Anda di halaman 1dari 42

PEKERJAAN

PEMBANGUNAN JARINGAN
IRIGASI D.I. LHOK
GUCI KABUPATEN ACEH
BARAT

STABILITAS – STRUKTUR TIMBUNAN/ TANGGUL IRIGASI STA. LG 18+3

TAHUN ANGGARAN 2023 - 2024


1. LOKASI PEKERJAAN
Lokasi pekerjaan berada pada Jaringan Irigasi D.I. Lhok Guci Kabupaten Aceh Barat Provinsi Aceh,
secara geografis berada pada koordinat 96°12'14.67"E - 96°13'6.00"E ; 4°17'11.01"N -
4°21'52.61"N, peta lokasi pekerjaan sebagai berikut :

2. DATA TANAH
Data tanah untuk lokasi pekerjaan timbunan saluran Irigasi Sta. LG 18+3 sebagai berikut :

1
Catatan :

- Titik Sondir : SO2 ( Lokasi 1 ) dan Titik Hand Bor : HB1 ( Lokasi 1 )
- Tinggi Muka Air Tanah : 1,6 m
- Kedalaman Tanah Keras : 3,6 m

3. REKAPITULASI ANALISA TIMBUNAN STA. LG. 18+3

REKAPITULASI ANALISA STABILITAS TIMBUNAN/ TANGGUL IRIGASI LHOK GUCI STA. LG 18+3
KABUPATEN ACEH BARAT
1 Stabilitas Guling
Safety Faktor/ SF 7.31 > 1.50
2 Stabilitas Geser
Safety Faktor/ SF 5.40 > 1.25
3 Daya Dukung Tanah
A Tanpa Perkuatan Geogrid
Safety Faktor/ SF 1.22 < 1.50 ( Isi Timbunan Sirtu )
1.34 < 1.50 ( Isi Timbunan Lempung, Pasir )
B Dengan Perkuatan Geogrid
Safety Faktor/ SF 2.23 > 1.50 ( Isi Timbunan Sirtu )
2.47 > 1.50 ( Isi Timbunan Lempung, Pasir )
4 Stabilitas Geser Rotasional
A Tanpa Perkuatan Geogrid
Safety Faktor/ SF 1.29 < 1.50
B Dengan Perkuatan Geogrid
Safety Faktor/ SF 1.5 > 1.30
5 Stabilitas Gelincir Lateral
Safety Faktor/ SF 2.5 > 1.50
6 Deformasi/ Regangan Batas Geogrid/ J
J  1746.78 kN pada arah sejajar mesin dan melintang mesin
7 Kuat Tarik Ijin Rencana Geogrid/ Ta
42.35 kN/m
8 Distribusi Perkuatan Geogrid
Tinggi Timbunan dibagi menjadi 3 zona perkuatan dengan tinggi yang sama
T.atas = 1/6 J = 291.13 kN/m
T.tengah = 1/3 J = 582.26 kN/m
T.bawah = 1/2 J = 873.39 kN/m
9 Spasi Vertikal Perkuatan
Jumlah lapis minumum/ N = 42 lapis
Nb = 21 lapis Distribusi pada 1/3 timbunan bawah
Nt = 14 lapis Distribusi pada 1/3 timbunan tengah
Na = 7 lapis Distribusi pada 1/3 timbunan atas
Spasi Vetikal Timbunan
Tinggi Timbunan = 1.4 m
Tinggi tiap zona = 0.47 m
10 Penurunan Timbunan/ Tanggul
A Tanpa Perkuatan Geogrid
Penurunan Total = 2.80 m
Waktu Terjadi = 10 Tahun
B Dengan Perkuatan Geogrid
Penurunan Total = 0.81 m
Waktu Terjadi = 17 Tahun

2
4. URAIAN ANALISA TIMBUNAN STA. LG. 18+3
A. Percepatan Gempa
JARINGAN IRIGASI D.I LHOK GUCI KABUPATEN ACEH BARAT PROVINSI ACEH
Struktur : Gempa
Bagian : Lokasi
Analisa Percepatan Gempa Rencana

Data-data
040 17' 26,46" N
Letak Geografis
960 12' 19,96 E
Kecamatan Pantai Ceureumen
Kabupaten Aceh Barat
Jaringan Irigasi D.I. Lhok Guci
Peta Zone Gempa

Perhitungan Koefisien Gempa


Zone Gempa 5 Tabel - Koefisien Zone
Koefisien Zone Gempa/ Z 1.20 - 1.40 Zone Koefisien Zona/ Z
Percepatan Gempa Dasar/ ac 190 100 Tahun 1 0.10 - 0.30
Faktor Koreksi Jenis Tanah/ v 1.1 2 0.30 - 0.60
Percepatan Gempa Terkoreksi/ ad 292.60 gal 3 0.60 - 0.90
Koefisien Gempa Horizontal/ Kh 0.298 4 0.90 - 1.20
Koefisien Gempa Vertikal/ Kv 0.149 5 1.20 - 1.40
6 1.40 - 1.60
Grafik Spektral Percepatan Gempa Sumber : Pd T-14-2004-A
Analisa Stabilitas Bendungan akibat Beban Gempa

Tabel - Percepatan Gempa Dasar


T Percepatan Gempa
(Tahun) Dasar/ ac (gal)
10 90
20 120
50 160
100 190
200 220
500 250
1000 280
5000 330
10000 350
Sumber : Pd T-14-2004-A
Analisa Stabilitas Bendungan akibat Beban Gempa

Tabel - Faktor Koreksi Jenis Tanah

3
B. STABILITAS TIMBUNAN/ TANGGUL

1.0 1.0
1.0 1.0

22.245

22.292

22.276

22.314

22.323

22.355

22.168

22.149
7.00 5.00 2.00 3.00 3.00 2.00 5.00

LG.18+3

0.2

MAT
3.6

Tanah Keras

4
DESAIN STRUKTUR TANGGUL IRIGASI LHOK GUCI KABUPATEN ACEH BARAT
Struktur : Stabilitas Tanggul Irigasi Sta. 18-3
Distribusi Gaya

WST1 WST2 WST3 1.0 WB1 WBA WB3


1.0
1.0
1.0

WB2
WT2 WT6
WT1 WT3 WT5 WT7

WLK
WT4 X
WT8

Keterangan :
X: Titik Guling
WT : Berat Timbunan
WST : Berat Sirtu
WB : Berat Beton
WA : Berat Air
WLK : Berat Lantai Kerja

Data Struktur
H 0.95 m L1 0.73 m gbeton 2.4 t/m3
h1 0.75 m L2 2.15 m gSi rtu 1.8 t/m3
h2 0.1 m L3 2.83 m gti mbuna n 2.17 t/m3
A 2 m B 1.00 m gl a nta i kerja 1.4 t/m3
C 2.3 t/m2
o
φ 14.7
Koefisien Tekanan Tanah Aktif/ Ka
1-Sin φ
Ka =
1+Sin φ
Ka 0.927
Koefisien Gempa/ K
Kh 0.251
Kv 0.126

Distribusi - Momen Gaya


G. Hori zonta l Jarak M. Akti f G. Verti ka l Jarak M. Pa s i f
Segmen Uraian
(ton) (m) (ton m) (ton) (m) (ton m)
Uplift
Uf
Uf = 1/2 gw.H.B 0.481 3.825 1.841
Berat Struktur
W = V.gb
WT1 = 0.5.b.h.gt 1.834 8.533 15.647
WT2 = b.h.gt 8.181 6.650 54.403
WT3 = 0.5.b.h.gt 1.834 5.067 9.290
WT4 = b.h.gt 0.158 3.865 0.612
WT5 = 0.5.b.h.gt 1.562 2.600 4.062
WT6 = b.h.gt 2.604 1.700 4.427
WT7 = 0.5.b.h.gt 1.562 0.800 1.250
W WT8 = 0.5.b.h.gt 0.477 0.733 0.350
WST1 = 0.5.b.h.gt 0.036 7.767 0.280
WST2 = b.h.gt 0.720 6.700 4.824
WST3 = 0.5.b.h.gt 0.036 5.633 0.203
WBA = 0,5.b.h.gbk 0.646 3.040 1.965
WLK = b.h.gbk 0.051 3.865 0.198
WB1 = 0,5.b.h.gbk 0.110 4.600 0.506
WB2 = b.h.gbk 0.175 3.865 0.677
WB3 = 0,5.b.h.gbk 0.110 3.100 0.341

