
983 -3.21 6.17 13.06 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
984 -3.23 6.27 13.16 4.18 ACCEPTABLE
985 -3.20 6.24 13.12 4.17 ACCEPTABLE
986 -200.03 485.43 526.75 156.64 ACCEPTABLE
987 -200.39 487.64 528.94 156.44 ACCEPTABLE
988 -200.01 485.43 526.75 156.14 ACCEPTABLE
989 -3.40 6.33 13.26 2.29 ACCEPTABLE

3. STABILITAS LERENG DINDING PENAHAN TANAH/ DPT ( Tinggi 7


meter dan Lebar 1,6 meter )
- Dinding penahan tanah ini berada pada lokasi Headpond dengan tinggi 7 meter dan
pengurangan lebar DPT menjadi 1,6 meter

- Hasil Analisa Stabilitas Lereng dengan program GEO 5, diperoleh Safety factor/ SF 1,29 >
1,5 artinya Kondisi stabilitas lereng Dinding Penahan Tanah di lokasi headpond stabil.

- Analisa selengkapnya sebagai berikut :

Slope stability analysis

Input data

Project

Settings
Standard - safety factors (21)

Stability analysis

Earthquake analysis : Standard


Verification Safety factors (ASD)
methodology :

52
Safety factors
Seismic design situation
Safety factor : SFs = 1.50 [–]

Interface

Coordinates of interface points [m]


No. Interface location
x z x z x z
1 1.00 0.00 6.70 1.00

2 -16.75 -5.20 -1.50 -5.20 -0.50 0.30


0.00 0.30 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00

2.00 1.00 6.70 1.00 20.10 1.00

3 0.00 -5.70 6.70 1.00

4 -1.59 -6.70 0.00 -6.70 0.00 -5.70


0.00 0.00

5 -16.75 -6.70 -1.59 -6.70 -1.59 -5.70


-1.50 -5.20

Soil parameters - effective stress state

53
ef cef 
No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3]

1 Pasir Lepas 32.50 23.00 15.10

2 Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense 33.50 0.00 18.50

Soil parameters - uplift

sat s n
No. Name Pattern
[kN/m3] [kN/m3] [–]

1 Pasir Lepas 15.10

2 Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense 18.50

Soil parameters

Pasir Lepas
Unit weight :  = 15.10 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 32.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Saturated unit weight : sa = 15.10 kN/m3
t

Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense


Unit weight :  = 18.50 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 33.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 0.00 kPa
Saturated unit weight : sa = 18.50 kN/m3
t

Rigid bodies

54

No. Name Sample
[kN/m3]

1 Material of structure 22.00

Assigning and surfaces

Coordinates of surface points


Assigned
No. Surface position [m]
x z x z soil
1 2.00 1.00 1.00 0.00 Poorly graded sand (SP), medium
6.70 1.00 dense

2 0.00 -5.70 6.70 1.00 Poorly graded sand (SP), medium


1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 dense

3 -1.59 -5.70 -1.59 -6.70


Material of structure
0.00 -6.70 0.00 -5.70

0.00 0.00 0.00 0.30

-0.50 0.30 -1.50 -5.20

4 -1.59 -6.70 -1.59 -5.70


Pasir Lepas
-1.50 -5.20 -16.75 -5.20

-16.75 -6.70

5 -16.75 -6.70 -16.75 -11.70 Poorly graded sand (SP), medium


20.10 -11.70 20.10 1.00 dense

6.70 1.00 0.00 -5.70

0.00 -6.70 -1.59 -6.70

Surcharge

55
Location Origin Length Width Slope Magnitude
No. Type Type of action
z [m] x [m] l [m] b [m]  [°] q, q1, f, F q2 unit

1 strip permanent on terrain x = 2.00 l = 3.00 0.00 7.60 kN/m2

2 strip permanent z = -7.50 x = 0.00 l = 3.00 0.00 5.00 kN/m2

3 strip permanent on terrain x = -16.75 l = 15.16 0.00 0.50 kN/m2

Surcharges

No. Name

1 Q
2 MATRAS

Water

Water type : No water

Tensile crack

Tensile crack not input.

Earthquake

Earthquake not included.

Settings of the stage of construction

Design situation : seismic

Results (Stage of construction 1)

Analysis 1
Circular slip surface

Slip surface parameters


x= -2.96 [m] 1 = -39.22 [°]
Center : Angles :
z= 1.68 [m] 2 = 85.61 [°]

56
Slip surface parameters
Radius : R= 8.88 [m]
The slip surface after optimization.

Slope stability verification (Bishop)


Sum of active forces : Fa = 378.38 kN/m
Sum of passive forces : Fp = 726.62 kN/m

Sliding moment : Ma = 3360.01 kNm/m


Resisting moment : Mp 6452.41 kNm/m
=

Factor of safety = 1.92 > 1.50


Slope stability ACCEPTABLE
Optimization of circular slip surface (Bishop)
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
1 -5.92 16.39 23.85 2.47 ACCEPTABLE
2 -5.92 16.39 23.85 2.47 ACCEPTABLE
3 -5.92 16.39 23.85 2.47 ACCEPTABLE
4 1.37 16.39 23.85 3.40 ACCEPTABLE
5 0.25 5.29 19.81 4.79 ACCEPTABLE
6 -8.94 8.94 16.05 75.99 ACCEPTABLE
7 -7.77 4.87 13.36 43.41 ACCEPTABLE
8 -3.31 1.08 8.32 12.47 ACCEPTABLE
9 1.18 17.24 24.54 3.39 ACCEPTABLE
10 -182.90 600.51 628.27 308.45 ACCEPTABLE
11 -175.61 600.51 628.27 84.16 ACCEPTABLE
12 -5.92 16.39 23.85 2.47 ACCEPTABLE
13 -0.46 13.64 21.69 3.00 ACCEPTABLE
14 -8.71 18.44 23.77 70.09 ACCEPTABLE
15 1.87 2.98 15.41 4.42 ACCEPTABLE
16 -4.06 21.63 29.60 2.95 ACCEPTABLE
17 -1.06 16.39 23.85 2.93 ACCEPTABLE
18 -1.55 8.00 19.98 3.76 ACCEPTABLE
19 -4.21 4.91 12.29 6.72 ACCEPTABLE
20 -26.88 84.27 90.06 136.00 ACCEPTABLE
21 -105.47 309.24 328.27 141.67 ACCEPTABLE
22 -8.14 11.78 18.95 51.86 ACCEPTABLE
23 -5.88 3.04 13.48 3.06 ACCEPTABLE
24 -3.07 1.49 10.52 2.49 ACCEPTABLE
25 -7.30 8.52 16.54 25.29 ACCEPTABLE
26 -4.24 5.01 12.35 11.45 ACCEPTABLE
27 -1.49 18.37 25.49 2.93 ACCEPTABLE
28 -265.81 1424.85 1451.70 99.20 ACCEPTABLE
29 -194.19 735.85 763.31 96.34 ACCEPTABLE

57
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]

30 -5.92 16.39 23.85 2.47 ACCEPTABLE


31 -3.00 17.84 25.04 2.72 ACCEPTABLE
32 -7.96 19.36 25.03 58.12 ACCEPTABLE
33 -17.27 84.68 89.88 68.22 ACCEPTABLE
34 -11.42 56.34 61.56 57.57 ACCEPTABLE
35 -0.55 6.64 17.05 3.31 ACCEPTABLE
36 -4.79 20.08 27.88 2.78 ACCEPTABLE
37 -2.68 16.39 23.85 2.71 ACCEPTABLE
38 -2.89 10.23 20.61 3.21 ACCEPTABLE
39 -5.11 9.32 16.44 37.23 ACCEPTABLE
40 -12.82 35.38 40.75 74.68 ACCEPTABLE
41 -11.94 33.42 38.63 74.21 ACCEPTABLE
42 -7.53 13.55 20.80 43.83 ACCEPTABLE
43 -4.87 3.48 14.15 3.08 ACCEPTABLE
44 -2.93 1.60 12.00 3.01 ACCEPTABLE
45 -4.11 5.79 14.01 2.28 ACCEPTABLE
46 -0.42 4.21 13.12 2.82 ACCEPTABLE
47 -4.43 4.25 10.75 52.50 ACCEPTABLE
48 -10.10 35.50 41.13 56.51 ACCEPTABLE
49 -5.03 20.44 26.04 49.48 ACCEPTABLE
50 -5.31 13.63 21.67 2.53 ACCEPTABLE
51 -4.58 10.27 19.26 2.69 ACCEPTABLE
52 -0.87 5.79 14.01 2.61 ACCEPTABLE
53 -3.37 4.77 16.12 3.35 ACCEPTABLE
54 -9.47 13.27 19.60 71.47 ACCEPTABLE
55 -6.46 9.27 14.80 69.26 ACCEPTABLE
56 -7.35 5.79 14.01 36.35 ACCEPTABLE
57 -6.06 1.23 11.87 3.30 ACCEPTABLE
58 -6.83 3.97 12.99 2.66 ACCEPTABLE
59 -5.10 12.63 20.92 2.56 ACCEPTABLE
60 -0.98 6.19 14.26 2.57 ACCEPTABLE
61 -4.11 5.79 14.01 2.28 ACCEPTABLE
62 -1.97 5.86 14.05 2.45 ACCEPTABLE
63 -4.50 5.33 12.19 49.41 ACCEPTABLE
64 -7.09 19.94 26.34 47.86 ACCEPTABLE
65 -4.02 13.08 19.44 42.91 ACCEPTABLE
66 -4.95 10.88 18.94 2.42 ACCEPTABLE
67 -0.82 1.82 12.07 3.16 ACCEPTABLE
68 -4.46 8.82 17.52 2.54 ACCEPTABLE
69 -1.95 5.79 14.01 2.45 ACCEPTABLE
70 -3.56 5.02 15.31 2.96 ACCEPTABLE
71 -3.46 2.39 10.45 2.15 ACCEPTABLE
72 -1.10 1.82 10.19 2.49 ACCEPTABLE
73 -3.63 1.64 8.39 55.52 ACCEPTABLE
74 -6.33 13.60 19.89 49.53 ACCEPTABLE

58
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
75 -3.22 7.82 14.04 45.84 ACCEPTABLE
76 -4.32 6.54 14.48 2.22 ACCEPTABLE
77 -3.86 4.90 13.49 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
78 -1.30 2.39 10.45 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
79 -3.03 1.97 12.12 2.90 ACCEPTABLE
80 -6.75 5.59 12.37 69.20 ACCEPTABLE
81 -4.41 3.31 9.43 63.76 ACCEPTABLE
82 -5.62 2.39 10.45 16.35 ACCEPTABLE
83 -5.31 1.52 10.06 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
84 -4.18 6.03 14.16 2.26 ACCEPTABLE
85 -1.38 2.61 10.56 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
86 -170.70 530.76 558.73 169.56 ACCEPTABLE
87 -199.30 766.79 794.20 116.24 ACCEPTABLE
88 -168.54 530.76 558.73 117.78 ACCEPTABLE
89 -3.46 2.39 10.45 2.15 ACCEPTABLE
90 -2.05 2.48 10.49 2.26 ACCEPTABLE
91 -3.64 2.09 9.16 33.61 ACCEPTABLE
92 -5.13 8.64 15.49 43.92 ACCEPTABLE
93 -3.13 5.54 12.33 43.52 ACCEPTABLE
94 -4.06 5.09 13.05 2.18 ACCEPTABLE
95 -3.75 4.09 12.48 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
96 -2.02 2.39 10.45 2.27 ACCEPTABLE
97 -3.14 2.08 11.53 2.64 ACCEPTABLE
98 -5.66 4.53 11.66 54.00 ACCEPTABLE
99 -3.99 2.90 9.63 53.12 ACCEPTABLE
100 -4.90 2.39 10.45 2.16 ACCEPTABLE
101 -4.45 1.12 9.91 2.43 ACCEPTABLE
102 -4.72 1.87 10.21 2.26 ACCEPTABLE
103 -3.95 4.73 12.84 2.22 ACCEPTABLE
104 -2.10 2.62 10.57 2.24 ACCEPTABLE
105 -145.85 369.92 398.74 186.86 ACCEPTABLE
106 -163.93 496.20 524.31 125.07 ACCEPTABLE
107 -144.41 369.92 398.74 134.62 ACCEPTABLE
108 -3.46 2.39 10.45 2.15 ACCEPTABLE
109 -2.58 2.62 10.57 2.19 ACCEPTABLE
110 -3.60 2.26 9.62 6.32 ACCEPTABLE
111 -4.50 6.15 13.39 21.67 ACCEPTABLE
112 -3.19 4.33 11.53 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
113 -2.44 4.93 11.92 2.08 ACCEPTABLE
114 -3.43 4.22 10.81 48.72 ACCEPTABLE
115 -4.53 9.25 15.69 45.20 ACCEPTABLE
116 -3.17 6.99 13.39 44.58 ACCEPTABLE
117 -3.69 6.60 13.70 12.77 ACCEPTABLE
118 -1.61 2.58 10.54 2.30 ACCEPTABLE
119 -3.36 5.57 13.00 2.10 ACCEPTABLE
120 -2.23 4.33 11.53 2.11 ACCEPTABLE

59
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
121 -2.83 3.91 12.00 2.25 ACCEPTABLE
122 -2.94 3.00 10.03 14.14 ACCEPTABLE
123 -4.79 6.15 12.77 49.53 ACCEPTABLE
124 -3.72 4.95 11.32 50.65 ACCEPTABLE
125 -4.15 4.33 11.53 23.01 ACCEPTABLE
126 -2.76 1.56 9.67 2.20 ACCEPTABLE
127 -2.16 1.03 9.05 2.23 ACCEPTABLE
128 -3.75 3.21 10.87 2.04 ACCEPTABLE
129 -2.65 2.26 9.62 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
130 -1.83 2.60 9.80 2.09 ACCEPTABLE
131 -2.82 2.09 8.81 50.17 ACCEPTABLE
132 -3.88 6.26 12.85 46.03 ACCEPTABLE
133 -2.52 4.34 10.89 45.92 ACCEPTABLE
134 -3.13 4.14 11.42 2.01 ACCEPTABLE
135 -2.85 3.36 10.96 2.09 ACCEPTABLE
136 -1.69 2.26 9.62 2.13 ACCEPTABLE
137 -2.37 2.00 10.26 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
138 -2.35 1.06 8.28 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
139 -1.49 1.28 8.38 2.09 ACCEPTABLE
140 -3.59 4.63 11.09 50.22 ACCEPTABLE
141 -2.22 2.89 9.30 46.56 ACCEPTABLE
142 -2.84 2.75 9.89 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
143 -2.06 3.20 10.16 2.04 ACCEPTABLE
144 -3.03 2.58 9.10 51.08 ACCEPTABLE
145 -4.16 7.07 13.46 50.01 ACCEPTABLE
146 -2.78 5.03 11.37 45.46 ACCEPTABLE
147 -3.35 4.78 11.82 18.35 ACCEPTABLE
148 -1.27 1.21 9.12 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
149 -3.03 3.88 11.26 2.03 ACCEPTABLE
150 -1.88 2.75 9.89 2.07 ACCEPTABLE
151 -2.52 2.44 10.47 2.21 ACCEPTABLE
152 -2.56 1.53 8.51 14.55 ACCEPTABLE
153 -4.41 4.28 10.85 52.10 ACCEPTABLE
154 -3.32 3.22 9.52 53.46 ACCEPTABLE
155 -3.80 2.75 9.89 28.78 ACCEPTABLE
156 -3.41 1.76 9.37 2.01 ACCEPTABLE
157 -3.62 2.31 9.65 5.93 ACCEPTABLE
158 -2.45 1.30 8.39 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
159 -1.62 1.58 8.53 2.05 ACCEPTABLE
160 -2.60 1.11 7.58 54.79 ACCEPTABLE
161 -3.74 5.03 11.37 50.87 ACCEPTABLE
162 -2.36 3.22 9.52 47.36 ACCEPTABLE
163 -2.96 3.06 10.07 17.18 ACCEPTABLE
164 -2.66 2.31 9.65 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
165 -1.49 1.30 8.39 2.08 ACCEPTABLE
166 -2.17 1.07 9.06 2.21 ACCEPTABLE

