Kenyataannya :
Staff tidak punya petunjuk
pasti berapa waktu yang
dibutuhkan karena tidak
tahu pekerjaan yang
dilakukan
SOLUSI
Staf perlu mem-breakdown pekerjaannya ke dalam aktifitas sehingga
diperoleh estimasi waktu dan durasi proyek yang jelas
• PROJECT
– Upaya temporer yang dilakukan untuk menciptakan /
membangun sebuah produk, service atau hasil yang
unik (produk yang khas). Ciri sebuah proyek adalah
kegiatan yang memiliki tahap mulai (initiation) dan
tahap akhir (closing).
Urutan
Enjiniring Deliverables
Kegiatan
• Apa saja pekerjaan yang akan dilakukan
(Urutan Kegiatan)
• Resource (sumber daya, terdiri dari
manusia dan peralatan) yang dibutuhkan
untuk bekerja
• Estimasi tiap elemen pekerjaan
• Siapa saja tim proyek yang terlibat
• Biaya yang dibutuhkan
• Memudahkan pelacakan terhadap kegiatan yang
dilaksanakan.
• Menjadi common language (bahasa umum) yang mudah
dimengerti oleh pihak lain yang memahami WBS.
• Masing-masing aktivitas bisa disusun secara paralel oleh
orang / tim yang berbeda.
• Mengurangi kompleksitas pekerjaan.
• Perencanaan manajemen resiko (Risk Management
Planning)
• Dapat dipergunakan sebagai tool Estimasi Biaya (Cost
Estimating) dan anggaran (Cost Budgeting) .
• Identifikasi aktivitas (Activity Definition)
• Fasilitas penjadwalan dan pengendalian pada proyek.
• Media komunikasi antar personal
proyek
• Menjaga konsistensi dalam
pengendalian dan pelaporan proyek
• Cara efektif untuk melengkapi tugas
manajemen
• Mengalokasikan beban kerja tiap SDM
• Melakukan estimasi biaya proyek
• Project : Mempunyai durasi dan terdiri dari fungsi, aktifitas
dan tugas (Task)
• Aktifitas : Unit kerja dengan durasi yang pasti atau
representasi deliverable utama
• Tugas : Unit terkecil dari work subject yang tidak bisa di
rinci lebih lanjut.
• Fungsi : Set aktifitas yang memperpanjang durasi proyek
WBS Structure and Project Control Level ILLUSTRATIVE
A B C D H J S X Y
10
WBS Structure and Project Control Level ILLUSTRATIVE
3 4 13 14 15 2 6 2 3 4
1Water Treatment System comprises of Desalination Plant, Demineralization Plant, Reverse Osmosis Plant, and Chlorination Plant
2ESP stands form Electro-Static Precipitator,
11
WBS Structure and Project Control Level
Coal-Fired Steam Power Plant – WBS Breakdown Under Construction
Main Construction
LV. 2 PRK Other Packages
Package
Engineerin Constructio
LV. 3 Work Phase Procurement
g n
Instrument
LV. 5 Discipline Civil Mechanical Electrical Mechanical Electrical
& Control
LV. 6 System
1 WBS Element is not shown on the illustration, detailed list of WBS is available in the following slides
2 Civil
Works required for Power Area System or Equipment is considered to be part of Common Area/Balance Of Plant, due to the following consideration; possibility that power
plant may have one or more Power Area Area and Civil Works required for Power Area may be performed by (or included in the scope worked of) Civil Works contractor
Construction
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
A. Access Road and Road
Works
B. Preparation Works
C. Temporary Facilities
D. General Services
Facilities
E. Administration Building
Construction
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
L. Civil Works for Pre- 5. Pre-treatment Plant
treatment Plant System
System
M. Civil Works for 6. Desalination Plant
Desalination Plant System
System
N. Civil Works for 7. Demineralization
Demineralization Plant System
Plant System
O. Civil Works for 8. Chlorination Plant
Chlorination Plant System
System
P. Civil Works for 9. Chemical Feed/
Chemical Feed/ Injection Plant
Injection Plant System
System