5
Pg Gaya Gempa
Pgh = W.Kh
Pgh1 0.460 8.533 3.927
Pgh2 2.053 6.650 13.655
Pgh3 0.460 5.067 2.332
Pgh4 0.040 3.865 0.154
Pgh5 0.392 2.600 1.020
Pgh6 0.654 1.700 1.111
Pgh7 0.392 0.800 0.314
Pgh Pgh8 0.120 0.733 0.088
Pgh9 0.009 7.767 0.070
Pgh10 0.181 6.700 1.211
Pgh11 0.009 5.633 0.051
Pgh12 0.051 3.865 0.198
Pgh13 0.110 4.600 0.506
Pgh14 0.175 3.865 0.677
Pgh15 0.110 3.100 0.341

Pgv = W.(1-Kv)
Pgv1 1.603 8.533 13.676
Pgv2 7.150 6.650 47.548
Pgv3 1.603 5.067 8.120
Pgv4 0.138 3.865 0.535
Pgv5 1.366 2.600 3.550
Pgv6 2.276 1.700 3.869
Pgv7 1.366 0.800 1.092
Pgv Pgv8 0.417 0.733 0.306
Pgv9 0.031 7.767 0.244
Pgv10 0.629 6.700 4.216
Pgv11 0.031 5.633 0.177
Pgv12 0.565 3.865 2.183
Pgv13 0.045 4.600 0.205
Pgv14 0.096 3.865 0.372
Pgv15 0.153 3.100 0.475

Σ Gaya Horizontal 5.22 ton


Σ Gaya Vertikal 38.05 ton
Σ Momen Guling/ Aktif 25.65 ton m
Σ Momen Penahan/ Pasif 187.44 ton m

Kontrol Terhadap Guling


Persamaan
Dengan Gempa
σMR
SF = SF 7.31 > 1.5 Ok
σMG
Dimana :
SF = Faktor keamanan
Σ MR = Jumlah Momen Penahan
Σ MG = Jumlah Momen Guling

Kontrol Terhadap Geser


Persamaan
Dengan Gempa
Vtancb
2
V  tan   c  b 2

Vtancb SF SF 
2
3 3 SF 5.40 > 1.25 Ok
SF H
3

H
Gesr Geser

H
Gesr
Dimana :
SF = Faktor keamanan
Σ MR = Jumlah Momen Penahan
Σ V = Jumlah Gaya Vertikal
Σ H = Jumlah Gaya horizontal

6
Kontrol Terhadap Daya Dukung Tanah
1 Luas Timbunan

Timbunan 1 Timbunan 2

1.0 1.0
1.0 1.0

22.276

22.314

22.323

22.355

22.168

22.149
5.00 2.00 3.00 3.00 2.00 5.00

LG.18+3

Luas Timbunan 1 Luas Timbunan 2 Luas Total Timbunan = Luas Timb. 1 + Luas Timb.2
Lebar Atas = 2 m Lebar Atas = 1 m = 7.895 m2
Lebar Bawah = 5.3 m Lebar Bawah = 3.5 m
Tinggi = 1.3 m Tinggi = 1.4 m
Luas Timbunan 1= 4.745 m2 Luas Timbunan 2= 3.15 m2

2 Kapasitas Daya Dukung Ultimit


Persamaan Meyerhoff

Ž– ൌǤ
qul t = Kapasitas daya dukung ultimit, KN/m2
CU = Kuat geser tanah, KN/m2
= 8 Kpa ; Lapisan Tanah Lunak
NC = Faktor Daya dukung

ൌͷǤͳͶ൅ ͲǤͳͷ

B = Lebar dasar timbunan, m


= 9.5 m
D = Kedalaman tanah lunak, m
= 3.6 m
NC = 6.459
3 Beban Maksimum Kondisi Tanpa Geogrid
Pma x = gt H + q
Pmax = Beban maksimum, kN/m2
gt = Berat isi tanah timbunan, kN/m2
= 21.7 kN/m2 ( berat isi timbunan Sirtu, PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
= 19 kN/m2 ( berat isi timbunan tanah, lempung dan pasir, PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
H = Tinggi Timbunan, m
= 1.4 m
q = Beban merata, kN/m2 ( Beban lalu lintas untuk stabilitas, PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
12 kN/m2
1 Beban Maksimum untuk Timbunan Sirtu
Pmax = 42.38 kN/m2
2 Beban Maksimum untuk Timbunan Tanah Lempung
Pmax = 38.60 kN/m2

7
4 Faktor Keamanan Daya Dukung Tanah Tanpa Geogrid
—Ž–

Ǥ ƒš
QULT = 51.68 KN/m2
FKU = 1.22 < 1.5 ( Isi Timbunan Sirtu ) Cek
FKU = 1.34 < 1.5 ( Isi Timbunan Tanah, Lempung, Pasir ) Cek
5 Beban Maksimum Kondisi Dengan Geogrid
Ǥɀ–൅ “
 ƒš ൌ

Pmax =
Beban maksimum, kN/m2
gt =
Berat isi tanah timbunan, kN/m2
=
21.7 kN/m2 ( berat isi timbunan Sirtu, PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
=
19 kN/m2 ( berat isi timbunan tanah, lempung dan pasir, PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
B =
Lebar Dasar Timbunan, m
=
9.4 m
W =
Lebar Puncak Timbunan, m
=
3.9 m
q =
Beban merata, kN/m2 ( Beban lalu lintas untuk stabilitas, PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
12 kN/m2
1 Beban Maksimum untuk Timbunan Sirtu
Pmax = 23.20 kN/m2
2 Beban Maksimum untuk Timbunan Tanah Lempung
Pmax = 20.94 kN/m2

6 Faktor Keamanan Daya Dukung Tanah Dengan Geogrid


—Ž–

Ǥ ƒš
QULT = 51.68 KN/m2
FKU = 2.23 > 1.5 ( Isi Timbunan Sirtu ) Memenuhi
FKU = 2.47 > 1.5 ( Isi Timbunan Tanah, Lempung, Pasir ) Memenuhi

7 Stabilitas Geser Rotasional


1 Tanpa Geogrid
Fk = 1.29 < 1.5
2 Dengan Geogrid

൅ ‰ Ǥ Ǥ‘ • ሺɅെȾሻ
ൌ > 1.3

ͳǤͷ െ
‰ൌ
Ǥ‘ • ሺɅ െȾሻ
Resisiting moment/ MD = 1448.96 kNm
Sliding moment/ MR = 1123.32 kNm
Kekuatan Geogrid/ Tg = 162.52 kN
Jari-jari Sliding/ R = 6.68 m
0
Sudut geser/ q = 14.7
0
Sudut orientasi geogrid/ b = 0
Fk = 1.5 > 1.3

8
8 Stabilitas Gelincir Lateral
1 Gaya Geser

Ž• ൌͲǤͷǤ Ǥ Ǥƒ Ǥ ɀ ൅ʹ“
Gaya geser Geogrid/ Tls = 174.68 kN
Safety faktor/ Fk = 1.5
Tinggi timbunan/ H = 1.4 m
Koef. tekanan tanah aktif/ Ka = 0.927
Berat jenis timbunan/ g = 21.7 kN/m3
Beban timbunan/ q = 12 kN/m2
Faktor Reduksi Rangkak/ RF = 3 (PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
F.Reduksi rusak saat instalasi/ s = 1.1 (PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
Tls > Tg sehingga T.Rencana
T.Rencana = 174.68 kN
2 Gelincir Lateral
ʹ „ Ǥɀ Ǥ–ƒ Ʌ