60
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
167 -3.99 2.58 9.10 57.07 ACCEPTABLE
168 -2.88 1.65 7.88 56.41 ACCEPTABLE
169 -3.41 1.30 8.39 30.43 ACCEPTABLE
170 -2.84 2.75 9.89 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
171 -1.59 1.53 8.51 2.06 ACCEPTABLE
172 -148.80 389.52 418.20 171.22 ACCEPTABLE
173 -160.85 473.72 501.92 132.39 ACCEPTABLE
174 -147.84 389.52 418.20 135.60 ACCEPTABLE
175 -2.45 1.30 8.39 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
176 -1.93 1.57 8.53 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
177 -2.57 1.21 7.86 52.25 ACCEPTABLE
178 -3.27 3.60 10.18 47.11 ACCEPTABLE
179 -2.36 2.51 9.06 46.48 ACCEPTABLE
180 -2.80 2.45 9.48 13.70 ACCEPTABLE
181 -2.60 1.98 9.23 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
182 -1.81 1.30 8.39 2.03 ACCEPTABLE
183 -2.25 1.14 8.83 2.11 ACCEPTABLE
184 -3.48 2.16 8.85 53.14 ACCEPTABLE
185 -2.72 1.51 8.03 53.27 ACCEPTABLE
186 -3.09 1.30 8.39 21.24 ACCEPTABLE
187 -2.99 1.07 8.28 6.05 ACCEPTABLE
188 -2.71 2.25 9.37 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
189 -1.89 1.47 8.48 2.01 ACCEPTABLE
190 -125.17 258.76 288.90 151.59 ACCEPTABLE
191 -132.41 302.57 332.06 124.58 ACCEPTABLE
192 -124.53 258.76 288.90 127.38 ACCEPTABLE
193 -2.45 1.30 8.39 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
194 -2.12 1.51 8.50 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
195 -2.53 1.26 8.04 47.32 ACCEPTABLE
196 -2.98 2.76 9.51 46.78 ACCEPTABLE
197 -2.37 2.08 8.80 46.60 ACCEPTABLE
198 -2.68 2.06 9.11 8.00 ACCEPTABLE
199 -2.55 1.76 8.95 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
200 -2.02 1.30 8.39 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
201 -2.31 1.19 8.67 2.04 ACCEPTABLE
202 -3.14 1.88 8.69 51.22 ACCEPTABLE
203 -2.62 1.44 8.14 50.70 ACCEPTABLE
204 -2.88 1.30 8.39 14.67 ACCEPTABLE
205 -2.81 1.15 8.32 5.95 ACCEPTABLE
206 -2.62 1.92 9.03 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
207 -2.08 1.42 8.45 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
208 -126.35 265.78 295.80 144.83 ACCEPTABLE
209 -131.18 294.98 324.57 127.08 ACCEPTABLE
210 -125.92 265.78 295.80 130.78 ACCEPTABLE
211 -2.45 1.30 8.39 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
212 -2.24 1.46 8.47 1.96 ACCEPTABLE

61
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
213 -2.51 1.28 8.16 27.21 ACCEPTABLE
214 -2.80 2.24 9.10 35.64 ACCEPTABLE
215 -2.39 1.81 8.65 28.42 ACCEPTABLE
216 -2.61 1.80 8.86 5.96 ACCEPTABLE
217 -2.52 1.61 8.76 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
218 -2.17 1.30 8.39 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
219 -2.35 1.22 8.58 2.01 ACCEPTABLE
220 -2.91 1.69 8.59 36.35 ACCEPTABLE
221 -2.56 1.39 8.22 35.56 ACCEPTABLE
222 -2.73 1.30 8.39 9.18 ACCEPTABLE
223 -2.64 1.10 8.29 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
224 -2.42 1.24 8.36 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
225 -2.69 1.08 8.06 20.00 ACCEPTABLE
226 -2.98 2.01 8.97 27.25 ACCEPTABLE
227 -2.58 1.59 8.53 19.93 ACCEPTABLE
228 -2.79 1.58 8.75 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
229 -2.58 1.74 8.83 3.95 ACCEPTABLE
230 -2.85 1.56 8.52 24.61 ACCEPTABLE
231 -3.13 2.54 9.48 31.56 ACCEPTABLE
232 -2.73 2.10 9.02 24.40 ACCEPTABLE
233 -2.94 2.09 9.23 7.54 ACCEPTABLE
234 -2.33 1.17 8.56 2.02 ACCEPTABLE
235 -2.86 1.90 9.13 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
236 -2.51 1.58 8.75 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
237 -2.70 1.50 8.93 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
238 -2.71 1.26 8.37 5.93 ACCEPTABLE
239 -3.25 1.98 8.96 34.40 ACCEPTABLE
240 -2.90 1.67 8.58 32.71 ACCEPTABLE
241 -3.07 1.58 8.75 11.51 ACCEPTABLE
242 -2.98 1.37 8.65 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
243 -2.63 1.08 8.29 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
244 -2.83 1.02 8.49 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
245 -3.03 1.48 8.70 5.90 ACCEPTABLE
246 -2.67 1.18 8.33 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
247 -2.90 2.00 9.18 3.81 ACCEPTABLE
248 -2.54 1.67 8.79 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
249 -127.14 270.52 300.46 143.73 ACCEPTABLE
250 -130.36 289.99 319.64 130.95 ACCEPTABLE
251 -126.86 270.52 300.46 133.32 ACCEPTABLE
252 -2.79 1.58 8.75 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
253 -2.65 1.69 8.81 3.77 ACCEPTABLE
254 -2.83 1.57 8.60 15.97 ACCEPTABLE
255 -3.02 2.21 9.23 21.26 ACCEPTABLE
256 -2.75 1.92 8.93 14.07 ACCEPTABLE
257 -2.89 1.92 9.07 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
258 -2.48 1.31 8.62 1.99 ACCEPTABLE

62
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
259 -2.84 1.79 9.00 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
260 -2.60 1.58 8.75 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
261 -2.73 1.53 8.87 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
262 -2.74 1.36 8.50 3.95 ACCEPTABLE
263 -3.10 1.85 8.89 20.42 ACCEPTABLE
264 -2.86 1.64 8.63 22.08 ACCEPTABLE
265 -2.98 1.58 8.75 7.49 ACCEPTABLE
266 -2.69 1.10 8.45 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
267 -2.92 1.45 8.68 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
268 -2.69 1.25 8.44 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
269 -2.81 1.20 8.57 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
270 -2.95 1.52 8.72 3.98 ACCEPTABLE
271 -2.71 1.31 8.47 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
272 -2.87 1.86 9.04 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
273 -2.63 1.64 8.78 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
274 -131.49 293.44 323.04 148.46 ACCEPTABLE
275 -133.69 306.96 336.39 140.79 ACCEPTABLE
276 -131.30 293.44 323.04 138.74 ACCEPTABLE
277 -2.79 1.58 8.75 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
278 -2.70 1.66 8.79 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
279 -2.82 1.57 8.65 11.97 ACCEPTABLE
280 -2.94 1.99 9.06 14.16 ACCEPTABLE
281 -2.76 1.81 8.87 9.99 ACCEPTABLE
282 -2.86 1.81 8.96 3.98 ACCEPTABLE
283 -2.59 1.40 8.66 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
284 -2.82 1.72 8.92 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
285 -2.66 1.58 8.75 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
286 -2.75 1.54 8.83 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
287 -2.76 1.44 8.58 5.59 ACCEPTABLE
288 -2.99 1.76 8.84 14.16 ACCEPTABLE
289 -2.84 1.62 8.67 14.71 ACCEPTABLE
290 -2.92 1.58 8.75 5.64 ACCEPTABLE
291 -2.73 1.26 8.54 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
292 -2.64 1.19 8.46 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
293 -2.88 1.49 8.71 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
294 -2.72 1.36 8.54 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
295 -2.81 1.32 8.63 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
296 -2.90 1.54 8.73 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
297 -2.81 1.62 8.77 3.97 ACCEPTABLE
298 -2.93 1.53 8.63 12.95 ACCEPTABLE
299 -3.05 1.95 9.04 14.25 ACCEPTABLE
300 -2.87 1.76 8.84 11.14 ACCEPTABLE
301 -2.97 1.76 8.94 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
302 -2.70 1.36 8.64 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
303 -2.93 1.68 8.90 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
304 -2.77 1.54 8.73 1.94 ACCEPTABLE

63
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
305 -2.86 1.50 8.81 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
306 -2.87 1.40 8.56 5.98 ACCEPTABLE
307 -3.10 1.72 8.82 16.27 ACCEPTABLE
308 -2.95 1.58 8.65 16.08 ACCEPTABLE
309 -3.03 1.54 8.73 5.66 ACCEPTABLE
310 -2.84 1.22 8.53 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
311 -2.76 1.15 8.44 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
312 -2.99 1.45 8.69 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
313 -2.83 1.32 8.52 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
314 -2.92 1.29 8.61 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
315 -3.01 1.50 8.71 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
316 -2.85 1.36 8.54 3.96 ACCEPTABLE
317 -2.95 1.72 8.92 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
318 -2.86 1.80 8.96 3.98 ACCEPTABLE
319 -2.98 1.71 8.82 11.20 ACCEPTABLE
320 -3.10 2.14 9.24 14.34 ACCEPTABLE
321 -2.92 1.95 9.04 10.10 ACCEPTABLE
322 -3.02 1.95 9.13 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
323 -2.75 1.54 8.83 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
324 -2.98 1.86 9.09 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
325 -2.82 1.72 8.92 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
326 -2.91 1.68 9.00 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
327 -2.92 1.58 8.75 5.64 ACCEPTABLE
328 -3.15 1.90 9.01 16.93 ACCEPTABLE
329 -3.00 1.76 8.84 14.90 ACCEPTABLE
330 -3.08 1.72 8.92 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
331 -2.89 1.39 8.71 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
332 -2.81 1.32 8.63 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
333 -3.04 1.63 8.88 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
334 -2.88 1.49 8.71 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
335 -2.97 1.46 8.79 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
336 -3.06 1.68 8.90 3.81 ACCEPTABLE
337 -2.90 1.54 8.73 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
338 -3.00 1.91 9.11 3.81 ACCEPTABLE
339 -2.84 1.76 8.94 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
340 -131.86 295.67 325.24 144.56 ACCEPTABLE
341 -133.32 304.68 334.14 141.04 ACCEPTABLE
342 -131.73 295.67 325.24 141.35 ACCEPTABLE
343 -2.95 1.72 8.92 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
344 -2.89 1.77 8.95 3.80 ACCEPTABLE
345 -2.97 1.72 8.85 9.35 ACCEPTABLE
346 -3.05 2.00 9.13 10.17 ACCEPTABLE
347 -2.93 1.87 9.00 9.35 ACCEPTABLE
348 -3.00 1.87 9.06 5.68 ACCEPTABLE
349 -2.81 1.60 8.86 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
350 -2.97 1.82 9.03 1.93 ACCEPTABLE

64
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
351 -2.87 1.72 8.92 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
352 -2.92 1.69 8.97 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
353 -2.93 1.62 8.81 3.98 ACCEPTABLE
354 -3.09 1.84 8.98 12.22 ACCEPTABLE
355 -2.98 1.75 8.87 10.09 ACCEPTABLE
356 -3.03 1.72 8.92 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
357 -2.91 1.50 8.78 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
358 -2.85 1.45 8.72 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
359 -3.01 1.66 8.89 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
360 -2.90 1.57 8.78 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
361 -2.96 1.55 8.83 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
362 -3.02 1.69 8.91 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
363 -2.92 1.60 8.79 3.79 ACCEPTABLE
364 -2.98 1.84 9.05 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
365 -2.88 1.75 8.93 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
366 -133.85 306.37 335.81 146.94 ACCEPTABLE
367 -134.83 312.48 341.85 142.23 ACCEPTABLE
368 -133.77 306.37 335.81 146.29 ACCEPTABLE
369 -2.95 1.72 8.92 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
370 -2.91 1.76 8.94 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
371 -2.96 1.72 8.88 7.50 ACCEPTABLE
372 -3.02 1.90 9.06 7.54 ACCEPTABLE
373 -2.94 1.82 8.97 5.66 ACCEPTABLE
374 -2.98 1.82 9.01 3.81 ACCEPTABLE
375 -2.86 1.64 8.88 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
376 -2.96 1.78 9.00 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
377 -2.89 1.72 8.92 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
378 -2.93 1.70 8.96 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
379 -2.94 1.66 8.84 3.98 ACCEPTABLE
380 -3.04 1.80 8.96 8.09 ACCEPTABLE
381 -2.97 1.74 8.89 8.06 ACCEPTABLE
382 -3.01 1.72 8.92 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
383 -2.92 1.57 8.82 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
384 -2.89 1.54 8.79 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
385 -2.99 1.68 8.90 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
386 -2.92 1.62 8.83 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
387 -2.96 1.60 8.86 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
388 -3.00 1.70 8.91 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
389 -2.93 1.64 8.84 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
390 -2.97 1.80 9.01 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
391 -2.90 1.74 8.93 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
392 -134.01 307.38 336.81 147.87 ACCEPTABLE
393 -134.67 311.46 340.84 145.85 ACCEPTABLE
394 -133.96 307.38 336.81 146.60 ACCEPTABLE
395 -2.95 1.72 8.92 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
396 -2.92 1.74 8.93 1.93 ACCEPTABLE

65
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
397 -2.96 1.72 8.89 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
398 -2.99 1.84 9.01 7.52 ACCEPTABLE
399 -2.94 1.79 8.95 5.66 ACCEPTABLE
400 -2.97 1.79 8.98 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
401 -2.89 1.67 8.89 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
402 -2.96 1.76 8.97 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
403 -2.91 1.72 8.92 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
404 -2.94 1.71 8.94 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
405 -2.94 1.68 8.87 3.98 ACCEPTABLE
406 -3.01 1.77 8.95 7.52 ACCEPTABLE
407 -2.96 1.73 8.90 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
408 -2.99 1.72 8.92 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
409 -2.93 1.62 8.86 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
410 -2.91 1.60 8.83 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
411 -2.98 1.69 8.91 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
412 -2.93 1.65 8.86 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
413 -2.95 1.64 8.88 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
414 -2.98 1.71 8.91 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
415 -2.93 1.67 8.86 3.79 ACCEPTABLE
416 -2.97 1.78 8.98 3.80 ACCEPTABLE
417 -2.92 1.73 8.93 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
418 -134.12 308.06 337.48 146.48 ACCEPTABLE
419 -134.56 310.78 340.17 142.50 ACCEPTABLE
420 -134.08 308.06 337.48 145.49 ACCEPTABLE
421 -2.95 1.72 8.92 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
422 -2.93 1.74 8.93 3.80 ACCEPTABLE
423 -2.96 1.72 8.90 5.66 ACCEPTABLE
424 -2.98 1.80 8.98 5.67 ACCEPTABLE
425 -2.94 1.76 8.94 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
426 -2.96 1.76 8.96 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
427 -2.91 1.68 8.90 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
428 -2.96 1.75 8.95 3.80 ACCEPTABLE
429 -2.93 1.72 8.92 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
430 -2.94 1.71 8.94 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
431 -2.94 1.69 8.89 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
432 -2.99 1.76 8.94 6.04 ACCEPTABLE
433 -2.96 1.73 8.90 6.03 ACCEPTABLE
434 -2.97 1.72 8.92 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
435 -2.94 1.65 8.88 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
436 -2.92 1.64 8.86 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
437 -2.97 1.70 8.91 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
438 -2.94 1.68 8.88 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
439 -2.92 1.70 8.89 3.98 ACCEPTABLE
440 -2.95 1.68 8.86 3.80 ACCEPTABLE
441 -2.97 1.76 8.94 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
442 -2.93 1.72 8.90 3.98 ACCEPTABLE

66
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
443 -2.95 1.72 8.92 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
444 -2.90 1.64 8.86 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
445 -2.95 1.71 8.91 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
446 -2.92 1.68 8.88 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
447 -2.93 1.67 8.90 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
448 -2.93 1.65 8.85 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
449 -2.98 1.72 8.90 5.66 ACCEPTABLE
450 -2.95 1.69 8.86 6.02 ACCEPTABLE
451 -2.96 1.68 8.88 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
452 -2.94 1.70 8.89 3.80 ACCEPTABLE
453 -2.97 1.68 8.86 5.65 ACCEPTABLE
454 -2.99 1.76 8.94 6.04 ACCEPTABLE
455 -2.95 1.72 8.90 5.65 ACCEPTABLE
456 -2.97 1.72 8.92 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
457 -2.92 1.64 8.86 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
458 -2.97 1.71 8.91 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
459 -2.94 1.68 8.88 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
460 -2.95 1.67 8.90 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
461 -2.95 1.65 8.85 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
462 -3.00 1.72 8.90 7.52 ACCEPTABLE
463 -2.97 1.69 8.86 7.50 ACCEPTABLE
464 -2.98 1.68 8.88 3.80 ACCEPTABLE
465 -2.95 1.61 8.84 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
466 -2.93 1.60 8.82 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
467 -2.98 1.66 8.87 3.80 ACCEPTABLE
468 -2.95 1.64 8.84 3.79 ACCEPTABLE
469 -2.96 1.63 8.85 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
470 -2.98 1.67 8.88 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
471 -2.95 1.64 8.84 3.79 ACCEPTABLE
472 -2.97 1.72 8.92 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
473 -2.94 1.69 8.88 3.98 ACCEPTABLE
474 -134.20 308.51 337.93 147.59 ACCEPTABLE
475 -134.49 310.32 339.72 145.72 ACCEPTABLE
476 -134.17 308.51 337.93 145.48 ACCEPTABLE
477 -5.83 18.95 26.15 18.37 ACCEPTABLE
478 -3.04 25.60 33.63 3.22 ACCEPTABLE
479 3.01 8.76 18.59 3.97 ACCEPTABLE
480 2.36 11.83 20.61 3.66 ACCEPTABLE
481 0.52 4.71 19.74 5.01 ACCEPTABLE
482 -0.12 4.21 13.11 2.87 ACCEPTABLE
483 7.17 4.21 13.11 79.25 ACCEPTABLE
484 0.78 3.13 19.22 5.50 ACCEPTABLE
485 -7.41 4.21 13.11 9.39 ACCEPTABLE
486 -2.11 20.11 29.14 3.32 ACCEPTABLE
487 8.00 1.28 11.88 83.60 ACCEPTABLE
488 -180.00 637.67 665.34 83.65 ACCEPTABLE

