WORKSHOP

PENULISAN JURNAL INTERNASIONAL :

ARTIKEL ILMIAH YANG PUBLISHABLE DAN
STRATEGI MENEMBUS JURNAL INTERNASIONAL

Oleh:
Dr. Ni Ketut Supasti Dharmawan,SH,M.Hum,LLM
Fakultas Hukum Universitas Udayana
Jakarta, Mahkaman Konstitusi, 23 Maret 2016
 OUTLINE PRESENTASI

 PENDAHULUAN
 “ARTIKEL ILMIAH PUBLISHABLE” INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL
YANG DITUJU
 STRATEGI MENEMBUS INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL
 PRAKTIK MENULIS “INTRODUCTION”
 PENUTUP
 PENDAHULUAN

 Penting memiliki Karya Ilmiah Publikasi Jurnal :

 Surat Edaran Dirjen DIKTI Nomor 20150/E/T/2011 Tentang
Kebijakan Unggah Karya Ilmiah
 Surat Edaran Dirjen DIKTI No. 152/E/T/2012 Tentang wajib publikasi
ilmiah bagi S1, S2, dan S3
 Permendiknas No. 17 Tahun 2010 Tentang Pencegahan dan
penanggulangan Plagiat di Perguruan Tinggi
 S3 wajib publikasi memiliki karya ilmiah yang dipublikasikan pada
“International Journal”
 International Journal apa yang dituju?
 Bagaimana menulis karya ilmiah  international journal
 Strategi memilih dan menembus International Journal
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL YANG DITUJU

 SCOPUS RANK
 SJR (Scimago Journal and Country Rank)
SCOPUS

http://www.fsm.rnu.tn/useruploads
/files/scopusindexed_journals.pdf
 SJR

 PENDAHULUAN
 MENGAPA PENTING MEMAHAMI
 SJR cont’d

 PENDAHULUAN
 MENGAPA PENTING MEMAHAMI
SJR cont’d
SJR cont’d
 SJR cont’d
(sumber dari bahan workshop indoneia law review)
 SJR cont’d
(sumber dari bahan workshop indoneia law review)
 SJR cont’d
(sumber dari bahan workshop indoneia law review)
 Bagaimana menembus Scopus-SJR ?

 Memilih sesuaikan dengan kemampuan, bisa dimulai dari tingkat

Indonesia, Asia, kemudian Australia, Eropa, UK, Amerika
 Pilih Journal International sesuai dengan topik hasil reset yang
dilakukan:
 Karya Ilmiah tentang Human Right Human Right Law Review, UK,
Journal of Human Right Practice, UK
 Karya Ilmiah tentang Hak Kekayaan Intelektual atau Hukum Bisnis
Journals of Intellectual Property Rights, ASEAN Journal of WTO, dll
 Karya Ilmiah Comparative Study tentang European Law
Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law
 Karya Ilmiah tentang studi-studi hukum Indonesia dalam perspektif
global, lokal dan nasional Indonesia Law Review
 Strategi menulis dan menembus
International Journal  Publishable

Pilih salah satu Journal International SJR yang paling

memungkinkan kita masuk (tingkat ASEAN) dan pilih
yang sesuai dengan topik reset atau karya ilmiah kita
Review, telaah/pelajari artikel ilmiah yang sudah di
publish di journal tersebut, kenali bahasanya dan juga
sistematika penulisan citation : foot note atau body
note,
jumlah halaman yang diminta, spasi , dan hal hal teknis
lainnya
Penting memperhatikan tahapan penulisan
Abstract
 Introduction
Main Body of the text
- Issue 1 First draft, second draft,
- Issue 2 First draft, secobd draft, etc
Conclusion
Menulis Introduction?

Pada umumnya dalam sebuah “Introduction” memuat : Why, What and

How a topic was studied (Ian Curry-Sumner Francois Kristen et al., School
of Law Utrecgt University, 2010, p.33).
 Why a topic was studied?
 What exactly was studied in relation to that subject (research
questions and sub-questions)
 How that subject was studied (methodology and structure)
Cek tulisan “Introduction” yang kita tulis apakah sudah memuat hal-hal
tersebut di atas.
 Bagaimana menulis
a first Draft- Writing Stage?