ƒ ሺɀ ൅ ʹ “ ሻ

Fk = 2.50 > 1.5


9 Deformasi / Regangan Batas

Ž–

ߝ݃݁ ‫݊݅ݏ‬
‫݇݅ݐ ݁ݐ‬

Regangan batas perkuatan/ J = 1746.78 kN/m


Kekuatan Geosintetis Ultimit/ Tls = 174.68 kN
Batas regangan/ e = 10 %
Modulus Perkuatan Geogrid untuk batas regangan 10%
J  1746.78 kN pada arah sejajar mesin dan melintang mesin
10 Kuat Tarik Ijin Rencana Geogrid/ Ta

—Ž– —Ž–
ƒ ൌ ൌ
ˆ ˆ ” š ˆ‹† š ˆ†
faktor reduksi rangkak/ Rfcr = 3 (PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
f.redksi kerusakan instalasi/ Rfid = 1.1 (PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
faktor reduksi durabilitas/ Rfd = 1.25 (PU. Geoteknik - Pt T-10-2002 )
Ta = 42.35 kN/m
11 Distribusi Perkuatan Geogrid
Tinggi Timbunan dibagi menjadi 3 zona perkuatan dengan tinggi yang sama
T.atas = 1/6 J = 291.13 kN/m
T.tengah = 1/3 J = 582.26 kN/m
T.bawah = 1/2 J = 873.39 kN/m
12 Spasi Vertikal Perkuatan
Jumlah lapis minumum/ N = 41.25
= 42 lapis
Nb = 20.63 Distribusi pada 1/3 timbunan bawah
= 21.0 lapis
Nt = 13.75 Distribusi pada 1/3 timbunan tengah
= 14.0 lapis
Na = 6.88 Distribusi pada 1/3 timbunan atas
= 7.0 lapis
Spasi Vetikal Timbunan
Tinggi Timbunan = 1.4 m
Tinggi tiap zona = 0.47 m

9
ANALISA PENURUNAN TIMBUNAN IRIGASI IRIGASI LHOK GUCI
KABUPATEN ACEH BARAT
1. Penurunan Tanpa Perkuatan Geogrid
Tebal Z g DP PO' + DP Sc Si Stotal
PO' Cc eo Ci
tanah lunak ( m ) (m) ( kN/m3 ) (kN/m2) (kN/m2) (m) (m) (m)
0.2 0.2 16.51 1.340 29.902 31.242 0.34785 1.271 0.042 16.79 0.0043 0.046
0.2 0.4 16.51 2.680 29.902 32.582 0.34785 1.271 0.066 8.395 0.0069 0.073
0.2 0.6 16.51 4.020 29.902 33.922 0.34785 1.271 0.085 5.597 0.0088 0.094
0.2 0.8 16.51 5.360 29.902 35.262 0.34785 1.271 0.100 4.198 0.0103 0.111
0.2 1 16.51 6.700 29.902 36.602 0.34785 1.271 0.113 3.358 0.0117 0.125
0.2 1.2 16.51 8.040 29.902 37.942 0.34785 1.271 0.124 2.798 0.0128 0.137
0.2 1.4 16.51 9.380 29.902 39.282 0.34785 1.271 0.133 2.399 0.0138 0.147
0.2 1.6 16.51 10.720 29.902 40.622 0.34785 1.271 0.142 2.099 0.0146 0.156
0.2 1.8 16.51 12.060 29.902 41.962 0.34785 1.271 0.149 1.866 0.0154 0.165
0.2 2 16.51 13.400 29.902 43.303 0.34785 1.271 0.156 1.679 0.0161 0.172
0.2 2.2 16.51 14.741 29.902 44.643 0.34785 1.271 0.162 1.526 0.0167 0.179
0.2 2.4 16.51 16.081 29.902 45.983 0.34785 1.271 0.168 1.399 0.0173 0.185
0.2 2.6 16.51 17.421 29.902 47.323 0.34785 1.271 0.173 1.292 0.0178 0.191
0.2 2.8 16.51 18.761 29.902 48.663 0.34785 1.271 0.178 1.199 0.0183 0.196
0.2 3 16.51 20.101 29.902 50.003 0.34785 1.271 0.182 1.119 0.0188 0.201
0.2 3.2 16.51 21.441 29.902 51.343 0.34785 1.271 0.186 1.049 0.0192 0.205
0.2 3.4 16.51 22.781 29.902 52.683 0.34785 1.271 0.190 0.988 0.0196 0.209
0.2 3.6 16.51 24.121 29.902 54.023 0.34785 1.271 0.193 0.933 0.0199 0.213
Penurunan Total ( m ) 2.804
Waktu yang diperlukan untuk Penurunan Total
ܵܿ
ܷ ൌ ͳͲͲ Koefisien Consolidasi/ Cv = 0.000281 cm2/s
ܵ ‫ݐ‬
Derajat Consolidasi/ U = 90.64972 %

ߨ ܷ Tv = 0.645064
ܶ ௩ൌ Waktu Penurunan/ t = 2.98E+08 sekon
Ͷ ͳͲͲ
= 9.45 Tahun
ܶ ‫ ܼݒ‬ଶ = 10 Tahun
‫ݐ‬ൌ
‫ݒܥ‬
Penurunan 2,8 m akan terjadi dalam waktu ± 10 Tahun

10
ANALISA PENURUNAN TIMBUNAN IRIGASI IRIGASI LHOK GUCI
KABUPATEN ACEH BARAT
2. Penurunan Dengan Perkuatan Geogrid
Tebal Z g DP PO' + DP Sc Si Stotal
PO' Cc eo Ci
tanah lunak ( m ) (m) ( kN/m3 ) (kN/m2) (kN/m2) (m) (m) (m)
0.2 0.2 16.51 201.340 29.902 231.242 0.34785 1.271 0.002 0.112 0.0286 0.030
0.2 0.4 16.51 202.680 29.902 232.582 0.34785 1.271 0.004 0.111 0.0286 0.032
0.2 0.6 16.51 204.020 29.902 233.922 0.34785 1.271 0.005 0.110 0.0286 0.034
0.2 0.8 16.51 205.360 29.902 235.262 0.34785 1.271 0.007 0.110 0.0286 0.036
0.2 1 16.51 206.700 29.902 236.602 0.34785 1.271 0.009 0.109 0.0286 0.038
0.2 1.2 16.51 208.040 29.902 237.942 0.34785 1.271 0.011 0.108 0.0286 0.039
0.2 1.4 16.51 209.380 29.902 239.282 0.34785 1.271 0.012 0.107 0.0286 0.041
0.2 1.6 16.51 210.720 29.902 240.622 0.34785 1.271 0.014 0.107 0.0286 0.043
0.2 1.8 16.51 212.060 29.902 241.962 0.34785 1.271 0.016 0.106 0.0286 0.044
0.2 2 16.51 213.400 29.902 243.303 0.34785 1.271 0.017 0.105 0.0287 0.046
0.2 2.2 16.51 214.741 29.902 244.643 0.34785 1.271 0.019 0.105 0.0287 0.048
0.2 2.4 16.51 216.081 29.902 245.983 0.34785 1.271 0.021 0.104 0.0287 0.049
0.2 2.6 16.51 217.421 29.902 247.323 0.34785 1.271 0.022 0.103 0.0287 0.051
0.2 2.8 16.51 218.761 29.902 248.663 0.34785 1.271 0.024 0.103 0.0287 0.053
0.2 3 16.51 220.101 29.902 250.003 0.34785 1.271 0.025 0.102 0.0287 0.054
0.2 3.2 16.51 221.441 29.902 251.343 0.34785 1.271 0.027 0.102 0.0287 0.056
0.2 3.4 16.51 222.781 29.902 252.683 0.34785 1.271 0.028 0.101 0.0287 0.057
0.2 3.6 16.51 224.121 29.902 254.023 0.34785 1.271 0.030 0.100 0.0287 0.059
Penurunan Total ( m ) 0.810
Waktu yang diperlukan untuk Penurunan Total
ܵܿ
ܷ ൌ ͳͲͲ Koefisien Consolidasi/ Cv = 0.000281 cm2/s
ܵ ‫ݐ‬
Derajat Consolidasi/ U = 95.0 %