Q. Civil Works for 10. Steam Generator
Steam Generator Feed-water System
Feed-water System
R. Civil Works for 11. Waste Water
Waste Water Treatment System
Treatment System
S. Civil Works for Coal 12. CoalSupply Handling
Supply Handling System
System
T. Civil Works for De- 13. De-dusting Vacuum
dusting Vacuum System of Plant
Common Area/Balance Power Area WBS that No corresponding activities
System WBS that requires Construction requires Construction are involved for this particular
activities activities WBS 14
WBS Structure and Project Control Level
Coal-Fired Steam Power Plant – WBS Breakdown Under Construction (3/8)
Construction
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
U. Civil Works for Service 14. Service & Control Air
& Control Air System System
Construction
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
X. Civil Works for Exhaust 23. Exhaust System
System
Y. Civil Works for 24. Steam Turbine & 1. Power Generator,
Power House for Auxiliaries System Excitation &
Steam Turbine Auxiliaries System
Generator System
25. Sampling Rack 2. Backup Power
System System
Z. Civil Works for 3. Power Transformer
Power Transformer & Auxiliaries
& Auxiliaries System
System
AA.Civil Works for 4. Switchyard
Switchyard Equipment &
Equipment & Accessories System
Accessories System 26. Steam Condensing
BB. Civil Works for Steam System
Condensing System
27. Deaerator & Feed-
CC. Civil Works for water Heater
Deaerator & Feed- System
water Heater System
DD. Civil Works for 28. Closed Cooling &
Closed Cooling & Cooling Tower
Cooling Tower System
System
EE. Civil Works for Open 29. Open Cooling
Cooling System System
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area WBS that No corresponding activities
WBS that requires Construction requires Construction are involved for this particular
activities activities WBS 16
WBS Structure and Project Control Level
Coal-Fired Steam Power Plant – WBS Breakdown Under Construction (5/8)
Construction
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
FF. Control & 1. Control & Monitoring
Monitoring Building System
GG.Civil Works for 30. Waste Handling
Waste Handling System
System
HH. Civil Works for Non- 31. Non-Fuel Gas
Fuel Gas Producing Producing Plant
Plant System System
II. Civil Works for 32. Liquid Fuel Handling
Liquid Fuel Handling System
System
JJ. Civil Works for 5. Black-Start
Black-Start Generator System
Generator System
KK. Laboratory,
Workshop &
Warehouse Facilities
LL. Civil Works for
Outdoor Piping
System
33. Crane, Hoist &
Conveying System
Construction
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
35. Elevator System
6. Lighting System
7. Telecommunication
System
8. Auxiliary Power
System
9. Distribution
Transformer &
Auxiliaries System
Construction
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
2. Security &
Surveillance System
3. Continuous
Emission
Monitoring System
4. Communication &
SCADA System
5. Measuring,
Metering &
Recording System
6. Instrumentation,
Control, Protection
Equipment & Cable
System
7. Emergency Plant
Protection System
MM.Landscaping
Construction
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Commissioning
1. Commissioning Works (incl. System-Level Working Integration) 1. Commissioning Works (incl. Load Test, Reliability Run,
2. Knowledge Transfers & Training Performance Test)
3. Completion Documents (incl. Project Completion Report, As-Built Drawings, and Design 2. Certification (incl. Statutory Compliance Test)
Operations & Maintenance Manuals) 3. First Inspection
Main Construction
LV. 2 PRK Other Packages
Package
Instrument
