“Smart Planning
for Sustainable Environment”
Oleh:
Prof. Dr. Ir. Hilwati Hindersah, MURP
Fakultas Teknik - Unisba
11 Desember 2023
Sungai Citarum
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
POKOK - POKOK
PEMBAHASAN
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
ISU
LINGKUNGAN
❖Perubahan Iklim Dunia
❖Kehilangan Keanekaragaman Hayati
❖Dampak Pemanasan Global
❖Dampak Urbanisasi
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Perkembangan Teknologi Informasi dan Komunikasi yang sangat cepat.
“In The Age of The Smart Machine” (Zuboff, 1984); “Being Digital”
(Negroponte, 1995); “The Digital Economy” (Tapscott, 1996); “Linked”
(Barabasi, 2003);
SMART
CITY
(2000 – Now)
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
“A smart sustainable city is an innovative city
that uses information and communication
technologies (ICTs) and other means to
improve quality of life, efficiency of urban
operations and services, and
competitiveness, while ensuring that it
meets the needs of present and future
generations with respect to economic, social
Smart City Components and environmental aspects”.
Sumber: Mohanty, S.P. et.al. 2016. Everything You Wanted to Know About Smart Cities, IEEE Consumer Electronics Magazine.
Most of the cities and projects are related to the reduction of
CO2 emissions/reduce traffic and energy consumption/save Daftar “Smart Cities”
energy, stormwater management and an increase of
production efficiency. ❑ San Francisco
❑ Seattle
❑ Portland
❑ Philadelphia (2009)
❑ London
❑ Amsterdam (2009)
❑ Stockholm (1994)
✓ GIS sebagai sistem
❑ Copenhagen
pendataan dan informasi
penataan ruang ❑ Oslo
✓ Teknologi bangunan dan ❑ Helsinki
infrastruktur yang ramah ❑ Barcelona
lingkungan ❑ Seoul
❑ Singapore
Konferensi Nasional ❑ Putrajaya, Malaysia (1997)
“SMART GREEN CITY PLANNING 2010”
(Kementerian PU) #SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
INFRASTRUKTUR HIJAU:
Kunci Keberlanjutan
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Benefits of Green Infrastructure (according to various ecosystem services aspects)
Area Benefits
Biodiversity/species protection Habitat for species
Permeability for migrating species
Connecting habitats
Climate change adaption Mitigating urban heat island effect with evapotranspiration, shading and keeping free
corridors for cold air movement
Strengthening ecosystems’ resilience to climate change
Storing flood water and ameliorating surface water run-off to reduce the risk of flooding
Climate change mitigation Carbon sequestration
Encouraging sustainable travel
Reducing energy use for heating and cooling buildings
Providing space for renewable anergy like hydroelectric power, biomass and wind power
Water management Sustainable drainage systems – attenuating surface water run-off
Groundwater infiltration
Removal of pollutants from water
Food production and security Direct food on angricultural land, gardens and allotments
Soil development and nutrient cycle
Preventing soil erosion
Recreation, well-being and health Recreation
Sense of space and nature
Clean air
Land values Positive impact on land and property
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
GI in Local Scale: [2]
Green Streets and alleys A green street is defined as a streetscape
designed to:
integrate a system of stormwater management
within its right of way,
reduce the amount of runoff into storm sewers,
make the best use of the street tree canopy for
stormwater interception as well as
temperature mitigation and air quality
improvement’ (Odefey et al., 2012: 2).
Chicago’s Green Alley Handbook defines a
green alley as ‘an alley designed and
constructed incorporating best management
practices (BMP) of environmentally sustainable
design’ (Chicago Department of Transportation,
2010: 41).
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
GI in Local Scale: [3]
Urban forests/Urban Parks
Auckland City Council (2008) defined urban
forests as all vegetation, including habitats
and ecosystems, on the Auckland isthmus.
This includes vegetation in private properties,
parks, reserves and street trees.