67
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
489 -0.12 4.21 13.11 2.87 ACCEPTABLE
490 -12.13 68.15 73.38 54.85 ACCEPTABLE
491 -3.28 32.45 37.66 49.16 ACCEPTABLE
492 -1.60 14.54 23.37 3.07 ACCEPTABLE
493 -0.78 10.37 20.50 3.34 ACCEPTABLE
494 4.74 4.21 13.11 5.06 ACCEPTABLE
495 0.60 3.34 17.01 4.57 ACCEPTABLE
496 -7.71 13.84 20.09 57.03 ACCEPTABLE
497 -4.39 9.74 14.94 58.36 ACCEPTABLE
498 -4.98 4.21 13.11 2.45 ACCEPTABLE
499 -16.79 67.51 72.71 72.07 ACCEPTABLE
500 -8.14 32.45 37.66 56.34 ACCEPTABLE
501 -4.32 8.90 18.67 2.89 ACCEPTABLE
502 -0.12 4.21 13.11 2.87 ACCEPTABLE
503 -2.80 1.77 15.41 4.28 ACCEPTABLE
504 -11.51 12.53 18.43 195.01 ACCEPTABLE
505 -9.25 9.74 14.94 182.82 ACCEPTABLE
506 -8.31 2.50 11.28 92.77 ACCEPTABLE
507 -4.89 11.60 20.45 2.70 ACCEPTABLE
508 0.05 3.62 12.82 2.98 ACCEPTABLE
509 -149.87 406.26 434.83 121.14 ACCEPTABLE
510 -145.01 406.26 434.83 66.83 ACCEPTABLE
511 -4.98 4.21 13.11 2.45 ACCEPTABLE
512 -1.19 2.27 12.23 3.00 ACCEPTABLE
513 -5.16 2.78 9.81 58.29 ACCEPTABLE
514 -4.78 14.93 21.03 46.15 ACCEPTABLE
515 -5.04 7.90 17.44 2.77 ACCEPTABLE
516 -1.74 4.21 13.11 2.61 ACCEPTABLE
517 -3.94 3.01 15.05 3.59 ACCEPTABLE
518 -9.49 9.65 16.44 84.00 ACCEPTABLE
519 -6.52 6.16 12.16 76.10 ACCEPTABLE
520 -7.73 3.66 12.50 30.06 ACCEPTABLE
521 -7.36 2.40 11.93 3.11 ACCEPTABLE
522 -5.43 9.61 18.52 2.62 ACCEPTABLE
523 -1.77 4.31 13.16 2.60 ACCEPTABLE
524 -164.95 478.31 506.49 329.86 ACCEPTABLE
525 -161.71 478.31 506.49 136.38 ACCEPTABLE
526 -4.98 4.21 13.11 2.45 ACCEPTABLE
527 -2.74 3.92 12.96 2.55 ACCEPTABLE
528 -5.24 3.70 11.14 39.18 ACCEPTABLE
529 -7.39 15.64 22.65 44.97 ACCEPTABLE
530 -4.44 9.90 16.87 40.03 ACCEPTABLE
531 -5.72 8.56 17.34 2.54 ACCEPTABLE
532 -5.36 7.04 16.40 2.68 ACCEPTABLE
533 -2.82 4.21 13.11 2.51 ACCEPTABLE
534 -4.56 3.70 14.71 3.20 ACCEPTABLE

68
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
535 -4.30 1.04 9.87 2.44 ACCEPTABLE
536 -6.61 9.94 16.89 47.49 ACCEPTABLE
537 -3.62 5.22 12.11 43.74 ACCEPTABLE
538 -5.06 4.48 13.25 2.42 ACCEPTABLE
539 -2.83 4.24 13.12 2.50 ACCEPTABLE
540 -5.34 3.97 11.30 52.77 ACCEPTABLE
541 -7.56 16.34 23.23 46.43 ACCEPTABLE
542 -4.59 10.42 17.27 41.09 ACCEPTABLE
543 -5.81 8.95 17.60 2.52 ACCEPTABLE
544 -5.43 7.35 16.58 2.64 ACCEPTABLE
545 -2.90 4.48 13.25 2.47 ACCEPTABLE
546 -4.62 3.93 14.80 3.14 ACCEPTABLE
547 -4.38 1.27 9.95 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
548 -6.77 10.53 17.35 50.33 ACCEPTABLE
549 -3.77 5.64 12.40 44.10 ACCEPTABLE
550 -5.15 4.83 13.44 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
551 -2.94 4.67 13.35 2.44 ACCEPTABLE
552 -5.46 4.33 11.52 52.05 ACCEPTABLE
553 -7.77 17.27 24.01 48.45 ACCEPTABLE
554 -4.77 11.10 17.81 41.10 ACCEPTABLE
555 -5.92 9.46 17.94 2.48 ACCEPTABLE
556 -1.94 1.15 11.84 3.20 ACCEPTABLE
557 -5.52 7.74 16.82 2.61 ACCEPTABLE
558 -2.99 4.83 13.44 2.43 ACCEPTABLE
559 -4.68 4.23 14.93 3.09 ACCEPTABLE
560 -4.48 1.57 10.07 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
561 -6.99 11.31 17.97 51.30 ACCEPTABLE
562 -3.96 6.20 12.80 46.52 ACCEPTABLE
563 -5.28 5.28 13.70 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
564 -4.91 3.97 12.98 2.49 ACCEPTABLE
565 -2.32 1.57 10.07 2.37 ACCEPTABLE
566 -4.13 1.26 11.87 3.09 ACCEPTABLE
567 -7.65 4.43 11.59 96.82 ACCEPTABLE
568 -5.21 2.21 8.70 81.77 ACCEPTABLE
569 -6.64 1.57 10.07 40.44 ACCEPTABLE
570 -5.18 4.93 13.50 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
571 -2.35 1.66 10.11 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
572 -171.90 529.99 557.96 238.18 ACCEPTABLE
573 -200.50 765.85 793.26 138.80 ACCEPTABLE
574 -169.74 529.99 557.96 143.97 ACCEPTABLE
575 -4.48 1.57 10.07 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
576 -3.01 1.49 10.04 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
577 -4.62 1.30 8.76 41.10 ACCEPTABLE
578 -5.98 7.10 14.36 46.72 ACCEPTABLE
579 -4.01 4.31 11.51 20.35 ACCEPTABLE
580 -5.03 3.99 12.41 2.29 ACCEPTABLE

69
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
581 -3.66 4.21 12.53 2.28 ACCEPTABLE
582 -2.30 4.48 12.68 2.35 ACCEPTABLE
583 -3.90 4.00 11.32 8.78 ACCEPTABLE
584 -5.29 11.23 18.31 41.74 ACCEPTABLE
585 -3.32 7.84 14.88 6.49 ACCEPTABLE
586 -4.22 7.22 15.42 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
587 -1.48 1.79 11.40 2.84 ACCEPTABLE
588 -3.93 6.11 14.73 2.43 ACCEPTABLE
589 -2.22 4.21 12.53 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
590 -3.31 3.79 13.49 2.74 ACCEPTABLE
591 -3.25 2.15 10.32 2.19 ACCEPTABLE
592 -1.82 2.19 10.34 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
593 -3.42 1.85 9.03 18.34 ACCEPTABLE
594 -4.87 8.19 15.14 45.00 ACCEPTABLE
595 -2.88 5.17 12.07 22.79 ACCEPTABLE
596 -3.83 4.77 12.85 2.21 ACCEPTABLE
597 -3.55 3.83 12.32 2.32 ACCEPTABLE
598 -1.81 2.15 10.32 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
599 -2.95 1.87 11.43 2.69 ACCEPTABLE
600 -5.43 4.23 11.46 51.18 ACCEPTABLE
601 -3.74 2.62 9.45 50.98 ACCEPTABLE
602 -4.69 2.15 10.32 2.19 ACCEPTABLE
603 -3.26 2.19 10.34 2.19 ACCEPTABLE
604 -4.86 1.85 9.03 61.12 ACCEPTABLE
605 -6.31 8.19 15.14 50.53 ACCEPTABLE
606 -4.32 5.17 12.07 45.55 ACCEPTABLE
607 -5.27 4.77 12.85 2.20 ACCEPTABLE
608 -4.99 3.83 12.32 2.31 ACCEPTABLE
609 -3.25 2.15 10.32 2.19 ACCEPTABLE
610 -4.39 1.87 11.43 2.67 ACCEPTABLE
611 -6.87 4.23 11.46 71.68 ACCEPTABLE
612 -5.18 2.62 9.45 64.47 ACCEPTABLE
613 -6.13 2.15 10.32 34.51 ACCEPTABLE
614 -5.95 1.65 10.10 11.91 ACCEPTABLE
615 -5.17 4.44 12.66 2.24 ACCEPTABLE
616 -3.32 2.36 10.42 2.16 ACCEPTABLE
617 -1.91 2.44 10.46 2.28 ACCEPTABLE
618 -3.50 2.05 9.13 29.17 ACCEPTABLE
619 -4.99 8.60 15.44 45.60 ACCEPTABLE
620 -2.99 5.50 12.29 41.70 ACCEPTABLE
621 -3.92 5.05 13.01 2.19 ACCEPTABLE
622 -3.61 4.06 12.44 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
623 -1.88 2.36 10.42 2.29 ACCEPTABLE
624 -3.00 2.05 11.50 2.65 ACCEPTABLE
625 -5.52 4.50 11.63 52.28 ACCEPTABLE
626 -3.85 2.87 9.60 52.12 ACCEPTABLE

70
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
627 -4.76 2.36 10.42 2.15 ACCEPTABLE
628 -3.35 2.44 10.46 2.15 ACCEPTABLE
629 -1.95 2.54 10.51 2.26 ACCEPTABLE
630 -3.54 2.13 9.18 33.41 ACCEPTABLE
631 -5.04 8.75 15.56 45.76 ACCEPTABLE
632 -3.04 5.62 12.38 44.24 ACCEPTABLE
633 -3.95 5.16 13.08 2.17 ACCEPTABLE
634 -3.64 4.14 12.49 2.28 ACCEPTABLE
635 -1.91 2.44 10.46 2.28 ACCEPTABLE
636 -3.03 2.12 11.53 2.63 ACCEPTABLE
637 -5.55 4.60 11.69 52.70 ACCEPTABLE
638 -3.89 2.96 9.66 52.57 ACCEPTABLE
639 -4.79 2.44 10.46 2.14 ACCEPTABLE
640 -3.39 2.54 10.51 2.13 ACCEPTABLE
641 -1.99 2.66 10.57 2.24 ACCEPTABLE
642 -3.58 2.23 9.23 40.23 ACCEPTABLE
643 -5.11 8.95 15.71 44.13 ACCEPTABLE
644 -3.10 5.77 12.49 42.83 ACCEPTABLE
645 -4.00 5.30 13.17 2.16 ACCEPTABLE
646 -3.68 4.25 12.55 2.27 ACCEPTABLE
647 -1.95 2.54 10.51 2.26 ACCEPTABLE
648 -3.06 2.21 11.57 2.61 ACCEPTABLE
649 -5.60 4.72 11.77 54.80 ACCEPTABLE
650 -3.94 3.08 9.74 52.62 ACCEPTABLE
651 -4.83 2.54 10.51 2.12 ACCEPTABLE
652 -3.43 2.66 10.57 2.12 ACCEPTABLE
653 -2.04 2.81 10.65 2.22 ACCEPTABLE
654 -3.63 2.35 9.30 47.77 ACCEPTABLE
655 -5.18 9.18 15.89 45.05 ACCEPTABLE
656 -3.16 5.96 12.63 44.29 ACCEPTABLE
657 -4.04 5.46 13.27 2.15 ACCEPTABLE
658 -3.72 4.38 12.63 2.25 ACCEPTABLE
659 -1.99 2.66 10.57 2.24 ACCEPTABLE
660 -3.09 2.32 11.61 2.58 ACCEPTABLE
661 -5.66 4.88 11.88 54.51 ACCEPTABLE
662 -4.00 3.23 9.83 54.10 ACCEPTABLE
663 -4.87 2.66 10.57 2.11 ACCEPTABLE
664 -3.48 2.81 10.65 2.10 ACCEPTABLE
665 -2.11 3.00 10.75 2.19 ACCEPTABLE
666 -3.69 2.49 9.38 50.45 ACCEPTABLE
667 -5.26 9.48 16.13 46.22 ACCEPTABLE
668 -3.24 6.20 12.80 44.67 ACCEPTABLE
669 -4.10 5.67 13.40 2.13 ACCEPTABLE
670 -3.76 4.54 12.72 2.24 ACCEPTABLE
671 -2.04 2.81 10.65 2.22 ACCEPTABLE
672 -3.13 2.45 11.67 2.55 ACCEPTABLE

71
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
673 -5.72 5.07 12.01 56.35 ACCEPTABLE
674 -4.08 3.42 9.95 53.66 ACCEPTABLE
675 -4.92 2.81 10.65 7.09 ACCEPTABLE
676 -4.43 1.43 10.01 2.34 ACCEPTABLE
677 -4.71 2.23 10.36 2.18 ACCEPTABLE
678 -3.98 5.25 13.14 2.17 ACCEPTABLE
679 -2.14 3.10 10.80 2.18 ACCEPTABLE
680 -146.95 368.65 397.48 318.03 ACCEPTABLE
681 -165.02 494.71 522.82 162.59 ACCEPTABLE
682 -145.51 368.65 397.48 182.12 ACCEPTABLE
683 -3.48 2.81 10.65 2.10 ACCEPTABLE
684 -2.63 3.11 10.81 2.12 ACCEPTABLE
685 -3.64 2.68 9.84 20.33 ACCEPTABLE
686 -4.58 6.80 13.83 44.71 ACCEPTABLE
687 -3.25 4.89 11.88 19.64 ACCEPTABLE
688 -3.91 4.68 12.44 2.11 ACCEPTABLE
689 -1.99 1.31 9.97 2.45 ACCEPTABLE
690 -3.68 3.98 12.03 2.18 ACCEPTABLE
691 -2.52 2.81 10.65 2.16 ACCEPTABLE
692 -3.23 2.55 11.31 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
693 -3.20 1.56 9.27 2.05 ACCEPTABLE
694 -2.32 1.76 9.36 2.09 ACCEPTABLE
695 -3.34 1.41 8.44 33.82 ACCEPTABLE
696 -4.31 5.15 12.06 45.47 ACCEPTABLE
697 -2.97 3.40 10.27 33.31 ACCEPTABLE
698 -3.64 3.25 10.89 2.04 ACCEPTABLE
699 -2.81 3.63 11.11 2.07 ACCEPTABLE
700 -3.82 3.12 10.10 44.49 ACCEPTABLE
701 -4.80 7.49 14.33 46.62 ACCEPTABLE
702 -3.47 5.48 12.29 43.01 ACCEPTABLE
703 -4.09 5.23 12.78 2.07 ACCEPTABLE
704 -2.13 1.68 10.12 2.36 ACCEPTABLE
705 -3.83 4.44 12.30 2.14 ACCEPTABLE
706 -2.68 3.25 10.89 2.11 ACCEPTABLE
707 -3.36 2.95 11.50 2.33 ACCEPTABLE
708 -3.37 1.97 9.47 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
709 -2.52 2.25 9.61 2.02 ACCEPTABLE
710 -3.52 1.81 8.65 53.68 ACCEPTABLE
711 -4.55 5.79 12.51 47.66 ACCEPTABLE
712 -3.19 3.95 10.62 45.21 ACCEPTABLE
713 -3.83 3.77 11.19 1.99 ACCEPTABLE
714 -3.58 3.06 10.79 2.06 ACCEPTABLE
715 -2.41 1.97 9.47 2.06 ACCEPTABLE
716 -3.11 1.73 10.15 2.28 ACCEPTABLE
717 -4.88 3.35 10.24 54.84 ACCEPTABLE
718 -3.75 2.31 8.94 54.57 ACCEPTABLE