LV. 5 Discipline Civil Mechanical Electrical Mechanical Electrical
& Control
LV. 6 System
1 WBS Element is not shown on the illustration, detailed list of WBS is available in the following slides
2 Civil
Works required for Power Area System or Equipment is considered to be part of Common Area/Balance Of Plant, due to the following consideration; possibility that power
plant may have one or more Power Area Area and Civil Works required for Power Area may be performed by (or included in the scope worked of) Civil Works contractor
Procurement
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil1 Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
A. Access Road and Road 1. Water Intake System 1. Switchyard 1. Control & 1. Boiler-Stoker & 1. Power Generator,
Works 2. Raw Water System Equipment & Monitoring System Auxiliaries System Excitation &
B. Preparation Works 3. Circulating Water Accessories System 2. Security & Surveillance 2. Electrostatic Auxiliaries System
C. Jetty & Breakwater System 2. Black-Start System Precipitator (ESP) & 2. Backup Power
System 4. Potable Water Generator System 3. Continuous Auxiliaries System System
D. Piling Works System 3. Lighting System Emission 3. Boiler-CFB & 3. Power Transformer
5. Pre-treatment Plant 4. Telecommunication Monitoring System Auxiliaries System & Auxiliaries System
System System 4. Communication & 4. ESP & Cyclone
6. Desalination Plant 5. Auxiliary Power SCADA System Separator
System System 5. Measuring, Metering Auxiliaries System
7. Demineralization 6. Distribution & Recording 5. Boiler-PC &
Plant System Transformer & System Auxiliaries System
8. Chlorination Plant Auxiliaries System 6. Instrumentation, 6. ESP & Flue Gas
System 7. Power Cable Control, Protection Desulphurization
9. Chemical Feed/ System Equipment & Cable Auxiliaries System
Injection Plant 8. Cable Shaft & Trays System 7. Boiler Fan System
System System 7. Emergency Plant 8. Exhaust System
10. Steam Generation 9. Earthing & Protection System 9. Steam Turbine &
Feed-water System Lightning System 8. Mandatory Spare Auxiliaries System
11. Waste Water 10. Cathodic Protection Parts & Special 10. Sampling Rack
Treatment System System Tools System for System
12. Coal Supply 11. Mandatory Spare Instrumentation & 11. Steam Condensing
Handling System Parts & Special Control System
13. De-dusting Vacuum Tools System for 9. Consumables for 12. Deaerator & Feed-
System Electrical Operation for water Heater
14. Service & Control 12. Consumables for Instrumentation & System
Air System Operation for Control
15. Limestone
1 Procurement for material related & Sand Electrical
to the Civil Works (i.e. concrete, steel, and
Handing System
consumable) is considered as part of the Civil Works, hence will not be listed out in Common Area/Balance of Plant WBS that requires Procurement
the procurement list. activities
Power Area WBS that requires Procurement activities 22
WBS Structure and Project Control Level
Coal-Fired Steam Power Plant – WBS Breakdown Under Procurement (2/2)
Procurement
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil1 Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
16. Closed Cooling &
Cooling Tower
System
17. Open Cooling
System
18. Waste Handling
System
19. Non-Fuel Gas
Producing Plant
System
20. Liquid Fuel
Handling System
21. Crane, Hoists,
Conveying System
22. Fire Fighting
System
23. Elevator System
24. HVAC System
25. Sampling &
Laboratory
Equipment System
26. Mandatory Spare
Parts & Special
Tools System for
Mechanical
1 Procurement for material related to the Civil Works (i.e. concrete, steel, and