Urban forests serve multiple functions
including pollution amelioration,
temperature regulation, carbon
sequestration and storage, as well as
providing aesthetic appeal.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
GI in Local Scale: [4]
Rain Gardens and Vegetated (Bio) Swales
A rain garden is ‘a man-made depression in the ground that is used as a landscape
tool to improve water quality’ (Virginia Department of Forestry, 2012).
Bioswales adalah saluran bervegetasi yang dapat mengalirkan air hujan sembari
berfungsi sebagai area infiltrasi. Dua fungsi sekaligus dalam satu macam infrastruktur
dapat menjadi alternatif penanggulangan genangan di kawasan terbangun. Dapat
pula diterapkan di sepanjang jalan hingga ke tempat parkir umum, sehingga ketika
hujan limpasan air dapat mengalir atau terinfiltrasi dan mengurangi beban saluran.
An engineered media is used to achieve primary functions that include reducing runoff
pollution, peak flows and total volumes.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
GI in Local Scale: [5]
Wet Ponds
According to EPA (2012c), ‘wet ponds (also known as stormwater ponds,
wet retention ponds, wet extended detention ponds) are constructed
basins that have a permanent pool of water throughout the year (or at
least throughout the wet season)’.
Ponds should almost always be the last choice due to their limited
protection function (EPA, 2012a).
Ponds provide limited ecosystem services.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
GI in Regional Scale: [1]
Wetlands, Rivers
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
GI in Regional Scale: [2]
Nature Reserves
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
GI in Regional Scale: [3]
Conservation Corridors
Conservation corridors have been useful tools for conserving
biodiversity and preventing the fragmentation of species due to
human encroachment on natural habitat.
Fragmentation is defined as ‘breaking up of large patches of native
vegetation into smaller and increasingly isolated patches’.
As landscapes become fragmented, habitats are lost or shrink,
edges increase (which favours species inhabiting edges such as
invasive colonisation and pest species, whilst putting stress on
species that require large and relatively intact interior areas),
biodiversity is isolated into patches and natural regimes are
disturbed.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
GI in Regional Scale: [4] Green Transport
Issues with the transport sector as:
Transport is responsible for the consumption of more than half of global liquid fossil fuels;
The combustion of fuels is responsible for nearly a quarter (23%) of the world’s energy related
carbon dioxide emissions;
More than 80% of outdoor air pollution in developing cities can be attributed to transport;
Transport is responsible for more than 1.27 million traffic accidents in developing countries; and
Traffic congestion is responsible for time loss and productivity loss as people wait on roads.
Research suggests many ways to ameliorate pollution including reducing the source of
pollutants (i.e. vehicles) and applying GI procedures such as green streets, street trees.
Calls for reducing the need to travel, shifting to more environmentally efficient modes of
travel and improving fuels and vehicles for higher efficiency.
Green Infrastructure can contribute to the greening of transportation via provision of
green streets that promote greener modes of travel (such as walking and bicycling) and
‘green alleys’, parking and paving for more vibrant access routes and parking spaces
that provide for multiple functions.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
IMPLEMENTASI:
Integrasi IH dalam Smart Planning
JEJARING
INFRASTRUKTUR HIJAU What Does Green Infrastructure
Look Like? Green infrastructure
encompasses a wide variety of
natural and restored native
ecosystems and landscape
features that make up a system of
“hubs” and “links.”
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
HUBS anchor green infrastructure networks and provide an origin
or destination for wildlife and ecological processes moving to or
through it.
Sungai Citarum
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
EKOSISTEM HULU EKOSISTEM HILIR
DAS CITARUM DAS CITARUM
Mangrove merupakan satu jenis
tumbuhan yang dapat ditemui
sepanjang pinggiran sungai,
Pegunungan
muara sungai dan pantai.
mempunyai fungsi
penting sebagai
kawasan resapan
air. Selain itu
pegunungan
merupakan habitat
flora dan fauna
yang mendukung
keberlangsungan
hidup seluruh
makhluk
Ada kekayaan dan keanekaragaman hayati, beranekaragamnya
ikan serta hewan liar seperti Little Egret (Egretta garzetta)
maupun Biawak (Monitor lizard), membentuk ekosistem pesisir
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23 yang spesifik.