ߨ ܷ Tv = 1.129
ܶ ௩ൌ Waktu Penurunan/ t = 5.21E+08 sekon
Ͷ ͳͲͲ
= 16.54 Tahun
ܶ ‫ ܼݒ‬ଶ = 17 Tahun
‫ݐ‬ൌ
‫ݒܥ‬
Penurunan 0,8 m akan terjadi dalam waktu ± 17 Tahun

Slope stability analysis


Input data
Project

Date : 21/02/2024

Settings
Standard - safety factors (32)
Stability analysis

Earthquake analysis : Standard


Verification Safety factors (ASD)
methodology :

Safety factors
Seismic design situation
Safety factor : SFs = 1.50 [–]

11
Interface

Coordinates of interface points [m]


No. Interface location
x z x z x z
1 3.53 4.93 3.73 5.13 5.73 5.13
5.93 4.93

2 2.01 3.65 3.28 4.93 3.53 4.93


5.93 4.93 6.18 4.93 6.38 4.73

7.23 3.88 7.23 3.83 7.96 3.83

7.96 3.88 8.81 4.73 9.01 4.93

10.01 4.93 11.43 3.52

3 6.38 4.73 6.52 4.73 6.72 4.53


7.27 3.98 7.92 3.98 8.47 4.53

8.67 4.73 8.81 4.73

4 6.72 4.53 8.47 4.53

5 7.23 3.88 7.96 3.88

6 0.00 3.63 0.96 3.63 2.01 3.65


2.96 3.67 5.96 3.68 8.96 3.71

10.96 3.52 11.43 3.52 13.42 3.51

12
Coordinates of interface points [m]
No. Interface location
x z x z x z
7 0.00 3.40 13.42 3.40

8 0.00 3.20 13.42 3.20

9 0.00 3.00 13.42 3.00

10 0.00 2.80 13.42 2.80

11 0.00 2.60 13.42 2.60

12 0.00 2.40 13.42 2.40

13 0.00 2.20 13.42 2.20

14 0.00 2.05 13.42 2.05

13
Coordinates of interface points [m]
No. Interface location
x z x z x z

15 0.00 2.00 13.42 2.00

16 0.00 1.80 13.42 1.80

17 0.00 1.60 13.42 1.60

18 0.00 1.40 13.42 1.40

19 0.00 1.20 13.42 1.20

20 0.00 1.00 13.42 1.00

21 0.00 0.80 13.42 0.80

14
Coordinates of interface points [m]
No. Interface location
x z x z x z

22 0.00 0.60 13.42 0.60

23 0.00 0.40 13.42 0.40

24 0.00 0.20 13.42 0.20

25 0.00 0.00 13.42 0.00

Soil parameters - effective stress state

ef cef 
No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3]

1 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL, CI), firm consistency 14.70 23.00 11.47

2 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL, CI), soft consistency 14.70 23.00 11.47

3 Clay with high or very high plasticity (CH, CV, CE), firm consistency 14.70 23.00 11.47

15
ef cef 
No. Name Pattern
[°] [kPa] [kN/m3]

4 Sand with trace of fines (S-F), medium dense 1.50 0.00 24.50

5 Sandy silt (MS), firm consistency 2.50 0.00 24.50

6 Clayey gravel (GC) 14.70 23.00 11.47

Soil parameters - uplift

sat s n
No. Name Pattern
[kN/m3] [kN/m3] [–]

1 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL, CI), firm consistency 11.47

2 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL, CI), soft consistency 11.47

3 Clay with high or very high plasticity (CH, CV, CE), firm consistency 11.47

4 Sand with trace of fines (S-F), medium dense 24.50

5 Sandy silt (MS), firm consistency 24.50

6 Clayey gravel (GC) 11.47

Soil parameters

Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL, CI), firm consistency


Unit weight :  = 11.47 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 14.70 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa

16
Saturated unit weight : sat = 11.47 kN/m3

Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL, CI), soft consistency


Unit weight :  = 11.47 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 14.70 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Saturated unit weight : sat = 11.47 kN/m3

Clay with high or very high plasticity (CH, CV, CE), firm consistency
Unit weight :  = 11.47 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 14.70 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Saturated unit weight : sat = 11.47 kN/m3

Sand with trace of fines (S-F), medium dense


Unit weight :  = 24.50 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 1.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 0.00 kPa
Saturated unit weight : sa = 24.50 kN/m3
t

Sandy silt (MS), firm consistency


Unit weight :  = 24.50 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 2.50 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 0.00 kPa
Saturated unit weight : sa = 24.50 kN/m3
t

Clayey gravel (GC)


Unit weight :  = 11.47 kN/m3
Stress-state : effective
Angle of internal friction : ef = 14.70 °
Cohesion of soil : cef = 23.00 kPa
Saturated unit weight : sa = 11.47 kN/m3
t

17
Rigid bodies


No. Name Sample
[kN/m3]

1 Beton K-175 23.00

2 Sirtu 18.00

3 Lantai kerja 14.00

4 Air 10.00

5 Tanah Timbunan Pilihan 21.70

Assigning and surfaces

Coordinates of surface
Assigned
No. Surface position points [m]
x z x z soil
1 5.93 4.93 5.73 5.13
Sirtu
3.73 5.13 3.53 4.93

2 6.72 4.53 7.27 3.98


Air
7.92 3.98 8.47 4.53

18
Coordinates of surface
Assigned
No. Surface position points [m]
x z x z soil
3 7.96 3.88 8.81 4.73
Beton K-175
8.67 4.73 8.47 4.53

7.92 3.98 7.27 3.98

6.72 4.53 6.52 4.73

6.38 4.73 7.23 3.88

4 7.23 3.88 7.23 3.83


Lantai kerja
7.96 3.83 7.96 3.88

5 2.96 3.67 5.96 3.68


Tanah Timbunan Pilihan
8.96 3.71 10.96 3.52

11.43 3.52 10.01 4.93

9.01 4.93 8.81 4.73

7.96 3.88 7.96 3.83

7.23 3.83 7.23 3.88

6.38 4.73 6.18 4.93

5.93 4.93 3.53 4.93

3.28 4.93 2.01 3.65

6 13.42 3.40 13.42 3.51 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
11.43 3.52 10.96 3.52 CI), firm consistency

8.96 3.71 5.96 3.68

2.96 3.67 2.01 3.65

0.96 3.63 0.00 3.63

0.00 3.40

7 13.42 3.20 13.42 3.40 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
0.00 3.40 0.00 3.20 CI), soft consistency

19
Coordinates of surface
Assigned
No. Surface position points [m]
x z x z soil

8 13.42 3.00 13.42 3.20 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
0.00 3.20 0.00 3.00 CI), firm consistency

9 13.42 2.80 13.42 3.00 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
0.00 3.00 0.00 2.80 CI), firm consistency

10 13.42 2.60 13.42 2.80 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
0.00 2.80 0.00 2.60 CI), firm consistency

11 13.42 2.40 13.42 2.60 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
0.00 2.60 0.00 2.40 CI), soft consistency

20
Coordinates of surface
Assigned
No. Surface position points [m]
x z x z soil

12 13.42 2.20 13.42 2.40 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
0.00 2.40 0.00 2.20 CI), soft consistency