consumable) is considered as part of the Civil Works, hence will not be listed out in Balance of Plant/Common WBS that requires Procurement
the procurement list. activities
No corresponding activities are involved for this particular 23
WBS
WBS Structure and Project Control Level
Coal-Fired Steam Power Plant – WBS Breakdown Under Procurement (2/2)
Procurement
Common Area/Balance of Plant Power Area
Civil1 Mechanical Electrical I&C Mechanical Electrical
27. Mobile Equipment
System
28. Consumables for
Operation for
Mechanical
1 Procurement for material related to the Civil Works (i.e. concrete, steel, and
consumable) is considered as part of the Civil Works, hence will not be listed out in Balance of Plant/Common WBS that requires Procurement
the procurement list. activities
No corresponding activities are involved for this particular 24
WBS
WBS Structure and Project Control Level ILLUSTRATIVE
Main Construction
LV. 2 Other Packages
PRK Package
Instrument
LV. 5 Discipline General Electrical Mechanical Civil
& Control
LV. 6 System
1DetailedEngineering Design will consist of engineering activities for all disciplines (Civil, Mechanical, Electrical, Instrumentation & Control, and General)
2Procedure and Manual will consist of engineering activities for all disciplines (Civil, Mechanical, Electrical, Instrumentation & Control, and General)
3Recheck Survey & Investigation will consist of engineering activities for Civil & General disciplines
The following table illustrate the milestone for Coal-Fired Steam Power Plant based
Milestone Milestone
Pre-CED CFSPP Post-CED CFSPP
1. Feasibility Study Completed 1. Site Preparation Finished 17. First Steam Admission
3. Location Permit(s) Acquired (Izin 4. First (Column) Steel Structure Erection 20. First Synchronization
Lokasi/Penetapan Lokasi Selesai)
5. Boiler Installation Completed 21. Load Test Finished
4. Funding Source Acquired (Kepastian
Pendanaan Didapatkan) 6. Steam Turbine Installation Completed 22. Load Rejection Test Finished
5. Forestry Permit(s) Acquired (Izin 7. Power Evacuation Facility Construction Completed (Fasilitas 23. Reliability Run Finished
Kawasan Hutan Selesai) Evakuasi Daya Selesai)
24. Performance Test Finished
6. Land Acquisition Completed 8. First Backfeeding
(Pembebasan Lahan Selesai) 25. Operational Readiness Certificate Issued (Sertifikat Laik
9. Hydrostatic Test Finished Operasi (SLO) Diterbitkan)
7. Tender Document Finished
10. Chemical Cleaning Finished 26. Commercial Operation Date (COD)
8. Tender Winner Announcement
11. Coal Bedding Completed 27. Taking Over Certificate (TOC) Issued
9. Contract Signed
12. First Coal Unloading 28. First Inspection (FI) Finished
10.Contract Effective Date (CED)
13. Refractory Dry-Out Completed 29. Final Acceptance Certificate (FAC) Issued
28
Illustration of Hydro Power Plant Layout based on WBS
Mapping ILLUSTRATION
C
Areas in Hydro-Power Plant:
C Common
II Waterways Area
II
III
29
Project Critical Milestone Discussion ILLUSTRATION
The following table illustrate the milestone for storage and pump storage hydro power plant :
Milestone Pra-CED Milestone Pasca-CED
PLTA Reservoir & Pump Storage PLTA Reservoir & Pump Storage
1. FS Selesai 1. Commencement Date 14. Main Control Room Full Operation
(Dimulainya Konstruksi)
2. Izin Prinsip Selesai 15. Fasilitas Evakuasi Daya Selesai
2. Diversion System Selesai (Cofferdam/ (Including Switchyard and T/L or D/L0
3. Izin Penetapan Lokasi Selesai
Tunnel)
16. First Backfeeding
4. Kepastian Pendanaan Didapatkan
3. Struktur Bendungan Diselesaikan
17. First Synchronization
5. Dokumen Lingkungan (AMDAL, UKL/UPL) Selesai