 Start writing as soon as you start reading. While you are

reading, begin to succinctly write down not only an outline of
the facts but also your thoughts or critical analysis of how
this fits into your argument. (Terry Hutchinson, 2002,
Thomson legal &Regulatory Limited, Australia, p. 161
 Editing, Rewriting and Revising the First draft
 Develop a clear research question
 Develop a clear argument and clear structure
 Ask our colleagues to review our work
 Use checklist for every stage of our writing
 CHECKLIST FOR INTRODUCTION

 Whether I already described the importance of research

(WHY we doing reaserch): reason and context
 Whether I already described research question and sub-
questions properly (WHAT : well-defined research questions)
 Whether I already described the method that I used to
answer research questions (HOW: methodology and
structure)
 Cheklist for rewriting
 (1) Content and ideas
a. Is the law right?
b. Have I included all the relevant issues?
c. Have I included all the relevant research?
d. Have I updated all the research?
e. Have I included all the necessary background information?
f. Have I eliminated those points that I found while doing my research but do not add to
the document?
 (2) Large-scale organisation
a. Do I have logical organisation?
b. Have I provided an overview so that the reader can understand how my paper progresses from
introduction to conclusion?
c. Have I put treshold issues first?
d. Have I given the answer first and then the explanation?
e. If writing persuasively, have I organised the issues in the most perssuasive order, putting the
strongest first, the second strongest last, and the weakest in the middle, unless logical organisation
precludes doing this?
f. Can any legal reader follow my logic?
g. Can the indended reader follow my logic?
h. Have I used positions of emphasis well?
 MENULIS CONCLUSION
 The conclusion should be limited to information following directly
from your research results only. The conclusion needs to contain all
the answers to the sub-questions that you have drafted in the
introduction
 CHECKLIST FOR CONCLUSION:
 Summary that related to the introduction and the main body
of the text
 Gives an answer to the research question
 Discusses the value of the finding and the answer found
 Does not contain any new information or arguments
(Ian Curry et al. 2002, p. 58)
 PENTINGNYA MENULIS SUMBER

 Justifikasi, Verifikasi, membantu untuk

menemukan lebih banyak lagi sumber yang
mendukung
 Dalam menulis artikel ilmiah meskipun sudah
dilakukan dengan cara “Paraphrasing” dan
“”Summarising” artikel atau bahan bacaan
orang lain, namun tidak mencantumkan
sumbernya dengan jelas tetap
dikategorisasikan telah melakukan plagiarism.
 CONTOH : PANDUAN PENULISAN
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL “
Sumber: journals.cambridge.org/action/displayJournal?jiid=AJL
A checklist for publishing your first journal article: tips from the
Asian Journal of International Law
A checklist for publishing your first journal Treat peer feedback constructively
article: tips from the Asian Journal of Follow revision instructions carefully
International Law Check proofs and respond to queries
Ensure your article is written in clear English promptly Ensure your article is written in
Attend suitable writing workshops clear English
Make an effort to follow the journal’s style Complete any copyright documentation
Read articles previously published in the with care
journal If you are unsuccessful try again
Ensure your article is complete Finally, be confident
Ask colleagues for feedback on your article For more advice on how to get published and more
before submission specific advice on determining the content of your article
Follow the journal’s procedures for do take a look at the following useful webpages:
http://www.ll.georgetown.edu/guides/Publishing.cfm
submission http://ssrn.com/abstract=1685422
Submit to one journal at a time http://guides.library.harvard.edu/friendly.php?s=gettingpublished&g
id=4882
Reacting to desk rejection http://lib.law.washington.edu/ref/lawrev.html
http://www.law.nyu.edu/students/studentwriting
PRAKTIK MENULIS ‘INTRODUCTION”

 Mari menulis Introduction

 Silahkan ajukan topik-topik reset Bapak Ibu.
 Gunakan Checklist setelah selesai menulis first
draft
 PENUTUP

 Memilih Internasional Jurnal sesuai dengan

topik tulisan
 Mengikuti cpanduan penulisan dari panduan
yang bersangkutan
 Selamat mencoba dan Semangat
THANK YOU