The Florida Greenways Commission
A New Vision of the Future
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Perencanaan dan Perancangan
Infrastruktur Hijau: Kasus2
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Planning Process [2]:
Steps to develop GI System
– 3 – Envision the Future – A draft report included a proposed timetable, cost
– Several meetings were held to discuss principles that estimate and funding options for completing the
would act as a framework for building the green recommendations. The committee and the planning
infrastructure system that made the region a commission jointly presented the final report at a
desirable place to live and that were vital to its long-
public meeting before the Board of Supervisors, who
term stability and success.
adopted the green infrastructure plan and agreed to
– 4 – Find the Hubs and Links budget funds each year for implementing the plan’s
– The committee identified the elements or hubs recommendations.
within each landscape type that contributed to the
rich natural fabric of the community and determined – 6 – Build the System
ways to interconnect the various hubs.
– Formed an environmental advisory council, as
– 5 – Create the Plan permitted by law, from the study committee’s
– The hubs and links were added to the collection of members, to work with the board of supervisors on
drawings. The committee create a coherent action implementing the recommendations in the action plan.
plan and map of the green infrastructure system.
– Over the next five years, the region was able to achieve
a number of its goals using a variety of land planning
techniques and working with a wide range of partners:
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
DEFINISI DAN JENIS GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE (GI)
US EPA mendefinisikan green infrastructure sebagai sistem dan praktik yang menggunakan atau meniru proses alami untuk infiltrasi,
evapotranspirasi (proses kembalinya air ke atmosfer baik melalui penguapan maupun tanaman), atau memanfaatkan kembali air hujan
limpasan (Rouse & Ignacio, 2013; Firehock, 2016).
6 9 12
JENIS JENIS GREEN 3
INFRASTRUCTURE
1
Vegetated filter strip Kolam Resapan (Infiltration Basin) Infiltration Trench (Parit Resapan) Green roof
4 7 10 13
Bioretention
5 8 11
Wet Pond (Kolam Retensi)
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
KASUS STUDI - GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE (GI)
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Barcelona Green
Infrastructure and
Biodiversity Plan 2020 • The plan presents a vision that Green Infrastructure is
Envisages a city in which nature permeates an essential element of a healthy and productive
urban life and urban environment.
Green Infrastructure is fully integrated into • Green corridors - strips of urban land covered in
City planning and management. vegetation - help to connect green areas and enhance
biodiversity within the city while also linking urban
areas with the surrounding environment such as the
coastline and the Collserola Natural Park.
• Filling built up spaces such as courtyards, roofs and
walls with greenery – a process known as
naturalisation - helps to absorb pollutants from the
air, reduce noise, balance the watercycle, reduce
energy consumption and hence CO2 emissions, and
foster biodiversity.
• Create a more appealing environment for people to
live in, while at the same time improving the health of
urban citizens.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Barcelona’s Trees –
Natural air purifiers
• Barcelona is one of the most densely populated cities in Europe,
with 1.62 million inhabitants living in an area of just 101.21 km².
• Currently there are around 161.423 trees of 150 different species
lining the streets of Barcelona.
• The city’s trees (including street trees, trees in parks, shrubs and
natural areas) play an important role in filtering harmful substances
from the air.
• They offset around 19,000 net tonnes of CO2 from the atmosphere,
and eliminated more than 305 tonnes of air pollutants.
• By reducing the amount of pollutants in the air, these urban trees
are providing an invaluable ecosystem service.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Neighbourhood
• Tarwewijk has a
waterfront and close
to largest city park.
• GI mainly consists of
gardens and a few
street trees and
several pocket parks.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Tipe2 GI: Skala Home,
Neighbourhood, City
Apa manfaat yang diberikan oleh
masing2 tipe GI ini ?