72
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
719 -4.33 1.97 9.47 18.72 ACCEPTABLE
720 -4.00 1.15 9.10 2.12 ACCEPTABLE
721 -4.19 1.61 9.30 2.03 ACCEPTABLE
722 -3.73 3.48 11.02 2.01 ACCEPTABLE
723 -2.50 2.19 9.58 2.02 ACCEPTABLE
724 -148.49 388.43 417.12 167.00 ACCEPTABLE
725 -160.54 472.50 500.71 130.48 ACCEPTABLE
726 -147.53 388.43 417.12 136.54 ACCEPTABLE
727 -3.37 1.97 9.47 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
728 -2.83 2.23 9.60 1.99 ACCEPTABLE
729 -3.48 1.90 8.94 32.04 ACCEPTABLE
730 -4.12 4.34 11.31 46.20 ACCEPTABLE
731 -3.23 3.22 10.16 30.87 ACCEPTABLE
732 -3.68 3.15 10.59 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
733 -2.35 1.02 9.04 2.21 ACCEPTABLE
734 -3.52 2.70 10.35 2.03 ACCEPTABLE
735 -2.73 1.97 9.47 2.03 ACCEPTABLE
736 -3.19 1.80 9.91 2.18 ACCEPTABLE
737 -3.18 1.19 8.59 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
738 -2.63 1.41 8.69 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
739 -3.28 1.11 8.05 47.15 ACCEPTABLE
740 -3.94 3.39 10.27 49.36 ACCEPTABLE
741 -3.04 2.34 9.18 46.01 ACCEPTABLE
742 -3.50 2.29 9.64 3.92 ACCEPTABLE
743 -3.34 1.88 9.43 1.99 ACCEPTABLE
744 -2.54 1.19 8.59 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
745 -3.01 1.05 9.05 2.15 ACCEPTABLE
746 -4.19 2.04 9.02 56.74 ACCEPTABLE
747 -3.41 1.37 8.18 53.33 ACCEPTABLE
748 -3.82 1.19 8.59 17.92 ACCEPTABLE
749 -3.43 2.11 9.54 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
750 -2.60 1.33 8.66 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
751 -137.95 325.90 355.12 169.33 ACCEPTABLE
752 -145.66 375.84 404.62 140.68 ACCEPTABLE
753 -137.31 325.90 355.12 147.97 ACCEPTABLE
754 -3.18 1.19 8.59 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
755 -2.83 1.37 8.67 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
756 -2.49 1.57 8.76 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
757 -2.91 1.33 8.32 25.98 ACCEPTABLE
758 -3.34 2.81 9.76 36.02 ACCEPTABLE
759 -2.73 2.14 9.06 23.87 ACCEPTABLE
760 -3.05 2.12 9.38 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
761 -2.72 2.36 9.51 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
762 -3.14 2.08 9.04 33.89 ACCEPTABLE
763 -3.56 3.69 10.60 45.38 ACCEPTABLE
764 -2.97 2.96 9.85 32.66 ACCEPTABLE

73
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
765 -3.27 2.93 10.15 3.90 ACCEPTABLE
766 -2.36 1.48 9.06 2.08 ACCEPTABLE
767 -3.15 2.61 9.97 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
768 -2.62 2.12 9.38 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
769 -2.91 1.99 9.65 2.05 ACCEPTABLE
770 -2.93 1.61 8.79 3.79 ACCEPTABLE
771 -3.74 2.76 9.73 47.66 ACCEPTABLE
772 -3.22 2.27 9.14 46.05 ACCEPTABLE
773 -3.48 2.12 9.38 11.78 ACCEPTABLE
774 -2.85 1.03 8.69 2.05 ACCEPTABLE
775 -3.34 1.78 9.21 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
776 -2.82 1.35 8.66 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
777 -3.12 1.25 8.96 2.05 ACCEPTABLE
778 -3.41 1.96 9.30 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
779 -3.07 2.18 9.42 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
780 -3.49 1.92 8.95 35.38 ACCEPTABLE
781 -3.91 3.49 10.48 45.22 ACCEPTABLE
782 -3.32 2.78 9.75 34.41 ACCEPTABLE
783 -3.63 2.75 10.05 8.19 ACCEPTABLE
784 -2.73 1.33 9.00 2.06 ACCEPTABLE
785 -3.51 2.45 9.88 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
786 -2.98 1.96 9.30 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
787 -3.28 1.84 9.58 2.05 ACCEPTABLE
788 -3.29 1.45 8.71 10.36 ACCEPTABLE
789 -4.09 2.58 9.64 47.99 ACCEPTABLE
790 -3.57 2.10 9.05 48.23 ACCEPTABLE
791 -3.84 1.96 9.30 16.07 ACCEPTABLE
792 -3.70 1.63 9.14 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
793 -3.18 1.20 8.60 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
794 -3.49 1.12 8.91 2.06 ACCEPTABLE
795 -3.77 1.81 9.22 10.76 ACCEPTABLE
796 -3.24 1.34 8.66 4.05 ACCEPTABLE
797 -3.57 2.61 9.97 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
798 -3.03 2.09 9.36 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
799 -131.12 287.48 317.17 173.46 ACCEPTABLE
800 -136.07 318.05 347.35 149.92 ACCEPTABLE
801 -130.69 287.48 317.17 155.16 ACCEPTABLE
802 -3.41 1.96 9.30 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
803 -3.19 2.12 9.38 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
804 -2.98 2.29 9.47 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
805 -3.25 2.10 9.15 22.80 ACCEPTABLE
806 -3.53 3.13 10.16 30.44 ACCEPTABLE
807 -3.13 2.67 9.68 22.99 ACCEPTABLE
808 -3.34 2.66 9.89 8.33 ACCEPTABLE
809 -2.73 1.69 9.16 2.01 ACCEPTABLE
810 -3.26 2.45 9.77 1.95 ACCEPTABLE

74
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
811 -2.91 2.12 9.38 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
812 -3.09 2.03 9.56 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
813 -3.11 1.78 8.99 6.07 ACCEPTABLE
814 -3.65 2.54 9.61 31.92 ACCEPTABLE
815 -3.30 2.22 9.22 31.35 ACCEPTABLE
816 -3.47 2.12 9.38 9.82 ACCEPTABLE
817 -3.05 1.37 8.90 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
818 -2.87 1.22 8.71 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
819 -3.39 1.90 9.27 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
820 -3.04 1.60 8.89 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
821 -3.23 1.53 9.09 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
822 -3.43 2.02 9.33 6.25 ACCEPTABLE
823 -3.08 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
824 -2.86 1.86 9.02 3.79 ACCEPTABLE
825 -3.14 1.68 8.71 24.61 ACCEPTABLE
826 -3.42 2.67 9.68 29.97 ACCEPTABLE
827 -3.02 2.22 9.22 22.61 ACCEPTABLE
828 -3.23 2.22 9.43 6.14 ACCEPTABLE
829 -2.62 1.29 8.74 2.01 ACCEPTABLE
830 -3.15 2.02 9.32 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
831 -2.80 1.70 8.94 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
832 -2.99 1.62 9.12 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
833 -3.00 1.37 8.56 7.74 ACCEPTABLE
834 -3.54 2.11 9.15 33.61 ACCEPTABLE
835 -3.19 1.79 8.77 32.26 ACCEPTABLE
836 -3.36 1.70 8.94 10.43 ACCEPTABLE
837 -3.28 1.49 8.84 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
838 -2.92 1.20 8.48 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
839 -3.13 1.14 8.67 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
840 -3.32 1.60 8.89 6.18 ACCEPTABLE
841 -2.97 1.29 8.52 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
842 -3.19 2.12 9.38 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
843 -2.83 1.79 8.98 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
844 -137.35 323.45 352.69 164.32 ACCEPTABLE
845 -140.74 345.04 374.08 152.16 ACCEPTABLE
846 -137.06 323.45 352.69 152.35 ACCEPTABLE
847 -3.08 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
848 -2.94 1.81 9.00 3.99 ACCEPTABLE
849 -3.12 1.69 8.79 18.79 ACCEPTABLE
850 -3.30 2.34 9.42 21.04 ACCEPTABLE
851 -3.04 2.04 9.12 15.01 ACCEPTABLE
852 -3.18 2.04 9.26 7.62 ACCEPTABLE
853 -2.77 1.43 8.81 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
854 -3.13 1.91 9.20 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
855 -2.89 1.70 8.94 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
856 -3.02 1.65 9.06 1.97 ACCEPTABLE

75
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
857 -3.03 1.48 8.68 7.58 ACCEPTABLE
858 -3.38 1.97 9.08 23.81 ACCEPTABLE
859 -3.15 1.76 8.82 22.59 ACCEPTABLE
860 -3.27 1.70 8.94 8.27 ACCEPTABLE
861 -2.99 1.22 8.63 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
862 -2.87 1.11 8.51 1.98 ACCEPTABLE
863 -3.21 1.57 8.87 3.85 ACCEPTABLE
864 -2.98 1.37 8.63 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
865 -3.11 1.32 8.76 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
866 -3.24 1.64 8.91 6.15 ACCEPTABLE
867 -3.00 1.43 8.66 3.81 ACCEPTABLE
868 -3.16 1.98 9.23 3.84 ACCEPTABLE
869 -2.92 1.76 8.97 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
870 -133.87 305.37 334.82 151.84 ACCEPTABLE
871 -136.09 319.21 348.50 143.40 ACCEPTABLE
872 -133.68 305.37 334.82 147.09 ACCEPTABLE
873 -3.08 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
874 -2.99 1.78 8.98 3.80 ACCEPTABLE
875 -3.11 1.69 8.84 13.42 ACCEPTABLE
876 -3.23 2.12 9.25 15.19 ACCEPTABLE
877 -3.05 1.93 9.06 11.28 ACCEPTABLE
878 -3.15 1.93 9.15 6.09 ACCEPTABLE
879 -2.88 1.52 8.85 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
880 -3.11 1.84 9.11 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
881 -2.95 1.70 8.94 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
882 -3.04 1.66 9.02 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
883 -3.05 1.56 8.77 5.90 ACCEPTABLE
884 -3.28 1.88 9.03 17.27 ACCEPTABLE
885 -3.13 1.74 8.86 16.21 ACCEPTABLE
886 -3.21 1.70 8.94 6.14 ACCEPTABLE
887 -3.02 1.37 8.73 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
888 -2.94 1.30 8.65 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
889 -3.17 1.61 8.90 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
890 -3.01 1.48 8.73 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
891 -3.10 1.44 8.81 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
892 -3.19 1.66 8.92 3.85 ACCEPTABLE
893 -3.03 1.52 8.75 3.82 ACCEPTABLE
894 -3.13 1.89 9.13 3.83 ACCEPTABLE
895 -2.97 1.74 8.96 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
896 -134.24 307.65 337.07 153.20 ACCEPTABLE
897 -135.72 316.88 346.20 145.86 ACCEPTABLE
898 -134.12 307.65 337.07 148.59 ACCEPTABLE
899 -3.08 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
900 -3.02 1.75 8.97 4.00 ACCEPTABLE
901 -3.10 1.70 8.87 10.16 ACCEPTABLE
902 -3.18 1.98 9.15 12.30 ACCEPTABLE

76
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
903 -3.06 1.85 9.02 8.11 ACCEPTABLE
904 -3.13 1.85 9.08 5.71 ACCEPTABLE
905 -2.94 1.58 8.88 1.95 ACCEPTABLE
906 -3.10 1.80 9.05 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
907 -3.00 1.70 8.94 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
908 -3.05 1.68 8.99 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
909 -3.06 1.60 8.83 3.81 ACCEPTABLE
910 -3.22 1.82 9.00 14.17 ACCEPTABLE
911 -3.11 1.73 8.89 10.17 ACCEPTABLE
912 -3.16 1.70 8.94 4.03 ACCEPTABLE
913 -3.04 1.48 8.80 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
914 -2.98 1.43 8.74 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
915 -3.14 1.64 8.91 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
916 -3.03 1.55 8.80 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
917 -3.09 1.53 8.85 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
918 -3.15 1.67 8.93 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
919 -3.05 1.58 8.81 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
920 -3.11 1.82 9.07 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
921 -3.01 1.73 8.95 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
922 -134.49 309.18 338.58 153.06 ACCEPTABLE
923 -135.47 315.33 344.66 149.89 ACCEPTABLE
924 -134.40 309.18 338.58 149.23 ACCEPTABLE
925 -3.08 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
926 -3.04 1.74 8.96 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
927 -3.09 1.70 8.90 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
928 -3.14 1.88 9.08 8.15 ACCEPTABLE
929 -3.07 1.80 8.99 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
930 -3.11 1.80 9.03 3.83 ACCEPTABLE
931 -2.99 1.62 8.90 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
932 -3.09 1.76 9.02 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
933 -3.02 1.70 8.94 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
934 -3.06 1.68 8.98 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
935 -3.07 1.64 8.86 4.00 ACCEPTABLE
936 -3.17 1.78 8.98 9.73 ACCEPTABLE
937 -3.10 1.72 8.91 8.11 ACCEPTABLE
938 -3.14 1.70 8.94 4.03 ACCEPTABLE
939 -3.05 1.55 8.85 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
940 -3.02 1.52 8.81 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
941 -3.12 1.66 8.92 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
942 -3.05 1.60 8.85 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
943 -3.09 1.58 8.88 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
944 -3.13 1.68 8.93 4.03 ACCEPTABLE
945 -3.06 1.62 8.86 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
946 -3.10 1.78 9.03 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
947 -3.03 1.72 8.95 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
948 -134.65 310.20 339.59 151.12 ACCEPTABLE

77
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
949 -135.31 314.30 343.65 146.11 ACCEPTABLE
950 -134.60 310.20 339.59 149.81 ACCEPTABLE
951 -3.08 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
952 -3.05 1.72 8.95 4.00 ACCEPTABLE
953 -3.09 1.70 8.91 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
954 -3.12 1.82 9.03 6.08 ACCEPTABLE
955 -3.07 1.77 8.97 8.10 ACCEPTABLE
956 -3.10 1.77 9.00 3.82 ACCEPTABLE
957 -3.02 1.65 8.91 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
958 -3.09 1.74 8.99 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
959 -3.04 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
960 -3.07 1.69 8.96 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
961 -3.07 1.66 8.89 3.81 ACCEPTABLE
962 -3.14 1.75 8.97 8.02 ACCEPTABLE
963 -3.09 1.71 8.92 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
964 -3.12 1.70 8.94 4.02 ACCEPTABLE
965 -3.06 1.60 8.88 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
966 -3.04 1.58 8.85 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
967 -3.11 1.68 8.93 4.02 ACCEPTABLE
968 -3.06 1.63 8.88 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
969 -3.08 1.62 8.90 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
970 -3.11 1.69 8.93 3.83 ACCEPTABLE
971 -3.07 1.65 8.88 3.81 ACCEPTABLE
972 -3.09 1.75 9.00 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
973 -3.05 1.71 8.95 3.81 ACCEPTABLE
974 -134.76 310.88 340.26 151.13 ACCEPTABLE
975 -135.20 313.61 342.97 149.73 ACCEPTABLE
976 -134.72 310.88 340.26 150.06 ACCEPTABLE
977 -3.08 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
978 -3.06 1.72 8.95 4.00 ACCEPTABLE
979 -3.09 1.70 8.92 3.82 ACCEPTABLE
980 -3.11 1.78 9.00 6.07 ACCEPTABLE
981 -3.07 1.74 8.96 4.00 ACCEPTABLE
982 -3.09 1.74 8.98 4.01 ACCEPTABLE
983 -3.04 1.66 8.92 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
984 -3.09 1.73 8.97 3.82 ACCEPTABLE
985 -3.06 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
986 -3.07 1.69 8.96 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
987 -3.07 1.67 8.91 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
988 -3.12 1.74 8.96 5.94 ACCEPTABLE
989 -3.09 1.71 8.92 6.06 ACCEPTABLE
990 -3.10 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
991 -3.08 1.72 8.95 4.00 ACCEPTABLE
992 -3.11 1.70 8.92 5.74 ACCEPTABLE
993 -3.13 1.78 9.00 6.08 ACCEPTABLE
994 -3.09 1.74 8.96 4.01 ACCEPTABLE

78
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
995 -3.11 1.74 8.98 4.01 ACCEPTABLE
996 -3.06 1.66 8.92 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
997 -3.11 1.73 8.97 3.82 ACCEPTABLE
998 -3.08 1.70 8.94 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
999 -3.09 1.69 8.96 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
1000 -3.09 1.67 8.91 1.92 ACCEPTABLE
1001 -3.14 1.74 8.96 5.94 ACCEPTABLE
1002 -3.11 1.71 8.92 6.07 ACCEPTABLE
1003 -3.12 1.70 8.94 4.02 ACCEPTABLE
1004 -3.09 1.63 8.90 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
1005 -3.07 1.62 8.88 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
1006 -3.12 1.68 8.93 4.03 ACCEPTABLE
1007 -3.09 1.66 8.90 4.02 ACCEPTABLE
1008 -3.10 1.65 8.91 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
1009 -3.12 1.69 8.94 3.84 ACCEPTABLE
1010 -3.09 1.66 8.90 4.02 ACCEPTABLE
1011 -3.11 1.74 8.98 4.01 ACCEPTABLE
1012 -3.08 1.71 8.94 4.00 ACCEPTABLE
1013 -134.83 311.33 340.71 151.99 ACCEPTABLE
1014 -135.13 313.15 342.52 149.62 ACCEPTABLE
1015 -134.81 311.33 340.71 150.06 ACCEPTABLE
1016 -2.96 1.68 8.88 1.92 ACCEPTABLE

3. WATERWAY PLTMH PATAMUAN


 STABILITAS WATERWAY PLTMH PATAMUAN
Analisa Percepatan Gempa Rencana

79
DETAIL DESAIN ENGINEERING PLTMH PATAMUAN
Struktur : Gempa
Bagian : Lokasi PLTMH PATAMUAN
Analisa Percepatan Gempa di Lokasi PLTMH PATAMUAN
Data-data
644706.852 N
Letak Geografis PLTMH PATAMUAN
30430.112 E
Desa
Kecamatan Mapat Tunggal Selatan
Kabupaten Pasaman
Sungai Lolo
Peta Zone Gempa