13 13.42 2.05 13.42 2.20 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
0.00 2.20 0.00 2.05 CI), soft consistency

14 13.42 2.00 13.42 2.05 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
0.00 2.05 0.00 2.00 CI), soft consistency

15 13.42 1.80 13.42 2.00 Clay with low or medium plasticity (CL,
0.00 2.00 0.00 1.80 CI), soft consistency

21
Coordinates of surface
Assigned
No. Surface position points [m]
x z x z soil

16 13.42 1.60 13.42 1.80 Clay with high or very high plasticity (CH,
0.00 1.80 0.00 1.60 CV, CE), firm consistency

17 13.42 1.40 13.42 1.60 Clay with high or very high plasticity (CH,
0.00 1.60 0.00 1.40 CV, CE), firm consistency

18 13.42 1.20 13.42 1.40 Clay with high or very high plasticity (CH,
0.00 1.40 0.00 1.20 CV, CE), firm consistency

19 13.42 1.00 13.42 1.20 Sand with trace of fines (S-F), medium
0.00 1.20 0.00 1.00 dense

22
Coordinates of surface
Assigned
No. Surface position points [m]
x z x z soil

20 13.42 0.80 13.42 1.00


Sandy silt (MS), firm consistency
0.00 1.00 0.00 0.80

21 13.42 0.60 13.42 0.80 Sand with trace of fines (S-F), medium
0.00 0.80 0.00 0.60 dense

22 13.42 0.40 13.42 0.60


Sandy silt (MS), firm consistency
0.00 0.60 0.00 0.40

23 13.42 0.20 13.42 0.40


Clayey gravel (GC)
0.00 0.40 0.00 0.20

23
Coordinates of surface
Assigned
No. Surface position points [m]
x z x z soil

24 13.42 0.00 13.42 0.20


Clayey gravel (GC)
0.00 0.20 0.00 0.00

25 0.00 0.00 0.00 -5.00 Sand with trace of fines (S-F), medium
13.42 -5.00 13.42 0.00 dense

Surcharge

Location Origin Length Width Slope Magnitude


No. Type Type of action
z [m] x [m] l [m] b [m]  [°] q, q1, f, F q2 unit

1 strip permanent on terrain x = 3.70 l = 2.00 0.00 12.00 kN/m2

Surcharges

No. Name

1 q-beban gandar

24
Water

Water type : GWT

Coordinates of GWT points [m]


No. GWT location
x z x z x z
0.00 2.05 13.42 2.05

Tensile crack

Tensile crack not input.

Earthquake

Horizontal seismic coefficient : Kh = 0.2980


Vertical seismic coefficient : Kv = 0.1490

Settings of the stage of construction

Design situation : seismic

Results (Stage of construction 1)

Analysis 1
Circular slip surface

Slip surface parameters


x= 6.72 [m] 1 = -77.73 [°]
Center : Angles :
z= 5.05 [m] 2 = 76.68 [°]

25
Slip surface parameters
Radius : R= 6.68 [m]
The slip surface after optimization.

Slope stability verification (Bishop)


Sum of active forces : Fa = 168.16 kN/m
Sum of passive forces : Fp = 216.91 kN/m

Sliding moment : Ma = 1123.32 kNm/m


Resisting moment : Mp 1448.96 kNm/m
=

Factor of safety = 1.29 < 1.50


Slope stability NOT ACCEPTABLE
Optimization of circular slip surface (Bishop)
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
1 7.67 6.95 6.54 1.49 NOT ACCEPTABLE
2 7.67 6.95 6.54 1.49 NOT ACCEPTABLE
3 7.66 6.94 6.53 1.51 ACCEPTABLE
4 6.74 6.77 7.25 1.61 ACCEPTABLE
5 6.75 8.22 8.00 2.21 ACCEPTABLE
6 6.72 4.29 6.55 1.42 NOT ACCEPTABLE
7 6.76 8.53 8.18 1.93 ACCEPTABLE
8 8.16 5.63 5.48 60.91 ACCEPTABLE
9 6.72 4.29 6.55 1.42 NOT ACCEPTABLE
10 7.91 96.23 92.76 92.11 ACCEPTABLE
11 6.72 4.29 6.55 1.42 NOT ACCEPTABLE
12 6.72 3.94 4.79 2.41 ACCEPTABLE
13 6.74 6.70 7.22 1.60 ACCEPTABLE
14 5.86 5.32 5.91 2.43 ACCEPTABLE
15 7.60 5.31 5.90 1.56 ACCEPTABLE
16 6.72 4.30 4.83 2.52 ACCEPTABLE
17 6.72 4.29 6.55 1.42 NOT ACCEPTABLE
18 7.52 162.70 159.24 4.36 ACCEPTABLE
19 6.72 4.29 6.55 1.42 NOT ACCEPTABLE
20 6.72 4.15 5.38 1.87 ACCEPTABLE
21 6.73 5.77 6.87 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
22 6.14 4.68 6.03 1.72 ACCEPTABLE
23 6.73 5.69 5.75 2.61 ACCEPTABLE
24 6.75 7.85 7.79 2.41 ACCEPTABLE
25 6.16 6.76 6.73 3.10 ACCEPTABLE
26 6.73 5.63 6.83 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
27 6.14 4.56 6.01 1.73 ACCEPTABLE
28 6.73 5.54 5.70 2.38 ACCEPTABLE
29 6.75 7.63 7.67 2.24 ACCEPTABLE

26
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]

30 6.16 6.58 6.65 2.66 ACCEPTABLE


31 6.73 5.49 6.79 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
32 6.14 4.44 6.00 1.72 ACCEPTABLE
33 6.73 5.39 5.65 2.25 ACCEPTABLE
34 6.75 7.42 7.56 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
35 6.16 6.40 6.57 2.40 ACCEPTABLE
36 6.73 5.35 6.75 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
37 6.14 4.33 5.98 1.73 ACCEPTABLE
38 6.73 5.24 5.61 2.14 ACCEPTABLE
39 6.74 7.22 7.46 1.81 ACCEPTABLE
40 6.16 6.23 6.50 2.25 ACCEPTABLE
41 6.73 5.22 6.72 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
42 6.14 4.21 5.97 1.75 ACCEPTABLE
43 6.73 5.10 5.57 2.08 ACCEPTABLE
44 6.74 7.03 7.37 1.75 ACCEPTABLE
45 6.16 6.07 6.44 2.18 ACCEPTABLE
46 6.72 5.08 6.68 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
47 6.13 4.09 5.95 1.76 ACCEPTABLE
48 6.72 4.96 5.52 2.03 ACCEPTABLE
49 6.74 6.84 7.29 1.64 ACCEPTABLE
50 6.15 5.90 6.37 2.06 ACCEPTABLE
51 6.72 4.96 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
52 6.72 4.95 6.65 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
53 6.14 4.35 5.98 1.72 ACCEPTABLE
54 7.31 5.90 6.37 1.60 ACCEPTABLE
55 6.72 5.13 5.57 2.08 ACCEPTABLE
56 7.30 4.36 5.98 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
57 7.29 4.09 5.95 1.49 NOT ACCEPTABLE
58 7.30 4.35 5.98 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
59 6.71 3.75 5.35 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
60 6.72 5.08 6.68 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
61 6.14 4.35 5.98 1.72 ACCEPTABLE
62 6.72 5.08 6.68 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
63 6.33 4.48 6.19 1.56 ACCEPTABLE
64 6.72 5.04 5.92 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
65 6.73 6.19 7.02 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
66 6.34 5.61 6.45 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
67 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
68 6.33 4.43 6.18 1.58 ACCEPTABLE
69 6.72 4.99 5.91 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
70 6.73 6.13 6.99 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
71 6.34 5.55 6.43 1.67 ACCEPTABLE
72 6.72 4.98 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
73 6.72 4.97 6.66 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
74 6.33 4.55 6.20 1.55 ACCEPTABLE