Tipe GI mana saja yang dapat
memitigasi banjir dan urban heat ?
Apa nama tumbuh2 an yang cocok
ditanam untuk masing2 tipe GI ?
Tipe GI mana saja yang
mempunyai multi fungsi ?
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
GI design to protect and improve
native biodiversity in Rio de Janeiro
The city of Rio de Janeiro now covers what was formerly coastal Atlantic
rainforest.
Native biodiversity has been lost from most of the metropolitan area due to
changes in land use, introduction of exotic species, and influence of foreign
designs in public and private parks and gardens, only scarce areas of native
ecosystems remain.
The emergence of green infrastructure planning and design has helped improve
urban sustainability, increase biodiversity, and provide measurable abiotic,
biotic, and cultural ecosystem services, such as water protection, heat-island
effect mitigation, flood and landslide prevention, aquifer recharge, air-quality
improvement, noise reduction, health related disease prevention, and an
increase in healthy urban recreation.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Green Guaratiba
Infrastructure Plan (1:10,000).
Guaratiba is named after the scarlet ibis (Eudocimus ruber, or Guarra in the
indigenous Tupi language), a bright-scarlet bird with long legs that lives in
mangroves.
It has specific goals at the watershed scale. The plan propose to:
(a) Protect existing mangrove, sandbanks, and coastal rain forest remnants, the
framework of the GI, with a buffer zone and a greenway along the main river,
connecting northern and southern fragments to allow biodiversity migration;
(b) Conserve existing productive landscapes with an ornamental plant center and
food production; remove invasive exotic species from legally protected
ecosystems
(c) Orient ecological and mixed-use urbanization in consonance with natural
processes. Avoid urbanization in conservation-unit buffer zones and on slopes
vulnerable to landslides and lowlands susceptible to floods
(d) Design green and multiple-use streets.
The proposal also aims to increase native biodiversity, protect vulnerable areas
from floods and landslides, reduce stormwater runoff and water bodies, reduce
pollution, maintain and protect clean transportation (pedestrian and bicycles),
and protect valued local landscape attributes.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Local-scale Proposition for greenway
along the Portinho River
At the local scale, low-impact development (LID) elements seek
to maintain and/or reestablish abiotic and biotic processes and
functions and prioritize clean transportation (pedestrians and
bicycles).
At the site scale, human use along the river includes bike lanes,
pedestrian paths, rest areas, and recreational sites.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Local-scale proposition
for the multifunctional street in
the core of the northern commercial road
An opportunity to design multifunctional green streets before the area is
developed. It will involve intensive tree planting and give the right of way
to pedestrians and cyclists.
At a local scale, green streets are designed with rain gardens to help
prevent floods, promote rainwater retention and infiltration, and
introduce native species (e.g., Tibouchina trichopoda, an endangered
species, and Acrostichum aureum).
Processing of
mobility
information
A combination of route
characteristics and
green infrastructure
produces a smart
routing system
Integrasi Infrastruktur Hijau Dalam
SMART PLANNING
Dengan pendekatan Adaptive Planning
(Abdulateef & Al-Alwan, 2022; Janiszek &
Krzysztofik, 2023).
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
Linkage is a Key to Collaboration
◦ The desired outcome for all green infrastructure initiatives is the creation of a green space network that
functions as an ecological whole, not as a random assemblage of separate, unrelated parts.
◦ The strategic connection of different system components — parks, preserves, riparian areas, wetlands,
and other green spaces — is critical to maintaining vital ecological processes and services (e.g., carrying
and filtering stormwater runoff, storing and cleaning fresh water, cleaning urban air) and to maintaining
the health and biodiversity of wildlife populations.
◦ In addition, green infrastructure requires linkages to be made among different agencies,
nongovernmental organizations, and the private sector.
◦ Linking green infrastructure efforts to statewide, regional and local smart growth programs provides a
useful and satisfying framework for development.