80
Perhitungan Koefisien Gempa
Zone Gempa PLTMH 5 Tabel - Koefisien Zone
Koefisien Zone Gempa/ Z 1.20 - 1.40 Zone Koefisien Zona/ Z
Percepatan Gempa Dasar/ ac 250 500 Tahun 1 0.10 - 0.30
Faktor Koreksi Jenis Tanah/ v 1.0 2 0.30 - 0.60
Percepatan Gempa Terkoreksi/ ad 350.00 gal 3 0.60 - 0.90
Koefisien Gempa Horizontal/ Kh 0.357 4 0.90 - 1.20
Koefisien Gempa Vertikal/ Kv 0.178 5 1.20 - 1.40
6 1.40 - 1.60
Grafik Spektral Percepatan Gempa Sumber : Pd T-14-2004-A
Analisa Stabilitas Bendungan akibat Beban Gempa

Tabel - Percepatan Gempa Dasar


T Percepatan Gempa
(Tahun) Dasar/ ac (gal)
10 90
20 120
50 160
100 190
200 220
500 250
1000 280
5000 330
10000 350
Sumber : Pd T-14-2004-A
Analisa Stabilitas Bendungan akibat Beban Gempa

Tabel - Faktor Koreksi Jenis Tanah

Dari Analisa diatas, untuk PLTMH PATAMUAN :

- Termasuk kedalam wilayah zona gempa 5


- Koefisien gempa horizontal 0,357
- Koefisien gempa vertical 0,178
- Dengan asumsi Kondisi tanah dilokasi PLTMH - Pasir lepas, dengan
parameter sebagai berikut :

Parameter Tanah
- Pasir Lepas Rata-rata Maks Min
Massa Jenis/ g (t/m3) 1.51 1.6 1.42
Sudut geser/ f (deg) 32.5 35 30
Kohesi/ C (t/m2) 2.3 3.5 1.1
Sumber : Bowle, Mekanika Tanah

81
- Analisa Stabilitas Waterway
STABILITAS WATERWAY PLTMH PATAMUAN
Struktur : Stabilitas Waterway

Distribusi Gaya

0.12 1.6 0.3


tanah longsoran

W1 W11
1.5
W2 1.9
0.2 W9

W3 W10
W5 W7
W6 0.4
W4 W8
1.6

Data Struktur
H 1.9 m L1 1.6 m gbt 2.4 t/m3
h1 1.5 m L2 0.3 m gbk 2.2 t/m3
h2 0.2 m L3 0.4 m gt 1.51 t/m3
h3 0.2 m B 2.4 m c 2.30 t/m2
o
φ 32.5

Koefisien Tekanan Tanah Aktif/ Ka


1-Sin φ
Ka =
1+Sin φ
Ka 0.301
Koefisien Gempa/ K
Kh 0.128
Kv 0.064

82
Distribusi - Momen Gaya
G. Hori zonta l Jarak M. Akti f G. Verti ka l Jarak M. Pas i f
Segmen Uraian
(ton) (m) (ton m) (ton) (m) (ton m)
Tekanan Tanah Aktif
Pa
Pa = 1/2 Ka .gt.h22 0.820 0.633333 0.520
Tekanan Tanah Pasif
Pp
Pp = 1/2 Kp .gt.h22 9.056 0.633333 5.735
Berat Ww
W = V. gb
W1 0.63 1.20 0.760
W2 0.99 2.15 2.129
W3 0.17 2.33 0.385
W4 0.18 2.20 0.387
W
W5 0.07 1.90 0.125
W6 0.70 1.20 0.845
W7 0.07 0.50 0.033
W8 0.18 0.20 0.035
W9 0.99 0.25 0.248
W10 0.17 0.07 0.011
W11 0.33 1.20 0.399

Pg Gaya Gempa
Pgh = W.Kh
Pgh1 0.081 1.96 0.160
Pgh2 0.127 1.15 0.146
Pgh3 0.021 0.900 0.019
Pgh4 0.023 0.100 0.002
Pgh Pgh5 0.008 0.467 0.004
Pgh6 0.090 0.300 0.027
Pgh7 0.008 0.467 0.004
Pgh8 0.023 0.100 0.002
Pgh9 0.127 1.150 0.146
Pgh10 0.021 0.900 0.019

Pgv = W.(1-Kv)
Pgv1 0.593 1.20 0.71
Pgv2 0.926 2.15 1.99
Pgv3 0.154 2.33 0.36
Pgv4 0.165 2.20 0.36
Pgv
Pgv5 0.062 1.90 0.12
Pgv6 0.659 1.20 0.79
Pgv7 0.062 0.50 0.03
Pgv8 0.165 0.20 0.03
Pgv9 0.926 0.25 0.23
Pgv10 0.154 0.07 0.01

83
Σ Gaya Horizontal -7.70 ton
Σ Gaya Vertikal 0.60 ton
Σ Momen Guling/ Aktif 5.69 ton m
Σ Momen Penahan/ Pasif 11.09 ton m

Kontrol Terhadap Guling


Persamaan
Normal Tanpa Gempa
σMR SF 21.35 > 1.25 Ok
SF =
σMG Normal dengan Gempa
Dimana : SF 1.95 > 1.25 Ok
SF = Faktor keamanan
Σ MR = Jumlah Momen Penahan
Σ MG = Jumlah Momen Guling

Kontrol Terhadap Geser


Persamaan
Normal Tanpa Gempa
Vtancb23
2
V  tan   c  b 2

Vtancb SFSFGesr SF 
2
3 3
SF 0.89 > 1.5 Cek
SF H H H
3 Gesr Geser
Normal dengan Gempa
H
Gesr
Dimana : SF -0.75 > 1.25 Cek
SF = Faktor keamanan
Σ MR = Jumlah Momen Penahan
Σ V = Jumlah Gaya Vertikal
Σ H = Jumlah Gaya horizontal

Kontrol Terhadap Daya Dukung Tanah


Persamaan
B σ Mt − σ Mg Tegangan yang terjadi
e= −ቆ ቇ
2 σV e -7.84 m
B/3 0.80 m
σ V 6E σt1 5.13 t/m2
σ1,2 = ൬1± ൰≤ σ′
L L σt2 -4.63 t/m2
Daya Dukung Tanah
qu 160.51 t/m2
f 32.50
Nc 37.20
Nq 22.50
Ng 20
SF. Daya Dukung 10.4 > 1.25 Ok

Qult = 1.3. c. Nc+ γ. Df. Nq + 0.5. γ.B. Nγ


Koefisien Daya Dukung Terzaghi
Keruntuhan geser umum Keruntuhan geser umum
φo Nc Nq Nγ Nc' Nq' Nγ'
0 5.7 1 0 5.7 1 0
5 7.3 1.6 0.5 6.7 1.4 0.2
10 9.6 2.7 1.2 8 1.9 0.5
15 12.9 4.4 2.5 9.7 2.7 0.9
20 17.7 7.4 5 11.8 3.9 1.7
25 25.1 12.7 9.7 14.8 5.6 3.2
30 37.2 22.5 19.7 19 8.3 5.7
34 52.6 36.5 35 23.7 11.7 9
35 57.8 41.4 42.4 25.2 12.6 10.1
40 95.7 81.3 100.4 34.9 20.5 18.8
45 172.3 173.3 297.5 51.2 35.1 37.7
48 258.3 287.9 780.1 66.8 50.5 60.4
50 347.6 415.1 1153.2 81.3 65.6 87.1

Vtancb Vtancb
2 2

SF SF
3 3

H H
Gesr Gesr

84
Dari Analisa diatas, untuk WATERWAY PLTMH PATAMUAN :

- Stabilitas Guling : Safety Factor/ SF 1,95 > 1,5


- Stabilitas Geser : Safety Factor/ SF 0,89 < 1,5
- Daya dukung tanah : Safety Factor/ SF 10,4 > 1,25
- Waterway PLTMH PATAMUAN, tidak aman untuk Kondisi Stabilitas Geser
nya
- Untuk memperbesar Stabilitas Geser, salah satunya dengan membesar/
memperlebar Dimensi dari Waterway. Analisa nya sebagai berikut :

- Lebar kondisi semula 0,4 m


menjadi 0,8 m
- Tinggi kondisi semula 0,2 m
menjadi 0,5 m

STABILITAS WATERWAY PLTMH PATAMUAN


Struktur : Stabilitas Waterway

Distribusi Gaya

0.12 1.6 0.3


tanah longsoran

W1 W11
1.5
W2 1.9
0.2 W9

W3 W10
W5 W7
W6 0.4
W4 W8
1.6

Data Struktur
H 1.9 m L1 1.6 m gbt 2.4 t/m3
h1 1.5 m L2 0.3 m gbk 2.2 t/m3
h2 0.2 m L3 0.4 m gt 1.51 t/m3
h3 0.2 m B 3.2 m c 2.30 t/m2
o
φ 32.5

85
Koefisien Tekanan Tanah Aktif/ Ka
1-Sin φ
Ka =
1+Sin φ
Ka 0.301
Koefisien Gempa/ K
Kh 0.128
Kv 0.064

Distribusi - Momen Gaya


G. Hori zonta l Jarak M. Akti f G. Verti ka l Jarak M. Pas i f
Segmen Uraian
(ton) (m) (ton m) (ton) (m) (ton m)
Tekanan Tanah Aktif
Pa
Pa = 1/2 Ka .gt.h22 0.820 0.633333 0.520
Tekanan Tanah Pasif
Pp
Pp = 1/2 Kp .gt.h22 9.056 0.633333 5.735
Berat Ww
W = V.gb
W1 0.63 1.20 0.760
W2 0.99 2.15 2.129
W3 0.17 2.33 0.385
W4 0.88 2.30 2.024
W
W5 0.07 1.90 0.125
W6 0.70 1.20 0.845
W7 0.07 0.50 0.033
W8 0.88 0.30 0.264
W9 0.99 0.25 0.248
W10 0.17 0.07 0.011
W11 0.33 1.20 0.399

Pg Gaya Gempa
Pgh = W.Kh
Pgh1 0.081 1.96 0.160
Pgh2 0.127 1.15 0.146
Pgh3 0.021 0.900 0.019
Pgh4 0.113 0.400 0.045
Pgh Pgh5 0.008 0.467 0.004
Pgh6 0.090 0.300 0.027
Pgh7 0.008 0.467 0.004
Pgh8 0.113 0.400 0.045
Pgh9 0.127 1.150 0.146
Pgh10 0.021 0.900 0.019

Pgv = W.(1-Kv)
Pgv1 0.593 1.20 0.71
Pgv2 0.926 2.15 1.99
Pgv3 0.154 2.33 0.36
Pgv4 0.823 2.30 1.89
Pgv
Pgv5 0.062 1.90 0.12
Pgv6 0.659 1.20 0.79
Pgv7 0.062 0.50 0.03
Pgv8 0.823 0.30 0.25
Pgv9 0.926 0.25 0.23
Pgv10 0.154 0.07 0.01

86
Σ Gaya Horizontal -7.52 ton
Σ Gaya Vertikal 0.69 ton
Σ Momen Guling/ Aktif 7.52 ton m
Σ Momen Penahan/ Pasif 12.96 ton m

Kontrol Terhadap Guling


Persamaan
Normal Tanpa Gempa
σMR SF 24.94 > 1.25 Ok
SF =
σMG Normal dengan Gempa
Dimana : SF 1.72 > 1.25 Ok
SF = Faktor keamanan
Σ MR = Jumlah Momen Penahan
Σ MG = Jumlah Momen Guling

Kontrol Terhadap Geser


Persamaan
Normal Tanpa Gempa
Vtancb23
2
V  tan   c  b 2

Vtancb SFSFGesr SF 
2
3 3
SF 1.74 > 1.5 Ok
SF H H H
3 Gesr Geser
Normal dengan Gempa
H
Gesr
Dimana : SF 1.63 > 1.25 Ok
SF = Faktor keamanan
Σ MR = Jumlah Momen Penahan
Σ V = Jumlah Gaya Vertikal
Σ H = Jumlah Gaya horizontal

Kontrol Terhadap Daya Dukung Tanah


Persamaan
B σ Mt − σ Mg Tegangan yang terjadi
e= −ቆ ቇ
2 σV e -6.30 m
B/3 1.07 m
σ V 6E σt1 2.76 t/m2
σ1,2 = ൬1± ൰≤ σ′
L L σt2 -2.33 t/m2
Daya Dukung Tanah
qu 172.41 t/m2
f 32.50
Nc 37.20
Nq 22.50
Ng 20
SF. Daya Dukung 20.9 > 1.25 Ok

Qult = 1.3. c. Nc+ γ. Df. Nq + 0.5. γ.B. Nγ


Koefisien Daya Dukung Terzaghi
Keruntuhan geser umum Keruntuhan geser umum
φo Nc Nq Nγ Nc' Nq' Nγ'
0 5.7 1 0 5.7 1 0
5 7.3 1.6 0.5 6.7 1.4 0.2
10 9.6 2.7 1.2 8 1.9 0.5
15 12.9 4.4 2.5 9.7 2.7 0.9
20 17.7 7.4 5 11.8 3.9 1.7
25 25.1 12.7 9.7 14.8 5.6 3.2
30 37.2 22.5 19.7 19 8.3 5.7
34 52.6 36.5 35 23.7 11.7 9
35 57.8 41.4 42.4 25.2 12.6 10.1
40 95.7 81.3 100.4 34.9 20.5 18.8
45 172.3 173.3 297.5 51.2 35.1 37.7
48 258.3 287.9 780.1 66.8 50.5 60.4
50 347.6 415.1 1153.2 81.3 65.6 87.1

Vtancb Vtancb
2 2

SF  SF 
3 3

H H
Gesr Gesr

87
- Setelah dimensi nya berubah, diperoleh hasil sebagai berikut :
Safety factor/ SF Guling 1,72 > 1,5
Safety factor/ SF Geser 1,63 > 1,5
Stabilitas Waterway Aman terhadap Kondisi Guling dan Geser

 ANALISA PLAT LAYANAN WATERWAY PLTMH PATAMUAN


- Plat layanan Waterway menggunakan material Beton Bertulang mutu K-
175 atau K-225
- Analisa Plat layanan sebagai berikut :

Plat layanan waterway

88
PERHITUNGAN PENULANGAN PLAT LANTAI WATERWAY PLTMH PATAMUAN
Beban
a. Beban Hidup (LL) = 1 KN/m Tebal plate (hm) = 0.12 m Faktor Reduksi φ = 0.8
Σ Beban Hidup (Ql) = 1 KN/m ρ beton = 20 mm β1 = 0.85
b. Beban Mati Pada Dinding (DL) fy = 240 Mpa Elastis tulangan (Es) = 200000
- Berat sendiri plate (Qm1) = 2.88 KN/m K = 22.5 Mpa
- Berat akibat air hujan (Qm2) = 0.5 KN/m fc' = 0.83 K Lebar pias bw = 1
- Berat akibat tanah longsoran = 1.51 KN/m
Σ Beban Mati (DL) = 4.89 KN/m 18.675 Mpa hmin = 100
3
Berat Jenis Baja = 7850 kgf/m
3
Persyaratan geser (Vu) = 2.24 kN Berat Jenis Beton = 2400 kgf/m
3
Vc = 41.054 kN Berat Jenis Air = 1000 kgf/m
Vc > Vu OK Berat Jenis tanah = 1510 kgf/m3

Type DL LL WU Mlx Mly Mtx Mty


No Lx (m) Ly (m) ly/lx 2 2 2
Plat (KN/m ) (KN/m ) (KN/m ) (KNm) (KNm) (KN/m) (KN/m)
1 4a 2.20 1.00 0.45 4.890 1.0 7.4680 0.8675 0.2464 2.4940 0.0896

Tulangan Lapangan

Type dx Mu Mn P P P P ASlx Tul. Slx Perlu Ambil Slx As pakai Kontrol Di pakai
No Pb 2 2 2
Ket
Plat mm KNm KNm min maks hitung pakai mm mm mm mm mm As min a Mn Mn Mu (Nmm) Tul
1 4a 85 0.2464 0.3081 0.00583 0.040 0.030 0.000000 0.00583 495.833333 10 158.319 200 392.5 250 5.9343 7727493.3 6181994.6 246444.0 10 - 200 OK
Jumlah Tulangan 12 batang
Tulangan Tumpuan

Type dx Mu Mn P P P P ASlx Tul. Slx Perlu Ambil Slx As pakai Kontrol Di pakai
No Pb Ket
Plat mm KNm KNm min maks hitung pakai mm2 mm2 mm mm mm2 As min a Mn Mn Mu (Nmm) Tul
1 4a 65 0.0896 0.1120 0.00583 0.065 0.048 0.00011 0.00583 379.166667 10 298.127 300 261.7 250 5.9343 3895662.2 3116529.7 89616.0 10 - 300 OK
Jumlah Tulangan 8 batang

Dari Analisa diatas, didapat :

- Plat layanan beton, termasuk Plat Satu Arah karena nilai Ly/Lx < 1
- Dipakai Beton K-175 atau K-225
- Dipakai Diameter Baja/ D 10 mm
- Jumlah Diameter baja D 10 mm ± 20 Batang

89
4. DINDING PENAHAN TANAH/ DPT PLTMH PATAMUAN
1. DINDING PENAHAN TANAH/ DPT Tinggi 5,5 METER

Diagram gaya-gaya yang bekerja

90
Hasil Analisa Stabilitas DPT dengan Software Gravity Wall

Gravity wall analysis


Input data
Project

Date : 16/01/2024

Settings
Standard - safety factors (21)

Materials and standards

Concrete structures : EN 1992-1-1 (EC2)


Coefficients EN 1992-1-1 : standard
Masonry (stone) wall : EN 1996-1-1 (EC6)
AASHTO - reduce parameters of friction soil/soil by 2/3 

Wall analysis

Active earth pressure calculation : Coulomb


Passive earth pressure Coulomb
calculation :
Earthquake analysis : Mononobe-Okabe
Shape of earth wedge : Calculate as skew
Allowable eccentricity : 0.333
Verification methodology : Safety factors (ASD)

Safety factors
Seismic design situation
Safety factor for overturning : SFo = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for sliding resistance : SFs = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for bearing capacity : SFb = 1.50 [–]

Material of structure
Unit weight  = 22.00 kN/m3

Masonry : Category II
Mortar origin : Prescribed mortar

Masonry strength fb = 2.00 MPa


Mortar strength f = 2.50 MPa
m

91
Parameters
Compressive strength fk = 0.96 MPa
Shear strength fvko = 0.10 MPa
Flexural tensile fxk = 0.05 MPa
strength
Partial factor M = 2.50

Geometry of structure

No Coordinate Depth
. X [m] Z [m]
1 0.00 0.00
2 0.00 4.50
3 0.00 5.50
4 -2.00 5.50
5 -2.00 4.50
6 -0.50 0.00

The origin [0,0] is located at the most upper right point of the wall.
Wall section area = 7.63 m2.