4. Stoplog & Gate Selesai
18. Load Test Selesai
6. Izin SIPPA
5. Waterway Selesai (Termasuk
19. Load Rejection Test Selesai
7. Izin Konstruksi terkait PLTA* Headrace & Surge Tank)
20. Reliability Run Selesai
8. Izin Kawasan Hutan Selesai 6. Penstock Selesai
21. Performance Test Selesai
9. Pembebasan Lahan Selesai 7. Tailrace Selesai
22. Sertifikat Laik Operasi (SLO)
10.Dokumen Lelang Selesai 8. Power Cavern Selesai
Diterbitkan
11.Pengumuman Lelang 9. Crane for Power Installation
23. O&M Training Selesai
12.Pelelangan Selesai Terpasang
24. Commercial Operation Date (COD)
13.Kontrak Konstruksi Ditandatangani 10. Power Generator & Turbine Selesai
25. Taking Over Certificate (TOC)
14.Effective Contract 11. Penutupan Diversion System Selesai
26. First Year Inspection (FYI) Selesai
15.Access Road Selesai 12. Inflow Monitoring System Selesai
27. Final Acceptance Certificate (FAC)
16.Infrastruktur Pendukung Selesai (Pembangunan 13. Penggenangan Selesai (Upper Dam
Diterbitkan
Distribusi 20 kV, Base Camp) dan/atau Lower Dam)
Notes: *termasuk izin konstruksi bendungan, izin konstruksi pada SDA PLTA, dan izin ruang di dalam bumi
30
Project Critical Milestone Discussion ILLUSTRATION
The following table illustrate the milestone for run-of-river hydro power plant :
Milestone Pra-CED Milestone Pasca-CED
PLTA Run-of-River PLTA Run-of-River
1. FS Selesai 1. Commencement Date 14. First Synchronization
(Dimulainya Konstruksi)
2. Izin Prinsip Selesai 15. Load Test Selesai
2. Diversion System Diselesaikan
3. Izin Penetapan Lokasi Selesai 16. Load Rejection Test Selesai
(Cofferdam/ Tunnel)
4. Kepastian Pendanaan Didapatkan 17. Reliability Run Selesai
3. Bendung (Weir) Diselesaikan
5. Dokumen Lingkungan (AMDAL, UKL/UPL) Selesai 18. Performance Test Selesai
4. Stoplog & Gate Diselesaikan
6. Izin SIPPA 19. Sertifikat Laik Operasi (SLO)
5. Intake Waterflow Diselesaikan
Diterbitkan
7. Izin Konstruksi terkait PLTA* (Headrace & Surge Tank)
20. O&M Training Selesai
8. Izin Kawasan Hutan Selesai 6. Penstock Diselesaikan
21. Commercial Operation Date (COD)
9. Pembebasan Lahan Selesai 7. Outlet Waterflow Diselesaikan (e.g.,
Tailrace) 22. Taking Over Certificate (TOC)
10.Dokumen Lelang Selesai
8. Power Generator & Turbine 23. First Year Inspection (FYI) Selesai
11.Pengumuman Lelang
Diselesaikan 24. Final Acceptance Certificate (FAC)
12.Pelelangan Selesai
9. Penutupan Diversion System Selesai Diterbitkan
13.Kontrak Konstruksi Ditandatangani
10. Inflow Monitoring System Selesai
14.Effective Contract
11. Main Control Room Full Operation
15.Access Road Selesai
12. Fasilitas Evakuasi Daya Selesai
16.Infrastruktur Pendukung Selesai (Pembangunan (Including Switchyard and T/L or D/L0
Distribusi 20 kV, Base Camp)
13. First Backfeeding
Notes: *termasuk izin konstruksi bendungan, izin konstruksi pada SDA PLTA, dan izin ruang di dalam bumi
31
Illustration of Power Plant based on WBS Mapping
Geothermal Power Plant Downstream – Layout Illustration on WBS Mapping1
Based on Geothermal Fluid Cycle - Flow Diagram for Back-Pressure (No Condenser) Type
Mechanical WBS for Geothermal Power Plant (GPP)
1. Geothermal Fluid Piping Auxiliaries System
System 7. Exhaust System
Generator 2. Steam Separator System 8. Geothermal Injection
3 Steam Steam 3. Steam Piping System System
1
Turbine 4. Demister System 9. Waste Handling System
6 5. Scrubber System 10. Liquid Fuel Handling
7 6. Steam Turbine & System
2 Separator
2Ø Fluid To Rock Muffler
Electrical WBS for GPP
1. Power Generator, 4. Switchyard Equipment &
Excitation & Aux. System Accessories System
2. Backup Power System 5. Black-Start Generator