◦ Integrating green infrastructure with programs that focus on growth and development will aid
state/province and community efforts to protect vital agricultural and other working lands.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
PERAN
PERENCANA
Konsep IH
menawarkan ruang
hunian dengan lebih
01 Perencana harus
memegang teguh
03
seimbang sekaligus tanggung jawab sebagai
meningkatkan sebagai khalifah fil ard
kesejahteraan tanpa yang merupakan
harus merusak kewajiban politiknya
lingkungan. yang sakral
02 04
Adalah tugas
perencana penataan
ruang untuk Just being
memperjuangkan
tegaknya aspek SMART in
keseimbangan dalam
rancangan ruang dan The Digital
tata nilai yang tidak
merusak alam. Era
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
References
• Abdulateef, M.F. & Al-Awan, H.A.S. 2022. Planning Steps of Urban Green Infrastructure in Existing Cities.
Administratio Locorum, 21(4), 465 – 478.
• Barabasi, Albert-Laszlo. 2003. Linked. New York, USA: A Plume Book.
• Benedict, M.A., McMahon, E.T. 2000. Green Infrastructure: Smart Conservation for the 21st Century. Sprawl Watch
Clearinghouse Monograph Series.
• Boyle, Carol. Et al. 2014. Greening Cities – A Review of Green Infrastructure. Transforming Cities: Innovations for
Sustainable Futures: University of Auckland, NZ.
• Carr, M.H. & Zwick, P.D. 2007. Smart Land-Use Analysis: The LUCIS Model. California, USA: ESRI Press
• Derkzen M L, van Teeffelen A J A and Verburg P H. 2017. Green infrastructure for urban climate adaptation: How
do residents’ views on climate impacts and green infrastructure shape adaptation preferences? Landsc. Urban
Plan. 157, 106–30
• Herzog, C. P. 2016. A multifunctional green infrastructure design to protect and improve native biodiversity in Rio
de Janeiro Landsc. Ecol. Eng. 12, 141–50
• Janiszek, Monika & Krzysztofik. 2023. Green Infrastructure as an Effective Tool for Urban Adaptation – Solutions
from a Big City in a Postindustrial Region. Sustainability, 15, 1 – 19.
• Korkou, M. Tarigan, A.K.M. Hanslin, H.M. 2023. The Multifunctionality concept in Urban Green Infrastructure
Planning: A Systematic Literature Review. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, 85, 1 – 9.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
References
• Meerow, S. & Newell, J.P. 2016. Spatial Planning for Multifunctional Green Infrastructure: Growing Resilience in
Detroit. Landscape and Urban Planning, 159, 62 – 75.
• Moura, F & Silva, J.dA. 2019. Smart Cities: Definitions, Evolution of the Concept and Examples of Initiatives.
• Mohanty, S.P. et.al. 2016. Everything You Wanted to Know About Smart Cities, IEEE Consumer Electronics
Magazine.
• Muvuna, J. et al. 2020. Information Integration in Smart City System – A Case Study on Air Pollution Removal by
Green Infrastructure through a Vehicle Smart Routing System. Sustainability, 20202, 5099. 1 – 14.
• Negroponte, N. 1995. Being Digital. New York, USA: Alferd A. Knopf, Inc.
• Tapscott, D. 1996. The Digital Economy. New York, USA: McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
• The North Carolina Forest Service. 2013. A Quick Guide to Community Planning for Green Infrastructure.
• US EPA. 2010. Green Infrastructure Case Study: In United States Environmental Protection Agency
• URban Biodiversity and Ecosystems Services (the URBES) Project. 2014. http://www.urbesproject.org
• Widyapura, P. K. 2019. Pengembangan Infrastruktur Hijau Di Berbagai Negara, Menyongsong Pembangunan
Berkelanjutan Berbasis Lingkungan.
• Williamson, K. S. 2003. Growing with Green Infrastructure. Heritage Conservancy.
• Zuboff, S. 1984. In The Age of The Smart Machine. US: BasicBooks.
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23
HATUR NUHUN
#SmartPlanningfor GI_HH_Desember 23