Basic soil parameters

ef cef  su 


No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [kN/m3] [°]

1 Pasir Lepas 32.50 23.00 15.10 5.10 21.70

All soils are considered as cohesionless for at rest pressure analysis.

Soil parameters

Pasir Lepas
Unit weight :  = 15.10 kN/
m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 32.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Angle of friction struc.-soil :  = 21.70 °
Soil : cohesionless

92
Saturated unit weight : sa = 15.10 kN/
t m3

Backfill
Assigned soil : Pasir Lepas
Slope = 45.00 °

Geological profile and assigned soils

Thickness of layer Depth


No. Assigned soil Pattern
t [m] z [m]

1 - 0.00 ..  Pasir Lepas

Foundation
Type of foundation : soil from geological profile

Terrain profile
Terrain behind the structure is flat.

Water influence
Ground water table is located below the structure.

Resistance on front face of the structure


Resistance on front face of the structure: not considered
Soil on front face of the structure - Pasir Lepas
Soil thickness in front of h = 1.00 m
structure

Terrain in front of structure is flat.

Earthquake

Factor of horizontal acceleration Kh = 0.1280


Factor of vertical acceleration Kv = 0.0640

Water below the GWT is restricted.

Settings of the stage of construction


Design situation : seismic

93
Verification No. 1
Active pressure behind the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  d Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [°]
1 4.50 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 21.70 0.270
2 0.76 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 21.70 0.270
3 0.24 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 21.70 0.270

Active pressure distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
4.50 67.95 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
4.50 67.95 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
2
5.26 79.43 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
5.26 79.43 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
3
5.50 83.05 0.00 0.98 0.91 0.36

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure) - partial results

Layer Thickness d   Ka Kae Kae-Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [°]
1 4.50 32.50 0.00 7.79 0.270 0.363 0.093
2 0.76 32.50 0.00 7.79 0.270 0.363 0.093
3 0.24 32.50 0.00 7.79 0.270 0.363 0.093

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure)

Layer Start [m] Z D Pressure Hor. comp. Vertical comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 77.73 7.23 6.72 2.67
1
4.50 63.60 14.13 1.32 1.22 0.49
4.50 63.60 14.13 1.32 1.22 0.49
2
5.26 74.35 3.39 0.32 0.29 0.12

94
Layer Start [m] Z D Pressure Hor. comp. Vertical comp.
No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
5.26 74.35 3.39 0.32 0.29 0.12
3
5.50 77.73 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Forces acting on construction

Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design


[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -2.20 167.75 1.22 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 21.47 -2.20 -10.74 1.22 1.000
Active pressure 0.11 -0.08 0.04 2.00 1.000
Earthq.- act.pressure 18.48 -3.67 7.36 2.00 1.000

Verification of complete wall


Check for overturning stability
Resisting moment Mres = 206.56 kNm/m
Overturning moment Mov = 114.95 kNm/m
r

Safety factor = 1.80 > 1.50


Wall for overturning is SATISFACTORY
Check for slip
Resisting horizontal force Hres = 130.37 kN/m
Active horizontal force Hact = 40.06 kN/m

Safety factor = 3.25 > 1.50


Wall for slip is SATISFACTORY
Overall check - WALL is SATISFACTORY

Bearing capacity of foundation soil


Dimensioning No. 1
Active pressure behind the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  d Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [°]
1 0.10 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 21.70 0.270

Active pressure distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

95
Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.
No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
0.10 1.49 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure) - partial results

Layer Thickness d   Ka Kae Kae-Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [°]
1 0.10 32.50 0.00 7.79 0.270 0.363 0.093

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure)

Layer Start [m] Z D Pressure Hor. comp. Vertical comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 1.40 0.13 0.12 0.05
1
0.10 1.40 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Forces acting on construction

Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design


[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -0.05 1.12 0.27 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 0.14 -0.05 -0.07 0.27 1.000
Active pressure 0.00 -0.10 0.00 0.53 1.000
Earthq.- act.pressure 0.01 -0.07 0.00 0.53 1.000

Wall check at the construction joint 0.10 m from the wall crest
Cross-section depth h = 0.53 m

Ultimate shear force VRd = 21.49 kN/m > 0.15 kN/m = VEd
Ultimate compressive force NRd = 203.84 kN/m > 1.05 kN/m = NEd
Ultimate moment MRd = 0.28 kNm/m > 0.00 kNm/m = MEd

Cross-section bearing capacity is SATISFACTORY

Hasil Analisa nya :

96
- Stabilitas Guling, safety factor/ SF 1,80 > 1,5
- Stabilitas Geser , safety factor/ SF 3,25 > 1,5
- Artinya Stabilitas Dinding Penahan Tanah Kondisi Stabil

2. DINDING PENAHAN TANAH/ DPT Tinggi 7,0 METER

Gaya – gaya yang bekerja

97
Hasil Analisa Stabilitas DPT dengan Software Gravity Wall

Gravity wall analysis


Input data
Project

Date : 16/01/2024

Settings
Standard - safety factors (22)

Materials and standards

Concrete structures : EN 1992-1-1 (EC2)


Coefficients EN 1992-1-1 : standard
Masonry (stone) wall : EN 1996-1-1 (EC6)
AASHTO - reduce parameters of friction soil/soil by 2/3 

Wall analysis

Active earth pressure calculation : Coulomb


Passive earth pressure Coulomb
calculation :
Earthquake analysis : Mononobe-Okabe
Shape of earth wedge : Calculate as skew
Allowable eccentricity : 0.333
Verification methodology : Safety factors (ASD)

Safety factors
Permanent design situation
Safety factor for overturning : SFo = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for sliding resistance : SFs = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for bearing capacity : SFb = 1.50 [–]

Material of structure
Unit weight  = 22.00 kN/m3

Masonry : Category I
Mortar origin : Prescribed mortar

98
Masonry strength fb = 2.00 MPa
Mortar strength f = 2.50 MPa
m

Parameters
Compressive strength fk = 0.96 MPa
Shear strength fvko = 0.10 MPa
Flexural tensile fxk = 0.05 MPa
strength
Partial factor M = 2.20

Geometry of structure

No Coordinate Depth
. X [m] Z [m]
1 0.00 -0.50
2 0.00 5.50
3 0.00 6.50
4 -2.00 6.50
5 -2.00 5.50
6 -0.50 -0.50

The origin [0,0] is located at the most upper right point of the wall.
Wall section area = 9.50 m2.

Basic soil parameters

ef cef  su 


No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [kN/m3] [°]

1 Pasir lepas 32.50 23.00 15.10 5.10 16.70

All soils are considered as cohesionless for at rest pressure analysis.

Soil parameters

Pasir lepas
Unit weight :  = 15.10 kN/
m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 32.50 °

99
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Angle of friction struc.-soil :  = 16.70 °
Soil : cohesionless
Saturated unit weight : sa = 15.10 kN/
t m3

Backfill
Assigned soil : Pasir lepas
Slope = 45.00 °

Geological profile and assigned soils

Thickness of layer Depth


No. Assigned soil Pattern
t [m] z [m]

1 - 0.00 ..  Pasir lepas

Foundation
Type of foundation : soil from geological profile

Terrain profile
Depth of terrain below the top of wall h = 0.50 m.

No Coordinates Depth
. x [m] z [m]
1 0.00 0.00
2 1.00 0.00
3 4.00 -2.00
4 5.00 -2.00

Origin [0,0] is located in upper right edge of construction.


Positive coordinate +z has downward direction.

Water influence
Ground water table is located below the structure.

Input surface surcharges

100
Surcharge Mag.1 Mag.2 Ord.x Length Depth
No. Action
new change [kN/m2] [kN/m2] x [m] l [m] z [m]
1 Yes permanent 7.60 4.00 6.00 on terrain

Resistance on front face of the structure


Resistance on front face of the structure: at rest
Soil on front face of the structure - Pasir lepas
Soil thickness in front of structure h = 1.00 m
Terrain surcharge f = 0.50 kN/m2

Terrain in front of structure is flat.

Earthquake

Factor of horizontal acceleration Kh = 0.1280


Factor of vertical acceleration Kv = 0.0640

Water below the GWT is restricted.

Settings of the stage of construction


Design situation : permanent

Verification No. 1
Pressure at rest on front face of the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  Kr Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3]
1 1.00 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 0.463

Pressure at rest distribution on front face of the structure

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
1.00 15.10 0.00 6.99 6.99 0.00

Active pressure behind the structure - partial results

101
Layer Thickness  d cd  d Ka Comment
No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [°]
1 0.64 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
2 0.79 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
3 0.51 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.772
4 0.57 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.772
5 1.49 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
6 1.38 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
7 0.13 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
8 1.00 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272

Active pressure distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
0.64 9.62 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
0.64 9.62 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
2
1.43 21.52 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1.43 21.52 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
3
1.94 29.24 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1.94 29.24 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
4
2.50 37.77 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
2.50 37.77 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
5
3.99 60.28 0.00 2.55 2.44 0.73
3.99 60.28 0.00 2.55 2.44 0.73
6
5.37 81.11 0.00 8.22 7.87 2.36
5.37 81.11 0.00 8.22 7.87 2.36
7
5.50 83.05 0.00 8.75 8.38 2.51
5.50 83.05 0.00 8.75 8.38 2.51
8
6.50 98.15 0.00 12.86 12.32 3.70

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure) - partial results

Layer Thickness d   Ka Kae Kae-Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [°]
1 0.64 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
2 0.79 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252

102
Layer Thickness d   Ka Kae Kae-Ka Comment
No. [m] [°] [°] [°]
3 0.51 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
4 0.57 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
5 1.49 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
6 1.38 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
7 0.13 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
8 1.00 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure)

Layer Start [m] Z D Pressure Hor. comp. Vertical comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 91.87 23.18 22.20 6.66
1
0.64 9.00 82.86 20.91 20.03 6.01
0.64 9.00 82.86 20.91 20.03 6.01
2
1.43 20.15 71.72 18.10 17.33 5.20
1.43 20.15 71.72 18.10 17.33 5.20
3
1.94 27.37 64.50 16.28 15.59 4.68
1.94 27.37 64.50 16.28 15.59 4.68
4
2.50 35.35 56.51 14.26 13.66 4.10
2.50 35.35 56.51 14.26 13.66 4.10
5
3.99 56.42 35.45 8.95 8.57 2.57
3.99 56.42 35.45 8.95 8.57 2.57
6
5.37 75.92 15.95 4.02 3.85 1.16
5.37 75.92 15.95 4.02 3.85 1.16
7
5.50 77.73 14.13 3.57 3.42 1.02
5.50 77.73 14.13 3.57 3.42 1.02
8
6.50 91.87 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Pressure profile due to surcharge - Surch.1 - strip

Point Depth Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. [m] [kPa] [kPa]
1 0.00 0.00 0.00
2 0.00 0.00 0.00
3 0.55 0.00 0.00
4 0.55 1.77 0.53

103
Point Depth Hor. comp. Vert. comp.
No. [m] [kPa] [kPa]
5 0.64 1.77 0.53
6 0.64 1.81 0.54
7 1.43 1.77 0.53
8 1.43 1.78 0.53
9 1.94 1.75 0.52
10 1.94 1.76 0.53
11 2.50 1.72 0.52
12 2.50 1.74 0.52
13 3.99 1.65 0.49
14 3.99 1.65 0.50
15 5.37 1.56 0.47
16 5.50 1.55 0.46
17 5.50 1.55 0.47
18 6.50 1.49 0.45

Forces acting on construction

Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design


[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -2.79 209.00 1.24 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 26.75 -2.79 -13.38 1.24 1.000
FF resistance -3.49 -0.33 0.00 0.00 1.000
Resistance on front face -0.23 -0.50 0.00 0.00 1.000
Active pressure 20.33 -1.16 6.10 2.00 1.000
Earthq.- act.pressure 72.16 -4.33 21.65 2.00 1.000
Surch.1 - strip 4.52 -1.47 2.97 2.00 1.000

Verification of complete wall


Check for overturning stability
Resisting moment Mres = 303.40 kNm/m
Overturning moment Mov = 416.20 kNm/m
r

Safety factor = 0.73 < 1.50


Wall for overturning is NOT SATISFACTORY
Check for slip
Resisting horizontal force Hres = 144.20 kN/m

104
Active horizontal force Hact = 120.05 kN/m

Safety factor = 1.20 < 1.50


Wall for slip is NOT SATISFACTORY
Overall check - WALL is NOT SATISFACTORY

Bearing capacity of foundation soil


Dimensioning No. 1
Active pressure behind the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  d Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [°]
1 0.10 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272

Active pressure distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
0.10 1.49 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure) - partial results

Layer Thickness d   Ka Kae Kae-Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [°]
1 0.10 32.50 0.00 7.79 0.272 0.362 0.090

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure)

Layer Start [m] Z D Pressure Hor. comp. Vertical comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 1.40 0.13 0.12 0.04
1
0.10 1.40 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Pressure profile due to surcharge - Surch.1 - strip

105
Point Depth Hor. comp. Vert. comp.
No. [m] [kPa] [kPa]
1 0.00 0.00 0.00
2 0.00 0.00 0.00
3 0.10 0.00 0.00

Forces acting on construction

Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design


[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -0.29 7.57 0.36 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 0.97 -0.29 -0.48 0.36 1.000
Active pressure 0.00 -0.10 0.00 0.65 1.000
Earthq.- act.pressure 0.01 -0.07 0.00 0.65 1.000
Surch.1 - strip 0.00 -0.10 0.00 0.65 1.000

Wall check at the construction joint 0.10 m from the wall crest
Cross-section depth h = 0.65 m

Ultimate shear force VRd = 30.82 kN/m > 0.98 kN/m = VEd
Ultimate compressive force NRd = 281.26 kN/m > 7.09 kN/m = NEd
Ultimate moment MRd = 2.25 kNm/m > 0.02 kNm/m = MEd

Cross-section bearing capacity is SATISFACTORY

Hasil analisa sebagai berikut :


- Stabilitas Guling, safety factor/ SF 0,73 < 1,5
- Stabilitas Geser , safety factor/ SF 1,20 < 1,5
- Stabilitas Dinding Penahan Tanah tidak Stabil, untuk memperbaiki dari Stabilitas DPT
tidak stabil sebagai berikut :
o Menambahkan struktur Matras Bronjong pada bagian depan DPT, uraian
selengkapnya seperti dibawah
o Revisi dimensi Lebar di rubah menjadi 3,5 m atau lebih kecil, uraian
selengkapnya seperti dibawah

106
Hasil Analisa Stabilitas DPT dengan Software Gravity Wall

Gravity wall analysis


Input data
Project

Date : 16/01/2024

Settings
Standard - safety factors (22)

Materials and standards

Concrete structures : EN 1992-1-1 (EC2)


Coefficients EN 1992-1-1 : standard
Masonry (stone) wall : EN 1996-1-1 (EC6)
AASHTO - reduce parameters of friction soil/soil by 2/3 

Wall analysis

107
Active earth pressure calculation : Coulomb
Passive earth pressure Coulomb
calculation :
Earthquake analysis : Mononobe-Okabe
Shape of earth wedge : Calculate as skew
Allowable eccentricity : 0.333
Verification methodology : Safety factors (ASD)

Safety factors
Permanent design situation
Safety factor for overturning : SFo = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for sliding resistance : SFs = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for bearing capacity : SFb = 1.50 [–]

Material of structure
Unit weight  = 22.00 kN/m3

Masonry : Category I
Mortar origin : Prescribed mortar

Masonry strength fb = 2.00 MPa


Mortar strength f = 2.50 MPa
m

Parameters
Compressive strength fk = 0.96 MPa
Shear strength fvko = 0.10 MPa
Flexural tensile fxk = 0.05 MPa
strength
Partial factor M = 2.20

Geometry of structure

No Coordinate Depth
. X [m] Z [m]
1 0.00 -0.50
2 0.00 5.50
3 0.00 6.50
4 -3.50 6.50

108
No Coordinate Depth
. X [m] Z [m]
5 -3.50 5.50
6 -0.50 -0.50

The origin [0,0] is located at the most upper right point of the wall.
Wall section area = 15.50 m2.