27
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
75 6.71 4.07 5.76 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
76 7.11 5.56 6.44 1.44 NOT ACCEPTABLE
77 6.72 5.06 5.93 1.70 ACCEPTABLE
78 7.10 4.55 6.20 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
79 7.10 4.43 6.19 1.39 NOT ACCEPTABLE
80 6.71 4.07 5.76 1.68 ACCEPTABLE
81 7.10 4.55 6.20 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
82 6.71 4.12 5.76 1.65 ACCEPTABLE
83 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
84 6.33 4.55 6.20 1.55 ACCEPTABLE
85 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
86 6.46 4.66 6.34 1.47 NOT ACCEPTABLE
87 6.72 5.02 6.17 1.52 ACCEPTABLE
88 6.73 5.74 6.86 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
89 6.47 5.37 6.50 1.49 NOT ACCEPTABLE
90 6.72 5.01 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
91 6.46 4.11 6.27 1.55 ACCEPTABLE
92 6.72 5.01 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
93 6.46 4.71 6.35 1.45 NOT ACCEPTABLE
94 6.72 4.41 6.56 1.40 NOT ACCEPTABLE
95 6.71 4.39 6.05 1.54 ACCEPTABLE
96 6.98 5.38 6.51 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
97 6.72 5.05 6.17 1.51 ACCEPTABLE
98 6.98 4.71 6.36 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
99 6.98 4.66 6.35 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
100 6.71 4.39 6.05 1.54 ACCEPTABLE
101 6.98 4.71 6.36 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
102 6.71 4.41 6.05 1.52 ACCEPTABLE
103 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
104 6.46 4.71 6.35 1.45 NOT ACCEPTABLE
105 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
106 6.55 4.79 6.45 1.39 NOT ACCEPTABLE
107 6.72 5.03 6.34 1.44 NOT ACCEPTABLE
108 6.73 5.49 6.79 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
109 6.55 5.26 6.56 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
110 6.72 5.02 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
111 6.54 4.41 6.39 1.44 NOT ACCEPTABLE
112 6.72 5.02 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
113 6.55 4.81 6.46 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
114 6.72 4.61 6.59 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
115 6.72 4.60 6.25 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
116 6.90 5.26 6.56 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
117 6.72 5.04 6.34 1.45 NOT ACCEPTABLE
118 6.89 4.82 6.46 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
119 6.89 4.41 6.39 1.39 NOT ACCEPTABLE
120 6.71 4.22 6.20 1.51 ACCEPTABLE

28
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
121 6.89 4.80 6.46 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
122 6.72 4.60 6.25 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
123 6.89 4.41 6.39 1.39 NOT ACCEPTABLE
124 6.89 4.82 6.46 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
125 6.72 4.61 6.25 1.44 NOT ACCEPTABLE
126 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
127 6.55 4.82 6.46 1.40 NOT ACCEPTABLE
128 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
129 6.61 4.88 6.53 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
130 6.72 5.03 6.45 1.39 NOT ACCEPTABLE
131 6.73 5.33 6.74 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
132 6.61 5.18 6.59 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
133 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
134 6.60 4.61 6.48 1.40 NOT ACCEPTABLE
135 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
136 6.61 4.89 6.53 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
137 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
138 6.72 4.74 6.39 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
139 6.84 5.18 6.60 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
140 6.72 5.04 6.45 1.41 NOT ACCEPTABLE
141 6.84 4.89 6.53 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
142 6.83 4.61 6.48 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
143 6.72 4.48 6.34 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
144 6.84 4.88 6.53 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
145 6.72 4.74 6.39 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
146 6.83 4.61 6.48 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
147 6.84 4.89 6.53 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
148 6.72 4.75 6.39 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
149 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
150 6.61 4.89 6.53 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
151 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
152 6.64 4.93 6.57 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
153 6.72 5.03 6.52 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
154 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
155 6.65 5.13 6.62 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
156 6.73 5.23 6.57 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
157 6.73 5.43 6.77 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
158 6.65 5.34 6.68 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
159 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
160 6.65 4.94 6.58 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
161 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
162 6.65 5.13 6.62 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
163 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
164 6.73 5.03 6.53 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
165 6.80 5.33 6.67 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
166 6.73 5.24 6.57 1.39 NOT ACCEPTABLE

29
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
167 6.80 5.13 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
168 6.80 4.93 6.57 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
169 6.73 4.84 6.49 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
170 6.80 5.12 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
171 6.73 5.03 6.53 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
172 6.80 4.93 6.57 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
173 6.80 5.13 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
174 6.73 5.04 6.53 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
175 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
176 6.65 5.13 6.62 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
177 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
178 6.68 5.16 6.66 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
179 6.73 5.23 6.62 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
180 6.73 5.36 6.75 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
181 6.68 5.30 6.69 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
182 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
183 6.68 5.03 6.63 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
184 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
185 6.68 5.17 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
186 6.72 5.09 6.69 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
187 6.73 5.10 6.59 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
188 6.78 5.30 6.68 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
189 6.73 5.23 6.62 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
190 6.78 5.16 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
191 6.78 5.03 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
192 6.73 4.97 6.56 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
193 6.78 5.16 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
194 6.73 5.10 6.59 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
195 6.78 5.03 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
196 6.78 5.16 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
197 6.73 5.10 6.59 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
198 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
199 6.68 5.17 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
200 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
201 6.69 5.19 6.68 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
202 6.73 5.23 6.65 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
203 6.73 5.32 6.74 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
204 6.69 5.28 6.70 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
205 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
206 6.69 5.10 6.66 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
207 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
208 6.69 5.19 6.68 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
209 6.72 5.14 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
210 6.73 5.14 6.63 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
211 6.76 5.27 6.69 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
212 6.73 5.23 6.66 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE

30
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
213 6.76 5.18 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
214 6.76 5.09 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
215 6.73 5.06 6.61 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
216 6.76 5.18 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
217 6.73 5.14 6.63 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
218 6.76 5.09 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
219 6.76 5.18 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
220 6.73 5.14 6.63 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
221 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
222 6.69 5.19 6.68 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
223 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
224 6.71 5.20 6.69 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
225 6.73 5.23 6.68 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
226 6.73 5.29 6.73 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
227 6.71 5.26 6.71 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
228 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
229 6.71 5.14 6.68 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
230 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
231 6.71 5.20 6.69 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
232 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
233 6.73 5.17 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
234 6.75 5.26 6.70 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
235 6.73 5.23 6.68 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
236 6.75 5.20 6.69 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
237 6.75 5.14 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
238 6.73 5.11 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
239 6.75 5.20 6.69 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
240 6.73 5.17 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
241 6.75 5.14 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
242 6.75 5.20 6.69 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
243 6.73 5.17 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
244 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
245 6.71 5.20 6.69 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
246 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
247 6.71 5.21 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
248 6.73 5.23 6.69 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
249 6.73 5.27 6.73 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
250 6.71 5.25 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
251 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
252 6.71 5.17 6.69 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
253 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
254 6.71 5.21 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
255 6.72 5.19 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
256 6.73 5.19 6.68 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
257 6.74 5.25 6.71 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
258 6.73 5.23 6.69 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE

31
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
259 6.74 5.21 6.70 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
260 6.74 5.17 6.69 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
261 6.73 5.15 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
262 6.74 5.21 6.70 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
263 6.73 5.19 6.68 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
264 6.74 5.17 6.69 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
265 6.74 5.21 6.70 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
266 6.73 5.19 6.68 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
267 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
268 6.71 5.21 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
269 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
270 6.72 5.22 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
271 6.73 5.23 6.70 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
272 6.73 5.25 6.72 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
273 6.72 5.25 6.72 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
274 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
275 6.72 5.19 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
276 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
277 6.72 5.22 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
278 6.72 5.20 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
279 6.73 5.20 6.69 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
280 6.74 5.24 6.71 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
281 6.73 5.23 6.70 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
282 6.74 5.21 6.70 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
283 6.74 5.19 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
284 6.73 5.18 6.69 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
285 6.74 5.21 6.70 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
286 6.73 5.20 6.69 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
287 6.74 5.19 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
288 6.74 5.21 6.70 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
289 6.73 5.20 6.69 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
290 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
291 6.72 5.22 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
292 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
293 6.72 5.22 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
294 6.73 5.23 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
295 6.73 5.25 6.72 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
296 6.72 5.24 6.72 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
297 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
298 6.72 5.21 6.71 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
299 6.71 5.20 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
300 6.72 5.21 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
301 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
302 6.71 5.22 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
303 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
304 6.71 5.18 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE

32
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
305 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
306 6.71 5.20 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
307 6.72 5.20 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
308 6.72 5.19 6.69 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
309 6.73 5.22 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
310 6.72 5.21 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
311 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
312 6.73 5.18 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
313 6.72 5.18 6.69 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
314 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
315 6.72 5.19 6.69 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
316 6.73 5.19 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
317 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
318 6.72 5.19 6.69 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
319 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
320 6.71 5.20 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
321 6.72 5.21 6.71 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
322 6.72 5.20 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
323 6.72 5.21 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
324 6.73 5.23 6.72 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
325 6.72 5.22 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
326 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
327 6.72 5.19 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
328 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
329 6.72 5.20 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
330 6.72 5.20 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
331 6.72 5.20 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
332 6.73 5.22 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
333 6.72 5.21 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
334 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
335 6.72 5.19 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
336 6.72 5.19 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
337 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
338 6.72 5.20 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
339 6.73 5.20 6.71 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
340 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
341 6.72 5.20 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
342 6.73 5.21 6.71 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
343 6.72 5.20 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
344 6.78 10.93 9.83 2.79 ACCEPTABLE
345 6.80 9.97 6.82 463.70 ACCEPTABLE
346 6.77 9.60 8.87 1.97 ACCEPTABLE
347 6.77 7.71 5.12 324.97 ACCEPTABLE
348 6.75 8.45 8.14 2.04 ACCEPTABLE
349 6.75 8.38 8.10 2.12 ACCEPTABLE
350 6.72 4.74 6.61 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE

33
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
351 6.77 9.62 8.89 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
352 8.22 6.22 5.69 63.35 ACCEPTABLE
353 6.71 4.64 3.91 259.12 ACCEPTABLE
354 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
355 6.77 9.62 8.89 1.96 ACCEPTABLE
356 8.21 6.23 5.70 60.58 ACCEPTABLE
357 6.71 4.65 3.92 278.99 ACCEPTABLE
358 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
359 6.95 138.92 135.46 74.00 ACCEPTABLE
360 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
361 6.72 4.39 4.84 2.56 ACCEPTABLE
362 6.75 7.44 7.57 2.00 ACCEPTABLE
363 5.87 5.91 6.11 2.85 ACCEPTABLE
364 6.72 4.47 6.57 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
365 6.72 4.47 6.57 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
366 5.84 3.71 5.65 2.19 ACCEPTABLE
367 7.60 5.91 6.10 1.81 ACCEPTABLE
368 6.73 4.80 4.93 2.86 ACCEPTABLE
369 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
370 5.84 3.71 5.65 2.19 ACCEPTABLE
371 7.52 162.75 159.28 24.77 ACCEPTABLE
372 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
373 6.14 3.81 5.94 1.82 ACCEPTABLE
374 6.72 4.62 5.46 1.90 ACCEPTABLE
375 6.74 6.38 7.09 1.49 NOT ACCEPTABLE
376 6.15 5.50 6.24 1.90 ACCEPTABLE
377 6.72 4.62 6.60 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
378 6.72 4.62 6.59 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
379 6.14 4.05 5.95 1.76 ACCEPTABLE
380 7.31 5.50 6.24 1.49 NOT ACCEPTABLE
381 6.72 4.78 5.49 1.94 ACCEPTABLE
382 7.29 4.06 5.95 1.50 ACCEPTABLE
383 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
384 6.14 4.06 5.95 1.79 ACCEPTABLE
385 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
386 6.33 4.18 6.16 1.62 ACCEPTABLE
387 6.72 4.70 5.85 1.63 ACCEPTABLE
388 6.73 5.77 6.87 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
389 6.34 5.24 6.35 1.58 ACCEPTABLE
390 6.72 4.69 6.61 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
391 6.72 4.69 6.61 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
392 6.33 4.28 6.17 1.60 ACCEPTABLE
393 6.71 3.83 5.75 1.73 ACCEPTABLE
394 7.11 5.24 6.35 1.39 NOT ACCEPTABLE
395 6.72 4.77 5.87 1.62 ACCEPTABLE
396 7.10 4.29 6.17 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE

34
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
397 7.10 4.18 6.16 1.45 NOT ACCEPTABLE
398 6.71 3.83 5.75 1.73 ACCEPTABLE
399 7.10 4.29 6.17 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
400 6.71 3.88 5.75 1.73 ACCEPTABLE
401 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
402 6.33 4.29 6.17 1.59 ACCEPTABLE
403 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
404 6.46 4.39 6.31 1.50 ACCEPTABLE
405 6.72 4.73 6.11 1.51 ACCEPTABLE
406 6.73 5.41 6.77 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
407 6.47 5.07 6.43 1.47 NOT ACCEPTABLE
408 6.72 4.72 6.61 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
409 6.72 4.72 6.61 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
410 6.46 4.44 6.31 1.48 NOT ACCEPTABLE
411 6.71 4.13 6.03 1.58 ACCEPTABLE
412 6.98 5.07 6.43 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
413 6.72 4.76 6.12 1.50 ACCEPTABLE
414 6.97 4.44 6.32 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
415 6.97 4.39 6.31 1.41 NOT ACCEPTABLE
416 6.71 4.13 6.03 1.58 ACCEPTABLE
417 6.97 4.44 6.32 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
418 6.71 4.16 6.03 1.56 ACCEPTABLE
419 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
420 6.46 4.44 6.31 1.48 NOT ACCEPTABLE
421 6.72 4.75 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
422 6.55 4.52 6.41 1.42 NOT ACCEPTABLE
423 6.72 4.74 6.28 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
424 6.72 5.18 6.71 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
425 6.55 4.93 6.48 1.42 NOT ACCEPTABLE
426 6.72 5.18 6.38 1.45 NOT ACCEPTABLE
427 6.73 5.65 6.83 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
428 6.56 5.41 6.60 1.44 NOT ACCEPTABLE
429 6.72 5.16 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
430 6.55 4.54 6.41 1.44 NOT ACCEPTABLE
431 6.72 5.16 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
432 6.55 4.95 6.49 1.40 NOT ACCEPTABLE
433 6.72 4.74 6.61 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
434 6.72 4.74 6.28 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
435 6.89 5.42 6.61 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
436 6.72 5.19 6.38 1.44 NOT ACCEPTABLE
437 6.89 4.96 6.49 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
438 6.89 4.54 6.42 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
439 6.71 4.35 6.22 1.47 NOT ACCEPTABLE
440 6.89 4.94 6.49 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
441 6.72 4.74 6.28 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
442 6.89 4.54 6.42 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE

35
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
443 6.89 4.96 6.49 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
444 6.72 4.75 6.28 1.43 NOT ACCEPTABLE
445 6.72 5.18 6.71 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
446 6.55 4.96 6.49 1.42 NOT ACCEPTABLE
447 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
448 6.61 5.02 6.56 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
449 6.72 5.18 6.49 1.41 NOT ACCEPTABLE
450 6.73 5.48 6.79 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
451 6.61 5.33 6.63 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
452 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
453 6.61 4.74 6.50 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
454 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
455 6.61 5.03 6.56 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
456 6.72 4.88 6.64 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
457 6.72 4.89 6.42 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
458 6.84 5.34 6.64 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
459 6.72 5.19 6.49 1.39 NOT ACCEPTABLE
460 6.83 5.03 6.57 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
461 6.83 4.75 6.51 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
462 6.72 4.61 6.37 1.40 NOT ACCEPTABLE
463 6.83 5.02 6.56 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
464 6.72 4.89 6.42 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
465 6.83 4.75 6.51 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
466 6.83 5.03 6.57 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
467 6.72 4.89 6.42 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
468 6.72 5.18 6.71 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
469 6.61 5.03 6.56 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
470 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
471 6.65 5.07 6.61 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
472 6.72 5.18 6.56 1.38 NOT ACCEPTABLE
473 6.73 5.38 6.76 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
474 6.65 5.28 6.66 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
475 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
476 6.65 4.88 6.57 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
477 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
478 6.65 5.08 6.61 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
479 6.72 4.98 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
480 6.72 4.99 6.52 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
481 6.80 5.28 6.66 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
482 6.72 5.19 6.56 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
483 6.80 5.08 6.61 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
484 6.79 4.89 6.57 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
485 6.72 4.80 6.48 1.37 NOT ACCEPTABLE
486 6.80 5.08 6.61 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
487 6.72 4.98 6.52 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
488 6.79 4.89 6.57 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE

36
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
489 6.80 5.08 6.61 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
490 6.72 4.99 6.52 1.36 NOT ACCEPTABLE
491 6.72 5.18 6.71 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
492 6.65 5.08 6.61 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
493 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
494 6.67 5.11 6.64 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
495 6.72 5.18 6.61 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
496 6.73 5.31 6.74 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
497 6.67 5.24 6.67 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
498 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
499 6.67 4.98 6.61 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
500 6.72 5.17 6.70 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
501 6.67 5.11 6.64 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
502 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
503 6.67 4.98 6.61 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
504 6.72 5.04 6.57 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
505 6.72 5.18 6.71 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
506 6.67 5.11 6.64 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
507 6.72 5.04 6.68 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
508 6.67 4.85 6.58 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
509 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
510 6.67 4.98 6.61 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
511 6.72 4.92 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
512 6.72 4.91 6.54 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
513 6.78 5.11 6.64 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
514 6.72 5.04 6.57 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
515 6.77 4.98 6.61 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
516 6.77 4.85 6.58 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
517 6.72 4.79 6.52 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
518 6.77 4.98 6.61 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
519 6.72 4.91 6.54 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
520 6.77 4.85 6.59 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
521 6.77 4.98 6.61 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
522 6.72 4.91 6.54 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
523 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
524 6.67 4.98 6.61 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
525 6.72 5.05 6.58 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
526 6.72 5.18 6.71 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
527 6.67 5.11 6.64 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
528 6.72 5.04 6.68 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
529 6.67 4.85 6.59 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
530 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
531 6.67 4.98 6.61 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
532 6.72 4.92 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
533 6.72 4.92 6.55 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
534 6.77 5.12 6.65 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE

37
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
535 6.72 5.05 6.58 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
536 6.77 4.99 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
537 6.77 4.86 6.59 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
538 6.72 4.80 6.53 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
539 6.77 4.98 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
540 6.72 4.92 6.55 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
541 6.77 4.86 6.59 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
542 6.77 4.99 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
543 6.72 4.92 6.55 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
544 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
545 6.67 4.98 6.61 1.35 NOT ACCEPTABLE
546 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
547 6.69 5.00 6.63 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
548 6.72 5.05 6.61 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
549 6.72 5.13 6.70 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
550 6.69 5.09 6.65 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
551 6.72 5.04 6.68 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
552 6.69 4.92 6.62 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
553 6.72 5.04 6.68 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
554 6.69 5.00 6.63 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
555 6.72 4.96 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
556 6.72 4.97 6.60 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
557 6.75 5.09 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
558 6.72 5.05 6.61 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
559 6.75 5.01 6.64 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
560 6.75 4.92 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
561 6.72 4.88 6.58 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
562 6.75 5.01 6.64 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
563 6.72 4.96 6.60 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
564 6.75 4.92 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
565 6.75 5.01 6.64 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
566 6.72 4.97 6.60 1.34 NOT ACCEPTABLE
567 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
568 6.69 5.00 6.63 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
569 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
570 6.70 5.02 6.65 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
571 6.72 5.05 6.64 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
572 6.72 5.10 6.69 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
573 6.70 5.08 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
574 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
575 6.70 4.96 6.63 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
576 6.72 5.04 6.68 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
577 6.70 5.02 6.65 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
578 6.72 4.99 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
579 6.72 4.99 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
580 6.74 5.08 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE

38
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
581 6.72 5.05 6.64 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
582 6.74 5.02 6.65 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
583 6.74 4.96 6.64 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
584 6.72 4.94 6.61 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
585 6.74 5.02 6.65 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
586 6.72 4.99 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
587 6.74 4.96 6.64 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
588 6.74 5.02 6.65 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
589 6.72 4.99 6.62 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
590 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
591 6.70 5.02 6.65 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
592 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
593 6.71 5.03 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
594 6.72 5.05 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
595 6.72 5.08 6.68 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
596 6.71 5.07 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
597 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
598 6.71 4.99 6.65 1.33 NOT ACCEPTABLE
599 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
600 6.71 5.03 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
601 6.72 5.01 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
602 6.72 5.01 6.64 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
603 6.74 5.07 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
604 6.72 5.05 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
605 6.73 5.03 6.66 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
606 6.73 4.99 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
607 6.72 4.97 6.63 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
608 6.73 5.03 6.66 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
609 6.72 5.01 6.64 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
610 6.73 4.99 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
611 6.73 5.03 6.66 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
612 6.72 5.01 6.64 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
613 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
614 6.71 5.03 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
615 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
616 6.71 5.03 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
617 6.72 5.05 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
618 6.72 5.07 6.68 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
619 6.71 5.06 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
620 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
621 6.71 5.01 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
622 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
623 6.71 5.03 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
624 6.72 5.02 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
625 6.72 5.02 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
626 6.73 5.06 6.67 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE

39
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
627 6.72 5.05 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
628 6.73 5.04 6.67 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
629 6.73 5.01 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
630 6.72 5.00 6.65 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
631 6.73 5.04 6.67 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
632 6.72 5.02 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
633 6.73 5.01 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
634 6.73 5.04 6.67 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
635 6.72 5.02 6.65 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
636 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
637 6.71 5.03 6.66 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
638 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
639 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
640 6.72 5.05 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
641 6.72 5.06 6.68 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
642 6.72 5.05 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
643 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
644 6.72 5.02 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
645 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
646 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
647 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
648 6.72 5.03 6.66 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
649 6.73 5.06 6.68 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
650 6.72 5.05 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
651 6.73 5.04 6.67 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
652 6.73 5.02 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
653 6.72 5.02 6.66 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
654 6.73 5.04 6.67 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
655 6.72 5.03 6.66 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
656 6.73 5.02 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
657 6.73 5.04 6.67 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
658 6.72 5.03 6.66 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
659 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
660 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
661 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
662 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
663 6.72 5.05 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
664 6.72 5.06 6.68 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE
665 6.72 5.05 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
666 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
667 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
668 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
669 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
670 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
671 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
672 6.72 5.06 6.68 1.31 NOT ACCEPTABLE

40
Center Radius
No. FS Verification
x [m] z [m] R [m]
673 6.72 5.05 6.67 1.32 NOT ACCEPTABLE
674 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
675 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
676 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
677 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
678 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
679 6.72 5.03 6.67 1.30 NOT ACCEPTABLE
680 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
681 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
682 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
683 6.72 5.04 6.67 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE
684 6.72 5.05 6.68 1.29 NOT ACCEPTABLE

41

Anda mungkin juga menyukai