1 Brine
3. Power Transformer & System
Aux. System 6. Auxiliary Power System
8
Mechanical System not Electrical System not I&C System not shown
shown shown
4 5 9 10 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4
The following table illustrate the milestone for Combined Cycle Power Plant
Milestone Milestone
Pre-CED PLTGU Post-CED PLTGU
1. Feasibility Study Completed 1. Site Preparation Finished 16.First Steam Admission
3. Location Permit(s) Acquired (Izin 4. First (Column) Steel Structure Erection 19.First Synchronization for Gas Turbine Unit
Lokasi/Penetapan Lokasi Selesai)
5. Gas Turbine Installation Completed 20.First Synchronization for Steam Turbine Unit
4. Funding Source Acquired (Kepastian
Pendanaan Didapatkan) 6. Steam Turbine Installation Completed 21.Load Test Finished
5. Forestry Permit(s) Acquired (Izin 7. Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG) Installation 22.Load Rejection Test Finished
Kawasan Hutan Selesai) Completed
23.Reliability Run Finished
6. Land Acquisition Completed 8. Gas Processing/Gas Handling Facility Construction Completed
(Pembebasan Lahan Selesai) 24.Performance Test Finished
9. First Gas In
7. Tender Document Finished 25. Operational Readiness Certificate Issued (Sertifikat Laik
10.Power Evacuation Facility Construction Completed (Fasilitas Operasi (SLO) Diterbitkan)
8. Tender Winner Announcement Evakuasi Daya Selesai)
26.Commercial Operation Date (COD)
9. Contract Signed 11.First Backfeeding
27.Taking Over Certificate (TOC) Issued
10.Contract Effective Date (CED) 12.First Gas Firing
28.First Inspection (FI) Finished
13.Hydrostatic Test Finished
29.Final Acceptance Certificate (FAC) Issued
14.Chemical Cleaning Finished
The following table illustrate the milestone for Geothermal Power Plant – Downstream Contract
Milestone Pre-CED GPP
Milestone Post-CED GPP Downstream
Downstream
1. Resource Confirmation Completed 1. Access Road Construction Completed 16. Main Control Room Full Operation
4. Environmental Documents 5. First (Column) Steel Structure Erection 20. Reliability Run Finished
Completed (Dokumen Lingkungan
Selesai) 6. Steam Above Ground System Installation Completed (Sistem 21. Performance Test Finished
Uap Terinstalasi)
5. Location Permit(s) Acquired (Izin 22. Operational Readiness Certificate Issued (Sertifikat Laik
Lokasi/Penetapan Lokasi Selesai) 7. Steam Turbine Installation Completed Operasi (SLO) Diterbitkan)
6. Funding Source Acquired (Kepastian 8. Power Evacuation Facility Construction Completed (Fasilitas 23. Commercial Operation Date (COD)
Pendanaan Didapatkan) Evakuasi Daya Selesai)
24. Taking Over Certificate (TOC) Issued
7. Forestry Permit(s) Acquired (Izin 9. First Backfeeding
Kawasan Hutan Selesai) 25. First Inspection (FI) Finished
10.Hydrostatic Test Finished
8. Land Acquisition Completed 26. Final Acceptance Certificate (FAC) Issued
(Pembebasan Lahan Selesai) 11.Chemical Cleaning Finished
Mechanical System not Electrical System not I&C System not shown
shown shown
8 9 10 11 2 5 6 1 2 3 4
Top Down
PENDEKATAN
Template Bottom-Up
WBS
Standard
Dibagi ke dalam 4 Metode :
1. Metode Top Down
Pengelompokan Pekerjaan
Deliverable
WBS Container umum yang di kustomosasi (diisi) dengan
informasi proyek
METODE KEUNTUNGAN TANTANGAN
Top-Down • Menjamin proyek ter-struktur Perlu perhatian konstan dan
secara logis ketelitian penuh
• Bagus dalam brainstorming
• Mengakomodasi deliverable
tambahan
WBS COMPARISON
2 (Dua) buah software disebut ekivalen jika :
Identifikasi Komponen
deliverable utama
Aktifitas
CONTOH WBS PLTU
No Milestone Unit #1 Unit #2 Unit #3
Task
Area
Short cut
Menu