Basic soil parameters

ef cef  su 


No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [kN/m3] [°]

1 Pasir lepas 32.50 23.00 15.10 5.10 16.70

All soils are considered as cohesionless for at rest pressure analysis.

Soil parameters

Pasir lepas
Unit weight :  =15.10 kN/
m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 32.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Angle of friction struc.-soil :  = 16.70 °
Soil : cohesionless
Saturated unit weight : sa = 15.10 kN/
t m3

Backfill
Assigned soil : Pasir lepas
Slope = 45.00 °

Geological profile and assigned soils

Thickness of layer Depth


No. Assigned soil Pattern
t [m] z [m]

1 - 0.00 ..  Pasir lepas

109
Foundation
Type of foundation : soil from geological profile

Terrain profile
Depth of terrain below the top of wall h = 0.50 m.

No Coordinates Depth
. x [m] z [m]
1 0.00 0.00
2 1.00 0.00
3 4.00 -2.00
4 5.00 -2.00

Origin [0,0] is located in upper right edge of construction.


Positive coordinate +z has downward direction.

Water influence
Ground water table is located below the structure.

Input surface surcharges

Surcharge Mag.1 Mag.2 Ord.x Length Depth


No. Action
new change [kN/m2] [kN/m2] x [m] l [m] z [m]
1 Yes permanent 7.60 4.00 6.00 on terrain

Resistance on front face of the structure


Resistance on front face of the structure: at rest
Soil on front face of the structure - Pasir lepas
Soil thickness in front of structure h = 1.00 m
Terrain surcharge f = 0.50 kN/m2

Terrain in front of structure is flat.

Earthquake

Factor of horizontal acceleration Kh = 0.1280


Factor of vertical acceleration Kv = 0.0640

Water below the GWT is restricted.

110
Settings of the stage of construction
Design situation : permanent

Verification No. 1
Pressure at rest on front face of the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  Kr Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3]
1 1.00 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 0.463

Pressure at rest distribution on front face of the structure

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
1.00 15.10 0.00 6.99 6.99 0.00

Active pressure behind the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  d Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [°]
1 0.64 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
2 0.79 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
3 0.51 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.772
4 0.57 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.772
5 1.49 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
6 1.38 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
7 0.13 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272
8 1.00 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272

Active pressure distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
0.64 9.62 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
0.64 9.62 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
2
1.43 21.52 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

111
Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.
No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
1.43 21.52 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
3
1.94 29.24 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1.94 29.24 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
4
2.50 37.77 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
2.50 37.77 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
5
3.99 60.28 0.00 2.55 2.44 0.73
3.99 60.28 0.00 2.55 2.44 0.73
6
5.37 81.11 0.00 8.22 7.87 2.36
5.37 81.11 0.00 8.22 7.87 2.36
7
5.50 83.05 0.00 8.75 8.38 2.51
5.50 83.05 0.00 8.75 8.38 2.51
8
6.50 98.15 0.00 12.86 12.32 3.70

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure) - partial results

Layer Thickness d   Ka Kae Kae-Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [°]
1 0.64 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
2 0.79 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
3 0.51 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
4 0.57 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
5 1.49 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
6 1.38 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
7 0.13 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252
8 1.00 32.50 22.17 7.79 0.384 0.636 0.252

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure)

Layer Start [m] Z D Pressure Hor. comp. Vertical comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 91.87 23.18 22.20 6.66
1
0.64 9.00 82.86 20.91 20.03 6.01
0.64 9.00 82.86 20.91 20.03 6.01
2
1.43 20.15 71.72 18.10 17.33 5.20
1.43 20.15 71.72 18.10 17.33 5.20
3
1.94 27.37 64.50 16.28 15.59 4.68

112
Layer Start [m] Z D Pressure Hor. comp. Vertical comp.
No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
1.94 27.37 64.50 16.28 15.59 4.68
4
2.50 35.35 56.51 14.26 13.66 4.10
2.50 35.35 56.51 14.26 13.66 4.10
5
3.99 56.42 35.45 8.95 8.57 2.57
3.99 56.42 35.45 8.95 8.57 2.57
6
5.37 75.92 15.95 4.02 3.85 1.16
5.37 75.92 15.95 4.02 3.85 1.16
7
5.50 77.73 14.13 3.57 3.42 1.02
5.50 77.73 14.13 3.57 3.42 1.02
8
6.50 91.87 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Pressure profile due to surcharge - Surch.1 - strip

Point Depth Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. [m] [kPa] [kPa]
1 0.00 0.00 0.00
2 0.00 0.00 0.00
3 0.55 0.00 0.00
4 0.55 1.77 0.53
5 0.64 1.77 0.53
6 0.64 1.81 0.54
7 1.43 1.77 0.53
8 1.43 1.78 0.53
9 1.94 1.75 0.52
10 1.94 1.76 0.53
11 2.50 1.72 0.52
12 2.50 1.74 0.52
13 3.99 1.65 0.49
14 3.99 1.65 0.50
15 5.37 1.56 0.47
16 5.50 1.55 0.46
17 5.50 1.55 0.47
18 6.50 1.49 0.45

Forces acting on construction

113
Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design
[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -2.63 341.00 2.19 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 43.65 -2.63 -21.82 2.19 1.000
FF resistance -3.49 -0.33 0.00 0.00 1.000
Resistance on front face -0.23 -0.50 0.00 0.00 1.000
Active pressure 20.33 -1.16 6.10 3.50 1.000
Earthq.- act.pressure 72.16 -4.33 21.65 3.50 1.000
Surch.1 - strip 4.52 -1.47 2.97 3.50 1.000

Verification of complete wall


Check for overturning stability
Resisting moment Mres = 805.08 kNm/m
Overturning moment Mov = 456.33 kNm/m
r

Safety factor = 1.76 > 1.50


Wall for overturning is SATISFACTORY
Check for slip
Resisting horizontal force Hres = 268.76 kN/m
Active horizontal force Hact = 136.94 kN/m

Safety factor = 1.96 > 1.50


Wall for slip is SATISFACTORY
Overall check - WALL is SATISFACTORY

Bearing capacity of foundation soil


Dimensioning No. 1
Active pressure behind the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  d Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [°]
1 0.10 0.00 32.50 23.00 15.10 16.70 0.272

Active pressure distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

114
Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.
No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
0.10 1.49 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure) - partial results

Layer Thickness d   Ka Kae Kae-Ka Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [°]
1 0.10 32.50 0.00 7.79 0.272 0.362 0.090

Earthquake effects (active earth pressure)

Layer Start [m] Z D Pressure Hor. comp. Vertical comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 1.40 0.13 0.12 0.04
1
0.10 1.40 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Pressure profile due to surcharge - Surch.1 - strip

Point Depth Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. [m] [kPa] [kPa]
1 0.00 0.00 0.00
2 0.00 0.00 0.00
3 0.10 0.00 0.00

Forces acting on construction

Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design


[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -0.28 8.56 0.47 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 1.10 -0.28 -0.55 0.47 1.000
Active pressure 0.00 -0.10 0.00 0.80 1.000
Earthq.- act.pressure 0.01 -0.07 0.00 0.80 1.000
Surch.1 - strip 0.00 -0.10 0.00 0.80 1.000

Wall check at the construction joint 0.10 m from the wall crest

115
Cross-section depth h = 0.80 m

Ultimate shear force VRd = 37.79 kN/m > 1.10 kN/m = VEd
Ultimate compressive force NRd = 322.25 kN/m > 8.01 kN/m = NEd
Ultimate moment MRd = 3.13 kNm/m > 0.25 kNm/m = MEd

Cross-section bearing capacity is SATISFACTORY

Hasil Analisa sebagai berikut :

- Stabilitas Guling, safety factor/ SF 1,76 > 1,50


- Stabilitas Geser , safety factor/ SF 1,96 > 1,5
- Dengan Dimensi Lebar 3,5 m DPT dengan tinggi 7 meter aman terhadap kondisi stabilitas
guling dan geser.

- Kondisi Dimensi DPT Tetap 2 meter tetapi ada penambahan Matras bronjong didepan
DPT setinggi 1 m
- Diperoleh hasil Safety Factor/ SF Stabilitas Guling 1,70 > 1,5 dan SF Stabilitas Geser 1,85 >
1,5 kondisi DPT setinggi 7 meter dengan Lebar 2 meter Stabil. Analisa selengkapnya
sebagai berikut :

Matras

Gravity wall analysis


Input data
Project

116
Date : 16/01/2024

Settings
Standard - safety factors (21)

Materials and standards

Concrete structures : EN 1992-1-1 (EC2)


Coefficients EN 1992-1-1 : standard
Masonry (stone) wall : EN 1996-1-1 (EC6)
AASHTO - reduce parameters of friction soil/soil by 2/3 

Wall analysis

Active earth pressure calculation : Coulomb


Passive earth pressure Coulomb
calculation :
Earthquake analysis : Mononobe-Okabe
Shape of earth wedge : Calculate as skew
Allowable eccentricity : 0.333
Verification methodology : Safety factors (ASD)

Safety factors
Seismic design situation
Safety factor for overturning : SFo = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for sliding resistance : SFs = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for bearing capacity : SFb = 1.50 [–]

Material of structure
Unit weight  = 22.00 kN/m3

Masonry : Category I
Mortar origin : Prescribed mortar

Masonry strength fb = 10.00 MPa


Mortar strength fm = 10.00 MPa

Parameters
Compressive strength fk = 4.50 MPa
Shear strength fvko = 0.10 MPa

117
Flexural tensile fxk = 0.10 MPa
strength
Partial factor M = 2.20

Geometry of structure

No Coordinate Depth
. X [m] Z [m]
1 0.00 -0.30
2 0.00 5.70
3 0.00 6.70
4 -2.00 6.70
5 -2.00 5.70
6 -0.50 -0.30

The origin [0,0] is located at the most upper right point of the wall.
Wall section area = 9.50 m2.

Basic soil parameters

ef cef  su 


No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [kN/m3] [°]

1 Pasir Lepas 32.50 23.00 15.10 5.10 21.70

2 Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense 33.50 0.00 18.50 8.50 10.50

All soils are considered as cohesionless for at rest pressure analysis.

Soil parameters

Pasir Lepas
Unit weight :  = 15.10 kN/
m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 32.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Angle of friction struc.-soil :  = 21.70 °
Soil : cohesionless

118
Saturated unit weight : sa = 15.10 kN/
t m3

Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense


Unit weight :  = 18.50 kN/
m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 33.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 0.00 kPa
Angle of friction struc.-soil :  = 10.50 °
Soil : cohesionless
Saturated unit weight : sa = 18.50 kN/
t m3

Backfill
Assigned soil : Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense
Slope = 45.00 °

Geological profile and assigned soils

Thickness of layer Depth


No. Assigned soil Pattern
t [m] z [m]

1 - 0.00 ..  Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense

Foundation
Type of foundation : soil from geological profile

Terrain profile
Depth of terrain below the top of wall h = 0.30 m.

No Coordinates Depth
. x [m] z [m]
1 0.00 0.00
2 1.00 0.00
3 2.00 -1.00
4 3.00 -1.00

Origin [0,0] is located in upper right edge of construction.


Positive coordinate +z has downward direction.

119
Water influence
Ground water table is located below the structure.

Input surface surcharges

Surcharge Mag.1 Mag.2 Ord.x Length Depth


No. Action
new change [kN/m2] [kN/m2] x [m] l [m] z [m]
1 Yes permanent 7.60 2.00 3.00 on terrain
2 Yes permanent 5.00 0.00 3.00 7.50

No. Name
1 Q
2 MATRAS

Resistance on front face of the structure


Resistance on front face of the structure: passive
Soil on front face of the structure - Pasir Lepas
Angle of friction struc.-soil  = 21.7 °
0
Soil thickness in front of h = 1.50 m
structure
Terrain surcharge f = 0.50 kN/m2

Terrain in front of structure is flat.

Applied forces acting on the structure

Force Fx Fz M x z
No. Name Action
new edit [kN/m] [kN/m] [kNm/m] [m] [m]
1 Yes Force No. 2 permanent 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.00
2 Yes Q permanent 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.00
3 Yes F1 permanent 5.00 5.00 5.00 150.00 0.00

Force l qx1 qx2


No. Name Type
new edit [m] [kN/m2] [kN/m2]
1 Yes Force No. 2 strip 1.00 1.00
2 Yes Q strip 2.00 15.00

120
Earthquake

Factor of horizontal acceleration Kh = 0.4350


Factor of vertical acceleration Kv = 0.2130

Water below the GWT is restricted.

Settings of the stage of construction


Design situation : seismic

Verification No. 1
Pressure at rest behind the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  Kr Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3]
1 0.66 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448
2 0.37 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448
3 0.23 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.834
4 4.44 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448
5 1.00 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448

Pressure at rest distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
0.66 12.24 0.00 5.49 5.49 0.00
0.66 12.24 0.00 5.49 5.49 0.00
2
1.03 19.00 0.00 8.51 8.51 0.00
1.03 19.00 0.00 8.51 8.51 0.00
3
1.26 23.25 0.00 13.87 13.87 0.00
1.26 23.25 0.00 13.87 13.87 0.00
4
5.70 105.45 0.00 55.54 55.54 0.00
5.70 105.45 0.00 55.54 55.54 0.00
5
6.70 123.95 0.00 63.83 63.83 0.00

Forces acting on construction

121
Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design
[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -2.79 209.00 1.24 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 90.92 -2.79 -44.52 1.24 1.000
FF resistance -266.73 -0.63 -90.97 0.01 1.000
Resistance on front face -4.35 -0.70 -1.43 0.01 1.000
Earthq.- face 13.64 -0.95 3.75 0.02 1.000
Pressure at rest 220.82 -2.25 0.00 2.00 1.000
Q 10.69 -4.25 0.00 2.00 1.000
MATRAS 0.00 -6.70 0.00 2.00 1.000
Force No. 2 -1.00 -2.20 0.00 2.00 1.000
Q -30.00 -2.70 0.00 2.00 1.000
F1 -5.00 -6.70 5.00 152.00 1.000

Verification of complete wall


Check for overturning stability
Resisting moment Mres = 1084.73 kNm/m
Overturning moment Movr = 639.11 kNm/m

Safety factor = 1.70 > 1.50


Wall for overturning is SATISFACTORY
Check for slip
Resisting horizontal force Hres = 53.50 kN/m
Active horizontal force Hact = 28.99 kN/m

Safety factor = 1.85 > 1.50


Wall for slip is SATISFACTORY
Overall check - WALL is SATISFACTORY

Bearing capacity of foundation soil


Design load acting at the center of footing bottom
Moment Norm. force Shear Force Eccentricity Stress
No.
[kNm/m] [kN/m] [kN/m] [–] [kPa]
1 -364.79 80.83 28.99 0.000 40.41

Service load acting at the center of footing bottom

122
No Moment Norm. force Shear Force
. [kNm/m] [kN/m] [kN/m]
1 -364.79 80.83 28.99

Dimensioning No. 1
Pressure at rest behind the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  Kr Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3]
1 0.10 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448

Pressure at rest distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
0.10 1.83 0.00 0.82 0.82 0.00

Forces acting on construction

Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design


[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -0.19 4.82 0.32 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 2.10 -0.19 -1.03 0.32 1.000
Pressure at rest 0.04 -0.03 0.00 0.60 1.000
Q 0.23 -0.05 0.00 0.60 1.000
MATRAS 0.00 -0.10 0.00 0.60 1.000
F1 -5.00 -0.10 5.00 150.60 1.000

Wall check at the construction joint 0.10 m from the wall crest
Cross-section depth h = 0.60 m

Ultimate shear force VRd = 15.24 kN/m > -2.63 kN/m = VEd
Ultimate compressive force NRd = 0.00 kN/m < 8.80 kN/m = NEd
Ultimate moment MRd = 2.62 kNm/m < 756.67 kNm/m = MEd

123
Kondisi Dimensi menjadi 1,60 m dengan penambahan Matras bronjong didepan DPT setinggi 1 m,
didapat hasil : SF (safety factor) untuk Guling 1,69 > 1,5 dan SF (safety factor) untuk Geser 2,96 > 1,5.
Stabilitas Bronjong Stabil. Analisa selengkapnya sebagai berikut :

Matras

Gravity wall analysis


Input data
Project

Date : 16/01/2024

Settings
Standard - safety factors (21)

Materials and standards

Concrete structures : EN 1992-1-1 (EC2)


Coefficients EN 1992-1-1 : standard
Masonry (stone) wall : EN 1996-1-1 (EC6)
AASHTO - reduce parameters of friction soil/soil by 2/3 

124
Wall analysis

Active earth pressure calculation : Coulomb


Passive earth pressure Coulomb
calculation :
Earthquake analysis : Mononobe-Okabe
Shape of earth wedge : Calculate as skew
Allowable eccentricity : 0.333
Verification methodology : Safety factors (ASD)

Safety factors
Seismic design situation
Safety factor for overturning : SFo = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for sliding resistance : SFs = 1.50 [–]
Safety factor for bearing capacity : SFb = 1.50 [–]

Material of structure
Unit weight  = 22.00 kN/m3

Masonry : Category I
Mortar origin : Prescribed mortar

Masonry strength fb = 10.00 MPa


Mortar strength fm = 10.00 MPa

Parameters
Compressive strength fk = 4.50 MPa
Shear strength fvko = 0.10 MPa
Flexural tensile fxk = 0.10 MPa
strength
Partial factor M = 2.20

Geometry of structure

No Coordinate Depth
. X [m] Z [m]
1 0.00 -0.30
2 0.00 5.70
3 0.00 6.70

125
No Coordinate Depth
. X [m] Z [m]
4 -1.59 6.70
5 -1.59 5.70
6 -0.50 -0.30

The origin [0,0] is located at the most upper right point of the wall.
Wall section area = 7.86 m2.

Basic soil parameters

ef cef  su 


No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3] [kN/m3] [°]

1 Pasir Lepas 32.50 23.00 15.10 5.10 21.70

2 Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense 33.50 0.00 18.50 8.50 10.50

All soils are considered as cohesionless for at rest pressure analysis.

Soil parameters

Pasir Lepas
Unit weight :  = 15.10 kN/
m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 32.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Angle of friction struc.-soil :  = 21.70 °
Soil : cohesionless
Saturated unit weight : sa = 15.10 kN/
t m3

Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense


Unit weight :  = 18.50 kN/
m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 33.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 0.00 kPa
Angle of friction struc.-soil :  = 10.50 °
Soil : cohesionless

126
Saturated unit weight : sa = 18.50 kN/
t m3

Backfill
Assigned soil : Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense
Slope = 45.00 °

Geological profile and assigned soils

Thickness of layer Depth


No. Assigned soil Pattern
t [m] z [m]

1 - 0.00 ..  Poorly graded sand (SP), medium dense

Foundation
Type of foundation : soil from geological profile

Terrain profile
Depth of terrain below the top of wall h = 0.30 m.

No Coordinates Depth
. x [m] z [m]
1 0.00 0.00
2 1.00 0.00
3 2.00 -1.00
4 3.00 -1.00

Origin [0,0] is located in upper right edge of construction.


Positive coordinate +z has downward direction.

Water influence
Ground water table is located below the structure.

Input surface surcharges

Surcharge Mag.1 Mag.2 Ord.x Length Depth


No. Action
new change [kN/m2] [kN/m2] x [m] l [m] z [m]
1 Yes permanent 7.60 2.00 3.00 on terrain
2 Yes permanent 5.00 0.00 3.00 7.50

127
No. Name
1 Q
2 MATRAS

Resistance on front face of the structure


Resistance on front face of the structure: passive
Soil on front face of the structure - Pasir Lepas
Angle of friction struc.-soil  = 21.7 °
0
Soil thickness in front of h = 1.50 m
structure
Terrain surcharge f = 0.50 kN/m2

Terrain in front of structure is flat.

Applied forces acting on the structure

Force Fx Fz M x z
No. Name Action
new edit [kN/m] [kN/m] [kNm/m] [m] [m]
1 Yes Force No. 2 permanent 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.00
2 Yes Q permanent 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.00
3 Yes F1 permanent 5.00 5.00 5.00 150.00 0.00

Force l qx1 qx2


No. Name Type
new edit [m] [kN/m2] [kN/m2]
1 Yes Force No. 2 strip 1.00 1.00
2 Yes Q strip 2.00 15.00

Earthquake

Factor of horizontal acceleration Kh = 0.4350


Factor of vertical acceleration Kv = 0.2130

Water below the GWT is restricted.

Settings of the stage of construction


Design situation : seismic

128
Verification No. 1
Pressure at rest behind the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  Kr Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3]
1 0.66 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448
2 0.37 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448
3 0.23 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.834
4 4.44 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448
5 1.00 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448

Pressure at rest distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
0.66 12.24 0.00 5.49 5.49 0.00
0.66 12.24 0.00 5.49 5.49 0.00
2
1.03 19.00 0.00 8.51 8.51 0.00
1.03 19.00 0.00 8.51 8.51 0.00
3
1.26 23.25 0.00 13.87 13.87 0.00
1.26 23.25 0.00 13.87 13.87 0.00
4
5.70 105.45 0.00 55.54 55.54 0.00
5.70 105.45 0.00 55.54 55.54 0.00
5
6.70 123.95 0.00 63.83 63.83 0.00

Forces acting on construction

Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design


[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -2.88 173.00 0.98 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 75.26 -2.88 -36.85 0.98 1.000
FF resistance -269.67 -0.64 -95.42 0.01 1.000
Resistance on front face -4.46 -0.71 -1.53 0.01 1.000
Earthq.- face 14.22 -0.96 4.29 0.02 1.000
Pressure at rest 220.82 -2.25 0.00 1.59 1.000
Q 10.69 -4.25 0.00 1.59 1.000
MATRAS 0.00 -6.70 0.00 1.59 1.000
Force No. 2 -1.00 -2.20 0.00 1.59 1.000

129
Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design
[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Q -30.00 -2.70 0.00 1.59 1.000
F1 -5.00 -6.70 5.00 151.59 1.000

Verification of complete wall


Check for overturning stability
Resisting moment Mres = 1011.96 kNm/m
Overturning moment Movr = 598.89 kNm/m

Safety factor = 1.69 > 1.50


Wall for overturning is SATISFACTORY
Check for slip
Resisting horizontal force Hres = 32.09 kN/m
Active horizontal force Hact = 10.85 kN/m

Safety factor = 2.96 > 1.50


Wall for slip is SATISFACTORY
Overall check - WALL is SATISFACTORY

Bearing capacity of foundation soil


Design load acting at the center of footing bottom
Moment Norm. force Shear Force Eccentricity Stress
No.
[kNm/m] [kN/m] [kN/m] [–] [kPa]
1 -374.49 48.49 10.85 0.000 30.48

Service load acting at the center of footing bottom


No Moment Norm. force Shear Force
. [kNm/m] [kN/m] [kN/m]
1 -374.49 48.49 10.85

Dimensioning No. 1
Pressure at rest behind the structure - partial results

Layer Thickness  d cd  Kr Comment


No. [m] [°] [°] [kPa] [kN/m3]
1 0.10 0.00 33.50 0.00 18.50 0.448

130
Pressure at rest distribution behind the structure (without surcharge)

Layer Start [m] Z W Pressure Hor. comp. Vert. comp.


No. End [m] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa] [kPa]
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
1
0.10 1.83 0.00 0.82 0.82 0.00

Forces acting on construction

Name Fhor App.Pt. Fvert App.Pt. Design


[kN/m] z [m] [kN/m] x [m] coefficient
Weight - wall 0.00 -0.19 4.70 0.30 1.000
Earthq.- constr. 2.05 -0.19 -1.00 0.30 1.000
Pressure at rest 0.04 -0.03 0.00 0.57 1.000
Q 0.23 -0.05 0.00 0.57 1.000
MATRAS 0.00 -0.10 0.00 0.57 1.000
F1 -5.00 -0.10 5.00 150.57 1.000

Wall check at the construction joint 0.10 m from the wall crest
Cross-section depth h = 0.57 m

Ultimate shear force VRd = 14.61 kN/m > -2.68 kN/m = VEd
Ultimate compressive force NRd = 0.00 kN/m < 8.70 kN/m = NEd
Ultimate moment MRd = 2.47 kNm/m < 756.58 kNm/m = MEd

5. STABILITAS BRONJONG PLTMH PATAMUAN

- Analisa perhitungan nya sebagai berikut :

131
PERHITUNGAN BRONJONG

1. DATA PERENCANAAN

1.1 Dimensi

B = 2.00 m
H = 0.50 m
L = 1.00 m
q (t/m)

b1 = 1.00 m
b2 = 1.00 m h5

b3 = 1.00 m h4

b4 = 1.00 m H = h1 h3

hw
hw = 2.50 m h2

h1 = 9.00 m
h3 = 1.00 m b1 b2 b3 b4

h4 = 1.00 m
B

h5 = 1.00 m

1.2 Parameter

Tanah 1
q = 0.76 t/m2 ( beban akibat tanah struktur forebay )
gm = 1.51 t/m3
ɸ˚ = 32.5 ˚
C = 2.30 t/m2

1.3 Angka keamanan

Guling = fs > 1.5


Eksentisitas = |e| < B/6
Geser = fs > 1.5

2. PERHITUNGAN STABILITAS

132
2.1 Beban vertikal

No. Uraian W (t) X (m) W×X


b × h × g × L
W1 2.00 × 0.50 × 1.51 × 1.00 1.51 8.50 12.84
W2 2.00 × 2.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 6.04 7.50 45.30
W3 2.00 × 3.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 9.06 6.50 58.89
W4 2.00 × 1.50 × 1.51 × 1.00 4.53 5.50 24.92
W5 2.00 × 1.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 3.02 4.50 13.59
W6 2.00 × 2.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 6.04 4.50 27.18
W7 2.00 × 4.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 12.08 3.50 42.28
W8 2.00 × 4.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 12.08 2.50 30.20
W9 2.00 × 2.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 6.04 1.50 9.06
W10 2.00 × 1.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 3.02 0.50 1.51
Gempa V 0.178 x 63.42 11.29 4.50 50.80
q 1.00 × 0.76 × 1.00 0.76 11.00 8.31
Total 75.46 324.86

2.2 Beban horizontal

a. Koefesien tanah aktif


Ka = ଶ ]Ǐ
‫݃ݐ‬ (45 - )

32.5
Ka = ‫݃ݐ‬ ଶ
(45 - )

= 0.30

b. Koefesien tanah pasif


Kp = ଶ ]Ǐ
‫݃ݐ‬ (45 + )

32.5
Kp = ‫݃ݐ‬ ଶ
(45 + )

= 3.32

Q = Ka × q = 0.23 ton/m

No. Uraian H (t) Y (m) H×Y

Pa1 0.23 × 9.00 2.05 4.50 9.20


Pa2 0.50 × 1.51 × 24.38 18.41 3.00 55.22
Phi d 0.50 x 1.00 x 6.25 3.13 1.25 3.91
Gempa H 0.36 x 63.42 22.64 4.50 101.88
Pp 0.50 × 3.32 × 3.40 5.64 2.00 11.29
Total 51.86 181.50

2.3 Stabilitas guling


∑ Mv
Fs =
∑ Mh
324.86
=
181.50
= 1.79 > 1.5 OK!!

133
2.4 Eksentisitas
(∑ W × X) - (∑ H × Y)
X =
∑W
324.86 - 181.50
=
75.46
= 1.90 m
|e| B
= - X
2
2.00
= - 1.90
2
= -0.90 m < B/6 = 0.33 OK!!

2.5 Stabilitas geser


(C × B) + (W × tgØ˚)
Fs =
∑W
4.60 + 29.98
=
75.46
= 0.46 > 1.50 TIDAK OK??

Dari Analisa diatas, didapat :

- Stabilitas Guling, safety factor/ SF 1,79 > 1,5


- Stabilitas Geser, safety factor/ SF 0,46 < 1,5
- Daya dukung tanah/ Eksentrisitas , safety factor/ SF -0,90 < 0,33
- Salah satu Solusi penanganan untuk memperbesar nilai Safety Factor dari
stabilitas geser adalah dengan memberi atau memakai material timbunan
matras dari Pasir Timbunan atau Sirtu karena kedua material ini
mempunyai nilai massa jenis yang besar, dengan massa jenis yang besar
akan memberikan dan menghasilkan stabilitas geser yang besar juga.
- Analisa selengkapnya pada uraian dibawah ini

134
PERHITUNGAN BRONJONG

1. DATA PERENCANAAN

1.1 Dimensi

B = 2.00 m
H = 0.50 m
L = 1.00 m
q (t/m)
b1 = 1.00 m
b2 = 1.00 m h5

b3 = 1.00 m h4

b4 = 1.00 m H = h1 h3

hw
hw = 2.50 m h2

h1 = 9.00 m
h3 = 1.00 m b1 b2 b3 b4

h4 = 1.00 m
B

h5 = 1.00 m

1.2 Parameter

Tanah 1
q = 0.76 t/m2 ( beban akibat tanah struktur forebay )
gm = 1.51 t/m3
ɸ˚ = 32.5 ˚
C = 2.30 t/m2

1.3 Angka keamanan

Guling = fs > 1.5


Eksentisitas = |e| < B/6
Geser = fs > 1.5

2. PERHITUNGAN STABILITAS

135
2.1 Beban vertikal

No. Uraian W (t) X (m) W×X


b × h × g × L
W1 2.00 × 0.50 × 1.51 × 1.00 1.51 8.50 12.84
W2 2.00 × 2.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 6.04 7.50 45.30
W3 2.00 × 3.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 9.06 6.50 58.89
W4 2.00 × 1.50 × 1.51 × 1.00 4.53 5.50 24.92
W5 2.00 × 1.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 3.02 4.50 13.59
W6 2.00 × 2.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 6.04 4.50 27.18
W7 2.00 × 4.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 12.08 3.50 42.28
W8 2.00 × 4.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 12.08 2.50 30.20
W9 2.00 × 2.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 6.04 1.50 9.06
W10 2.00 × 1.00 × 1.51 × 1.00 3.02 0.50 1.51
Gempa V 0.178 x 63.42 11.29 4.50 50.80
q 1.00 × 0.76 × 1.00 0.76 11.00 8.31
Total 138.46 331.53

2.2 Beban horizontal

a. Koefesien tanah aktif


Ka = ଶ ]Ǐ
‫݃ݐ‬ (45 - )

32.5
Ka = ‫݃ݐ‬ ଶ
(45 - )

= 0.30

b. Koefesien tanah pasif


Kp = ଶ ]Ǐ
‫݃ݐ‬ (45 + )

32.5
Kp = ‫݃ݐ‬ ଶ
(45 + )

= 3.32

Q = Ka × q = 0.23 ton/m

No. Uraian H (t) Y (m) H×Y

Pa 1 0.23 × 9.00 2.05 4.50 9.20


Pa 2 0.50 × 1.51 × 24.38 18.41 3.00 55.22
Phi d 0.50 x 1.00 x 6.25 3.13 1.25 3.91
Gempa H 0.36 x 63.42 22.64 4.50 101.88
Pp 0.50 × 3.32 × 3.40 5.64 2.00 11.29
Total 51.86 181.50

2.3 Stabilitas guling


∑ Mv
Fs =
∑ Mh
331.53
=
181.50
= 1.83 > 1.5 OK!!

136
6. KESIMPULAN DAN SARAN

- Untuk memperbesar nilai keamanan/ Safety factor suatu bangunan


terhadap Kondisi Geser, salah satunya dengan memperbesar dimensi dari
bangunan. Untuk Waterway PLTMH PATAMUAN :

Kondisi awal, lebar 0,4 meter, diperoleh nilai Sf Geser 0,89 < 1,5

Kondisi Lebar menjadi 0,8 meter, diperoleh nilai SF Geser 1,63 > 1,5

- Plat layanan Waterway dengan Lebar Total 2,2 meter termasuk plat
layanan satu arah karena nilai dari perbandingan ly/lx < 1, memakai beton
bertulang mutu K-175 atau K-225
- Untuk Dinding Penahan Tanah PLTMH PATAMUAN, kondisi kestabilan nya
diperoleh salah satunya dengan penambahan matras bronjong sebagai
momen penahan terhadap gaya aktif pada dinding penahannya. Salah
satunya untuk DPT dengan tinggi 7 meter kestabilan nya didapat dengan
menambah matras bronjong setinggi 1 meter.
- Untuk DPT dengan Lebar 2 meter, bisa diperkecil minimal 1,6 meter
dengan syarat penambahan matras bronjong setinggi 1 meter dibagian
depan dan material timbunan menggunakan pasir atau sirtu.
- Untuk Matras Bronjong dengan tinggi 9 meter yang berada di lokasi
Headpond PLTMH PATAMUAN, ke stabilan nya diperoleh dengan
menambahkan material pengisi timbunan bronjong dengan pasir atau sirtu
dikarenakan kedua material ini mempunyai massa jenis bahan yang besar
sehingga kestabilan dari konstruksi bronjongnya menjadi lebih besar
- Stabilitas lereng PLTMH PATAMUAN Teruma yang berada di lokasi
Waterway Sta 0+000 itu yang paling kritis dengan tinggi ± 21 meter,
untuk kondisi eksisting diperoleh nilai SF nya 0,74 < 1,5 kondisi lereng
tidak stabil, dengan penambahan atau memakai konstruksi Anchor bolt
atau spray concrete diperoleh nilai SF nya 1,64 > 1,5 kondisi lereng stabil

137
- Pada waktu pelaksanaan konstruksi harus dilakukan pekerjaan sondir, bor
tangan untuk mengetahui kondisi dari daya dukung bangunan sipil yang
ada di PLTMH PATAMUAN

138

Anda mungkin juga menyukai